risk analysis in capital budgeting decisions
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
1/26
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
2/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 22
Common Techniques used forCommon Techniques used for
Investment EvaluationInvestment Evaluation Discounted Cash Flow TechniquesDiscounted Cash Flow Techniques
-- Net present valueNet present value
-- Internal Rate of ReturnInternal Rate of Return-- Profitability IndexProfitability Index
NonNon--Discounted Cash Flow TechniquesDiscounted Cash Flow Techniques
-- Payback PeriodPayback Period
-- Accounting Rate of ReturnAccounting Rate of Return
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
3/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 33
Nature of RiskNature of Risk
Risk exists because of the inability of theRisk exists because of the inability of the
decisiondecision--maker to make perfect forecasts.maker to make perfect forecasts.
An investment is not risky if we can specify aAn investment is not risky if we can specify aunique sequence of cash flows for it.unique sequence of cash flows for it.
However there are always uncertainties aboutHowever there are always uncertainties about
cash flows which render risk to the capitalcash flows which render risk to the capital
investment proposals with regard to theirinvestment proposals with regard to their
acceptance.acceptance.
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
4/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 44
Concept of ProbabilityConcept of Probability
The concept of probability is fundamental toThe concept of probability is fundamental to
the use of risk analysis techniques.the use of risk analysis techniques.
The probability estimate based on a very largeThe probability estimate based on a very largenumber of observations is known as annumber of observations is known as an
objective probability.objective probability.
The probability estimates that are dependentThe probability estimates that are dependent
on the state of belief of a person are calledon the state of belief of a person are called
subjective probabilities.subjective probabilities.
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
5/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 55
Statistical Techniques for RiskStatistical Techniques for Risk
AnalysisAnalysis Expected Net Present Value (ENPV) = TheExpected Net Present Value (ENPV) = The
expected net present values can be found outexpected net present values can be found out
by multiplying the monetary values of theby multiplying the monetary values of thepossible events (cash flows) by theirpossible events (cash flows) by their
probabilities.probabilities.
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
6/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 66
ENPV for a Single PeriodENPV for a Single Period
Calculate theCalculate the
ENCF for eachENCF for each
project and findproject and find
out which projectout which projectis preferable if theis preferable if the
initial outlay is Rs.initial outlay is Rs.
6500?6500?
EventEvent Project AProject A Project BProject B
CFCF ProbProb CFCF probprob
MM 45004500 0.20.2 1400014000 0.150.15
NN 52005200 0.10.1 1200012000 0.100.10
OO 67006700 0.40.4 70007000 0.500.50
PP 71007100 0.10.1 50005000 0.100.10
QQ 84008400 0.20.2 30003000 0.150.15
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
7/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 Bindu NairBindu Nair -- IMMIMM 77
Solution.Solution.
EventsEvents Project AProject A Project BProject B
MM CFCF ProbProb Exp.Exp.
ValueValue
CFCF ProbProb Exp.Exp.
ValueValue
NN 45004500 0.20.2 900900 1400014000 0.150.15 21002100
OO 52005200 0.10.1 520520 1200012000 0.100.10 12001200
PP 67006700 0.40.4 26802680 70007000 0.500.50 35003500
QQ 71007100 0.10.1 710710 50005000 0.100.10 500500
84008400 0.20.2 16801680 30003000 0.150.15 450450
ENCFENCF 64906490 77507750
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
8/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 88
Expected NPV Multiple PeriodExpected NPV Multiple Period
A company hasA company hasdetermined thedetermined thefollowingfollowing
probabilities forprobabilities for
net cash flowsnet cash flowsfor three yearsfor three yearsgenerated by agenerated by a
project:project:
Calculate theCalculate the
ENPV at 12%ENPV at 12%discount rate ifdiscount rate ifthe expectedthe expectedcash outflow iscash outflow is6000?6000?
Year1Year1 Year2Year2 Year3Year3
CFCF ProbProb CFCF ProbProb CFCF ProbProb
11001100 0.10.1 11001100 0.20.2 11001100 0.40.4
24002400 0.30.3 24002400 0.30.3 24002400 0.10.1
32003200 0.20.2 32003200 0.40.4 32003200 0.30.3
45004500 0.40.4 45004500 0.10.1 45004500 0.20.2
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
9/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 99
Standard DeviationStandard Deviation the absolutethe absolute
measure of riskmeasure of risk Variance of NCF = (NCFVariance of NCF = (NCF11 ENCF)ENCF)
22 * Prob* Prob11 ++
(NCF(NCF22 ENCF)ENCF)22 * Prob* Prob22 + (NCF+ (NCFnn ENCF)ENCF)
22 **
ProbProbnn
Standard Deviation = Root of variance.Standard Deviation = Root of variance.
Coefficient of variation : it is the relativeCoefficient of variation : it is the relative
measure of risk.measure of risk.
CV = Standard Deviation / Expected Net CashCV = Standard Deviation / Expected Net Cash
Flow.Flow.
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
10/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 1010
Question???Question???
Calculate theCalculate the
Variance, StandardVariance, Standard
Deviation andDeviation and
Coefficient ofCoefficient ofVariationVariation
EventEvent Project AProject A Project BProject B
CFCF ProbProb CFCF probprob
MM 45004500 0.20.2 1400014000 0.150.15
NN 52005200 0.10.1 1200012000 0.100.10
OO 67006700 0.40.4 70007000 0.500.50
PP 71007100 0.10.1 50005000 0.100.10
QQ 84008400 0.20.2 30003000 0.150.15
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
11/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 1111
Conventional Techniques of RiskConventional Techniques of Risk
AnalysisAnalysis
RiskRisk--adjusted discount rateadjusted discount rate
Certainty EquivalentCertainty Equivalent
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
12/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 1212
RiskRisk--adjusted Discount rateadjusted Discount rate
RiskRisk--adjusted discount rate method uses aadjusted discount rate method uses a
higher discount rate for more risky cash flowshigher discount rate for more risky cash flows
and lesser discount rate for less risky cashand lesser discount rate for less risky cash
flows.flows.
RiskRisk--adjusted discount rate = Riskadjusted discount rate = Risk--free rate +free rate +
Premium for the riskPremium for the risk
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
13/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 1313
Question???Question???
An investment in a project will cost Rs.An investment in a project will cost Rs.
100000 initially and it is expected to generate100000 initially and it is expected to generate
cash flows in years one through four of Rs.cash flows in years one through four of Rs.
25000, 50000, 35000,and 20000. What is the25000, 50000, 35000,and 20000. What is the
projects NPV, assuming a 10% riskprojects NPV, assuming a 10% risk--free rate.free rate.
Also compute the riskAlso compute the risk--adjusted NPV if theadjusted NPV if the
discount rate is 15%.discount rate is 15%.
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
14/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 1414
Solution.Solution.
RiskRisk--free NPV = + 3970free NPV = + 3970
RiskRisk adjusted NPV =adjusted NPV = -- 59805980
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
15/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 1515
Certainty EquivalentCertainty Equivalent
Certainty Equivalent approach computes theCertainty Equivalent approach computes theNPV of the project by converting the riskyNPV of the project by converting the riskycash flows into equivalent riskcash flows into equivalent risk--free cash flowsfree cash flows
and discount them with riskand discount them with risk free rate.free rate. The certainty equivalent coefficient can beThe certainty equivalent coefficient can be
calculated as :calculated as : Certain net cash flow/Risky netCertain net cash flow/Risky net
cash flow.cash flow. The certainty equivalent coefficient is always aThe certainty equivalent coefficient is always a
value between 0 and 1.value between 0 and 1.
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
16/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 1616
Question????Question????
Riskless Enterprises is a fastRiskless Enterprises is a fastgrowing company that follows agrowing company that follows a
rather conservative approach to itsrather conservative approach to its
capital expenditure plans due tocapital expenditure plans due to
the inherent risks involved. Thethe inherent risks involved. The
firm normally does not takefirm normally does not take
capital expenditure that last morecapital expenditure that last more
than 5 years and follows a policythan 5 years and follows a policy
of converting the risky cash flowsof converting the risky cash flows
to their certainty equivalents byto their certainty equivalents by
assigning certainty equivalentassigning certainty equivalent
factors of 0.9, 0.8, 0.7, 0.6 and 0.5factors of 0.9, 0.8, 0.7, 0.6 and 0.5for the cash flows of Year 1 tofor the cash flows of Year 1 to
Year 5, respectively.Year 5, respectively.
The cost of capital is 15% whileThe cost of capital is 15% while
riskrisk--free return is 6%free return is 6%
YearYear ProjectProject
AA
Project BProject B
00 --250250 --250250
11 6060 100100
22 7070 120120
33 8080 100100
44 120120 2020
55 120120 4040
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
17/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 1717
Question contd..Question contd..
Which project should be undertaken based onWhich project should be undertaken based on
NPV rule?NPV rule?
Which project should be undertaken if C.E.Which project should be undertaken if C.E.approach is followed?approach is followed?
Which project would you recommend ifWhich project would you recommend if
(a) Shareholders are dominant(a) Shareholders are dominant (b) Debt holders are dominant.(b) Debt holders are dominant.
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
18/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 1818
Practice Question???Practice Question???
Delta corp. is considering anDelta corp. is considering aninvestment in one of the twoinvestment in one of the twomutually exclusive proposals;mutually exclusive proposals;Project A involves an initialProject A involves an initialoutlay of Rs. 1,70,000 and Projectoutlay of Rs. 1,70,000 and ProjectB Rs. 1,50,000. The C.EB Rs. 1,50,000. The C.EApproach is employed inApproach is employed inevaluating the risk associated withevaluating the risk associated withthe investments. The current yieldthe investments. The current yieldon the treasury bills is 5% . Theon the treasury bills is 5% . Theexpected values of cash inflowsexpected values of cash inflowswith their C.Es are follows:with their C.Es are follows:
Which Project should beWhich Project should beaccepted?accepted?
Which project is riskier? HowWhich project is riskier? Howdo you know?do you know?
YrsYrs Project AProject A Project BProject B
CashCash
FlowFlow
C.EC.E CashCash
FlowFlow
C.EC.E
11 9090 0.80.8 9090 0.90.9
22 100100 0.70.7 9090 0.80.8
33 110110 0.50.5 100100 0.60.6
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
19/26
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
20/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 2020
Scenario AnalysisScenario Analysis
Scenario Analysis measures the change inScenario Analysis measures the change in
NPV of the project under different scenariosNPV of the project under different scenarios
changing several variables at a time because ofchanging several variables at a time because of
interrelationship of variables amongstinterrelationship of variables amongst
themselvesthemselves
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
21/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 2121
Decision Tree AnalysisDecision Tree Analysis
A decision tree is a powerful tool of analyzingA decision tree is a powerful tool of analyzing
sequential decisions. It breaks up complexsequential decisions. It breaks up complex
decisions into smaller decisions and calculatedecisions into smaller decisions and calculate
the NPV backwards to arrive at the mostthe NPV backwards to arrive at the most
pragmatic decision based on maximization ofpragmatic decision based on maximization of
NPV.NPV.
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
22/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 2222
Question???Question???
ABC computers is considering an optionABC computers is considering an option
to develop two models; Model A andto develop two models; Model A and
Model B of Laptops. Both the modelsModel B of Laptops. Both the models
are expected to be hot sellers for theare expected to be hot sellers for the
next two years.next two years.
The capital expenditure involved inThe capital expenditure involved in
Model A is 225 cr. while Model B costsModel A is 225 cr. while Model B costs
Rs. 250 cr.Rs. 250 cr.
Since Model A is an improvised versionSince Model A is an improvised version
of the existing laptop it offers a certainof the existing laptop it offers a certain
Cash Flow of Rs. 140 cr. and Rs. 180 cr.Cash Flow of Rs. 140 cr. and Rs. 180 cr.
for the next two years.for the next two years.
However in case of Model B ABC isHowever in case of Model B ABC is
not very sure of its Cash Flows.not very sure of its Cash Flows. It expects a cash inflow of Rs. 150 cr inIt expects a cash inflow of Rs. 150 cr in
the first year with 70% probability andthe first year with 70% probability and
under exceptional circumstances it mayunder exceptional circumstances it may
yield a cash flow of Rs. 180 cr.yield a cash flow of Rs. 180 cr.
The cash flows in the second year areThe cash flows in the second year are
dependent upon the outcome of thedependent upon the outcome of the
first year. If the firm gets normal cashfirst year. If the firm gets normal cash
inflow of 150 cr in the first year theinflow of 150 cr in the first year the
chances are 30% that it would repeatchances are 30% that it would repeat
the cash flows, 40% chances that itthe cash flows, 40% chances that it
might improve to 180 cr. And 30%might improve to 180 cr. And 30%
chances that it might do exceptionallychances that it might do exceptionally
well and it may increase to 220 cr.well and it may increase to 220 cr.
If the firm does exceptionally well inIf the firm does exceptionally well in
the first year then ,chances are itthe first year then ,chances are it
would have cash flows of eitherwould have cash flows of either
220cr, 230 cr, or 250 cr, with220cr, 230 cr, or 250 cr, with
probabilities of 50%, 30% and 20%probabilities of 50%, 30% and 20%
respectively.respectively.
Examine both proposals andExamine both proposals and
recommend the best one to ABCrecommend the best one to ABC
assuming a cost of capital of 12%assuming a cost of capital of 12%
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
23/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 2323
Solution.Solution.
Model AModel A Cash InflowCash Inflow Present value@Present value@12%12%
Ist YearIst Year 140.00140.00 125.00125.00
IInd YearIInd Year 180.00180.00 143.49143.49
Total Present Values of InflowsTotal Present Values of Inflows 268.49268.49
Less Initial InvestmentLess Initial Investment 225.00225.00
NPVNPV 43.4943.49
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
24/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 2424
Model BModel B
Year 1Year 1 Year 2Year 2
ProbabilityProbability Cash FlowCash Flow ProbabilityProbability Cash FlowCash Flow
0.70.7 150150 0.30.30.40.4
0.30.3
150150180180
220220
0.30.3 180180 0.50.5
0.30.3
0.20.2
220220
230230
250250
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
25/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 2525
Model B contd.Model B contd.
Present Value of Year 2 cash flows at the end of year 1Present Value of Year 2 cash flows at the end of year 1
ENCF = 0.3*150 + 0.4*180 + 0.3*220 = 183.ENCF = 0.3*150 + 0.4*180 + 0.3*220 = 183.
Present Value of ENCF @ 12% = 183*0.893 = 163.41Present Value of ENCF @ 12% = 183*0.893 = 163.41
ENCF = 0.5*220 + 0.3*230 + 0.2*250 = 229ENCF = 0.5*220 + 0.3*230 + 0.2*250 = 229 Present Value of ENCF @ 12% = 229*0.893 = 204.46Present Value of ENCF @ 12% = 229*0.893 = 204.46
-
8/6/2019 Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting Decisions
26/26
7/1/20117/1/2011 2626
Model BModel B
Value of Cash FlowValue of Cash Flow YY ZZ
Cash Flow of Yr.1Cash Flow of Yr.1 150.00150.00 180.00180.00
PV of Cash Flow of YearPV of Cash Flow of Year22
163.39163.39 204.46204.46
Total Cash Flow at YearTotal Cash Flow at Year
11
313.39313.39 384.46384.46
Expected Cash Flow AtExpected Cash Flow AtPoint XPoint X
313.39 * 0.7 + 384.46*0.3 = 334.71313.39 * 0.7 + 384.46*0.3 = 334.71PV of 334.71 = 298.85PV of 334.71 = 298.85
ENPV = 298.85ENPV = 298.85 250 = 48.85250 = 48.85