r-s.documents.coastal.ca.gov/reports/1999/6/f8a-6-1999.pdf · volleyball tournament in the...

STATE OF CALIFORNIA. THE RESOURCES AGENCY

r-s.GRAY DAVIS, Governor

CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION ~, South Coast Area Office

•

Oceangate, Suite 1000 g Beach, CA 90802-430~ 2) 590-5071

Filed: 3/19/99 49th Day: 5/7/99

•

•

LOCAL GOVERNMENT:

LOCAL DECISION:

APPEAL NUMBER:

CO-APPLICANTS:

AGENT:

PROJECT LOCATION:

PROJECT DESCRIPTION:

APPELLANTS:

180th Day: 9/15/99 Staff: CP-LB ,-~ Staff Report: 5/19/99 - ' Hearing Date: June 8-11, 1999 Commission Action:

STAFF REPORT: APPEAL NO SUBSTANTIAL ISSUE

City of Manhattan Beach

Approval with Conditions

A-5-MNB-99-111

City of Manhattan Beach & Association of Volleyball Professionals (AVP)

Richard Thompson, Director of Community Development

Beach area south of the Manhattan Beach Pier, City of Manhattan Beach, Los Angeles County.

Appeal of City of Manhattan Beach approval of coastal development permit for Manhattan Beach Open Volleyball Tournament to be held August 28-29, 1999 with set-up starting Oi1 August 25th.

William Victor, Harry Ford & Yury Gurvich

SUMMARY OF STAFF RECOMMENDATION

The staff recommends that the Commission, after public hearing, determine that the appeal raises no substantial issue. The locally approved event frJIIy conforms to the City of Manhattan Beach certified Local Coastal Program (LCP) and the public access policies of the Coastal Act. Although the locally approved event may attract large numbers of people to Manhattan Beach, the local coastal development permit approval contains provisions that: a) protect public pedestrian access along the Strand, pier and beach; b) protect public access to the upper pier public parking facilities; ·and c) provide free public transportation between remote parking areas and the beach. The motion to carry out the staff recommendation is on page 5.

A-5-MNB-99-111 Manhattan Beach Open

SUBSTANTIVE FILE DOCUMENTS:

1. Local Coastal Development Permit No. 99-4 (Manhattan Beach Open). 2. City of Manhattan Beach Certified Local Coastal Program (LCP). 3. City of Manhattan Beach LCP Amendment Request No. 1-97. 4. City of Manhattan Beach LCP Amendment Request No. 3-97. 5. Appeal/Permit Application No. A-5-MNB-97-84 (1997 Manhattan Beach Open).

I. APPELLANTS' CONTENTIONS

•

On March 2, 1999, after a public hearing, the Manhattan Beach City Council approved with conditions Local Coastal Development Permit No. 99-4 for the Manhattan Beach Open Volleyball Tournament to be held August 28-29, 1999, with set-up starting on August 25th (Exhibits #4-6). The general public may view the proposed event on a first-come, first-served basis. There is no admission fee for spectators. Participation in the competition is restricted to AVP players and a limited number of qualifying teams. Non-AVP competitors are subject to a tournament entry fee.

On March 19, 1999, William Victor, Harry Ford and Yury Gurvich submitted an appeal of the City's approval of Local Coastal Development Permit No. 99-4 to the Commission's office in Long Beach (Exhibit #7). The appellants contend that the locally approved permit: •

1. Violates the City of Manhattan Beach certified Local Coastal Program (LCP). 2. Violates the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). 3. Destroys the use of the beach for normal non-privileged beach goers. 4. Prevents public use of 24 volleyball courts. 5. Does not require adequate noise control. 6. Blocks the beach. 7. Does not comply with City standards. 8. Contains no remedies for failure to comply. 9. Allows commercial use of public parking lots without mitigation.

II. LOCAL GOVERNMENT ACTION

According to the City's staff report dated March 2, 1999 (Exhibit #6), the AVP submitted in November of 1998 a proposal to the City of Manhattan Beach to co-sponsor a pro beach volleyball tournament in the tradition of the Manhattan Beach Open. The City Council reviewed the proposal and responded to the A VP proposal with the following directives: a) delete the request for paid seating at the. event; b) pay for all of the City's direct costs for the event; and c) scale back the size and scope of the event, specifically the bleachers, noise, music, number of parking spaces required, and tents. •

-.

•

•

•


On February 12, 1999, the AVP submitted to the City a revised request for the proposed event (including an application for a coastal development permit} that addressed the prior directives of the City Council.

On March 2, 1999, after a public hearing, the Manhattan Beach City Council approved with conditions Local Coastal Development Permit No. 99-4 for the Manhattan Beach Open Volleyball Tournament (Exhibit #5}. The proposed 1999 event includes:

1. No paid seating. 2. Reduction in the total number of bleacher seats to a maximum of 1,500. 3. Use of 45 parking spaces in the lower pier public parking lots. 4. Reduction in the number of tournament days from three to two. 5. Reduction in the number bf days needed for set-up (3) and take-down (1}. 6. Six tents less than the 1996 event. 7. An A VP agreement to pay the City's direct costs for the event.

The proposed event would be held August 28-29, 1999, with set-up starting on August 25th. The event is proposed to be located on the south side of the Manhattan Beach Pier in a sandy area that is currently occupied by approximately 24 volleyball courts {Exhibit #4). The proposal includes the reservation of 45 of the 71 parking spaces located in the lower south and lower north public beach parking lots for use by A VP equipment trucks, television equipment and event personnel {Exhibit #3).

At the March 2, 1999 public hearing, the City Council heard the testimony of fifteen speakers both supporting and objecting to the proposed event. Some of the speakers supported the event but expressed concerns over the operation of past volleyball tournaments. Concerns over noise impacts from loudspeakers and pollution were expressed by several speakers. The public hearing was closed and the City Council approved the local coastal development permit finding that the proposed event would not block or prohibit public access to the pier and/or shoreline, and is consistent with the certified LCP (Exhibit #5). The action by the City Council was final and not appealable at the local level.

On March 5, 1999 the City's Notice of Final Local Action for Local Coastal Development Permit No. 99-4 was received in the Commission's Long Beach office. The Commission's ten working day appeal period was then established and noticed. On March 19, 1999, the last day of the appeal period, the Commission received the appellants' appeal of the City's approval {Exhibit #7). The public hearing on Appeal A-5-MNB-99-111 was opened and continued at the Commission's April 13, 1999 meeting in Long Beach.

Ill. APPEAL PROCEDURES

After certification of Local Coastal Programs, the Coastal Act provides for limited appeals to the Coastal Commission of certain local government actions on coastal development permits.


Developments approved by cities or counties may be appealed if they are located within th. mapped appealable areas, such as those located between the sea and the first public road paralleling the sea or within three hundred feet of the mean high tide line or inland extent of any beach or top of the seaward face of a coastal bluff. Furthermore, developments approved by counties may be appealed if they are not designated "principal permitted use" under the certified LCP. Finally, developments which constitute major public works or major energy facilities may be appealed, whether approved or denied by the city or county [Coastal Act Section 30603(a)].

Under Section 30603(a)( 1 ) of the Coastal Act, the proposed project site is located in an appealable area by its location on the beach (between the sea and the first public road).

Section 30603(a)(1) of the Coastal Act states:

(a) After certification of its Local Coastal Program, an action taken by a local government on a Coastal Development Permit application may be appealed to the Commission for only the following types of developments:

( 1) Developments approved by the local government between the sea and the first public road paralleling the sea or within 300 feet of the inland extent of any beach or of the mean high tide line of the sea where there is no beach, whichever is the greatest distance. •

The grounds for appeal of an approved local Coastal Development Permit in the appealable area are stated in Section 30603(b)(1 ), which states:

(b)( 1) The grounds for an appeal pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be limited to an allegation that the development does not conform to the standards set forth in the certified Local Coastal Program or the public access policies set forth in this division.

The action currently before the Commission is to find whether there is a "substantial issue" or "no substantial issue" raised by the appeal of the local approval of the proposed project. Section 30625(b)(2) of the Coastal Act requires a de novo hearing of the appealed project unless the Commission determines that no substantial issue exists with respect to the grounds for appeal.

If Commission staff recommends a finding of substantial issue, and there is no motion from the Commission to find no substantial issue, the substantial issue question will be considered moot, and the Commission will proceed to the de novo public hearing on the merits of the project. The de novo hearing will be scheduled at the same hearing or a subsequent Commission hearing. A de novo public hearing on the merits of the project uses the certified LCP as the standard of review. In addition, for projects located between the first public r. and the sea, findings must be made that any approved project is consistent with the publi

------- ~-----------------------------------

•

•

•

A~5-MNB~99-111

Manhattan Beach Open

access and recreation policies of the Coastal Act. Sections 1311 0-1 3120 of the California Code of Regulations further explain the appeal he~ring process.

If the Commission decides to hear arguments and vote on the substantial issue question, proponents and opponents will have three minutes per side to address whether the appeal raises a substantial issue. The only persons qualified to testify before the Commission at the substantial issue portion of the appeal process are the applicants, persons who opposed the application before the local government (or their representatives), and the local government. Testimony from other persons must be submitted in writing.

The Commission will then vote on the substantial issue matter. It takes a majority of Commissioners present to find that no substantial issue is raised by the local approval of the subject project.

IV. STAFF RECOMMENDATION ON SUBSTANTIAL ISSUE

The staff recommends that the Commission determine that no substantial issue exists with respect to the conformity of the project with the City of Manhattan Beach certified local Coastal Program and the public access policies of the Coastal Act, pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 30625(b)(2) .

MOTION: Staff recommends a YES vote on the following motion:

I move that the Commission determine that Appeal No. A~5-MNB-99-111 raises NO substantial issue with respect to the grounds on which the appeal has been filed.

A majority of t]le Commissioners present is required to pass the motion. "/•

V. FINDINGS AND DECLARATIONS

The Commission hereby finds and declares:

A. Project Description and History

The Association of Volleyball Professionals (AVP), in cooperation with the City of Manhattan Beach, proposes to conduct the 1999 Manhattan Beach Open Volleyball Tournament on August 28~29, 1999, with set-up starting on August 25th. The general public may view the proposed event on a first-come, first-served basis. There will be no admission fees for spectators.

- -·----··-------


The proposed event is located on the south side of the Manhattan Beach Pier in a sandy a. that is actually owned by Los Angeles County. The event area is currently occupied by approximately 24 volleyball courts (Exhibit #4). Although the beach is actually owned by Los Angeles County, it falls within the City limits of Manhattan Beach, and therefore, falls under the coastal development permit jurisdiction of the City pursuant to the certified Manhattan Beach LCP. As property owners, the Los Angeles County Department of Beaches and Harbors regulates the special events on the beach. The proposed 1 999 Manhattan Beach Open is one of several volleyball tournaments and other special events approved by the County on the beach during the summer {Exhibit# 9, p. 1 4).

The annual Manhattan Beach Open Volleyball Tournament has a long tradition that dates back to 1960. The first coastal development permit approval for the event, however, did not occur until 1997 when the City approved Local Coastal Development Permit No. 1 0-97. Prior to 1997, the City did not believe that the event fell under the definition of development as defined in the certified LCP1

• That all changed in 1 997 when the A VP proposed to charge admission fees to spectators of the Manhattan Beach Open Volleyball Tournament.

On March 18, 1997, the City of Manhattan beach approved Local Coastal Development Permit No. 1 0-97 for the 1997 Miller Lite Manhattan Beach Open Volleyball Tournament. The City's approval would have allowed the A VP to sell tickets to all of the seating for the final matches of the tournament. Subsequent to the City's approval, three appeals of the local coastal development permit were submitted to the Coastal Commission. The primary gro. for the appeals was that the proposed event, with admission fees for spectators, was inconsistent with the certified LCP's Open Space (OS) land use designation for the beach. The certified OS land use designation permits "sporting events for which no admission is charged", but does not permit sporting events for which admission is charged.

On May 13, 1997, the Commission found that a substantial issue existed with respect to the grounds of the three appeals (See Appeal A-5-MNB-97-84). Also on May 13, 1997, the Commission held a public hearing on a City of Manhattan Beach LCP amendment request" that would have added "sporting events for which admission is charged" to the OS permitted use list (See LCP Amendment Request No. 1 A-97). That day, the Commission rejected Manhattan Beach LCP amendment request No. 1A-97, and approved the de novo permit for the proposed event on appeal {See Exhibit #8: Appeal A-5-MNB-97-84). The Commission's action on May 13, 1997 approved a coastal development permit for the proposed event, but denied the City's and the A VP' s request to charge admission fees to spectators. Ultimately, Coastal Development Permit A-5-MNB-97-84 was never issued, and the 1997 Manhattan Beach Open was cancelled.

In its action on Appeal A-5-MNB-97-84, the Commission found that, pursuant to the certified LCP, a coastal development permit was required for the proposed event because it falls within the definition of development contained in Section A.96.030 of the certified LCP and Section

1 The Commission on May 12, 1994 certified the City of Manhattan Beach LCP. •

•

•

•

---- -------------------------


30106 of the Coastal Act ("Development" means ... the placement or erection of any solid material or structure; ... change in the intensity of use of water, or of access thereto; ... }, and that the certified LCP contains no provision for the exclusion or exemption of the proposed event. Furthermore, admission fees for spectators may not be charged for sporting events on the beach because such a use is not permitted by the certified LCP.

In October of 1997, the City submitted LCP amendment request No. 3~97 to the Commission in an attempt to insert new provisions into the certified LCP to permit and exempt temporary events on the beach. As stated above, there are currently no provisions in the LCP that allow temporary events on the beach, regardless of size or type of event, to be exempted from permit requirements. On February 3, 1998, the Commission approved LCP amendment request No. 3-97 with suggested modifications that would have laid out specific LCP standards for the exempting and permitting of temporary events on the beach. The City, however, declined to accept the Commission's suggested modifications and the Commission's action on LCP amendment request No. 3-97 has lapsed.

For this year's proposed event, the 1999 Manhattan Beach Open Volleyball Tournament, the City and the A VP have significantly scaled down its size and scale from prior years, and have eliminated all spectator admission fees. The proposed August 28-29, 1999 event, approved by City of Manhattan Beach Local Coastal Development Permit No. 99-4, includes:

1. No paid seating. 2. Reduction in the total number of bleacher seats to a maximum of 1 ,500. 3. Use of 45 parking spaces in the lower pier public parking lots. 4. Reduction in the number of tournament days from three to two. 5. Reduction in the number of days needed for set-up (3) and take-down (1). 6. Six tents less than the 1996 event. 7. An A VP agreement to pay the City's direct costs for the event.

Participation in the competition is restricted to A VP players and a limited number of qualifying teams. Non-A VP competitors are subject to a tournament entry fee. Set-up for the proposed event will start on Wednesday, August 25th, and take-down must be completed on Monday the 30th. The proposal includes the reservation of 45 of the 71 parking spaces located in the lower south and lower north public beach parking lots for use by A VP equipment trucks, television equipment and event personnel (Exhibit #3). Public access to the pier and along the water will not be blocked by the event, and the bicycle path will be kept open. Bicyclists may, however, be required to walk their bikes past the pier if the area becomes too congested.

The City-approved site plan for the proposed event includes two sets of bleachers and a main stage and scoreboard around a main center court (Exhibit #4). The area behind the proposed stage and scoreboard (below the pier) is a fenced area with several tents for players, medics, food, referees, and the media. There will not be a fence installed around the perimeter of the event area. Several outer courts (with no seating provided) are proposed to be used for the


event's preliminary matches. The proposed event also includes an interactive area below t. pier for event sponsors' booths where free merchandise samples may be distributed to the general public (Exhibit #4). Two inflatable sponsor ads are also shown on the City-approved site plan. In total, the City-approved site plan for the proposed event covers approximately 150,000 square feet of beach area (Exhibit #4).

In order to enhance beach access for event visitors and other beach goers, the City approval states that the A VP will be providing a shuttle service to and from the proposed event on Saturday and Sunday (August 28-29, 1999).

B. Substantial Issue Analysis

As stated in Section Ill of this report, the grounds for appeal of a coastal development permit issued by the local government after certification of its Local Coastal Program (LCP) are specific. In this case, the local coastal development permit may be appealed to the Commission on the grounds that it does not conform to the certified LCP or the public access policies of the Coastal Act. The Commission must then decide whether a substantial issue exists in order to hear the appeal.

In this case, the appellants contend that the City's approval of the proposed event does not conf~rm to the certified LCP. In addition, the appellants contend that the locally approved. perm1t:

1. Violates the City of Manhattan Beach certified Local Coastal Program (LCP). 2. Violates the California Environmental Quality Act (CEOA). 3. Destroys the use of the beach for normal non-privileged beach goers. 4. Prevents public use of 24 volleyball courts. 5. Does not require adequate noise control. 6. Blocks the beach. 7. Does not comply with City standards. 8. Contains no remedies for failure to comply. 9. Allows commercial use of public parking lots without mitigation.

The certified Manhattan Beach LCP contains specific policies that apply to all development located within the City's coastal zone. The proposed event does fall within the definition of development that is contained in Section A.96.030 of the certified LCP and Section 30106 of the Coastal Act (11Development" means ... the placement or erection of any solid material or structure; ... change in the intensity of use of water, or of access thereto; ... ). Because the certified LCP contains no provision for the exclusion or exemption for temporary events on the beach, the proposed event must obtain a coastal development permit. All development approved within the City's coastal zone, including the proposed event, must comply with the policies of the certified Manhattan Beach LCP. •

•

•

•

-~·····----·-·-~--------------------------------


First, the proposed event must qualify as a permitted use within the Open Space (OS) land use designation of the beach. Secondly, the proposed event must comply with the following relevant LCP policies:

POLICY 1.A.2: The City shall encourage, maintain, and implement safe and efficient traffic flow patterns to permit sufficient beach and parking access.

POLICY I.A.S: The City shall maintain visible signage to El Porto accessways and beach parking, along Highland Avenue.

POLICY 1.8.1: The City shall encourage public transportation service to mitigate excess parking demand and vehicular pollution. All transportation/congestion management plans and mitigation measures shall protect and encourage public beach access.

POLICY I. 8.3: The City shall encourage pedestrian and bicycle modes as a transportation means to the beach.

POLICY 1.8.6: The Strand shall be maintained for non-vehicular beach access.

POLICY I.C.2: The City shall maximize the opportunities for using available parking for weekend beach use.

POLICY I.C.3: The City shall encourage additional off-street parking to be concentrated for efficiency relative to the parking and traffic system.

POLICY I.C.9: Use of existing public parking, including, but not limited to, on-street parking, the El Porto beach parking lot, and those parking lots indicated on Exhibit #9 (in the certified LCP), shall be protected to provide public beach parking ...

POLICY: The beach shall be preserved for public beach recreation. No permanent structures, with the exception of bikeways, walkways, and restrooms, shall be permitted on the beach.

PROGRAM II.A.6: Consider the establishment of alternative transportation systems and park-mall facilities, including a shuttle service to the El Porto beach area.

PROGRAM 11.8.13: Improve information management of the off-street parking system through improved signing, graphics and public information and maps .


PROGRAM II.B. 1 4: Provide signing and distribution of information for use of the Civic Ce. parking for beach parking on weekend days.

In addition, the proposed event must conform to the following public access policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act:

Section 3021 0 of the Coastal Act states:

In carrying out the requirement of Section 4 of Article X of the California Constitution, maximum access, which shall be conspicuously posted, and recreational opportunities shall be provided for all the people consistent with public safety needs and the need to protect public rights, rights of private property owners, and natural resource areas from overuse.

Section 3021 1 of the Coastal Act states:

Development shall not interfere with the public's right of access to the sea where acquired through use or legislative authorization, including, but not limited to, the use of dry sand and rocky coastal beaches to the first line of terrestrial vegetation.

Section 30212 of the Coastal Act states, in part:

(a) Public access from the nearest public roadway to the shoreline and along the coashall be provided in new development projects ...

Section 30213 of the Coastal Act states:

Lower cost visitor and recreational facilities shall be protected, encouraged, and, where feasible, provided. Developments providing public recreational opportunities are preferred. ··

The staff recommends that the Commission determine that the proposed event does comply with the City of Manhattan Beach certified LCP and the public access policies of the Coastal Act, and find that no substantial issue exists with respect to the grounds of the appeal.

First, the proposed event is a permitted use within the Open Space (OS) land use designation. The certified OS land use designation specifically permits .. sporting events for which no admission is charged". The proposed volleyball tournament is a sporting event. Local Coastal Development Permit No. 99-4, issued by the City of Manhattan Beach specifically states that: "the tournament is free and open to the public, with no admission for entry to the event" and "access to the main court area (bleachers) will be open to the public and based upon a firstcome, first-served basis" (Exhibit #5, p.2). Therefore, the proposed event complies with the LCP and has avoided the issue that has caused so much controversy in the past two year.


• Secondly, the proposed event also complies with the policies of the certified LCP and the public access policies of the Coastal Act by ensuring that public access to the pier and shoreline will "remain open and unobstructed during the duration of the proposed event" (Exhibit #5, p.2). The City-approved site plan does not permit any development in the public accessways that provide access to the pier, water and bike path (Exhibit #4). The proposed event will occupy a 300-foot wide portion of the approximately 450-foot wide beach area that exists between the bike path and mean high tide line (MHTL). Therefore, there will be a 150-foot wide open area preserved along the shoreline for lateral public access. The Commission's approval of Coastal Development Permit A-5-MHB-97-084 for the 1997 Miller Lite Manhattan Beach Open included similar conditions for the protection of public access (Exhibit #8, p.4).

•

•

Additionally, the proposed event will provide the public with a free recreational opportunity in the form of a professional sporting event with free public admission. Although approximately 24 public volleyball courts will be occupied by the six-day event, the displacement will be temporary, and unrestricted public use of the public volleyball area will resume after one day of take-down activities. The Commission's approval of Coastal Development Permit A-5-MHB-97-084 for the 1997 Miller Lite Manhattan Beach Open also required that the event take-down be completed in one day (Exhibit #8, p.5).

As required by the certified LCP, the City approval encourages public transportation service to the event in order to mitigate excess parking demand and vehicular pollution. The City approval states that the A VP will be providing a shuttle service to and from the proposed event on Saturday and Sunday (August 28-29, 1999). The event's impacts on the public parking supply have been reduced by minimizing the number of parking spaces that can be reserved for use by A VP equipment trucks, television equipment and event personnel. The City approval permits the reservation of 45 of the 71 parking spaces located in the lower south and low,( north public beach parking lots for use by A VP equipment trucks, television equipment and event personnel (Exhibit #3). The City's approval of the 1997 Manhattan Beach Open included the reservation of 55 public parking spaces.· Although, the reservation of 45 public parking spaces will temporarily use public beach parking spaces, the City's approval has minimized the amount of reserved parking for the event. The 50 public parking spaces in the two upper pier lots and the on-street parking along Manhattan Beach Boulevard will be available for public use on a first-come, first-served basis. By minimizing the amount of reserved parking, the proposed event is consistent with the LCP policy that requires the City to maximize the opportunities for using available parking for beach use.

The Commission's approval of Coastal Development Permit A-5-MHB-97-084 for the 1997 Miller Lite Manhattan Beach Open required the applicants to implement a very specific public transportation program (Exhibit #8, p.2). The proposed 1997 event, however, was proposed as a much larger and heavily promoted event with paid admission and over 6,800 bleacher seats. The heavy promotion and many pre-event advertisements in 1997 was part of the


AVP's attempt to generate funds by selling tickets to the 1997 Manhattan Beach Open2 ••

anticipated impacts on public parking for the 1997 event were different than this year's scaled-down event with only 1 ,500 bleacher seats, although many people may attend because it is free. The shuttle service is required by the City to maximize the availability of parking for public access to the beach and the event. Therefore, the City's requirement for the A VP to provide a shuttle service to and from the proposed event on Saturday and Sunday (August 28-29, 1999) is consistent with the LCP.

While noise control is not an issue addressed by certified LCP policies, the appellants have raised it as an issue. Specifically, the appellants assert that the local approval does not require adequate noise control. The City staff report dated March 2, 1999, states, "Staff will work with the A VP to direct the speakers away from houses and businesses on the east side of the Strand, thereby cutting down on noise near beach residents". Therefore, the City has·· addressed noise-control as an issue, and has directed its staff to take measures to cut-down on the noise. The Commission's approval of Coastal Development Permit A-5-MHB-97-084 for the 1 997 Miller Lite Manhattan Beach Open did not contain any conditions that addressed the issue of noise control.

The appellants' assertion that the local approval does not contain any remedies for failure to comply is incorrect. The City approval contains a specific provision entitled "Compliance with the Law". Furthermore, the standard enforcement mechanisms of the City Municipal Code could be applied to any instance of non-compliance with a City code or condition. •

In conclusion, the proposed event and the City's coastal development permit for the proposed event are in compliance with the City of Manhattan Beach certified LCP and the public access policies of the Coastal Act. The appellants have not provided any evidence that the proposed event violates the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The proposed event, as approved and conditioned by City of Manhattan Beach Local Coastal Development Permit No. 99-4, will not have a significant effect on coastal access or coastal resources. Furth~rmore,

the City's approval of the proposed event is consistent with prior Commission actions. There are no feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures available which would substantially lessen any significant adverse effect which the activity may have on the environment. Therefore, the Commission finds that the appeal raises no substantial issue.

2 The 1997 Miller Lite Manhattan Beach Open Volleyball Tournament was cancelled and relocated to • Hermosa Beach after the Commission denied the request to charge admission at Manhattan Beach.

•

-

•

M~n..h~-rta:"'" "lBe..a.c..h.. Ore.n.

£V£NT

• SI\E COASTAL COMi~HSSiON A·..S-MNB-99-// I

EXHIBIT # ........ / .......... . I I . PAGE ••...••••• OF ........••

t

•

' .

• uu +----North

(f-lighla~d J '

•• uu .. .

'

.-Parking and Circulatiop

~

0; ~ D~

~·o o~, o th

Odi;atori 1 I St. D (Ma-r111a«ar1 1\~e.---~

~ h t

(ocea~DriVe-- n--)

t~~~!~~~~~:: l

.------,-- .. ·-.-;

De: tour len& right

'

~ h .

21spau..s lower South l'arking LN

@'Ve~tiO~ion)

Road Closed To Through Traffic Right Tum Only

COASTAL COMMISSION A·S·MN~-99-11 \ EXHIBIT # _____ :3. _________ _ PAGE _____ l_ __ OF ___ j ___ _

PROPOSE() '99 MANHATTAN BEACH OPEN SITE PLAN ,1_ ISoJ!t'u;t- .,._ MlfTL.

-J!!il m

ec .. tu ,_, 81achcJo

1224 scotiii!J copoc:ity e .... z ....

SpoftSOI" lftflotable

~ I s-Fence with Spoil-logo u r-_j ____ il

I [ZS]e 81achu·12Zscotiftgl / :

Ft..... I I

I PloycrRest

_,., ...... 0 l ' l r--~~

tv Boom Ccllnera tlaktrO!Iic$ Score ~~· [??Ji p

I e R

!•300' ·I .. !.!.!.?. ••

..,.,. llllorld'• •••••

I Date o.-: 213199 o.- By: D. Donroff Sufr'-1 til sfO*

-----"' I I I#

0 .z.·· ~Q

"'--like Path-----.,.

•

~! Referee Tent 1":71 1

(IOdO)~I r:;- ------1 '[6]ioTc I I I --, I I

]_...._..,,.,.._,n•) CENTER COURT

I SpOIISOI"/ VIP Tented Skybo>ccs -l I :

I SPa<SOR I ,.J.~~-:.~:---' I c=plVTower ~-"~~1 ~~X~

" ~ ... M~ ""'I~ IOI91BI7I615I4I3IZJ1IHC

Porki"9 Lot (28 spoccs)

•

EVENT ENTRY

T ~ lleac:h Pier

~--lfl __ jl l'ub&c Re.-IIII$NMrs ~

COASTAL COMMISSION ~~·NNB · <J9-ll I EXHIBIT # --------~-----~---· PAGE ___ / ____ • __ _( ___ _

•

•

•

City of Manhattan Beach 1400 Highland Avenue Manhattan Beach, CA 90266f (310) 545-5621 (310) 545-9322 (FAX)

COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT

Project No COP 99 - 4 Page 1 of4

On March 2. 1999 the City Council of the City of Manhattan Beach conducted a public hearing and granted to the Association of Volleyball Professionals (Applicant) this permit for the temporary event described below, subject to the attached Standard and Special conditions.

Site: Beach Area south of the Manhattan Beach Pier

Description: Manhattan Beach Open Volleyball Tournament ·to be held August 28 and 29, south of the Manhattan Beach Pier and will include: a Pro-Am Men's Two Person Volleyball Tournament; a women's Pro Two Person Volleyball Tournament; and, a Junior Two Person Amateur Tournament. The Qualifier for the Pro-Am Men's Tournament will be held on August 27th. Set up for the tournament will take place from August 25-27. All equipment is to be removed within 24 hours of the close of the tournament. The first 28 seeded spots of the Pro-Am Men's Tournament will be for AVP players with the four top teams from the Qualifier playing in the event. The AVP will guarantee the appearance of 15 of the top 20 AVP rated teams (to include 3 of the top 5 AVP rated teams, barring injury) for the Men's Pro-Am Tournament.

fssued by: Richard Thompson, Director of Community Development

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT Richard Thompson, Director

Acknowledgment:

The undersigned permittee acknowledges receipt of this permit and agrees to abide by all terms and conditions thereof.

Date Signature of Permittee

E'J'''f''.,. 4- Iff:!!"' .~ .. r~;u: • ~ ........ ~ ••.•.••••••

PAGE ..•. J. ... OF •. !:/.. ...




Required Findings: (Per Section A.96.150 (A) and (B) of the Local Coastal Program)

Written findings are required for all decisions on Coastal Development Pennits. Such findings must demonstrate that the project, as described in the application and accompanying material, or as modified by any conditions of approval, confonns with the certified Manhattan Beach Local Coastal Program.

A. That the project, as described in the applicant and accompanying materials, as modified by any conditions of approval, conforms with the certified Manhattan Beach Local Coastal Program:

(Finding): The event will provide a total of 1,500 bleacher seats with ancillary equipment and facilities. The tournament is free and open to the public,

•

with no admission for entry to the event. Based upon the description provided above (Page 1 ), there is nothing to suggest that this event will be • inconsistent with the goals and policies of the Manhattan Beach Local Coastal Program.

B. The temporary event is in conformity with the public access and recreation policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act of 1976 commencing with Section 30200 of the Public Resources Code, specifically:

(Finding): The event does not physically block or prohibit access to the Pier and I or . shoreline by the general public. All existing access points to the Pier will remain open and unobstructed during the duration of the proposed event. Access to the beach areas near the Pier will also remain open and unobstructed. Access to the main court area (bleachers) will be open to the public and based upon a first come -first served basis.

EXHiBIT # ........ $.:.····-··· PAGE ---~-- OF ••• 'f._

•

•

•




Standard Conditions:

1. Notice of Receipt and Acknowledgment. The permit is not valid and the temporary event shall not commence until a copy of the permit, signed by the permittee or authorized agent, acknowledging receipt of the permit and acceptance of the terms and conditions, is returned to the Community Development Department.

2. Expiration. The Coastal Development Permit shall expire if not implemented during the approved dates scheduled for the temporary event. The City Council may grant a reasonable extension of time for due cause. Said time.· extension shall be requested in writing by the applicant or authorized agent prior to the expiration of the permit.

3. Compliance. All activities associated with the temporary event must occur in strict compliance with the proposal as set forth in the application for permit, subject to any special conditions set forth below. Any deviation from the approved plans must be reviewed and approved by the Director of Community Development.

4. Interpretation. Any questions of intent or interpretation of any condition will be resolved by the Director of Community Development.

5. Terms and Conditions are Peroetual. These terms and conditions shall be perpetual, and it is the intention of the Director of Community Development and the permittee to bind all future owners and possessors of the subject property to the terms and conditions.

Special Conditions:

1.

2.

The subject Coastal Development Permit will be operated and implemented in ponformance with all conditions and recommendations of the Manhattan Beach Cjty Council.

The subject Coastal Development Permit will be operated and implemented in conformance with all conditions and recommendations of the "Manhattan Beach Open Agreement" dated March 2. 1999.

CO.~ST!tl COMMISSION A-s .. M~~ · 9~-u'

~""}'LJ'P.IT .u. s L. \.l-., !-' f "1"r' ··-·---···········-··

PAGE .3 ... OF •. !i ...



Project No CDP 99 - 4 Page4of4

• 3. The subject Coastal Development Permit will be operated and implemented in

conformance with all provisions and policies of the Certified Manhattan Beach Local Coastal Program and the LCP • Implementation Program.

•

COASTAl COMMISSION A·S-M~~-9,.1

EXHIBIT # ......... $ ....... . PAGE ····~·- OF --~···

•

•

•

R£CE\V£~~, South Cot15\ Rc .....

M~R 2 S .,ljlj9 CITY OF MANHA TI AN BEACH

CA.i..\fORtliA N coA.STAL coMM\SS\0

MEMORANDUM

TO: Honorable Mayor Napolitano and Members of the City Council

THROUGH: Geoff Dolan, City Manager r/1 FROM: Richard Gill, Director of Parks and Recreation R: ~ /; . /J

Pamela L. Farber, Recreation Services Manager t.{7fJ7-DATE: March 2, 1999

SUBJECT: A Public Hearing to Consider an Application for a Coastal Development Permit by the City of Manhattan Beach and the Association of Volleyball Professionals to Stage the Manhattan Open to be Held on August 27-29, 1999.

RECO:MMENDATION It is recommended that the City Council conduct the public hearing, approve issuance of a voluntary Coastal Development Permit and authorize the City Manager to execute the attached agreement with the Association of Volleybal1 Professionals (AVP) to co-sponsor the 1999 Manhattan Beach Open August 27-29.

BUDGET IMPLICATION Under the tenns of the attached contract, the A VP will reimburse the City for all of its direct costs associated with the event. The A VP will retain the proceeds from the top 28 seeded teams and the City will retain all other entry fees.

BACKGROUND ln November 1998, the A VP submitted a proposal to the City of Manhattan Beach for the co-sponsorship of a pro-am beach volleyball tournament. The City Council and staff reviewed the proposal and responded to the A VP with the following direction:

1. Delete request for paid seating at the event. 2. Pay for all of the City's direct costs for the event. 3. Scale back the size and scope of the event. Specifically scale back bleachers,

noise, music, number of parking spaces required, and tents.

PROPOSED EVENT In February, the A VP submitted a revised proposal which staff feels addresses the Council's prior concerns.

COASTAL COMMISSION A·5"'MNB·f.J9·/11

EXHIBIT # ··---~---···------PAGE .. .J ..... 1

0F _;$. ___ _

Highlights of the new proposal include:

1. 2.

3. 4. s. 6. 7.

No paid seating. Reduction in the number of bleacher seats from 4,346 in 1996 to a proposed 1,500 for this year's event. Use of only one parking lot instead of four. Reduction in the number of tournament days from three to two. Elimination of two full days for set up and tear down. Elimination of six tents from the 1996 event. Agreement to pay for all City expenses that are incurred.

The proposed 1999 Manhattan Beach Open will be held August 28 and 29, south of the Manhattan Beach Pier and will include a Pro-Am Men's Two Person Volleyball Tournament, a women's Pro Two Person Volleyball Tournament and a Junior Two

•

Person Amateur Tournament. The Qualifier for the Pro. Am Men's Tournament will be ~· held on August 27. Set up for the tournament will take place from August 25-27. All equipment is to be removed within 24 hours of the close of the lournament. The first 28 seeded spots of the Pro-Am Men's Tournament will be for A VP players with the four top teams from the Qualifier playing into the event. The A VP will guarantee the appearance of 15 of the top 20 A VP rated teams (to include 3 of the top S A VP rated teams, barring injury) for the Men's Pro-Am Tournament.

The City will permit advertising and promotion of the event within the City for a minimum of three weeks prior to the tournament. This commitment includes banners • {hung no more than two weeks prior to the event) provided by the AVP, placed on the two major arteries of the City (PCH and Manhattan Beach Boulevard), two inflatable advertisements placed at the southwest and northwest locations of the event, distribution of storefront posters and local news releases. Additionally, the AVP will be allowed to sell AVP and event merchandise on the pier, however, the City shall retain the right to sell event consumables {food and beverage) and retain the proceeds. The A VP must seek the City's approval to sample products. The AVP will provide for the television broadcast of the Manhattan Beach Open, highlighting and promoting the City of Manhattan .. Beach in a three-minute special feature.

Bleachers for the event will be placed parallel to the ocean facing the Strand so as not to obstruct the spectator's view. Staff will work with the A VP to direct the speakers away from the houses and businesses on the east side of the Strand, thereby cutting down on the noise near beach residents. There will be a Center-Court stage with television towers placed at the south and east sides. The City will provide any necessary services required for the event such as Police, Fire, Recreation and Public Works. The estimated costs for these services must be paid 30 days prior to the event. Also, the A VP will be providing the shuttle service to and from the event on both Saturday and Sunday. The A VP will be responsible for securing all County and City permits.

COASTAl CCr~MISjiN A·,S·MN~·,9·91

EXHIBIT # ..... 6. . ..;. --PAGE •• ~. OF ~-

•

•

•

Environmental Review The proposed temporary event is exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Per the CEQA Guidelines the event is exempt pursuant to the following provisions: Section 15304 (e), "Minor Alterations to Land"; Section 15311 (c), "Accessory Structures"; and, Section 15323, "Nonnal Operations of Facilities for Public Gatherings".

The proposed event is a temporary activity being conducted on the public beach in which there are no mature trees which could be potentially affected. Additionally, the event will not result in any degradation or alteration to the condition of land, water or vegetation. Based upon past events of this nature, no pennanent environmental effects are anticipated.

Coastal Development Permit The Beach area is located within the "OS" (Open Space) district ofthe City's Zoning Code, and is regulated by the provisions ofthe City's certified Local Coastal Program (LCP). The Open Space District allows "Sporting events for which no admission is charged" as a permitted use subject to a temporary use permit. Additionally, given the location and nature of the event the Community Development Department has determined that a Coastal Development Permit is required for the tournament.

Consistent with the regulations of Chapter A.96 of the LCP, an application was filed by the Association of Volleyball Professionals. Community Development Department staff have reviewed the application and prepared a Coastal Development Permit for the event. The Permit is attached as Exhibit 3 .

ALTERNATIVES 1. To authorize the City Manager to execute an agreement with the A VP for the

1999 Manhattan Beach Open August 27-29 with modifications to the agreement. 2. Deny the request. 3. Discuss and redirect staff.

RG:jg.

Attachments: Exhibit 1 -Letter from A VP with Site Plan Exhibit 2 - Proposed Agreement Exhibit 3 - Coastal Development Permit

2D

CGASTl\l COMMISSION A:·S·MN a-<J<) .. H \

-···•)•;:,•"<" ../.i.. 6 t,~~- ;:!.J; j "'H'" ............................. -

r· / r,r.: ..., o- ·-:» . r •'-·!...., -~......... r -~---·

STATE OF CALIFORNIA· THE RESOURCES AGENCY COPY TE WILSON, Governor

CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION South Coast Area Office

South toast Regi~n 200 Oceangate .. 10th Floor Long Beach, CA 90802-4302 (562) 590-5071

APPEAL FROM COASTAL PERMIT DECISION OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT

(Commission Form D>

MAR 1 9 1999

_ _ _ ~AbiFORN!A COASTAL COMMISSION

Please Review Attached Appeal Information Sheet Prior To Completing This Form.

SECTION I. Appellant<s>

Name, mailing address and telephone number of appellantCs>: WILLIAM VICTOR

POD 24A72, LOS ANGELES, LOS ANGELES, CA. 90024 ( 310-) 374-0086

Zip Area Code Phone No.

SECTION II. Decision Being Appealed

1. Name of local/port government: CITY OF MANHATTAN BEaCH

BEACH AND ADJACENT

a. Approval; no special conditions: _____ ...,.,.... __ _

b. Approval with spechl conditioras:.x~__,..----------,

c. Denlal: '2tJuf( <",.a~ t/-4 /3-u,, Note: For jurisdictions with a total LCP, denial

decisions by a local government cannot be appealed unless the development is a major energy or public works project. Denial decisions by port governments are not appealable.

TO BE COMPLETED BY COMMISSION:

APPEAL No:A--G-MA/ta,-99-1//

DATE FILED: ~.fl, qq Co flSTI: 1 COM!t!'~=--~~u .... N N rh. f~,h;l.)va

,

DISTRICT: so.CoB~t HS: 4/88

A·S·MNl3·99·l·

EXHIBIT # ····---1----······· PAGE ••• J .... OF .... 'f ...

•

•

•

APPEAL FROM COASTAL PERMIT DECISION OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT <Page 2>

·s. Decision being appealed was made by CchecK one>:

a. __ Planning Director/Zoning c. __ Planning Commission Administrator

b. ~City Counci 1/Board of d. _Other _____ _ Supervisors

6. Date of local government's decision: .... 3~-.=.2....;.-.::.9.::.9 _______ _

7. Local government's file number Cif any):cpi:!.£.P=..-9:::.;.9:::.;.-:::..:4:!-_____ _

SECTION III. Identification of Other Interested persons

Give the names and addresses of the following pArties. (Use additional paper as necessary.)

a. Name and mailing address of permit applicant: ASSOCIATION OF VOLLEYBALLPROFESSIONALS 300 WASHINGTON BLVD.STE 600 MARINA DEL REY,CA. 90292 (THEY ARE BANKRUPT, I AM INFORMED SO THE ADDRESS MAY NOT BE CURRENT IF THERE IS ONE)

b. Names and mailing addresses as available of those who testified (either verbally or in writing) at the city/county/port hearing(s). Include other parties which you Know to be interested and should receive notice of this appeal •

(1) HARRY FORD,VILLAGE CIRCLE MANHATTAN BEACH

(2)SUSIE BAILEY, 133 13th Street, Manhattan Beach, Ca.

(3) YURY GURVICH, 1430 11th Street, Manhattan Beach

-·--------·---~---·-----

(4)RGBBRT CALDWELL, 2200 StrtH'ld, ~fan'ftattan Beae'A, Ca,

SECTION IV. Reasons Supporting This Appeal

Note: Appeals of local government coastal permit decisions are limited by a variety of factors and requirements of the Coastal Act. Please review the appeal information sheet for assistan~·Ac:"~'fl cnf.."".·,tir-'::_:·, ~' in completing this section. which continues on the next page.i.IU ·"'!,\ ....... Hal.&.)"._,;,'(

. A·~·MtfB·9~·11 \

EXHm:T # ...... t. ......... . PAGE ... 2,. .. OF ... ':f .. .

APPEAL FRQM COASTAL PERMIT DECISION OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT (Page 3>

State briefly your reasons for this appeal. Include a summary description of Local Coastal Program, Land Use Plan, or Port Master Plan policies and requirements in which you believe the project is inconsistent and the reasons the decision warrants a new hearing. CUse additional paper as necessary.) THIS PERMIT VIOLATES THE LCP, CEQA, no traffic/safety studies,

desboys fornormal non-privileged beachgoers use of beach by remov1ng from use 24 volleyball courts, not requiring

• noise control for residents and beach goers, blocking beach despite self Serving language by joint-veututer,The CiLi of Manhattan Beach, there is conspicuous absence from the fi e of compliance with C1tf!l own standards tot such events, Lltete is pxooision for at least 15 tents for the duration of permit, there are no remedies tor failure to comply with the very minimal xequixemetJts-of the mock contract,commercial use of parking lots prohibited by the State ot caritornta ,no plan attacl1ed to mitigate the removal of parking for ordinary beachgoers and users of this coastal area.More will be supplied by the undersigned and other participants during this appeal process.

Note: The above description need not be a complete or exhaustive statement of your reasons of appeal; however, there must be sufficient discussion for staff to determine that the appeal is allowed by law. The appellant, subsequent to filing the appeal, may submit additional information to the staff and/or Commission to support the appeal request.

SECTION V. Certification

The information and facts stated above are correct to the my/our knowledge.

ignature of Ap ellant<s> or Authorized Agent

Date ______ 3_-_1_9_-_9_9 ______________ ____

NOTE: If signed by agent, appellant<s> must also sign below.

Section VI. Agent Authorization

I/We hereby authorize PLEASE SEE ATTACHED* to act as my/our representative and to bind me/us in all matters concerning this appeal. *Other signatures may be attached and/or are being directed

to the Coastal Commission. Please see attached*

•

Gl!f\.J !h!. l;;;.,.h.!o•in.l~ Signature of Appellantt~k~·"l"r..'- rr.>~' :.+:~:

Date · . A ..SMI\\ll- . 1\

Ex. J'"'T ..~.. ~ r1,..,,, iT ......... L.. ...... 6--

PAGE •.• -3 .. OF •••• ~-

•• 0 •••

•

•• •

WE, TilE UNDERSIGNED RESIDENTS AND CITIZENS, WISH TO ADD OUR NAMES AS APPELLANTS TO TilE APPEAL BY WILLIAM VJCTOR. WHOSE VIEWS HAVE REPRESENTED OURS AGAINST TilE CITY OF MANHATTAN BEACH COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR PROJECT NO: COP 994 GRANTING TilE PERMIT TO TilE ASSOCIATION OF VOLLEYBALL PROFESSIONALS TO HAVE A SPORTING EVENT WITH COMMERCIAL ADVERTISING AND BLEACHERS FOR APPROXIMATELY (MORE OR LESS THAN) 1,500 SEATS AND EXCLUSIVL Y UTILIZING TO TilE EXCLUSION OF orn:ERS CERTAIN PORTIONS OF TilE PUBLIC BEACH FOR NO LESS THAN SIX (6) DAYS BEGINNING AUGUST 25 AND THROUGH AUGUST 30 ,1999

. OR TIIEREAFTER UNDER A WRIITEN AGREEMENT WITH CITY Nor REQUIRINGSPEAKERS TO BE PLACED IN DIRECTIONS A WAY FROM BEACH GOERS AND RESIDENTS, CLOSING OFF MORE THAN ONE PARKING LOTS' SPACES FOR BEACHGOER PARKING, AND REMOVING 24 VOLLEYBALL COURTS FOR THAT PERIOD FROM USE BY BEACHGOERS AND WE WISH TO RECEIVE ALL NariCES FROM TilE COASTAL COMMISSION, TilE CITY OF MANHATTAN BEACH, TilE PERMIT APPLICANT AND ALL NariCES NORMALLY RECEIVED BY TilE APPELLANT(S) IN SUCH PROCEEDINGS.

NAME (please print) MAD..ING ADDRESS TEL NUMBER SIGNATURE

\j~ llf. '.u";~ 1Y!>f ifi'~m.l!. ~·~~ -. - -- ·~

. • t . • -- . - . - . . . -

• 0 • • - • - - ... ... - "' - - •• • .~: - - - .. •

. .

WE, TilE UNDERSIGNED RESIDENTS AND CITIZENS, WISH TO AQD OUR NAMES AS APPELLANTS TO TilE APPEAL BY WILLIAM VJCTOR, WHOSE VliWS HAVE REPRESENTED OURS AGAINST TilE CITY OF MANHATTAN BEACH COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR PROJECT NO: COP 994 GRANTING TilE PERMIT TO TilE ASSOCIATION OF VOLLEYBALL PROFESSIONALS TO HAVE A SPORTING EVENT WITH COMMERCIAL ADVERTISING AND BLEACHERS FOR APPROXIMATELY (MORE OR LESS THAN) 1,SOO SEATS AND EXCLUSIVL Y

. UTILIZING TO TilE EXCLUSION OF orn:ERS CERTAIN PORTIONS OF TilE PUBLIC BEACH P~ NO LESS THAN SIX (6) DAYS BEGINNING AUGUST 25 AND THROUGH AUGUST 30,1999 ~ TH£atAFTER UNDER A WRITTEN AGREEMENT WITH CITY Nor REQUIRINGSPEAKERS TO BE PLACED IN DIRECTIONS A WAY FROM BEACHGOERS AND RESIDENTS, CLOSING OFF MORE THAN ONE PARKING LOTS' SPACES FOR BEACHGOER PARKING, AND REMOVING 24 VOLLEYBALL COURTS FOR THAT PERIOD FROM USE BY BEACHGOERS AND WE WISH TO RECEIVE ALL NariCES FROM 11IE COASTAL COMMISSION, THE CITY OF MANHATTAN BEACH, TilE PERMIT APPLICANT AND ALL NariCES NORMALLY RECEIVED BY TilE APPELLANT(S) IN SUCH PROCEEDINGS.

NAME (please print)

~,r=, b;~d.

COASTAL COMMISSION A6-MNB·99-I'\

EXHIBIT '"# r ru. ,.. ..s: l.J. ns: I.J

•

!fAJf OF CALIFORNIA· THE RESOURCES AGENCY PETE WILSON, Govemor

·cALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION South Coast Area Ol'lic:e 200 Oeeangate, Suite 1000 Long Beach, CA eoa02-'302 (562) 510-5071

Page: 1 of 5 .Date: May 22, 1997

· Permit Application No.: A·5·MHS.&7-oa4

NOTICE OF INTENT TO ISSUE PERMIT

On 13 May 1997, the California Coastal Commission granted to Association of Volleyball Professionals (AVP) Coastal Development Permit A-5-MHB-97..084, subject to the attached conditions, for development consisting of: the 1 997 Miller Lite Manhattan Beach Volleyball Tournament on June 1 2-15. More specifically described in the application file in the Commission offices.

The development is within the coastal zone in Los Angeles County at Beach area south of Manhattan Beach Pier, City of Manhattan Beach.

The actual development permit is being held in the Commission office until fulfillment of the Special Conditions imposed by the Commission. Once these conditions have been fulfilled, the permit wiJI be issued. For your information, all the imposed conditions are attached.

.·

Issued on behalf of the California Coastal Commission on May:&. PETER DOUGLAS By: ~ 2 • Executivo Director Title: Coastal Program Analyst

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The undersigned permittee acknowledges receipt of this notice of the California Coastal Commission determination on Permit No. A-5-MHB-97-084, and fully understands its contents, including all conditions imposed.

Date Permittee

Please sign and return one copy of this form to the Commission office at the above address.

COASTAL COMMISSIQAL.. A~.s -MNB -99·1·

EXHIBIT # ........ 8._ ........ _ PAGE ··---~---· OF •• .s.-.. _

•

•

• l

. ..

. . ~OTICE OF INTENT TO ISSUE PERMIT Permit Application No. A-5-MHB-97-084

Page 2 of 5

STANDARD CONDITIONS

1. .l'l.otice of Receipt and Acknowledgment. The permit is not valid and development shall not commence until a copy of the permit, signed by the permittee or authorized agent, acknowledging receipt of the permit and acceptance of the terms and conditions, is returned to the Commission office.

2. Expiration. If development has not commenced, the permit will expire two years from the date on which the Commission voted on the application. Development shall be pursued in a diligent manner and completed in a reasonable period of time. Application for extension of the permit must be made prior to the expiration date.

3. Compliance. All development must occur in strict compliance with the proposal set forth in the application for permit, subject to any special conditions set forth below. Any deviation from the approved plans must be reviewed and approved by the staff and may require Commission approval.

4. Interpretation. Any questions of intent or interpretation of any condition will be resolved by the Executive Director or the Commission.

5. Inspections. The Commission staff shall be allowed to inspect the site and the project during its development, subject to 24-hour advance notice.

6. Assignment. The permit may be assigned to any qualified person, provided assignee tiles with the Commission an affidavit accepting all terms and conditions of the permit.

7. Ierms and Conditions Bun with the Land. These terms and conditions shall be perpetual, and it is the intention of the Commission and the permittee to bind all future owners and possessors of the subject property to the terms and conditions.

SPECIAL CONDITIONS: 1. Parkjng/Traffjc Management Plan

Prior to the issuance of the Coastal Development Permit and May 30, 1997, the applicant shall submit a Parking/Traffic Management Plan, for the review end approval of the Executive Director. The approved plan shall be implemented by the applicant and shall include the following components:

e)

.·

The applicant shall provide a valid lease or licensing agreement for remote parking lots providing public parking for no fewer than 1 ,080 cars, in order to replace the parking reserved in the lower pier parking COASTAL COMMISSION

·.u; 8 . EXHIBIT -n- ·····-···-·-

PAGE •••• J... Of •• $.:_

I •

b)

NOTICE OF INTENT TO ISSUE PERMIT Permit Application No. A-5-MHB-97-084

Page 3 of 5

Jots and on the street for the car display, and provide parking to meet the increased demands generated by the proposed event. The replacement parking shall not include any parking Jots that are identified as public beach parking supplies by the certified LCP. The applicant shall provide a valid lease agreement for each Jot indicating its number of spaces and location. The 1 ,080 required parking spaces shall be available for use by all members of the public on Saturday and Sunday (June 14-15, 1997) between the hour• of 7 a.m. to 7 p.m.

The applicant shall be responsible. for the provision of a free shuttle service, In· order to provide free public transportation between the remote parking lots and the event and beach area. The applicant shalf 1;

provide a valid agreement with a shuttle operator, shuttle routes and · operating schedule to provide such a shuttle service, as follows: the shuttle service shall run continuously to provide free public beach transportation between the beach area and the remote parking areas on Saturday and Sunday (June 14-15, 1997) between the hours of 7 a.m. to 7 p.m.; the .. headway" time between shuttle service pickups shall not be more than 15 minutes; and, the free shuttle service shall be available for both the general public and event spectators.

c) The plan shall include conspicuously posted on-street informational signs and banners to direct visitors to the remote 11:1.1 parking areas and 11:1.1 shuttle stops. The signs and banners shall also inform the public of availability of a free bus shuttle for both event customers and the general public. No fewer than ten informational signs shall be placed along major intersections leading into the City i.e., Manhattan Beach Boulevard, Highland Avenue, Manhattan Avenue, Valley Drive, Ardmore Avenue, and Aviation Boulevard. The signs and banners shall be no smaller than 2' x 3'.

d) The applicant shall provide no fewer than eight radio announcements within the Los Angeles county area informing the public of the availability of remote parking. These stations shall represent all diverse ethnic and cultural Los Angeles radio markets and shall include Spanish language, youth and news stations.

e) Interim traffic control shall be provided at the intersection of Manhattan Beach Blvd. and Manhattan Ave. and at other points along those streets, as appropriate, to avoid the need to close the upper pier parking lots due to lack of traffic circulation and potential gridlock at that intersection and around the event site. The traffic control plan coupled with the signage program should direct traffic away from the

•

•

event lite to the remote lots a·nd other available parking In tho vicinity COASTAL COMMI~N

a-exHiBIT # ·-···-····-·--PAGE ••• 3. ... OF __ :;£_

1:

•

•

•

2.


Page 4 of 5

and avoid significant traffic congestion on streets surrounding the event site to the maximum extent possible.

f) The parking/traffic management plan shall include provisions for monitoring and evaluating the effectiveness of the approved plan. The monitoring must document the adequacy of off-site parking by identifying the percentage of lots, or number of spaces, occupied during the time of highest attendance each day; the condition of traffic flow along Manhattan Beach Blvd., Manhattan Ave. and Highland Ave., in the vicinity of the event and along the proposed shuttle routes (i.e., free-flowing but moving, congested, gridlock, etc.); and the effectiveness of signage, traffic officers, etc., based on the applicant's observations and feedback from the public and City of Manhattan Beach. Following the event, the monitoring program shall be summarized in a written report which shall be submitted to the Executive Director on or before July 31 , 1997. The report should identify any problems that occurred and make recommendations for improvements in the future. The report shall be retained in the file and used in the review of future permit applications for the AVP volleyball tournament or similar events .

The permittee shall undertake the development in accordance with the approved parking/shuttle program. Any significant changes to the approved plan should be reported to the Executive Director. No change to the plan shall occur without a Commission-approved amendment to the permit unless the Executive Director determines that no such amendment is required. The applicant shall provide the required parking spaces, signs and free shuttle service as approved by the Executive Director.

Pier. Bicycle Path and The Strand

The event shall not interfere with the public's use of the pier, bicycle path and The Strand, a public walkway that parallels the beach. The pier, bicycle path and The Strand shall remain open and unobstructed. No fences, trucks or other structures shall be placed on the bicycle path or The Strand, or block access to the pier. The applicant shall monitor The Strand and bicycle path in order to prevent any encroachments by event sponsors and vendors.

3. Public Access to and Along the Water

The proposed event, and all associated development, shall not encroach any closer than 50 feet to the highest water mark.

COASTAL COMMISSION

EXHIBIT # ......... B. ......... . PAGE •.... 'i .. OF .S. ... .

-----------------~------------


Page 5 of 5

4. Removal of Temporary Improvements

All temporary improvements permitted herein shall be removed in their entirety and the site restored to its pre-existing condition by no later than 8:30p.m. Monday, June 16, 1997.

5. Conformance with the Lee

Approval of the proposed charge for admission is conditioned upon the Coastal Commission's certification of City of Manhattan Beach Local Coastal Program amendment No. 1 A-97. Accordingly, after compliance with all other conditions of approval and upon issuance of the coastal development permit, the applicant shall be permitted to stage the event as herein approved. However, the permittee shall not require a ticket or otherwise · ~ charge a fee for admission to or seating at any match unless the City of Manhattan Beach Local Coastal Program amendment No. 1 A-97 has been certified by the Commission.

(Note: City of Manhattan Beach Local Coastal Program Amendment No. 1 A· 97 was rejected by the Commission on May 13, 1997. Therefore; the permittee shall not require a ticket or otherwise charge a fee for admission to or seating at any match.]

AFTER YOU HAVE SIGNED AND RETURNED THE DUPLICATE COPY YOU WILL BE RECEIVING THE LEGAL FORMS TO COMPLETE (WITH INSTRUCTIONS) FROM THE SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE. WHEN YOU RECEIVE THE DOCUMENTS IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE LEGAL DEPARTMENT AT (415) 904-5200.

CP:bll

17014nol

c:\mloffic:e\winword\templltelregnoi.dot Printed on May 22. 1117

•

•

COASTAL COMMISSION

• . 8· EXHIBIT # ..................... .

PAGE .... ?... OF •. ::a.:..

.':>LH.Lt:.. Ui' .t:.. \' t:..l'H .:>

I ~~ .. -. -

I DATE ORGANIZATION OF NAME EVENT

2/12- City of Manhattan 3126 Beach

'. .

•• Los Anseles County

Department of Beaches and Harbors

MARINA DEL REY AND BEACHES SCHEDULE OF EVENTS

-·- -.----

Questions? Contact: Lynn Atkinson

Department of Beaches and Harbors 13837 Fiji Way

"'

Marina del Rey, CA 90292 TELEPHONE: 3101305-9565

FAX: 310/823-6841

.. --- -- ~~---··

CONTACT US TO HAVE YOUR EVENT LISTED ON OUR WEBSITE! -·~- ·- ...

FEBRUARY 1999

NAME OF EVENT/ CONTACTPERSON:ILOCATION~¥r~ 1 SPECTATORS

TYPE OF EVENT WELCOME

6:00a.m.-M. Setterholm 7:30a.m.

Physical Fitness 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan Monday, YES Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier ·wednesday, 310/545-5621 Friday,

Saturday

MARCH 1999

.l "b""' 1 •. ~

Jl

II

PARTICIPANTS ONLY

http://beaches.co.la.ca.us/scriptslsched l.htm COASTAL COMMISSION A5·MN5 .. <)9- 1115118199

EXHIBIT # ....... 9. ... ·--···-PAGE ••••• L. .. OF .•• !.-?._

Sl.:H.hUUL.h Ut .h V .hN 1 ~ J:agt; "-,_

~ -J ~ -DATE OF ORGANIZATION NAME OF EVENT/ CONTACT PERSON· LOCATION EVENT SPECTATORS PARTICIPANTS

EVENT NAME TYPE OF EVENT • TIME WELCOME ONLY


2112. City of Manhattan Physical Fitness 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan Monday, YES 3126 Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Wednesday,

310/545-5621 Friday, Saturday

USSF Los Angeles - M.Drummy USSF Western 320 A venida Sierra

3t6-3n Region Surfmg Orange County San Clemente, CA Torrance 7:00a.m.- YES Coastal Grand Prix State Beach 6:00p.m. Association Surfing Contest 92672

949/369-6677

L. Noble 6:00p.m.-

3/8/99-4137 Alia Road Burton Puppy

12131199 Correct-A-Pet Dog Training Classes Los Angeles, CA Chace Park Class YES 90066 (Grass Area) 7:00p.m.-310/821-0882 Adult Dogs

C. Griffin

3/13. California Beach Volleyball 8330 W. Manchester Will Rogers 8:30a.m. Volleyball Playa del Rey, CA YES 3114 Association Tournament 90293 Tower 18 8:00p.m.

310/821-0960

C. Cutting or J. Funtsch

Volleyball 1147 Manhattan Ave., Manhattan 8:00a.m.-3/13 Volleyball Ventures #201 YES Tournament Manhattan Beach, CA Beach Pier 7:00p.m.

90266 310/376-4541

A. Lukei Marina 3908 Las Flores 3/14 Adventures Sports Sunset Paddles Canyon Beach 3:00p.m.- YES (Kayaking) Malibu, CA 90265 (Mothers 6:00p.m.

310/396-8790 Beach)

- ----·- ----~-~-

http://beaches.co.la.ca.us/scripts/sched l.htm COASTAL COMMISS!QI

99

• • ---------------------~=------------iE;.X~I-f~IB~IT :fl: --------=::-PAGE --~-- OF /~.&;'

~Ltl.C Ul' C Vl'l" 0

• J. 41!:;1,..) .....

------" --- -' B. Press or

D. Houser

3/27 King•s Harbor Bodyboard Contest 219 N. Broadway Manhattan 7:00a.m.- YES Church Redondo Beach, CA Beach Pier 5:00p.m. 90266 310/376-6555

P. Simon

3/27- Marina del Rey Annual Marina del ... ~. 4230 Del Rey Avenue Weigh-in at 3:00p.m.-3/28 Anglers Rey Halibut Derby · Marina del Rey, CA Burton 6:00p.m. YES

90292 Chace Park 310/821-7262

1999

DATE ORGANIZATION NAME OF EVENT/ SPECTATORS PARTICIPANTS OF NAME TYPE OF EVENT CONTACT PERSON: I,OCATION 'TIME WELCOME ONLY EVENT

L. Noble 6:00p.m.-

3/8/99- 4137 Alia Road Burton Puppy

12/31/99 Correct-A-Pet Dog Training Classes Los Angeles, CA Chace Park Class YES 90066 (Grass Area) 7:00p.m.-310/821-0882 Adult Dogs

-~-·



90266 310/376-4541

@] C. Saikley 5:00p.m.-City of Manhattan Adult Volleyball 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 7:30p.m. YES Beach Instruction Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Monday-1

310/545-5621 Friday

bl I Physical Fitness

6:00a.m.- II M. s~~oolm l~ 7:30a.m. City of Manhattan 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan Monday, YES . Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Wednesday,

http://beaches.co.la.ca.us/scripts/sched l.htm COASTAL COMMIS~JpJt9

EXHIBIT # ........ 2 ....... ·-.3. PAGE •••••••••• OF •• t.:2_

;:,L..HJ.::.UULt:. U1' t:. V t:.!~ 1;::, .l&l~~ .....

L_jl II 11310/545-5621 IL _j[Friday, L II I -

. _ Saturday

§] J. Bourget Santa Monica Bay Halibut Derby

2117 Ashland A venue Burton 12:00p.m.- YES Halibut Derby Santa Monica, CA Chace Park 6:00p.m. 1

310/450-5131

Intramural Sport Erin or Judy 3201 N. Sepulveda

4/13 South Bay Sport Leagues: Beach SuiteD Rosecrans 6:00p.m.- YES and Social Club Football and Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Ave. Beach 8:00p.m. Soccer 310/546-1121

Erin or Judy

4/14- South Bay Sport Intramural Sport 3201 N. Sepulveda Manhattan 6:00p.m.-Leagues: 4x4 and 2x2 SuiteD YES 4/15 and Social Club Beach Volleyball Manhattan Beach, CA Beach Pier 8:00p.m.

310/546-1121

K. Conti 3699 Wilshire Blvd.

4/24 March. of Dimes WalkAmerica Walk- #520 Marina 7:00a.m.- YES a-thon Los Angeles, CA Beach 4:00p.m. 90010-2719 213/637-5041

A. Lukei Marina Sunset Paddles 3908 Las Flores Beach 3:00p.m.-4125 Adventures Sports Canyon YES (Kayaking) Malibu, CA 90265 (Mother's 6:00p.m.

310/396-8790 Beach)

I MAY 1999 I DATE ORGANIZATION NAME OF EVENT/ Ell EVENT I SPECfATORS PARTICIPANTS OF CONTACT PERSON: EVENT NAME TYPE OF EVENT TIME WELCOME ONLY

C. Saikley .,..,. 5:00p.m.-EJcicyof~ttan Adult Volleyball 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan . 7:30p.m. YES Beach Instruction Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Monday-

310/545-5621 Friday

http://beaches.eo.la.ea.us/scripts/sched l.htm COASTAL COMMIS§I.ett

• • EXHIBIT# •• ~ PAGE _____ 'f __ OF ~1..2_··

::,L.HJ..:.UULJ::. Ul' 1:. v 1:.!"' 1 i:>

• '. • 1 <1~\.. ..J •••

-I


415- City of Manhattan Physical Fitness 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan .Monday,

YES 6/11 Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Wednesday, 310/545-5621 Friday,

Saturday

A. Lukei Marina Sunset Paddles 3908 Las Flores Beach 3:00p.m.-

5/1 Adventures Sports Canyon YES (Kayaking) Malibu, CA 90265 (Mother's 6:00p.m.

310/396-8790 Beach)

L. Noble 6:00p.m.-

3/8/99- 413 7 All a Road Burton Puppy

12/31/99 Correct-A-Pet Dog Training Classes Los Angeles, CA Chace Park Class YES 90066 (Grass Area) 7:00p.m.-310/821-0882 Adult Dogs

J. Miller Manhattan Pure Surfing Spring Showdown 524 14th Street Beach at 6:30a.m.-

5/1 - 5/2 Manhattan Beach, CA YES Experience Surf Contest 90266 Rosecrans 2:30p.m.

310/546-4451 Avenue

~~!ltli!tlU!!: J. Funtsch


90266 310/376-4541

D. Smith Manhattan 5/15- California Beach Volleyball 112- 38th St. Beach at Call for 5/16

Volleyball Tournament

Manhattan Beach, CA Rosecrans time YES Association 90266 Ave. 310/545-9917

Cl Volleyball Ventures

C. Cutting or

I M~~ II 8:00am. -I J. Funtsch

Volleyball 1147 Manhattan Ave., #201 YES

COASTAL COMMISSION http:/ /beaches.co.la.ca.us/scripts/sched l.htm 5/18/99

EXHIBIT # .......... 2.·-··· PAGE ••. ..5.. •• OF .L:i._

~l..lU..:.UULJ.:. Vi' J.:. V J.:..t'l .1. i:> J. ... b ..... ,...

Ll II

J Manhmmn Beac~ CA 1 _JD L 90266 310/376-4541

- ~ ' '-

_JUNE 1999 l

Tournament Beach Pier .. 7:00 p.m

~'},TE ORGANIZATION NAME OF EVENT/ FONTACf PERSON· ~ WCATION ~~VENT I SPECTATORS PARTICIPANTS EVENT NAME TYPE OF EVENT • TIME WELCOME ONLY

~ C. Saikley 5:00p.m .• City of Manhattan Adult Volleyball 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 7:30p.m. YES Beach Instruction · Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Monday -

310/545-5621 Friday


415- City of Manhattan Physical Fitness 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan Monday, YES 6/11 Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Wednesday,


L. Noble 6:00p.m.-

3/8/99-4137 Alta Road Burton Puppy

12131/99 Correct-A-Pet Dog Training Classes Los Angeles, CA Chace Park Class YES 90066 (Grass Area) 7:00p.m.-310/821-0882 Adult Dogs

1~4-~61 --~-

§ Men's Novice C. Saikley City of Manhattan Volleyball 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan YES Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Tournament 310/545-5621

.

~~5-~6~ California Beach C. Griffin Will Rogers Volleyball 8330 W. Manchester 8:30a.m.-

Volleyball Tournament Playa del Rey, CA Beach Tower 8:00p.m. YES Association 310/821-0960 18

D. Aitken Dockweiler Beach Volleyball

1314 Lorna Drive, #1 Beach at 8:00a.m.-6/12 Beach Volleyball Hermosa Beach, CA. YES

Events 90254 Playa del 6:00p.m.

310/937-4795 Rey __ ,

---·-···········-

http://beaches.co.la.ca.us/scripts/sched l.htm COASTAL COilUf~&QN

• • EXHIBIT ~---9. ······--0 IS PAGE ·--· ••• f ___ _:_

~LU.LloUl' !oV!ol'i> • EJ Locomotion '99 !:J~ishop Boys and Girls 5K/10K Walk/Run 2232 Lincoln Blvd. Club of Venice Bicycle Fun Ride Venice, CA

Dragon Boat Races 310/578-0095

§] -

California Beach C. Griffin

Volleyball Volleyball 8330 W. Manchester

Association Tournament Playa del Rey, CA 3 310/821-0960

EJ C. Saikley City ofManhattan I Over-the-Line 1400 Highland Ave. Beach Softball Manhattan Beach, CA

310/545-5621


Volleyball r l•fHvfaDbattan Ave., 6/19 Volleyball Ventures #201 Tournament Manhattan Beach, CA

90266 310/376-4541

J. Tingl~Y 6/21- Summer Beach Camp 1537 Stanford Ave.

9/3 BeachSports, Inc. and Junior Lifeguard Redondo Beach, CA Program 90278

310/318-6072 ~

C. Saikley 6/21- City of Manhattan Aqualetics 1400 Highland Ave. 8/27 Beach Manhattan Beach, CA

310/545-5621

§] J C. Saikley

City of Manhattan Beach Camp 1400 Highland Ave. Beach Manhattan Beach, CA 7

310/545-5621

Ill II II C. Saikley

http://beaches.co.la.ca.us/scripts/schedl.htm

J Burton 8:00a.m.-

Chace P~k . 2:00p.m.

Will Rogers 8:30a.m.-Tower 18 8:00p.m.

Manhattan Beach at 8:00a.m.-

26th St. 6:00p.m.

-

Manhattan 8:00a.m.-Beach Pier 7:00p.m.

Manhattan Beach at 8:30a.m.-14th St., 4:30p.m. Redondo Monday-Beach at Friday Avenue I

9:00a.m.-Manhattan l2:00p.m. Beach at Tuesday 8th St. and

Thursday

Manhattan 7:00a.m.-

Beach at ·5:00p.m. Monday-8th St. Friday

II Manhattan 110:00 a.m.-~

4:00p.m.

1 oJ.gl. I •. ~ YES ~ YES CJ

=:J r=

YES

NO

YES

YES

YES

II I CO:\SIAL COMMISSION.

5/18/99

EXHIBIT # ---·-----'1-PAGE •.•. Z .. OF .1~

~L.tU..:.UULt:. Ut· t:. 'V t:.fll 1.::, J.w0 ;..o ....

6/21- .. City ofManhattan 1400 Highland Ave EJIB• ~ :A ~~~~ l~y I YES IL_j EJ C. Saildey Manhattan ~45 p.m. -

City of Manhattan Boogie Board Class 1400 Highland Ave. Beach at 0 p.m. YES Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Sth St onday -

310/545-5621 . day

EJ I I C. Saikley 6:00p.m.-City of Manhattan Ocean Awareness 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan. 8:00p.m. YES Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pter Monday -

310/545-5621 Friday


6/21 - City of Manhattan Physical F' tness 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan Monday, YES 8/20 Beach 1 Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Wednesday,


City of Manhattan Surfing Class 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan. 8:30a.m. YES Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pter Monday-EJ I I C. Saikley 7:00a.m. -

310/545-5621 Friday I

City of Manhattan Youth Volleyball 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 12:00 p.m. YES EJ C. Saikley 9:00a.m. -

Beach Instruction Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Monday -310/545-5621 Friday

J. Bateman-B. Kocsis .

6/21- Hammerhead 1812 Marine Ave Manhattan 8.30 a.m.-8/27 Beach Camp Inc. Beach Camp Manhattan Beach: CA Beach at 4:30p.m., YES

90266 6th St. M-F

310/546-7223

EJ M 1 dW 1 C.Saikley §] City of Manhattan en~ m: omens 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan Beach AA ol eyball Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier . YES

Tournament 310/545-5621

http://beaches.co.la.ca.us/scripts/sched 1.htm

• • COP~STAl COMMISSION

5/18/99

EXHIBIT # .. .a9.. ... _ PAGE ----~--~ :!...:[_ .,.

..>\....11LJ..IULL V1' L ~ Li>j!..>

• • Los Anaeles County

Department of Beaches and Harbors

MARINA DEL REY AND BEACHES SCHEDULE OF EVENTS

Questions? Contact: Lynn Atkinson

Department of Beaches and Harbors 13837 Fiji Way

Marina del Rey, CA 90292 TELEPHONE: 310/305-9565

FAX: 310/823-6841

~ - --- -

CONTACT US TO HAVE YOUR EVENT LISTED ON OUR WEBSITE!

JULY 1999

.b~,9 -.

OF ORGANIZATION NAME OF EVENT/ CONTACT PERSON· LOCATION EVENT SPECTATORS PARTICIPANTS DATE E~EfJ !

EVENT NAME TYPE OF EVENT • TIME WELCOME ONLY

L. Noble 6:00 p.m. -3/8/99 . 4137 Alia Road Burton Puppy 12131199 Correct-A-Pet Dog Training Classes Los Angeles, CA Chace Park Class YES

90066 (Grass Area) 7;00 p.m. -310/821-0882 Adult Dogs

~ C. Saildey 5:00p.m.- I II 1 City of Manhattan Adult Volleyball 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 7:30p.m. YES Beach Instruction Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Monday -

http://beaches.co.la.ca.us/scripts/sched2.htm COASTAL COj\Y;/l~~ION

EXHIBIT # ________ 2 .......... . PAGE ___ J. ____ OF .iS.

;)L.UCUUL...t:. U.l.' C v 1:.1~ i,::, !<4~1.,;·--· 10

I I I I 3 10/545~5621 II II Friday II II JJ

J T' 1 Manhattan , · mg e.Y Beach at 8·30 am • I

6121 Summer Beach Camp 1537 Stanford Ave. 14th St 4:30 p. ·

913 • BeachSports, Inc. and Junior Lifeguard Redondo Beach, CA Redond~ Mond~~: NO YES Program 90278 B h ·da

310/318-6072 eac at Fn Y Avenue I

C S 'kl 9:00 am. -• 31 ey Manhattan 12·00 p m

6121 - City of Manhattan Aqualetics 1400 Highland Ave. Beach at M~nday. · YES 8127 Beach Manhattan Beach, CA '

310/545-5621 8th St. rne:a~esday,

EJ . I I C. Saik!•Y Manhattan 7:00 a.m. -Crty ofManhattan Beach C 1400 Highland Ave. Beach 81 5:00p.m. YES Beach amp Manhattan Beach, CA 8th St Monday -

310/545-5621 . Friday

C Saikley I 0:00 a.m. -

6121 - City of Manhattan Beach Trip Day 1400 Highland Ave. ~~a!:" i2~st.~· YES 8127 Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Marine and

310/545~5621 Thursday

EJ . C. SaiJc!ey Manhattan 12:45 p.m. -Ctty of Manhattan Boogie Board Class 1400 Htghland Ave. Beach at 4:00 p.m. YES Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Sth St Monday -

310/545-5621 . Friday

EJ C. Saikley 6:00p.m.-

City of Manhattan Ocean A ness 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 8:00 p.m. YES Beach ware Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Monday -

310/545-5621 Friday

6:00am.-M. Setterholm 7:30am.

6121 - City of Manhattan . . 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan Monday, 8120 Beach Phystcal Fitness Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at P...ier Wednesday, YES

310/545-5621 · Friday, Saturday

----·-···-- --··-- L___ _____ ,, -------·-·················

COASTAL COMMISSION http://beaches.co.lacaus/scripts/sched2.htm 5/18/99

• • EXHIBITA----.. --2. ____ _ PAGE -~- ·•OF ./...1!2...

• .. • ./'F~-.,:}\....11Li.JULL Vl LV L!'i 10

EJ I C. Saikley 7:00a.m.-

City of Manhattan Surfing Class 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 8:30a.m. YES Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier . Monday-7 310/545-5621 Friday

EJ C. Saikley 9:00a.m.-

City of Manhattan Youth Volleyball 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 12:00 p.m. YES Beach Instruction Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Monday-7 310/545-5621 Friday

17/3 -7/41 J. Neuens

C.B. V .A./Neuens 2 Man Beach 5054 Moonstone Way ZumaBeach 7:00a.m.- YES Volleyball Oxnard, CA 93035 Tower2 8:00p.m. 805/984-8382

K. Johnson

Fourth of July 4701 Admiralty Way Marina del 9:00p.m.-7/4 Free Fireworks Show Marina del Rey, CA ReyMain YES Fireworks 90292 Channel 10:00p.m.

310/305-9546

EJ Junior Open C. Saikley City of Manhattan 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 9:00a.m.-Beach Volleyball Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier 7:00p.m. YES 1 Tournament 310/545-5621

D. Smith Manhattan 7/17- California Beach Volleyball 112- 38th Street Beach at Call for 7/18 Volleyball Tournament Manhattan Beach, CA Rosecrans time YES

Association 90266 Avenue 310/545-9917 !



90266 310/376-4541

~llbutmnerbead II

I J. Bateman- B. Kocsis 1812 Marine Ave. I Manhattan lls:Jhm.- II I I

COASTAl COMMISSiON http://beaches.co.la.ca.us/scripts/sched2.htm 5/18/99

EXHIBIT # _________ 9_ _________ _ PAGE __ _/.[_ __ Of . .!5.

L:>\...UCUULJ.:. U!' J.:.ll J.:.l'l! .:>

LJ Beach Camp Inc.

II

Beach Camp

_j United States Youth Volleyball Volleyball for Kids

7/17 League Charity Volleyball and Los Angeles Tournament Ronald McDonald House

7/24- California Beach · Volleyball 7/25 Volleyball Tournament Association

EJ Classic Yacht Old Fashioned Day in Association the Park

I DATE ORGANIZATION NAME OF EVENT/ OF NAME TYPE OF EVENT EVENT

3/8/99-12/31/99 Correct-A-Pet Dog Training Classes

§] City of Manhattan Adult Volleyball Beach Instruction 1

l=l Summer Beach Camp BeachSports, Inc. and Junior Lifeguard

http://beaches.co.la.ca.us/scripts/sched2.htm

•

J.<l~~--· Y)_

-- ----~---- ----- - -- - -- .. ---

16tit-st. --

II II L_ _j 90266 310/546-7223

Manhattan Beach. CA .. Beach at 4:30p.m YES

R. Sapoznik 12501 S. Isis Ave. Will Rogers 9:00a.m.- YES Hawthorne, CA 90250 Tower 15 6:00p.m. 310/643-8398

D. Smith Manhattan 112 - 38th Street Beach at Call for Manhattan Beach, CA Rosecrans time YES 90266 Avenue 310/545-9917

J. Butz Burton lO:OOa.m.-~I I Chace Park 626/968-8503 and Docks 3:00p.m.

AUGUST 1999 I I CONTACT PERSON:~ LOCATION II~~~ I SPECfATORS PARTICIPANTS WELCOME ONLY

L. Noble 4137 Alia Road Burton Los Angeles, CA Chace Park 90066 (Grass Area) 310/821-0882

C. Saikley 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier 310/545-5621

J. Tingley Manhattan Beach at 1537 Stanford Ave. 14th St., Redondo Beach, CA

•

6:00p.m.-Puppy Class 7:00p.m.-Adult Dogs

5:00p.m.-7:30p.m. Monday-Friday

8:30am.-4:30p.m.

YES

YES

~I YES I Co#\<!Tnlr.n~,nn~rs~"'""' ~

"'"' H q,ts ui~vi~ 'll!t. ~. 5/18/99

EXHIBIT #·---9--------- . PAGE ---~------ 0~ _./_5_

L:>LHLUULL U1' L \' Ll'l 1 .::> 9, • Redondo Monday-

.lu~~ ,._.. ··3 [J~ ~~ I~F~ L ·~-'

C S "kl 9:00a.m.-· at ey Manhattan 12 ·OO m

6/21- City of Manhattan Aqualetics 1400 Highland Ave. Beach at M~n<t!'y, · YES 8/27 Beach Manhattan Beach, CA 8th St W d da

310/545-5621 · ~ nes y, Fnday

EJ . I I C. Saildey Manhattan 7:00a.m. ~ Ctty of Manhattan Beach Cam 1400 Htghland Ave. Beach at 5:00p.m. YES Beach P Manhattan Beach, CA 8th St Monday -

310/545-5621 · Friday

C S "kl I 0:00 a.m. -· at ey Manh ttan 4·00 m

6/21 - City of Manhattan B h T . D 1400 Highland Ave. B ha t T. dap. . YES 8/27 Beach eac np ay Manhattan Beach, CA ea~ a ues Y

310/545-5621 Manne and Thursday

EJ . C. Saik!ey Manhattan 12:45 p.m.-Ctty ofManhattan Boo ie Board Class 1400 Htghland Ave. Beach at 4:00p.m. YES Beach g Manhattan Beach, CA 8th St Monday -

310/545-5621 · Friday

EJ C. Saikley 6:00p.m.-

City ofManhattan O A 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 8:00p.m. YES Beach cean wareness Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Monday -

310/545-5621 Friday


6/21- City of Manhattan Ph . al F"tn 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan Monday, YES 8/20 Beach ystc 1 ess Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Wednesday,


EJ C. Saikley ·7:00a.m.-

City of Manhattan Surfi Cl 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 8:30a.m. YES Beach mg ass Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Monday -

310/545-5621 Friday

I I II I C. Saikley II 119:00 a.m. - II II I COASTAL COMMISSION

http:/ lbeaches.co.la.ca.us/scripts/sched2.htm 5/18/99

EXHIBIT =If: •••••••.. J.. ........ . PAGE •• 1:3. .. OF •• /.<:2..

::tl...l1tUULJ:. U.l' J:. \1 .1:..!~ 1 i:>

Beach EJ City ofManhaltan

lnstruct10n I Youth '!olleyball

[~6-m[ Men•s and Women's City of Manhattan AAA Volleyball Beach Tournament

California Beach 8/14- Volleyball Volleyball ' 8/15 Tournament Association

Volleyball 8/14 Volleyball Ventures Tournament

...tlllll" ........ , Manhattan Open 8128-• AVP Volleyball

- Tournament J \. ~

. uc-_.._ ..... itational 8128- S. Cressman 8129 Volleyball

Tournament

6121- Hammerhead 8/27 Beach Camp Inc. Beach Camp

I

http://beaches.co.la.ca.uslscripts/sched2.htm

•

1400 Highland Ave. j Manhattan 112:00 p.m. ~ Manhattan Beach, CA 310/545-5621

Beach at Pier ~J3a_~Y - .

C. Saikley 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 9:00a.m.-Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier 7:00p.m. 310/545-5621

D. Smith Manhattan 112 - 38th Street Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Call for

Rosecrans time 90266 Avenue 310/545-9917

C. Cutting or J. Funtsch 1147 Manhattan Ave., Manhattan 8:00a.m.-#201 Beach Pier 7:00p.m. Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 310/376-4541

Reception 330 Washington Blvd., #600 Manhattan 9:00 a.m. -Marina del Rey, CA Beach at Pier 6:00p.m. 90292 310/577-0775

S. Cressman Dockweiler 7906 Arlane Avenue Los Angeles, CA Beach at 9:00a.m.-

90045 Playa del 8:00p.m.

310/337-0601 Rey

J. Bateman- B. Kocsis 1812 Marine Ave. Manhattan 8:30a.m.-Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at 4:30p.m., 90266 6th St. M-F 310/546-7223

SEPTEMBER 1999

•

YES

YES

YES

YES

YES

YES

YES

.1.<1!:;.~ ....

1"/

II I

I COASTAL COM~,~ISSION

5/18/99

EXHIBIT ._ • .2__ . PAGE ---~ OF •• !.~2-

:::,~H.L:.UUL.L:. UJ.' C V Ci'l i .::>

• • DATE ORGANIZATION NAME OF EvENT/ I CONTA~ PERSON·!! LOCATION~VENT I OF

EVENT NAME TYPE OF EVENT • TIME -~ w-•

L. Noble 6:00p.m.-

318199- 413 7 Alia Road Burton Puppy

12/31199 Correct-A-Pet Dog Training Classes Los Angeles, CA Chace Park Class 90066 (Grass Area) 7:00p.m.-310/821-0882 Adu1tDogs .....

@] C. Saikley 5:00p.m.-City of Manhattan Adult Volleyball 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan 7:30p.m. Beach Instruction Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Monday-1

310/545-5621 Friday

J. Ting~ Manhattan Beach at 8:30am.-

6/21- Summer Beach Camp 1537 Stanford Ave. 14th St., 4:30p.m. BeachSports, Inc. and Junior Lifeguard Redondo Beach, CA 913 Program 90278 Redondo Monday-

310/318-6072 Beach at Friday Avenue I

§] -~ Malibu Surfing G. Stellem Malibu

6:30a.m.-Surfing Contest 1460 Casa Grande Surfrider Association Pasadena, CA 91104 B h 6:00p.m. 2

6261798-9868 eac


Volleyball 114 7 Maiihattan Ave., Manhattan 8:00am.-9/11 Volleyball Ventures #201 Tournament Manhattan Beach, CA Beach Pier 7:00p.m.

90266 310/376-4541

-··


9113- City of Manhattan Physical Fitness 1400 Highland Ave. Manhattan Monday, 11/12 Beach Manhattan Beach, CA Beach at Pier Wednesday,


I I I J. Griesbacl! ll II II

http:/lbeaches.co.la.causlscriptslsched2.htm

SPECTATORS WELCOME

YES

NO

YES

YES

YES

IS •

"""c"',&

PARTICIPANTS I ONLY

YES

YES

I COAST;1l CtJMMf3SUn~

5118199

EXHIBIT # --------~------·····PAGE -~-I.S:.. OF .LS:.

•

I

•

•

r-s.documents.coastal.ca.gov/reports/1999/6/f8a-6-1999.pdf · volleyball tournament in the...

Documents