RESUME OF WORK DONE BY LOK SABRA

(EIGHTH LOK SABHA - TIDRTEENTH SESSION)

(21st February to 15th May, 1989)

WK SABRA SECRETARIAT NEW DELHI

June, 1989IAsadha, 1911 (Saka)

,.,.,.." IJNDD Rtu: 1Il 01' .... R1JLI:I 01' hoar.DtJu AND CONDOCr 01' IklIINDI IN LoK SdBA (SuTa EDmoN) AND PIIN'nD n .... MANAGa, GowIuaa:NT 01' ..... ....., P.L. thaT, MDrro RoAD, NEW Da.m.

PREFACE

ThiI publication COIItaias • brief resume of wort done by Eiabth Lok Sabba durin& the Thirteenth Seuion i.c. from 211t Fcbruary to 15th May, 1989.

NEW DELHI;

111M, 1989

AstuUta, 1911 (Sah)

SUB HASH C. KASHY AP, Secr«Iuy-Gertmll.

PAOlI 1. DURA 110N OF SESSION . .... ......... ......... ............. ...... ... .... .................. ........ 1

2. BB.LS (i) 00¥crameDt BBII .................................................................................... 2 (ii) Private Membcn' BiOI ............................................................................. 8

3. CALlJNG ATI'BNTION ............................................................................. 14

4. DMSIONS ............................................................................................... 16

5. FINANaAL BUSINESS (i) Railway BudFt .................................................................................... 17 (ii) GeDerai Budfet .................................................................................... 18

(iii) Budfet iD reIpOCI or Slate or Pllaj8b ........................................................ 20

6. LEAVE OF ABSENCE .......................................... ; .................................... 21

7. M0110NS

(i) MotioaI UDder RuIea 191 aDd 342 ............................................................ 22 (ii) MoIioDI UDder Rule 388 for IUlllCDIioo of RuIea ......................................... 24

(iii) Motiooa UDder Rule 374 for ....,elllioa of Memben .................................... 25

8. OBrruARY REFERENCES ........................................................................ 28

9. PAPERS LAID ON nfE TABLE ................................................................. 30

10. PERSONAL EXPLANAll0N ...................................................................... 31

11. PE11TIONS ............................................................................................... 32,

12. PRESlDEN'rS ADDRESS ........................................................................... 33

13. PIUVD..EGE MATIERS ............................................................................. 34

14. QUES110NS (i) Starred ................................................................................................ 39

(Ii) Sbort Notice ........................................................................................ J9 (iii) UIII&Irred ............................................................................................ J9 (iv) HaIf-u-Hour cIIcuIIioD ....... out or UIIWerI to queItioaI .......................... 40

15. RESlGNA1l0N BY MEMBERS .................................................................. 41

16. RESOLU110NS (i) Go¥enuDcat R.eIoIatioD ......................................................................... 42 (Ii) S&atutory ReIoIuIica ............................................................................. 43 (iii) Private Meaaben' ReIoIu1ioaI ................................................................. 45

(iii)

(iv)

PAOlI 17. SHORT DURATION DISCUSSIONS (RULE 193) .......................................... ~

18. SrT11NGS OF LOK SABHA .............................................................•••........ 48

19. SPEAKER/DEPUTY SPEAKER/CHAIRMAN AIIDouacemeatl/Oblervatioai/Refereacea ....................................................... 49

20. ST ATE.MENTS (i) StatcmcDta madellaid by MiDialen UDder Rule 372 ..................................... !iO (ii) SlatclDellt by Member ............................................................................ 52 (iii) Matten UDder Rule 377 . -_ ....................................................................... 52

(a) Number of mattcn railed .................................................................. 52 (b) POIiIioo reprdioa receipt of repIiea from MHIiIten COIICerMd

(_ on 22.6.1989) ............................................................................. 52

21. STAlEMENT SHOWING TIME TAKEN ON V AJUOUS KINDS OF BUSINESS ................................................................................................ 53

RESUME OF WORK DONE BY EIGHTH LOK SABHA DlJaING THE TlURTEENTB SESSION, FEBRUARY-MA Y, 1989

1. DURATION OF SESSION

Date of Commencement Date of adjournment sine die Date of Prorogation Total number of days of Session Number of days of sittings Number of hours of sittings

21st February, 1989 -15th May, 1989 23rd May, 1989 84 days 49 days 320 hours and 47 minutes

-The session was originally scheduled to conclude on Wednesday. the 10th May. 1989.

2-III

LLS

(I)

Qh

a

.... 51

. 11

Ik 0

1 di

e _

Dal

e of

D

ate

of

Dat

e o

f Ti

me

No.

of

No.

of

Pro

pa

II

No.

iDtro

due-

layi

Da

on

diIc:u

IIicJn

ta

tea

ameo

d-am

end-

Rem

ab

tioD

tb

e Ta

ble

ill L

ot

mea

ts

mea

ts

(ia

tbe

SIbb

a ta

bled

ca

rried

Q

Ie of

BiD

s pI

IIR

d by

R

ajya

Sab

ba)

2 3

4 5

6 7

8 9

H

M

I. '11

Ie R

aiIn

yI B

iD.

1986

25

.4.8

6 21

.2.8

9 o

01

Rep

ort

of

(Ear

lier

(Pre

sent

atio

d Jo

iat

t-.)

Seai

oD)

of R

epor

t of

C

omm

ittee

Jo

int

Com

mitt

ee)

prae

oted

2.

1k

Dire

ct T

ax L

a ..

U12

.88

3.5.

89"

2 31

h

aed

(A

IM. t

at)

BiB.

198

8 (E

ti-.

(Con

side

ratio

n an

d Se

IIio

a)

pass

ing

of d

ill.

M

rqHN

ted

by

Join

t C

orrv

rtiIte

t) 22

.2.8

9 3

41

30

'IT

haed

._

23.2

.89

• ...

....

.wI

(Con

side

ratio

n an

d pa

ssin

g)

3. TIle FIaaace BIl, M9

28.2.89

4. ~

The IDcome-IU (AmeDdmcDt)13.3.89

BiD. 1989

oS. The Central IDdustriaI

Security Force (AmeudmcDt)

BiD. 1989, tI$ ,.,.u by

RIIjytJ s.bIwI

6. The Beedi aDd apr Worbn -

(Coadi ___ of EmpIoyaIeat)

Ameadmeat BiD, 1989. tI$

JHIDftI by RIIjy. s.bIt.

7. The AppJopriatiOa (Vote OIl

17.3.89

Acx:ouat) Bill, 1989

8. The AppropNtioo (Rdways) 17.3.89

BiD, 1989

16.3 .•

16.3.89

'27.4.89

28.4.89

2.5.89

(Cou&ideilitiotl

mel pIIlIIias)

28.3.89

29.3.89

(Coasideratioa

aad ........ >

11.5.89

(Couidcratioa

met pilling)

17.3.89

(0 ·f '.tioo

aad ,...m,)

17.3.89

(Coalideratioa

aDd ..... )·

12 31

6 6

......".

..............

2 41

Pasted

o ~

Paaed

PeadiDa

o 01

r-d

o 02

,...

-nc ... lilt QDIIIideratioD of"dIe am. III ~ by loW ~ .. disc:IIIIed aIoapitb the DemMds for. ~ Graa$a (Railways) .. 1""

"The IDOIioit for COIIIideratiOll of the BiD .. diec:ulled together with the Statutory RaoIutioD seekiDa diupprovaI of tie Iacome-IU (Am

t .)

Ordiuace, 1989 (0rdiaaDce No. 1 of 1989).

....

2 3

4 5

6 7

8 9

~

H M

9. 'I1II'AppropiiatioD

17.3.89

17.3.89

o 01

Puled

(Railways) No.2 Bill. 1989

(Consideration

and pasaiog)

10. llIe Delhi MUDic:ipaI

27.3.89

29.3.89

136

P-.I

Laws (Amendment) Bill. 1989

(Consideration

and palling)

11.

The Appropriatioa BiD', 1989

27.3.89

27.3.89

o 02

r-d

( Consideration

and passing)

12.

The Puajab Appropriatioo

27.3.89

27.3.89

o 01

Palled

(Vote OIl ACItlIMqIl) Bill. 1989

(Consideration

~

and passing)

13.

11Ie ~ AppmpriaIioo

27.3.89

27.3.89

o 01

Palled

·BiII, 1989

(Coasideration

mel pasina)

@14. '!be Cluondjpdl Disturbed

4.4.89

9.5.89

1 36@@ -

PMICCi

Areas (Amendment) BiD. 1989

10.5.89

~

aDd passing)

15.

'!be RepresentatioD of the

6.4.89

11.5.89

2 36

2 Puled

People (Amendment) BiD. 1989

(Coasideration

aDd passing)

@16. The Terrorist and Disruptive

24.4.89

9.5.89

1 36@@ 5

Palled

Acdvitia (PreftBtioD)

10.5.89

Ameodmeat BiD. 1989

(Consideration

and passing)

17.

The AppropriatioD (Nf.2)

26.4.89

26.4.89

o 01

Passed

BiD. 1989

(CoIIIideratioo

IDd .-ma>

~ The UDioD"Dutiea of Em.e

2.5.89

10.5.89 -\

Passed

(DiItributioD) Ameadmmt

(Coalideratioo

BiD: 1989

IDd pusiDa)

"'19. The Aclditioaal Duties of

2.5.89

10.5.89

r o 58

Passed

EsciIe (Goods of Specia1

ImpoilmCe) Amerdmeot

BiD. 1989

20. ne Geoenl IIIIuraDce

2.5.89

Pending

a..-. (Natiooalilatioo)

IA

AmeadmeDl BiD. 1989

21.

The ~

2.5.89

1 Pending

(SiDy-dUrd

~

BiD. 1919

22.

The AppropriatioD (1Wlwaya) 3.5.89

3.5.89

o 01

Puled

No.3 BiD. 1989

(Coasideratioo

IDd paIIiDa)

23.

The SmaU IDduItriea

10.5.89

PeodiDa

DeveIopmcat BUlk of IDdia

BiD. 1989

24.

The Appiopiatiou (No.3)

10.5.89

10.5.89

o 02

P.-cd

BiD. 1989

(Coalideratioo

IDd p8S1iaa)

@DiIcuaed lOfetber.

@@TUDe taken on the combined cIiIc:uiIiOD of both the Bills _

1 hour aud 36 minutes.

'!foDilcuaed fDIdber.

2 3

4 5

6 7

8 9

H M

25.

The Punjab Pre-emption

2.11.88

11.5.89

o 52

2 2

P ......

(Chandisarh and Delhi Repeal)

(Eartier

(Consideration

.-to..t

BiU. 1988. G$ ptmrd by

Session)

and passing)

Rlljya SGbIuJ

26.

The Wealth (Inheritance)

12.5.89

Peodiaa

Duty Bill. 1989

27.

The Assam University BiU.

12.5.89

15.5.89

1 31

2 Paaed

1989. G$ ptmrd by

~

Ra;,a s.bIta

and passing)

28.

The Constitution (Sixty-fourth

15.5.89

3 25

40

Pending

a-

Amendment) Bill. 1989

29. The Delhi Motor Vehicles

15.5.89

Pending

Taxation (Amendment)

BiD. 1989

SUMMARY

'1. Billa peadioa at the end of the lut IICIIioa 12 2 BiIII iatroduced 23 3. Billa oppoacd at Introduction .... 1 4. Billa paued by Rajya Sabba and laid on the Table' ) 5. Billa puaed by Rajya Sabba and retumed by Lot SalIba with AJDeDdments 1 6. Billa returned by Rajya Sabba with amendments and laid OD the Table Nil 7. Billa palled 22 8. BiIII neptived Nil 9. BilII withdrawn Nil

10. Billa part diacuaed Nil 11. MotioDl for IdjourDmeDt of debate on Billa adopted Nil 12. Bills referred to Select Committee Nil 13. Bills referred to Jomt Committee Nil 14. BilII reported by Select Committee Nil IS. Billa reponed by Jomt Committee 1 16. BiIII on,matia, in and referred to Joint Committee

by Rajya Sabba in reapec:t of wbic:b motion for coacurrence wu adopted by L9k Sabha Nil

17. BiIII pendiDa at the end of the 'IbirteeD SdIiOD vide para No. 2953 of Lot Sabba Bulletin-Part D,. dated 25th May, 1989 16

7

(I)

Prm

fe .

....

... ' ...

S1.

TItle

of t

he B

ill

Dal

e of

D

ale

of

Dat

e of

Tu

nc

No.

of

No.

of

Prop

e8I

No .

. iD

trodu

c-la

ying

on

disc

ussio

n ta

ken

amen

d-am

end-

Rem

arb

tion

the

Tabl

e in

Lok

m

enti

m

ents

(in

the

Sabb

a ta

bled

ca

rrie

d ca

se o

f Bi

lls.

pass

ed b

y ,..

Raj

ya S

abba

)

2 3

4 5

6 7

8 9

I.

The

Fair

Pri

ce S

bops

24

-2-1

989

21-4

-198

9 H

M

N

il N

il D

iscu

ssio

n (R

egul

atio

n) B

iU. 1

989

5-5-

1989

on

the

by S

bri G

. S.

Bas

avar

aju.

(C

omid

erat

ioo)

m

otio

n fo

r 3

S5

CO

DIid

entio

o no

t coo

-du

ded.

oc

Peod

io&

2.

The

Agr

icul

tura

l Pro

duce

24

-2-1

989

o 02

PeD

cIiDa·

Price

s Fl

Dti

oo B

ill. 1

989

by S

bri

min

utes

U

ttam

Rat

hod.

ta

ken

on

intro

duct

ion

of th

e Bi

lls

at S

.Nos

. 1

and

2 3.

Th

e U

aorp

nise

d La

bour

26

-7-1

985

25-1

1-19

88

8 06

N

lI N

il Bi

ll w

ith-

Wel

fare

Fun

d B

iD. 1

985

by

(Ear

lier S

essi

on)

(Tw

dftb

Ses

sion

) (e

sduc

liDf 2

dn

wn

by

Sbr

i BaI

aube

b V

ikbc

: Pat

iJ.

24-2

-198

9 ho

urs

and

09

Iea\

leol

dle

10-3

-198

9 m

iDut

es

tro.

e.

7-4-

1989

ta

keo

durio

& 21

-4-1

989

1WeI

ftIa

(Fur

ther

con

side

ratio

n)

Seas

ion)

4.

The RestrictioD on Holidays

10-3-1989

in Public 0f6ces Bill. 1988 by

Shri S. B. Sidnal.

5. The Nalional Child Welfare

~

Board Bill. 19f!M by Shri S. B.

Sidna\.

6. TIle Christian Marriage ami

Ill. :l·I"X9

Matrimonial Cau.vs Bill. i9X9

by Shri Thampan Thoma'.

7. The (",.)mrul",'n· SIt"rilis;1lin"

III 1 1''''-'

Bill.

IIJI(IJ 1>\

Shn G.S lIa";l\";\raju

1(.

The Welfare of Uandn:al'l'cJ

~

and Mentally Relarded Children

Bill. 1989 by Sbri Shanlilal Pale\.

9.

The Constitution (Amendment) 10-3-1989

Bill, 1989 (Substillllioll of MIt'

10.

11.

III1iI* for III1iI* 57) by Sbri A.

Charles.

The Domestic Worken

(Conditions of Service)

Bill. 1989 by Sbri 1bampan

Thomas.

The Represenaatioo of the

People (AlDeeclmeat) Bill,

1988 ~

S«Iiotu 59

fIIUI 61) by SIiri Shand Dipe.

10-3-1989

2241988

(Earlier Seaioo)

10-3-1989

(Motion for withdrawal)

o 04

minutes

taken on

introduction

ofBiUs at

S.NoI.4

to 10.

o 01

Pending

Pendinc

Pending

Pending

Pending

I'ending

Pending

Bill with·

drawn by

leave of the

House.

•

2 3

4 5

6 7

II 9

12.

The Constitution (AmeadmeDt) 7-4-1989

Pendinc

BiD. 1989 (A-.6nellf of ankle

316) by Sbri V. S. Krishna Iyer.

[BiD No.4 of 1989)

13.

The Constitution (Amendment) 7-4-1989

Pending

Bill. 1989 (AtrteIIIIment 01 arricle

316) by Sbri V. S. Krishna lyer.

[Bill No. 1 of 1989)

14.

The CoaIbtutioa (Amendment) 7-4-1989

Pending

Bill. 1989 (AmDIdmmI ofankk

198J by Sbri V. S. Krisboa lyer.

IS. The Constitution (Amendment) 7-4-1989

Pending

BiD. 1989

~ 01 tII'tida

... 123 tutd 213) by Sbri V.S.

C>

Krisboa lyer.

16. The AU-Iadia Services

7-4-1989

Pendinc

(Ameodmeot) BiD. 1989 (1Mn'-

tiort 01_ I«Iions 2B to 21)

by Prof. Madbu Daodavatc.

17.

The lodiao Medic:iDe Central

7-4-1989

re .....

Couacil (Amendment) BiD. 1989

~ of m:tioII 2, etc.)

by ,Prof. Madbu DaDdavatc.

18

The Code of CrimiDaJ Procedure 7-4-1989

......

(Amendment) BiD. 1989

(OmWioft 0/1«IioM 107 ad

1(9) by Prof. M8dIlu Daadavatc.

19.

The Criminal Law Amendment

(Repeal) BiU, 1989 by Prof.

Madhu Dandavate.

20.

The Constitution (Amendment)

Bill, 1989 (/nsmion of ~

lIrticie

31) by Sbri Sharad Dighe.

21.

'The Constitution (Amendment)

~ 1989 (lnsmion o.f new artick

19A. rIc.) by Shri Ramashray

Prasad Singh.

7·4-1989

7.4-1989

7-4-1989

22.

'The India .. Penal Code(Amend-

21-4-1989

ment) Bill, 1989

~ of

uction 376, rIc.)

by Shri Haroobhai Mehta.

23.

The Abolitioll of Capital

21-4-1989

Punishment Bii1, 1989 by

Shri Thampan Thoma!.

24.

'The Constitution (Amendment)

21-4·1989

Bill, 1989

~~

0./ articlr

101, elC.). by Sbri Shantaram

NailL

25.

The Constitution (Amendment)

Bm. 1989

~ 0{

~ lIrticie

35OA) by Sbri Sbantaram Naik.

21-4·1989

o 05

minutes

taken on

introduction

of Bills at

S. Nos. 12 to

21.

o 02

minutes

taken on

introduction

oC Bills at

S. Nos. 22 to

25.

Pending

Pending

Pending

Pending

Pending

Pending

Pending

2 3

4 S

6 7

8 9

26.

The Old Aae PeoIioa Bill, 1989 5-5-1989

Pending

by Shri S. M. 0urIICIdi.

27.

The Coostitutioa (Ameadmenl) 5-5-1989

Pending

Bill, 1989 ~ o/1II1icIe

340) by Sbri Syed-$hahahucldin.

28.

The CoostitulioD (AJDeDdmenl) 5-5-1989

Pending

Bill. 1989 ~ of .nick

jlA) by Sbri Shaatanm Nait.

29.

The CoaIbtutioD (AmeDlheDt) 5-5.1989

PendiDl

Bill. 1989 (I,..,.". of,.,.. ....

J47A) by Prof. NIniD Qaad

ParasIw.

... N 30.

The IDdiaD Penal Code (Ameod-5-5-1989

o 02

Peadin&

menl) BiD. 1989 ~ of

minutes

section 323) by Sbri Shaatanm

taken on

Naill.

introduction

of BiIII al

S. Nos. 26 to

30.

SUMMARY

1. Billa peDdiIIa at the ead of Twelfth Saaioa 316

2. Bills iDtroduced 28

3. BiIII-Motioa for iDtroductioa DCptived Nil

4. Bills ~ 2

s. Billa witbdraWD 2

6. Billa DCptiYed Nil

7. Bills I'CIDO¥ed fnm the Rqiater of Pendina Billa Nil

8. Bw.-Part4acuaed

9. Bills pcodiDa at the ead of the ThirteenTh Seuion vide 342 Pua No.29S4 of Bulletin-Part n, dated 25.S.1989

13

J ..:1 -I 7!a !'" ~ !"'. . ~

[tl [lIt Ifill ~ ~ ~ sIll $([1. I!l :'Ii ffl I ft fl.8.,1 ~ l I

~ ~ I ~ III t; r1 . ~ il-Ih fli !ll NI I 't :,1 ~ I iff !I I f IIJ r f L II! ~ e f I I'll f . ~ t f" $,.. $11; I ~ S·I ~ f f s· f.fl f ~

!"

~ r. f. i

~ f. if i !t :< 0

if ~

f ~

Ii'II , • -i -I 14) -~ ;. ... -'f

I

f 0 0

~ Vt -

t I 1.1 Ii. f if ! II a

I·r

(II [

_!: -!II ~ r C ~ ~ ~ ... i I ~ I i

~

11·1 5'1,'5 ft .... ~ a

o 11 ... ::l o --3 ~ 0 I Vt . =-.. .... s:;:g

.. I

• • ... ... J GO ..... c.-

~ ~ ; ~ 1'": flil fill' ~ -I I II f" I I s. I r It I I I '1-

~ $ lJl'J Jfi ~ ~ II ~ ~ II f f 'I I 1 itl ,r a. $11. II I ilK D ~ f 2 • It i (1. f.f i a. It I

rl I II tI t I ." a Ii! i r .- ."1

. f II,. J .f II a. III I 11 ~ fJ i I ffll fll J ,I,a. f R ,'i.' ~ ~ ! (II i ~ 11 "hi ~ I ;.1 i ~ !i Iii I,tt. ~ r. ~ f. f. f. f ~

I (iii i I Iii ~ S f f;t

~~ t - - j

[rjl Jiji ~ [

(

0 '

e.. e ~ ~ r /t_ 1:-0 ~~ ,f ~ 3-?!is: e: ~ I-I ~ ~ i 2": 9 l i I 0 .a ';z ~

~

'" !: ~ ~ ~ ~ -ill I i I

~ f

f. ~

1- f ~ f. ~ s .., :a- s-o.. ... ~

I i' I t I ~

o

~ o -

o

't. o

~

)1

5. fINANCIAL BVSINDS

SHjed

(We fII

(We fII

~ .....

Pi

I .....

I 2

3 4

(I)....., .....

BudFt (Railways) for

H M

1989-90

23.2.1989

1 02

~

19 ~

7.3.1989

8.3.1989

Oeoeral Discussion

9.3.1989

10.3.1989

17.3.1989

. -Disc:uuion 8IId YOtin& "\

on Dcmaods for Grants

Supplementary Demands for

14.3.1989

17.3.1989

-Discussion and YOtin& on

{ 1 27

Grants in respect of

Supplementary Demands for

Budget (Railways) for 1988-89

Grants (Railways)

Demaods for Excess Grants in

24.4.1989

3.5.1989

@Discussion and voting on

0 01

respect of 8udFt (Railways)

DeIlUlDds for Excess Grants (Railways)

for 198(HJ7

-I>iaaaIed aIoopith the Government Resolution seeking approval of recommendatioos amtaiocd in the thirteenth Report of tbe Railway Coawotioa

Committee, 1985.

@ Discussed aIongwith motion for consideratioa of the Railways Bill, 1986, as reported by loint Committee.

-'-I

2 3

4

(II)

Gae

nII ..

...

H

M

Bud

Ft

(Gea

eraI

) 28

.2.1

989

IUI_

} 1

35

for

1989

-90

15.3

.198

9 16

34

16.3

.198

9 G

ener

al D

iscu

ssio

n 17

.3.1

989

17.3

.198

9 D

iacu

ssio

n an

d vo

ting

on

o 01

D

eman

ds f

or G

rant

s O

D

Acx

:ouo

t (V

oted

with

out

dDcu

isio

D)

Satii

Atm

catu

y D

caao

dI f

or

16.3

.198

9 27

.3.1

989

Disc

ussio

n an

d vo

ting

OD

1

36

Gr.

D iD

rap

ect

of

Supp

lem

enta

ry D

eman

ds f

or

Bud

Ft

(Gen

eral

) fo

r 19

88-8

9 G

rant

s (G

ener

al)

Dem

mds

for

Eu

as

Gra

nts

iD

2.5.

1989

10

.5.1

989

Disc

:uas

ion a

nd v

otin

g,. o

n 2

37

resp

ect

of t

ile B

udF

t (G

ener

al)

Dem

ands

for

Exc

ess

Gra

nts

oc

for

1986

-87

(Gea

eral

) Di

sc:u

sIIio

n an

d vo

tin&

on

S.<.IWW

} D

eIlW

lds

for

Gra

nts

of M

inis

try I

6.4.

1989

En

eraY

10

18

Dep

artm

eat

of

7.4.

1989

10

.4.1

989

124 I"

"}

19.4

.198

9 A

gric

ultu

re

12 4

9 20

.4.1

989

21.4

.198

9

21.4

.198

9}

Exte

rnal

26

.4.1

989

Aff

ain

4 37

Gui

1Iot

ined

Ci

vil

Avi

atio

n an

d To

uris

m

at 6

.00

P.M

. C

omm

en:e

on

26.

4.19

89

Com

mun

icat

ions

D

efen

ce

Envi

ronm

ent

and

Fore

sts

F"1IU

IIJCe

Fo

od a

nd C

ivil

Supp

lies

Food

Proc

:essin

& ID

dust

ries

Hea

lth a

nd F

amily

Wel

fare

H

ome

Affa

irs

Hum

an R

esou

rce

Dev

elop

men

t In

dust

ry

lDfo

rmat

ion

and

Bro

adca

stin

g La

bour

La

w a

nd J

ustic

e Pa

rlia

men

tary

Aff

ain

Peno

rmeJ

. P

ublic

Grie

vanc

:es

and

PeDS

ioDs

Peuo

leum

and

Nat

ural

Gas

PIaD

nin&

Prop

-am

me

Impl

emen

tatio

n Sc

ienc

e an

d Te

dmoJ

o&y

Stee

l an

d M

ines

Su

rfac

e Tr

ansp

ort

Text

iles

Urb

an D

evel

opm

ent

Wat

er R

aoun

:a

Wel

fare

A

tom

ic E

Der

I)'

EIec

trooi

cs

Oce

an D

eYel

opm

eat

Spac

e L

ok S

abba

R

ajya

Sab

ba

Secr

etar

iat

of V

ICe-

Pres

iden

t To

tal

time

take

n on

Dem

ands

for

Gra

nts

00

4

'-C

2748

Subj

ect

....

.. (

haja

b)

lor

19f19

.CJO

Supp

lem

eata

ry D

emaa

ds f

or

Gru

tl i

ll ra

pe

d o

f Ib

e 8

ud

pt

(Paa

jab)

for

198

8-89

eDiK

lDlc

d tO

Ftbe

r.

"

(II)

...

...

ill ~ '

" s.

.te '"

...

..

Dat

e of

D

ate

of

Pra

eata

tioo

Dbc

ussi

oo

17.3

.198

9

17.3

.198

9

21.3

.198

9 27

.3.1

989

21.3

.198

9

°Gen

eral

Disc

uIsio

a °D

isc:u

ssio

n aa

d vo

ting

00

D

eman

ds f

or G

rant

s on

Acc

ount

°Disc

ussio

n an

d vo

ting

00

Su

pple

men

tary

Dem

ands

for

G

rant

s (P

unja

b)

TUDe

...

.

H M

o

06

3 38

~

6. LEAVE OF ABSENCE

51. No. Name of Member Period for which Date when leave leave granted ganted

1. Smt. Prernalabai Chavan 30th November to 16th December, 1988

2. Smt. O.K. Bhandari 3rd November and 4th November and 15th November to 16th December, 1988.

3. Shri Srikantha Datta 21st February to Naralimharaja 15th March, 1989. Wadiyar

31st March, 19119.

4. Shri S.S. RamMimy 18th August to Padayac:hi 24th AulUS!,

29th August to 5th September, 2nd November to 4th November, 15th November to 16th December. 1988 and 21st February 10 24th February, 1989.

S. Shri A.B.A. Ghani Khan 23rd August, Choudhury 29th August to

5th September, 2nd November to 4th November, 15th November to 16th December, 1988 and 21st February to 7th March, 1989.

6. Shri Bhausaheb Thorat 21st February 10 10th March, 1989.

21

SI.

No.

•

Brie

f Su

bjec

t

1

Mot

ion

unde

r ru

le

3

1. Cc

Jnde

nmin

. aD

M.P

. SI

ai

191

Ari

f Mal

ad.

KIw

t. fo

r .. ~

to -

..It

Mia

iIter

of

Stat

e fo

r Pa

rtia

mea

t8y

Am

lin

1.

Rep

ort

of d

ie 0

:-'",,

-,,,,

342

OD

C

eaue

-Sta

te R

datio

aI

3. IaY

iciaa

die

Atto

mey

-GeD

eral

19

1 to

die

HoU

le t

o am

biI ~

derc

d op

iDio

a •

to w

heth

er o

r DO

t th

e 1b

Ub

r cO

+""'

j_.

doc:u

lDell

tl a.

id O

D th

e Ta

ble

CO

b-sti

tute

cI di

e fu

ll R

epor

t •

ca..

d b

y di

e Oo

wea

[t

7. M

0110

NS

(I)

M..

a.. ..

....

... ,

... 1

42

Nam

e of

Mem

ber

Dat

e <I

) of

Tu

ne

no m

oved

di

lcul

sion

take

n

4 5

6

Sbr

i H

.It.

L.

Bba

pt

15.3

.89

Sbri

Bula

SiD

P 30

.3.8

9 31

.3.8

9 4.

4.89

5.

4.89

Sbri

Indr

ajit

Gup

ta

4.4.

89

H

M

o 09

IS

38

o ~

Min

istry

I

Dep

artm

ent

cooc

erne

d

7

Rem

Mb •

Putia

meD

tary

Affa

irs

Ado

pted

Hom

e A

ffai

n

Hom

e A

fr.in

N

eptM

d

~

4.

Inte

rim

aacr F

JDal

Rep

orb

01 t

he

342

Thak

kar

Com

miI

Iioa

on

th

e as

ussi

oatio

n of

Sm

t. In

dira

G

aDdb

i. th

e la

te P

rime

Mia

ilter

ao

d th

e M

emor

aadu

m o

f A

ctio

n T

aken

thep

oa.

laid

OIl

the

Tabl

e of

the

Hou

se O

Il Ib

e 27

th M

arch

. 19

89

·S.

Con

dem

natio

n of

th

e bl

atlll

tl,

191

parti

san

attit

ude

of th

e G

o¥cm

or

of K

amat

aka

ia ia

itiatiD

s .:

tioa

apin

It

the

Stat

e O

o¥cr

ameo

t w

ithou

t Jiv

iaI o

ppor

tuD

ity t

o th

e C

hief

Min

iste

r of

the

Sta

te t

o de

moa

stra

te m

ajor

ity s

uppo

rt t

o

his

Min

iItr

y ill

the

AIIe

mbl

y ID

CI

dem

aod

for

rem

oval

of G

over

aor

01

Kam

atak

a fr

om

his

offic

e fo

rtIn

ritb

Sbri

Bul

a S

inp

Sbri

DiDe

Ib

GoI

wam

i

10.4

.89

11.4

.89

24.4

.89

25.4

.89

26.4

.89

8 10

H

ome

Affa

irs

9 56

H

ome

Affa

irs

Nep

tiY

ed

·DiI

cuac

d aI

oapi

th t

he S

labd

ory

RaoI

1dio

a ap

prov

iDa

the

proc

lam

atio

n iss

ued

UDde

r ut

icle

3S6

of

the

Coas

titudo

o ill

rel

atio

n to

the

Sta

te 0

1 1W

aata

b.

,

~

(I) ............... ,. ...

II •

• fill

...

.

51.

Mem

ber

Dat

e on

whi

ch

Tune

tak

en

Rem

arks

N

o.

Subj

ect

who

mov

ed

mot

ion

mov

ed

H

M

1. Su

spen

sion

of

Rul

e 32

of

the

Rul

es o

f Sh

ri B

asud

eb

14.3

.89

0 02

N

epti

ved

Proc

edur

e an

d C

ondu

ct o

f B

usin

ess

in

Ach

aria

Lo

t Sa

bha

in s

o fa

r as

it

prov

ides

for

th

e ti

nt h

our

of t

he s

ittin

g be

in& m

ade

avai

labl

e fo

r th

e as

king

and

ans

wer

ing

of q

uest

ions

to

ena

ble

the

Hou

se

to

discu

ss th

e R

epon

of t

he l

bakb

r.C

om-

mis

sion

w

bicb

sho

uld

be

laid

on t

he

Tabl

e or

the

Hou

se i

mm

edia

tely

~

2.

Susp

ensi

on o

f R

ule

32 o

f th

e R

ules

of

Shri

C.

Mad

bav

24.4

.89

0 m

N

epti

ved

Proc

:edun

: an

d C

ondu

ct o

f B

usin

ess

in

Red

dy

Lot

Sabh

a in

so

far

as i

t pr

ovid

es f

or

the

tint

hou

r of

the

sitt

in&

bei

ng m

ade

avai

labl

e fo

r as

king

and

' ans

wer

ing

of

ques

tions

to e

nabl

e th

e H

ouse

to d

iscus

s th

e de

velo

pmea

ts i

n K

.am

atak

a

SI.

No.

B

riel S

ubje

ct

(III

) M

....

1III

IIer

nile

374

....

. _

II II

.. 0

1 ..

....

...

Nam

e of

Min

iste

r w

ho m

oved

D

ate

on

whi

ch m

oved

2 3

4

_,. ..

wD

of th

e fo

llow

ing

58 m

elrib

er$

fOr

I. th

e fe

_ini

nc d

ays

of th

e w

eell

i.e.

15th

, Sh

ri H

. K

. L.

B

haga

l 15

th M

arch

, 19

89

16th

cl

17th

Mar

ch.

1989

of

the

13th

ses

sion

of

8dt

Lot

Sab

ba .

......... '

" 1.

'S

hri

C.

Mad

hav

Red

dy

2.

Shri

V.

Sobb

anad

rees

war

a R

ao

3.

Shr

i E

. A

yyap

u R

eddy

4.

Sh

ri B

ezaw

ada

Papi

Red

dy

S. Sh

ri S

riha

ri R

ao

6.

Shri

mat

i N

. P.

Jha

nsi

Labb

mi

7.

Dr.

T.

KaI

pana

Dev

i 8.

S

bri

o. B

hoop

athy

9.

S

bri

M.

Rap

uma

Red

dy

10.

Sbr

i M

anit

Red

dy

11.

Shri

A.

J. V

. B

. M

ahes

war

a R

ao

12.

Shri

P. A

ppal

anar

asim

ham

13

. Sh

ri C

. Sa

mbu

14

. D

r. G

. V

ijaya

Ram

a R

ao

IS.

SItri

H.

A.

Dor

a 16

. Sh

ri B

asud

eb A

char

ia

17.

Sbr

i A

jit

Kum

ar S

aba

18.

SItri

Baj

u Ba

n R

iyan

19

. SI

tri H

anna

n M

olla

h 20

. Sb

rim

ali

Bib

ha G

hosb

Gos

wam

i

TIm

e ta

ken

H

M

o : 0

6 5

Rem

arks

.6

Ado

pted

~

2 3

4 s

6

21.

SIIr

i Sy

ed M

.uda

I H

o.ai

a 22

. S

hri

ZIIiIa

eI A

bedi

D

23.

SIIr

i A

joy

Bil

wa

14.

Sbr

i Sa

""""

: M

isra

25

. D

r. Su

dIIir

Roy

26

. S

bri

AD

iI BM

u n.

S

bri

MatH

aI H

aDId

a 28

. Sb

ri Pu

ma

Cba

dra

Mal

ik

29.

Sbri

S.

J ...

. R

eddy

30

. SI

ui V

.S.

KriI

Ima

lyer

31

. Sb

ri R

am B

ab8d

ar S

iDp

32.

Sbr

i Th

Mnp

mt

'I'boi

D.s

33.

Sbr

i V

ijay

K ..

....

Mill

an

34.

Sbri

Iodn

jit G

upta

35

. Sb

rimad

Gila

Muk

hajc

e ~

36.

Sbr

i V

ajoy

Kum

ar Y

ldav

37

. S

bri

Raa

aahn

y Pr

asad

Sin

p 38

. S

hri

DiD

esh

Gan

ami

39.

Sbr

i Bb

adJC

SW'IiI

Taa

ti 40

. S

bri

Mub

iram

SaW

a 41

. S

IIri

PIIM

Bum

ao

42.

Sbr

i S

uat

Kum

ar M

mda

I 43

. S

bri

<lw

anji

t Si

nIh

Wal

ia

44.

Sbr

i Tu

Iocb

an S

iqb

Tur

45.

Sbri

C.

Jao

p R

eddy

46

. D

r. A

.X.

Pate

l 47

. S

bri

AJiIa

r R

oypr

adba

o 48

. Sb

ri C

lIitta

Mab

ata

49.

Dr.

A.

KaJ

aaid

bj

!IO.

Sbri

BaI

nDt

SiDab

Ram

oow

aIia

11.

51.

!ijlri D.B. Patil

52. Sbri Arif Mohammad Khan

53.

Shri Raj Kumar Rai

54.

Shri Ram Dban

~ Shri Ram Pujan Patel

St..

Shri Vidyacbaran Shukla

57.

Sho K. Manvendra Singh

58.

Shri Visltwanath Pratap Singh

Suspension of the following 5 members for

the remaining days of the week i.f.'. 15th.

1bth·& 17th March. 1989 of the 13th

session of 8th lok Sabha.

1. 2. 3. 4. 5.

Shri Somn.oIh Chauerjee

Shri Saifu",Jill Chowdhary

Shri K:P. llnnikrishnan

Shri V. Kishore Chandra S. Dco

Shri Nara}"n cboubey

Shri H.K.L

Bhapt

15th March.

1989

o 02

Adopted.

t..> -.J

•• 0

8rr

u,u

V I

lER

IlEN

Cr.

s

51.

Nam

e D

ate

of d

eath

D

ale

on w

hich

obi

tuar

y Ti

me

take

n N

o.

refe

renc

e m

ade

2 3

4 5 H

M

I.

Sbri

Vir

dha

Ram

Pbu

iwar

iya.

16

-12-

1988

(M

embe

r, 7

th L

ot

SabI

Ia)

2.

Sbri

Rat

aola

l B

rahm

an,

4-1-

1989

~

21-2

-198

9 0

04

(Mem

ber.

5th

Lo

t Sa

bba)

3.

Shri

Cha

pala

Kan

ta B

bau.

c:ba

rya.

16

-1-1

989

(Mem

ber.

2nd

. 3r

d .t.

4th

Lo

t Sa

bha)

Shri

Vas

antr

ao P

ati!,

1-

3-19

89

'»

4.

2-3-

1989

0

02

oc:

(Mem

ber.

7th

Lo

t Sa

bha)

S. Sh

ri C

hbut

tan

Lal.

8-3-

1989

1 0

03

(Mem

ber,

Sth

Lo

t Sa

bha)

17-3

-' ...

. )

27-3

-198

9

6.

Shri

Hem

wal

i N

anda

n B

ahup

lUl,

(M

eabe

r, 5

th.

6th

.t. 7

th L

ot

Sabh

a)

7. Sh

ri B

enoy

Kri

shna

Das

cbow

dbur

y,

25--2

-''189

\

0 03

(M

embe

r. 4

th &

5t

h Lo

ll Sa

bba)

31

-3-1

989

8. D

r. P

. Sr

iniv

asan

. 12

·3-1

989 ,

J (M

embe

r, 3

rd L

ok S

abha

)

9.

Shri

S.

M.

Josh

i, 1-

4-19

89

(Mem

ber,

4th

Lo

t Sa

bba)

3-

4-19

89

0 02

10.

Sbri Dbuam Bir SiIJ!Ia.

~~

(Member, 5th ct 7th Lot SalIba)

12-4-1989

0 03

11.

Sbri Ghayoor Ali Khan,

7-4-1989

(Member, 4th ct 7th Lot Sabha)

12· Sbri Awacp.eswar Praud SiDba,

27-3-1989

5-5-1989

0 02

(Member, . Provisional Parliament

and 1st Lot Sabba)

13.

5bri Manetlal Maganlal Gandhi,

8-5-1989

15-5-1989

(Member, 1st ct 2nd Lok Sabba)

0 02

~

t. PAPEIIS LAID ON THE TABLE

(a) By GovenuDeat ................ 1659 (b) By Private Members . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nil

10. PERSONAL EXPLANATION

NIIBC of Member

ClarifyiDa cerUin remarks..... Sml. V';'yuthiaWa &.Ii by Smt. Vyjayutbimala &.Ii ill the Ho.c OD lib Much, 1989 about 'NelIna C hswy ba'.

31

Date TIme taken

H M

9-3-1989 o 01

II. PETmONS

Prc:scnted by memberS Four

Dat

e of

A

ddre

ss

21.2

.198

9

Dat

es o

f di

scus

sion

on

Mot

ion

of T

hank

s

23.2

.198

9 24

.2.1

989

27.2

.198

9 28

.2.1

989

1.3.

1989

2.

3.19

89

3.3.

1989

11.

PRE

SID

£N'rS

AD

DRE

SS

Mem

bers

who

IJI

Oved

an

a-w

a:JO

ded

Shri

V.N

. G

adgi

l Sh

ri R

.L.

Bha

tia

No.

of

No.

of

Mot

ion

of

amen

dmen

ts

amen

dmen

ts

lban

ks

tabl

ed

carr

ied

adop

ted

on

403

3.3.

1989

Tim

e ta

ken

H

M

23

52

Pres

iden

t's

mes

sage

re

pone

d on

8.3.

1989

.... ....

S.No.

I.

13. PmVILEGE MA1TERS

Brief Subject

2

Name of the

member who

raised the

matter

3

OUCStioa qf"privilege against Shri Rajendra Shri Chiranji

Mathur. Cllirf Editor. Shri Surendra Pratap Lal Sharma

Singh. ElICCUtive Editor. Shri Ramesh

Chandra. PriRter and Publisher and Shri

Ramnh Gaur. City Correspondent ofNa\'·

bharat Tirrws' for allegedly publishing a

false neWli item about him under the cap-

tIon "Sharaab peekar gadi chala raha Sansad

giraftar.

~ on the front pa,e of its issue

dated I3tb.rlanuary. 1989.

Date on

wbicb

maner

broupt

before the

Houle

4

1.3.1989

lime

Taken

5

H M

o 05

Decision of the House

6

The Speaker informed the House that the Chief

Editor, Executive Editor, Printer and Publisher IDCI

the City Correspondent of the newspaper had teD-

dered unconditional apolocy for the inadvenant mis-

take wbicb had occurrred dee to similarity in the

names of Hoo'ble Member <tf Parliament aad the

offender and had also issued necessary c\arificalioa in

the issue of 'Navbharat Times' of 15th January. l_

aud h:ld pubtished apology OIl front paJe of tbe

newspaper OIl 16th January. 1989.

'The Speaker observed that since the -..........

bad already made adequate amends for tbe iaacha-

IMt lapse OIl its pan IDCI bad ~

deep repel.

be w .. treating the matter IS dosed. SbuiIII die

apy of the member. the Speaker ClulioDed die

prell that tile)' should be extremely careful ....

pubIiIbiDa news reports about the me.... a.d

should confirm the authenticity thereof befoft ...

50.

~

2. 3. 4.

Motion regarding Fourth Report of the Prof. Madhu

Committee of Privileges Presented to the Dandavate

House on 7th March. 1989.

Question of privilege against ISbri Mani

Ram Bapi. ell-MI'. for allegedly casting

reflectioos on the Speaker. the memben

and the House in a letter addressed to the

Speaker and published in Vur Arjun dated

3rd March. 1989.

Sbri Dharam

Pal Singh

Malik

9.3.1989

10.3.1989

Question of privilege against Sbri S.B. Prof. Madhu

29.3.1989

Chavan. Minister of finance for allegedly Dandavate

deliberately IIIisleadin& the House on 28th

Feburary.

~ durin& his Budget speech.

o 30

o 05

o 10

Prof. Madbu Dandavate moved the foUowiing motion

and spoke briefly :-

"That this House do consider the Forth Report

of the Committee of Privileges presented to the

House on the 7th March. 1989:'

After division. the motion was negatived.

The Speaker. after taking sense of the House refer-

red the matter to the Committee of Privileges for

investigation and report.

The speaker informed the House that the Minister of

~ in his comments had inur aJiII stated that

the pool account of Oil Coordination Committee

represented the surplus accruing to oil oompaaia

arising from the difference between sellin& prica 0(

petroleum products and retention prices allowed to

the companies.

As the Oil Coordination Committee kept their fuDdI

in deposit with Government since these were surplUi'

to their normal requirements. it was decided that. Rs.

2300 crores should be transferred from deposit

aocount as contribution to Government. The Minister

further stated that the overall deficit of Government

was computed taking into account the transactions of

the Consolidated Fund as weU as Public Account.

"" ....

2 3

4

s. Q

uest

ion

of

priv

ileJe

ap

iDIt

Shri

Bul

a Pr

of.

Mad

bu

3.4.

1989

Si

Dp,

M

inis

ter

of

Hom

e A

llain

fo

r D

mda

vate

, al

Iqed

Jy d

elib

erat

ely

mis

lead

iq th

e H

ouse

Sb

ri 1b

ampI

D

0.0 2

7th

Mar

cb, 1

989,

by

no

t pla

ciDa

011

the

"I:1Io

mII a

ad

Tab

le a

ll th

e vo

lum

es o

f 1b

illa

r Co

mm

is-Sb

ri C

. M

adha

v si

on R

epor

ts o

n th

e as

ussi

natio

n o

f Sm

t. R

eddy

In

dira

GaD

dbi,

form

er P

rim

e M

iDist

er.

5

4 .w

6

As

the

addi

tion

to

C

onso

lida

ted

Fuod

ha

d be

en

neut

ralis

ed b

y th

e re

duct

ion

in t

he P

ublic

ACC

IDUD

t, th

is tr

ansf

er t

rans

actio

n di

d no

t af

fect

the

ove

nII

defic

it of

the

Cen

tral

Gov

ernm

ent.

With

hold

ing

his

cons

ent

to. t

he r

aisi

ng o

f qu

aIio

a of

pri

vile

ge t

he S

peak

er o

bser

ved

that

aft

er C

8I'Cf

W

cons

ider

atio

n of

the

mat

ter,

he

was

sat

isfie

d ..

...

tile

Fina

Dc:e

Min

iste

r ha

d no

t co

ncea

led

any

infO

l"8l

8lio

8 fr

om t

he P

arli

amen

t an

d R&

d pu

t aJ

l th

e fK

ts o

a re

cord

. A

s su

ch,

the

ques

tion

of

delib

erat

ely

IIIiII

e8d-

ing

the

Hou

se a

nd t

here

by c

omm

ittin

g a

breI

IdI

01 il

l pr

ivile

ae d

id o

ot a

rise

.

The

Spea

ker

adde

d th

at w

hile

it

was

tru

e dl

at ...

tra

DSf

er t

id n

ot

affe

ct t

he o

vera

ll de

fici

t, it

wou

ld

~

have

bee

n m

ore

appr

opri

ate

if t

he s

urpl

us i

D th

e ac

coun

t ba

d no

t be

en

utili

sed,

ev

en

part

idy,

to

offl

et t

he r

even

ue d

efic

it. I

t w

as,

how

ever

, eo

tirel

y fo

r th

e G

oYem

men

l to

dec

ide

the

man

ner

in w

IIicb

th

e bu

dget

pro

poul

s w

ere

to b

e pr

epar

ed m

d til

e H

ouse

had

the

fin

al a

utho

rity

to

appr

ove,

mod

ify o

r re

ject

the

m.

1be

Spea

ker

gave

con

sent

to

Prof

. M

adhu

Dan

dava

te

to

raise

th

e qu

esti

on

of

priv

ilege

. Pr

of.

Mad

bu

Dao

dava

te t

hen

aske

d fo

r th

e le

ave

of t

he H

ouse

to

rais

e th

e qu

esti

on o

f pr

ivile

ge.

As

no o

bjec

tion

was

ta

ken,

the

Spe

aker

inf

orm

ed t

he H

QUse

tha

t le

ave

bad

been

gra

nted

. Se

vera

l m

embe

n to

ok p

an in

the

de

bat.e

. A

fter

di

scus

sion

, Pr

of.

Mad

hu

Dan

dava

te

mov

ed t

he f

ollo

win

g m

otio

n :-

6. Shouting of slogans from the Visitors'

Gallery.

~ Question of privilege against Shri Buta

Singh. MioisIer of Home Affairs for

allegedly mis1eading the House on 8th

May, 1989, while replying to the discussion

regarding communal situation in various

parts of the country.

Shri V.

Kishore

Chandra

S.Deo.

21.4.1989

15.5.1989

o 02

o 03

"That this House is of the oplDlOD that the

Home Minister, Shri Buta Singh has committed a

breach of privilege of the House in deliberately

misleading the House by not laying on the Table

of the House complete report of the Thakkar

Commission regarding assassination of Shrimati

Indira Gandhi."

The motion was negatived'.

The Deputy Speaker ipfonned tbe House that a

visitor who shouted slogans from the Visitors"

Gallery at about 14.40 hours, had been taken into

custody by the Director. Security, immediately and

~ him. The visitor had made a statement

but had not expressed regret for his actioo. On a

motion moved by the Minister of State in the

Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs, the House resolved

that the visitor had committed a grave offence and

was guilty of the contempt of the House. The House

further resolved that he be kept in the custody Of the

Director. Security, tiU the rising of the House and

thereafter released with a stem warning.

Withholding his consent to ralSmg the question of

privilege, the Speaker observed that on going through

the proceedin,s of 1.ok Sabha dated the 8th May.

1989, he did not come across any reference made by

the Minister of Home Affairs regarding the constitu-

tion of a Division Bench for hearing the Babri

... -.I

2 3

4 5

6

Mas

jid-R

am J

anam

bhoo

mi

disp

ute.

The

Min

iste

r ba

d in

fa

ct

stat

ed

that

tb

c C

entr

al

Gov

ernm

eat

bad

ditc

ussi

oDs

with

the

Gov

ernm

ent

of U

nar

Prad

ab

rega

rdin

g th

e sa

id d

ispu

te a

nd it

was

sug

geste

d th

at a

D

ivis

ion

Ben

eb o

f th

e A

llah

abad

Hig

h C

ourt

CO

ID-

pris

ing

of t

hree

jud

ges

mip

t be

ar t

he c

ae.

The

Spea

ker

adde

d th

at i

nste

.p o

f M

inis

ter

of

Hom

e A

ffairs

bav

ina m

islea

d th

e H

ouse

, it

appe

ared

to

be

a ca

se o

f m

isrep

ortiD

a th

e pr

oc:e

edin

p of

the

HOUl

e by

the

sai

d ne

wsp

aper

and

Sbr

i D

eo p

1acio

& to

tal

relia

oce

on t

he p

ress

rep

orts

with

out

verif

ying

th

e sa

me

from

th

e re

cord

s of

th

e HO

Ule.

The

Spea

ker

empb

aIiz

ed

that

m

embe

rs

shou

ld

befo

re

mak

ing

alle

ptio

os,

veri

fy

the

corr

ectn

ess

ther

eof

~

inst

ead

of

plad

ng i

mpl

icit

faitb

011

pr

ess

repo

rts.

14. QVIBI'IONS

(I) __ Qr d-

(a) Number of QuoatioaI put dowD ill Queaioa UItI for Oral '"949 AaIweI'I.

(b) Number of QueItioaa orally auawcred. 306

(ii) SIIart NadcIe Qr d-

(a) Number of QuesIioaa put dowD ill Short Notice <Neatioa UItI.

(b) Number of Short Notice 0ueIti0III orally ~

(iii) U ........... ~

2

2

(a) Number of QuesIioaa put dowD ill 0uati0D U. for writteD •• 8P70 Answen.

(b) Number of QucatioDa for wbic:h writteD aDIWCII were laid iD!;lud-ina thole put dowD for Oral ~ but DCJt ~ for Oral AnsweR.

'·1DdudeI 37 Starred 0uesti0DI witbclrawD/poetpoaed/deJeted/tnlllferrecl'from ODe MiDiItry to aaotber.

··lDdudea 192 UIlltarrCd Quaao. witbdnwa/deleted/trllllllllerred 110m ODe MiDiItry WI aDOtber.

39

51.

Brie

f Su

bjec

t N

ame

of

the

Mem

ber

who

D

ate

MiD

iIby/

T

uae

takeD

N

o.

raile

d th

e di

scuI

IIioo

D

epar

tmea

t H

n. M

b.

1. ~ o

f N

atio

MI

Com

miI

Iioa

Sh

ri S

bara

d Di

abc

1.3.

89

Urb

an D

eveI

opm

eat

0 4,

O

D U

rtw

iuri

oa

2.

Strik

e by

Re.

e.ri

I 1C

boIu

s.0I

AU

IDdia

Sb

ri C

baad

ra P

rata

p 8-

3-89

H

ealth

apd

fam

ily W

elfu

e 0

51

IDIti

tute

01

Med

ic:aJ

Sci

eDI:a

. N

an

ia S

iD8b

3.

F"1D

UICi

aI A

rIiItI

lDCe

to

Itefu

aees

from

Sb

ri J

aaak

1Uj

Gup

ta

15.3

.89

Hom

e A

ffai

rs

0 39

Pa

k-«X

Upi

ed A

lar

01 J8

111111

11 aa

d 1C

aIIm

ir.

4.

Sbo

rt Sa

ppIJ

01. ~

Sbri

Sha

nd D

iabc

29.3

.89

Food

ad

CM

I Su

pplie

s 0

51

~

5.

Dne

Iopm

eat

fJl F

Ifuce

tion

ill B

orde

r Sb

ri V

udbi

CIu

mde

r la

iD

12.4

.89

HWIW

I Re

sour

ce

0 34

•

Ala

r .

Dev

eIop

mea

t

51.

Nam

e of

Mem

ber

No.

1.

Sbri

Ra

jmu

pl

PaDd

e

2.

Sbr

i R

. A

n ....

..... b

i

3.

Sbr

i P.

Pen

dI.lt

i.b

15.

IID

IGN

A11

0N B

Y M

EMB

EItS

Stat

e C

OIII

titue

ocy

Dat

e fr

om w

bidl

ac

cqJt

ed b

y Sp

eake

r

U.P

. D

eori

a 12

.1.1

989

TU

lii N

D

PoIa

:hi-

(SC

) 2.

2.19

89

ADdb

ra .

....

. N

eDar

e-{S

C)

7.4.

1989

Rem

arb

AJm

ouoc

emeo

t m

ade

by S

peak

er i

n th

e H

ouse

011

21

.2.1

989

AIm

ouD

cem

eDl

IDId

e by

D

qNty

Sp

eake

r in

the

Hou

se o

n 7.

4.19

89

~

" 16

. Il

ISO

LUI'I

ON

S

51.

Subj

ect

Nam

e of

N

o.

mem

ber

who

m

oved

"I.

App

rova

l of

rec

omm

enda

tions

mad

e in

Sb

ri M

adha

vrao

pa

ras

9 to

12

c:oo

tain

ed i

n th

e Th

irte

enth

Sc

indi

a R

epor

t of

the

Rai

lway

Con

vent

ion

Com

mitt

ee,

1985

. pr

esen

ted

on 2

2.2.

89

Dat

e of

m

ovin

g an

d di

scus

sion

17.3

.89

TIm

e M

inis

tryl

R

emar

ks

take

n D

epar

tmen

t co

ncer

ned

H

M

1 22

R

ailw

ays

Ado

pted

"Dilc

usse

d aI

onpi

th (

i) D

eman

ds f

or G

rant

s in

res

pect

of t

he B

udge

t (R

ailw

ays)

for

198

9-90

and

(ii)

Sup

plem

enta

ry D

eman

ds fo

r G

rant

s (R

ailw

ays)

for

19

88-8

9.

... N

SI.

No.

S

ubje

ct

~ I

Nam

e of

mem

ber

sec:t

ion o

f w

ho m

o¥ed

eo

..tit

ulio

o I

Act

'

2 3

4

1.

App

rova

l of

the

DO

Iifi<:

abon

of

Se

ctio

n 3(

6)

Sbr

i B

uta

Sin

p

the

Gov

ernm

ent

of I

ndia

in

the

of t

he

Min

istry

of

Hom

e A

ffai

n N

o.

Com

miss

ions

of

S.O

. 22

3(E)

da

ted

the

23rd

lD

quiry

Act

. 19

52

Mar

ch,

1989

, by

wbi

cb th

e no

tifi·

catio

n of

th

e G

ovet

1llll

CDt

of

Indi

a in

the

M

inis

try

of H

ome

Aff

ain

No.

S.

O.

260(

E)

date

d th

e 15

th

May

. 19

86

bas

been

ra

cind

ed.

2.

Dis

appr

oval

of

th

e In

com

e-ta

x A

rtic

le 1

23

(Am

endm

eDt)

O

rdin

ance

. 19

89

(0rd

iDan

ce N

o.1

of 1

989)

"'3.

App

rova

l of

th

e Pr

ocla

mat

ion

Art

icle

356

iss

ued

by t

he

Pres

iden

t on

the

21

st A

pril,

19

89.

unde

r ar

ticle

35

6 of

the

Con

stitu

tion

in r

ela·

tio

n to

the

Sta

te o

f K

amat

aka.

Shri

C. J

up

R

eddy

Shr

i So

otos

b M

oban

Dev

Dat

e(s)

of

movin

& aD

d di

scus

sion

5

27.3

.89

28.3

.89

29.3

.89

24.4

.89

25.4

.89

26.4

.89

'Di5C

US1iC

d aI

ongw

itb t

he I

JlOtio

n fo

r co

nsid

erat

ion

of t

he I

ncom

e·tax

(A

men

dmen

t) B

ill,

1989

. Tim

e ta

ken

6 H

M

o 01

22

3

1008

Min

istr

y I

Dep

artm

ent

conc

erne

d

7

Hom

e A

ffai

rs

Fana

nee

Hom

e A

ffai

rs

Rem

arks

8

Ado

pted

Neg

ativ

ed

Ado

pted

"Dis

cuss

ed a

JoD

gwith

the

mot

ion

by S

hri D

ines

h G

osw

ami.

M.P

. re

gard

ing

parti

san

attit

ude

of G

over

nor o

f K

arna

taka

and

his

rem

oval

fro

m t

be o

ffic

e of

G

over

DO

l'.

~

\H

4.

2 3

App

rova

l of

thr

con

tinua

nce

Art

icle

in

for

ce o

f th

r Pr

odaI

aatio

a 35

6 da

ted

11.5

.198

7 in

rel

atio

n to

the

Sta

te o

f Pu

njab

iII

ued

UDde

r ar

ticle

356

of

the

Coa

stitu

tioD

by

the

Prai

deat

fo

r a

farth

er p

erio

d of

•

moo

tbs

with

effe

ct .

...

11.5

.198

9.

4

Shri

But

a Si

ngh

5

8.5.

89

9.5.

89

6

4 57

7 8

Hom

e A

ffai

n A

dopt

ed

~

(II)

...

....

....

ben

RaD

Iatio

n

51.

Subj

ect

N_

of

Mem

ber

Dat

e(I)

of

movm

, TI

IDC

Min

istr

y I

Rem

ub

No.

w

bo I

IIO'fe

d aa

d di

Icua

ioo

tUcn

D

epar

tmen

t

H

M

1.

1_-1

-m

.-ti

oa

of

New

SI

Iri S

c.ud

a R

atb

19.8

.198

8 1

18

Prop

-am

me

Nep

tMd

2.9.

1988

(eK

IudiD

a Im

plem

enta

tion

(Ele

veD

th S

aIio

a)

7 bo

urs

18.1

1.19

88

IDd

31

2.12

.198

8 m

imat

a (I

'weI

ftb S

eIIio

D)

take

n du

riDa

3.3.

1989

E

leve

ntb

aad

Twel

fth

SeII

ioD

s)

1.

Gui

detio

eI f

or I

ppO

iDbn

eat

an 5

. Jm

pu I

Wdy

3.

3.19

89

3 33

La

w a

nd

Nep

tMd

.,. an

d tr

uIIf

er o

f G

oYen

aon.

17

.3.1

989

Just

ice

\A

3.

Mea

sure

s to

COD

troI

Dr.

ICnI

pMiD

dbu

BbGi

31

.3.1

989

7 41

H

ealth

and

D

iscu

ssio

n po

pula

tion

apIo

Iion

. 1

2.4

.1_

Fa

mily

no

t 28

.4.1

9119

W

elfa

re

conc

lude

d

Sl.

Subject

Uader

Name of member

Date(s) of

Time ..

Mioistryl

Remarks

No.

NIe

who raised the

discuaion

taken

Department

discussion

concerned

2 3

4 5

6 7

(I

H M

1. SituaIioa ..... out of me settle-

193

Prof. Madhu

22.2.89

2 00

Industry

DiscussiOli ~

IIIIIlt between abe ~

Dandavate

(Department

cooduded

of Iadia BOd abe multiDational

of Chemicals

COIIIpIUIy Uaioa Carbide for pay-

aod Petro-

mall of COIIIpC8IIItion to the vic-

chemicals)

tm. of the BhoPal gas tragedy.

2. Situation ariIiaI GUt of the ~

193

Shri B.R Bhapt

5.4.89

2 52

HOlM Affairs

.eo.

ported Delnll belWCeO AfIhan re-

6.4.89

~

bela BOd Ia1tJriIU in Puajab.

4i3.

Situation arisin& out of the apta-

193

Shri Olintamani

19 .... 89

5 36

Home Affain.

tioo for a sqNIrate Slate Iauached

JeBa

20.4.89

by the All Bodo Studeats' Union

BOd the IdioD takca by the

GoveIlllDCDl iD dial reprd.

4.

Commlllllll situation in

193

Sbri BaJwant Sin&h 24.4.tI'J

10 51

Home Affairs

various parts of the country.

RamoowaIia

2.5.89

3.5.89

4.5.89

5.5.89

8.5.89

5. 6.

Stat

emea

t m

ade

by t

he M

inis

ter

of S

tate

in

the

Min

istr

y of

Per

-so

nnel

. Pu

blic

G

rieva

nces

an

d Pe

nsio

ns i

n th

e H

OU

K

on

the

19th

A

pril.

19

89

repr

ding

Ii

bera

lisat

ioo

of

orde

n w

ith

• vi

ew to

impr

oviD

& th

e re

prel

Cnt

a-tio

D of

Sc

bedu

led

Cas

tes

and

Scbe

cIuIed

Tri

bes

com

mUD

ities

in

Cel

ltrai

G

over

nmen

t Po

sts I

Serv

ices

.

Stat

emen

t m

ade

by

the

Prim

e M

inis

ter

in

the

HO

UK

on

th

e 28

th

Apr

il,

1989

re

prdi

ng

J.w

ahar

Roz

pr Y

ojna

.

7.

Atr

ociti

es o

n W

omen

.

·8.

Situ

atio

n an

sanl

l ou

t of

ac

ute

short

a&e

of

drink

iD&

wat

er

in

vari

ous

part

s o

f th

e C

OIII

Itry ..

the

step

s ta

ken

by t

he G

over

n-m

ent

in t

hat

rqar

d.

193

193

193

193

Sbri

E.

Ayy

apu

Red

dy

4.5.

89

11.5

.89

12.5

.89

Sbri

V.

Sobb

anad

ree&

-8.

5.89

W

arB

R

ao

Sbri

Bal

wan

t Si

nBh

12.5

.89

RaDt

oowa

1ia

Shri

Hui

sh R

awat

12

.5.8

9

6 04

15

8

2 09

2 41

Peno

nnel

, Pu

blic

G

riev

ance

s an

d Pe

nsio

ils

Api

cultu

re

(Dep

artm

ent

of R

ural

D

evel

opm

ent)

Dis

cuss

ion

not

cood

uded

·

Hum

an R

esou

rce

Disc

ussio

n D

evel

opm

ent

not

conc

lude

d (D

epar

tmen

t of

W

omen

and

aU

ld

Dev

elop

men

t)

Urb

an

Disc

:uss

ioo

Dev

elop

men

t no

t oo

oclu

ded

@A

s de

cide

d by

the

Hou

se o

n 11

.4.1

989.

Cal

linll

Atte

ntio

n on

the

sub

ject

was

con

vert

ed i

nto

di8c

ussio

n un

der

rule

193

. •

As

deci

ded

by. t

he B

usin

ess

Adv

isor

y C

omm

ittee

, Ca

llina

Att

enti

on c

onve

rted

int

o •

diIa

iaio

D U

Dde

r ru

le 1

93.

~ ....

11. SITI1NGS OF LOIt SABIIA

51. Subject No.

1. CaoceUatiOD of IlittiDp of Lok Sabha on 20th. 21st IDd 23rd March. 1989.

2. CaoceUatiOD of aittiD& of Lok Sabba on the 17th April. 1989.

3. Fiution of additional IlittiDp of Lot Sabha up to Mooday. the 15th MIIy. 1989.

Date on Remarks which

decided

2.3.1989 BUIineu Advilory Committee in their Sixty·Sinh Report inter-alia recom-mended canceUation of sittinp of Lot Sabba fixed for 20th. 21st IUld 23rd March. 1989. On the motion moved by Sbri H.K.L. Bhapt. the report was adopted by the HoUle. .

11.4.1989 Business Advisory Committee in their Sixty-ninth Report inter-alill recom-mended canceUation of sitting of Lok Sabha fixed for 17th April. 1989. On the motion moved by Sbri H.K.L. Bhagat. the report was adopted by the HoUle.

10.5.1989 Motion regarding extension of sittinp of Lok Sabba moved by Shri H.K.L. Bbapt was adop&cd by the HOUle.

48

.t. SPIt.\KEIl/DEPUTY SPEAJaUl/CIIAIDUN AaaeuncemeatslObse"atlonllllefereaca

51. Subject By whom No.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

Announcement regarding adjournment of the House at 4.30 P.M. on 28.2.1989 to re-assemble at 5 P.M. for the preaentation of the General Budget. Announcement regarding decision of the Speaker to seek the advice of the Attorney-General as to wbat constituted the complete report of tbe Coauniuion of Inquiry beaded by Justice Thakkar on the assassina-tion at the late Prime Minister (Smt. IDdira Gandhi). Announcement regarding fortnation of "lanata Dal Legislature Party in Lok Sabba". Observations regarding certain allegations of a per-sonal character made against the Speaker in a section of the press. Observations regarding appointment of Shri P. Kolandaivelu as OJairman of Public Accounts Com-mittee fur 1989-90.

49

Speaker

Deputy Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Speaker

Date

28.2.1989

28.3.1989

11.4.1989

8.5.1989

15.H989

a. STATEMENTS (I) se ................. by MIaIIIen .... Rule 372

SI. Subject Name of Minister No.

2 3

1. Correcting the answer Jiven on 1 De- Shri Shyam Lal cember. 1988 to Starred Question No. Yadav 29S reprding animal and bird sac:rifice by Shri Paruram Bhardwaj.

2. Government Buaineu for tbe week Smt. Sheila Dikahit commencing the 27th FebNlry. 1989.

3. Accidents involvin,: Shri Mahabir Pruad

(i) 3 UP Nainpur-Howbagh-Jabalpur Narrow Gauge Paueqer train on 26th FebNlry. 1989; and

(ii) 413 UP Mokama-Patna Pauenger and 328 Down Oanapur-Howrah Flit Paueaaer traiDs on 26th Feb-ruary. 1989.

4. Qarifying certain remarks made by the Shrimati Sheila Prime Minister during Question hour on Dikahit '1:1.2.89.

S. Clarifying certain remarks made by tbe Shri Rajiv Gandbi Prime Minister during the Question Hour on 27th FebNlry. 1989.

6. Fire that took place at Semiconductor Shri K. R. Naray-Comptell Ltd.. Chandigarh. anan

7. Government BuainCD for the week Shri H.K.L. Bhagat commencin, the 7tb March. 1989.

8. Change in Government Business to be Shri H.K.L. Bhagat tranaac:ted in Lok Sabha.

9. Government Buaineu for the week Smt. Sheila Dibhit commencina Monday. the 13th March. 1989.

·10 Launching of the Home Loan Ac:c:ount Sbri Eduardo Scheme by the National HoUlin, Bank. Faloiro

11. Attaining of aiticality of Narora Shri K.R. Naray-Atomic Power Plant. anan

12. Delay in pretCIltation of Puajab Budget Shri H.K.L. Bhagat for 1989-90.

13. Price policy of raw jute and raw cotton Shri Bbajan LaI for the 1989-90 1eIIOII.

14. Decision to lay 011 the Jeble Repon of Shri Rajiv Gandhi the Thakkar Commiuion regardina auauination of Smt. Indira Gaadhi.

IS. Change in the Propamme of diIcusaion Shri. P. NlIDIYaI and votilll of Demands· for Grants of Ministriea.

• AIIo laid on the'" Table a note containiq details of the ICbeme.

Date

4

Tune taken

H. M 23.2.89 0 01

24.2.89 0 11

27.2.89 0 04

27.2.89 0 01

28.2.89 0 03

1.3.89 0 02

3.3.89 0 06

8.3.89 0 01

10.3.89 o 13

13.3.89 o 03

o 01

o 01

16.3.89 o 03

17.3.89 o 02

27.3.89 o 02

2 J

16. Government BusiDelS for the week Sbri H.K.L. Bhagat comrneocing the 3rd April, 1989

17. Withdrawal of mouey from the Contin- Shri SontOlh gency Fund of India for depositing in Mohan Dev the Delhi Hip Court in compliance of the order dated 30th January, 1989 in Execution' cue No. IS8/88 "Abdul Wahid and Others-Vs-Union of India".

18. Change in the Sugar Licensing Policy Shri Sukh Ram for the Seventh Plan period.

19. Implementation of pre-arrallled Prof. K.K. Tewary aa:ommodation scheme at Makkab arid Madinah for Haj 1989.

20. Government Buaiuess for the week Shri H.K.L. Bhagat collllN!ncing the 10th April, 1989.

21. Government Business for the week Shri H.K.L. Bhapt commencing the 19th April, 1989.

22. Strike by Port and Dock worken in Sbri Rajesh Pilot major ports.

23. Liberalisation of orden with a view to Shri P. Chidam-improving the representation of baram Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes communities in Central Government Posts/Services.

24. Accident involving No. 927 Down Ban- Sbri galore-New Delhi Kamataka Express on Prasad 18.4.89.

Mahabir

25.

--26.

27.

28.

29. 30.

31.

Government Business' for the week commeocing the 24th April, 1989. Dissolution of Kamataka Legislative Asaembly. Operation of the National Security (Amendment) Act, 1987. Government Buaineu for the week commencing tbe 2nd May, 1989. Jawabar Rozpr Yojana. Government' Business for the remaining part of the 1eIIion. Government', decision to releue an inataimcnt, of Additional Deame .. AUownace to the Central Government Employees w.e.f. 1.1.89

Sbri H.K.L. Bbapt

Sbri Buta Singh

Shri Buta Singh

Sbri H.K.L. Bhagal

Sbri Rajiv Gandhi Smt Sheila Dibhit Sbri B.K. Gadbvi

4

31.3.89

4.4.89

.5.4.89

5.4.89

7.4.89

12.4.89

19.4.89

19.4.89

19.4.89

21.4.89

21.4.89

27.4.89

28.4.89

28.4.89 .5 . .5.89

11 . .5.89

s H. M o 10

o 01

o 04

o 02

o 12

o 10

o OS

o 03

o 06

o .5 o 06

o 03

o 12

o 08 o 01

o 02

•• Also laid on the Table a copy of the Proclamation dated the 2bt April, 1989 illued UDder article 356 of the Conatitution in relation to the State of Kamataka and order dated the 211t April, 1989 made by the President in purIIIIIDCe bf sub-dauae (i) of clause (c) of the Proclamation.

Also laid a copy of the Report dated 19.4.1989 aDd -.ublequent IIICIIIIIC of the Governor of Kamatab to thePrelident.

.51

(I) sa. N.me of the Member

Certaill rmwb IHde by 8 Member Shri C. JIDga Reddy in tbe HoUIC OD 7th Mardl, 1989 about tbe raoIutioos adopted by Bberatiya JIData Party.

(II) MIdIIn Vader ... m (8) Number of Matten railed .... 298

Date

9.3.1989

Tune taken

H M o 01

(b) PoIitiOD reprdina receipt of replies from Minilten concerned as 00-

22.6.1989.

Fint SeaIiOD Sec:ood SeIIiOD 1bird Seaion Fourth SeaiOD f1ftb SeuiOD Sistb SeaIioa Seveatb ScIaiOD Eilbth SeaiOD (Part I) Eiptb SeIIioo (Part m NiDtb SeuioD Tenth SCIIion Eleventh ScaiOD TweUth SeIIiOD 'I'bbteeatb SIIIioa

Total DUIIlber of Number of repliea matten railed aent to Memben by

Minister & . oopiea endoned to Lot Sabba Secretariat

61 61 351 34S 158 151 ISO 145 330 30S 149 135 178 161

341 278 147 128 178 137 362 2S5 153 108 180 123 298 124

52

Percenta&e of replies sent to the Memben by the· MinisteR

. 100 98.3 96.2 96.6 92.4 90.6 90.4

8U 87.0 76.9 70.4 70.6 68.3 42.6

21. STATEMENT SHOWING TIME TADN ON VAIlIOOS laNDS or BUSINESS

BUliDell TIme Percentqe. to taken the total time

taken

BILLS H M (a) Government Bills ·35 04 10.9 (b) Private Members' Bills 12 17 3.8,

BUDGETS (a) Railway Budget @22 20 7.0 (b) General Budget 50 11 15.6 (c) Budget in respect of State 3 44 1.2

under President's rule CALLING AlTENTION NOTICES (Rule 197) 5 30 1.7 DISCUSSIONS

(a) Half-an·Hour Discussions (Rule 55) 3 54 1.2 (b) Short Duration DiscllSSions (Rule 193) 34 11 10.7

MA lTERS UNDER RULE 377 7 15 2.3 MOTIONS

(a) Motions under rule 191 and 342 ·24 20 7.6 (b) Motions under rule 388 0 09

PRESIDENT'S ADDRESS 23 52 7.5 QUESTIONS 41 44 13.0 RESOLUTIONS

(a) Government Resolutions @ (b) Statutory Resolutions ·15 06 4.7 (c) Private Members' ResolutioDl 12 32 3.9

STATEMENTS (Rule 372) 2 34 0.8 OTIlER MA lTERS such as Oath or 26 04 8.1

Affirmation, papers laid on the Table, Obituary References, Questions of Privilege, Points of Order. Personal ExplanatioDS etc.

320 47 100.0

·(1) Joint discussion took place on a Statutory Resolution (ViM Statement No. 16 (ii) SI. No, 2) and Motion for Consideration of theCOMected Government Bill [ViM Statement No.2 SI. No.4). Time taken on joint discussion bas been shown UDder Government Bills.

(2) Joint discussion took place on a Statutory Resolution (ViM Statement No. 16(ii) SI. No.3) and a Motion by Shri Dinesh Ooswami, M.P. (Vldt' Statement No.7 SI. No.5). Time taken on joint discussion has been shown under Statutory Resolutions.

@(l) Joint discussion took place on (i) I Government Resolution [ViM Statement No. 16(i) SI. No.1) (ii) Demands for Grants in respect of Budget (Railways) for 1989-90 and (iii) Supplementary Demands for Grants (Railways) for 1988-89. Time laken on joint discussion has been shown under Railway Budget.

(2) Joint discussion took place on Demands for Excess Grants (Railways) for 1986-87 [ViM Statement No. 51 and Motion for Conaideration of a Government Bill [Vide Statement No.2 SI. No.1). Time taken on joint discussion has been showl\ under Government Bills.

53