recommendation for structuring, editing and publishing of phase iv deliverables in russia, norway...

Recommendation for structuring, editing and publishing of Phase IV deliverables in Russia, Norway and internationally

III Russian – Norwegian Conference, Razvilka – Gazprom VNIIGAZ, 9th December 2010

Tore Sildnes, RN01 co-ordinator

Barents 2020 - Working Group RN01

© Det Norske Veritas AS. All rights reserved.

Barents 2020 - Expert Group No.RN01

2

Barents 2020 Phase IV – RN01 Members

Name Company

Vladimir Vernikovskij GAZPROM / TK23

Dennis Thikomirov VNIIGAZ

Alexander Ermakov S-DAG

Annie Audibert-Hayet TOTAL

Jan Gustaf Eriksson STANDARDS NORWAY

Alf Reidar Johansen OGP

Per Eirik Fosen STATOIL

Morten Bøhlerengen Moss Maritime

Anatoly Baryshnikov ENI E&P

Tore Sildnes DNV



3

Working Group RN01 - Mandate for Phase IV

Recommend how Phase 3 recommendations and Phase 4 deliverables should be:- structured, - edited - and published

to fit well into the collection of existing standards

Recommend how the relevant documents from Barents 2020 Phase 4 can be used in revision and/or development of new ISO standards



4

Options for final reporting 1. Barents 2020 technical report

2. Proposal for Guideline(s) or Recommended Practice(s)- GAZPROM (STO)- DNV (RP)- OGP

3. Proposal for identical Russian and Norwegian national supplementary standard to an ISO standard

- GOST R Standard, Recommendation or “set of rules”- NS or NORSOK standard

4. Proposal for national annex to adopted ISO or EN-ISO standard

5. Proposal for ISO Technical Specification (TS)

6. Proposal for ISO Technical Report (TR)

7. Proposal for ISO Publicly Available Specification (PAS)

8. Proposal for ISO International Workshop Agreement (IWA)

9. Proposal for ISO Amendment to existing standard (Amd)



5

Selection Criteria General agreement within RN01 that the preferred goal should be to seek

to issue as much material as possible as ISO standards

This will facilitate the results to be recognised and used locally in arctic regions on a worldwide basis.

ISO/IEC

CEN/CENELEC

NN

NNSNNEK

ANSIGOST-R

NORSOKAPI

Regional

International

National

Industry&

Associations

DNVOGP

GOST

STO

The working groups have differing:- scopes, - target groups - and technical maturity level for

their tasks,

Recommendations on format of deliverables have thus been given individually for each group



6

How to propose an ISO Standard

Major challenge to achieve international consensus

Includes long ballot periods to assure time for all relevant parties to review and provide comments on the draft documents presented.

Typically the process can be described as follows: - 1. New work item proposal (NWIP) (by Norway/Russia) - 2. NWIP Ballot in ISO TC67 (3 months) by its 29 national P-members - 3. Development of draft ISO IS by ISO work group (6-12 months)- 4. Draft IS ballot (3 months) - 5. Review comments and agree final draft/document - 6. Final draft IS ballot (2 months)- 7. ISO to publish (3 months)

Timeline for the process: 24-48 months.

Development of an ISO Amd, TR and TS typically: 15-21 months.

Development of IWA, PAS typically 6-15 months



7

How to propose a GOST R standard

7

Major challenge to achieve national consensus on subject matter.

Typically the process can be described as follows: - 1. Submitting of a proposal to the Secretariat of TC- 2. Development of the first draft national standard (3-6 month)- 3. Review of first draft and public discussion (2-5 month)- 4. Development of the final draft national standard (3-6 month)- 5. Approval of the final draft by TC/SC (2 month)- 6. Editing and publishing (2 month)


Development of an R (Recommendation): 12-21 month as well



88

How to propose an STO GAZPROM

Major challenge to achieve consensus on subject matter.

Typically the process can be described as follows: - 1. Submitting of a proposal to the Perspective standards development plan- 2. Development of the first draft standard (3-6 month)- 3. Review of first draft and public discussion (1-2 month)- 4. Development of the final draft national standard (3-6 month)- 5. Approval and registration of the final draft (1 month)- 6. Editing and publishing (1 month)


Development of an R Gazprom (Recommendation): 9-12 month



9

How to propose and issue a DNV Guideline/RP

DNV Guidelines are published as “Recommended Practices”.

The stages of development are:1. Propose new publication to DNV “Rules and Standards

Secretariat”

2. Acceptance by DNV Rules and Standards Secretariat and relevant Service Line Director

3. Develop draft text for hearing

4. Submit draft for hearing to Rules Secretariate

5. Internal and external hearing

6. Comment review and approval by DNV Design Review Board

7. Publication.

Duration typically 3 months from finished draft document- “Fast track” publishing under special circumstances



10

How to propose and issue an OGP Report (Guideline, RP, etc.).

1. Typically one or more members of the OGP standing committees made up of OGP member representatives proposes document

2. The committee needs to agree for the need for this document and approve the start of the process, with a minimum of three members from different companies agreeing to draft the report.

3. This Responsible Committee arranges for the development, review within OGP membership and approval of the report in co-operation and agreement with OGP secretariat.

4. Normally, a minimum of four working weeks shall be allowed for the Responsible Committee’s review of the draft document.

5. For some documents (position papers) the OGP Management committee approval is required.

6. An OGP report can be developed and published in a very short time if need be as no outside bodies need to be consulted, but normally it may take 6-12 months.



11

Format of Deliverables

Format for deliverables to be structured and edited as far as reasonably practical in conformance with

- ISO/IEC Directives, Part 2, “Rules for the structure and drafting of International Standards”

This applies irrespective of type document produced

This will assure- best possible harmonisation of language

and formats with the numerous international standards referenced in the B2020 project



12

RN02: Ice Loads - Recommended Format

Barents 2020 phase 4 deliverable

Document specifying an annex to ISO 19906 on Ice Loads

Document to be proposed to the Russian and Norwegian standards developing organisations (SDO) as a national annex (supplement) to the assumed Russian and Norwegian adoption of ISO 19906 (or EN ISO 19906)

- Russia: National annex to GOST R ISO 19906- Norway: National annex to NS-EN-ISO 19906

Alternatively, document proposed for a harmonised new separate GOST R and NS standard

- to leave the adoption of ISO 19906 as a clean document

Following B2020 phase 4 (2012 - )

Input to ISO 19906 amendment or revision process

Alternatively, a new ISO standard within the area of arctic operations



13

RN03: Risk Management - Recommended Format

Objective

The working group’s focus is on information exchange during seminars, and not direct input to standardisation

Barents 2020 phase 4 deliverable:

Seminar proceedings on Risk Management

Include seminar introduction/conclusions in the general phase 4 report

Produce conference/seminar proceedings as a separate report, also including extract from phase 3 conclusions for this group



14

RN04: Evacuation and Rescue - Recommended Format


Document specifying an annex to ISO 19906 on EER

Document to be proposed to the Russian and Norwegian standards developing organisations (SDO) as a national annex (supplement) to the assumed Russian and Norwegian adoption of ISO 19906 (or EN ISO 19906)

- Russia: National annex to GOST R ISO 19906- Norway: National annex to NS-EN-ISO 19906

Alternatively, document proposed for a harmonised new separate GOST R and NS standard

- to leave the adoption of ISO 19906 as a clean document

Functional specifications to be issued as Barents 2020 technical reports - Depending on the maturity of the outcome, they may be considered for issue as DNV RP.


Input to ISO 19906 amendment or revision process

Alternatively, a new ISO standard within the area of arctic operations



15

RN05: Human Factors - Recommended Format


Guideline on Human Factors in Barents Sea

Document to be proposed initially as:- Corporate standard of GAZPROM (STO) - DNV RP


Input to a new stand-alone ISO standard within this area



16

RN06: Ice Management - Recommended format


Guideline on Ice Management

Document to be proposed initially as:- Corporate standard of GAZPROM (STO) - DNV RP


Input to a new stand-alone ISO standard within this area



17

RN07:Operational Emissions and Discharges - Recommended format


• Document specifying regional standard on Operational Emissions/ Discharges

• Document to be proposed to the Russian and Norwegian standards developing organisations (SDO) as:

- National Russian standard (GOST R and SanPin (Sanitary Rules and Norms))

- Norwegian Standard (NS)- (alternatively industry guideline)



18

Concluding Remarks

The recommendations given should not be regarded as definite final conclusions

Progress should be continually observed throughout the duration of B2020 phase 4

Format of deliverable to be adjusted as necessary based on:- actual progress- quality of work- response from potential publication “owners”



19

Further work tasks

for RN01



20

Further work tasks for RN01

1. Review deliverables from working groups for compliance with the recommendations report of RN01, and prepare roadmaps for implementation of deliverables

2. Create awareness among the potential recipients (e.g. standards organisations) as to what is coming and acting as an intermediary as necessary and appropriate



21

Creating Awareness - ISO/TC67/SC7 Relations

Most of the deliverables of Barents 2020 are related to ISO/TC67/SC7 standardization activities

ISO 19906 which is the major standard for E&P in arctic regions was developed under responsibility of SC7

WG8 of SC7 finished its job with ISO 19906 and now is in a “stand-by” mode but could be reengaged to start working with Barents 2020 deliverables

SC7 has lack of information about Barents 2020 activities

There is an urgent need to inform SC7 about current project status and to aware them about future plans and deliverables including AHG “Arctic operation” activities

Best way to do that is to make a presentation at closest SC7 plenary meeting in January 2011

Management of SC7 welcomes RN01 experts to attend the plenary meeting to establish close connections among ISO and Barents 2020 project

21



22

2011 additional tasks for RN01

1. Review deliverables from working groups for compliance with the recommendations report of RN01, and prepare roadmaps for implementation of deliverables

2. Create awareness among the potential recipients (e.g. standards organisations) as to what is coming and acting as an intermediary as necessary and appropriate

3. Provide proposal for an Arctic long term international standards program (ref. ISO/TC67 MC Ad-hoc group Arctic Operations) and including potentially missing international standards for the broader Arctic environment



23

ISO TC67 MC Ad-hoc Group “Arctic Operations”

Terms of references:

- Provide a proposal for an Arctic (or cold conditions) operations long term international standards programme

- Propose the way ISO/TC 67 should deal with such standards- Take input from the Barents 2020 project- Present a proposal at the ISO/TC67 plenary meeting in Moscow,

September 2011



24

ISO TC67 MC Ad-hoc Group “Arctic Operations”

Members:

Marat Mansurov, VNIIGAZ, chair

Alf Reidar Johansen, OGP, co-chair

Jan Inge Dalane, Statoil

Anatoly Baryshnikov, ENI

Muayad Ajjawi, Qatar Petroleum

UK (to be determined)

++



25

RN01 work plan and deliverables

Proposal for an arctic long term international standards program:- Input from B2020 work groups by March 2011- Present draft report at B2020 May meeting- Finished report by end June 2011- Handover to ISO TC67 MC Ad-hoc Group



26

Summary

Deliverables Short term use Long term use - Overall report phase 4 - RN02: Document specifying Annex to ISO

19906 on Ice Loads National annex to GOST R ISO and NS-EN-ISO 19906

ISO 19906 revision or new ISO ice loading std.

- RN03: Seminar proceedings on Risk Management

- RN04: Document specifying Annex to ISO 19906 on EER

National annex to GOST R ISO and NS-EN-ISO 19906

ISO 19906 revision or new ISO ice loading std.

- RN04: Functional Specifications (arctic lifeboat/rescue vessel)

Two B2020 Technical reports (DNV RP)

- RN05: Guideline on Human Factors in Barents Sea

GAZPROM (STO) DNV RP

New ISO std.

- RN06: Guideline on Ice Management GAZPROM (STO) DNV RP

New ISO std.

- RN07: Document specifying regional standard on Operational Emissions/ Discharges

(GOST R and SanPin (Sanitary Rules and Norms)) Norwegian Standard (NS) (alternatively industry guideline)

Written in format of ISO Directives part 2



27

Safeguarding life, property and the environment

www.dnv.com

recommendation for structuring, editing and publishing of phase iv deliverables in russia, norway...

Documents

iso amd

iso work group

group rn01 slide

iso amendment

iso tc67

eniso standard

development of draft

group slide