report on capacity building workshop - wordpress.com€¦ · the capsem project is designed to...
TRANSCRIPT
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 1
REPORT ON CAPACITY BUILDING WORKSHOP
11 and 12 September, 2017, IIT Bombay, Mumbai
12 November, 2017, Prof Shyam R Asolekar
This report serves as a summary of the first year capacity building workshop Deliverable 3.1
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 2
Table of Contents
1) Introduction
2) The Design and Contents of the Programme
3) Articulation of the Stakeholder Perspective
4) The Field Visit to the Pilot-Scale Constructed Wetland
5) Poster Session
6) Suggestions from the Participants on Future Capacity Building Workshop
7) Selected Photographs from the Capacity Building Workshop
8) Appendix 1 – Schedule of the Programme
9) Appendix 2 – List of the Participants
10) Appendix 3 – Proforma of the Evaluation of Speakers (Day 1)
11) Appendix 4 – Proforma of the Evaluation of Speakers (Day 2)
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 3
INTRODUCTION
Indian Institute of Technology Bombay (IITB), a partner institution in the on-going
collaborative project entitled “Capacity Building in Sustainability and Environmental
Management” (CapSEM) - which is funded by Erasmus+ Programme of the European
Union; organized a two-day international capacity building programme entitled:
“Enhancement of Environmental Sustainability: The New Horizon of Circular Economy &
Organizational Improvement”. This programme was designed and delivered in
association with Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway,
IN+ Center for Innovation, Technology and Policy Research, Instituto Superior Técnico,
University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal, Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Mumbai,
Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu and Kathmandu University, Kathmandu, Nepal. This
two-day international capacity building programme was conducted on the campus of
IITB for the selected key industry personnel, environmental regulators, government
administrators, international experts as well as consulting engineers engaged in real-life
projects (designing and implementation) from India.
The CapSEM project is designed to contribute in achieving global frameworks for
sustainable development, including the UN Sustainable Development Goals and the
UNFCCC Climate Agreement and help to combat climate change and global poverty
from a transregional perspective. This project desires to forge ahead with a multi-actor
collaborative partnerships aimed at the increased educational capacity and
sustainability knowledge around the Globe.
THE DESIGN AND CONTENTS OF THE PROGRAMME
The two-day international capacity building programme was inaugurated at the Victor
Menezes Convention Centre in Powai, a Suburb of the City of the Mumbai, at the hands
of Dr. P. Anbalagan (Member Secretary of Maharashtra Pollution Control Board,
Mumbai), Prof. Dr. Ing. Annik Magerholm Fet (Department of Industrial Economics and
Technology Management, Norwegian University of Science and Technology,
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 4
Trondheim, Norway) and Prof Sanjeev Choudhari (Head of Centre for Environmental
Science and Engineering, IITB).
The detailed schedule of the two-day international capacity building programme has
been appended in „Appendix 1‟.
The overall technical deliberations were divided in six sessions. In addition to the 18
technical presentations made by the subject experts, the participation of the delegates
was invoked through group discussions, panel debates, the plenary presentations by
the break-away groups as well as field visit. The design and contents of the two-day
international capacity building programme was aimed at capacity building, stakeholder
participation and highlighting the significance of incorporation of the theory and
practices of circular economy and preventive environmental management.
Four delegates from Europe, five delegates from Nepal and four delegates from TISS,
Mumbai (all program country-partners) were the resource persons for the two-day
international capacity building programme. Also, in all 20 persons (graduate students,
researchers and faculty members) participated from Centre for Environmental Science
and Engineering, IITB. In addition, 6 researchers from IIT Roorkee, IIT Madras and
National Institute of Industrial Engineering participated in the programme.
The list of participants attending the two-day international capacity building programme
has been appended in „Appendix 2‟.
Composition of the Participants in the Training Programme:
5 Faculty members and 15 Graduate students and researchers from CESE, IITB
1 Faculty member and 3 researchers from TISS, Mumbai
6 Researchers from IIT Madras, IIT Roorkee and NITIE
4 Faculty members from Europe
5 Faculty members from Nepal
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 5
5 Participants from Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM)
4 Participants from regulatory agency (Maharashtra Pollution Control Board)
19 Participants from industry and consultancy firms
The Pie-chart depicting the composition of participants
The bound volume of the “Lecture Notes” entitled: Enhancement of Environmental
Sustainability: The New Horizon of Circular Economy & Organizational Improvement
was released at the hands of Prof. Dr. Ing. Annik Magerholm Fet in the inauguration
session and the copies were distributed to all the participants in the capacity building
programme. The bound volume included the presentations of the speakers in the
training programme as well as the literature reviews on the salient topics including
preventive environmental management, the theory and practice of circular economy.
The volume also included the recent literature on natural treatment systems,
wastewater management, solid waste management, energy management and
Faculty (15)
Students (24)
Municipality (5)
Regulatory (4)
Industry (19)
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 6
organizational improvements and business strategies from the circular economy
perspective.
ARTICULATION OF THE STAKEHOLDER PERSPECTIVE
The stakeholder perspective was articulated by conducting group discussion among the
four break-away groups consisting of nearly 15 participants each. Each group elected
two representatives for making presentations at the plenary for the benefit of the entire
audience. The participants articulated their group‟s opinion (in a format prescribed to
them) at the end of one-hour group discussion in the respective break-away groups.
Representatives from each group making presentations
The two designated representatives from each group presented the drivers and
obstacles for application of the so-called “eco-friendly technologies and waste
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 7
minimization practices in industries and municipalities in India” at the plenary. The
highlights of the conclusions articulated by the four groups, as presented by their
representatives at the plenary, have been summarized as follows:
Strategies for Industry:
Drivers Obstacles
The demands from consumers, investors
and various stakeholders are different.
Hence, minimize the waste generation
which ultimately reduces the operating
cost to company (otherwise used for
waste treatment). Resource recovery
from waste can lead to reduced cost of
raw materials or be an additional source of
income. Looking at the waste as a
resource leads the industry towards
sustainability.
No or very little incentives are given by the
government. Even if they are available, it
is difficult to obtain them. Lack of
incentives is an obstacle. By providing
incentives, it can act as driver towards
waste minimization or adopting eco-
friendly techniques. People are not
reliable on the newer technologies due to
fear of technical failure. Additionally,
adapting to new technology would require
trained manpower, new setup, land etc.
CETP not working or closed by the
government. The competition between
similar industries for the demonstration of
technology leads to image building among
stakeholder.
It becomes unaffordable to provide low
cost products while abiding with the
stringent environmental standards which
require costly treatment technologies.
Man power is required for operation and
maintenance of installed facility. Also,
cost increases with treatment process.
The detailed cost analysis data is not
available.
Customer demands certain environmental
standards to be met (certification).
Decision of the process pathway is made
while putting up an industry and least
thought is given to waste management or
treatment. When the problem arises, it
becomes difficult to make changes in an
already working plant. Up-gradation of
existing systems as demanded by
stringent standards is a challenge with
limited land.
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 8
Drivers Obstacles
Stringent environmental standards are
given by the regulatory framework. Each
industry follows these government
regulations and compliance.
Implementation of laws is not strict and
the penalties are affordable as compared
to other countries where the owner of the
company is jailed and not the operator in
case of a breach. There is a
communication gap between industry and
regulators. Environmental awareness at
all levels from decision makers to plant
operators should be developed. Lack of
awareness exists with respect to risks,
benefits, social, environmental and
economic impacts. Public participation in
purchasing eco-friendly products and
minimizing waste to conserve natural
resources versus culture of use and throw
and not in my backyard. The way citizen‟s
act can be a driver or obstacle.
New concept of industrial ecosystems
coming up with potential use of waste
from one industry as a resource in other
industry.
Sufficient market needs to be made
available for recycled products which
should lead to profitable recovery.
Strategies for Municipality:
Drivers Obstacles
Reduction in use of water and using
appropriate technologies which further this
cause will lead to reduced water bills
(along with resource conservation). Water
bills will be reduced if grey water is
recycled in a decentralized manner.
People will not contaminate surface
waters if they are taught that it comes
Lack of awareness among the community
and society‟s attitude. The cost of
resources in developing countries is very
low which does not generate enough
funds for treatment after use. For a
private player, the profits may be much
less in implementing eco-friendly
technology as compared to a conventional
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 9
Drivers Obstacles
back to them which lead to diseases. They
will then try to not pollute the water and
get good quality water.
treatment technology. Long-term health
impacts are more harmful rather than short-
term impacts. Also, there is a mismatch
between regulations and ground reality
due to theft and leakage in old pipes,
improperly engineered supply and
sewerage systems. Additionally, delay in
completing projects increases the cost of
projects. Furthermore, the cost of
restoring degraded natural systems is very
high.
People won‟t throw garbage on the roads
to get clean surroundings which are
aesthetically pleasing and disease free
which will lead to improved health
conditions and increase cost of property.
Furthermore, clean and well maintained
cities attract businesses and tourists.
Compliance to environmental standards
leads to adaptation to permissible limits.
Aesthetics or cultural beliefs hinder the
setting up of treatment plants in the cities
or in/near residential areas. Monitoring is
not done properly. There exists a lack of
public participation and coordination.
Existing scarce nature of resources
demands better management at various
stages of its use phase. The incentives
should be given in order to encourage the
community to participate.
The regulating authorities have limited
organizational man power which leads
more time for the various types of
clearance required from different
authorities for implementation. Large area
of land requirement increases the financial
burden on the projects. Social
acceptance is less as everyone thinks
neighborhood should accept the
technology.
Demand from the public and NGOs is
rising day by day as the environmental
awareness is increasing. Life cycle cost is
reduced by implementing eco-friendly
technologies. Being committed to
protecting natural habitats and reducing
In order to understand the clearer picture
of the problem, significant statistical data
is required which is lacking at most of the
sites. Lack of skilled labors causes the
failure of the treatment system. The
clarity is missing in the standards and
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 10
Drivers Obstacles
impact of urbanization over existing
ecosystems, these low cost technologies
seems to better as they are simple to
operate methods and reduces skilled
labors. Useful end products are obtained
such as biogas etc. Moreover, they are
highly reliable and flexible and therefore,
can be adopted with more efficiency.
Cradle to cradle approach can lead to
improved resource consumption.
regulatory documents.
THE FIELD VISIT TO THE PILOT-SCALE CONSTRUCTED WETLAND
The field visit to pilot-scale Constructed Wetland (CW) at IIT Bombay Campus was
arranged during the evening of the first day of workshop. The participants enjoyed the
beautiful green campus and the scenic beauty of the Powai Lake while walking to the
treatment facility (Research Station) situated on the edge of the Lake at nearly 1.5 km
distance.
The pilot-scale CW facility has dimensions of 13 m length, 3 m width and 0.6 m depth.
The Canna indica plants are used for the vegetation over the media (approximately 450
square feet plan area, nearly 1,000 Canna indica plants). This treatment facility was
commissioned in November 2013.
The facility is situated adjoining the sewage pumping station - which receives the
wastewater of the entire IITB campus and pumps it to the underground trunk-sewer
outside the property of IITB. The pilot-scale CW facility is fed through the tapping on
the pressurized wastewater pipeline (rising main) which is pumping to the trunk-sewer.
In the pilot-scale CW, the inlet wastewater is maintained few inches below the surface
of the media and thereby the problems of odour, mosquitoes and other vectors are
nearly eliminated.
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 11
The pilot-scale horizontal sub-surface flow constructed wetland at IIT Bombay Campus
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 12
The participants at the site of pilot-scale horizontal sub-surface flow constructed wetland
POSTER SESSION
The posters describing the results from the on-going research projects at IITB were
displayed in the foyer at the venue (Victor Menezes Convention Centre on IITB
Campus) of the two-day international capacity building programme by the researchers
participating from the Centre for Environmental Science and Engineering in the
programme.
The topics related to circular economy and sustainable development were presented in
the posters installed at the display. For example, the findings from the on-going
research and development activities at IITB in the Research Group of Prof Asolekar
included strategies for catalysing rural development and women empowerment through
implementing eco-centric technologies aimed at gainful utilization of treated domestic
wastewaters, empowerment of leprosy patients through implementing eco-centric
technology aimed at gainful recycling of treated sewages, recycling of treated sewages
at pilgrimage places, innovative management of asbestos bearing hazardous wastes
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 13
and disposal of old stockpile of dumped municipal solid wastes through the innovative
approach of landfill mining for recovery of energy from combustible fractions of the
wastes and preparing construction materials by using reclaimed inerts.
The participants and guest speakers viewing the posters during the session breaks
SUGGESTIONS FROM THE PARTICIPANTS ON FUTURE CAPACITY BUILDING WORKSHOP
Each participant in the two-day international capacity building programme evaluated the
presentations made during the programme by the experts drawn from the academia,
government and industry. The participants were given the prescribed tabular format for
recording their ratings of each presentation in every technical session of the two-day
programme. Accordingly, the anonymous evaluation forms were collected at the end of
the programme and reviewed.
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 14
The prescribed formats for recording the evaluation of speakers at the two-day
international capacity building programme have been appended in „Appendixes 3 and
4‟.
In one of the questions, the participants were requested to make the specific
suggestions on “future focus areas” for conducting capacity building programmes. The
list of topics proposed by the participants for conducting the future capacity building
workshops is shown below:
1) Technologies for achieving the so-called zero liquid discharge (ZLD) from
municipality and industry (focuses on circular economy, technical and financial
evaluation of the treatment strategies, management issues)
2) Technologies for rain water harvesting and management of harvested and recycled
wastewaters (focus on urban and rural community projects, technical and financial
evaluation of the decentralized projects, management issues)
3) Innovations versus practices in treatment and reuse of municipal and industrial
wastewaters
4) Innovations versus practices in treatment of municipal solid wastes
5) Rejuvenation of urban lakes and rivers stretches
6) Management of sanitation and drinking water (urban informal and congested
habitats as well as for rural India)
7) Industry ecology, eco-industrial networks and preventive environmental
management (case studies to compare and contrast the Indian and the international
experiences)
8) Case studies in environmental sustainability (compare and contrast the Indian and
the international experiences)
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 15
9) Future of the Indian industry in the context of Indian and international environmental
regulations
10) Management of municipal solid wastes and industrial hazardous, biomedical wastes
and e-wastes
11) Waste to energy, power generation from municipal solid wastes
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 16
SELECTED PHOTOGRAPHS FROM THE CAPACITY BUILDING WORKSHOP (1/2)
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 17
SELECTED PHOTOGRAPHS FROM THE CAPACITY BUILDING WORKSHOP (2/2)
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 18
APPENDIX 1 – SCHEDULE OF THE PROGRAMME
TWO-DAY INTERNATIONAL CAPACITY BUILDING PROGRAMME
ENHANCEMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY:
THE NEW HORIZON OF CIRCULAR ECONOMY & ORGANIZATIONAL IMPROVEMENT
Co-funded by the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay
Venue: Victor Menezes Convention Centre
Room No. 3, Ground Floor
IIT Bombay Campus,
Powai, Mumbai 400076, INDIA
Dates:
11th & 12th September, 2017
(Monday & Tuesday)
ORGANISED BY:
INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY BOMBAY CENTRE FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & ENGINEERING
IN ASSOCIATION WITH:
NORWEGIAN UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, TRONDHEIM, NORWAY
UNIVERSITY OF LISBON, LISBON, PORTUGAL
TATA INSTITUTE OF SOCIAL SCIENCES, MUMBAI
TRIBHUVAN UNIVERSITY, KATHMANDU, NEPAL
KATHMANDU UNIVERSITY, KATHMANDU, NEPAL
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 19
Monday, 11th September, 2017 DAY ONE
08:30 – 09:00 Registration and Tea/Coffee
09:00 – 09:10 Welcome and Introduction to the Workshop
Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar (about 5 min) Coordinator of the two-Day Programme Centre for Environmental Science & Engineering (CESE) Indian Institute of Technology Bombay
Round of Introduction (about 5 min) Participants
09:10 – 10:00 Environmental Management in India‟s Industries & Municipalities: Achievements and the Imminent Challenges
Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar CESE, IIT Bombay
10:00 – 10:15 What are the priority areas in “Environmental Management” in your sector?
Survey based on the individual‟s perspective (mode: questionnaire filling by the participants) Facilitators: PhD Scholars, IITB
10:15 – 11:15 Inauguration Ceremony
Prof. Sanjeev Chaudhari, Head (about 5 min)
Centre for Environmental Science & Engineering (CESE) Indian Institute of Technology Bombay Prof. Petety V. Balaji (about 10 min) Dean R&D, IIT Bombay
Dr. P. Anbalagan IAS (about 15 min)
Member Secreatry Maharashtra Pollution Control Board, Mumbai
Plenary Lecture by: Prof. Dr.Ing. Annik Magerholm Fet (about 30 min)
Department of Industrial Economics and Technology Management (IØT) Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU) N-7491 Trondheim, Norway Title: Sustainable Development Goals as the Direction to Meet the Local Challenges
11:15 – 11:45 Tea/Coffee
11:45 – 12:45 Implementing competitive sustainability strategies in companies followed by Q/A session
Haley Knudson and Prof. Annik Magerholm Fet, IØT, NTNU
12:45 – 13:15 Use of Constructed Wetlands and other Natural Treatment Systems
Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 20
for Treatment and Reuse of Domestic Wastewaters in India: Highlights of National Survey and Lessons from the Experiences
CESE, IIT Bombay
13:15 – 14:00 Lunch
14:00 – 15:00 Sustainability in the Value Chain Perspective: Upstream and Downstream Challenges in Waste Management followed by Q/A session
Prof. Fernanda Magarido Center for Innovation, Technology and Policy Research, IN+, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, Instituto Superior Tecnicó, University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal
15:00 – 15:30 Catalyzing Rural Development and Women Empowerment Through Implementing Eco-centric Technologies Aimed at Gainful Utilization of Treated Domestic Wastewaters
Rahul Sutar, Lekshmi B. and Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar CESE, IIT Bombay
15:30 – 16:00 Tea/Coffee
16:00 – 16:15 Production Processes and Spatial Organisation of Plastic Recycling Clusters in Mumbai: Preliminary Observations & Methodological Notes
Aravindhan Nagarajan and T. Jayaraman School of Habitat Studies, TISS, Mumbai
16:15 – 16:45 Case Study: Engineering Solutions for Disposal of End of Life Plastic Waste by Converting it into Fuel Oil, Carbon Black & Lubricating Grease
Mr. Suhas S. Dixit, Director, Pyrocrat Systems LLP, Navi Mumbai
16:45 – 17:30 Practitioners' Panel Debate: How could the Municipalities and Industries Face up to the Advanced Treatment Technologies and the Associated Steep Costs?
Moderator: Mr D P Misra
17:30 – 18:30 Visit to the Constructed Wetland on IITB Campus Fellowship, Networking & Relaxing
1 km walk to the wetland site and back to the venue for dinner
19:00 – 19:45 Dinner Foyer in VMCC, IIT Bombay
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 21
Tuesday, 12th September, 2017 DAY TWO
08:30 – 09:00 Tea/Coffee
09:00 – 09:40 A Novel Business Model Through Combining Constructed Wetland Technology with Social Engineering: A Way towards Circular Economy
Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar CESE, IIT Bombay
09:40 – 10:10 Case Study: The State-of-Art Facility for Reuse of Treated Sewage in a Five-Star Hotel
Mr Ajit Khandeshe, Managing Director,
Kwan Environmental Solutions India Private Limited, Ambernath (East) 421 506 State of Maharahstra, India
10:10 – 11:00 Plenary Talk:
Management of Environmental Services in MCGM: Challenges in the 21st Century
followed by Q/A session
Dr. Sanjay Mukharjee, IAS
Additional Municipal Commissioner (Projects), Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM), Mumbai
11:00 – 11:30 Tea/Coffee
11:30 – 12:30 Stakeholder Inclusion in Design and Planning of Wastewater Management followed by Q/A session
Prof. Martina Keitsch Department of Design, NTNU Trondheim, Norway
12:30 – 13:15 Montreal Protocol: Recent Challenges on Twinning of Ozone Depletion and Climate Change followed by Q/A session
Dr. R. Gopichandran Director, Vigyan Prasar,
Department of Science and Technology, Government of India, New Delhi
13:15 – 14:00 Lunch
14:00 – 15:00 Practical Sustainability Strategies and Corporate Sustainability Performance: An Integrated approach of Pollution Prevention and Social Welfare followed by Q/A session
Prof. Annik Magerholm Fet IØT, NTNU, Trondheim, Norway
15:00 – 15:30 Practitioners' Group Discussion: Drivers and obstacles in promoting eco-friendly technologies and waste minimization in the industry
(Group facilitators to be announnced for each break-away session)
15:30 – 16:00 Tea/Coffee
16:00 – 16:30 Presentations by Practitioners' Groups
Moderator: Prof. Dr. Ing. Annik Magerholm Fet, NTNU
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 22
16:30 – 17:00 Case Study: Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD) Systems for Textile Industry
Mr Ravishankar Vaidya Director, Ecotex Pte. Ltd. Singapore and Ecotex Environmental Technologies blr Pvt. Ltd., Bengaluru, India
17:00 – 17:30 Case Study: Alternate Sources of Water: Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD)
Mr Ajay Popat President, Ion Exchange (India) Limited, Mumbai
Valedictory Session
17:30 – 18:00 Address by the Guest of Honour: “Regulatory Priorities and Tasks for MPCB”
Mr. Pundalik K. Mirashe Assistant Secretary (Technical), MPCB, Mumbai
Concluding remarks & Distribution of Certificates
18:00 – 18:30 Refreshments Fellowship, Networking & Relaxing
Foyer in VMCC, IIT Bombay
CONTACT PERSONS
Prof. (Dr.) Shyam R. Asolekar
Indian Institute of Technology Bombay Centre for Environmental Science & Engineering Powai, Mumbai 400 076 (Phone) +91-22-2576 7867 (E-mail) [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Logistics and Directions
Rahul S. Sutar: +91 95959 39389
Richa Singh +91 99206 58638
Lekshmi B. +91 82915 30667
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 23
APPENDIX 2 – LIST OF THE PARTICIPANTS
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 24
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 25
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 26
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 27
APPENDIX 3 – PROFORMA OF THE EVALUATION OF SPEAKERS (DAY 1)
Po
or
Be
low
Ave
rag
e
Ave
rag
e
Go
od
Exce
llen
t
1 2 3 4 5
Speaker: Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar
Environmental Management in India‟s Industries & Municipalities:
Achievements and the Imminent Challenges
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speaker: Prof. Dr.Ing. Annik Magerholm Fet
Sustainable Development Goals as the Direction to Meet the Local
Challenges
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speakers: Haley Knudson and Prof. Annik Magerholm Fet
Implementing competitive sustainability strategies in companies Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
EVALUATION OF PRESENTATIONS
Day 1: Monday, 11th September, 2017
Two-day international capacity building programme entitled: “Enhancement of Environmental
Sustainability: The New Horizon of Circular Economy & Organizational Improvement”
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 28
Speaker: Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar
Use of Constructed Wetlands and other Natural Treatment
Systems for Treatment and Reuse of Domestic Wastewaters in
India: Highlights of National Survey and Lessons from the
Experiences
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speaker: Prof. Fernanda Magarido
Sustainability in the Value Chain Perspective: Upstream and
Downstream Challenges in Waste Management
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speakers: Rahul Sutar, B. Lekshmi and Shyam R. Asolekar
Catalyzing Rural Development and Women Empowerment
Through Implementing Eco-centric Technologies Aimed at Gainful
Utilization of Treated Domestic Wastewaters
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speaker: Aravindhan Nagarajan and T. Jayaraman
Production Processes and Spatial Organisation of Plastic
Recycling Clusters in Mumbai: Preliminary Observations &
Methodological Notes
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speaker: Mr. Suhas S. Dixit
Case Study: Engineering Solutions for Disposal of End of Life
Plastic Waste by Converting it into Fuel Oil, Carbon Black &
Lubricating Grease
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 29
APPENDIX 4 – PROFORMA OF THE EVALUATION OF SPEAKERS (DAY 2)
Po
or
Be
low
Ave
rag
e
Ave
rag
e
Go
od
Exce
llen
t
1 2 3 4 5
Speaker: Prof. Shyam R. Asolekar
A Novel Business Model Through Combining Constructed Wetland
Technology with Social Engineering: A Way towards Circular
Economy
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speaker: Mr Ajit Khandeshe
Case Study:
The State-of-Art Facility for Reuse of Treated Sewage in a Five-
Star Hotel
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speaker: Prof. Martina Keitsch
Stakeholder Inclusion in Design and Planning of Wastewater
Management
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
EVALUATION OF PRESENTATIONS
Day 2: Tuesday, 12th September, 2017
Two-day international capacity building programme entitled: “Enhancement of Environmental
Sustainability: The New Horizon of Circular Economy & Organizational Improvement”
12 NOVEMBER, 2017, PROF SHYAM R ASOLEKAR 30
Speaker: Dr. R. Gopichandran
Montreal Protocol: Recent Challenges on Twinning of Ozone
Depletion and Climate Change
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speaker: Prof. Annik Magerholm Fet
Practical Sustainability Strategies and Corporate Sustainability
Performance: An Integrated approach of Pollution Prevention and
Social Welfare
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speaker: Mr Ravishankar Vaidya
Case Study:
Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD) Systems for Textile Industry
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction
Speaker: Mr Ajay Popat
Case Study:
Alternate Sources of Water: Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD)
Relevance and Contents
Effectiveness of Presentation
Question & Answer Interaction