risk factors for rehospitalization of patients with mental disorders a case control study margaret...

19
RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi College of Health Sciences, Dr Robert Start and Dr Felix Kauye 07/03/22 1

Upload: phoebe-hart

Post on 04-Jan-2016

216 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATIONOF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERSA CASE CONTROL STUDY

Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education,Malawi College of Health Sciences, Dr Robert Start and Dr Felix Kauye

04/20/23

1

Page 2: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

INTRODUCTION

Studies from other parts of the world indicate that severe mental disorders can be treated and the affected individuals can lead a normal life again [WHO 2008].

However, Zomba Mental Hospital, Malawi, is experiencing a lot of rehospitalization some of which take place in less than a year after discharge.

2

Page 3: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

Aim of study

•To find out the factors that lead to rehospitalization of patients at the mental hospital in Malawi.

•To assist policy makers to utilize the findings to come up with measures to minimize relapses and hence improve community integration of patients discharged from the psychiatric hospital.

04/20/23

3

Page 4: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

Specific Objectives

•To compare persons who have been readmitted within one year of discharge and those who have not been readmitted on a number of variables including:▫demographic characteristics▫ illness characteristics▫ family support▫ substance abuse▫compliance to medication

04/20/23

4

Page 5: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

Method•The study used an unmatched case control design

Cases were:•Current inpatient in ZMH •Having a severe mental disorder•Readmitted in less than a year after last dischargeControls were:•Currently attending outpatient clinic at ZMH•Previously admitted with a severe mental disorder•Discharged at least 1 year before recruitment to the study.

04/20/23

5

Page 6: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

Data collection

•Data was collected by the researcher through the use of a structured questionnaire. This took place in the month of July 2011 for a period of 4 weeks.

04/20/23

6

Page 7: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

04/20/23

7

DEMOGRAPHICS

Variable Cases (n=75) Controls(n=71)  Subjects N=146 N percentage N percenta

gep-value

Males 43 57.3 45 63.4 0.501

Employed 29 38.7 40 56.3 0.046*

Married 21 28 25 35.2 0.377*

Primary or no education

55 73.3 37 52.1 0.010*

Residence: Rural 63 84 45 63.4 0.005*

Mean SD Mean

SD

Age 31.36 9.390 34.92 9.694

Page 8: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

DIAGNOSIS (CASENOTE)

• 46 (61.3%) of the cases and 41 (57.7%) of the controls were diagnosed as schizophrenia.

• The next common condition was Mania/bipolar disorder. There were 14 (18.7%) cases with this diagnosis and 12 (16.9%) controls

• The third diagnosis was drug-induced psychosis. Eight of the cases (10.7%) and 14.1% of the controls were diagnosed as having this condition

• No significant differences between cases/controls

04/20/23

8

Page 9: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

ILLNESS CHARACTERISTICS• Mean admission number for the cases was

3.84(SD 1.748) while the controls had a mean admission number of 2.46 (SD1.43). Independent 2 tailed T-test p-value of <0.005

• 66.7% 0f the cases and 25% of the controls had been violent (p value of 0.005).

• 74.7% of the cases and 94.4% of the controls believed that they had a mental disorder (p value of 0.001).

04/20/23

9

Page 10: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

FAMILY SUPPORT

04/20/23

10

Page 11: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

SUBSTANCE MISUSE04/20/23

11

Page 12: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

MEDICATION COMPLIANCE

•53% of the cases and 83.1% of the controls were compliant with medication following discharge (p value of 0.005)

04/20/23

12

Page 13: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

Multivariate Analysis (logistic regression)The factors significantly associated with

being a case vs. control were:• primary or no education• living in rural area• having a history of violence to others• Lack of insight• non compliant with medication after discharge• not receiving financial and practical support

from family• not getting help with medication

04/20/23

13

Page 14: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

DISCUSSION• From the findings we conclude that the nature of the

illness is associated with rehospitalization due to:▫ having a history of violence to others▫ not believing that has a mental illness

• We did not find an association with marijuana misuse (but this was self-report)

• Those who are not rehospitalized are getting less support from the family:▫ receiving financial support from family▫ getting help with medication

• .

04/20/23

14

Page 15: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

DISCUSSION• Several modifiable factors are associated with

rehospitalization of patients:

▫ not receiving practical support from family• not compliant with medication after discharge• residing in rural areas

• These could be improved by improving community outreach services particularly in rural areas.

• Home visiting to include psychoeducation, support with medication compliance, and rehabilitation

04/20/23

15

Page 16: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

Limitations of the study

We depended on cases to give information which may not be reliable.

The study only looked at cases and controls from Zomba which may not be representative for Malawi

04/20/23

16

Page 17: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

Recommendations for practice and future research

For future research involve other districts and health centers.

A prospective cohort study can also be done to recruit patients on discharge and follow them up.

04/20/23

17

Page 18: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

Acknowledgements

•Dr Robert Stewart•Dr Felix Kauye•Professor Linda Kalilani•The executive Director MCHS•Colleagues•Students

04/20/23

18

Page 19: RISK FACTORS FOR REHOSPITALIZATION OF PATIENTS WITH MENTAL DISORDERS A CASE CONTROL STUDY Margaret Eliphy Nkangala, Bsc Health Science Education, Malawi

ct

04/20/23

19