radiation protection in norm industries

42
1 adiation protection in NORM industries Karin Wichterey Federal Office for Radiation Protection, Germany IRPA13, Refresher Course (RC 12), 16.05.2012, Glasgow

Upload: duman

Post on 06-Feb-2016

40 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Radiation protection in NORM industries. Karin Wichterey Federal Office for Radiation Protection, Germany. IRPA13, Refresher Course (RC 12), 16.05.2012, Glasgow. Content. Natural radioactivity: new field of regulations Contents of NORM regulations in Germany - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Radiation protection in NORM industries

1

Radiation protection in NORM industries

Karin WichtereyFederal Office for Radiation Protection, Germany

IRPA13, Refresher Course (RC 12), 16.05.2012, Glasgow

Page 2: Radiation protection in NORM industries

2

Content

• Natural radioactivity: new field of regulations

• Contents of NORM regulations in Germany

• Materials / scenarios / pathways

• Dose calculations

• Impact on industries

• Practical experience

Page 3: Radiation protection in NORM industries

3

Natural radioactivity – RP regulations development

• May 1996: Directive 96/29/EURATOM (EU-Basic Safety Standards) first regulations on NORM - different from usual RP (now: „work activities“ vs. „practices“)

• implementation into national law till 2000 Germany 2001 (StrlSchV) Radiation Protection Ordinance (RPO)

- Radiological criterion: 1 mSv/a (in addition to natural background) to members of the public

• now: 10 years experience in industries, authorities

Page 4: Radiation protection in NORM industries

4

Natural radioactivity – RP regulations development

• IAEA/EU: new development more specific regulations on natural RA and included in regular RP system,

• 29.09.2011: Proposal Council Directive (Basic Safety Standards)http://ec.europa.eu/energy/nuclear/radiation_protection/doc/com_2011_0593.pdf under discussion

- more stringent requirements concerning natural RA

- NORM regarded as planned situation regulatory control, but graded approach

- stricter dose values (0.3 mSv/a for public in case of clearance of NORM)

Page 5: Radiation protection in NORM industries

5

Implementation of EU-BSS ‘96: Example GermanyComprehensive analysis of existing information on:• Branches of possibly relevant industries• Masses of materials / residues, their reuse or disposal options• Mass specific activities of materials and residues• Effective doses to workers and members of the public (literature)• Calculation of doses and derived limits of specific activities

Materials considered: slags ashes sands wasterock, stoneReuse / disposal options: heaps, disposal use for road construction, backfilling building material (additive), others

Page 6: Radiation protection in NORM industries

6

Contents of the regulations (1)Radiation Protection Ordinance (RPO) – Part 3

Subject

Protection of humans and the environment from natural radiation sources (work activities)

Basics level of protection: 1 mSv/a in addition to natural background (as reference level for the public*) selectivity (‚Positive list‘ Annex XII, Part A) no licensing – surveillance only self-control of industries concerned (to a large extent) if > 2.000 t of materials arising per year: declaration to authority* Workers without exposure category as well

Page 7: Radiation protection in NORM industries

7

Contents of the Regulations (2) Appendix XII – List of Residues to be considered (shortened)

- Sludges and scales from oil and natural gas extraction,

- Impure phosphorgypsum; sludges, dust, slags from the production / processing of raw phosphate,

- waste rock, sludges, sands, slags and dusts from the extraction and preparation of bauxite, columbit, copper shale, tin, ...

- Dust and sludges from the off-gas cleaning of blast furnaces in raw iron and non- ferrous metal processing

Excemptions:• if used in the processes as raw material• C < 0.2 Bq/g for each RN of the U-238 sec/Th-232 sec series (= upper range of mass specific activity in soils in Germany unamenable to control!), U-235 series considered in models only

Page 8: Radiation protection in NORM industries

8

Contents of the Regulations (3) Appendix XII – Surveillance limits

CU238max + CTh232max < C No residue requiring control /surveillance!

Reuse- / disposal conditions Surveillance limits C in Bq/g general 1

Disposal of > 5000 t of a residue in any calendar year in the catchment area of a usable aquifer

Addition of > 20 % of a residue to building materials (house building)

Addition of > 50 % to construction materials used for road construction, landscaping, hydraulic engineering

0.5

Underground disposal / backfilling 5

Disposal or reuse of waste rock on areas > 1 ha in road construction, landscaping within the catchment area of a usable aquifer

CU-238max 0.2 and CTh-232max 0.2

Page 9: Radiation protection in NORM industries

9

Contents of the Regulations (4) Release of Residues from control

Release on application of the Legally Responsible Person

- precondition: < 1 mSv/y, public (without specific measures)- other preconditions:

no obligations regarding (conventional) waste law Declaration of the whereabouts (applicant) Declaration of acceptance (re-user / disposal facility)

CCC ThU maxmax 232238 formal release from controlif

Page 10: Radiation protection in NORM industries

10

Contents of the Regulations (5) Proof of compliance with dose criteria on release of residues

MM232Th

M238U CCC

maxmax

Dose assessment according to priciples layed down in Appendix XII Part D Realism (Parameters) inclusion of all relevant paths/ exposures

Demonstration of compliance also possible by demonstrating (in case of joint disposal with other residues and waste), if conditions according to Annex XII Part C fulfilled:

If proof fails:Residues should remain under surveillance!

(mean specific activities of all materials disposed of within 12 months)

Page 11: Radiation protection in NORM industries

11

Contents of the regulations (6)Values for CM (Annex XII Part C)

Disposal Option CM in Bq/g

Underground 5

Groundwater contamination

excluded

1

Disposal area 15 ha

0,1

Disposal area > 15 ha

0,05

massTotal

UMU M

AC 238238

massTotal

ThMTh M

AC 232232

Disposal of residues together with other waste (“mixing”)

If C >10 Bq/g (50 Bq/g for special disposal sites) dose assessment obligatory

Page 12: Radiation protection in NORM industries

12

Contents of the regulations (7)Surveillance of other materials

Materials: (§ 3 (2) No. 20): Substances comprising natural radioactivity (if not subject to ‚practices‘)

• only applicable in case of significantly enhanced exposures• authority may direct: protective measures that the materials are to be kept / stored at a specific place kind of disposal

not specific, need for guidelines of application

Page 13: Radiation protection in NORM industries

13

Example of check for the need of surveillance

Bauxite processing - red mudAssumption: > 5,000 t in calender year; Disposal within catchment area of a usable aquifer

Nuclide series

U-238 sec Th-232 sec

Nuclide U-238 Ra-226 Pb-210 Th-228 Ra-228

Bq/g 0.19 0.18 0.17 0.28 0.34

CU238max + CTh232max < 0.5 Bq/g

0 + 0.34 = 0.34 < 0.5

no residue requiring control!

Page 14: Radiation protection in NORM industries

14

What are representative measurements?

Definition of batches

Statistical procedures (confidence limits)

Software support!

Page 15: Radiation protection in NORM industries

15

Scenarios

re-use disposal other

re-use

house construction

sportsfields etc. road-/landscape construction

publicworkers publicworkerspublic

Page 16: Radiation protection in NORM industries

16

disposal

aboveground underground (disposal / backfill)

publicworker

other

use of slags as abrasives

worker

Page 17: Radiation protection in NORM industries

17

Pathways external -radiation inhalation of radon / radon DP / dust ingestion of contaminated food (incl. drinking water) ingestion of contaminated material

Radionuclides U-238 sec U-235 sec (fixed natural ratio to U-238) Th-232 sec K-40 (found to be not relevant, not regulated) Pb-210 + (important in case of thermal processes)

Page 18: Radiation protection in NORM industries

18

Pathways according to ‚Calculation Guide‘

Page 19: Radiation protection in NORM industries

19

Calculation bases for determination of the effective dose due to NORM in Germany

Monitoring of Radiation Exposure at Working

Activities (Guidance for the implementation of legal

provisions of German RPO, Part 3)

Calculation Bases for the Determination of Radiation Exposure due to Mining-caused Environmental

Radioactivity (Calculation Bases Mining)

First edition1999

Second edition 2010

English version2011

Page 20: Radiation protection in NORM industries

20

„Calculation Bases Mining“ (BfS, 1999/2011)

First paper to specify calculation models and parameters enabling „realistic, but sufficiently conservative“ dose assessments special guide for mining-related exposures with generic assumptions (formulas, parameter, reference person, background values…) made for exposures from mining (uranium, copper) and U-milling/ Cu-smelting has to be adapted to NORM residues, if known (scenarios, leaching rates, radionuclide vector…) Dose calculations for members of the public and workers different scenarios and parameter english version: http://doris.bfs.de/jspui/handle/urn:nbn:de:0221-201109056212

Page 21: Radiation protection in NORM industries

21

External exposureMeasurements (work place) ambient dose rate measurement H*(10) (µSv/h) to estimate external exposure by -radiation in 1 m above ground calibration of rate meter with Ra-226 effective dose calculation according to „Monitoring of radiation exposure at work activities“

Calculation using models known activities and geometry house-scenario: equivalent to RP 112 model room dose factors (mSv/h)/(Bq/g) calculation according to „Calculation Guide“

Page 22: Radiation protection in NORM industries

22

Inhalation of dust calculation according to „Calculation Guide“ dust concentration dependent on scenario and kind of material (0.05 … 3 mg/m³) concentration factor 4 for some materials (soil, waste rock, sand) due to enrichment in fine particles

Berner-Impactorwith dust collectors

Inhalation of Radon/Radon DP calculation according to „Calculation Guide“ dose conversion coefficient: ICRP 65 diffusion from soil, rock, building materials air (indoor/outdoor) using models / empirical data

Page 23: Radiation protection in NORM industries

23

Waterpath / groundwaterleading scenario: private well, with paths

drinking water

cattle watering

cow – milk – milkproducts

meat

irrigation of forage plants & vegetables …

for six age groups according to EU-BSS (1996)

In case of surface water contamination:

same paths like „well scenario“, except drinking water

Page 24: Radiation protection in NORM industries

24

Consumption of contaminated food

via: - irrigation of vegetables / forage plants

- deposition of dust on plants

calculation according to „Calculation Guide“

Ingestion of contaminated material (direct) stay on / work with contaminated material

ingestion rates according to the „Calculation Guide“

concentration factor 2 for some materials (soil, waste rock, sand)

Reference person, critical group six age groups according to EU-BSS (1996)

Page 25: Radiation protection in NORM industries

25

Example Zircon-Sand: Estimate of effektive dose *

f Conversion factor of ambient dose to effective dose (default?)H*(10) Ambient dose rate, 1.5 µSv/h (maximum of measured rate)b Standard breathing rate of a person, 1.2 m3/h (default)e Inhalation dose coefficient in µSv/Bq (default?)c Average total alpha activity conc. at work place, x mBq/m3 (measured)cRn Radon-222 concentration in Bq/m³ (calculated)F Equilibrium factor, 0.4 (default)g Dose conversion, 7.8E-03 (µSv/h) / (Bq/m³) (default)tW Working hours at work place in h/a (to investigate)

* See Guidance „Überwachung von Strahlenexpositionen bei Arbeiten“

.

EInh = b ∙ e ∙ c ∙ tW + cRn ∙ F ∙ g ∙ tW Eext = f ∙ H*(10) ∙ tW.

Effective dose = external dose + internal dose

E = Eext + EInh

Page 26: Radiation protection in NORM industries

26

Estimate of effective dose

Which conversion factor?

Conversion factor of ambient dose to effective dose depending on irradiation geometry/ photonenergy

Conversion factor for adults: 0.4 to 0.9 for (0.1 … 3) MeV

For unknown irradation geometry: conversion factor = 1

In comparison to “Calculation Bases Mining“: Semi-infinite volume source for U-238- or Th-232 series

Age group Conversion factor

> 12 a 0.61 - 12 a 0.7 ≤ 1 a 0.8

Page 27: Radiation protection in NORM industries

27

Dose-coefficient for inhalation

Default values in the Guidance „Monitoring for radiation exposures of work activities“, BfS 2006: (slowest lung absorption class) (IAEA Safety Guide RS-G-1.6 “Occupational Radiation Protection in the Mining and Processing of Raw Materials“, 2004):

• U – class S (highly insoluble compounds)• Th, Pa, Ac – class S (oxide and hydroxide)

• Ra – class M (one value for all compounds) • Po – class M (oxide, hydroxide and nitrate)• Pb – class F (one value for all compounds)

ICRP 71: (Age-Dependent Doses to members of the public…): If NO information about the chemical compound (solubility) → class M should be used (except thorium (class S) and actinium (class F))

Conforms to default values in “Calculation Bases Mining”, BfS 2010

Which lung absorption class? (1/2)

Page 28: Radiation protection in NORM industries

28

Dose-coefficient for Inhalation

For environmental exposure, the physico-chemical form of inhaled radionuclides is generally less well defined than in case of workplace exposure (radioactive element often is a minor component of the inhaled particles).

Absorption of the radionuclide to body fluids then may be well controlled by dissolution of the particle matrix

Procedure for unspecified compounds after ICRP 71 (mainly class M)

In airborne particles at work places the dissolution often is governed by the (generally known) chemical compound of the radionuclide

For work places coefficient for known compound should be used (for unknown compound: slowest absorption class)

Lung absorption class (2/2)

Page 29: Radiation protection in NORM industries

29

Dose-coefficient for inhalation

Which AMAD (Activity Median Aerodynamic Diameter) should be used?

ICRP recommended a default AMAD for occupational exposure of 5 µm = analysis of measurements at different types of work places: nuclear power industry, research centres, uranium mills, other U-facilities, fuel handling and other facilities (only few places with monazite or mineral sand taken into account)

BfS measurement by cascade impactor in zircon sand milling room (not representative): alpha-activity in a range of 0.3 – 3.0 µm

In compliance with literature data for milled zircon sand: Dose calculation with AMAD = 1 µm and assumption of NO enrichment of radioactivity in the fine-grained fraction (for the public: always AMAD = 1 µm)

Page 30: Radiation protection in NORM industries

30

Dose-coefficient for inhalation of dust

Dose estimation from total-alpha-activity

Effective dose-coefficient is the dose coefficient for the mixture divided by the number of alpha-emitting nuclides in the series (for U-nat: 5 and Th-nat: 3)

For U-nat: 8.2 µSv/Bq

For Th-nat: 22 µSv/Bq

Results of γ-spectrometric measurements of zircon sand:

Fraction of nuclides: U-nat / Th-nat ≈ 2 : 1

Effective dose coefficient:

8.2 µSv/Bq x 0.67 + 22 µSv/Bq x 0.33 ≈ 13 µSv/Bq

Page 31: Radiation protection in NORM industries

31

Impacts on industries

— Usually, no personnel qualified in radiation protection; assistance provided by consultants, authorities (guidelines etc.), industrial associations industries can solve problems !— Reduction of doses – reasons:

• specific measures to reduce exposures (working regime, H&S)• technical progress (automation) • substitution of radioactive additives

— Increasing public awareness also industries not directly concerned with the regulations are forced to deal with RP:

• portal monitors at disposals• quality certificates of materials containing radioactivity• fears of image loss Example: water works

Page 32: Radiation protection in NORM industries

32

Experience - water works

— 20 tons gravel filter

— C Ra-226 > 1 Bq/g

No controlled residue, but operator insisted on formal release (food supplier, fears of image loss)

Page 33: Radiation protection in NORM industries

33

Experience – residues from oil / gas

— scales and sludges with C Ra-226 up to 1,000 Bq/g

— in Germany: 10,000 t of scrap per year, containing 1,000 t of scales

— C >> Control limits to be released from control!

— different disposal options

new technology: removal of scales, immobilisation (geopolymers)

D < 1 mSv/a

Page 34: Radiation protection in NORM industries

34

Support by Industrial Associations: Code of Practice

Page 35: Radiation protection in NORM industries

35

Example: Thoriated gas mantles

• Trend: Th replaced by Y• Working regime at change of mantles: clearly reduced internal exposure when not done overhead

Page 36: Radiation protection in NORM industries

36

Water works: Reduction of radon exposure (1)

Organisation of work, remediation measures, technical development (automation)

Page 37: Radiation protection in NORM industries

37

Water works: Reduction of radon exposure (2)

Page 38: Radiation protection in NORM industries

38

Experience - practical problems (1)

— specification of residues to be controlled is suitable to confine

regulatory and practical effort

Problem: changing industries, raw materials, processes

(e. g. geothermal energy) need for updates !?

— some possibly important materials are not listed (e.g. filter gravel)

— specification of residues partly not precise enough

examples:

‚scales from oil production‘ – and if enclosed in pipes ( = scrap?)

‚residues from the extraction and preparation of bauxite‘

Page 39: Radiation protection in NORM industries

39

Problems with selectivity – Example bauxite

— 630,000 t/a

— Ra-226 up to 1.6 Bq/g

Sludges from processing

of bauxite to aluminium

oxide red mud

But:Blast bauxite also within the scope ?

Page 40: Radiation protection in NORM industries

40

Experience - practical problems (2)— some disposal operators reluctant to accept radioactive materials

(although released residues are not radioactive in the meaning of law)

— regulatory inconsistencies with ADR (European regulations on the carriage of dangerous goods by road): exceedance of ADR limits class 7 transport as „radioactive material“, but not in the sense of RPO (released from surveillance)

— standardisation of methods, models, parameters

— NORM specific calculation guide for dose assessments

— simple measurement methods (dosemeters, contamination monitors)

Some further poblems:

Page 41: Radiation protection in NORM industries

41

ConclusionsRegulations on NORM partly lead to a considerable decrease of exposures of workers

In other fields exposures turned out to have been overestimated in the past realistic rather than conservative dose estimates Guideline for dose assessments necessary

Regulated workplaces / residues partly not up to date more flexibility desirable!

Concept of self-control has proven itself to be adequate (no authorization necessary), but needs assistence by RP professionals

Page 42: Radiation protection in NORM industries

42

Good luck with the implementation of radiation protection in NORM industries!

Thank you for your attention!

For questions:Bundesamt für Strahlenschutz

SW 1.2: Natürlich vorkommende radioaktive Materialien, radiologische Altlasten

Karin Wichterey+49-3018 - [email protected]