r u j (/2 carna90 court-reporting compaq, ltd. q ii·

CARNA90 COURT-REPORTING COMPA...Q, LTD. 888 Mililani Street, Suite 705_

Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 ~'r:-Telephone: (808) 532-0222

(FAX 808-532-0234)-·

EDWIN SAKODA 1151 PUNCHBOWL STREET HONOLULU, HAWAII 96813

Date: May 30,1995

RE: CIVIL OR CASE NO. 92-0655-02

r U

r ,I I "I U J __ (/2 "p\.J-.\ J... I

I q 0 II· CL ) Q 1

ZuoY-XD.3

MAKAKILO HALE I v. PAN PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION

Deposition(s) of: EDWIN SAKODA

The original of your deposition in the above-entitled case is ready for you to read and sign. Please phone 532-0222 and make arrangements to come in at your earliest convenience.

If not signed by JULY 3. 1995, the original will be sealed without signature, and will be kept on file at our offices.

You are entitled to 30 days in which to read and sign your deposition; however, if trial intervenes, and request is made for this deposition to be filed with the court prior to trial, we will do so without further notice to you.

TRIAL DATE SET FOR:

cc: original transcript

Very truly yours,

Donna L. N. Sato Diane T. Ohata CARNAZZO COURT-REPORTING COMPANY, LTD.

ARCHIE T. lKEHARA, ESQ., JASON M. YOSHIDA, ESQ.

.. o o FUJIYAMA. DUFFY &. FUJIYAMA

.JAMES E. DUFFY, .JR. RODNEY M. FU.JIY ... M ... ... RCHIE T. IKEH"'R ...

GLENN K. S"'TO LESLIE E. KOB ... Y ... SHI

W ... LLACE S. I'U.JIY ... M ... (1925'1994)

LEE T. N ... K ... MUR... STEVEN T. BRITT ... IN W ... RD 1'. N.I'U.JIMOTO REESE R. N ... KAMURA BRIAN P. "'BURANO D"'NIELL[ N.DEGELE·MATHEWS GREGG M. USHIROD... CHRIS .... THOMAS .JEAN POLH ... MUS CREADICK USA· ... NN L. KIMURA

OF COUNSEL PAUL H. SATO

KERRY M. KDM"'TSUB ... R ... D ... VIS D. HIG ...

VIA HAND-DELIVERY

Mr. Edwin Sakoda

ATTORN EYS AT LAW. A LAW CORPORATIOtl-? ~ ,SUITE 2700. PAUAHI TOWER. BISHOP SQUARE

1001 BISHOP STREET

HONOLULU. HAWAII 96813-3427"··~ "!,, -

May 31, 1995

Department of Land and Natural Resources

Commission of Water Resource Management

1151 Punchbowl Street Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

'.' i .. -

Re: Makakilo Hale I, et al. v. Pan-Pacific Construction, Inc., et al.; Civ1l No. 92-0655-02

and Pan-Pacific Construction, Inc. vs. Chiyoda Pacific. Inc .. et al.; Civil No. 94-0582-02

Dear Mr. Sakoda:

TELEPHONE

(808) 53S'0802

TELECOPIER

(80B) 53S· 5117

Enclosed herewith are the four (4) tapes of the CWRM meeting held on August 19, 1992, which you provided to us at your deposition last week.

Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.

ATI: skk

Enclosures as stated

Very truly yours,

FUJIYAMA, DUFFY & FUJIYAMA, Attorneys At Law, A Law

Corporation

~/~ By ARCHIE T. IKEHARA

-

...

,

o FUJI YAMA, DUFFY &

ARCHIE T. IKEHARA 2488-0 -sutte-2-7-{)0-,-Paual1i Tower Bishop Square 1001 Bishop Street Honolulu, Hawaii Telephone No.

Attorney for Defendant and Third-Party Plaintiff PAN-PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION, INC. in civil No. 92-0655-02 and Plaintiff PAN-PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION, INC. in civil No. 94-0582-02

~ fI :,-/ rO "11 n H "'VC4

. qST C1RCUiT COURT STATE OF HAWAII . ISSUED

IqQS MAY -8 P 3: 50

c?' ' .. '~' (.,.,'"

.... ,.

',' ,:,,~

,.' .. c..n c.o

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIRST CIRCUIT

STATE OF HAWAII

MAKAKILO HALE I, an association ) of homeowners; MAKAKILO HALE II, ) an association of homeowners; ) PALEHUA GARDENS, an association ) of hom~owners;~EHOA ) RECREATION CEN'rER, an ) association of homeowners; JOE --) JEFFERS; BERTHA JEFFERS; GLEN ) YOSHIDA; CYNTHIA YOSHIDA; ) KALEINOHEAOKEALAULA SCOTT ) AKAMINE; JANIELLE NAAUAO ) AKAMINE; EDWARD SANTOS; DIANA ) LIN CRANDALL; LORRAIN BURGESS; ) ALFRED DlLAY, JR.; SHARRON ) DlLAY; ALLEN WILLIAMSON; JOYCE ) WILLIAMSON; JAMES L. WINGO; ) ROSELINE QUIOCHO; RODERICK ) QUIOCHO; RANDALL QUIOCHO; DENNIS ) BIERMAN; BRIANA ANDERSON; ALBERT ) MAX CHILDERS; ONA C. SOLBERT; ) TERRIE L. GORTON; STEVEN B. ) ARIEL; RALPH KIRK; JOELLE KIRK; ) MINDY BERGER; JOSEPH M. FORTH; ) JEFFREY IRENZE; CAROL IRENZE; ) RICHARD HELSHAM; NORMA HELSHAM; ) DAVID A. PURVIS; DIANA L. ) PURVIS; HENRY HOFFMAN; LURA JEAN ) HOFFMAN; LUCY KANG; AIDE NOHEMI ) HALDEMAN; STEPHEN D. HALDEMAN; ) TIMOTHY MILLS; MARY MILLS; LEVI )

CIVIL NO. 92-0655-02 [NON-MOTOR VEHICLE TORT] (Consolidated Ca~es)

SUBPOENA .

(Ed Sa;koda)

TRIAL DATE: MARCH 25, 1996

..

Ke. tJUiLu &,C, {.thAi (!104~J2!.

%rt J3ct~ii~ Wff{( 1004-0~)

~al.li~- &,CI w)t ( UOf-,)Z.)

"'~ : ..

.' .

o LAKE; LOUISE LAKE; WILLIAM HART; ) MARIA HART; RODNEY K. HACHIKUBO; ) FRANCES L. AMMON; NELSON CORREA; ) PHILOMINA CORREA; CHARLES PITTS; ) GRATIA PITTS; CLARENCE PlENA; ) VERONICA PlENA; RUDOLPH ) RONACHER; LINDA M. NAJ; MARK ) AMORIN; RAMONA AMORIN; HENRY ) KAALEKAHI, JR.; PEGGY KAALEKAIU; ) JOSEPH NUUANU; ELIZABETH NUUANU; ) JAMES FULGONI; DEANNA FULGONII ) MARGARET Y. FLOYD; EDWARD ) GARCIA; SONJA GARCIA; NIKKI ) MALANI; DAN CARDINAS; DERRIK ) AKAMINE; BENNETT KRISE; SHARI YN ) KRISE; ETHEL M. DAY; GABRIEL ) COMPEHOS; and Plaintiffs JOHN ) DOE 46 through 1000, )

Plaintiffs,

vs.

PAN-PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION, INC., a Hawaii corporation; and Defendants 1 through 10,

Defendants,

and

PAN-PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION, INC., a Hawaii corporation,

vs.

Defendant and Third-Party Plaintiff,

CHIYODA PACIFIC, INC.; MAKAKILO GOLF CORP.; JOHN DOES 1-100; JANE DOES 1-100; DOE PARTNERSHIPS 1-100; DOE CORPORATIONS 1-100; ROE "NONPROFIT" CORPORATIONS 1-100; AND ROE GOVERNMENTAL ENTITIES 1-100,

Third-Party Defendants.

2

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

o

o PAN-PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION, INC., )

) Plaintiff, )

) vs. )

) CHIYODA PACIFIC, INC.; MAKAKILO ) GOLF CORP.; JOHN DOES 1-100; ) JANE DOES 1-100; DOE ) PARTNERSHIPS 1-100; DOE ) CORPORATIONS 1-100; ROE "NON- ) PROFIT" CORPORATIONS 1-100; AND ) ROE GOVERNMENTAL ENTITIES 1-100, )

) Defendants. )

-------------------------------) SUBPOENA

THE STATE OF HAWAII:

o CIVIL NO. 94-0582-02 [Other Civil Action]

TO THE SHERIFF of the State of Hawaii or his Deputy, or

any Police Officer in the State of Hawaii:

YOU ARE COMMANDED to ~ubpoena ED SAKODA, State of

Hawaii, Department of Land and Natural Resources, Water Resource

Management Division, 1151 Punchbowl Street, Honolulu, Hawaii,

96813, and to appear before a court reporter at Fujiyama, Duffy &

Fujiyama, suite 2700, Pauahi Tower, Bishop Square, 1001 Bishop

street, Honolulu, Hawaii, on Thursday, May 25, 1995, at 9:00

o'clock a.m., to testify as witness on the part of PAN-PACIFIC

CONSTRUCTION, INC. for the taking of a deposition upon oral

examination in the above-entitled matter.

DATED at Honolulu, Hawaii, MAY -8 1995

N.ANAYA

Clerk of the Court

3

--------------------------------- -----------------------,--

o o RETURN OF SERVICE

Received this subpoena at ______ _ on ________________ __

and on I at I served it on the within

named by delivering a copy to and

tendering to the fee for one day's attendance and the

mileage allowed by law.

DATED:

4

-----------------------------------___ I'r ___________ -ifWl""_

D Q Please sign and return this receipt to: (Cheryl) c\0213.2A

CARNAZZO COURT REPORTING COMPANY, LTD. 888 Mililani street, suite 705

Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Telephone: (808) 532-0222

Fax: (808) 532-0234

CIVIL NO. 94-0582-02 COURT: FIRST CIRCUIT

CASE TITLE: PAN-PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION, INC. v CHIYODA PACIFIC, INC.

RECORD FROM: STATE OF HAWAII, DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL

RESOURCES, COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

REGARDING: THE MAKAKILO GOLF COURSE PROJECT

PRODUCED IN RESPONSE TO SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM IN TH~ ABOVE-ENTITLED MATTER. RETURN OF RECORDS HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGED.

DATED )/:2-I/r5: BY:~a~/<.L.l..;,~!~(J~do-=--_____ _ rl rJ

,

'~ ~~ l. ..... - ~~ ~~7 ~ --::~ ~ (/ ( /-1' ~ .uv..-........ --r ,:7..' ~/\1N

......... .,.,......,. ~ t .-.., ~ -wJ.'n(j "

'r'" Ly ffY ~# ~ L~ ~?i --G

~'*1''7 ypfY/ (z 04- ~~ (t

4-~/'W fJ~

'~J/~~

~. ~ ~ • '.; -,.-.c-• .:-. ---:-rok~.---.:""'-.. /;,

?-~1f 0,,)<& • 0

os "~I

)""Pt'I"

'~;l ~'>:Vj

OW8W

o

March 3, 1993

Department of Land and Natural Resources

Commission on Water Resource Management

POBox 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

ATTENTION: RAE M. LOUIE

Gentlemen:

o

~~ Re: Temporary Use of Fort Barrett Well (Well No. 2004-~)

The undersigned corporation is the general contractor with respect to the construction of the Makakilo Golf Course. For reasons of economics, the construction has come to a temporary halt. As the general contractor, and considering that the developer of the golf course is without any agents in Hawaii, we have taken it upon ourselves to do whatever that has come to our attention as being in need of keeping the project viable.

One of the critical elements in the development and operation of a golf course, needless to say, is water. Our attention was invited to a letter dated September 8, 1992 written by Rae M. Louie indicating that the permit to draw water from the above referenced well would expire on March 8, 1993.

In view of the foregoing, we hereby request on behalf of the developers and the owners of the golf course to have the permit extended for another six (6) months from and after March 8, 1993. The reason for needing this extension is predicated upon the fact that all parties are presently exerting their collective efforts in trying to complete the construction of the golf course and until such time as any affirmative efforts are abated, the status quo with respect to water needs to be maintained.

PAN-PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION, INC. PPC-TOKYU JOINT VENTURE

1132 Bishop Street. SUite 2300. Honolulu. Hawaii 96813 Telephone (808) 537 ·2922 FaCSimile (808) 521·6308

o Q Letter to Department of Land and

Natural Resources Page two (2) March 3, 1993

Your cooperation will be appreciated.

Very truly yours,

PAN-PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION, INC.

By----1./'-Y:.i~'L=---==, ~==~-=--, -=--' ===: Hiroshi usami, Vice President

o Q

FIELD MEMORANDUM

FILE REFERENCE: cJ'i~ (~~oJL U '/ USER NAME: Makakilo Golf Course OWNER OF LAND: Chiyoda Pacific FIELD INSPECTION DATE: 12/21/92 WELL LOCATION: Ft. Barrette Well is located 25 feet mauka from the Makakilo Freeway off ramp and 50 feet in from the first road on the right leads to the well site.

TMK 9-2-19:65 QUAD MAP: 0-6 LAT. 21 20' 54" LONG.1S8 04 53"

PRESENT: Richard Jinnai, Darrel Ikeda (Pan Constr. Staff) ph. no. 6721-8961

WATER USE: Well 2004-03 (Makakilo Golf Course) .. Dust control

STATUS: 1. June 12, 1991 Makakilo GC requested permission to test Fort Barrette Well for 6 months.

2. June 18, 1991 request granted by Chairman. 3. Feb. 27, 1992 Makakilo GC requested for 6 mo. extention. 4. May 20, 1992 request denied by Deputy Director. 5. June 23, 1992 Makakilo GC submitted water use permit for

6 to 12 months. 6. August 19, 1992 request was granted by the Commission for 6

months temporary water use only. Extention of up to 6 months may be granted by the Chairman.

WELL DESCRIPTION: The well was drilled 1941 by the U.S. Navy. Since drilled in 1941 no well completion report or as-built were submitted or found. According to the well index and verified in field the well has a 12" casing, and from the Well Index, the total depth 190', ground elevation 175' bottom of solid casing -7'. Chloride reading 243 ppm.

PUMP DESCRIPTION: Pump through sight verification is a 40 hp 3535 rpm motor. Water from the well flows to a 4" CI metered pipe then to a 20,000 gallon metal reservoir located in the golf course construction area. Water trucks uses the water from the reservoir primarily for dust control. On a typical construction day Darrel Ikeda said they use about 40,000 gallons.

Today the golf course construction has been halted due to money problems. Water is not being used from the well. Makakilo Golf Course manages to irrigate the lower end (Pearl City Side) of the golf course, by purchasing water from Oahu Sugar Company's Waihole Ditch System. Water is pumped from the ditch through an 8" pipeline that empties into an open reservoir near the 18th hole. The chloride contents from the ditch system is said to be 10 ppm. Once construction is over Fort Barrette Well will be sealed.

NOTE: Makakilo Golf Course also applied ground water use for Wells 1904-02 and 1904-03. The wells are located 1.1 mile below Farrington Hwy. on the right side of Barbers Pt. Access Road. Both wells has been field checked and water is not being used.

o Wells 1904-02 & 03 will be the primary wells for the Makakilo Golf Course Desalting Plant. Water will then be pumped to the main open reservoir and gravity flow to 3 other open reserviors on the golf course via 10" pipeline. The Ft. Barrette Well will be sealed after construction is over. We need to sent the proper fonn for well sealing.

SUMMARY: 1. Temporary Water Use Permit issued Aug. 19, 1992. 2. Water to be used primarily for dust control. 3. We do not have any well completion report, as-built drawings, and

pumpage data. 4. Using water from Waihole Ditch to irrigate a

portion of the golf course. 5. Need to send proper fonn for well sealing Ft. Barrette Well.

'\

o o

ft?1TC 9 AU ~ Ss December 8, ~

·CU;"n.1S)"'1'iN r~N W~,ltR RESOl:~;CE H/-)iAGEf.~aH

TO: Water and Land Development Division Department of Land and Natural Resources P. O. Box 373 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

Attention: Roy Hardy

SUBJECT: Fort Barrette Well

Transmittal job No. 054-40

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

We herewith transmit the following:

1 copy Form for Makakilo Golf Course - Well Monitoring Data for Fort Barrette Well

Remarks: For your use.

Signed:

~d<~ re Fukumitsu

680 Ala Moana Boulevard, First Floor • Honolulu, Hawaii 96813-5406 • Phone: (808) 521-5361 • Fax: (808) 538-7819 A Belt Collins & Associates Company

PROJECf: MAKAKILO GOLF COURSE - WELL MONITORING DATA FOR FORT BARRETTE WELL

DATE: December 2,1992

GALLONS

DATE: PCCMETER USED FROM

READINGS· LAST READING

(GALLONS) (GALLONS)

01-Dec-92 281291000

• WATER USE DATA PROVIDED BY PAN-PACIFIC

CONSTRUCTION COMPANY (pCC)

0

EQUIVALENT

AVE GALLONS CHLORIDES COMMENTS

USED TESTED

(MGD) (PPM)#

225/230 STARTED PUMPING AND SAMPLED.

# CHLORIDE TESTING BY TOM NANCE WATER RESOURCES ENGINEERING

0

0

."

~aktlO

MR. WILLIAM W. PATY

o MAKAKILOr:fPC?~F:l~pRP.

S2lJEC 7 p3: 2tl 0 E C ~ A 8: 25 December 2, 1992 "

Chairman, Commission On Water Resource Management Dept. of Land and Natural Resources P. O. Box 62i Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

Dear Mr. Paty :

Re: Temporary Use of Fort Barrette Well (Well No. 2004-03)

This is to notify the Commission Of Water Resource Management, Department of Land and Natural Resources, that the temporary use of the Fort Barrette Well Commenced on December 1, 1992. Water usage reports shall be measured and reported to the Commission on a monthly basis by Tom Nance Water Resources Engineering, Inc.

If there are any questions, please call me at 599-8804

cc: Ms. Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director, DLNR Mr. Gregg Fukumitsu, P.E., TNWRE, Inc.

Seven Waterfront Plaza· Suite 220 • 500 Ala Moana Boulevard· Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Phone: 808-599-8804 • Fax: 808-599-5743

Q MAKAKILO GOLF CORP.

, December 2, 1992

MR. WILLIAM W. PATY Chairman, Commission On Water Resource Management Dept. of Land and Natural Resources P. O. Box 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

Dear Mr. Paty :

RECr=,tVE"D

92 DEC., A 9: "J

Re: Temporary Use of Fort Barrette Well (Well No. 2004-03)

This is to notify the Commission Of Water Resource Management, Department of Land and Natural Resources, that the temporary use of the Fort Barrette Well Commenced on December 1, 1992. Water usage reports shall be measured and reported to the Commission on a monthly basis by Tom Nance Water Resources Engineering, Inc.

If there are any questions, please call me at 599-8804

.Sincerely,

~~.~lm~0~s7e~~~~~ Project Manager

cc: ~s. Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director, DLNR Mr. Gregg Fukumitsu, P.E., TNWRE, Inc.


t_

o JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII

STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

REF:WRM-KO

Makakilo Golf COrp. Seven Waterfront Plaza, Suite 220 500 Ala Moana Boulevard Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Gentlemen:

P. O. BOX 621

HONOLULU, HAWAII 96809

SEP - 8 1992

Temporary Use of Fort Barrette Well (Well No. 2004-03)

WILLIAM W. PATY

CHAIRPERSON

JOHN C. LEWIN. M.D. MICHAEL J. CHUN, Ph.D.

ROBERT S. NAKATA RICHARD H. COX. P.E.

GUY K. FUJIMURA

RAE M. LOUI, P.E.

DEPUTY

The Conunission on Water Resource Management approved your request for a temporary water use pennit at its meeting on August 19, 1992. You are permitted to use 360,000 gallons of water per day for construction water, dust controL and the initial growin period of the golf course, subject to the following conditions:

1. The pennit shall be for a period of six months from the date of this letter. An extension of up to six months may be granted by the Chairperson upon showing of good cause. Modification of any other permit condition shall be approved by the Commission.

2. The applicant shall comply with all applicable laws, rules, and ordinances.

3. The applicant shall provide and maintain an approved meter or other appropriate device or means for measuring and reporting total water usage. Water usage shall be measured on a monthly basis and reported to the Conunission.

4. The proposed use shall not adversely affect existing or future legal uses of water in the area, including any surface water or established instream flow standards. This permit shall not constitute a determination of correlative water rights. The permittee is notified and by this provision understands that the quantity of water taken from the well could be reduced by the Conunission in the future. This pennit is not a committment that the pump capacity permitted here or even some lesser amount is guaranteed in the future.

If you have any questions, please contact Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director, at 587-0214.

Very truly yours,

,f --' >,.

ITEM 13

ITEM 3

o o

Mr. Cox said he would secondl.{\p.e motion on the basis that the project can be '~ completed within the two-year period and they ".rill tak@ care of the silt probl~

Unanimously approved (Fujimura/Cox). ~e.e; ~,

HONOLULU BOARD OF WATER SUPPLY APPUCATION FOR STREAM CHANNEL ALTERATION PERMIT. VARIOUS STREAMS BElWEEN HAUUlA AND lAIE. OAHU

Mr. Cox asked if it was possible to complete the project in the two-year time frame if the work is to be done only during the summer/dry months.

Mr. Yuh said they would try to meet the conditions proposed by the staff. They may have a problem with working only during the summer months but will check with the contractor and get back to the staff. Ms. Loui said the reason the project was limited to the summer/dry months (June, July, August) is that the aquatic species spawn in the early winter.

Mr. Cox understood that the BWS did an environmental assessment eEA) and asked if staff comments on EAs. Ms. Loui said staff tries to comment on most EAs. Ms. Samuels added that comments were made on this environmental assessment.

Mr. Nakata asked how the chlorinated water discharge would be handled.

Mr. Hiu said BWS and DOH would be meeting to discuss this matter. He understood that the regulation would come into effect on October 1st. They may be allowed to put the water directly into the wastewater sewer line which goes directly into the sewer treatment plant, not discharged as run-off. Conditions will need to be worked out between BWS, DOH, and the City. In areas where there are no sewer lines, the water will be treated to de-chlorinate the water before discharging.

In terms of crossing each of the streams, Mr. Cox asked how long it would take the contractor to install the pipes.

Mr. Yuh said he could not give exact numbers but depending on the length of the stream and if it's dry, it should not take too long.

Mr. Martin asked if specific precautions or contingencies were made if flood flows occur during construction (written testimony also provided). \

Mr. Yuh replied that they would have to meet with the contractor to work within the plans if those conditions should occur. At this point, there is no specific contingency.

Mr. Cox suggested that the applicant request an extension early on in the project if they find that the project cannot be completed in two years.

Unanimously approved (Cox/Fujimura).

~ <01''' (tt'{., MAKAKILO GOLF CORP •• APPUCATION FORA TEMPORARY WATER USE PERMIT. FORT BARETTE WELL. MAKAKILO GOLF COURSE. OAHU

Mr. Fujimura asked for clarification regarding the condition that the water applied to the golf course be 200 mg/l or less.

Mr. Sakoda stated that was the condition on the caprock well after it is desalted. Mr. Tom Nance, representing the applicant, added that the other source being used

- 4 -

- o

is water purchased from 200 mg/l.

The mix of the waters is well under the

Chairperson Paty asked what phase the Course was in. Mr. Bob Imose replied that they were ready to plant. Planting had been delayed for about six months due to a lack of water. Trees have been planted and are being watered by hand.

NHAC submitted written testimony. Mr. Martin also asked for clarification on the process of approval or written permission given for test pumping or water use because he was unaware of such specific procedures. He felt the applicant also requires a temporary pump installation permit to proceed with the project and he did not notice any such reference in the submittal.

Mr. Sakoda said that the request for a temporary water use permit assumes that a pump will be installed. Mr. Martin stated they were concerned with the staff giving approval for pumping without Commission approval. Mr. Nance added that the well had been abandoned and filled in with mud well above the water table. The :we~ was cl~aned out in the process of adding the well as part of a &esaltin~ 10 I-f C/JifYlIL morutonng reqUIrement.

Mr. Martin understood about perhaps overlooking the pump installation permit but it still did not address his concern about staff giving permission to do the test pumping as it occurred in Items 3 and 4. He felt the Commission should address applying appropriate procedural control over the process.

Mr. Fujimura commented that Mr. Martin's point is well taken but if Mr. Martin went further down the cruonology he would notice tha,t at the point of extension corrective measures were taken.

Mr. Fujimura inquired if 316,000 mgd was enough for a startup on a golf course. Mr. Nance replied that water is also being used from Oahu Sugar as well as water from the well.

Mr. Fujimura said there has been a request that the Commission confer administrative approval to the permit if the applicant is unable to meet the timeframe for reasons beyond their control. He asked Mr. Tam if this could be done. Mr. Tam replied that the Chairman could be granted that option.

Mr. Fujimura amended the Condition to provide that

"should(~)time of up to~;~~~·)e needed, it would be within the discren6n-of the Chairman to extend· this permit if for reasons beyond the applicant's control the initial 6-month time frame cannot be met."

Mr. Cox also asked that the following condition be added:

"The proposed uses shall not adversely affect existing or future legal uses of water in the area, including any surface water or established instream flow standards. This permit or the authorization to pump water from the wells shall not constitute a detennination of correlative water rights. The permittee is notified and by this provision understands that the quantity of water taken from the wells could be reduced by the Commission in the future. This permit is not a commitment that the pump capacities permitted here or even some lesser amount are guaranteed in the future."

Unanimously approved as amended (Fujimura/Cox).

- 5 -

'\

o o State of Hawaii

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Department of Land and Natural Resources

Honolulu, Hawaii

August 19, 1992

Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management State of Hawaii Honolulu, Hawaii

Gentlemen:

Makakilo Golf Corp. Application for a Temporary Water Use Permit

Fort Barrette Well. Makakilo Golf Course, Oahu

Applicant:

Makakilo Golf Corp. Seven Waterfront Plaza, Suite 220 500 Ala Moana Boulevard Honolulu, HI 96813

Landowner:

Finance Realty Co., Ltd. P.O. Box 3979 Honolulu, HI 96812

•

Background: Fort Barrette Well (Well No. 2004-03) was drilled in 1941 and develops fresh (235 to 240 mgll chlorides) basal water from the Ewa-Kunia Aquifer System. It is one of the wells to be. used as a monitor well for the Department of Health's monitor plan for the golf course. In June 1991 the applicant requested and received written pennission to test pump the well for six to tUne months to gather hydrologic data and to use the water for dust control In February 1992 the applicant requested a six-month extension to continue pumping. Staff recommended that the applicant formally apply for a temporary water use permit. The applicant stopped using the well and is requesting a six to twelve month temporary use of the well until their desalting plant is built. The applicant has a water use permit from the Commission to use 1.15 mgd of brackish caprock water from Makakilo Golf Course Well (Well No. 1904-02) located about a mile south of the golf course. Because the golf course is situated over the basal aquifer, the applicant was required to build a desalting plant to treat the water. The chloride content of the water applied to the golf course is to be 200 mg/l or less.

Action Requested: Approval of a temporary (6 to 12 months) water use permit to use 360,000 gallons per day (0.36 mgd) from Fort Barrette Well for construction water, dust contro~ and the initial grow-in period of the golf course.

Source of Water Supply: Pearl Harbor Sector, Ewa-Kunia Aquifer System, Pearl Harbor Ground Water Management Area.

Project Location/Tax Map Key: The well is located near Makakilo, at Tax Map Key: 9-2-19:2, Oahu.

Well Description (typical):

Ground elevation: Casing diameter: Solid casing depth: Total depth:

175 ft. 12 inches 182 ft 190 ft.

Impact on Surrounding Wells: The Honolulu Eoard of Water Supply has commented that the temporary use of the well should caUSE: no long-tean advetse effec~ on the BVo'S Makakilo Well located 1,200 feet downgradient from the well. The BWS Makakilo Well has slightly higher chlorides than the Fort Barrette Well

Approved by Commission on Water Resource Manaaement at the meeting held on ~

_---.;;AU~G-..I!'-'"9r...&1.w.:;;9914_2 __ 1·-.:1 ~ ~ 1 t"vuL LL

ITEM 3

o o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management August 19, 1992

Public Notice: In accordance with DLNR Administrative Rules, a public notice was published in the Star Bulletin on July 3 and 10, 1992. In addition, copies of the public notice were sent to the Mayor's office, the County Council, the Department of Health, the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands, the Office of Hawaiian Affairs, the State Historic Preservation Division, the Honolulu Board of Water Supply, and to other interested parties. Written comments to the proposed permit were to be submitted to the Commission by July 22, 1992. There were no objections to the application.

RECOMMENDATION:

That the Commission approve the issuance of a temporary water use permit to Makakilo Golf Corp. to use 360,000 gallons per day of water for construction water, dust control, and the initial grow-in period of the golf course, subject to the following conditions:

Attach.

1. The permit shall be for a period of six months from the date of issuance. Modification of any permit condition shall be approved by the Commission.

2. The applicant shall comply with all applicable laws, rules, and ordinances.

3. The applicant shall provide and maintain an approved meter or other appropriate device or means for measuring and reporting total water usage. Water usage shall be measured on a monthly basis and reported to the Commission.

Respectfully submitted,

UBMITIAL:

WILLIAM W. PATI, Chairperson

•

\

"

',( I

"

,1

/

\

I, , 10

i!}J " " ,

,; / /,

ii

! , Gulch,

j,

~

Fort Barrette Well

(Well No. 2004-03)

, SLAND OF Ol\/IU

.'I\LlI v~ .""'"j

'~

rt.: .. .. ,

JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII

AUG 18 1992

MEMORANDUM

o o



P. O. BOX 621

HONOLULU. HAWAII 96809

WILLIAM W. PATY

CHAIRPERSON

JOHN C. LEWIN. M.D. MICHAEl J. CHUN. Ph.D.


GUY K. FUJIMURA

RAE M. LOUI. P.E.

DEPUTY

To: Mr. William W. Paty

From:

Subject: Background of Makakilo Golf Course Wells (Well Nos. 1904-02, 03) and Fort Barrette Well (Well No. 2004-03)

September 27, 1989

March 15, 1990

February 1, 1991

April 24, 1991

ACTION TAKEN

The Commission issued a well construction permit to Finance Realty Company to drill and test Makakilo Golf Course Well (Well No. 1904-02) in the brackish caprock aquifer.

The Commission approved the issuance of a water use permit to Makakilo Golf Corp. to use 1.15 mgd of brackish caprock water for golf course irrigation use from the Makakilo Golf Course Well. Conditions:

1. Chloride Content of the water used on the Makakilo Golf Course shall be 200 ppm or less;

2. The development of the ground water source shall be completed within 24 months from the date of permit issuance.

Note: Though the Commission approved the issuance of the water use permit, technically, the actual permit was never issued since it is still "under review" by the Attorney General.

Makakilo Golf Corp. submitted an application for a well construction permit to construct and test a stand-by well to act as a backup source for the primary brackish, caprock well.

The Commission approved the well construction permit for the Makakilo Golf Course Standby Well (Well No. 1904-03).

o o Memorandum to Mr. William W. Paty Page 2

AUG 18 1992

June 12, 1991

June 18, 1991

November 25, 1991

January 10, 1992

February 27, 1992

May 20,1992

June 23, 1992

August 19, 1992

Makakilo Golf Corp. requested pennission to test Fort Barrette Monitor Well for six to nine months from date of approval.

The request to test Fort Barrette Well was approved by letter from the Chairperson.

Makakilo Golf Course Well was completed.

Makakilo Golf Course Standby Well was completed.

Makakilo Golf Corp. requested a six-month extension of the test period for the Fort Barrette Well.

The request was denied by letter from the Deputy Director.

Makakilo Golf Corp. submitted a water use permit application to use 0.36 mgd from the Fort Barrette Well for 6 to 12 months until the construction of the 1 mgd desalination plant is completed.

Commission scheduled to act on temporary water use permit.

It can be argued that Makakilo Golf Corp.'s water use permit has expired since one of the conditions, that "the development of the ground water source shall be completed within 24 months from the date of permit issuance", has not been met. Water from the brackish, caprock well cannot be used on the golf course until the desalting plant is completed. Makakilo Golf Corp. will be sending a letter soon requesting an extension of the water use permit. The matter will be taken ~o the Commission for action.

ES:ko

--------------------------------------------------------------------

BOARD OF WATER SUPPLY 0 CITY AND COUNTY OF HONOLULU

630 SOUTH BERETANIA STREET


Mrs. Rae M. Loui Deputy Director Commission on Water Resource

Management Department of Land and Natural

Resources State of Hawaii P.O. Box 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

Dear~:

July 30, 1992

FRANK F. FASI, Mayor

WALTER O. ~TSON, JR, Chairman e. E f" t: • ~~E H. YAMASATO, Vice Chairman n .... , ~ SISfER-M DAVILYN AH CHICK, O.S.F.

JOHN W ANDERSON, JR. REX D. JOHNSON

92 JJl 31 If''~HAltfs~REET KAZU HAYASHIDA Manager and Chief Engineer

Subject: Applications for Temporary Water Use Permits for Kapolei Golf Course Wells (2003-01 to 03) and Makakilo Golf Course Well (2004-03)

Thank you for the opporturiity to comment on the applications for a temporary water use permit for use of caprock water in the Pearl Harbor GWCA by Kapolei Golf Course and Village and for the Makakilo Golf Course. We support the applications since the use of caprock water should not have any adverse effects on or compete with potable water in the Waianae basal aquifer.

If you have any questions, please call George Hiu at 527-6134.

Very truly yours,

KAZU HAYASHIDA Manager and Chief Engineer

Pure Water. , . man's greatest need - u.~e it wisely

o MAKAKILO GOLF CORP.

Ms. Rae M. Loui Deputy Director

July 24, 1992

Commission on Water Resources Management Department of Land and Natural Resources, State of Hawaii P. O. Box 621 Honolulu Hawaii 96809

Dear Ms. Loui ;

Subject: Fort Barrette Monitor Well No. 2004-02

Please find enclosed a copy of our letter to the Division of Water Resource Management, sent on September 19, 1992, providing notice of pumpage start for the subject well. We wish to inform you that we did comply to that condition and to correct the statement in your letter of May 20, 1992.

If there are any questions, please do not hesitate to call me or Randy Chu at 599-8804, at your convenience.

Sincerely,

ase Project Manager


-

~KAKIlO GOLF CORF.O

FiVE WATERFRONT PUZA SUITE 310 500 ALA MOANA BOULEVARD


September 19,1991

Mr. Manabu Tagomori, PE. Deputy Director Division of Water Resource Management Department of Land and Natural Resources P.O. Box 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

Dear Mr. Tagomori :

Re: Fort Barrette Monitor We!1 No. 2004 - 02

TEL: 808-599-3804 FAX: 808-599-5743

In accordance with the conditions imposed by your letter cf June 18, 1991, we are providing notice that:

The testing ef We!1 No. 2004-02 will prcceed en September 20, 1991.

Pumpage data will be submitted monthiy starting as of Oc:cber "00" 1_- I.

The Division will be notified upon test completion and all accumulated data from the test will be submitted.

If there are any questions, please do net hesitate to call me erRancy Chu at 599-8804.

Sinoerely

'~~ obert . Imose

Project Manager

------------------------------------------,---------------------.-~.--

· .. - -~. o o PUBLIC NOTICE

Applications for Temporary Water Use Permits Pearl Harbor Water Management Area. Oahu

, , ....

Applications for the following water use permits have been received and are hereby made public in accordance with Department of Land and Natural Resources Administrative Rules 13-171, "Designation and Regulation of Water Management Areas."

1. Fort Barrette Well (Well No. 2004-03)

APPLICANT: Makakilo Golf Corp. Seven Waterfront Plaza, Suite 220 500 Ala Moana Boulevard Honolulu, HI 96813

Date Application Received: June 25, 1992 Source of Water Supply: Pearl Harbor Sector, Ewa-Kunia Aquifer System, Pearl Harbor Ground Water Management Area. Location of Well: Makakilo Golf Course, Oahu, at Tax Map Key: 9-2-19:2. Ouantity Requested: 360,000 gallons per day. Proposed Water Use: For temporary use of construction water for Makakilo Golf Course, pending construction of a desalination plant. Place of Water Use: Makakilo Golf Course.

2. Kapolei-HFDC Irrigation Wells A, B, & C (Well Nos. 2003-01 to 03)

APPLICANT: Housing Finance & Dev. Corp. Seven Waterfront Plaza, Suite 300 500 Ala Moana Boulevard Honolulu, HI 96813

Date Application Received: December 2, 1991 Source of Water Supply: Caprock Aquifer, Pearl Harbor Ground Water Management Area. Location of Wells: Kapolei Golf Course and Village, Oahu, at Tax Map Key: 9-1-16:25. Ouantity Requested: 500,000 gallons per day per well. Proposed Water Use: Temporary use for dust control and start-up irrigation for the golf course, pending approval of a permanent water use permit by the Commission. Place of Water Use: Kapolei Golf Course and Village.

Written objections or comments on the applications for water use may be filed by any person who has property interest in any land within the hydrologic unit of the source of water supply or who will be directly and immediately affected by the proposed water use. Written objections shall: (1) state property or other interest in the matter; (2) set forth questions of procedure, fact, law, or policy, to which objections are taken; and (3) state all grounds for objections to the proposed permits. Send written objections by August 4, 1992, to the Commission on Water Resource Management, P.O. Box 621, Honolulu, Hawaii 96809.

COMMISSION ON W AT RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

Dated: ..Ill -8 1992

Publish in: Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of July 14 and 21, 199

Mr. Kazu Hayashida Manager and Chief Engineer Board of Water Supply 630 South Beretania Street Honolulu, Hawaii 96843

Dept. of Health Ground Water Protection Program Environmental Planning Office SOO Ala Moana Blvd., Suite 2S0B Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Mr. Thomas K. Kaulukukui, Sr. Chairman & Trustee-At-Large Office of Hawaiian Affairs 1600 Kapiolani Blvd., Suite IS00 Honolulu, Hawaii 96814

Mr. William Meyer, District Chief U. S. Dept. of the Interior Geological Survey 677 Ala Moana Blvd., Suite 415 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Ewa Plains Water Development Corp. 828 Fort Street Mall, Suite 500 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

*Makakilo Golf Corp. Seven Waterfront Plaza, Suite 220 SOO Ala Moana Blvd. Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

o v' ',VI't ~" rL''''''''"-'v'" ...... ~'lr,'' \""'T(..,.r'(,."I",I"\r..l

~-? •

Honorable Frank F. Fasi Mayor City and County of Honolulu 530 South King Street Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Dept. of Health Safe Drinking Water Branch Environmental Management Division Five Waterfront Plaza SOO Ala Moana Blvd. j Suite 2S0 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Mr. William D. Balfour, Jr. President and Manager Oahu Sugar Company P. O. Box 0 WaipahU, Hawaii 96797

Sierra Club Legal Defense Fund, Inc. 212 Merchant Street; Suite 202 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Commandin* Officer Pacific Divi~ion, NAVFACENGCOM Pearl Harbo~, Hawaii 96860

I

*Housing Finance & Develop. Corp. Seven Waterfront Plaza, Suite 300 SOO Ala Moana Blvd. Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Chair and Members Honolulu City Council Honolulu Hale Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Honorable Hoaliku L. Drake Director Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands P. O. Box 1879 Honolulu, Hawaii 9680S

Mr. Samuel Keala Campbell Estate 828 Fort Street Mall; Suite sao Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Historic Preservation Division DLNR 33 South King Street; 6th Floor Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Dept. of Land Utilization City and County of Honolulu Honolulu Municipal Bldg. 6S0 South King Street Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

STATE OI}-WAWAII

REQUISITION & pbMCHASE ORDER

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES CWRM

ORGANIZATION FUNCTION AND ACTIVITY

NOTICE TO VENDORS Conditions of purchase are listed on the back side of this purcha~e order. Please read carefully. Payments may be delayed if all steps are not followed. i

Hawaii Newspaper Agency/ Hono]ulu Star Bulletin

0"

Date ___ 0_7_0_9_9_2 _________ _ Deliver Before ____________ _

DELIVERY ADDRESS

- ~ \."\ TER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT ! [' i' ~ ':::GI Resources

-'':;:::;:';1 227 , \-:;;.;1:)

BILLING ADDRESS

P. O. Box 3350 1.1° '-·1 r~ \!"/\Tr~. RESOURCE ~.1ANAG~J\,1EN1· P. O. reX 373

Honolulu, Hawaii 96801 The State of Hawaii is an EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY and AFFIRMATIVE AOTION employer. We encourage the participation of women and minorities in all phases of employment.

QUAN. UNIT DESCRIPTION

PUBLIC NOTICE - Application for a Temporary Water Use Permit - Pearl Harbor Water Management Area, Oahu

Publish in Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of July 14, and 21, 1992

DAGS PL 92-66

V RE41UISITIONER U TELEPHONE

Faith GOObS/SERVICES RECEIVED IN GOOD ORDER AND CONDITION BY DATE

i.",~_:,,:,., ,":i t':""')

OBJECT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT

X$2DIX.IDIX $400.00

" -__________ FO_R_DE_P_AR_T_M_E_NT_US_E_O_N_LY _____________ --I

VENDOR NUMBER SFX

OC

SFX TC F YR APP D OBJECT CC

XX XXX X xx xxx xx XXXX XXXX 01 621 G 93 044 C 4000 U72b

PROJ NO. PH ACT ESTIMATED COST

XXXXXX xx xxx XXXXXXXXXXX IXX 000000 ou p70

$400 100 I I I I I I

COpy #1 - VENDOR

ACTUAL COST M R OPT DEPT DATA

XXXXXXXXXXXIXXX X XXXXXXXXXXX I I I I I I I I

STATE ACCOUNTING FORM C·03 JULY 1, 1983 (REVISED)

f""'.' o

CONDITIONS - READ CAREFULL V

1. Prices include delivery charges unless otherwise stated. '

2. Show purchase order number, date, appropriation symbol, and discounts allowed on all invoices.

3. The State reserves the right to reject any items supplied that are not in accordance with specifications even though payment has been made in order to obtain discounts.

4. This is not a purchase order unless assigned a P.O. number and authenticated by authorized signature.

5. Send original and three (3) copies of invoice. '(The Original invoice is required.urider sections 40-56 and 40-57, Hawaii Revised Statutes, before paiments canbemCiqe.).

6. Vendor and purchaser recognize that in actual economic practice, overcharges resulting from antitrust violations are in fact usually borne by the purchaser. Therefore, vendor hereby assigns to purchaser any and !3-11 claims for suc.h overchmges as to goods and materials purchased in connection with this order or contract. except as to overcharges whierl resu:! liO:;l clntilrust violations comll1encing after the price is established under this o,de: or contr'ac\ and which are not passed on to HiG pUld13ser under all escalation clause.

..

t- l- t STATE O~AWAII tJa=. I I REQUISITION .. P CHAse ORDER C20.5"16

070992 ce"AFl'TMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOUROES CWRM 0."..,.1" •• to~.

OfliiiAN.ZATION f"'UNCT'ON ANCo .... CTJVtTV D.LIVIf,.", ADDA ••• NOTIC. TO V.NDO ... . - _. ,

~~ '''';.fXTl!'PIt RESOUAoa MANAOEMIINT 00n4;l1110"_ 0' ,.~~~. ~":yf~:-:.I~~.~h~ :lo:-::.:~d:,..O!-.Jr~~fro~~ •• or".r, PI __ -

01-r ... d o.r..t'~fly. ... : ;~ /" r·!c.~".lral -=-•• 0..,1"0._

nOon., 227 .. I .. ~ ••. ~._.i bi)~'13

iI~~~fi'iJ ~e}f:g~PI:=;] tl~ilgY/ .ILLIN~ ADD" •••

P. O. Box 3350 MI' ,--"-'''' I ,..,.'" "~.·ATr.,q. FtESOu,""OF.E MANAOI!£MIiNT P,o, eClo:n S?'3

Hono1u1.u. Ha"Ws.::l.::l. 96eo~ (··.w~·:,.;~''-:o.J. I!_ ~....,;.,H £:!u:· . .,a I

~~.p,,!~,1r:.'=tt:~~~I~~".:'JU'~I'~r:r.s:T:-,~r-J"~'::~"'!~~/Z'':~'i.''''''''''MAT1V11 ACTION .mp'u"" •. w •• "eou"",._ CUAN,

J

=. lJNIT oe.C"'I~TION OIl ..... QT I.JN1T PR.gE AMOUNT

I I

?UBLIQ NOTjCE - App11cat10n for a Temporary X$ZXX.:IIXX Water Use e~m1t - Pearl. Herbor Water $400.00 Mane.ement Are ..... Oahu

Pub1:lah ::Ln HonoJ.uJ.u Star Bul.l.e"C1n :1.ssuea of J'u:Ly 1.4. and 2],. 1992 ,

I DAGS PL 92-66 i

.-oat-It- brand tax t,...namlltal marno 7'871 I" of .... _ •• ;;2. i

I"'" "MA- ... ,I!!., l t .. .f-t ..... ...... r:::: . ;1. ./ I

1- ,~ ... "- lA ~1V1 1-.. •·

.... .!: -o-;;z..fr-c __

, c:;;. 7 L.J..l..l.4. c_ ... Bi" ·1O'2.lDf

.. ,.

•• TIM"",TEa coaT AOTUAL COST M A O~T C.PT DATA

(')( )( )(2S..l5.l!.X X X)( '" )( )( X X X X X )( X )( X )( ><)( x )( )()()()()()( >c )( )( X )(

oopy *1 - VaNDOA

TRANSMISSION REPORT

THIS DOCUMENT WAS SENT

** #

COUNT 2 **

(REDUCED SAMPLE ABOVE)

*** SEND *** iNo' REMOTE STATION I. D. START TIME DURATION #PAGES COMMENT

Rt 7- 9-92 10:22AM 1 '33" 2 ..L.-

TOTAL 0:01'33" 2 XEROX TELECOPIER 7020

o PUBLIC NOTICE

Applications for Temporary Water Use Permits J;JL q Pearl Harbor Water Mana~ement Area. Oahu

Applications for the following water use permits have been received and are hereby made public in accordance with Department of Land and Natural Resources Administrative Rules 13-171, "Designation and Regulation of Water Management Areas."

1. Fort Barrette Well (Well No. 2004-03)

APPLICANT: Makakilo Golf Corp. Seven Waterfront Plaza, Suite 220 500 Ala Moana Boulevard Honolulu, HI 96813

Date Application Received: June 25, 1992 Source of Water Supply: Pearl Harbor Sector, Ewa-Kunia Aquifer System, Pearl Harbor Ground Water Management Area. Location of Well: Makakilo Golf Course, Oahu, at Tax Map Key: 9-2-19:2. Quantity Reguested: 360,000 gallons per day. Proposed Water Use: For temporary use of construction water for Makakilo Golf Course, pending construction of a desalination plant. Place of Water Use: Makakilo Golf Course.

2. Kapolei-HFDC Irrigation Wells A, B, & C (Well Nos. 2003-01 to 03)

APPLICANT: Housing Finance & Dev. Corp. Seven Waterfront Plaza, Suite 300 500 Ala Moana Boulevard Honolulu, HI 96813

Date Application Received: December 2, 1991 Source of Water Supply: Caprock Aquifer, Pearl Harbor Ground Water Management Area. Location of Wells: Kapolei Golf Course;and Village, Oahu, at Tax Map Key: 9-1-16:25. Quantity Requested: 500,000 gallons per day per well. Proposed Water Use: Temporary use for dust control and start-up irrigation for the golf course, pending approval of a permanent water use permit by the Commission. Place of Water Use: Kapolei Golf Course and Village.

Written objections or comments on the applications for water use may be filed by any person who has property interest in any land within the hydrologic unit of the source of water supply or who will be directly and immediately affected by the proposed water use. Written objections shall: (1) state property or other interest in the matter; (2) set forth questions of procedure, fact, law, or policy, to which objections are taken; and (3) state all grounds for objections to the proposed permits. Send written objections by August 4, 1992, to the Commission on Water Resource Management, P.O. Box 621, Honolulu, Hawaii 96809.

Dated: J.l. -8 1992

Publish in: Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of July 14 and 21, 199

II •

o MAKAKILO GOLF CORP.

RECl!}vt"n

MR. WILLIAM W. PAlY Chairman, Commission On Water Re~ource Management Dept. of Land and Natural Resources . p. O. Box 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

Dear Mr. Paty :

Re: Water Use Permit Application for Well No. 2004-03, Fort Barrette Well, Makakilo , Ewa, Hawaii.

Enclosed is our water use permit application for well No. 2004-03, commonly known as the Fort Barrette well. Our proposed use would be for 360,000 GPD during the interim period until the construction of our 1,000,000 GPD desalination plant is completed. The desalination plant (a supplemental equipment to maintain irrigation water at or below 200 ppm chlorides, a requirement of the Water Commission) is scheduled for installation and completion by the end of the 4th quarter,1992. The Fort Barrette source, along with Waiahole Ditch water purchased from Oahu Sugar Company (OSCo), would be used for construction purposes and the initial landscape grow-in period of Makakilo Golf Course.

Recent studies have established that the direction of ground water flow in this portion of the Waianae Aquifer is to the west. If there is any return flow to the aquifer of water pumped from Fort Barrette Well, the only well that may possibly be affected would be BWS's Makakilo well, State No. 2004. We have written to the BWS outlying our proposal as presented to the you in this correspondence and as the enclosed letter from BWS indicates, it has no objection to our proposed use for the period indicated.

As you are aware, we have been testing Fort Barrette Well since September 1991 and utilizing the discard water for golf course construction purposes. During that time, water quality from the well has remained steady between 235 to 240 ppm chlorides and no adverse effect at BWS's Makakilo Well has occurred. Based on this, we would like to continue our present use of the well pending further action by the Water Commission on our application.


:::>tI"7

,.. o o Our proposed usage of the well water is as follows:

1. During the construction stage and for dust control purposes, (mainly on the south half of the golf course), the contractor will utilize the water from the Fort Barrette well sparingly and primarily on the areas of excavations and along paths traversed by the construction vehicles. It will also be used to suppress the origination of dust and minimize its migration from the project site onto the adjacent properties. The water will not be utilized to wet the entire project site with frequent drenching, but rather will be used for controlled surface spraying of the disturbed areas requiring treatment with enough water to keep the dust from rising. Because of the climate and especially the wind conditions at the area, a crust forms rather rapidly over the soil. This crust will minimize the dust from those areas, and we will then be able to concentrate on the disturbed areas for dust control. We believe the temporary use of this well water for dust control purposes will not harm or cause any degradation to the underlying basalt aquifer.

2. For the initial grow-in period on the north portion of the golf course (holes 1-7 and part of hole 18), we will use the Waiahole Ditch water exclusively. This water has a negligible chloride content (less than 10 ppm) and is fed into the lake at hole #2, which is a part of the irrigation system. We are currently in the process of constructing a 10 inch pipeline from Lake #2, across the golf course to the Lakes #9/10 complex, which is also under construction. The pipeline, when completed, will be used to transfer the Waiahole water to Lake #10 and allow us to blend the two sources of water and thus conform to the 200 ppm requirement imposed by the Water Commission. The blended water will then be used for the grow-in period on the south side of the golf course (See Map attached).

We have tried to obtain other sources of water for the project but all our efforts have been in vain. The complete lack of other sources of water on the south side of the golf course compels us to petition the Water Commission to allow us the use of Fort Barrette Well. Since our request is for the temporary use of Fort Barrette well and our need to obtain a source of water is very urgent, we additionally request that our application be processed expeditiously. Your concurrence and approval of our request would be greatly appreciated.

If there are any questions or require additional information, please do not hesitate to call me or Randy Chu at 599-8804.

la',

o o SaARa OF WATER SUFPLY

,::-:- ( ANC CCU~r,( OF "'CNCLJL'J

,.;:._ ::.: _ _ _ :-,1

June 10, 1992

Mr. Robert M. Imose Project Manager Makakilo Golf Corporation Seven Waterfront Plaza 500 Ala Moana Boulevard, Suite 500 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Dear Mr. Imose:

S~bject: Your Letter of Mav 29. 1992 on the Use of Fort Barrette Well 2004-03

Thank you for your letter of May 29, 1992 requesting support for your proposal to use 350,000 gallons a day from the Fort Barrette Well.

We have no objections to your proposal to temporarily use the water from the well for dust control and irrigation until the desalting plant is completed in about 7-10 months.

Our Makakilo Well is located about 1,200 feet downgradient of the golf course, but the water from the Fort Barrette Well has chloride ranging between 235 to 240 ppm, which is slightly below the chloride of our Makakilo Well.

We do not anticipate any long-tenn adverse problems to our Makakilo Well due to the short-tenn use of the water from the Fort Barrette Well.

If you have any questions, please call Herbert H. Minakarni at 527-6183.

Very truly yours,

KAZU HAYASHIDA Manager and Chief Engineer

o State of Hawaii o COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

Department of Land and Natural Resources Division of Water Resource Management

APPLIC.ATION FOR WATER USE PERMIT

• GROUNDWATER or 0 SURFACE WATER 5-26-92 054-40

INSTRUCTIONS: pt.... print or type and •• nd compl.t.d appUcaUon With attachm.nt. to the DtVi,lon of Wat.r and t.nd D.v.lopment. P.O. Box 313. Honolulu. Hawaii ... 0.. Application mu.t b. accompani.d by a non-refundable nunr f .. of S25.00 payable to the Departm.nt of Land and Natural Ruourc... (PWnr t •• WaiTed for conmm.nt ar.nd ••• ) It nee .... ry. phone 548-1543. Hydl'OloU/GeoloU S.ction for ... i.tanc ••

1. WATER MANAGEMENT AREA Pearl Harbor Groundwater Control Area, Basal Aquifer, Kapolei Sector

2.' (a) WELL/DIVERSION OWNER: (b) LANDOWNER: Firm Name Makakilo Golf Corp. Firm Name Finance Realty Co.,

Contact Person Bob Imose Address Seven Waterfront Plaza, Ste. 500 Ala Moana Blvd. ~~one IloiiOlulu, Hawa;; 968n-

3. SOURCE TYPE: D Spring DDlke-confined

4. SOURCE NAME AND NUMBER

Contact Person 220 Address P. O.

Honolulu, Hawa i i

OStream DPerched

We 11 No. 2004-03

Journ Vee Box 3979 96812 Phone

.Basal OCaprock

<well or stream diversion name/number)

5. SOURCE LOCATION: Island Oahu Tax Map Key 9-2-19: Lot 2 Address Along Makakilo Drive in Makakilo

Ltd.

(Attach a USGS map (scale 1"=2000') and property tax map showing source location referenced to established property boundaries.)

6. LOCATION OF PROPOSED WATER USE (if different from IS) Makakilo Golf Course (Indicate location of water use on same map showing source location.)

7. QUANTITY OF WATER REQUESTED 360,000 gallons per day 8. QUALITY OF WATER REQUESTED (check appropriate box)

DFresh .Brackish DSalt O'Potable DNon-Potable

9. PROPOSED USE OMunicipal (including hotels, stores, etc) o Domestic (individual, noncommercial water sys.) DIrrigation (specify) ________ _

o MiUtary Sonstruction DIndustrial Water for _Other (specify) Golf Course

10. DESCRIBE ANY POTENTIAL RESTRICTIONS ON USE (i.e., in stream standards, seasonal variations) ______________________________________________________________ __

11. PROPOSED TIME OF WATER WITHDRAWAL OR DIVERSION Continuously as needed (indicate hours of operation)

12. PROPOSED METHOD OF TAKING THE WATER o Artesian Flow ODiverted Flow OCentrifugal Pump O'Submersible Pump .Vertical Turbine Pump

13. NO. OF RESIDENTIAL OR COMMERCIAL UNITS TO BE .SERVED (specify"-) ____ No_n_e __ _

TOTAL ACRES PROPOSED FOR IRRIGATION Type of Crop ______ _ . Temporary Water for Construction of

REMARKS. EXPLANATIONS Makak;lo Golf Course (if more space is needed, co-n'Ttir-n.I.Jullll.e~o~n.L.ibr.:::a:....c":Ok~s.:,..id...,.:e::::.:;)~~---~r-------------

14.

15.

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Owner (print)

For Official Use Only:

Date Received ------Date Accepted ____ _

Landowner (print) ~ WAr MUN CHUNG

Slgnat~ rf: U4J.,.. ~ Datel 19,L

C?

Hydro logic Uni t ______ _ Diversion Works No. ------State WeLL No. _______ _

---------------------------------------------------_.-----------------

15. REMARKS, EXPLANATIONS:

Temporary construction water for Makakilo Golf Course is needed during a period of 6 to 12 months while the proposed Desalting Plant is being built.

c o

" ,.

...• ::~ .. :.. .':;;:

Fort Barrette Well

(Well No. 2004-03)

1\ II II II. ft

60 8\\04

1\ II

ISLAND OF OAHU

DIAMOND "tAD

o o JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII


I


P. O. BOX 621


MAY 20 1992

Mr. Robert M. Imose, Project Manager Makakilo Golf Corp. Seven Water Front Plaza, Suite 220 500 Ala Moana Blvd. Honolulu, HI 96813

Dear Mr. Imose:

Fort Barrette Monitor Well Request to Extend Test Pumpage

14r2~J ~ I', (9 t: (\ -(~/ f '~

WILLIAM W. PATY

CHAIRPERSON

JOHN C. LEWIN. M.D. MICHAEL J. CHUN. Ph.D.


GUY K. FUJIMURA

RAE M. LOUI, P.E.

DEPUTY

Your request to extend the pumping test period for Fort Barrette Well No. 2004-02 has been denied for the following reasons:

1. Two conditions specified by the CWRM Chairperson were that you: 1) notify the Commission when pumping would commence; and 2) submit monthly pumpage reports. Neither of these conditions has been met despite intermittent pumping since September '91 totalling 21 million gallons.

2. We have had reports that the pumped water is being used for dust control at the Makakilo Golf Course site. On March 15, 1990, the CWRM approved your water use permit for the caprock golf course wells with the condition that water used on the course shall be 200 ppm or less. Although it is wise to put the pump test water to use, the chloride concentration from the Fort Barrette Monitor Well (230+ ppm) is in excess of 200 ppm and it would be inconsistent for us to allow the monitor well quality water to be applied in the golf course area. The reason for this is that BWS has a well (State No. 2004-04) downgradient of the golf course site which is already experiencing chloride levels in excess of 200 ppm.

3. Since this well is to be used for monitoring purposes it is unclear how further pumping will improve upon data already gathered. Ideally, monitor wells should not even be pumped but, rather, sampled "in-situ" by lowering specialized containers to gather water at specified depths.

Mr. Robert M. Imose Page 2

o MAY 20 1992

If you have any questions, please contact Mr. Ed Sakoda at 587-0225.

RH:ko

•

Sincerely,

RAE M. LOUI Deputy Director

o o REGm.ATION BRANCH


FROM: l4\. A II __________ DATE: ,,~ FILE IN:

TO: INIT:

~E. SAKODA K. Oshiro

S. Samuels £R. Hardy

Q. T. Than

PLEASE:

See Me Call

_ Review & Comment _ Take Action _Investigate & Report _ Draft Reply _ Acknowledge Receipt _ Type Draft _ Type Final

Xerox _ copies

FOR YOUR:

_ R. LOUI _ Approval __ _ S. Kokubun _ Signftre __ _ G. MATSUMOTO! -h-r Info ation ,-1.-1 __ _._ Y. SHIROMA f~(..~) It ~ w M , flY

I L -t rI ~J l;t./fJ /;; S~·<- ;,f W t' t-C !4IItu,t"

0cft~~t'f-7 t It/\

-----------------------

FROM: a \.j

TO: INIT:

E. SAKODA K. Oshiro

/ S. Samuels -Z _R. Hardy

_Q. T. Than

R. LOm S. Kokubun G. MATSUMOTO Y. SHIROMA

o o REGUlATION BRANCH


DATE: t- 6-7'k: FILE IN: ____________ _

RE~: &~--jJ See Me Ro ... t.h~ .. MW1'{\ ~ ~\AJ S ~~ \ . Call '~ . 1)) () 0 Review ~ Comment j,\ ..00 (\... wJt '\\ \AI" ~. r ~ (..tvV\

1 Take ActIOn \ \-t4'\. '1 v. 1- Y J = Investigate & Report --I () ~ k .:&- r l J Jwf 5' LIT L4 J _ Draft Reply 12.-. j;~ bI 1'--· '-\ t _ Acknowledge Receipt r. 0 ~

Type Draft '(~ r .. ~ M~ Type Final ~ ~~ .-w \ v---t ~S Xerox copies A< , I 1 -ft..lJ . rI:i

FOR YOUR: Iv,.; ~ (lNk.-~ l ru"1"'1l hi( )

Approval ~les f~.). D ~ t ~ C-4l',W ~J.nAI~ Signature I (j ,/rn .... - )

Information ut .. rr J) 1 n -u.. ~I ",J~ w~ ~ CU- .

{w,.)t~

PLEASE:

TOM NANCE WATER RESOURCES ENGINEERING

DATE: April 23, 1992

o Transmittal

TO: DLNR - Division of Water Resource Management

ATTENTION: Roy Hardy

SUBJECT: Fort Barrette Monitoring Data

We herewith transmit the following:

o Job No: 054-40_

680 Ala Moana Blvd .• Suite 100. Honolulu. Hawaii 96813 Phone: (808)521-5361. FAX: (808)538-7819

1 4/23/92 Summary of Fort Barrette Well Monitoring Data

1 4/22/92 Well Pumpage data for Pan Pacific Construction.

Remarks:

We herewith transmit the above items for your use as requested.

Please feel free to call the undersigned if there are any questions regarding this matter.

Sincerely, Tom Nance Water Resources Engineering

~dz:,~ Greg Fukumitsu, P.E.

cc: Bob Imose - MGC.

PROJECl': MAKAKIID GOlF COUR:;E - WElL MONfIURING DATA FOR FORT DARRmE WEilt DATE: APRIL 23, 1992

GAllDNS EQUIVAIENT DATE: PCC METER USED FROM AVE GAIlDNS CHWRIDES

READINGS • LAS1' READING USED T~D

(GAIlDNS) (GAlLONS) (MGD) (PPM)

18-Jun-91 DINR - COWRM APPROVED TES!' PUMPING OF FORT DARRE'ITE WElL NO

09-Se~-91 0 0 14-Sep-91 20-SeIl-91 27-Sep-91 30-SEm-91 2153000 2153000

no ~_L n. Inn 'HH\ fl 1 o "1'1 flflfl J. U -Vl.;\.- -OJ J. ~u';"uuuu

31-Oct-91 5114000 1000000 15-Nov-91 6312000 1190000 29-Nov-91 7963000 1651000 -13-Dec-91 9180000 1217000 27-Dec-91 31-Dec-91 10523000 1343000 04-Jan-92 17-Jan-92 11841000 1318000 31-Jan-92 13219000 1378000 14-Feb-92 14872000 1653000 26-Feb-92 28-Feb-92 16171000 1299000 13-Mar-92 17420000 1249000 30-Mar-92 31-Mar-92 19435000 2015000 16-AQr-92 21. 375, 000 1940000

• WATER USE DATA PROVIDED BY PAN-PACIFIC CONSTRUCTION COMPANY (PCC)

- ---b

233 233

102524 1 n.H\~A

03692 79067

117929 86929

236 74611

240 77529 98429

118071 240

92786 89214

235 111944 121250

COMMENTS

2004-02

PUMP SHAKEDOWN BY ROSCOE MOSS CO. PUMP VERIFIED OPERATIONAL DY RMC WATER TES!'ED BY TOM NANCE WATER WATER TES!'ED BY TNWRE

WATER TES!'ED BY TNWRE

WATER TESTED BY TNWRE



0

0

o ~\f'C. CONsrJ?'t),

~ April 1992

To: Belt Collins & Associates 680 Ala Moana Blvd., Suite 200 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Attn: Greg Fukumitsu

Re: MAKAKILO GOLF COURSE Fort Barrett Well Meter Readings

Gentlemen:

o

The following are meter readings on the Fort Barrett Well in millions of gallons on the given days.

Start Date: Sept. 9, 1991

Sept. 30, 1991 2.153 Oct. 18, 1991 4.026

I Oct. 31, 1991 5.114 Nov. 15, 1991 6.312 Nov. 29, 1991 7.963 Dec. 13, 1991 9.180 Dec. 31, 1991 10.523 Jan. 17, 1992 11. 841 Jan. 31, 1992 13.219 Feb. 14, 1992 14.872 Feb. 28, 1992 16.171 Mar. 13, 1992 17.420 Mar. 31, 1992 19.435 Apr. 16, 1992 21.375

If there are any questions regarding this matter please call the undersigned at 672-8961.

TC:rac

cc: File/R.K. PAN-..... 111 GDNSTRUCIION, INC. PPC·IOKYU JOINT VlN1'URE

Sincerely,

Pan-Pacific Construction, Inc.

Tim Clays Project Engineer

2621 Walwa, Loop, Honolulu. HawaII 96819 Telephone: (808) 836-2854 FaCSimile: (808) 839-2612

o ~ MAKAKILO GOLF CORP.

~akiiO

Mr. Manabu Tagamori, P. E. Deputy Director

February 27, 1992

Commission on Water Resources Management Department of Land and Natural Resources, State of Hawaii Kalanimoku Building, Room 227 1151 Punchbowl Street Honolulu Hawaii 96813

Dear Mr. Tagamori ;


t;.\ .. ) r~·.)

r''1!i 1::::)::) ri ;

We wish to inform you that the test data we have accumulated from the monitoring well can only be deemed inconclusive because of "9.~i~rlt weather , ~Jl{lditiol1~ and contrary to instructions, the well was not pumped consistently, but on an intermittent basis. This was caused by an unreliable power source (portable generator) prior to hook-up of Hawaiian Electric Company electrical power lines. We believe the hydrologic data obtained may be distorted.

We would like to request that the test period be extended for an additional 6 months. Your immediate attention to this matter will be greatly appreciated.

If there are any questions, please call me or Randy Chu at 599-8804.

/


JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII

o o -,~-. ! ' .. ~

WILLIAM W. PATY

CHAIRPERSON

JOHN C. LEWIN. M.D. MICHAEL J. CHUN. Ph.D.



REF:WRM-LN

Mr. Robert M. Imose Project Manager Makakilo Golf Corp. Five Waterfront Plaza, Suite 310 500 Ala Moana Blvd. Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Dear Mr. Imose:

P. O. BOX 621

HONOLULU. HAWAII 96809

JUN 18 1991

ROBERT S. NAKATA

RICHARD H. COX GUY K. FUJIMURA

MANABU TAGOMORI

DEPUTY

Your request to test pump the Fort Barrette Monitor Well No. 2004-02 is approved subject to the following conditions: -------- -------_.-

The Division of Water Resource Management shall be notified when the pumpage is to begin.

Pumpage data shall be submitted monthly to the Division of Water Resource Management.

Upon completion of the test pumping the Division shall also be notified and all data acquired from this test shall be submitted.

If you have any questions, please call the Division of Water Resource Management at 548-7539.

Chairperson

Kev. ll/~U ION OF WATER RESOURCE MANA~~MENT

FROM: ____ ~=Jo_---\w-·-';-- DATEb "-l ~ _ FIL:~N: ________ _

TO: INITIAL: PLEASE: REMARKS:

G. AKITA ~eMe

\)~~ t (-- r 1. Nanbu __ Take Action By

--19- E. Sakoda z{0ute to Your Branch

~ Review & Comment G. Matsumoto _ Draft Reply_ E. Lau __ Acknowledge Receipt 1. Chang Xerox __ copies

~~\ Y. Shiroma __ File

~ ~. J

Mail

FOR YOUR:

_Approval _ Signature

Information M. TAGOMORI S. Kokubun

tLAKAKILO GOLF CORP.

/

.f 2 '.,~ ~ . _, L. . ry~

.;', \. ,_ ",. :. ,- l. ~."

! ... ..

\ '. ,1 ~ ~ ... )

Mr. wilfii:l'm W:;Paty' : Chairperson

FIVE WATERFRONT PLAZA, SUITE 310 500 ALA MOANA BOULEVARD


June 12, 1991


Department of Land and Natural Resource

P. O. Box 621

Honolulu, Hawaii 96809

Dear Mr. Paty:


{YL: 808-599-8804

F : 808-599-5743 1

We respectfully request your permission to test the Fort Barrette monitor

well for a period of Six (6) to Nine (9) months commencing from the date of

approval. We propose to install a temporary pump of 250 gpm capacity to

gather hydro-geologic data for this well. The data will be used to determine

design criteria for selecting permanent measuring devices necessary for the

monitor well.

Your early and favorable consideration wiil be appreciated. Should you

have any questions on this matter, please have your staff call me or Mr. Randy

Chu at 599-8804

o o State of Hawaii

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Department of Land and Natural Resources

Honolulu, Hawaii

March 15, 1990

Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management State of Hawaii Honolulu, Hawaii

Gentlemen:

Applicant:

Finance Realty P.O. Box 3979

Finance Realty Application for a Water Use Permit

Makakilo Golf Course Well. Makakilo. Oahu

Landowner:

Honolulu, Hawaii 96812

The Estate of James Campbell 828 Fort Street Mall, Suite 500 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813

Action Requested: Approval of a water use permit to use 1.15 million gallons per day (mgd) from Makakilo Golf Course Well (Well No. 1904-02) for irrigation of the Makakilo Golf Course.

Source of Water Supply: Caprock aquifer, Pearl Harbor Water Management Area.

Project Location: The well is located along the access road to Barbers Point Naval Air Station, Honouliuli, Ewa, Oahu.

Proposed Water Use: Golf course irrigation, Makakilo Golf Course. Brackish water from the caprock well will be desalted before being applied to the golf course.

Water Availability and Impact on Surrounding Wells: The well is located in the Kapolei Sector of the Caprock Aquifer. Sustainable yield under current conditions is estimated at 5 mgd. There are no other caprock wells being used in the Kapolei Sector at this time. Brackish caprock water from the well will be desalted then applied to the golf course. The golf course is situated over the Waianae Basal Aquifer. The Navy's Barbers Point Shaft and the Board of Water Supply's Makakilo Well both tap the Waianae Basal Aquifer and are within a mile of the golf course. The Board of Water Supply, the Department of Health, and the Navy have expressed their concern that brackish water not be allowed to be used over the basal aquifer. Concerns have also been expressed concerning the possibility of contamination of the basal aquifer by pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers applied over the recharge area. The Department of Land Utilization approved Finance Realty's application for a Conditional Use Permit for the Makakilo Golf Course on February 14, 1989. A condition of the permit is that the owner/developer establish a ground water monitoring plan to be approved by the Department of Health. Condition 6 of the Conditional Use Permit states that "should data from the monitoring wells indicate the presence of the measured compound and! or the increased level of such compound, the DOH can require the owner/developer or subsequent owner to take immediate mitigative action to stop the cause of contamination. Subsequently, the developer/owner or subsequent owner shall mitigate any adverse effects caused by the contamination."

ITEM 3

o o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management March 15, 1990

Public Notice: In accordance with DLNR Administrative Rules, a public notice was published in the Star Bulletin on January 31 and February 7, 1990. In addition, copies of the public notice were sent to the Mayor's office, the Department of Health, the Honolulu BWS, the Navy, Oahu Sugar Company, and to The Estate of James Campbell. Written objections to the proposed pennit were to be submitted to the Commission by February 22, 1990. The Navy has expressed their concern that the iProposed Makakilo Golf Course may result in the contamination of the Barbers Point Shaft, which provides about 2.5 mgd of potable water for the Naval Air Station (NAS), Barbers Point. The Honolulu Board of Water Supply recommended approval of the application on the condition that the chloride content of the water applied to the golf course be 160 ppm or less. Oahu Sugar Company did not have any specific objection to the permit application but expressed their concerns regarding the administration of the aquifer and the importance of increasing recharge to the aquifer to maintain its present quality. No other concerns or objections have been submitted.

RECOMMENDATION:

That the Commission approve the issuance of a water use permit to the applicant to use 1.15 mgd of brackish caprock water for golf course irrigation use from Well No. 1904-02, subject to the following conditions:

General Conditions

(1) The water use authorized by the permit must be for the reasonable-beneficial use described in the permit.

(2) The use must not interfere with any existing legal use of water.

(3) Modification of any permit condition must be approved by the Commission.

(4) The applicant must comply with all other applicable laws, rules, and ordinances.

Additional Conditions

(1) The permit shall be subject to the Chairperson's approval of a water use plan recommending possible measures to prevent or minimize saltwater contamination of the Caprock Aquifer and establish courses of action to prevent the aquifer from becoming too saline. The applicant must comply with the approved plan.

(2) Chloride content of the water used on the Makakilo Golf Course shall be 160 ppm or less.

(3) An approved flowmeter must be installed to measure withdrawals and a record of the withdrawals must be kept and reported.

2

o o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management March 15, 1990

(4) The development of the ground water source shall be completed within 24 months from the date of permit issuance.

Attach.

3

/

//

.....

t "

I'

" ''. .~

.. ~~.~

'.,

MAKAKILO GOLF COURSE WELL

(1904-02) .\\

" '\ : 'it."

i\' II i\ i: I;

1\ II II I' II II

" I· " .,

ISLAND OF OAHU

...-. ....

T

........

Q ............ I

.....

•

--~~~-- ,,,,c,.1'."+

£: · '. D" "" VEYBRANCH-~ j?..... lVI.tOn of W ter Re "" FROM: ~ source Managemet •. /

_=----.::=-\--_____ DATE: I~-+-I-_ FILE IN: ------

TO: . INITIAL:

'~ ~~':""". E. SAKODA

__ F. Ching

__ w. Rozeboom __ P. Haraguchi __ G. Bauer __ N. Fujii __ A Okamura __ B. Micua

__ G. AKITA __ L. Nanbu __ G. MATSUMOTO __ E.LAU __ L. CHANG __ Y. SHIROMA ~

FOR

_ __ M. TAGOMORI A,I / I'

~~~) REMARKS:

See Me (\ ~ 1- ~ I) ~:ew 8. Comment -r-'<l ~CIT well /I

Take Action . . " #" Investigate & Report ;) d! AIo ;Z ()() tj - cr2. H Draft Reply " • Acknowledge ReceiP(f ~:Jfjj~) J L () / ,~/ tV 1) -' Type Draft ~~ ...y LaJU 'fp...d/ ~!J~ I

Type Final cc: ' J '..JJ ' Xerox _ copies /tUrli I-<I( of (/~ !fN5

OUR: ~M 10 /J4. f I 15 /)"'- "f =.:. -liru well uJ tlJ' /?'4n;-6r Information / I' / j) 4'r.,L ~ f' £)0/1: ~--tr jJ fAr' \f<Y -IJ..-C,1';::'UzrTr- • .c/1i '"- P'uJ wdf

2-1- S //'~ Ji.,;,JJ. a ~ ----- ~\------&f\t. r~; \ ,; .:;l... '1

~..:1 .:, S ,.v-'

7~ -M.-.(J-- S. Kokubun /I"~I ~L. ?-/J.-:r/sM

'"" I,.

i / ........ /

,t ..... ,'., ... ,.,

.1

• ~ .. ,~,

,~

"

r u j (/2 carna90 court-reporting compaq, ltd. q ii·

Documents