relt30062 indian philosophy - jacqueline view online ... · pdf file01/28/18 relt30062 indian...
TRANSCRIPT
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - JacquelineSuthren Hirst(2015-2016)
View Online
188 items
General Introductions on Hinduism and Buddhism (9 items)
The sacred thread: Hinduism in its continuity and diversity - Brockington, J. L., 1996Book | Any edition, especially chapters 2-6. Chapter 5 is on the 'six schools' specifically
Sources of Indian tradition: vol. 1 - Embree, Ainslie Thomas, Hay, Stephen N., De Bary,William Theodore, 1988
Book | Chapter on Hindu philosophy [for a simple and relatively short overview of eachof the schools]
A survey of Hinduism - Klostermaier, Klaus K., c1994Book | [any edition, chs. 4-6 on various texts, chs. 12-14 on Knowledge, ātman and
brahman, and Liberation, and chs. 23-26 on the brahmanical schools (Structures ofthought) may be particularly useful]
Hinduism: a very short introduction - Knott, Kim, 1998Book | [very short, so the philosophical stuff is brief but may give you a quick easy to
read overview which then needs extending by more detailed reading]
Hindus: their religious beliefs and practices - Lipner, Julius, c2010Book | [any edition, esp ch.1 as background for those of you who haven’t studied it at
all before, chs. 2-4 more detailed stuff on different types of texts which are then used insome of the different philosophical schools]
An introduction to Buddhism: teachings, history and practices - Harvey, Peter, 2004Book | [any edition, readable but detailed survey]
Buddhism: a very short introduction - Keown, Damien, 1996Book
Mahayana Buddhism: the doctrinal foundations - Williams, Paul, c2009
Book | [excellent and detailed intro to a range of Mahāyāna schools]
Buddhist thought: a complete introduction to the Indian tradition - Williams, Paul, Tribe,Anthony, NetLibrary, Inc, c2000
Book | [available as e-book]
1/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
1.2 General Introductions and Surveys on Indian Philosophy (7 items)
An introduction to Indian philosophy - C. J. Bartley, c2011Book
Indian philosophy: a very short introduction - Sue Hamilton, 2001Book
Essentials of Indian philosophy - M. Hiriyanna, 1949Book
Outlines of Indian philosophy / M. Hiriyanna. - M. HiriyannaWebpage
Indian philosophy: an introduction to Hindu and Buddhist thought - Richard King, 1999Book
A survey of Hinduism - Klaus K. Klostermaier, c1989Book
Classical Indian philosophy - J. N. Mohanty, c2000Book
Topic 1: What is Indian Philosophy? (15 items)See also Topic 12
Primary sourcesSee Topic 4 and throughout
Key text (1 items)
Indian philosophy: an introduction to Hindu and Buddhist thought - King, Richard, 1999Book | chapter 1
Further reading (10 items)
Hindu and Buddhist ideas in dialogue: self and no-self - Kuznetsova, Irina, Ganeri,Jonardon, Ram-Prasad, Chakravarthi, 2012
Book
The lost age of reason: philosophy in early modern India 1450-1700 - Ganeri, Jonardon,2011
Book
Hinduism and the proper work of reason - Jonardon GaneriChapter | See also ch.1 of his book Philosophy in Classical India [becomes tough but first
part is useful for all]
2/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Indian and Tibetan Philosophy - Richard P. HayesChapter | Navigate to p439
Perception: an essay on classical Indian theories of knowledge - Matilal, Bimal Krishna,1991, c1986
Book | ch.3 ‘The nature of philosophical argument’
On Matilal's Understanding of Indian Philosophy - J. N. Mohanty, 1992Article
Essays on Indian philosophy - Mohanty, J. N., Bilimoria, Purusottama, 2002Book
Reason and tradition in Indian thought: An essay on the nature of Indian philosophicalthinking - Mohanty, J. N., 1992
Book | Introduction etc
Philosophy as Distinct from Religion in India - Charles A. Moore, 1961Article
Text, Commentary, Annotation: Some Reflections on the Philosophical Genre - KarinPreisendanz, 2008
Article
Useful sources for Sanskrit names and terms (1 items)
PHILTAR - Indian Philosophy - Christopher Bartley, 2005Webpage
Useful journals (3 items)
Journal of Indian philosophyJournal
The Journal of the International Association of Buddhist Studies - International Associationof Buddhist Studies
Journal
Philosophy East and West - 1951-Journal
Topic 2: Schools of Indian Philosophy (20 items)
Primary sourcesSee anthologies for
•Śaṃkara ( 8th c Advaita Vedānta, probably South Indian),
3/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
•Rāmānuja (11/12th c Viśiṣṭādvaita Vedānta, South Indian); •Īśvarakṛṣṇa (c.350-450 CE);•Śāntideva (7th/8th c Mahāyāna Buddhist, monk at Nālanda, North India),•Jayanta Bhaṭṭa (9th c Nyāya, in Kashmir)•Vidyāraṇya (14th c. Yoga-Advaita Vedānta)
Key Texts (3 items)
Indian philosophy: an introduction to Hindu and Buddhist thought - King, Richard, 1999Book
Religion, language, and power - Green, Nile, Searle-Chatterjee, Mary, 2008Book | See Suthren Hirst, J.G, 'Who are the others? three moments in Sanskrit-based
discourse', pp. 101-122
Sources of Indian tradition: vol. 1 - Embree, Ainslie Thomas, Hay, Stephen N., De Bary,William Theodore, 1988
Book | ‘Hindu Philosophy’, pp.295-302 for a simple and relatively short overview.
Further reading: classical schools (8 items)
A source book of AdvaitaVedanta - Deutsch, Eliot, Van Buitenen, J. A. B., 1971
Book | [anthology of texts, excellent on triple foundation, very readable on philosophybackground]
The essentials of Indian philosophy - Hiriyanna, M., 1995Book | [useful intros but read with other primary and secondary sources]
A survey of Hinduism - Klostermaier, Klaus K., c1994Book | [has useful summaries of the different darśanas (philosophical schools of
thought) in chs 23-26]
Vedantic approaches to God - Lott, Eric J., 1980Book | [the most useful introduction to Vedānta, with sections in each chapter on
Śaṃkara, Rāmānuja and Madhva]
Buddhism as philosophy: an introduction - Siderits, Mark, 2007Book
Mahayana Buddhism: the doctrinal foundations - Williams, Paul, c2009
Book | [useful for those with no background]
4/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Sri Vaishnava Home PageWebsite | [brief articles on Rāmānuja’s texts amongst others written by scholars, though
a little old-fashioned]
Works of Sankaracharya, Advaita Vedanta and Hindu Sacred ScripturesWebsite | [includes some English translations of parts of Śaṃkara’s texts, but note that
the short works included are often thought to be inauthentic by critical scholars. Those onthe site which are commonly accepted are: Gītā-Bhāṣya, Brahma-Sūtra-Bhāṣya,Upaseśasāhasri (Thousand Teachings)]
Other sources: Modern advaita (4 items)
Primary sources - websites (4 items)
Advaita FellowshipWebsite
What Is Consciousness? www.advaita.org - 23 Dec 2006Audio-visual document
Advaita Vedanta Anusandhana KendraWebsite
Works of Sankaracharya, Advaita Vedanta and Hindu Sacred ScripturesWebsite
Secondary schools for critique (3 items)
Accomplishing the accomplished: the Vedas as a source of valid knowledge inSankara - Rambachan, Anantanand, c1991
Book | [esp Intro and conclusion]
The limits of scripture: Vivekananda's reinterpretation of the Vedas - Rambachan,Anantanand, c1994
Book
'Modern interpretations of Śaṃkara: TMP Mahadevan and Ramaṇa Mahārṣī' - JacquelineSuthren Hirst, 1985
Document | (unpublished paper, 1985 - paper copy available from JSH)
Reference works (2 items)
A history of Indian philosophy: Vol.1 - 1975
5/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Book | NB five volumes in total. [gives historical overview of authors in different schoolsas well as summaries of key teachings. Can be rather hard work, but vols 1 & 2 useful forShankara's school, vol 3 for Ramanuja's]
Encyclopedia of Indian philosophies: Vol.1: Bibliography - Potter, Karl H., AmericanInstitute of Indian Studies, 1995
Book | Multi-volume work. [includes volumes on Nyaya-Vaisesika (vol 2), Samkhya (vol4) and Advaita Vedanta (called Advaita Vedanta up to Samkara and his pupils).Introductions on the development of thought in these schools with primary source extractsfrom works of key authors in translation] Use the bibliographies from these and King for further leads
Topic 3: The Nature of the Person (10 items)
Main primary sourceŚaṃkara’s Thousand Teachings Prose chapter 1 (Three translations available: SwamiJagadananda, S. Mayeda, A.J. Alston plus extract in Śaṃkara anthology)
Key Text (1 items)
A thousand teachings: theUpadesasahasri ofSankara -Sankaracarya, Mayeda, Sengaku, c1992
Book | Chapter 1
Further reading (9 items)
6/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
The Category of the person: anthropology, philosophy, history - Carrithers, Michael,Collins, Steven, Lukes, Steven, 1985
Book
Being Hindu or Being Human: A Reappraisal of the puruṣārthas - Donald R. Davis Jr., 2004Article
Indian Buddhist theories of person: Vasubandhu's refutation of the theory of a self -Duerlinger, James, 2003
Book
Chapter 3: The myth of the ethics of puruṣārtha or humanity’s life-goals’ - Daya KrishnaChapter
Hindu and Buddhist ideas in dialogue: self and no-self - Kuznetsova, Irina, Ganeri,Jonardon, Ram-Prasad, Chakravarthi, 2012
Book
The Fruits of our desiring: an enquiry into the ethics of the Bhagavadgita for our times -Lipner, Julius, Dharam Hinduja Institute of Indic Research (University of Cambridge),Conference of the Dharam Hinduja Institute of Indic Research, 1997
Book | [on the puruṣārthas]
In search of self in India and Japan: toward a cross-cultural psychology - Roland, Alan,c1988
Book
Personal Identity and Buddhist Philosophy - Mark Siderits, November 2003Book | NB not yet in stock
The Buddhist Unconscious: The Alaya-vijñana in the context of Indian Buddhist Thought(Routledge Critical Studies in Buddhism) [Paperback] - William S. Waldron
Book | NB not yet in stock
Topic 4: Reading Indian Philosophical texts (9 items)
Main primary source: 'Now therefore the desire to know Brahman': a rupture with Pūrvamīmāṃsā (Brahma-Sūtra-Bhāṣya 1.1.1, translation by G. Thibaut or Swami Gambhirananda, in Śaṃkara
anthology) http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/sbe34/index.htm
Key Text (1 items)
S
7/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
amkara's AdvaitaVedanta: a way of teaching - Suthren Hirst, Jacqueline, 2005
Book | See CHapter 2
Further reading (8 items)
The structure and meaning ofBadarayana's Brahmasutras: a translation and analysis of adhyaya 1 - Adams, George C., 1993
Book
Theology afterVedanta: an experiment in comparative theology - Clooney, Francis Xavier, c1993
Book | especially chs I.IV-IV
The method of early AdvaitaVedanta: a study ofGaudapada,Sankara,Suresvara, andPadmapada - Comans, Michael, 2000
Book | Postscript and scan for examples
8/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Philosophy in classical India: the proper work of reason - Ganeri, Jonardon, 2001Book
Retrieving the Hidden Meaning: Jain Commentarial Techniques and the Art of Memory -Mari Jyväsjärvi, 2010-3-19
Article | [although this is on Jain material, it is a very useful insight into howcontemporary situations mould approaches to root texts and deals with the problem ofhow interpretation looks very different from the text itself]
Apologetics and Philosophy in Mandana Miśra's Brahmasiddhi - Hugh Nicholson, 2002Article | [This is a long and quite complicated article, but it cleverly shows how positions
– including one's own – may be distorted in order to assert a position and, in this case,disguise Buddhist influence on Advaita, while using an idea derived from the BhāṭṭaPūrvamīṃāṃsaka, Kumārila, on perception, to critique Buddhist, Bhāṭṭas and Vaiśeṣikasalike. You might like to compare this with Qvarnstrom’s milder view on why doxographicalwritings might not put an author’s view as he would.]
Chapter 16: The science of language - Frits StaalChapter
Images of Śaṃkara: Understanding the Other - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst, 2004Article
Topic 5: How do we Know What we Know? (10 items)
Primary source: Nyāya-sūtra 1.1.2-1.1.5. Translated by Michael Williams.
See also Bhaṭṭa Jayanta, Much Ado about Religion, ch.3
Key reading (1 items)
Indian philosophy: an introduction to Hindu and Buddhist thought - King, Richard, 1999Book | ch. 3
Further reading (8 items)
Pramāṇa Are Factive: A Response to Jonardon Ganeri - Matthew Dasti, Stephen H. PhillipsArticle
Philosophy in classical India: the proper work of reason - Ganeri, Jonardon, 2001Book | Ch. 1
Indian logic: a reader - Ganeri, Jonardon, 2001Book
9/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
The concealed art of the soul: theories of self and practices of truth in Indian ethics andepistemology - Ganeri, Jonardon, 2007
Article | Ch. 5
The Study of Indian Epistemology: Questions of Method—A Reply to Matthew Dasti andStephen H. Phillips - Jonardon Ganeri, 2010
Article
Logic, language and reality: an introduction to Indian philosophical studies - Matilal, BimalKrishna, 1990
Book
Perception: an essay on classical Indian theories of knowledge - Matilal, Bimal Krishna,1991, c1986
Book
On what do we rely when we rely on reasoning? - Richard Nance, 2007Article
Topic 6: Creation and Casuality (9 items)
Primary source: The world of name and form (Śaṃkara's Brahma-Sūtra-Bhāṣya 2.1.14)
For translations, see 4. above, or Alston below.
For Rāmānuja's critique of Śaṃkara's position, see his Śrībhāṣya 1.1.1 The GreatSiddhānta, tr G. Thibaut (Vedānta-Sūtras of Bādarāyaṇa with the commentary ofRāmānuja, in JRULM, and on-line at
http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/sbe48/index.htm First adhyāya, First Pada, thewhole section following the brief intro at The Great Siddhānta (The long establishment, i.e.of Rāmānuja's position) http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/sbe48/sbe48025.htm The Truecannot be known by the Untrue, addresses some of Śaṃkara's arguments directly. Thewhole section is designed to refute an Advaitin position.
Key Texts (2 items)
Indian philosophy: an introduction to Hindu and Buddhist thought - King, Richard, 1999Book | Ch. 9
A thousand teachings: theUpadesasa
10/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
hasri ofSankara -Sankaracarya, Mayeda, Sengaku, c1992
Book
Further reading (6 items)
'Samkara on the creation -Sankaracarya, Alston, A. J., 1980
Book
The method of early AdvaitaVedanta: a study ofGaudapada,Sankara,Suresvara, and
11/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Padmapada - Comans, Michael, 2000
Book
Characteristics of Śaṃkara’s Thought - Paul HackerChapter
Reconciling dualism and non-dualism: three arguments in Vijñānabhikṣu’s BhedābhedaVedānta - Andrew J. Nicholson, 2007-8-8
Article
Encyclopedia of Indian philosophies: Vol.3: AdvaitaVedanta up toSamkara and his pupils - Potter, Karl H., 1981
Book | Part 1.4
Samkara's AdvaitaVedanta: a way of teaching - Suthren Hirst, Jacqueline, 2005
Book | Ch. 5 , The context of the teaching
Topic 7: Is there an 'external' World? a dispute with BuddhistOpponents (8 items)
Primary sources and explanation
Śaṃkara's Brahma-Sūtra-Bhāṣya 2.2.28-31, given in A.J. Alston Śaṃkara on Rival Views(London: Shanti Sadan, ), pp.276-87 and the rest of chapter 11.5 [difficult but persist atleast with introduction]
For on-line source, see 4 above
See also Udayana (a Nyāya thinker, ? late 11th c AD) Ātmatattvaviveka (Discriminating the
12/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
reality of the self) in ed Karl Potter, Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies: the tradition ofNyāya-Vaiśeṣika up to Gaṅgeśa, 29, pp.526-546 esp paras 74-75
Key Texts (2 items)
Dreams and Reality: The Śaṅkarite Critique of Vijñānavada - Chakravarthi Ram Prasad,1993
Article | Requires Central username and password for off campus access
Advaita epistemology and metaphysics: an outline of Indian non-realism - Ram-Prasad,Chakravarthi, 2001
Book | Section 1, chapters 2-3
Further reading (5 items)
Śankara and the Buddhists - Shlomo Biderman, 1978-12Article
Śaṁkara's Arguments against the Buddhists - Daniel H. H. Ingalls, 1954Article
On being and what there is: classicalVaisesika and the history of Indian ontology - Halbfass, Wilhelm, c1992
Book | [for those who really love ontology!]
Early AdvaitaVedanta and Buddhism: theMahayana context of theGaudapadiya-karika - King, Richard,Gaud
13/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
apadaAcarya, c1995
Book | Ch. 3
Indian philosophy: an introduction to Hindu and Buddhist thought - King, Richard, 1999Book | Chapters 5 and 7
Topic 8: Consciousness and the Body (4 items)
Key Text (1 items)
Indian philosophy: an introduction to Hindu and Buddhist thought - King, Richard, 1999Book | chapter 8 [and follow up particular schools from his refs]
Primary sources and Further reading (3 items)
For Sāṃkhya: For Śaṃkara’s Advaita: (2 items)
Samkara on the soul -Sankaracarya, Alston, A. J., c1981
Book | [Part of an excellent introductory series. Each chapter contains a lucidintroduction to Shankara's thought, followed by selections of texts to illustrate the points.Unfortunately, the layout of the books is chronic, but worth persevering with for content.NB The last footnote at the end of an extract will give you the reference for the abstract]
14/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Some useful passages from Śaṃkara:
Bṛhadāraṇyaka-Upaniṣad-Bhāṣya 2.4.12 (Alston, VIII.1, p.10-12, ref in footnote 29, p.79)
Upadeśasāhasrī (Thousand Teachings) Prose chapter 1.64-74 (Alston, VIII.1, pp.12-14, refin footnote 33, p.80) [Jagadananda tr available on line at http://shankaracharya.org/upadesa_sahasri.php ]
Praśna Upaniṣad 4.8 (Alston, VIII.1, pp.15-16, ref in footnote 38, p.80) [on reflectionanalogy]
Upadeśasāhasrī (Thousand Teachings) Metric chapter 18.32-50 (Alston, VIII.1, ref infootnote 44, p.80)
For Rāmānuja on consciousness: (1 items)
Śrībhāṣya 1.1.1 The Great Siddhānta, tr G. Thibaut (Vedānta-Sūtras of Bādarāyaṇa withthe commentary of Rāmānuja, in Main Library, and on-line at
http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/sbe48/index.htm First adhyāya, First Pada, the wholesection following the brief intro at The Great Siddhānta (The long establishment, i.e. ofRāmānuja's position), especially sections on consciousness
See also Śāntideva extract provided etc
Further reading[You will need to select your focus. Ask JSH if you need more help]
Topic 9: The Nature of Liberation (14 items)
Primary sources (3 items)
Primary sources:
The path to liberation (Rāmānuja's Vedārthasaṃgraha 126, in anthology)
A
15/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Samkara source-book: Vol. 6:Samkara on enlightenment ; [translated] by A.J. Alston -Sankaracarya, Alston, A. J., 1989
Book | esp ch. XVI.1,2 and 4
Vidyāraṇya on liberation:
See also Īśvarakṛṣṇa (Sāṃkhya) and Śāntideva (Mahāyāna Buddhist) extracts
Key Texts (11 items)
Encyclopedia of Indian philosophies: Vol.11: AdvaitaVedanta from 800 to 1200 - Potter, Karl H., 2006
Book | Section 1.2.II Liberation in Advaita and 1.2.III, pp..32-44
Knowledge and liberation in classical Indian thought - Ram-Prasad, Chakravarthi, 2001Book
Further reading (9 items)
Desire and motivation in Indian philosophy - Framarin, Christopher G., 2008Book
The Problem with Pretending: Rāmānuja’s Arguments Against Jīvanmukti - ChristopherFramarin, 2008-9-30
Article
Jivanmukti in transformation: embodied liberation in Advaita and neo-Vedanta - Fort,Andrew O., c1998
Book
16/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
The face of truth: a study of meaning and metaphysics in theVedantic theology ofRamanuja - Lipner, Julius, 1986
Book | esp. chs. 3-6 [on Rāmānuja]
Vedantic approaches to God - Lott, Eric J., 1980Book
Self-surrender (prapatti) to God inSrivaisnavism: Tamil cats and Sanskrit monkeys - Raman, Srilata, 2007
Book
Knowledge and Action I: Means to the Human End in Bhātta Mīmāmsā and AdvaitaVedānta - C. Ram-Prasad, 2000
Article
Samkara's AdvaitaVedanta: a way of teaching - Suthren Hirst, Jacqueline, 2005
Book | chapter 8 [and whole book for context, especially chapter 2]
Gradual and Sudden Enlightenment: The Attainment of Yogipratyakṣa in the Later IndianYogācāra School - Jeson Woo, 2008-12-11
Article
Topic 10: The Nature of Language (5 items)
17/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Primary sources: Śaṃkara Bṛhadāraṅyaka Upaniṣad Bhāṣya 2.3.6, tr SwamiMadhavananda; Śaṃkara Taittirīya Upaniṣad Bhāṣya 2.1.1, tr Swami Gambhirananda, inEight Upaniṣads, vol II (in anthology)
See also Rāmānuja anthology
Key Texts (1 items)
Samkara's AdvaitaVedanta: a way of teaching - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst, 2005
Book | Chapter 7
Further reading (3 items)
The face of truth: a study of meaning and metaphysics in theVedantic theology ofRamanuja - Lipner, Julius, 1986
Book | esp ch.1 Language and Meaning
Encyclopedia of Indian philosophies: Vol.5: The philosophy of the Grammarians - Coward,Harold G., Kunjunni Raja, K., 1990
Book | Maṇḍana Miśra Sphoṭasiddhi (The Proof of sphoṭa – see glossary) ch. 9, pp.181-191 [for those who like linguistics]
The Brahman and the Word Principle (Śabda) - Sthaneshwar Timalsina, 2009-4-1Article
Topic 11: Does God Exist? comparisons with Nyaya (18 items)
Primary sources:
18/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Jayanta Bhaṭṭa Nyāyamañjarī English summary and commentary in ed Karl PotterEncyclopedia of Indian Philosophies: the tradition of Nyāya-Vaiśeṣika up to Gaṅgeśa,16 pp. 341-343. Text, pp. 343-394, esp paras 125f (Existence of God), pp.371f.
OR
Much ado about religion - JayantaBhatta,Dezso, Csaba, 2005
Book | available in various downloads athttp://www.claysanskritlibrary.org/Much-Ado-About-Religion-v-11.html,date last accessed14 Jan 2008
OR
Encyclopedia of Indian philosophies: the tradition ofNyaya-Vaisesika up toGangesa, Vol.2: Indian metaphysics and epistemology - Potter, Karl H., 1977
Book | Udayana (11th c Nyāya) Nyāyakusumāñjalī English summary pp.557-588
Key Texts (2 items)
Indian philosophy of religion - Perrett, Roy W., 1989Book | See Chakrabarti, A, 'From the fabric to the weaver', pp. 21-34
A survey of Hinduism - Klostermaier, Klaus K., c1994Book | Chapter 26 Hindu Theology, old and new: Purva Mimamsa and Vedanta, esp.
p367 and n.7 and pp.373-377 [Note page nos. may differ in this new ed.]
Further reading (11 items)
Development ofNyaya philosophy and its social context - Bhattacharyya, Sibajiban, Project of History of IndianScience, Philosophy, and Culture, Centre for Studies in Civilizations (Delhi, India), 2004
Book | [for background on different Nyāya thinkers, esp 2.4 on Udayana]
19/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
What Is the "Subaltern" of the Comparative Philosophy of Religion? - PurushottamaBilimoria, 2003
Article | pp.340-66, esp pp.352-53 for reasons why comparisons with Udayana becamepopular
Indian philosophy of religion - Perrett, Roy W., 1989Book | Hermann, AL 'Religions as Failed Theodicies: Atheism in Hinduism and Buddhism'
[use with caution. Check against Potter of King]
The Design Argument in Classical Hindu Thought - C. Mackenzie Brown, 2008Article | [extensive section on Udayana’s arguments and Rāmānuja’s
counter-arguments. Also on Śaṃkara but treat what he says with care.]
New perspectives on advaitaVedanta: essays in commemoration of Professor Richard de Smet - Smet, Richard V. de,Malkovsky, Bradley J., 2000
Book | Malkovsky, B.J. ‘Śaṃkara and Divine Grace’, pp.70-83
OR
The role of divine grace in the soteriology ofSamkaracarya - Malkovsky, Bradley J., 2001
Book
Against a Hindu god: Buddhist philosophy of religion in India - Patil, Parimal G., c2009Book
Presuppositions of India's philosophies - Potter, Karl H., 1991Book | [on forms of argument/proof]
A Hindu perspective on the philosophy of religion - Sharma, Arvind, 1990Book | p.2f [NB Beware: he puts Udayana’s arguments in a more Western user friendly
way than Karl Potter]
Samkara's AdvaitaVeda
20/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
nta: a way of teaching - Suthren Hirst, Jacqueline, 2005Book | chapter 6
Topic 12: Can Philosophy be Indian? [See also Topic 1] (4 items)
See also Topic 1
Key Text (1 items)
Indian philosophy: an introduction to Hindu and Buddhist thought - King, Richard, 1999Book | chapter 2
Further reading (2 items)
Philosophy in classical India: the proper work of reason - Ganeri, Jonardon, 2001Book | Introduction and ch. 1 [and the rest of the book for those who like mathematical
logic and formal philosophy]
India and Europe: an essay in philosophical understanding - Halbfass, Wilhelm, 1990Book | ch. 15 ‘Darśana, Ānvīkṣikī, Philosophy’; ch.16 ‘The adoption of the concept of
philosophy in modern Hinduism’
Primary Sources: published anthologies (3 items)
Indian religions: a historical reader of spiritual expression and experience - Heehs, Peter,c2002
Book | [not all on ‘philosophy’ but has useful extracts with helpful short introductions]
Encyclopedia of Indian philosophies: Vol.1: Bibliography - Potter, Karl H., AmericanInstitute of Indian Studies, 1995
Book | Vols 2 - 12 are available at Blue,Floor 3: 109.54/E1[see above: strictly not theprimary sources themselves but contain very detailed summaries of many texts]
A Source book in Indian philosophy - Radhakrishnan, S., Moore, Charles Alexander, c1957Book | [contains introductions and selections of texts from Vedic and Epic periods and
from the heterodox (nāstika) and orthodox (āstika) schools, including extracts from thedifferent Vedāntins, Śaṃkara, Rāmānuja and Madhva]
School-specific primary sources (43 items)
Buddhist (4 items)
Nāgārjuna (2nd c CE Mahāyāna key teacher of Madhyamika) (1 items)
21/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
The fundamental wisdom of the middle way:Nagarjuna'sMulamadhyamakakarika -Nagarjuna, Garfield, Jay L., 1995
Book
Vasubandhu (4th c Mahāyāna joint key teacher of Yogācāra =Cittamātra school, called Vijñānavāda by Advaitins) (1 items)
Seven works of Vasubandhu, the Buddhist psychological doctor - Vasubandhu, Anacker,Stefan, 1984
Book | [extracts from Vasubandhu, useful as background for Topic 7 in particular]
Śāntideva (sometime between 685 and 763 CE; Mahāyāna Buddhistmonk) (2 items)
The Bodhicaryavatara -Santideva, Crosby, Kate, Skilton, Andrew, Williams, Paul, 1995
Book | esp ch. 9 The Perfection of Understanding will be provided [but text needs to beread as whole to see how it works. Useful intro to Mahāyāna and on Topic 4 method, buthas things to say on almost all our topics]
TheBodhicaryavatara -Sa
22/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
ntideva, Crosby, Kate, Skilton, Andrew, 1998
Book | esp ch. 9 The Perfection of Understanding will be provided [but text needs to beread as whole to see how it works. Useful intro to Mahāyāna and on Topic 4 method, buthas things to say on almost all our topics]
Nyāya (7 items)
Jayanta Bhaṭṭa (9th c CE Naiyāyika from Kashmir) (7 items)
Much ado about religion - JayantaBhatta,Dezso, Csaba, 2005
Book | [extract from chapter 3 Religion Denied and Defended to be supplied] [anextensive introduction to this ‘philosophical play’ can be found on line athttp://www.claysanskritlibrary.org/volume.php?id=11 > Download extras, date lastaccessed 28 Jan 2008] [useful for Topic 4 on method, social contexts of philosophicalideas, Topics 11, 5 and others]
Encyclopedia of Indian philosophies: the tradition ofNyaya-Vaisesika up toGangesa, Vol.2: Indian metaphysics and epistemology - Potter, Karl H., 1977
Book | Bhattacharya, Janakivallabha and Karl H Potter, summary of Nyāyamañjarī,pp.341-394 [extract supplied, useful for Topic 11]
Philosophy in classical India: the proper work of reason - Ganeri, Jonardon, 2001Book | chapter 1
Indian logic: a reader - Ganeri, Jonardon, 2000Book
Logic, language and reality: an introduction to Indian philosophical studies - Matilal, BimalKrishna, 1990
Book | Introduction and chapter 2
23/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Perception: an essay on classical Indian theories of knowledge - Matilal, Bimal Krishna,1991, c1986
Book
Williams, M. Translation Nyāya-sūtra 1.1.2-1.1.5. (Will be provided prior to Topic 5)
Sāṃkhya (4 items)
Iśvarakṛṣṇa (c.350-450CE) (4 items)
Sources of Indian tradition - De Bary, William Theodore, 1958Book | The Sānkhya Kārikās, extracts supplied. pp.303-310 [useful for Topics 6, 8, 9
and others]
Best secondary source intro:
ClassicalSamkhya: an interpretation of its history and meaning - Larson, Gerald James, 1969
Book | [either ed]
ClassicalSamkhya - Larson, Gerald James,Isvarakrsna, 1979
Book | [either ed]
Vedānta: Advaita (20 items)
Shankara/Sankara Acharya/Śaṃkara (c.700CE) (variously transliteratedinto English) (also see Alston books below) (20 items)
A source book of AdvaitaVedanta - Deutsch, Eliot, Van Buitenen, J. A. B., 1971
Book | [anthology of key texts]
24/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Upadeśasāhasrī (6 items)
The prose section (Gadya-Bandha) provides an excellent easyish introduction to Śaṃkara [in anthol, useful for Topic 4 Method, Topics 3, 8 and others]
Upadeshasahasri of Sri Sankaracharya - JAGADANANDA, Swami, 1961Book | [though older, probably more reliable in many instances]
OR
A thousand teachings: theUpadesasahasri ofSankara -Sankaracarya, Mayeda, Sengaku, c1992
Book | [contains excellent readable introduction to Śaṃkara's thought]
OR
The thousand teachings (upadesasahasri) ofSri
Sa°m
25/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
karacarya -Sankaracarya, Alston, A. J., 1990
Book
Brahma-sūtra-bhāṣya (BSBh) (6 items)(commentary on Brahma-Sūtras = Vedānta-Sūtras) (1.1.1-1.1.4 introduce many ofŚaṃkara’s key ideas) [extracts from 1.1.1 only provided: Topic 4, Topic 9, 5, 6 and others; 1.1.4 provided: Topic 42.1.11 provided: Topic 52.1.14 provided: Topic 4, 6, 72.2.28-31 provided: TA, Topic 7, 3, 8 and others4.1.2 provided: Topic 10, 9, 3]
TheVedanta-sutras -Sankaracarya, Thibaut, G., 1962
Book | (2 vols, Oxford: Clarendon, 1890 or reprints) [standard transln, though his introis now thought misleading in many respects]
TheVedanta-su
26/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
tras -Sankaracarya, Thibaut, G., 1962
Book | (2 vols, Oxford: Clarendon, 1890 or reprints) [standard transln, though his introis now thought misleading in many respects]
TheVedanta-sutras: With the commentary bySankarakarya - Thibaut, G.,Sankaracarya, 1890
Book | (2 vols, Oxford: Clarendon, 1890 or reprints) [standard transln, though his introis now thought misleading in many respects]
TheVedanta-sutras: With the commentary bySankarakarya - Thibaut, G.,San
27/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
karacarya, 1896
Book | (2 vols, Oxford: Clarendon, 1890 or reprints) [standard transln, though his introis now thought misleading in many respects]
OR
Brahma-sut -Sankaracarya,Gambhirananda, 1993
Book | [easier layout and translation in many respects. Includes the sūtras in Sanskrit,transliterated]
Śaṃkara’s Upaniṣad commentaries (6 items)
Eight Upanishads: Vol.1:(Isa, Kena, Katha andTaittiriya) -Sankaraca
28/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
rya,Gambhirananda, 1957
Book
Eight Upanishads: Vol.2: (Aitareya, Mundaka,Mandukya andKarika, andPrasna) -Sankaracarya,Gambhirananda, 1958
Book
EightUpanisads -Sankaraca
29/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
rya,Gambhirananda, Ramakrishna Vedanta Centre, 1989
Book
EightUpanisads -Sankaracarya,Gambhirananda, Ramakrishna Vedanta Centre, 1989
Book
TheB.rhadara.nyaka Upani.sad: with the commentary ofSankaracarya -Sankaracarya,Ma
30/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
dhavananda, 1950
Book
[extracts from Īśa Upaniṣad commentary, Taittirīya Upaniṣad commentary and Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad commentary provided in Śaṃkara anthology. Useful for Topic 4Method, Topic 5, 10, 11 and others]
Bhagavadgītā commentary (GBh) (1 items)
Brahma-sutras:Sri-bhasya : with text, English rendering, comments according to Sri-Bhasya of Sri Ramanuja, andindex -Ramanuja, Vireswarananda,Adidevananda,Swami, 1978
Book
Vedānta: Viśiṣṭādvaita (8 items)
Rāmānuja (8 items)
Śrībhāṣya (ŚBh) (4 items)(R's commentary on the Brahma-sūtras=Vedānta-Sūtras) * ŚBh 1.1.1 has a long outline of
31/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
Advaitin arguments (Mahāpūrvapakṣa) and then a long establishment of Rāmānuja’sViśiṣṭādvaita view (Mahāsiddhānta) [TA: useful for Topic 4 Method, 6,7,8, 10 and others]
Brief extracts in Rāmānuja anthology but for TA get at least Radhakrishnan and Moore
A Source book in Indian philosophy - Radhakrishnan, S., Moore, Charles Alexander, c1957Book | Excerpts in *Radhakrishnan & Moore, see Anthologies above
OR
TheVedanta-sutras: With the commentary ofRamanuga - Thibaut, G.,Ramanuja, 1904
Book
Vedārthasaṃgraha (VS) (3 items)(R's summary of the meaning of the Upaniṣads) Short. Read it! [extracts in Rāmānujaanthology useful for Topic 9, 10, 11 etc]
Ved?rthasamgraha ofSri R?m?nuj?c?rya -Ramanuja,Sudarsana
32/33
04/25/18 RELT30062 Indian Philosophy - Jacqueline Suthren Hirst | The University of
Manchester
carya, Raghavachar, S. S., 1956
Book
OR
Ramanuja'svedarthasamgraha -Ramanuja, Van Buitenen, J. A. B., 1956
Book
Gītā commentary (1 items)
Ramanuja on theBhagavadgita: a condensed rendering of hisGitabhasya -Ramanuja, Van Buitenen, J. A. B., 1968
Book
33/33