rio group information and feedback on the compendium of good practices

Rio Group Rio Group

Information and Feedback on the Information and Feedback on the

Compendium of Good Practices Compendium of Good Practices Zélia Magalhães Bianchini

Deputy Director of Surveyse-mail: [email protected]

Expert Group Meeting on the Handbook on Poverty Statistics – UNSD, United Nations – New York

28-30 June 2005

Rio Group - Background information • UN Statistical Commission in 1996

approved the recommendation to establish an Expert Group on Poverty Statistics (Rio Group)

• Rio Group is chaired by IBGE with ECLAC acting as Executive Secretary

• The meetings were an opportunity for many countries to present and compare their experiences and methodologies in measuring and analyzing the situation of poverty in their different aspects

Rio Group - Most relevant conditions established to accept a measurement as practice • The estimates are the responsibility of a

public or private (academic) institution• The estimates are public and available to

the media• The estimates are periodic permitting a

comparable series• The methodologies used are available for

the public• Well-known sources of information are

available for the public.

Expert Group on Poverty Statistics

Meetings • First meeting: Santiago, 7-9 May 1997

• Second meeting: Rio de Janeiro, 13-15 May 1998

• Third meeting: Lisbon, 22-24 November 1999

• Fourth meeting: Rio de Janeiro, 15-17 October 2001

• Fifth Meeting Rio de Janeiro, 13-15 November, 2002

• Sixth Meeting, Rio de Janeiro, 12-14 November 2003

• Seventh Meeting, Rio de Janeiro, 6-8 December 2004

Expert Group on Poverty Statistics Participants • Countries: 22

Argentina, Australia, Belarus, Botswana, Brazil, Canada, Chile, France, India, Indonesia, Mexico, Netherlands, Nigeria, Peru, Portugal, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Turkey, Uruguay, United Kingdom, United States of America.

Expert Group on Poverty Statistics Agencies and others institutions: 18

• Centro Latinoamericano de Demografía (CELADE/ ECLAC)

• Economic Commission for Africa (ECA)

• Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC)

• Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP)

• Economic Commission for Europe (ECE)

• EUROSTAT

• Human Science Research Council

• Inter-American Development Bank (IDB)

• International Labor Organization (ILO)

• London School of Economics and Political Science

Expert Group on Poverty Statistics Agencies and others institutions: 18

• Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development Paris 21

• Pan American Health Organization/World Health Organization (PAHO/WHO)

• Townsend Center for International Poverty Research

• The World Bank (BIRD)

• United Nations Latin American and Caribbean Institute for Economic and Social Planning

• United Nations Development Programme (UNDP)

• United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF)

• United Nations Population Fund (UNPF)

• United Nations Statistics Division (UNSD)

Rio Group - Compendium of Good Practices SummaryIntroduction 2. Absolute Poverty

3. NBI / DI - Unsatisfied Basic Needs / Deprivation Indicators

4. Integrated Approach

5. Relative Poverty

6. Subjective Poverty

Conclusions

Rio Group - Compendium of Good Practices Framework of chaptersA. Introduction Concepts and methods

B.Standards and resources Standards Resources for meeting standards

Sources of information

C. Availability of periodic calculations

D. Technical characteristics: Similarity and differences among estimates

E. Challenges, options and shortcomings

Rio Group - Compendium of Good Practices Introduction

• It covers two main distinctive purposes: – it explains the content of the compendium,

making clear the Rio Group limitations and its scope of countries coverage

– it presents a conceptual and historical approach of poverty

Rio Group - Compendium of Good Practices

Chapter 2 - Absolute Poverty • In this chapter Canada, USA and ECLAC

experiences are well covered• It is necessary to work better the aspects

of income and consumption showing the differences between the notion of expenditure and consumption.

• As the structure of the chapter should be representative of the majority of international practices, a “box” is being prepared relating the most important experiences.


Chapter 3 - UNB / DI (Unsatisfied Basic Needs / Deprivation

Indicators)• This chapter gives a good framework about

Basic Needs practices although the experiences are mostly related to Latin American countries.

• An international approach will be added.• As a complementary approach, a “box” will

be included with some practices based on multi-dimensional indicators such as HDI.


Chapter 4 - Integrated Approach • The draft we have is specific of the British

experience (even though it is an official measurement in Ireland)

• It will be included details of how income and deprivation indicators are combined to measure poverty by Ireland and UK

• The method should be described in more general terms

• Some steps of the deprivation index will be more clarified

• Others experiences must be added such as Kaztman y Boltvinik as well as the World Bank proposal to measure income integrating the information of surveys and Census


Chapter 5 - Relative Poverty

• This chapter describes mainly the EUROSTAT practices

• Other practices will be included• Calculations, similarities, differences,

options and challenges comments will be more developed


Chapter 6 - Subjective Poverty

• The draft of this chapter it been done by ECLAC

• It is mostly used as a complementary method to objective and relative measurement

• In this sense, this method has a different status in relation to the others, since it is not officially used by any country


Conclusions

• There will be 2 or 3 parts. • The idea is to establish a connection

between methods and policies and international comparisons.

• ECLAC is in charge of the strategies of information.

Rio Group - Compendium of Good Practices Next Steps

• Preliminary version - July / August 2005

• Comments by experts - September 2005

• Revision by IBGE and ECLAC - October 2005

• Editing - November 2005

Expert Group on Poverty Statistics

Background documents (7 meetings)• IBGE http://www.ibge.gov.br/poverty

• UNSD - http://unstats.un.org/unsd/methods/citygroup/rio.htm

rio group information and feedback on the compendium of good practices

Documents