raul galvez valdovinos, a090 066 373 (bia nov. 21, 2014)

8/10/2019 Raul Galvez Valdovinos, A090 066 373 (BIA Nov. 21, 2014)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/raul-galvez-valdovinos-a090-066-373-bia-nov-21-2014 1/7

Fin Gary Esq.Law O ice of Gary Fi n82632H ghway 1 1, Suite 2Ind o CA 9200

Executive O ce r Imm grat on R v ew

Board of Immigration Ap ealsO ce of he C e k

L

S/ CE Office of Chief Cou sel IMP11 5 N mperial AveE Ce t o CA 92243

Name: GALVEZ V DOVINOS RAU A 090-066 373

Da e of this o ice: 11/2 /201

closed s a copy of he Board' de s o d o der n e above-re enced ca e.

E c os e

P M bC y, h

S ce ly,

D CDon a CarrC e erk

k

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished

Cite as: Raul Galvez Valdovinos, A090 066 373 (BIA Nov. 21, 2014)



GALVE VAL OVINOS AULP O BOX 3MECCA CA 9225

f •

U S D p n of u ic

xec ve O ce g Rev e

Boa d of Immigra ion pp alO c of h l k

07 leesb rg Pike S te 200Fa Ch c V n 3

HS/ CE Office of Chief Cou sel - IMP5 N mperial Ave

El Ce ro CA 922 3

Name GALVE VAL OV NOS AUL A 090-066-373

ate of this otice /2 /20

E c sed s c y f e B d s dec s e b ve- e e e ced c se T s c y s v ded y u s c u esy Y u ey e ese ve s bee se ved

dec s u su 8 C F R § 1292 ( ) e c e ec s e s yem ved m e U ed S es ms mm g Judge s dec s de g

be em ved y e ev e e c ed dec s mus be ed d eby e e c u f e s d ys f e d e e dec s

c su e

M bC y J.

S ce ely

D Q c C

C e e

s am:




U.� DeparentJuticeE v O r g w

F l C V 20530

File A090 066 373 pe ial CA

D e Bd m A

Date NOV 120 4

re R L EZ V LDOV OS a k aR vezI M V L P OC D GS

PE

ON B LF OF SPO D y Fi , squire

ON BEH F OF DHS:

CH GE:

Willia P Holl ichAssis nt Chief Counsel

No ce S 212 (a (2 (A )(i)( , N Ac 8 U S C§ l182 (a )(2 )( (i)( ) ] -Controlled subs ce iolation

PLICAT ON Term nation

he Dep ent of Homeland S rity ("DHS ) app als om the Immi ion Judge's D ember 14 2 12, deci io ter nati g the r pon ent s re ov roce ing responde t, a ve d citize of Mexico d la l pe ent reside of the Un ted St e ,oppo es he app a The appe w ll b dismiss

e re ew r cle e or the n i gs o fac clu ing the d natio of credib lmade by he Immi on udge 8 C.F.R§ 003. (d)( )(i). We review de novo l o er issues,

nclud g w ther the ie have me the relev t burden of proo i sues of discre8 C F.R § 003. (d ( 3)(ii)

We adopt nd f t Im i a on udge s decision te mi at ng e res ond s rproce ngs The respondent was ch ged wit being removable a an alien convi e ocon ll subs nce violation as a re lt of a 1999 convi on r po session of a con ollesubs ce in violation o io 11 77 o Cali a H lt S e Code that case, e re pondent r eived a de ed en o jud ent d the case was d sm ss on June 122 0, r e succes l y com le the requ ed div ion pro( J at 1

The DHS contends on app that the r s on ent s 9 o ens ted i a c nvnder se ion 10(a )( 48 A of the mi io d Nation ity Act 8 U S C§1101(a ( 8 A )

The HS sser s hat the deci ion o the nit d St es Cou o pea s r the i CircL A endz v. IS 222 F d 728 749(9 C 2000 , which provid to the contradoes not apply thi c e b e it was ove led byNunez-R es v Holr, 646 F 3d 68 ,




ITED STATES DEP TMENT OF JUSTICEEXECUT VE OFF CE FOR M G TION REVIEW

GR T ON CO RT2409 A BRUCHER E RO

IMPERIAL CA 92251

AW OFF CE OF G Y FIG Y FI , ESQ;82632 H Y 11 , STE B-2

ND O CA 92201

Date: Dec 1 20 2

File A090 0 6 7

n he Ma er of:GA Z VA DO NOS RAU

� At ached is a copy of the wri en decisio of he Immigra io Judge.This decision is fin l u less appe is aken o he Board of

mmigratio Appeals The e closed copies of FO EOIR 26 Notice o Appeal a d FORM EO R 27 Notice of E r as A tor ey orReprese a ive properl exec ed m st be f led wi h the Board of

mmigr io Appeals on or beforeThe appeal mus be accompanied by proo of paid fee ($ 0 00)

E c osed is copy of he oral decision

E closed is a ranscrip of the tes imo y o record.

Yo are gran ed ntil to s it a briefo his office i s ppor of your appea

Opposi g co sel is gra ed u i o s bmi a brief i opposi ion o he appeal

� nclosed is copy of the order/decis o of he mmigra ion Jud e

papers fi ed wi he Cour sha l be accompa ied by proofof service upo oppo ing counse

cc DISTR CT CO SE1115 N IM ER A AE ENT O A 9224 0000

Sincer ly

�

mmigratio

Clerk U



" /,

UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JS ICEEXC TIV OFFICE FOR IMMIGRA ION REVIEW

IM I RA ON COU TI PE L, C IFO

F LE O 9 066 373

)IN HE TE OF: )

)aul G Z Val ov nos )

esponde )

A P ICATION Mo on o Te na e

On Behalf of esponde tGa y F nn82632 g way 11 , Su te B-2

nd o, C 90014

MOV PROCEEDI GS

December 14 20

O e a f f t e G v rnme t

W a o e c5 N I per a ve

El Cen ro C 9 243

ECISION AN O ER T G MOT O O E M E

On Oc o er 6, 2 1 , e Dep ent o Ho e d ecur y eg heseremova proceed ngs w e l ng of a No ce o A e da ed Se ember 28,20 1 T s no ce o a e s perseded a No ce o Appear ssued l 25, 1In e ed No ce o A e , D S c arged a e res onden s removab e forhav ng been conv c ed n J y 999 of a con ro ed subs ce o ense re a g

e possess on of me p e ne n v o at on of§ 11377 of e Cal fo aea a d Sa y Code T e responden oved to e m na e e roceed ngs

because e wa gr ed a defe ed en y of d en der§ 000 of e

Ca fo a Penal Code T e respon en 's case a d sm ssed on J e 2, 0 ,a er e success ly co p eted e equ ements of e d vers on s a u e

e p es o od spu te he ovee d t oo e c so the c e Theys pl sagree a out e appl ca l y oujan- m nd v F 3d 7 8(9 h Cr . 0 T a case hel t a conv ct ons n state co a e no conv c onun er t e m g a on c ey wou d qual or rel ef under e ederal



O de c had e bee ied in de cou . Rece ly he ci cu t cou te ea e om is iew o e eLuj z upra, bu o y

ospec i e y o e oacti e yN z- y s . Hol r 646 .3d 6 4 ( i0 . doi g so e ci c t cour note : "Fo t ose a i s c icte be e h

pub ic ion date o is dec sioL m d iz a p ies o ose l ensco icte e e p b c t o ate o is decisioL j is." In my

iew is estab shed a b i t ne ist nc o S nce e espo e t s conbe o e t e p b ca o ou ez-R s,he ets t e e e t o t e ru ein Lu an

e d iz is ssession o ense o ha e bee subjec to t e bene s o eFede a rst O de Act. Hence it s ot a emo b e se.

D S ues t e es onden cou d o e bee i ue ced he

i Luj z because his lea an di e sio da ed deci o .Howe e o ase bee ci e a wo d ca e h tu Ar n ar z

eq i e y inqu to a e o co ctio o de er e p c i it oFe e a s O Act

I IS HER FORE OR ERE is be e eby sDISMESSE

AN E M A E .

0 0 066 373 P ge o De e be 4 0

raul galvez valdovinos, a090 066 373 (bia nov. 21, 2014)

Documents