realtor® university speaker series presentation: the new american suburb: poverty, race, and the...
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
1/36
kanacker@gmu.
edu
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
2/36
Context: Suburbs
• “Over the past several decades some suburbanpicture windows in the United States havedeveloped cracks [!. "an# suburbs are nolonger places with high proportions o$
homeowning non%&ispanic 'hites and nativeborns with relativel# high household incomes(high levels o$ education( and without an#problems [!. )ndeed( some suburbs have neverhad these characteristics [!. )nterestingl#
perception has been lagging behind [!*+,nacker( -/0( /1.
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
3/36
Context: Suburbs
+cont2d1• changes in demographics( socioeconomics( andhousing stock3 $ocus: U.S. suburban decline andpovert#
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
4/36
Context: Suburbs
+cont2d1• changes in demographics( socioeconomics( andhousing stock3 $ocus: U.S. suburban diversit#
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
5/36
Context: Suburbs
+cont2d1• changes in demographics( socioeconomics( andhousing stock3 $ocus: suburbs in the internationalcontext
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
6/36
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
7/36
4ive 5e# 6hemes
/. Suburban povert#3
-. 7acial( ethnic( and nativist change3
8. Suburban 9ecline or not;
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
8/36
6able o$ Contents
• )ntroduction +5atrin =. ,nacker1
• Section ): Suburban >overt#
• 6he 7esurgence o$ Concentrated >overt# in ,merica:"etropolitan 6rends in the -s +?liabeth
5neebone and Care# ,nne Aadeau1• 9ebunking the “Cookie%Cutter* "#th $or Suburban
>laces and Suburban >overt#: ,nal#ing their Bariet#and 7ecent 6rends +5aren =eck >oole#1
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
9/36
6able o$ Contents
+cont2d1• Section )): 7acial( ?thnic( and Aativist Change• 6he 'ashington 9C "etropolitan 7egion 6raditional Ao
"ore; +Carol#n allaher1
• Docal )mmigration Degislation in 6wo Suburbs: ,n?xamination o$ )mmigration >olicies in 4armers =ranch(
6exas( and Carpentersville( )llinois +=ernadette &anlon and 6homas E. Bicino1
• Section ))): Suburban 9ecline or Aot;
• =e#ond Sprawl: Social Sustainabilit# and
7einvestment in the =altimore Suburbs +=ernadette&anlon1
• "etropolitan rowth >atterns and )nner%7ingSuburban 9ecline: , Dongitudinal ,nal#sis $or the /Dargest U.S. "etropolitan ,reas +Sugie Dee( Aance#
reen Deigh( and ,ndrew "c"illan1
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
10/36
6able o$ Contents
+cont2d1• Section )B: Suburban 4oreclosures• 7esponses to 4oreclosure and ,bandonment in
Cleveland2s )nner Suburbs: 6hree Case Studies +'.9ennis 5eating1
•
>unctuated ?Fuilibrium: Communit# 7esponses toAeoliberalism in 6hree Suburban Communities in=altimore Count#( "ar#land +regor# Smithsimon1
• Section B: Suburban >olic#
• 7evitaliing 9istressed Older Suburbs: Case Studies in
,labama( "ichigan( Ohio( and >enns#lvania +5athr#n '.&exter( ?dward '. +Aed1 &ill( =enGamin H. Clark( =rian ,."ikelbank and Charles >ost1
• 6he 7esponse o$ the AonproIt Sa$et# Aet to 7isingSuburban >overt# +=enGamin E. 7oth and Scott '. ,llard1
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
11/36
Section ):
Suburban >overt#
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
12/36
6he 7esurgence o$ Concentrated >overt# in,merica: "etropolitan 6rends in the -s+?liabeth 5neebone and Care# ,nne Aadeau1
• 4indings:
• 6he 7esurgence o$ Concentrated >overt# in theUnited States3
• 7egional )mpacts3
• Cit# and Suburban 6rends3• 9emographic Shi$ts3
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
13/36
6he 7esurgence o$ Concentrated >overt# in,merica: "etropolitan 6rends in the -s+?liabeth 5neebone and Care# ,nne Aadeau1
+cont2d1Extreme-PovertyTracts
1990 2000 2005-2009
Change:1990 to2005-2009
Change:2000 to2005-2009
6otal>opulation
J(Kopulatio
n
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
14/36
6he 7esurgence o$ Concentrated >overt# in
,merica: "etropolitan 6rends in the -s+?liabeth 5neebone and Care# ,nne Aadeau1+cont2d1Ty&eo'!"b"rb
TotPo& inExtremePovertyTracts2000
TotPo& inExtremePovertyTracts2005-09
(Change
Poor Po& inExtremePovertyTracts2000
Poor Po& inExtremePovertyTracts2005-09
(Change
Suburban 6otal
JL(J-K
/(-
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
15/36
Section )):7acial( ?thnic( and Aativist
Change
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
16/36
6he 'ashington 9C "etropolitan 7egion 6raditional Ao "ore; +Carol#n allaher1
• goal: comparing the 'ashington "etropolitan,rea to the 6raditional [suburban! "odel +&anlonet al.( -N13
• =lack,$rican ,merican population3
• Datino population3• Aon%&ispanic 'hite population3
• Houng workers.
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
17/36
6he 'ashington 9C "etropolitan 7egion 6raditional Ao "ore; +Carol#n allaher1 +cont2d1
*ig"re +.,: Cens"s Tracts ith Pro&ortion lac/%'rican %merican Po&"lationThan ne Positive !tanar 3eviation 'rom $ean# 4ashington 3C $etro&olit 2010
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
18/36
6he 'ashington 9C "etropolitan 7egion 6raditional Ao "ore; +Carol#n allaher1 +cont2d1
*ig"re +.+: Cens"s Tracts ith Pro&ortion lac/%'rican %merican Po&"lation
To Positive !tanar 3eviations 'rom $ean# 4ashington 3C $etro&olitan %
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
19/36
6he 'ashington 9C "etropolitan 7egion 6raditional Ao "ore; +Carol#n allaher1 +cont2d1
*ig"re +.: Cens"s Tracts ith 6atino Pro&ortion o' the Po&"lation reater
ne Positive !tanar 3eviation# 4ashington# 3C $etro&olitan %rea# 2010
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
20/36
6he 'ashington 9C "etropolitan 7egion 6raditional Ao "ore; +Carol#n allaher1 +cont2d1
*ig"re +.7: Cens"s Tracts ith 6atino Pro&ortion o' the Po&"lation reaterTo Positive !tanar 3eviations# 4ashington 3C $etro&olitan %rea# 2010
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
21/36
6he 'ashington 9C "etropolitan 7egion 6raditional Ao "ore; +Carol#n allaher1 +cont2d1
• 'ashington "S, departs $rom 6raditional "odel+&anlon et al. +-N13
• clusters o$ =lack,$rican ,mericans are more likel#to be located in suburban locates than inside cit#
limits +KN.K/M located in >rince eorge2s Count#13• clusters o$ Datinos are located in the inner
suburbs3
• non%&ispanic 'hite share o$ population in man#
9C tracts grew ver# rapidl# - -/3• #oung workers cluster in 9C and in innerIrst
suburbs +,rlington( B,3 ,lexandria( B,1
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
22/36
Section ))):Suburban 9ecline or
Aot;
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
23/36
"etropolitan rowth >attern and )nner%7ingSuburban 9ecline: , Dongitudinal ,nal#sis $orthe / Dargest U.S. "etropolitan ,reas
+Sugie Dee( Aance# reen Deigh( and ,ndrew"c"illan1
• examine patterns o$ inner%ring suburban change$or the / largest U.S. metropolitan areas($ocusing on metropolitan growth patterns andurban containment policies3
*ig"re .1: Trans'ormation o' the $etro&olitan !&atial !tr"ct"re an 8nner-i
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
24/36
"etropolitan rowth >attern and )nner%7ingSuburban 9ecline: , Dongitudinal ,nal#sis $or the/ Dargest U.S. "etropolitan ,reas+Sugie Dee( Aance# reen Deigh( and ,ndrew"c"illan1 +cont2d1*ig"re .2: $etro&olitan roth Patterns an 8nner-ing !"b"rban
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
25/36
"etropolitan rowth >attern and )nner%7ingSuburban 9ecline: , Dongitudinal ,nal#sis $or the
/ Dargest U.S. "etropolitan ,reas+Sugie Dee( Aance# reen Deigh( and ,ndrew"c"illan1 +cont2d1
*ig"re .,: Trens o' elative Per Ca&ita 8ncome PC8; 'or the 100 6by !"barea 190 < 200;
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
26/36
"etropolitan rowth >attern and )nner%7ingSuburban 9ecline: , Dongitudinal ,nal#sis $or the
/ Dargest U.S. "etropolitan ,reas+Sugie Dee( Aance# reen Deigh( and ,ndrew"c"illan1 +cont2d1
*ig"re .+: Trens in the Poverty ate 'or the 100 6argest C!%sby !"barea 190 < 200;
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
27/36
"etropolitan rowth >attern and )nner%7ingSuburban 9ecline: , Dongitudinal ,nal#sis $or the/ Dargest U.S. "etropolitan ,reas+Sugie Dee( Aance# reen Deigh( and ,ndrew"c"illan1 +cont2d1
*ig"re .): atio o' the College-E"cate Po&"lation to the %vera'or the 100 6argest C!%s by !"barea 190 < 200;
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
28/36
"etropolitan rowth >attern and )nner%7ingSuburban 9ecline: , Dongitudinal ,nal#sis $or the/ Dargest U.S. "etropolitan ,reas
+Sugie Dee( Aance# reen Deigh( and ,ndrew"c"illan1 +cont2d1• h#pothesis: urban containment polic# or the level
o$ urban sprawl pla#s a role in the decline o$inner%ring suburban communities3
• 8< metropolitan areas with urban containment
policies• NN metropolitan areas non%urban containment
policies
• sprawl index: +lowest sprawl1 to / +highest
sprawl1
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
29/36
"etropolitan rowth >attern and )nner%7ingSuburban 9ecline: , Dongitudinal ,nal#sis $or the/ Dargest U.S. "etropolitan ,reas
+Sugie Dee( Aance# reen Deigh( and ,ndrew"c"illan1 +cont2d1
=ear ContainmentTy&e
N"mber o'C!%s
$ean !&ral8nex
/JL Containment 88
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
30/36
Section B:Suburban >olic#
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
31/36
6he 7esponse o$ the AonproIt Sa$et# Aetto 7ising Suburban >overt# +=enGamin7oth and Scott ,llard1• 6hree research Fuestions:
• 'hat is the demand $or social services in thesuburbs( and how is it changing;
• 'hat challenges do service providers encounter to
operating programs in the suburbs;• &ow do nonproIts respond to these challenges;
• 6hree case studies:
• Chicago3
• Dos ,ngeles3
• 'ashington( 9C.
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
32/36
6he 7esponse o$ the AonproIt Sa$et# Aetto 7ising Suburban >overt# +=enGamin7oth and Scott ,llard1
+cont2d1
Co"nty$"nici&ality Poverty ate# 2000 Poverty ate# 2005-09
Dos ,ngeles Count# /L.JM /0.
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
33/36
6he 7esponse o$ the AonproIt Sa$et# Aetto 7ising Suburban >overt# +=enGamin7oth and Scott ,llard1
+cont2d1
Co"nty$"nici&ality Poverty ate# 2000 Poverty ate# 2005-09
'ashington( 9C -.-M /K.8M
"ontgomer# Count#("9 0.rince eorge2sCount#( "9
L.LM L.
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
34/36
6he 7esponse o$ the AonproIt Sa$et# Aetto 7ising Suburban >overt# +=enGamin7oth and Scott ,llard1+cont2d1• Changes( 9emands( and Challenges $or Social
Service >roviders
• )ncreased and Shi$ting 9emand3
• )mmigrant Communities3
• 6he Search $or ,Pordable OQce Space3• 4unding
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
35/36
6he 7esponse o$ the AonproIt Sa$et# Aetto 7ising Suburban >overt# +=enGamin7oth and Scott ,llard1+cont2d1
Percentageo'rgani?ations
>rioritiing Clients b# 9egree o$ Aeed 0.M7e$erring a reater Aumber o$ Clients Out 6 StaP
-
8/17/2019 REALTOR® University Speaker Series Presentation: The New American Suburb: Poverty, Race, and the Economic Crisis
36/36
www.ashgate.com
0="5/