review open access treading & threading memories: a ... · review open access treading &...

17
REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé L Zent Abstract This brief essay, which represents the third editorial of the series "Recollections, Reflections, and Revelations: Ethnobiologists and their First Time in the Field", captures a few memories of the author's first fieldwork in the Venezuelan rainforest. It is a collage of objects, subjects, feelings, spaces, and events that pendulate in spheres of meaning straddling between the author's identities as both a student and a woman. The author's evocations of fifteen years ago are diluted in lasting reflections about what could be ethnoecology embraced by spaces of interactions and associations between organisms and their surroundings. Keywords: Ethnoecology, Ethnobotany, Fieldwork, Amazon, Jotï, Amerindian, Evocations Resumen Este breve texto, que representa el tercer editorial de la serie Recuerdos, Reflexiones y Revelaciones: Etobiólogos y su Primera Salida de campo, atrapa algunos recuerdos del primer trabajo de campo del autor en la selva amazónica venezolana. Constituye un entramado de objetos, sujetos, sentimientos, espacios y sucesos que pendulan en esferas de significados cabalgando entre las identidades del autor como estudiante y como mujer. Las evocaciones del autor de hace 15 años se diluyen en reflexiones que perduran acerca de lo que podría ser etnoecología abrazada por espacios de interacciones y asociaciones entre los organismos y sus entornos. Ethnoecology entrapped me by its fascinating eclectic and transdisciplinary qualities. Not just theoretical and applied initiatives are inherently articulated in ethnoecology, but also different epistemologies, events and life encounters, such as evocations [1]. These traits manifest themselves in the dynamics of selecting interesting problems, hypotheses and methods. Even the utterance of what ethnoecology means takes more than a few words when someone raises the simple question: what do you do? In a nutshell, ethnoecology was for me a good pretext to live a text and appreciate the contexts of how people and their environ- ments interrelate. This paper hopes to provide a text about the context that gave meanings to my pretext to live among the Jotï, an Amerindian group of about 1000 persons scattered in Amazon and Bolívar States of the Venezuelan rainforest ([2,3] see http://ivic.academia.edu/ Zent). Due to space limitations, here I explore just three key issues: (1) articulation of personal and academic life; (2) alterity, in a biocultural setting very different from where I was raised; and (3) relativity of notions, values and principles. Context In April 1996, Stanford, my life and academic partner, and I, initiated a three-year long ethno-ecological field- work among the Jotï in their stretch of high forest terri- tory located in the Sierra Maigualida (Figure 1). The Jotï, as well as their homeland, were at the time little known in the scientific community. Published reports of the Jotï appeared for the first time in 1969 [4-6], and some ethnological studies were conducted during the 70s and 80s [7-15]. By the mid 90s however, just 11 references Correspondence: [email protected] Laboratory Human Ecology, Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones Científicas, Panamericana km 11 Ado 20632, Altos de Pipe, edo. Miranda, Venezuela JOURNAL OF ETHNOBIOLOGY AND ETHNOMEDICINE © 2013 Zent.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

Upload: others

Post on 27-Dec-2019

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

JOURNAL OF ETHNOBIOLOGY AND ETHNOMEDICINE

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

REVIEW Open Access

Treading & threading memories: a personalencounter with forest and people inSouthern VenezuelaEgleé L Zent

Abstract

This brief essay, which represents the third editorial of the series "Recollections, Reflections, and Revelations:Ethnobiologists and their First Time in the Field", captures a few memories of the author's first fieldwork in theVenezuelan rainforest. It is a collage of objects, subjects, feelings, spaces, and events that pendulate in spheres ofmeaning straddling between the author's identities as both a student and a woman. The author's evocations offifteen years ago are diluted in lasting reflections about what could be ethnoecology embraced by spaces ofinteractions and associations between organisms and their surroundings.

Keywords: Ethnoecology, Ethnobotany, Fieldwork, Amazon, Jotï, Amerindian, Evocations

Resumen

Este breve texto, que representa el tercer editorial de la serie “Recuerdos, Reflexiones y Revelaciones: Etobiólogos ysu Primera Salida de campo”, atrapa algunos recuerdos del primer trabajo de campo del autor en la selvaamazónica venezolana. Constituye un entramado de objetos, sujetos, sentimientos, espacios y sucesos quependulan en esferas de significados cabalgando entre las identidades del autor como estudiante y como mujer.Las evocaciones del autor de hace 15 años se diluyen en reflexiones que perduran acerca de lo que podría seretnoecología abrazada por espacios de interacciones y asociaciones entre los organismos y sus entornos.

Ethnoecology entrapped me by its fascinating eclectic andtransdisciplinary qualities. Not just theoretical and appliedinitiatives are inherently articulated in ethnoecology, butalso different epistemologies, events and life encounters,such as evocations [1]. These traits manifest themselves inthe dynamics of selecting interesting problems, hypothesesand methods. Even the utterance of what ethnoecologymeans takes more than a few words when someone raisesthe simple question: what do you do? In a nutshell,ethnoecology was for me a good pretext to live a text andappreciate the contexts of how people and their environ-ments interrelate. This paper hopes to provide a textabout the context that gave meanings to my pretext to liveamong the Jotï, an Amerindian group of about 1000

Correspondence: [email protected] Human Ecology, Instituto Venezolano de InvestigacionesCientíficas, Panamericana km 11 Ado 20632, Altos de Pipe, edo. Miranda,Venezuela

© 2013 Zent.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. ThCommons Attribution License (http://creativecreproduction in any medium, provided the or

persons scattered in Amazon and Bolívar States of theVenezuelan rainforest ([2,3] see http://ivic.academia.edu/Zent). Due to space limitations, here I explore just threekey issues: (1) articulation of personal and academic life;(2) alterity, in a biocultural setting very different fromwhere I was raised; and (3) relativity of notions, valuesand principles.

ContextIn April 1996, Stanford, my life and academic partner,and I, initiated a three-year long ethno-ecological field-work among the Jotï in their stretch of high forest terri-tory located in the Sierra Maigualida (Figure 1). The Jotï,as well as their homeland, were at the time little knownin the scientific community. Published reports of the Jotïappeared for the first time in 1969 [4-6], and someethnological studies were conducted during the 70′s and80′s [7-15]. By the mid 90′s however, just 11 references

is is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creativeommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, andiginal work is properly cited.

Page 2: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Figure 1 Jotï homeland and forested landscape, April 2012.

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 2 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

Page 3: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 3 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

mentioned the Jotï. Likewise, the Sierra Maigualida hadbeen explored mostly in the high tepuy areas whereasbelow 1500 m asl there was very little information available[16-19]. The virtual absence of previous ethnoecologicaland botanical literature provided a double stimulus for ourstudy. From the outset, a main goal was to propose that aprotected area be created for both the people and themountain range. Thus, we expected to generate high qual-ity data-bases to certify the Jotï’s property of their landthrough their fine traditional ecological knowledge. Ourtheoretical and methodological background was quiteeclectic, ranging from Anthropology, Art History, Botany,Ecology, Linguistics, to Poetry. While both of us had previ-ous field research experiences: I in the páramos, a uniquebeautiful ecosystem but a setting that was almost myhomeland in the high tropical Andes above 3000 m asl;and Stanford among the Piaroa, in the Amazonian uplandforests. I think his blood was already impregnated with thejungle. He loved the idea of going back to live among thetrees. Different from him, I had to explore my own capabil-ity to live in the forest and with forest people. In this con-text, during the summer of 1994, Stanford and I set off forthe Jotï territory to explore the (logistic, material, legal,spiritual) viability of conducting long-term field researchthere. We did not know where their homes were located.We knew that no highways or roads existed to go there byway of motor vehicles. We were not sure whether therewas fluvial access to some communities but we were surewe could reach them on foot. This was the first time that Iwas looking for a site to live and carry out my own projectin a totally new social and ecological setting. The memor-ies below illustrate how we initiated our articulation withthe Jotï and the Maigualida, a few of the many relative as-pects of life, and my alterity space among my discrete selfand the extreme other of those early days.

ArticulationJune 1994

The morning when we left San Juan de Manapiare in thedugout canoe in a blind search of Jotï communities has asoothing taste in my mind. We departed with Basilio andJoel, Piaroa and Yabarana friends of Stanford, who wereexperienced woodsmen and had just a global sense ofwhere Jotï settlements could be found. The river seemedmalleable and we advanced slowly. Humidity waseverywhere. Rain is almost non-stop in this area fromJune to August. Thirsty plants welcomed the waterwithout satiating the craving for more. The Manapiaregave way to the Ventuari River the first evening and wehung our hammocks for the night in a pleasant Yekwanasettlement. However, the people there had very little tosay about the Jotï. The next morning we reached themouth of the Asita, a narrow tributary of the Ventuari.

After a short ride, we unexpectedly came to the first Jotïcommunity we had ever seen right on the riverbank. Athome were three shy but friendly people, a young man inhis 30′s, and two girls, a teenager probably 12 and asmiling one of around 9 years old. There was a singleshelter and a little garden recently planted. They did notlook suspicious but curious about us climbing their river(Figure 2). They laughed at our many tries tocommunicate with them in Spanish, Piaroa, Yabarana orEnglish. Still years after this first meeting we wonderedwhy the Jotï did not have any recollection of contacts withother ethnic groups except the Eñepa even though theirland is bordered by that of several ethnic groups. The Jotïseemed to have chosen to be un-contacted or to have fewassociations with these “other people”. We walked aroundthe tiny village for about 40 minutes while the curiousresidents followed us, and then we were off again.Although no interchange of foods, goods or intelligiblespoken words were possible, I spent the next hourthinking of many nonverbal ways to communicate andgrasp life and their many meanings. We did not see thesepeople again but met many of their relatives upriver.Several hours later, we left the main course of the Asitaand entered the Jkalo Ijkuala (Caño Iguana). Thewaterway narrowed even more. Along the banks, I couldsee tangled plants of multiple sizes and colors lingeringhere and there, competing for light in a fearless survivalquest. Above, the sky was cut by giant canopy treesunaware of time and silent. A soft chant was heardfaraway. Then it happened, one of the most intenseaesthetic experiences I ever had: flanked by deep forestthrough dark gentle waters, being followed by myriads ofeyes and so many tones and shapes of green, unable tothink… It was a non-rational touch with my archaic selfand a non-canonic prettiness that somehow my blood,my cells, recognized as alike. It called me without words.It was difficult to focus my perception. The nakedbeauty and my own primitiveness scattered in the rainforest overwhelmed me.

Less than an hour later on the opposite bank we saw acouple of lean-to shelters. Our guides laughed,regarding them as feeble and grungy. We disembarked.No one was around. It was quite, shady and cool. Iloved the feeling. A mystic air sounded at the sight ofanimal bones and skulls interlaced in curious shapesand hung with soft vines outside the lean-tos and overstumps around (Figure 2). They were fascinating andintriguing signs. Seven years later, I learned that theyhonored the jkyo aemo, hypostases of the huntedindividuals. This is part of a much more complexhunting ritual and praxis. Respect and zeal to certainparts of the eaten bodies guarantee the return of thespiritual-selves of the animals back to the material

Page 4: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Figure 2 Jkalo Ijkuala: Jotï Children playing and facing theRiver and young Mother, May 2012b.

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 4 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

world and thereby the constant replenishent of theprey populations. Returning to the canoe, wecontinued our journey with growing appeals andquestions.

An unpassable rapid flanked by huge trees impededour transit and forced us to end totally the fluvial trip(Figure 3). It was good to walk. Entering the forest waslike an open fresh Cathedral protecting our skin fromthe strong sun and embracing our steps. But we weretotally lost. It was then, soon after we realized we hadbeen walking around in circles when Jtobá appearedalone. He was tall and except for a loincloth and afew beaded necklaces, he was naked. His body’s profile,salient over the many tones of greens, daunted us.However, his big smile announced his friendlydisposition. His feet were engraved in our memory:they were prominent, strong and curved inward, justas if they had been designed as perfect climbing tools.We tried our best to ask Jtobá to take us to his house.Months later we understood that he explained the besthe could that we were taking the wrong trail. Probablyhe saw us since the day before and realized ourineptness as forest trekkers. He arrived at hiscommunity at nighttime after walking in circles for atleast 4 hours.

The first impression I had of the Jotï has persisteduntil today: gentle, smiling, resourceful, sensitive and de-termined people. The strong impact that their forestmade on me has also remained. Both trigger my years offieldwork, furthermore with increased knowledge of theforest and people of Maigualida augmented my admir-ation and respect for them; also my awareness of thehuge range of differences among us humans as well asour likenesses.This first trip lasted five weeks. Although we were lost

much of the time, and disoriented among tiny rivers andhuge trees, we managed to visit around 10 Jotï commu-nities in different types of floral communities. We de-cided to write a project that allowed us to go back to theMaigualida: Quantitative Ethnobotany and BehavioralEcology of the Jotï Indians of the Circum-Maigualida,Amazonas and Bolívar States, Venezuela. After gettingthe permits and some research grants, we started ourethnoecological fieldwork in 4 communities located indifferent ecological and social settings which were sepa-rated by 3-8 days of foot travel from each other. Furtherexplorations, data collection and learning of the languagewas initiated in May of 1996. The range of similarities anddifferences were fascinating but also challenging. We wereconfronted with the task of making “scientific” order outof the apparent chaotic vastness of both ecological andsocio-cultural settings.

Page 5: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Figure 3 Stanford and I going up river with our dear Piaroa friend Basilio, Animal skulls interlaced, August 1995.

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 5 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

Page 6: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 6 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

May 1996

It happened during a season of heavy rains. We hadbeen trekking in an exceptionally closed canopy andhilly rain forest in Sierra Maigualida with two Jotïbrothers, Jani Jlado and Abado. We had met them afew days before and they agreed to take us to meetsome of their relatives. Many shades of green coveredour days and nights like an unbroken mat. We hadnot had a clear view of the sun or the sky for fourdays. Denseness weaved in an endless intensity ofgreens dwelling in such a huge diversity of plant life-forms stroked my eyes with a wonderful appeal. Tinyopen spots filtered here and there little patches of lightglowing into the tangled understory. Tall, straight,leaning, wide, twisted, curled, soft or hard stems andbranches of trees, vines, shrubs, treelets and herbs,puffed-up to grasp the meager amount of sun thatentered the forest. Greens were halted irregularly bycolorful caterpillars, mushrooms and elaborate flowers,notoriously the brightly bracteolate bromeliads andorchids. Sneakily, heavy drops ofwater fell incessantlyon each form, including us. Sun and water calibrateprominent dynamics in the Amazon letting uniquelifestyles to be set into motion in the forest. Life takeson so many colors and profiles in the forest thatbiodiversity seems endless. Such a setting makes us,humans, just one of millions of material structures ofexistence. A very humble feeling is a constant mood inthis setting. Humility reminds us constantly about ourfragility and interdependence, in essence about ourrole in a chain of direct interrelationships withdifferent species of which we are just consumers,unable to survive without recourse to many producers.Human interactions in the forest can be creative ordeleterious, diverse and consistent.

Figure 4 Typical Jotï trail.

Climbing was a slow endeavor since the Jotï, with theaid of sharp machetes, had to open the trail for us tobe able to go through (Figure 4). The Amazon is life.Nothing remains still in the rain forest. All processesare dynamic. Life expresses itself in eternal movement.A freshly cut trail will stay open for only a few days.The extremely low densities of human populationmake it impossible to spare the labor needed tomaintain the footpaths, especially when they are littleused. Trails are prominent human disturbances. Theyactivate dynamic ecological processes allowing light toenter in bigger patches and halting the continuity ofhabitats and niches. Sun-loving creatures fight tobloom in those open spaces. Creeping life-forms absorbthe light in no time and turn it into new shades of lifeappropriating the shape of plants or arthropods.Pleased and gentle butterflies, bees and hummingbirds

Page 7: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 7 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

fill the clearings in the forest increasingpollinization activity by the hundreds which in turnset off the production of more and more life.Forest-life processes were here instigated by people.Our steps were silent and slow consenting a ratherunique opportunity to sense the forest? We couldhear the manifold sounds that speed hides and shutfrom our perception? For at least one hour we couldmake out the faint rumble of rushing water whichgrew louder with each passing step. Thus, weexpected to run into a river, which in turn willsubstitute our sheltered ceiling of trees for a solitarysky tinted by hues of tropical blues. It wasunexpectedly bright however, to reach a scene thathad followed me as a pennant of unusualexquisiteness.

The sudden appearance of massive light hurt my eyes.The sun’s rays entered the water reflecting vigorouslife. A gorge appeared in plenitude. Misty low cloudslevitated over the water in a continuum of states ofliquid-vapor in a single essence. We could see the sunand the sky for the first time after four days. The tree’sstockades came to an end abruptly on both sides of theriver’s bank. The bluest sky was competing in intensitywith the reverberation of the water’s rapids. A band ofyellow, blue and red macaws described a twisted arcon their sonorous playful fly contrasting with so muchblue now. Big grey rocks covered with moss, lichensand fungi, stood out solid rather timid?, against thestrength of the water, which permeated theatmosphere. A strong scent of humidity flutteredaround. Away from some minutes?, I could feel howmy body was penetrated by scents, sounds and lightsseemly forever.

The beauty of the place minimized the real deaththreatening moment that we were about to experience.The trail was not halted by the river. Rather, in orderto keep going ahead on our hike, we had to cross a logthat had been cut down and stretched from one ledgeof the gorge to the next, acting as a bridge. Althoughthe log was huge, it seemed tiny in perspective againstthe rapids intoning its strength some 165 feet below.The portion of log overhanging the white water wasabout 50 feet long. It was wet and covered by mossand therefore probably slippery and dangerous tocross. But turning back was not an option; the evidentconsensus set silently our motion to cross the river?The Jotï helped us with our heavy backpacks.Dexterously and effortlessly, they crossed the log in notime and then they stopped and stared at us from theother side, waiting for us to come. Fearful that wecouldn’t keep our balance upright, Stan and I had to

straddle the log bridge, with our legs and armswrapped around the trunk, and drag ourselvesforward little by little. Stan went first. He wasadvancing firm and steady. I was very apprehensivewhile he was crossing the log. He was good and agile;his thin but sturdy body fit the embrace of the trunk.A new serenity invaded me when I saw him safe onthe other side waiting for me. I followed him. Myobvious clumsiness made the journey longer. I sat onthe log. I felt my own fluids joining the wet spongy butpliable texture of the moss. For a few minutes my bodygrew used to the new texture. I glided and embracedthe wide trunk. My heart bumped faster. A few morefeet and I was in the middle of the log. I could notresist thinking about dying there. I closed my eyes andfelt a profuse love, simultaneous with a deep gratitude.Thoughts of beauty and fear ran through me. I keptgoing forward. I slid twice more and my little hatalmost felt once. I got scared but moved on morecarefully. It has been the one time in my life whenbeauty seemed bigger than death in all dimensions.Mixing such different realms, aesthetics andtranscendence, provided me with a new enchantedsense of life. Finally I joined Stan at the opposite end.We smiled and breathed a silent sigh of relief andaccomplishment. All stared for a brief moment andaborbed the mixing of attractive danger and beautyconcentrated in that spot. No word was said. I knewthereafter that I always belonged there.

Ahead of us was an extremely steep trail. As ifentering a tunnel, we crossed the threshold towards thegreen again. A shallow, shapeless forest made out ofmostly monocots embraced us. High Strelitziaceae,gracious Cyperaceae attractive Marantaceae, colorfulZingiberaceae, attractive Acantheacea, scentedAraceae and broad-leaved Musaceae, dotted here andthere by Cecropiaceae and Piperaceae. The softer andshallower woods gave way transitionally to moresturdy forest. We were back under the shelter of greens.Tall Lecythidaceae, Burseraceae, Flacourticacea,Rubiaceae and Meliaceae flanked a morebeaten-down trail, indicating regular human traffic.The almost vertical path took us to the first house wehad seen in several days. It was sitting on a smallopen plateau enfolded by distant hills. It appearedbright. It was made from the palm leaves of ulu(Attalea maripa Mart.) from bottom to apex. A singleopening acted as door and window. No one wasaround. Going up gradually, we had arrived at over900 m asl. Our Jotï friends announced that we hadarrived at Jkujkyo luwei (‘the house of a man namedJkujkyo’), and the surrounding area was known asJkujkyo majaijka (‘Jkujkyo’s place’).

Page 8: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

F

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 8 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

Jkujkyo bajaila came after strenuous walks (Figure 5).Water was present all the time. Not only was itraining day and night, but we were constantly crossingmany streams or the same spirally stream into whichwe submerged our permanently wet bodies. Ourhuman fluids were confused and analogous to theforest substances. Jkujkyo’s house was an extension of theforest, damp, dark and occupied by indefinite creaturesthat often produced scurried sounds at night. Waterdripped and poured through the flimsy and looselythatched roof just like it did when we were out under thecanopy. A non- conscious identity assured us security forfinding shelter in a human-made house? We stayedthere alone for several days, searching for Jkujkyo’swhereabouts and exploring the forest, old gardens,sunsets and sounds. We learned from our companionsthe process of making strings out of wild and cultivatedfibers; we rested and gained some confidence in ouracquaintance with the hilly rain-forest.

igure 5 Jkujkyo bajaila & luwei, 1996, 2012.

Sometimes, the focus of memoirs clings attached to ourmind, unconsciously, to beauty, happiness, desires, know-ledge, transcendence or mysticism among many other ab-stract or concrete concepts and sensations. To me, thememory of Jkujkyo bajaila’s is associated with intensity toa day when beauty overcame death; within a punctual mo-ment in my life where aesthetic and transcendence some-how were tied in an illogical but continuous ethos thatundisclosed a little about the complexities of humannature.

AlterityJune 1996

The day I met Jkujkyo a confusing blend of sensationsof proximity and distance were pulling me in differentand rushed directions through logical and sensualalleys. On the eighth morning of trekking, we woke updetermined to keep on hiking deeper into the Sierra

Page 9: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

F

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 9 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

Maigualida, hoping to make contact with isolated Jotïbands. Although we had not come across any peopleyet, we had seen human tracks, houses, tools, gardensand even believed to have heard some notes of flutemusic. We were tired and hungry, since our foodsupply was close to nothing and thus we were anxiousto find people. A little past noontime, a progressivelymore pungent odor bathed the air. I never had smelleda scent that strong before. As we walked through aforest with a rather sparse understory, the odorbecame stronger and closer. Swiftly we ran into thesource of the odor: a small fireplace where ulu dalepalm fruits (Attalea maripa Mart.) were being cooked.A Jotï woman accompanied by her four children, allboys, was attending the fire. Despite being soisolated and alone they did not manifest anysurprise or fear upon our encounter. They were just

igure 6 Jkujkyo and his family 1996, Jlade spinning cotton, 2012, and B

curious like us. Maybe they were a little eager toexplore who we could be. We approached theshelter slowly and without concealing someastonishment we drew near to the lean-to behindJani Jlado and Abado. Few words were interchanged.Our guides were originally from an area close to there.They were familiar with the people and environmentthat we were crossing through. Without mediating aword, it was decided that we would camp there aswell. Jani Jlado and Abado went to look for someleaves to build our own shelter for the night. Wewaited, smiled and looked around. We humans arediverse and pliable. I was captivated by the encounterand wanted to learn some more about the people weran into, but we did not have yet have the skills tocommunicate effectively in their language. All of theJotï present, including our guides, were monolingual.

ijkio starting a fire 2013b.

Page 10: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 10 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

Gestures, then, worked as a good tool to conveymeanings (Figure 6).

The woman seemed to be in her late 30′s, she was ofmedium contexture, about 5′ and had a friendlysmile. As most Jotï woman I had met, her only attirewas a small cotton loincloth. She, as well as herchildren, was profusely adorned with long necklacesmade out of wild and cultivated beads, but also mixedwith pieces of bird’s bones and feathers, mammals’dentures, pieces of holed canes and tins, old hollowedcoins and used thread carrels, and a few glass beads.Two necklaces covered all her breast, used laterallyand crossed in a croix that met just under her breast.She had also thread carrels inserted into her earlobes.Disordered black dots of a thick paint covered part ofher arms and legs. Her kids, ranging between about 2and 9 years old, smiled permanently and were usingsimilar black dots on their bodies but fewer beads.

A peaceful air ran without hurry. Silently we justobserved them and they observed us.

Ulu fruits are single seed ovals of about 2-3 cm indiameter surrounded by edible meat or mesocarp.Heavy racemes of the fruits are collected and cookeddirectly without processing in boiled water. It is highlyappreciated throughout the Amazon region as a goodsource of protein and lipids. Huge piles of eaten seedsrested high to the sides of the lean-to made from thesame palm tree’s leaves as a shelter under the canopy.It was clear that they had been feeding generouslyfrom ulu fruits. Judging from the amount heaped in apile, they had probably been there for about a monthhaving this fruit as a staple food. It emits aparticularly strong, unmistakable scent that foreverwas sealed in my memory as the hungriest days of mylife, but also filled with strong emotions andhappiness. It prompted also the possibility ofconsidering the Amazonian Indians as builders of theforest through the creation of seed banks and dispersalof seeds. We have been endorsing this idea also overthe years.

Jani Jlado and Abado came back with long leaves(Heliconia spp., Attalea spp., Phenakospermunguyannense (L.C. Rich.) Endl. ex Miq.). Simple knotswere rapidly and laxly weaved from their midribs.A large load of thin poles of different species (Cecropiaspp., Apeiba spp., Ouratea spp.) were also brought toframe the structure of our make-shift shelter. Soon wehad a lean-to with enough poles to hang ourhammocks. We were busy trying to make a home forourselves when we heard a soft whistle produced by a

flute made out of a hollowed thin cane. We looked upand there was Jkujkyo, the husband and father of thepeople we had interacted with for the last couple ofhours.

Jkujkyo arrived with his son of about 13 years old.Jkujkyo had a broad smile and was muscularly built.He talked and walked very fast. His human fluidsemitted a scent strongly mixed with the forest odors.

We spent a couple of days and nights among Jkujkyoand his people. It was pleasant. We walked andexplored the area, but also rested. Sadly we were notable to collect any samples since we were alreadycarrying heavy loads and had very little or no food atall. Jkujkyo’s people shared with us their food, mostlyulu fruits, raw and processed as soups and juices.Morning, noon and evening ulu was the staple food. Ifound that ulu fruit tastes like soap and its scent isassociated in my sensual memory with being amazedand alien as ever as well as being observed andstudied closely by very different people.

The third morning we were ready to continue on withour journey and set out to walk after dawn. It was acalm sunny morning. Parts of the trail were well keptindicating more frequent use. After just about threehours walk through a relatively easy but steady climb,we arrived at a quiet handsome settlement: Abiema’scommunity.

Abiema was a natural leader among the Jotï. Thesettlement was located at the top of a hill (~1000 masl) flanked by bigger mountains. His house lookedstrange because it was unlike any other Jotï house wehad seen up to that point. It was rather well made,sturdy, larger, round and tall, in fact its heightappeared to be greater than its diameter.

Upon looking at him, I felt an immediate attraction tothe image that he inspired in me: that of unspoiledprimitiveness. Unavoidably, at first impression Iobjectified him. In the second that I discovered myown archetypal projection I realized more similaritiesthan differences between him and us. Abiema meansthe bearded one. He, like Jkujkyo, had a short blackbeard. Not he nor any of his group were using at thattime any necklaces, which I found curious. Years laterwe learned that donning no paraphernalia oradornments such as beads is part of the mortuaryritual. Probably this group was honoring the death ofa former member of the community and that couldexplain why their bodies were just covered by thetraditional annatto-dyed loin-cloth.

Page 11: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 11 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

There were about 20 people in Abiema’s group. He hadtwo wives. Instead of the cotton loincloth, the younger onewas wearing a monocot leaf fastened onto a strip of jonojyeï’s bark (Lecythis sp.) circling her waist, thusindicating that she was having her menstrual period,therefore was potentially dangerous and not allowedto cook. The elder one was carrying a baby. They didnot show any fear upon seeing us (Figure 7). I had atwinkling sensation that they had seen us during thelast few days approaching their lands. They werefriendly.

Figure 7 Abiema jluwe and his family 1996, some of hisdescendents 2011.

Abiema exuded a sort of dignity that I have sensed just afew times in my life. It was his certitude of being anhonest, kind and comprehensive man. He seemed to beproud of being right where he was and who he was. Hewas a sturdily built man with broad shoulders. He smileda few but meaningful times. His feet, but specially his bigtoes were particularly pointed inward, which I took to bea clear sign of climbing trees since his early years.

Abiema and Jkujkyo were unique persons within mineas well as their own cultural landscapes. In more thanone sense they were marginal to their culture. Their dis-tinctiveness stemmed from several sources. They weresettled in an isolated area on the hearth of Jotï culturalmeanings and dynamics.? However, gradual waves of mi-grations turned this area, known as Jwanëbo jedä into ademographic sink area. Only a handful of family groupsremained fulltime in this area. Jkujkyo’s and Abiema’shomes were located in jwana jkuwë bajaila, below thehabitat of jwana (Arthrostylidium spp.). Jwana is a poly-semic term that refers to a bamboo-like plant, to thehollow cane obtained from this plant and which is theprimary raw material used to fabricate blowguns, and tothe blowgun itself. The Jotï are blowgun hunters, thusperiodic expeditions in search of the cane are carriedout on a frequent basis by Jotï from all communities.Arthrostylidium is a grass with a very restrictive geo-graphical distribution usually at the highest extremes ofthe tepuy province vegetation and on particular headwa-ters of a few rivers. Jkujkyo’s and Abiema’s groups actedas symbolic custodians of the jwana. Their communitiesmoved constantly in a ratio of about 20 km. Their highlymobile houses are located at the base of the jwana re-gion (900-1100 m asl). Since Jkujkyo and Abiema wereguardians of the route towards the jwana, they had ac-cess to the flows of people from all Jotï communities.Therefore, despite being “geographically” isolated, theywere probably among the liveliest social communitiessince they were in the capacity of passing informationand services through many within their ethnic group.This ethnic bridge transcends the material sphere.Jkujkyo’s and Abiema’s groups were also main holders of

Page 12: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 12 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

the baede ba Jotï ba jadï ba jawa. That is they still car-ried on the traditional Jotï lifestyle, the one rooted in theancestral ways of being and acting in the world. Not sur-prisingly therefore, Jkujkyo and Abiema were actuallyfeared by many of their fellow Jotï of different communi-ties. They were ascribed magical and shamanistic powersthat we were able to feel but not see in action. Later, Iheard that Jkujkyo’s house had been burned down onone occasion in a bigger community by accusationstinted with witchcraft and malevolent spiritual powers.Meeting Jkujkyo’s and Abiema’s groups provided mewith a broader notion of human nature or with the feel-ing that they had a us (Figure 8).

RelativityDespite the small total population size of the Jotï (< 1000persons), we were amazed at the huge diversity within theethnic group from the first contacts?. That fact promptedus to select four communities for our study in the attempt

Figure 8 Hunting for Jotï gardens 1996, 2012.

to capture some of this variation in social, cultural andecological spheres. These three spheres turned to beintertwined and relative to each other in many contextssuch as the following reminiscence portrays.

July 1996

We had spent the last month at Majagua balo, arelatively recently founded Jotï community of about 25people. At about 250 m asl, both the local biotic andsociocultural characteristics are different from higherbasi-montane and sub-montane areas (600-1000 m asl)more common to the Jotï biocultural landscapes. Thecommunity was settled on the left bank of a narrow andwinding creek that flows into the Parucito River. Duringthe rainy season it takes a whole day to make the tripupriver in a dugout canoe powered by an outboardmotor from the mouth of the river to the Jotï community,whereas this same trip takes about 3 to 4 days in the

Page 13: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 13 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

dry season when the water level is much lower.According to their oral traditions, the Majagua peoplehad migrated to this zone from the North about tenyears before. While building strategies to understandand deal with new configurations imposed by contactwith other indigenous groups (mainly Eñepa, Piaroaand Yabarana)as well as Westerners, the Jotï had beencolonizing new environmental (lower gallery and floodedforests) and social settings.

Although the Jotï at Majagua were quite friendly andhospitable, we were ready to explore some other Jotïsettlements in this area. Uli au balo [big water land],or the land of Abie jolowajka Jotï [the coarse beardedpeople], seemed like an appealing place to explore asit was the home of a very intriguing subgroup.Although they were said to be located just a day’s walkupriver from where we were, all Jotï at Majagua werereluctant to take us there. They were veryapprehensive of the Abie jolowajka Jotï, who weredescribed as being powerful witches, trekkers withoutgardens, hostile and strong-willed people. Suchremarks only served to arouse even more our eagernessto visit that community and meet the people.

Marco, an Eñepa man from Culebra, a communitylocated about six-hour walk awayfrom Majagua, wasthe only one inclined to take us to Uli au balo. He wasmarried with a Jotï woman, a close relative of theMajagua people. Socially and structurally, he wasclearly marginal to his own Eñepa people. Marco’smanners and movements seemed a little awkward, butwe had no other option.

At sunrise of a soft morning we started walking towardsUli au balo. Marco was leading our way. The forest wasdamp, bursting with day-loving creatures. The manifoldsounds echoing through the understory called andobserved us. Butterflies, macaws, caterpillars, quails,wasps, hummingbirds, termites, squirrels, toucans, frogs,parrots, spiders, oropendolas, mosquitoes, orioles… somany life forms produced a non-tuned concerto decidedlyexquisite and mysterious. Around the vines, trees, shrubs,palms, the sounds were not shy; they were statements,announcing the presence of those that produced them.

The trail was wet under the canopy; the sun rays didnot touch the soil. The aroma of dampness permeatedeverywhere. Mushrooms and fungi sprouted profusely,cutting the profile of green here and there. Many tractsof the trail were muddy; some were even underwater,forcing us to literally swim to keep going forward. Idiscovered then that my backpack floated. It had beenraining for the last couple of weeks and water

accumulated and moved freely all over the forest. Therivers were clogged with so much water and no placeto run off. We zigzagged across the same waterway atleast five times, an uneasy task, given the slipperynature of the logs that serve as bridges in Jotï land,although at times, the bridge-log was itselfunderwater. Patches of the trail were closed by a thickcurtain of tangled vines, trees, shrubs, understory,forcing us to hack it open with a machete.

We walked steadily but quietly behind Marcos forabout 9 hours before reaching the community. At leasthalf of that time it was pouring down rain. Our ownsweaty fluids mixed with the warm water filtered fromthe sky to the screen of trees to land in our bodies. Ourpacks were also soaked and the extra water madethem feel heavier. Crossing water bodies, big andsmall, moving and stagnant, was the constant imageof our walking day.

At one point during the walk, Marco suddenly stoppedfor what seemed like a long time while bending overand peering intently at the ground. He indicated thathe had momentarily lost sight of the trail and wastrying to pick it up again. We thought it was quite oddthe way he tilted his head so close to the ground. Thenit dawned on us: he was almost blind. But just whenwe started to openly lament our predicament (¨theblind leading the blind¨) he found the path and set offagain, and we had no choice but to follow. Finally, weglimpsed two small houses almost hidden under thecanopy, one besides the other sheltered by the treeswithout a clearing evincing their presence from the sky.Although the trail was not an easy one, we realizedthat the distance itself from Majagua to Uli au balowas not so great. The obstacles to get to thecommunity, mostly water in its many dispositions andmodes, made Uli balo seem far away. As soon as wegot there, people at the community came up to look atus. Two adult men and three women, a teenage boy ofabout 12 years old, four children and a baby girl werestaring at us, aliens coming from nowhere. Weexperienced one of those astonishing moments thatsediment in your memory forever. In this case, it wasthe absolute awareness given in a second, of being verydifferent in a continuum of resemblances.

Stan’s field notes capture the strong experience: “Forthe first 10 or 15 seconds I got the deep impressionthat this was a quite isolated group of people that donot have hardly any connection with the outside worldthat I am used to. This is the sort of primitive ‘other’object and experience that I desired for, that drove meto go into anthropology in the first place. Here it is

Page 14: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 14 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

right in front of me, looking back at me. Then I got thisintense feeling: so what? What is so great about this?You cannot become one of these people yourself, youmay never see them again, and maybe I should noteven be here”. I had a similar sense. All our musclesand bones were exhausted, which probably enhancedthe encounter and made it stick with me as a specialstate of mind-body; embraced by a magical halo oforange-brownish light emanating from a mixture ofsunlight, water and clouds in the late afternoon forest.The longing and feeling evaporated soon due thepreeminence of material needs. We turned all ourattention to practical matters. It was going to rainagain at any moment and we needed to make ashelter for the night. No word was pronounced. Thewhole community was staring at us while wefrantically and hastily erected the poles and then theroof. They did not move one finger to help. The olderman, whose name we learned later was Aunë(meaning ‘caiman’), had a quizzical smile on his face.He seemed to be studying us. Meanwhile the youngerman looked intently at our possessions.

This is perhaps the strongest interaction I experiencedamong unknown Jotï without involving any words atall. Still, so much was interchanged among us. In myhammock that evening while listening to the waterdropping onto the Attalea leaves, my thoughtswondered about how much relativity of perceptionstaint the categories and behavior among us humans:the people that seemed to be the most “primitive” to uswere actually the “vanguard” among “other” Jotïgroups, and “all” the Jotï groups did not considerthemselves as “one ethnic pack”.

Words came the next morning. We were ready toexplore around the very muddy, swampy, flooded anddamp surroundings. Since a research goal during thisphase was to collect data related to the size,composition and distance from the settlements to thegardens and hunting areas, we asked the people totake us to their gardens. All of them stated insistentlythat they did not have a garden. Where do theplantains they were eating come from then? “You musthave a garden!” we thought. Resolute, Stanfordpleaded with them to show us their gardens. Finallythey answered, “Jotea ñaña, ñajti jtojto dekae bada” or“yes, we have one but is really far away from here”.Our previous experiences with the expression, ñajtijtojto, seemed to indicate it meant the opposite ofjamena dekae bada ‘close, nearby’. Furthermore, it wasobvious that they were benefitting, at least partially,from garden products. We assumed that it was notthat far away after all. So despite their reluctance, we

convinced them to take us to their garden. The minutewe set out to walk it started raining. It was that styleof rain that exists just in the rainforest, hitting hardany form that avoids its speedy march. Water wasflowing through all interstices. Water was penetratingshapes and life forms. Water was chanting to plants.Water was feeding life. All seemed to explode with therain in the forest, now chaotic then diverse.

The trail to the garden was non-existent. We strodethrough the forest literally “running” behind Marco,who was also straining to kee up with Aunë and histeenage son. The boy seemed to enjoy our clumsinessand our huge effort to not get lost. It was very difficultto keep up with their speed. Their agility contrastedsharply with our ineptness, their belonging to the foreststood out from our clear otherness. After less than anhour, we ran into a temporary lake within the forestcreated by the accumulation of water. The Jotï werealready emerging onto the other side of it and couldn’tcare less about our whereabouts. In a desperateattempt to not lose our Jotï travel companions, weanxiously dove in and swam in their direction as fastas we could. Marco refused to enter the water, despitethe fact that we were already as wet as possibly couldbe. He declared that he had had enough and he left usright then and there! He turned his back and withoutsaying any more words he took off!

There we were … alone. Water was everywhere, in us,pouring endlessly from above and accumulatedeverywhere down below us. We could not even hear anyother sound but water. All smelled of water. No time tothink or complain. Swimming the best we could, wereached the lake edge and ran as fast as possible tocatch our fleet Jotï “guides”. Our hearts were bouncinghard. The rain receded a little bit. We were able to hearthe Jotï and “happily” ran behind them for the next twohours before reaching the garden. It was certainly ñajtijtojto dekae bada! We had been running, not walking,for the last three hours!

As a double gift, the rain stopped just as we reachedthe garden. It appeared to be a “semi-abandoned”garden; opened may be 5-7 years before. We spottedold patches of cultivated yam and sweet potato.Diverse varieties of standing banana trees were stillproductive. Happy to find food, we ate lots of bananaswith pleasure and enjoyed a few warm, smiling rays ofsun. Life seemed quiet again. We quickly set up acouple of sample plots and censused the crops insidethem. Then we measured the perimeter the best wecould and tried to get a GPS location reading, a majorpiece of data to plot our findings. The GPS was so wet

Page 15: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 15 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

that it did not work! Even though it was advertised asbeing waterproof. But this was no place to make acomplaint…perhaps the Magellan company made itwith non-tropical waters in mind… all the trouble tocollect data that could not be georeferenced…

We waited for at least an hour while the GPS wastaking a sunbath. After a while we tried again. It didnot even catch one satellite! Our Jotï friends were gettingimpatient and told us they were leaving. Withoutdragging our feet, but lacking any option whatsoever wemoved at their momentum and wishes. Running behindthem on the way back was even harder since our bodieswere exhausted and we knew it was a hard trail. Wearrived at a place where a huge log was completelyblocking the “trail”. Not only was it almost as tall as Iam but it was also very slippery. Dexterously the Jotïwent up and down within a few seconds and keepstriding on down the trail. I clambered ineptly and fell.It was unfortunate and inopportune, but foremost it wasvery painful. Stanford shouted for help. Much to oursurprise, the Jotï stopped and looked back at me. Theymanaged to try a smile but could not understand whywe were calling them. Stanford showed them my awfulstate. They just stared at us with an empty but alsounannoyed look on their faces. Beyond this visualcontact, there was no communication at all. Two verydifferent ethos and codes of human relations were sideby side in this event: parallel but notinter-communicable lifestyles.

Struggling with hunger, pain and mental weariness, werealized suddenly about their absolute lack of empathytowards us. Our fear about getting lost, was notcomprehensible to them. Adults our age in theirculture have already mastered the basic skills andknowledge about the forest. Therefore they arecompletely apt to survive alone without requestinghelp. Our claim was totally new to them. They couldnot believe our incapacity to find our way withouttheir assistance. The teenager’s playful way ofdisappearing and then reappearing gaudily fromour sight while we were rushing to keep up withthem, may have been just a gesture of friendshipand a way to test our humanity, but I do notbelieve that he meant to ¨lose¨ us or harm us inany way. We learned that empathy does not matchsurvival skills in the forest.

Water started to fall again. Further reflection waspostponed while we had to keep on walking. Iclambered over the log with Stanford’s help, took astick to walk again and after a little while I wasrunning for survival (again).

Water was still pouring from the sky when we arrivedcontentedly back at the community where the twohouses were surrounded by flooded patches of forest.No word was said again. A mixture of feelings andideas kept creeping to my mind all through the walk.Leading my thoughts was the certitude of the relativityof notions as time and space, of possibilities tocommunicate beyond language and to interact indeepness despite having just one event to recall. Thecomplex of space-time is tightly tied for people like theJotï. Forest space, its dynamics and functioningconstitute major tools for this people. Time is ameasure of dynamics in space. Human’s interactionsare not independent of the forest. They learn to bewith and in the forest. Our inability to see the forestlife forms, its structure, its processes and eternalchanging state is our handicap; however it comprisesan important survival kit for them. Knowledge aboutthe forest and themselves is a cumulative process thateach Jotï acquires since they are born. In the end,knowledge is built more through interactions than bypure intellectual reception and processing. Life isknowledge.

Two years after this event, Majlu arrived at a Jotï com-munity where Stanford and I had been staying for awhile. His two and a half year-old daughter was very sickand needed emergency medical help. We decided to takethem to the closest place where Western medical carewas available. In the dugout canoe and walking, Majluwas carrying his girl in a most tender way, providingwater and love every second of the way. This man, con-sidered a strong and non-sensitive Jotï, has been the onlyJotï that I have seen crying profusely, facing the impo-tence of alleviating the pain of his dying little girl. Herdistended belly evidenced many parasites living in herbony body. But no food would stay in her system. Shevomited permanently everything, and even the multivita-mins that we gave her for a week were finally discarded.She was very ill, extremely thin, weak and almost uncon-scious. It was very sad to see Majlu caressing the girland in so much despair silently. We arrived at the clos-est dispensary on the 3rd day at 5 p.m., located in an in-digenous multi-ethnic community of around 100 people.It was a little old hut, with mud walls, dirt floor andbroken ceiling. The only sign it was a health clinic was anew weighing-scale. The afternoon was giving way tothe night in the forest and many insects were singing inearly March 1998. The nurse, a Piaroa male, gave the girla shot but in less than an hour she passed away. SeveralYabarana women bawled loudly and steadily while Majluchanged his expression from sadness to alertness andimmediately declared: “I am leaving now”. He ran fastand took off in the middle of the night, leaving us the

Page 16: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Figure 9 Jotï high morbility and mortality is confronted withhigh natality.

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 16 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

corpse of his daughter. Surprised, local people and uscarried out a minimal but respectful burial ceremony.The women wailed all night long taking turns, somechildren cried, and a Yekwana man made a wood cof-fin. Despite being very sad, we tried to figure out thedifferent notions and behavior towards the dead girl.No one, except us, found it unusual that the onlyrelative of the deceased departed the minute after shedied. Everyone took on the mortuary ceremony as acommunity effort and duty despite that nobody therehad even ever seen Majlu or his daughter before. Noone questioned why she died for lack of medical helpsince the only real disease she had was too many par-asites. The next afternoon after the morning burial,no one cried again and everything was back to nor-mal. We also took off.Sadly the Jotï have high morbidity and mortality rates,

most of them associated to infectious diseases easilyavoidable with proper care (Figure 9). Over the years wehave learned that they have three etiological explana-tions of illnesses: autochthonous, introduced, and thesynergy of both. They have good ways to cure their own“traditional” illnesses but not the foreign ones, thoseusually fatal for them.

Final wordsI assume the risk of being pigeonholed as dialectical,symmetrical or a-theoretical. However, my own defin-ition of Ethno-ecology settles me at home in a no-spaceor nobody quarter, while simultaneously it touches virtu-ally all human endeavor nowadays: global warming anddelicate cognitive process. Amid anthropology and ecol-ogy, sociology and botany, philosophy and zoology,ethnoecology is difficult to grasp as a single discipline.Defining ethno-ecology as inter- and trans-disciplinary isjust a piece of the multiple facets of this realm. Ethno-ecological researchers find themselves often dwelling indilettante stances of immanent liminal states. Liminalspaces present an endless supply of surprises, explora-tions and enthrallments to me. I identify myself withinterstitial areas, where life can be stagnant sometimes,but can exploit more often?. In-between disciplines andcultures, in the middle of diverse theories and anomal-ous methods, inhabiting alien spaces while discoveringmany similarities to their hometowns in there. Usually itis more difficult to find the right context to explain howto enter the quotidian lives of communities differentthan ours while simultaneously we try to know theirlocal biological diversities, understanding their interac-tions and dynamics.I speculate that as many anthropologists [20], also

some ethno-ecologists openly or covertly, indulge them-selves in a self-reflective chase for answering ontologicalquestions while conducting their research [21]. In fact,

Page 17: REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a ... · REVIEW Open Access Treading & threading memories: a personal encounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela Egleé

Zent Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013, 9:55 Page 17 of 17http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/9/1/55

the geographical setting, the ethnic group, the theoret-ical and methodological backbones of a project depict anintimate self beyond the investigator in charge of a pro-ject. The first time is probably a non-conscious engage-ment of the ethno-ecologist with him or herself to asocio-ecological setting often times alien to her/him.

Competing interestsThe author declares that she has no competing interests.

AcknowledgementsI am deeply in debt to numerous Jotï for their collaboration, friendship andwillingness to share with me their homes, wisdom and lives: they took careof me and taught me many things among them to be a better person, tounderstand more love and pain, life and death. I will always be grateful toStanford Zent my husband and academic partner whom I share ideas,feelings, images, dreams, a life. I thank Nuria Martín and S. Zent for allowingme to use the map efficiently elaborated by them I am very thankful toAndrea Pieroni and Justin Nolan for inviting me to be part of this wonderfulinitiative "Recollections, reflections, and revelations: ethnobiologists and their‘First Time’ in the field which brings to light a set of memories that have leadthe experiences of many of us beyond academic grounds. I thank IVIC tosponsor my research over the years as well as the National ScienceFoundation, the Wenner-Gren Foundation Hunt Fellowship program (Gr7518), and the Herbariums support (MYF, VEN, and TFA).

Received: 30 July 2013 Accepted: 2 August 2013Published: 6 August 2013

References1. Tyler S: Post-Modern Ethnography: from document of the occult to

occult document. In Writing culture: the poetics and politics of Ethnography.Edited by James C, Marcus GE. Berkeley: University of California Press; 1986.

2. Zent E: Etnobotánica Hotï: Explorando las interacciones entre la flora y el serhumano del Amazonas Venezolano. Ahens: Tesis de PhD University ofGergia; 1999. xxiv, 519 pp.

3. Zent E, Ecogony J, Venezuelan Amazon: Environmental Research Letters 8.2013. 015008. http://stacks.iop.org/1748-9326/8/015008.

4. Bodin R: Finding. Brown Gold 1969, 27(12):7–9.5. Bou J: Found … But Lost. Brown Gold 1970, 28(3):6–7.6. Dye P: Yowana contact. Brown Gold 1970, 28(8):3–5. 15.7. Jangoux J: Observations on the Hoti Indians of Venezuela. ; 1971. Manuscript.8. Eibl-Eibesfeldt I: Die Waruwádu (Yuwana), ein kurzlich entdeckter, noch

unerforschter Indianerstamm Venezuelas. Anthropos 1973,68(1–2):137–144.

9. Corradini H: Los Indios. Chicanos Venezuela Misionera 1973, XXXV(405):6–9.(406):42-44; (407):88-91. http://www.academia.edu/501293/Etnobotanica_Cuantitativa_entre_los_Hoti_Selva_Tropical_Guayana_Venezolana.

10. Guarisma V: Los Hoti: introducción etno-lingüística, Tesis de Licenciatura.Caracas: Universidad Central de Venezuela; 1974.

11. Coppens W, Philippe M: Les Indiens Hoti: compte rendu de missions.L'Homme 1974, XIV(3-4):131–142.

12. Coppens W: Contribución al estudio de las actividades de subsistenciade los Hotis del río Kaima. Boletín Indigenista Venezolano 1975,XVI(12):65–78. nueva época.

13. Coppens W: Los Hoti. In Los Aborígenes de Venezuela, Volume II. Edited byCoppens W. Caracas: Fundación La Salle/Monte Avila Editores; 1983.

14. Guarisma V, Coppens W: Vocabulario Hoti. Antropológica 1978, 49:3–27.15. Vilera D: Introducción morfológica de la lengua Hoti. Caracas: Tesis de

Licenciatura, Escuela de Antropología, Universidad Central de Venezuela;1985.

16. Huber O, Alarcón C: Mapa de vegetación de Venezuela. Caracas, Venezuela:1:2.000.000. Ministerio del Ambiente y de los Recursos Naturales Renovablesand The Nature Conservancy; 1988.

17. Huber O, Rosales J, Berry P: In Estudios Botánicos en las Montañas Altas de laCuenca del Río Caura (Estado Bolívar, Venezuela). Edited by Huber O, RosalesJ. Ecología de la cuenca del Río Caura, Venezuela: II. Estudios Especiales.Scientia Guaianae; 1997:441–468.

18. Yerena 1982 voucher collections. y Herbario nacional de Venezuela (VEN):Herbario Víctor Manuel Ovalles (MYF).

19. Fernández 1980-1985 voucher collections. y Herbario nacional de Venezuela(VEN): Herbario Víctor Manuel Ovalles (MYF).

20. Rosaldo R: Ideology, place, and people without culture. Place and voicein anthropological theory. Cult Anthropol 1988, 3(1):77–87.

21. Nolan J, Pieroni A: Recollections, reflections, and revelations:ethnobiologists and their “First Time” in the field. J Ethnobiol Ethnomed2013, 9:12.

doi:10.1186/1746-4269-9-55Cite this article as: Zent: Treading & threading memories: a personalencounter with forest and people in Southern Venezuela. Journal ofEthnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2013 9:55.

Submit your next manuscript to BioMed Centraland take full advantage of:

• Convenient online submission

• Thorough peer review

• No space constraints or color figure charges

• Immediate publication on acceptance

• Inclusion in PubMed, CAS, Scopus and Google Scholar

• Research which is freely available for redistribution

Submit your manuscript at www.biomedcentral.com/submit