ramirez 2019 audit of state asset forf presentation audit of state asset forf...§agree the auction...

17
5/6/19 1 61 ST COUNTY AUDITORS INSTITUTE MAY 7-10, 2019 AUSTIN TEXAS Presenter: Toni Ramirez Director of Audit Services and Special Projects Auditing of State Asset Forfeitures District Attorney’s Office OVERVIEW Ø PURPOSE Ø DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE Ø AUDIT Ø CONTINUOUS MONITORING

Upload: others

Post on 09-Aug-2020

8 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

1

61ST COUNTY AUDITORS INSTITUTE

MAY 7-10, 2019AUSTIN TEXAS

Presenter: Toni RamirezDirector of Audit Services and Special Projects

Auditing of StateAsset Forfeitures

District Attorney’s Office

OVERVIEW

ØPURPOSE

ØDISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE

ØAUDIT

ØCONTINUOUS MONITORING

Page 2: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

2

PURPOSE

COMMISSIONERS COURT RESPONSIBILITY

Code of Criminal Procedure §59.06 (g)(1):

All law enforcement agencies and attorneys representing the state who receive proceeds or property under this chapter shall account for the seizure, forfeiture, receipt, and specific expenditure of

in an audit, which is to be performed annually by the Commissioners Court or governing body of a municipality, as appropriate.

Page 3: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

3

OUR RESPONSIBILITY

Chapter 59 Asset Forfeiture Report- 2013

Obtain Resolution and Order to perform Asset Forfeiture AuditsApproval of the resolution and order authorizing the County Auditor to conduct all audits on behalf of Commissioners Court required by Article 59.06 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for fiscal year 2014 and henceforth until otherwise directed by Commissioners Court.

DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE

Page 4: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

4

DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE

Bexar County District

Attorney

Bexar County Sheriff’s Office

City of San Antonio Police Department

Bexar County Constable’s

Offices & Fire Marshal’s

Office

University & School

Districts Police Departments

Other LEA State Agencies

DA ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

Seized and Forfeited Assets§ Quickbooks

§ BOA Court Online Banking

Asset Forfeiture Revenue and Expenditures§ County Financial System

Page 5: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

5

SEIZED ASSET FLOW

LEA

•Seizes Currency

•Notifies DA Bookkeeper

•Deposits Currency at BOA

•Files Seizure Affidavit

DA Bookkeeper

•Creates subaccount at BOA

•Provides LEA with BOA subaccount info

•Records Deposit in Quickbooks

DA Civil Attorney & Paralegals

•Receives Seizure Affidavit from LEA

•Adds case to Agency Log

•Accepts or Denies

•Prepares and Files Notice of Seizure with District Clerk’s Office

BOA COURT ONLINE BANKING

Page 6: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

6

QUICKBOOKS REPORT

AGENCY LOG

Page 7: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

7

AUDIT

Page 8: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

8

PLANNING- INFORMATION

§ Review prior audit and any notes for next year§ Review statutes and County Purchasing/Travel Policies

for any changes§ Review OAG website for any changes to the State

Report§ Review General Ledger Report for DA’s Fund

• Make sure you include the expenditures for September of the PY

• Perform analysis of the expenditures for August of PY to capture any changes

§ Obtain any new or updated LEA agreements§ Gather Information on any Major Changes to the DA’s

Office

PLANNING- RISK ASSESSMENT§ Complete Risk Assessment

§ Focus on Risky Areas

§ Determine Testing• Statistical• Stratified• Judgmental• 100% Selection

Page 9: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

9

RISK ASSESSMENT- SEIZED FUNDS

AUDIT PROGRAM

§ Use Risk Assessment to Build Audit Program § Audit Program Should Follow the CH. 59 Report§ Audit Procedures Should be Detailed

• Update as needed• Notate the Name of the Reports and Who

Provided them on Workpapers

Page 10: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

10

I. SEIZED FUNDS

I. B) 2) Seizure During Reporting PeriodObjective: To determine if the Seized Funds Amount properly includes seized cases that meet the following criteria:

§ §59.03 CCP, LEA must file a Seizure Affidavit with the District Attorney’s Office

§ Funds have been transferred to the custody of the District Attorney’s Office

Testing§ Reconcile the DA’s Agency Report to the Seized Funds Report (QB)

• Research discrepancies to determine if the case should be included or excluded

§ Validate the seized case meets the qualifications of §59.023

§ Verify the seized case was deposited in DA’s Account (BOA)

I. SEIZED FUNDS

I. C) Forfeiture Petitions Filed For All Agencies Objective: To determine if the Forfeiture Petitions Filed amount properly includes seized cases that meet the following criteria: § §59.04 CCP, Notice of Seizure (NOS)was filed no later than the 30th

day after the seizure per §59.04 CCP§ NOS was filed during the reporting period 09/01/20XX TO 08/31/20XX

Testing:§ Obtain the list of NOS cases filed from the Docket System for the

reporting period§ Reconcile List of NOS cases to the Agency Log

• Research discrepancies• Does not include seized assets that were filed after 8/31• Include PY seizures filed during the audit period

§ Verify NOS was filed no later than the 30th day after the seizure

Page 11: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

11

I. SEIZED FUNDS

I. F) Amount Returned to Defendants/Respondents

§ Request list of Rejected Cases § Verify to supporting documentation

I. SEIZED FUNDS I. G) Amount Transferred to Forfeiture Account Objective: To determine if the Amount Transferred to the Forfeiture Account properly includes seized cases that meet the following criteria:§ Forfeited and Final Judgement was issued § Seized Case funds were transferred to the forfeiture account

Testing:§ Request the QB Check Register for the audit period to recalculate the

total• Deduct Checks Issued for Rejected Cases, Non Asset Forfeiture

Deposits, & PY Reissuance Checks§ Agree the recalculated total to the amount notated for the Amount

Transferred to Forfeiture Account§ Verify seized funds were transferred to the forfeiture account§ Verify the forfeiture is disbursed according to the Judgement

• Payee names agree to the Judgement- Respondent & Attorney

§ Recalculate the disbursement per the inter-local agreements 70%/30%

§ Verify court cost is paid for forfeitures > $2,500

Page 12: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

12

II. FORFEITED FUNDS & OTHER COURT AWARDS

II. B) Amount Forfeited For All Agencies You Represent

B) 2) Amount Forfeited and Received By your Agency

§ Verify amounts agree to the reports provided

§ Agree amount to the revenues reported in the DA’s Fund per the County’s System

II. F) Auction Proceeds§ Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents § Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset Listing § Agree the auction disbursement agrees to the inter-local

agreement• 70/30 or after in-service of 3 years the LEA maintains 100% of

the proceeds

PROPERTY SECTIONS

III. Other Property§ Request Property Worksheet § Clarify Property Categories

Standard- Motor Vehicles, Real Property, Computers, Firearms

Other-Clothing and Jewelry, Electronic and Tools, etc…

§ Review the LEA Property Reports attached to the Seizure Affidavits

IV. Forfeiture Property Received & V. Forfeiture Property Transferred/Loaned-

§ Interlocal Agreements, available Supporting Documentation

Page 13: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

13

VI. EXPENDITURES

Unallowable Expenditures: §59.06(d-1) May not use proceeds or property received for:1. Contribute to a Political Campaign 2. Make a donation to any entity, except as provided by

Subsection (d-2)3. Pay training or education expenses for judges4. Pay any travel expenses related to attendance at training

or education seminars that violate Commissioners Court policies

5. Purchase alcoholic beverages6. Make any expenditure not approved by Commissioners

Court if the current elected official does not file for reelection or loses in a primary, general, or runoff election

7. Increase a salary, expense, or allowance for an employee who is budgeted by Commissioners Court

VI. ALLOWABLE EXPENDITURES

Allowable §59.06 (D-4):If the expenditure is made for an activity of an attorney or office of an attorney representing the state that relates to the preservation, enforcement, or administration of the laws of this state it is an allowable expenditure.

Page 14: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

14

VI. A) PAYROLL & B) OVERTIMERepresents:

§ Employee salaries paid 100% or Partial from Asset Forfeiture Funds

§ Overtime salaries paid from Asset Forfeiture Funds

Testing:

§ Verify work performed by employee meets the requirement of §59.06• Job Description• Location of employee

§ Verify Commissioners Court approved any increases to an employee’s salary, allowance, or expenditure

VI. C) EQUIPMENT & D) SUPPLIESRepresents:

§ Vehicles, Computers, Firearms, Protective Body Armor, Personal Equipment, Furniture, Maintenance Costs, Uniforms, K9 Related Costs, Visual Aid Equipment for Litigation

§ Office Supplies, Mobile Phone and Data Account Fees, Internet, Other

Testing:

§ Verify expenditure qualifies as a §59.06 CCP expenditure

§ If it is an asset purchase- Validate the asset’s existence and location

§ PY Asset Purchase- verify existence and location

Page 15: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

15

VI. E) TRAVEL (IN & OUT OF STATE)

Represents:§ Transportation, Meals & Lodging, Mileage, Incidental

ExpensesTesting:

§ Review the detail documentation for travel especially travel advances and T-Cards

§ Verify travel was completed by individual§ Review for County Travel Policy violations

• Travel should be completed in the most efficient, cost-effective method

• Meal reimbursement classification

VI. REMAINING EXPENDITURES

§ Determine if testing is necessary

• Threshold Amount

§ Trace to supporting documentation

Page 16: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

16

QUESTIONABLE EXPENDITURES

Medals, Promotional items, etc…:§ Answer the question – How does the expenditure

relate to the “preservation, enforcement, and administration of state laws”

§ Should not have Official’s Name§ Request picture of item if invoice does not contain

enough descriptive informationStill Questionable§ Request a memo (email) stating the reasons the

expenditure is allowed under §59.06

AUDIT REPORT

§59.06 (g)(1)

§ Due 60 days from the last day of the State Fiscal Year which is 10/30/20XX

§ Allows 5 days to submit the report

§59.06 (g)(2)

§ Request Extension

• Report must be in before the 76th day after 8/31/XX

Commissioners Court

§ File Report for Record

Page 17: Ramirez 2019 Audit of State Asset Forf Presentation Audit of State Asset Forf...§Agree the auction proceeds to the sale documents §Verify the DA marked the asset as sold on the Asset

5/6/19

17

MONITORING

Quickbooks§ Monthly Reconciliation of Cash Accounts§ Verify Bank Transactions are RecordedExpenditures§ Work with AP to monitor expenditures for unallowable

items§ Review purchases with P-Cards and T-CardsJudgments§ Sample Quarterly§ Review Judgment Accounts in QB for unusual

transactions

FEDERAL ASSET REPORTING (EQUITABLE SHARING)Issued Revised ManualReport Changes

§ Requires Jurisdiction Finance Contact Information

Ø Important- Must approve, sign, and submit the Account Request for eShare Access for the Admin Access

§ Requires the Auditor’s Information and the County’s Single Audit Number Assigned by Harvester Database