putting science into standards: power-to-hydrogen and hcng · 9 risks related to accidental hcng...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Workshop
Putting Science into Standards: Power-to-Hydrogen and HCNG
Session 3: use of HCNG for re-powering, mobility, heat
Standardization: Benno Weinberger R&D Manager Unit Safe and Clean
Energy and Processes
2
Safe use of hydrogen
Hydrogen is used in large quantity by the petrochemical industry with a good safety record up to now.
But challenges need to be addressed :
• Integration of H2 applications P2G in existing infrastructure
• Various concepts in decentralized infrastructures
• Irregular frequencies of use related to intermittent energy carrier
• Contact of untrained people to these hydrogen services
Public acceptance of new H2 applications : only possible if all risks are identified and correctly assessed
3
Basic properties of Hydrogen
Hydrogen properties are quite different from hydrocarbons and have to be addressed in standardization
Hydrogen-air Methane-air
Explosion limits 4% à 75 % 5 à 15 %
Mini. ignition energy 20 µJ 200 µJ
Burn rate 3,3 m/s 0,5 m/s
Quenching limit (tube
burner)
3,9 µg/s 40 µg/s
“Density” ~14 times less dense
than air
~2 times less dense
than air (CH4)
Heat conductivity 0,186 W(m*K) 0,0341 W(m*K)
4
Risk: Fire
• Hydrogen fires: The hydrogen flame is nearly invisible at daytime
• …while it is clearly visible at night
Fuel Leak Simulation Dr. Michael R. Swain University of Miami Coral Cables, FL 33124
Elmore et al., « Hydrogen emergency response training for first responders », International Conference on Hydrogen Safety, San Sebastian (Spain), 2009
5
Risk: Ignition energy
• Ignition energy as a function of gas concentration:
The low ignition energy of hydrogen over a large range of concentration makes its inflammation very likely in the case of a leak in confined space
6
Risk: Embrittlement
Hydrogen is non-corrosive but can weaken materials by its entrance into metals and alloys ("H2 embrittlement"). This embrittlement depends on many factors: temperature, pressure, purity, concentration, exposure time, mechanical properties, microstructure, surface ...
•
Particular attention should be paid to the selection of materials
e.g. Hydrogen blistering e.g. Hydrogen “attack”
7
What has to be done in H2 standardization? (1)
• A critical issue is the probable leak size for H2 installations
• The leak size permits to determine • the ATEX zone according to European regulation
• the necessary dimension of ventilation
• This issue is addressed in: • Standard EN 60079-10-1 Explosive atmospheres gives an example of a leak
surface of 1 mm2
• EIGA IGC Document 134/05/E makes reference to a leak diameter for hydrogen of 0,1 mm.
An international standard concerning the probable leak size for hydrogen applications would be the first step to harmonize safety distances and ventilation
8
What has to be done in H2 standardization? (2)
• Vented deflagrations in containers and in enclosures for hydrogen energy applications is an important issue to prevent unacceptable consequences in terms of disruption of confinements, missiles, pressure waves
• Vent sizing for hydrogen is addressed in the standard EN 14994 Gas explosion venting protective systems but related to the reactivity of Hydrogen not applicable
Further pre-normative research is necessary to standardize explosion venting protective systems for hydrogen
9
Risks related to accidental HCNG releases
• Looking to the transport of HCNG two scenarios are predictable:
- The transport of HCNG by the existing natural gas pipes
- The development of an adapted gas distribution system
In both cases the accidental situation with gas release will be different from natural gas
• Modeling of accident scenarios involves determining the basic data of natural gas / hydrogen mixtures like:
Flame length
Flame temperature
Thermal radiation of the flame
10
Example of pre-normative research: Flame length of HCNG
=> The flame length mainly depends on the pressure and the diameter of the orifice and marginally on the composition of the gas.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Pression de rejet (bar)
Lo
ng
ue
ur
de
fla
mm
e (
m)
100% H2
80% H2
50% H2
20% H2
100% CH4
Flame length as a function of discharge pressure for 10mm orifice*
*Results of the project HYDROMEL supported by French Research National Agency
11
=> The temperature of the flame increases with the hydrogen content, but remains modest in the field of HCNG (20% H2)
Example of pre-normative research: Flame temperature of HCNG
1200
1250
1300
1350
1400
1450
1500
1550
1600
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Concentration en H2 (% v/v)
Te
mp
éra
ture
ma
xim
ale
(°C
)
4 mm
7 mm
10 mm
Maximum flame temperature as a function of the hydrogen concentration for three leak diameters*
Result: Highest temperatures are
obtained for pure hydrogen
Smaller flow rates correspond to the highest temperatures
*Results of the project HYDROMEL supported by French Research National Agency
12
Example of pre-normative research: Radiation of CHNG
The influence of the gas composition to the thermal flux radiated by the flame is very modest while the influence of the diameter of the orifice appears to be real.
0
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
70000
80000
90000
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Concentration H2 (%v/v)
Flu
x r
ay
on
né
(W
/m2
)
4 mm
7 mm
10 mm
Trend: the radiated flux increases with the flame length (and thus the leak diameter)
Average values of the heat flux radiated by the flame depending on the composition of the mixture and the size of the flame*
*Results of the project HYDROMEL supported by French Research National Agency
13
What has to be done for HCNG standardization?
End user installations have to be certified for HCNG e.g. regarding the compatibility to flame stability and hydrogen embrittlement
Gas detection devices have to be standardized for HCNG
All kinds of mitigating safety measures (TPRD, Explosion Protection Systems, etc.) have to be certified for HCNG
Re-assessment of the ATEX Zoning should be standardized for HCNG
The probable leak size for HCNG installations has to be standardized
14
Conclusions
The specific properties of Hydrogen are well known in petrochemical industry but not to end-users of HCNG
Current standardization related to hydrogen work mainly focused on transport applications, not on P2G addressing similar but not the same problems
To ensure the safety of P2G and the management of risks, new standards are necessary taking in account its irregular use related to intermittent energy carrier
Acceptance by the general public is key for success, this is only possible if all risks are identified and correctly assessed
15
Perspectives
All relevant basic safety data of natural gas / hydrogen should be determined - e.g. mitigating safety measures design like explosion venting - and formalized to a safety standard
In addition there is a need of a generic risk analysis of the different HCNG systems
Results should be condensed into a new standard for such systems
This could serve as reference to the logic of the “New approach” legislation