s-70a-9 black hawk: balancing airworthiness & sustainment … · s-70a-9 sustainment...

26
S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment Management with the Demands of a Domestic Special Operations Capability and International Sustainment Community Army Aviation Systems Program Office Major Steve Wardill S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR

Upload: others

Post on 01-Jan-2020

15 views

Category:

Documents


6 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness &

Sustainment Management with the Demands of a Domestic

Special Operations Capability and International Sustainment

Community

Army Aviation Systems Program OfficeMajor Steve Wardill

S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager

Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski

S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR

Page 2: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

Major Steve Wardill:

• S-70A-9 Black Hawk overview

• Three case examples:

– Fatigue critical component suspected cracking

– Managing the possibility of concealed structural corrosion

– Critical component CRT uncertainty

Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski:

• Managing and communicating risk

SCOPE

Page 3: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

Army Aviation Systems Program Office (AASPO)

BACKGROUND

DEPSEC CASG

JOINT MARITIME LANDAIR

Helicopter Systems

Division

Aerospace Systems

Division

Navy Aviation

Systems Branch

Army Aviation

Systems Branch

AASPO CHUSPO

Troop Lift Mgt

Unit

Tiger/Taipan

Mgt Unit

Light Heli Mgt

Unit

Page 4: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

S-70A-9 Black Hawk

BACKGROUND

1974 1979 1987 1991 2014 2015 2022

(x 39)

1989

5th Aviation Regiment

(Townsville)

20062006

6th Aviation Regiment

(Sydney)

Fleet drawdown to 18 aircraft

Page 5: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

Sustainment Management Challenges

Case Examples

Page 6: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 1: MAIN ROTOR SHAFT EXTENSION SUSPECTED CRACKING

Page 7: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 1: MAIN ROTOR SHAFT EXTENSION SUSPECTED CRACKING

Page 8: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 1: MAIN ROTOR SHAFT EXTENSION SUSPECTED CRACKING

Page 9: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 1: MAIN ROTOR SHAFT EXTENSION SUSPECTED CRACKING

Page 10: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 1: MAIN ROTOR SHAFT EXTENSION SUSPECTED CRACKING

From Sea Hawk SPO:

Page 11: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 1: MAIN ROTOR SHAFT EXTENSION SUSPECTED CRACKING

Page 12: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 1: MAIN ROTOR SHAFT EXTENSION SUSPECTED CRACKING

Page 13: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 1: MAIN ROTOR SHAFT EXTENSION SUSPECTED CRACKING

Page 14: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 1: MAIN ROTOR SHAFT EXTENSION SUSPECTED CRACKING

Page 15: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

Key takeaways:

• Foster informal design support networks

• Can’t rely on the OEM

• Always reproduce positive NDT results

CASE 1: MAIN ROTOR SHAFT EXTENSION SUSPECTED CRACKING

Page 16: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 2: ADF ANTENNA CORROSION

Page 17: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 2: ADF ANTENNA CORROSION

Page 18: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 2: ADF ANTENNA CORROSION

Page 19: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 2: ADF ANTENNA CORROSION

Page 20: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

Key takeaways:

• Cross-discipline consultation during design

• Trial modifications/designs prior to fleet roll out

• Know your MO’s capabilities and limitations

• Close comms with your design support network

CASE 2: ADF ANTENNA CORROSION

Page 21: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 3: PLANETARY GEAR CARRIER LIFING POLICY

Page 22: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 3: PLANETARY GEAR CARRIER LIFING POLICY

OEM CRT:

9800

US ARMY CRT:

6500

Page 23: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

CASE 3: PLANETARY GEAR CARRIER LIFING POLICY

0.0 1000.0 2000.0 3000.0 4000.0 5000.0 6000.0 7000.0 8000.0 9000.0

A25-218

A25-102

A25-112

A25-108

A25-106

A25-101

A25-105

A25-107

A25-224

A25-204

A25-205

A25-114

A25-104

A25-110

A25-215

A25-213

A25-203

A25-225

A25-214

A25-211

A25-103

A25-212

A25-109

A25-201

PGC Elapsed Life

Tail

Nu

mb

er

Page 24: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

Key takeaways:

• Global design support network is a double-edged sword

• Design support arrangements need to include substantiation

data

• It’s all about stakeholder engagement and communicating

risk

CASE 3: PLANETARY GEAR CARRIER LIFING POLICY

Page 25: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

• Know the ADF CRE

• C = Configuration – MTC, TCDS, TCB, Type Design, Type Record

• R = Role – SOIU, OpSpec

• E = Environment - SOIU

• Understand MTCHO responsibilities

• DASR 21.A.42 – Integration and 21.A.44 Obligations - TCAE

• Failures, Malfunctions & Defects (Occurences)

• Issues are rarely ‘Black or White’

• Depend on TIR – Know When It’s TAAI

• Communicate - Contact! Wait Out – MAO / DASA

• Action Strategy – Multi-disciplinary team – revisit and update

• System Safety, Hazard Log, ASIP/ESIP (immediate and longer-term)

Continued Airworthiness and Capability -CENGR Perspective

Page 26: S-70A-9 Black Hawk: Balancing Airworthiness & Sustainment … · S-70A-9 Sustainment Engineering Manager Lieutenant Colonel Adam Kurylewski S-70A-9 HoDO/DoSA/MTCH/CENGR. Major Steve

• ‘How to SFARP’ – 7 Steps

• Credible and Defensible

• Communicate - Language

• ORPR

• Experience – Mentorship, Corporate Memory

• Depend on SMS – reinforce lessons learned

• Nimrod, Violation Behaviour – Sea King BOI (Nias 2005), Black Hawk

BOI (Fiji 2006), A15-102 COI (CH-47D) Afghanistan 2011

• Target Hot-Spots (CISM)

• Depend on Monitoring Programs – SSP, ASIP/ESIP

• Depend on DSN – Relationships with CoE, 21J – exercise capabilities –

‘Capability in Crisis’

Continued Airworthiness and Capability -CENGR Perspective