response by philip clarke
TRANSCRIPT
RESPONSE BY PHILIP CLARKE
INTRODUCTION Bless you and thank you all for coming1 A full Church1 ,_... Better than Easter ••• probably the largest gathering I've
seen here in all of my years. Thank you for coming and for honoring me in such a warm and wonderful way ••••
To sever the ties lToven through five decades - the fifties, the sixties, seventies, eighties and nineties - leaves me at a loss for words to adequately express the depths of :nw feelingS'I•&M my gratitude. Thank you. Thank you. To all of you •••• and to the Board of Trustees of this church for organizing and promoting and paying for this gathering. You're the greatest!
DEVELOPMENT I've loved every minute of my ministry here. The dozen or so members and friends of this church when I arrived here
in December of 1956 patiently c?.ndured my youthful inexperience and my pastoral inadequacies. I had had only about a year's experience in a church in Scotia, New York ••• working with Junior High and Senior High youth. I came with about six sermons "in the barrel" which were pretty much used up the first two months and from then on •••• it was pretty much a fresh sermon each week and some 2,000 of them are filed away in two filing cabients in my study.
Those who don't think much of my preaching now should have been around ba.ck in those early years. I can still picture a few folks falling as'ieep and actually snoring ••• while I was up here "doing my thing" the best I couldl Remember, Mrs. Tabor, Harold?
It was on October the 8th, 1956 that I sat with the Pastor - Parish Relations Committee and heard about the church ••• seven of us were there •••• I remember them well - Paul Russell, Harold Black, Merle Gripman, Winifred Howe, Elmer Bostock and my wife and myself. I also remember hearing that Don Larsen was pitching a perfect game that afternoon at Yankee Stadiwn. Oh, I wanted to be there •••• four subway stops from the Church. Some of you will remember that }TYC was the baseball capital of the universe - Dodgers, Giants, Yankees. Crossing the Tappan Zee Bridge that early evening I recall seeing a huge sign np in the heavens that said: GO TO NEW YORK. To me, a sign from above. Someone later told me it was the Goodyear Blimp.
The afternoon of that interview, Mrs. Russell and Mrs. McCartney showed me the church. They omitted showing me the basement area ••• for good reason. And the first time I walked in here my heart sank ••• poor lighting, soot and grime on w~lls untouched by paint for 30 years, pew cushions falling apart. But underneath it all you could see touches of beauty ••••
Those of you who were here in my early years gave me the freedom to speak whatever was on my heart and you have been across the years •• o
Most generous in your judgements and infinitely considerate in your kindness!
And for all of this I am profoundly grateful. I came here at the age of 27 with a dream of trying to build a church in this city that would be interracial, international and tnter denominational. •• a church whose doors would be "open" ••• open to all people ••• regardless.
·-'
FAREWELL RECEPTION
1. Bebe Ahmad
2. Rehanna London
3. Joanne Alban Hanschell
h. Judith Allen
5. Judi Fer land
6. Judi Ferland (Husband ???)
7. Judi Ferland
8. Claudia Jo Alhtand Bel.Jiont ( 1 )
9. Betty Altoollian
10. C~alie Baile7
11. Bibi Banoo
12. Neil Bardach
13 • Andrea. Ba.rdach
14. Michelle Barton
15. Moniaue (Michelle's daughter)
16. .Qu intasia (Monique 1 s friend)
17. Richmond Bates
18. Lili Bate•
19. CharJU.ne BembUI7
20. Lee White / BembUIT
21. Salehe BembUI7
22. Abije_ ~mbur,.J:;a.g~J:telilecik spelling of name)
23. Elizabeth Berg
2L.. Harold Black
25. Deborah Black
-- ~- -- & -- --
ADD:
L.03: Vaughn Watson (Orga.n18t)
I -, ·- -~~-~-~~ I
- _j
26. Lynn Blair
27. Bob Blt.llftenberg
28. Jim Bobick
29. Valerie KOJIII.r (Jill's fiancee)
30. Dan Boone
31. Ken Borgeson
32. Catherine Bose
33. Gail Ann Bradshaw
34. Olga Br0111.tield
3 5. Susan LJ!m Brom
36. Gordon Bryant
37. Ann Bryant
38. Son, Bryants
3 9. Son, Bryant•
40. Ipn Bruha
Ll. Katherine Back
L2. Elizabeth Callahan
43. Charles Carpenter
LL. Robyn Carpenter
45. Ann Cavallaro
h6. Angelo Chacona•
47. Jane Cbane7
48. Bert Chernizer
49. Victor Childer•
;o. Catherine Clarke
(Allen)
'( -,. 'I~ ) -.. .n~~· ,• --
51. ~roy Co!'f'un
52. Carl Condra
53. Wendy Cooper
54. David Corvette
55. Gail Corvette
56. Iria CottOJl
51. Paula {Iris's daughter)
;a. Michae 1 Crail
59. George Crawtard
60. Howard daCosta
61. Meg da Costa
62. Il7a Da Costa
63. Norma D&llbroeie
64. Jeanne Dambresie
65. Cary Danford
66. Patri4la D~---- '
67. Patricia Daniel (.triel!ld)
68. Patricia Daniel (.triend)
6 9. John Danley
10. Peggy Daniel
71. Marty Davis
72. Christine Day
73. Thomas DeBow
74. Suzanne De Bow
75. Anna. Del•on
-4-
76. Warren Dennie
77. Ingrid Dennie
78. Mark Else
79. Greta Else
80. Janet Erast
81. Margaret Fisher
82. Russell F~&
8.3. Holley Flag&
84. Ted Fl.a~&
85. Vidya Foley
86. Hillary Ford (and 2 children)
87. BeatriQI!lirasier
88. E:ttie French
89. Josefina Garcia ( ? )
90. U,e Gartrell
91. Joyce Gartrell
92. Ann Pearl GU7
9.3. Sarah Gill
94. GeGrge Gill ???
95. Sall;r Gill ???
96. Nat Grady
97. Gretchen Grant
98. Jill Gray
99. Herman Greene
100. Mrs. Herman Greene
- 5 -
101. Eddie Gunder•on
102. Peg~y Gunderson
103. Ruez Habib
104. Linda Guran
105. Linda !·Guran•s daughter, Christine, or hueband ???
1re. Eric HaillB
107. Charlette Haiu
108. Ken Halcott
109. Andrea Halcott
110. Thomas Hallqan
111. Bjorn Hanson
112. Cathy HalUIOD
11.3. Sabrina Hansoa
llil. Jack Harria
115. ~H&1J!Mt8
11.6. Daniell• Haymea
117. John He hlk:e
118. Deborah Helmke
119. Patricia HeDrT
120. Rache 1 Bard Henr7
121. Paul HeDrT
122. Bobbie Heren
123. Stan Solomon
12h. Donna Hobltes
125. Bob Lipton
126. David Howarcf_:_ ·
127. Jeff HU«he•
128. Betty Sue Hagh••
129. Catherine Hummel
130. Linda Hutcherson
131. Bridpt Hutchereon
132. Julie H1Jl8n
133. Lucene Thorne Inniss
134. Rev. Fred Jackson
135. Dorotb_y Jackson
136. Peter Jacobson
137. Janet Jacobson
138. Linnea Jacobson
139. Peter Jacobson
11o. A:ltrr J ue•
141. Friend1 AJq James
142. Jane Jame•
113. Jennifer Jenkin•
:J.Lh. Edward Ferrar• (er Ferraro ???)
115. Sharon Johnson
116. Rita Mauer
117. Charlette Juchter
148. Beverl1' J•dge
149. Nancy Kaplan
150. Jose Alexander (in place of Jennifer Karia •• her brother)
- 7 -
151. Tom Keane
152. Dana Keane
153. SOJlh ie Keane
154. Gri.ffin KeaM
155. Josephine Keill
156. Antonio Klle
157. Mirim .· Khe
158. MaryAnnKho
159. Miche lJ.e Kho
160. Mae Kho
161. Charlea Ki.Jl
162. Soo Kill
163. Michael Kipnisa
164. Pam Kipniaa
165. Michael K~r
166. Charlette Kittilaen
167. Lerea Kittilsem
168. Kristina Kittilsen
169. Gary Klein
170. Jutie Klein
171. Matthew Klein
172. Christopher Klein
173. Pe,a Koeppel
174. Harve;r Koeppel
175. Do Lamprecht
- 8 -
176. Jennifer Lamprecht
177. Charles Langal.t•
178. TaJ~~Jq Langa11s
179. Frank Leackfe1dt
180. Francine Leackteldt
181. Geerge Leopold
182. Regina Poddslds
18). Edward Levay
184. Patricia Mintz Levay
18$. Robert Lewis
186. ~· A~~.Rl.efta· ·
187. Daniel Lewis
188. Will :r..wis ..
189. · · Andre1!;?t,~tii:t--
190. Purita Liberato
191. Jeu~1!, Ll•.rd
192. J ohll Lollbard•
193. A11x Lembard•
194. Marisa Lembar.d•
19$. F1erence lAne
196. DaYid Lew
197. Nancy Lw
198. Pauline Marsden
199. Jett Marshall
200. Rachel Marsten
201. Cynthia McCollum
202. T. A. McKinney
203. Perri McK1nne:r
20U. . Frusee: fll-
205. Qrnthia Mele
206. Dr. Nelson Mendell_
207. Martha Mendell
2ot3. Roberto Mer ilea
20'. Roberto Meriles I tam11y .ember
210. Roberto Merilita ·I tamil.;r mealter
211. Earle Milber;r
212. Carol Milbery
213. Jeffrey Miles
21L.. Natbidad Miranda
215. Natividad Miranda I friend
216. Larry Morales
217. Doreen Morales
21B. Carol Hawkins Mulcrone
219. Keith Mulcrone
220. Diane Murra7
- 9-
221. Diane Murray I friend ? Stattord Reynolds
222. Deborah Cox-Riches
22.3. Karl Newlin
224. Shannon Newlin
225. Susan N'icholu
- 10 -
226. Spike lfeubercer
227. Du!!) Neubercer
228. A.lpo Niskanen
229. Alpo Niskanea's wife
230. DaYi.d niell
231. 1DaYid Odell I t.riend
232. Sharon Channeaiall
233. ICaren Ol.dDa
23h. Itarea Oldbaa / trieDd ???
235. Roberta Olson
236. Allegra 018on
237. Mr. Olson I Roberta 1a husband. ••• Alex Johnson.
238. Acnes Olsson
239. OliYia Olsson
240. Cecelia Oltmann
241. Louise O'Neill
242. Jacque Paice
2LJ. Eel Paice
2ll. Jill PerJd.rw
245. Bridc•t Perld.ns
246. Traey Piatt
247. Kenn;r Piatt
24e. Ron Piatt
24,. Edith Piper
25'0. Eric Preston
- 11 -
251. Marjorie Preston
252. Jane Radna7
253. Mark Raker
2$U. Kristin Raker
255. Rajkoe.er Ramkis•o•n
256. Vanessa RBJild.ssoon
257. Christine Ramk!ss .. D
256. a. .. ce Redinltte
259. Doroth7 RediDcten
260. MarT Lou Rislq
261. Lillie Rodgers
262. Dunia Rodgers
263. Earl Roosa
264. Nicque Roosa
265. Alexis Roosa.
266. Nicholas Roosa
267. Helen Rus•ell
268. '!bad R\tssell
269. Barbara RusHll
270. Sam Russell
271. Paul Russell
272. Suzanne Sales
273. Anne Sappington
274. Alan Samuels
275. Tina Sayers
- 12-
276. Jay sa,..rs
277. Charles Scardino
278. Dorothy Scardino
279. Michael Schaffield
280. Dee Schatf'ield
2e1. Dianne Keller Schindo
2~2. Edward Schindo
2e3. Jack Schmidt.
284. Liz otto Schmidt
285. Joseph Schneider
2R6. Joan Schneider
287. Phyllis U!topolti
288. Anne Schumann
289. Gary Scrugg•
290. Kathryn Scrugc•
291. Tyler Scrugg•
292. Colby Scruggs
293. Carter Philip Scruggs
294. Der Scutt
295. Lean Scutt
296. Edward Segal
297. Richard Sharp
298. Mickey Clarke Sharp
299. Robert Sharp
.300. Nancy Sharp
301. David (Bob Sharp's soa)
302. Matthew (Bob Sharp's son)
303. Frances Shelton
304. Jane Scatarro
305. Barbara Siec
3o6 • Ash ley S ie «
3CJ7. Kendall Sieg
30e. Tracey Simmons
309. Edward Kofi Simpson
310. Dorcas Siapson
- 13 -
311. Mr. Sill!pson (name unknown to PC)
312. Kvekti:;~impson
313. Tina Hopermann Slocumb
314. Travis SlocUJilb
315. Roxanne SnoTer
316. Leticia Soriano
317. Friend of aticia Simpsoa
31~. Walter Spencer
31,. Friend /Walter Spencer
320. Jeffrey Sprouse
321. Rebecca ~hmann Sprouse
322. Stacey Staaterman
32.3. Brian Feeney
32h. Edward Stack
325. Dorothy Staine
-11-
32~ William Staubach
327. Margaret Staubach
32e. Helen Tait
329. John Tait
330. Evelyn Thayer
331. Duane Thompson
332. Brenda Thompson
333. Shirley Carr Thompson
334. David Thcnnp•on
335. Nancy Trespasz
336. Ignn Weddington Tucker
337. Nichola Tucker I or Andrew Tucker ??
33e. Nancy Ulloa
339. Jim Ull011
340. A•tor Val Hackett
341. Nica Val Hackett
342. Alana Val Hacatt
3L3. Noni Val Hackett
3h4. Sandra Van CleYe
345. Philip Vasan
31·6. Tina Vasan
3L.7. Chri~tina Veneracion (Reyno)
3htJ. Nancy Ward
3h9. Gene Washincton
350. Gene Washington I Friend
- 15 -
351. Bonnie Lane Weber
352. Glenn Weeks
353. Barbara Week8
35L. Daughter I Barbara and Glenn Weeks
355. Erich Werner Jatzke
356. Pat Werner Jatzke
357. Ashley Werner Jatzke
35B. Hans Werner Jatzke
359. Chel.8ea Werner Jatzke
360. PhTllis WestermaJU'l
361. Joan (Althea) White
362. William White
363. Vonne Whittleton
364. Wayne Wiebe
365. Carol Foster Wie'be
366. Megan Wiebe I ar friend
367. Srkes Wilford
36B. Jane Wilford
369. Sykes Wilford, Jr.
370. Paul Wilford
371. Sarah Wilford
372. Joyce WillialiS
373. Ginger Haselden Weyheruneyer
374. Jim Weyhenmeyer
375. Mol~ Weyhenmeyer
"" - 16 -
376. L!m WilliatM
377. Bert Williams
37B. Renee Willia•s
37,. Sam Wilson
380. Billie Wilson
3~1. Lyndon Woodside
3~2. Jane Wocdside
363. Lisa Zi:mmerman
3eh. Ja7 Zimmermall
3e5. Tim O'Connor
386. Walter Gerbereux
387. Sandy Kours
3BB. Mrs. Sand~.ry Koura
38,. Harold Abramrl.tz
390. Mrs. Harold Abromwitz
391. Seymour ???
3 92. Rea Getze ls
393. Kathryn Carroll
39h. Tina Hammond
.395. Janice Hara;rda
.396. Noi ???
397. Rabbi David Lincoln I ???
3,5. Edward Duda I Campbells
.3 99. Dr. Marsha U.ng
L.oo. Lynn ThOJI'lson
hol. Judy Wilska Whel.a.D
h02. Ken Whelan
CLARKE I SOME RESUME NOTES AND 11BI011 INFORMATION
Some of the things done apart from the pa.storing and preach~ at the Park Avenue United Methodist Church •••
COMMUNITY CONCERNS
President or the East Midtown Ministers I Associatton (1959 - 1961); Trustee, The Chap in School ( 1966 - 1972); Chaplain, IIlW'ood Home For Unwed Mothers (1968 to 1972); Member, Tri-Faith Housinc Corporation (1966 to 1968)~ Member. , Yorkville Counselling Center Board1 (1964 to 1968); Trustee, Easts1.de Hospital Chaplaincy Program (1968 to 1974);
UNITED METHODIST CONFERENCE (New York Annual Conference)
OTHER
Chairman, Deaconess Association of the NY Annual Conference (1958 to 1962); Chairperson of the NY Annual Conference Board of Ecumenical Relations. (1968 to 1974); Member of the NY Annual Conference Review Committee (1974 to 1977); Program Chairperson for the Monday Club and Treasurer, too (1972 - 1976); Member of the District Committee on the District Superintendency (1985 to 1999)
Delegate to the World Methodist Conference in London, 1967.
Delegate to the World Methodist Conference, Singapore, 1992.
Swmner preacher, Caroga Lake Chapel, Caroga (in the Adiron~acks), '2 Sundays each sumer, 1986 - 1998. ·
Invited to give the Induction Day Invocation, Cooperstown Hall of Fame for Baseball, 1990 and again in 1994.
Summer preacher, Methodist Church, Ogunquit, Maine 1968 and 1969 and 1970.
Member I Men's Health Club, 1970 to 1999 I 92nd Street YMHA
THE /WALL STREET JOURNAL. C 1999 Dmv Jonn & Ctnrtpany, Inc. AI Riglrls Reseroed
VOL. CCXXXIII NO. 118 EEICP, * * FRIDAY, JUNE 18, 1999 INTERNET ADDRESS:. http://WSj.com
: Mainline Protestant churches get a bad i!f'&P· Yes, overall cburch membership is de•:clining and yes, there's a lot of truth to the ;!charge that the focus on liberal political :,causes has driven away worshippers more •!interested in prayer than politics on Sun· :'day mOrnings. :: Yet there are many individual mainline ;!Protestant churches that are thriving. •There's no sure-fire recipe for success::eacb congregation is different-but the ,;story of bow one failing church managed to
., ., "l \. ;,-
Houses of Worship
By Melanie IGrkpatrick
';transform itseUinto a bustling bouse of >worship and a force for good in its commu;:mty can perhaps offer some insights for •!otber struggling churches. ~. The church is Park Avenue United ::MethOdist Church, !Oea~ on the pp~~;er. .. Kast Side of Manhattan. The force behind ::its transformation is its minister, Philip ;: A. C. Clarke, who will retire from the pulpit I· SUnday after 43 years of service. Mr; ~Clarke's approach includes a traditional :;wonrup service, programs to help the ~needy and an attitude of welcome that em::braces people of au races, backgrounds and ::political beliefs. In short, the Park Avenue ;.name, with its intimations of exclusivity, ~:does not define the mission of the church. ·: What about the evangelical churches '• that are drawing worshippers away from :mainline Protestantism? Like the evangelHeals, Mr. Clarke says, "I believe in a per·;: sonal experience of God in your life. But a t: church needs to fly on two wings: not just ·• the personal experience but also social ::outreach."
:: When Mr. Clarke arrived at Park Av' enue in 1956, he foond a chun:b on the brink ::of closing. There were 25 or so members, a :•building in disrepair and no money. The ,: SUnday be preached his fll'St sermon, he ;: remembers thinking: "The church is dead ~·bot somehow they don't know it." Today ::the church has 600 members, a splendidly · ~ restored facility and, thanks to the man;: agement of a member who knew his way ;; around Wall Street, a healthy financial !: statement, including a trust of S9 million :. dedicated to supporting needy cbun:hes in ::New York and helping the poor. ~ Park Avenue Methodist flnt opened its ;. doors in 1837 in Yorkville. a village in upper ·: llaDhattan then connected by stagecoach . ·'to tbe "city" several miles south. It was a ., mission outpost of John Street Methodist . Chlll'dl, fOWlded iB 11i8, wtlidl claims to
be the oldest Methodist meetinghouse. inJl the New World.
Over the next 100 years. the church ' flourished in a neighborhood tbat by the i late 19th century had become a fashionable : residential district. Its membership bit 700 . in the 1870s and was up to more than 1,000 in 1927, when it moved into its current ad- I Tell a Methodist that you know a minisdress. Large, aging buildings are a burden ' ter who's been at the same cbun:b for 43 to many urban churches today· But Mr. , :years and be is likely to say a prayer for Clarke sees Park Avenue's building as a i 1he liar before him. Mr. Clarke's lengtb of boon; its Romanesque sanctuary draws i ~rvice at Park Avenue is tmbeanl of in the people in and is ·"one of our most com- ' ;vnited Methodist Chwdl, who&e clergy .pelling evangelists." . ~ically spend a maximum of five to eight .; ' Mr. Clarke says he hasn't tiDkerl!d I ars at a single church. It's a system that ' much with styles of worship over the ye8.!'1· .J, · w out of the "circuit riding~ tradition of : His service is "formal" and usually m-. ,19th century, when Metbodlst minis-: eludes three hymns, the Apostles' creed, \ ters on horseback followed their floeb to · tbe Lord's Prayer and a sennon that never 1 the frontier. lasts more than 20 minutes and never dis-! How did Mr. Clarke manage to stick cusses his personal political views .... Part l around so long? He cites two factors. One, i of our appeal is that people walk in and say : his mobile ~ ebaDced c:on- ! it's like my church back home," be says. l stantly, so it was like (fetting a new chun:b J
Roughly 60% of the current members come i every five years. And twe, "I learned to :
·'~ro~~-<>~~~:~.t:= I . keep a low profile arWnd bishops."·' -\
even other faiths. . ! · Ms. Kirlq~Gtrick, a ftlf!lftber of Auk Av- . Park Avenue Methodist's membership I e,nue Methodist Church. is the assistant edi- :
is now as diverse as the city it serves, but tl1r of file lolmlll's editorial 1f111B. / 1 that diversity didn't come easily. ~·, Clarke remembers a white member whoy 10 · ·' · · · --·h-.J
the early 1960s, refused to let a photograpb of herself in church appear in a magazine because she didn't want to be pictured standing with a black member and ~ Ko-rean-American member. One of his fa-vorite stories about how the church 1
changed tor the better concerns the Sun- 1\
day a U.S. Senator worshipped at Park Av-enue Methodist, only to be rebuked by a ~ steam fitter in the Brooklyn dockyards for 1
leaving the communion rail too early. I
r
.·';; THE 1\LL STREET JOURNAL. . . - - . . .
VOL. CCXXXIII NO. 118 F..EICP * * FRIDAY, JUNE 18, 1999 INTmumT ADDRBss: http://wsj.com
1Stepping Down, Looking lJack . : llaiblint Pnltel&ant ~ get a bad be the oldest Methodist lllt'etiDgboutlln l ,,. Yes. Oftl'lll cbllrtb membersllip Is • the New World. ·I •!cumncaaclyes,tbere'salotoftnllbtotbe Over the next 100 yean. tilt dluicb t
i:cblqe lllat the b:us on liberal political floUrillbed in a ~ tlllt by the · ~tt:allleS·bu driven away wonldppas more late dill cr.ntury bad become a fasbionable : ~!infen!sted In prayer than poUtks on SUn- restdeotial ctistrict. lbi membmlbip bit 710 ;!daJ IDOIIUJCS. in the tlmts a1 WU up to more thaD 1,8110 :: Yet llll!rf are many inclmlual mainJine in 19'l7. wileD it moved into its cumnt • : Tell a MethJdllt tbat .,.,., mo. a~ :.•o..r.-.. t clturcbes that are thriving. dress. Laqe, aging buildings are a burden · J-,. ·- . ;: WileD Mr. ctane anived at Part. Av- ....... But llr w wbo'l beea at a.e same dada far a : •'l'bere's no sure-lire ftCipe for success- •eauehll&,belouodacbun:bontbebrint to maRY Ul'tllll dlurc:bel --Y· · · .Jt!UI aad be il tibly to S1J a )~DYer' IDr \ ~eadl-~ is different-but tbe ~!Gfc:lolillc.'lberelftft2Sorsomemben,a Clam sees Put Aftlale'•-~dra:ll a i tbeliar beforebim.llr. Clalb's ........ of .:ltoi'JofbOIUIJefailiDCcburcbmanacecJto ' :•....._ b1 dinpllr ad m llaleJ. 1be boOD; its RomaDelque sa-1811 . WI i ~~atPukAftllueis'l8dleardofiJitlle ..• · '~~r .• -... .... : ........ ~. n·- ...... _... in and Is Mane of cur IDOit a~m- · ................ ~__.. -'-- __ , , · · · · ;--Y 11111: prfleu.:u ,_ u,. llei'1DOD, 11111: i ,......,.... - ~...._ •- .._..., ., Hfd•- 0( Wors•l .. I t!rememberatbiDktng: "'lbecburdlisdead .. feilingevangelists." 't .._~ ei]II!DdamuimumGiftfttet(pt ·: - '"I' :•but tomebow tlley don't blow it" Todly i ·· Mr. CJarte says be balD __. asfnlledllrdl.. lt"sa.,.._lllld ' " • ..._ ..... _ .... ____ ~.._ splelldidly m·-.. wi""-"-of-.. *Oftl'llleytan. . of..._ .... _.;. __ tnrd'H..-6 ·.\ B Melani v;..t.-~ · k .,....,.,..... .... .__ • ...,....,.,...,a uu1 u1• .. r ......... owur . ...., ~ ....... ,...... -· : ·. •. ,: y e n..ua.p;.tnc ;:~ fatllity and. tiJanb to U.: man- i, His senire is Miormai" and ..uy ill- c:eabl:y, Wllellllfelllolllllllbdl-.
·• · .. · \ 1 ,. apmem of a member Wbo 1mew bis way : dudes three bymns. tbe Apo&tlel' creed. ter5 oa bonetJKk folloRd dll!tr ftodls to ;.-... · •'uuuad Will Slreet 1 bealtiV' finaDdal · tile lArd's Prayer aod a sermon that aever: tbe frolltier. · ;trallsform itsetf into a bustling bcue of ;: .. 1 • ........, ..... ......; a .__. ..6 • _.._ lasts more than 21 JllinUtel and never dis· : u- did Mr auu -- to llll:t ::wcnldp aud a force for good In_ i~ a!lllmlt- ::;;D;i;lt.;;p;;;lll' ;;dy "'~ cus&eS his peniOOII1 poliHcaJ views. "Part : an:'.~ 10 loa('!. He c:1a ~ ODe.
1 ;.ally cu ~offer liDIDt iftsiCbts for :MewYcn ... belpillctllepour. ofourapPealiatbatpeoplewaltinanclsay: bill 11111111e ... ....- c:llllled cat- 1
;:Citber struatinr churdles. ,. Pan A-.e MetboiiW lint opeoe4 its It's like my cburdl baa home," be II&YI· : saaauy • ., it wullke lf!lUiw a ..-ct.dl i ~.· '1'be dmdl ts Pan. Avenue United ::dooniDJJ31illYCIIlYIIe.a-'u..-ia,,_ Roughlym.ofthecurreatmembeneome: _rift yean. ADd tw, .,......., te _; • ~ ..... _.. ....__ ...... on ..._ •- • ......, -rr-- - .u...-. . ...... ~ _ • ....., ·, the adler.,· ;;.::a._ _____ w---.•·' ! ,,iieiiiUiJ6i YIIIIUI, OUOO:..a& 0..: un- ':Ne•tta• lllea CIIIUledfld by~ PUIU Aft'!'.._ ........... - _...,. - .. - --..__ .. Jut Side of Jlanbaltall. Tbe force bellind :, to tbe "dty" seteniiDDes lOUth. It wu a fi oome from otber denomiaationl a8d : j
~- lnllllolwtioa _is ~ I'DiiD*r. Philip lliiiii..-.- of JGIID sana liethodlst nen Giber taitta. \ 11s. ~ • ...,_. D/ An • 1 i'A.C. aaate, wbo will retft from tbe pulpit · Cllllln* • ._... 18 1.,. • ...._ .._ to Part Avenue Metbodist's membenbip \ e..- MdiDiist ~.;. ae asi.., •- · ;&mcaay after 43 years of service. Mr. ; is now as dtYerst u the city it servea, IU 1 ,.,.,.___..,....,JIIIllll. / j ·•Clute's approatll inclUdes a trlditional that di~mlty didn"t rome easily. M!· ! , .k j
~wonldp service, procrams to belp the Clarleremembenawtlitememberwho,m I ~ aeedy ad an attitude of welcome that em- tbe ear1y l!lliDa, refUied to let a JlhC*IIriPil ·.:tnees people of an races, bar.qrouDds and of herself in clwrdl appear in a mapline
1 :;pJtitic:al beliefs. In short, the Part Avenue bKause she didn't want to lie pidured :•ume, wttll i11 intbnatkms of exdllimty, standing w_ith a blact member and a Ko-!;*-not cWiDe tbe misskm of the dlurdl. rean-Amencan member. One of his fa· 1 · • Wbat about Ole mmgelic:al cburdles vorite stones about bow tbe chUrdli •:~~~at are drawing wunhippen away from ebanpd tor the better mncems tbe SUn- I :mainline Protestantism? Like tbe evangel· day a u.s. Senator worship])ed at Pan Av-1 ~ it.als, Mr. Clart.e says, "IIM!Iieve in a per- enue Metboctilt. oa1y to be rebUked by a ~ ;.ICIUI experifance of God In your life. But a steam fitter in tbe Brooklyn dockyards f« • ~church needs to fly on two wings: not just leaving the communion rail too early. I ·• tbe personal experieace but also sodal ::outreach.~
1
.... THE 1\LL STREET JOURNAL. VOL. CCXXXIU NO. 118 F.EJCP * * FRIDAY. JUNE 18, 1999 lrmmMRT AoDRSSS: http://wsj.com
~Stepping Down, Looking Back .
t
THE 1\LL STREET JOURNAL. VOL. CCXXXIII NO. 118 F~P * * FRIDAY. JUNE 18, 1999 iN'rKHNRT A.oi>R8SS: http://wsj.com
~Stepping Down, Looking IJack ·.
f
THE 1\LL STREET JOURNAL. VOL. CCXXXIII NO. 118 f;&JCP * * FRIDAY, JUNE 18, 1999 iN'rKKNBT AoDRBss: http://wsj.com
1Stepping Down, Looking lJack ·.
!
THE lLL STREET JOURNAL. VOL. CCXXXIII NO. 118 F~P * * FRIDAY. JUNE 18, 1999
~Stepping Down, Looking &Jck . be the oldest Methodist meetiDgbouse in :
1 tbe New Wortd.
IN'rmoon' ..\oDR§S: bttp://WSj.com
Over tbe next 100 yean. die dlui'dl : ftoUI1Ibed in a~ tat by the • late ttlll Cf!lltui'Y bad IM:come a fuhionable : residential d.islrid. lbl membmlbip bit 700 in tbe 18781 ud wu up to more tbaD UID in 192'1, when it JDO¥ed into ibl aJm!Dl .. j Tell & Metboltilt tbat Vnlt kJJOW a miDif-..o-~ , ... -, .. .nnaa...;LH .. .-areaburden' ~-.: WileD Mr. Ctlrke arrived at Part At· ........... ..-..~ .. --... ....._...... tel' trbo'l beea at die same dlllrc* lor G :
•enueiD115Uaelouodacbun:boatbellrinl to maay urban dmd1I!S today. But Mr. • ._;ran aadlle illibly to say a...,_ •: ::Gf dCJiille. Tbere 1ftft 25 or so memben, a ClatU sees Part AtSUe'P:_~drau a ~ lheliar befort IBm. Mr. Clatb's _... af
· ::........., m dilft9ab' IDd.., JDIMY. 'lbe boon; its Romanesque saudiW)' · WI i ~~~&viceatPaftAveoueilunbelrdofilttbe • om • .-... ...... -- .. ,. n·-· - __... in and is ~one cf cur moat com- . ..~ A..-a. _,___ -. ' ;--Y aJIII; .. .._...;,.. IUD uM senDOD, •"'~' ~"'"~""' - -..-. .. _ -.-u
. ' BOllia of Woi'IJ.I.. ·"l'tiiM!IIlllen thinking· '"l'lle cburdl is dead . ,eelinC evangelists." • . . ~spend aJDIXimUm olfiYe ....... : 'MJ' 1 ~:but~ they cbt't mow it.• Today ·· Mr. ClalU says he hunt tiDIIend i asirlltedlllrc:IJ.It'sa.,.._aat • ..... _.. ., .._ -......~u mucbwitb..-.. cf-.. *Oftl'ltle,ean. ·,._ · of..._"-'-·_ ... ""'"-". ---~ · \ B M 1 · v:_ .. __ · k .u.e.;.... .... bal mena~ ... a___., ... 1..... ........... ·=an., UliC ~··-.- .. _ •
. : ,: Y e arue n..uav•.tnc ,!~ tacliity uad, tbanb to~ man- ; ifi5 sen~ is Miormal" aod ......; iii:- i Clelltmy, nen lll!tJio&llt miDit-, • .. '\ . ,. ~ of a member wbo mew bil way eludes three hymnS, tbe Apdel' creed. : ten oa bolsellat!k folloRd t11etr fllds to ,- ::aruuac~ Wall Street, a beiJtby finandal tlleLord'sPrayerandasennoatbatnever: tbefnlotier. ';transform itself into a bustling boull! " , !!Ita~ indtMI;.. a trust «t • ml1Uua lasts more tban 2ll Jllimlls and never dis· ~ How did Mr. aaru ...-p to ~tim :•wonldpud a force for good in its ecmmu- :;dedleat~ ~needy dlurcbes iD cusses his peniOOill political VieWs. "Part : arouad 10 laDe? He dtl!!ll twa flcbln. o.e,
1 .:aitJ eu pertllps offer IOIDe iJ1sicbts for ~:NewYon..abelpillrtt.epoor. ofouraiJpealiatbatpeoplewllkiDandsay: bill mallie ~ e 1.- ca. 1 ::dba' llnaatiDr dwrtbes. ,. Pam A,_. Medlodid lint opeoed i&s It's De my cburr.h back home," be says. : staaUy ,., It •• De_... a.., dluldt \ .• Tbe dlUI'dl is Part Avenue United ::docniDlDTiaYCJrtvtle,a.nu..-ia•- RouchlY&O%oftbecurreatmemberiCDPe: -Aft_ .. ADd tw ... lleanlld te '.· .. Jietboctilt Olurcb ~orated tile·- ·- -...- - u .................. _ ....... ;the CJiber; ~ • ._~-------.··' ! ·' • . on ... _ ~:Me•UI• tllea CliiiiM!dlld by lllpcloKb =."=-from· . ~de-.;,_'-~- -- ri ........ - .. - .,.,.._ .. ___ ; ..... Side 0( JlanbattaJl. 'I'be force bebind . ,...,_., -1 -n- -- ft ...,-,., ...,..... UUIQ IIIUIIUIWUUIIIt -:·.-_...a.-.,.._ ts .... _ ... ...._. ....... -~r.u.r ..... , _wa ____ .. a f 1
- ~~-- ........ ._ • ....... · - ..~ ~-u~ evenotber litlll. i Jls. -s-:. o _,.. ""Alrt Av- . •... ·.·"C.~ • ...._,-... -'D _..._- ,_ -alnit . --, :::!::::::..-~--,'=..=!.. ~ t' --. ..... \ _,.,...._, "' a. ~- ..... ...... ~"' uuou IlK.....- ___ .. _ _ _ Put Avenue MetbodiS s mem ..... -- ~ ~ ~. ;sllle...,.,tlllli· · ;Sunday alter u yean ll semce. Mr. • isoowasdiverseutbecityitll'ftet,ld 1 ,.,.,.~ .. ....,,.,. /j .,Qarte's approach includes a trlditioftal tb&t dlnnlty didn't come easily. ~- I, , -kl
~wonldp smite, )JI'OihmS to belp the Clalterememberuwtlitememberwho,m I ~ !Ieedy ud an aWtude .. weJaue tbat em- tbe ea11y llllla, mu.t to tela Jlbokllnpb :~nm~ pq1e 11 an races, bat.kgroqDds and of henelf in cburdl appear in a maguiDe
1
::PlliticaJ beliefs. In short, the Part Avenue because sbe didn't want to bt l*tUJ'fd !•ume, Wlth its indmatlolls ci etdulmty, staDdlng with a blatt member and~ Ko-!:esnotdefiDetbfmissioooftbedlurd\. rean-American member. ODe of bis fa·, · • What about tbe evangelical cbUI'thes vorite stories about bOw tbe church 1 •: lbat are drawing worshippers away from cbaJII!d tor the better c:onoems the sun- I :mainline Protestantism? Like the evangel· day a U.s. Senator worshipped at Part Av· \ ._ieals, Mr. Clarke says, "I hl!lieve in a per· enue Methodist. only to be rebuked by a~ ~ 100&1 experittnce of God ln your life. But a steam fitter in the BrootJyn dockyards for 1
~chUrch needs to fly on two wings: not just leaving tbe rommunion rail too early· I ·• the penonal experience but also social ::outreach.~