relationship to district 3. enter your name and while you

WHILE YOU’RE WAITING...

ex. John Smith - Parent

Please mute your mic,and update your Zoom Username to help us know you better.

1. Click on Participants 2. Click on your name and More 3. Enter your name and relationship to District

COMMUNITY ADVISORY TEAM

Session #4October 12, 2021

Agenda

● Community Survey Results● Recap Process & Findings● Discussion● CAT Recommendation

Powered by

Northwest Local Schools Master Plan Option Survey ResultsMonday, October 11, 2021

3,474Total Responses

Q1: What is your age?Answered: 3,474 Skipped: 0

Q2: What BEST describes your relationship with the District?Answered: 3,466 Skipped: 9

Q3: How long have you lived in the district?Answered: 3,474 Skipped: 0

Q4: What’s your Zip Code?

Q5: Have you attended or watched any of the previous Community Forums or Community Advisory Team sessions?Answered: 3,461 Skipped: 14

Q6: Northwest Local Schools Important Value StatementsAnswered: 3,175 Skipped: 300

4-Strongly Agree 3- Agree 2-Disagree 1-Strongly

DisagreeWeighted Average

Clean Feeder 34.69% 47.52% 15.16% 2.63% 3.14

Building Equity 70.73% 27.40% 1.33% 0.54% 3.68

One HS 21.88% 25.21% 34.69% 18.22% 2.51

One MS 14.03% 22.23% 41.13% 22.61% 2.28

Q7: Master Plan OptionsAnswered: 2,728 Skipped: 747

4-Very App 3- App 2-Inappropriate 1-Very Inappropriate

Weighted Average

Option A 14.58% 21.54% 29.99% 33.89% 2.17

Option B 17.32% 29.83% 30.24% 22.61% 2.42

Option C 29.91% 36.52% 20.67% 12.90% 2.83

Option D 7.66% 22.28% 40.00% 30.06% 2.07

Option E 26.45% 30.32% 24.48% 18.75% 2.64

Q8: Are you aware that the 1997 Bond Expiring in 2021 (1.15 mils)Answered: 2,617 Skipped: 858

Q9: How strongly do you agree with the following statements?Answered: 2,590 Skipped: 885

4-Strongly Agree 3- Agree 2-Disagree 1-Strongly

DisagreeWeighted Average

SOME K-8Students 27.64% 46.43% 15.54% 10.39% 2.91

ALL K-8Students 26.37% 35.69% 22.35% 15.60% 2.73

Would you support improvements that provide new schools for…

Q10: How many mils would you be willing to support if it ensured equity in NWLSD schools? (1 mil = $35/Year per $100K Home Valuation)Answered: 2,207 Skipped: 1,268

SCHOOL YEAR BUILT FACILITY APPRAISAL

RENOVATE/REPLACE %

LONG-TERMRENO COST

5YR WARM, SAFE & DRY

Colerain High School 1964 56% 79% $61,800,000 $11,328,529Northwest High School 1972 53% 73% $44,400,000 $12,560,774White Oak Middle School 1961 49% 84% $21,200,000 $2,664,338Colerain Middle School 1930 46% 70% $14,700,000 $0 *Pleasant Run Middle 1969 51% 68% $20,100,000 $3,804,858Colerain Elementary School 1923 47% 80% $20,000,000 $0 *Monfort Heights Elementary 1999 73% 44% $13,400,000 $2,755,236Struble Elementary School 2018 100% - - $44,033Taylor Elementary School 2018 100% - - $44,033Pleasant Run Elementary School 2018 100% - - $44,033Houston Early Learning Center 1966 54% 78% $16,200,000 $4,206,045

* CES & CMS were slated for replacement in the 2014 Master Plan. Therefore, there are no maintenance funds assigned.

Existing School Facilities

EDUCATIONALLY APPROPRIATE

FINANCIALLY RESPONSIBLE

COMMUNITY SUPPORTED

Educational Visioning Team BIG IDEAS

● Expanded academic offerings● Operational efficiency● Schools that foster relationships● District-wide equity

Financial Realities● Replacing existing 1997 bond with new

bond of original millage (1.15mil fund)● Cost per 100k home = $40.25/year● Cost per 250k home = $100.63/year● Funds $40M repaid over 35 years● *Estimated values will fluctuate over time

CAT Values

● Instructional Excellence● Exceptional Student Opportunities● Equity - Equal Educational Access● Great Learning Environments

CAT CONSENSUS

● Address buildings with greatest need first● District-wide Equity● Preference for 6-8 MS● Preference for “Clean Feeder” organization● Preference to minimize student transitions

VERY APPROPRIATE

APPROPRIATE

NEUTRAL

INAPPROPRIATE

VERY INAPPROPRIATE

CAT3 MASTER PLAN RANKING

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

PLEASANT RUN900

MONFORT HTS702

TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

HO

UST

ON

* 2

20t -

550

c

1807 2278

Adjust MS’s to approx 1050 and 900 capacities for “CLEAN FEEDER”

NEW COLERAIN515 pk-5 = 61,132 sf NEW

COLERAIN1168 =

157,015 sf

RENOVATE/ REPLACE

PRMS639

New COMBINED HS

2278 = 356,832 sf(or reno/expand

Colerain + approx. 100,000 sf)

3918 projected

$68.7M

mp2

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

HO

UST

ON

* 2

20t -

550

c

Could be “CLEAN FEEDER” with 1050 and 900 capacity MSs; reuse of NWHS sq ft as MS aligns with CES, MH + one 900 student elem

NEW

C

OLE

RA

IN M

S90

4 =

127,

076

NEW

MS

or

Ren

o N

WH

S (d

emo

Car

eer

Tech

) 904

in

140,

565

cred

itabl

e sf

1807 2278

NEW COLERAIN515 pk-5 = 61,132 sf

PLEASANT RUN900

MONFORT HTS702

TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

New COMBINED HS with Career

Tech2278 = 356,832 sf(or reno/expand


3918 projected

$40.

0M

$19.3M

mp8

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

HO

UST

ON

* 2

20t -

550

c

Could be “CLEAN FEEDER” if 450, 600, and 900 MS capacities

NEW COLERAIN584 = 83,829

sf600

NEW White Oak MS

584 = 83,829 sf

RENO PRMS

639


PLEASANT RUN900

MONFORT HTS702

TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

1807 2278


Tech2278 = 356,832 sf(or reno/expand


3918 projected

$45.7M

mp10

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

HO

UST

ON

* 2

20t -

550

c

Could be “CLEAN FEEDER” if 450, 600, and 900 MS capacities

NEW COLERAIN584 = 83,829

sf

NEW White Oak MS

584 = 83,829 sf

RENO PRMS

639


PLEASANT RUN900

MONFORT HTS702

TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

1807 2278


Tech2278 = 356,832 sf

3918 projected

CAREER TECH CENTER

1099 combined = 135,203 sf$45.7M

600

mp14

Community Forum #2

Master Plan

DRIVERS● Address buildings with greatest need first● District-wide Equity● Preference for 6-8 MS● Preference for “Clean Feeder” organization● Expanded academic offerings● Operational efficiency● Schools that foster relationships

Survey

Insert relevant survey content

SURVEY SUMMARY (3,474 Respondents)

WeightedAverage

Option A 2.17

Option B 2.42

Option C 2.83

Option D 2.07

Option E 2.64

Important Values Weighted Average

Clean Feeder 3.14

Building Equity 3.68

One HS 2.51One MS 2.28

Support Improvements that address

Weighted Average

SOME K-8 Students 2.91

ALL K-8 Students 2.73

BOE to decide:● Final Master Plan Configuration● Scope & Timing of Next Phase

DISCUSSION

CAT/EV to recommend:● Preferred District-wide Master Plan

Option “C” - 2 Middle Schools & 2 High Schools

Pros & Cons

mp2.2 – Min. Next Phase New CES/New MS = $65.1M + $3M Demo = 68.1M Min. Next Phase = 1.92 Mils = $67.24/$100,000 home value

Opt. Next Phase = New PRMS, MH reno +1.5M demo = $122.9 = 3.47 Mils @ $121/yr/$100k home value Total MP = (+$4.8 Demo) $260.5M = 7.35 Mils = $257/$100,000 home value

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900

Future MONFORT HTS Reno702 students

TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future NEW PRMS

900 Students

New NWHS w Career Tech 1,000 students

New CHS w Career Tech 1,275 students

NEW COLERAIN

MS1050

students

NEW COLERAIN ES515 students

possiblyconnected to

GREATEST PHYSICAL NEED:Providing new schools for SOME of our k-8 students

● New Colerain ES & MS● $68.1 million● 1.92 mil● $67/yr/$100,000 home

EQUITY BASED:Providing new/renovated schools for ALL of our k-8 students

● New Colerain ES & MS● New Pleasant Run MS● Monfort Hts Reno● $122.9 million● 3.47 mil● $121/yr/$100,000 home

Future Phase● 2 New HSs● Houston Reno

Total Combined Cost of all phases ● $260.5 million minus $60 million

State Credit

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future New WOMS

450 students

Future New PRMS

900 students




NEW COLERAIN

MS600 students

mp3.2 - Min. Next Phase New CES/New MS = $46.8M + $3M Demo = $49.8M Min. Next Phase = 1.40 Mils = $49.17/$100,000 home value Opt. Next Phase = New MSs, MH reno + 1.5M demo = $126M = 3.55 Mils @ $124/yr/$100k home value

Total MP = (+$4.8M demo) $263.6M = 7.44 Mils = $260/yr/$100,000 home value





● New Colerain ES & MS● New Pleasant Run MS● New White Oak MS● Monfort Hts Reno● $126 million● 3.55 mil● $124/yr/$100,000 home

Future Phase● New HSs● Houston Reno


State Credit

Option “E” - 3 Middle Schools & 2 High Schools

Pros & Cons

POLL - tell us what you think

Based on what we’ve learned, what is the most appropriate Educational Facility Master Plan For Northwest Local Schools.

THANK YOU!

FOLLOWING SLIDES ARE SOURCE

CONTENT - NOT FOR PRESENTATION

Discussion: Based on what we’ve learned, what is the most appropriate

Educational Facility Master Plan for

Northwest Local Schools?

Option A - 1 Middle School & 1 High School

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Futu

re H

OU

STO

N E

CC

Ren

o 2

20

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future New HS w Career Tech

2,278 students

NEW MS1807 students


Option A - 1 Middle School, 1 High School

Timing and Cost

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut

HO

UST

ON

EC

C R

eno

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future New HS w Careet Tech

2,278 students

NEW MS1807

students


mp1A - Min. Next Phase = New CES + New MS = $88.8M+$3M Demo = $91.8M Min. Next Phase = 2.59 Mils = $90.63/$100,000 home value Opt. Next Phase(s) = +MH reno + 1.5M demo = $106.7M = 3.01 Mils @ $105/yr/$100k home value Total MP = $233.8M + $4.8M Demo = $238.6M: 6.73 Mils = $236/$100,000 home value


● New Colerain ES ● New MS● $91.8 million● 2.59 mil● $91/yr/$100,000 home


● Add Monfort Hts Reno● $106.7 million● 3.01 mil● $105/yr/$100,000 home

Future Phase● New HS ● Houston Reno


State Credit

Focus area of next phase

Option A - 1 Middle School, 1 High School

Educational Pros & Cons

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut

HO

UST

ON

EC

C R

eno

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future New HS w Career Tech

2,278 students NEW MS

1807 students


mp1A - Min. Next Phase = New CES + New MS = $88.8M+$3M Demo = $91.8M Min. Next Phase = 2.59 Mils = $90.63/$100,000 home value Next Phase(s) = New HS, MH reno, Houston Reno Total MP = $233.8M + $4.8M Demo = $238.6M: 6.73 Mils = $236/$100,000 home value

Pros● District-wide equity● Community unity● Operational efficiency● More Academic

Offerings

Cons● Combining HSs

○ Tradition & History○ Extra-curricular

opportunities (sports & arts)

● One MS○ A lot of kids in one

school○ Fewer

extracurricular opportunities

Option B - 2 Middle Schools & 1 High School

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

NEW COLERAIN MS1050 students


Future NEW PRMS

900 Students

Future NEW HS w CAREER TECH 2278 students


Option B - 2 Middle Schools, 1 High School

Timing and Cost





Future Phase● New HS ● Houston Reno


State Credit

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future NEW PRMS

900 Students


NEW COLERAIN

MS1050

students


Min. Next Phase New CES/New MS = $65.1M + $3M Demo = $68.1M Min. Next Phase = 1.92 Mils = $67.24/$100,000 home value

Opt. Next Phase = New PRMS, MH reno +1.5M demo = $122.9M = 3.47 Mils @ $121/yr/$100k home value Total MP = (+4.8M demo) New: $254.8M: 7.19 Mils = $252/ 100,000 home value



Option B - 2 Middle Schools, 1 High School


Pros● District-wide equity● Community unity● Operational efficiency● More Academic

Offerings● Smaller MSs


○ Tradition & History○ Fewer

extra-curricular opportunities (sports & arts)

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future NEW PRMS

900 Students


NEW COLERAIN

MS1050

students



Option C - 2 Middle Schools & 2 High Schools

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

NEW COLERAIN MS1050 students


Future NEW PRMS

900 Students




connected to

Option C - 2 Middle Schools, 2 High Schools

Timing and Cost

mp2.2 – Min. Next Phase New CES/New MS = $65.1M + $3M Demo = 68.1M Min. Next Phase = 1.92 Mils = $67.24/$100,000 home value

Opt. Next Phase = New PRMS, MH reno +1.5M demo = $122.9 = 3.47 Mils @ $121/yr/$100k home value Total MP = (+$4.8 Demo) $260.5M = 7.35 Mils = $257/$100,000 home value

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future NEW PRMS

900 Students



NEW COLERAIN

MS1050

students







Future Phase● 2 New HSs● Houston Reno


State Credit


Option C - 2 Middle Schools, 2 High Schools


Pros● Maintains 2 HSs

○ Avoids challenges of combining

● Smaller MSs

Cons● Hard to maintain

District-wide equity● Continues community

division● Inefficient to operate● fewer Academic Offerings

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future NEW PRMS

900 Students



NEW COLERAIN

MS1050

students



Option D - 3 Middle Schools & 1 High School

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900


Future New WOMS

450 students

Future New PRMS

900 students


NEW COLERAIN

MS600 students


Option D - 3 Middle Schools, 1 High School

Timing and Cost

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900


Future New WOMS

450 students

Future New PRMS

900 students

NEW COLERAIN ES515 students NEW CMS

600 students

mp3.1 - Min. Next Phase New CES/New MS = $46.8M + $3M Demo = 49.8M Min. Next Phase = 1.40 Mils = $49.17/yr/$100,000 home value

Opt. Next Phase = New MSs, MH reno + 1.5M demo = $126M = 3.55 Mils @ $124/yr/$100k home value Total MP = (+$4.8 demo) $253.1M = 7.14 Mils = $250/yr/$100,000 home value








State Credit


Option D - 3 Middle Schools, 1 High School


Pros● District-wide HS equity● Community unity● More HS Academic

Offerings● Smaller MSs


○ Tradition & History○ Fewer

extra-curricular opportunities (sports & arts)

● Different size MSs● Harder to maintain MS

equity● Operational ineffeciency

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900


Future New WOMS

450 students

Future New PRMS

900 students

NEW COLERAIN ES515 students NEW CMS

600 students


Option E - 3 Middle Schools & 2 High Schools

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future New WOMS

450 students

Future New PRMS

900 students


NEW COLERAIN

MS600 students

possibly connected to



Option E - 3 Middle Schools, 2 High Schools

Timing and Cost

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future New WOMS

450 students

Future New PRMS

900 students




NEW COLERAIN

MS600 students

mp3.2 - Min. Next Phase New CES/New MS = $46.8M + $3M Demo = $49.8M Min. Next Phase = 1.40 Mils = $49.17/$100,000 home value Opt. Next Phase = New MSs, MH reno + 1.5M demo = $126M = 3.55 Mils @ $124/yr/$100k home value

Total MP = (+$4.8M demo) $263.6M = 7.44 Mils = $260/yr/$100,000 home value








State Credit


Option E - 3 Middle Schools, 2 High Schools


Pros● Maintains 2 HSs

○ Avoids challenges of combining

● Smaller MSs

Cons● Hard to maintain

District-wide equity● Continues community

division● Inefficient to operate● fewer Academic Offerings● 3 Different size MSs● Operational inefficiency

P K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

Fut R

eno

HO

UST

ON

220

PLEASANT RUN900


TAYLOR900

STRUBLE900

Future New WOMS

450 students

Future New PRMS

900 students




NEW COLERAIN

MS600 students


5 Options to

Consider

relationship to district 3. enter your name and while you

Documents