sap forum 2014 - presentation tiger project @ geistlich pharma
TRANSCRIPT
Lean and validated ERP implementation at
Geistlich Pharma
Dr. Renzo Salzmann
Geistlich Pharma AG
Daniel Kuhn
Swisscom IT Services AG
SAP Forum Basel
May 20, 2014
Agenda
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
Agenda
Introduction 1
Project Requirements 2
Challenges 3
Project Approach 4
Key Success Factors 5
Conclusion 6
Benefits 7
2
1. Introduction Who is Geistlich Pharma AG?
Company Overview
Who is Geistlich Pharma?
• World market leader in regenerative dentistry
• International leader in biological bone, cartilage and soft tissue regeneration (dental
and orthopedics)
• Global player with eight subsidiaries and a distribution
network in more than 50 countries
• Producer and supplier of pharmaceuticals
and medical devices.
• 450 employees, 250 in Switzerland
• Located in Wolhusen & Root (LU)
• Family owned
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
3
1. Introduction Geistlich Pharma as a global Player
Company Overview
Global presence and distribution network 20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
4
• Headquarters
• Subsidiary
• Distributor
1. Introduction Dental indication
Company Overview
• Treatment with Geistlich Bio-Oss® and Geistlich Bio-Gide®
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
5
1. Introduction Orthopedic indication
Company Overview
• Orthoss® – ideally suited for bone regeneration
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
6
1 prosthesis revisions (e.g. hip and knee)
in treatment of benign tumors and bone cysts 2
absence of healing of a fracture or osteotomy 3
fusion of the spinal column 4
ideal carrier material for bone marrow cell concentrate 5
1. Introduction Geistlich Pharma as a global Player
Everything under one roof
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
7
R &
D
Pro
ducti
on
Mark
eti
ng &
Sale
s D
istr
ibuti
on
2. Project Requirements What lead to the Tiger Project?
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
8
Project Requirements
Why a new ERP system?
• Old legacy systems no longer supported, no interfaces to crucial systems (e.g. LIMS)
• No efficient handling of increasing complexity (products, markets)
• Lack of transparency and real-time data
• Computer System Validation (CSV) issue
Conclusion:
• Starting Project Tiger (Targeted Implementation of Geistlich Enterprise Resources)
2. Project Requirements Goals to be achieved?
Objectives
What needs to be achieved
• Implementation of a fully integrated SAP ERP System
• Using SAP Best Practices for Chemicals as a standard
• Interfaces to all critical sub-systems
• Full conformity with all compliance requirements (EU, FDA)
• Scalable system to support future growth and competitiveness
• Enhance grade of automation and highest possible efficiency in handling transactions
• Targeted implementation within a very short time and within budget - severe
restrictions in Change requests and strict cost controlling
• Build Up an early SAP Competence Center to establish internal project and operation
support
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
9
2. Project Requirements Scope
Scope
• Project scope: SAP ERP, SAP Solution Manager, SAP GRC, OpenText Archive
• Process coverage: Production and Planning, Purchasing, Warehouse Management,
Sales & Distribution, Quality Management, Finance, Controlling,
HR, Workflow for Purchase Orders and Invoices, Mobile Scanning
Devices and several Interfaces
• Rollout scope: Switzerland (the implemented processes are designed for later
international rollouts to Geistlich Pharma AG subsidiaries)
• Method: SAP Best Practices for Chemicals, SITS Project Methodology,
Validation Guidelines ISPE GAMP5 (V-Model), SAP Solution
Manager, ASAP Roadmap
• Implementation
partner: Swisscom IT Services AG (SITS)
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
10
2. Project Requirements Scope
Scope
• Project duration: 10 months
• Go-live date(s): 01-July-2013
• # of users
implemented: 120
• Additional users
planned: 40 (for international rollout)
• Project effort: 3’500 person days
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
11
3. Challenges
Challenges
Major project challenges
• Fulfilling CSV (Computer System Validation) requirements by:
• engaging SAP DE CSV experts to bring in a CSV Best Practices method
• use of SAP Solution Manager as DMS for the complete process and system
documentation incl. electronic sign-off procedures (e-signature) and progress
control.
• Short implementation timeframe by:
• using best business experts as well as best external consultants and have
dedicated times they can work for this project.
• proper project management, controlling and risk management.
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
12
3. Challenges
Challenges
• Managing project complexity and various partners, implementing different SAP
systems, interfacing external systems and approval workflow by:
• Swisscom project manager as SPOC for communication, resource availability.
• Project management enforcing project governance to all involved parties and
resources.
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
13
3. Challenges Put the Tiger in your tank
Put the tiger in your tank
Clearly a big challenge… 20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
14
3. Challenges Key question
Key question
Key question
Is a lean and validated SAP ERP implementation
in a pharmaceutical SME possible?
Swisscom/Geistlich Pharma Reference Film
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
15
4. Project Approach How to proof the key question…
Proof the key question
In the following we are going to prove that it is possible if…
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
16
4. Project Approach Timeline, Organization, Scope, Method
Project Approach
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
17
Swisscom
GEISTLICH SwisscomGEISTLICH
Project Management
CO Consultant SD Consultant PP-PI Consultant
Sub-project Validation
Team
Sw
issc
om
Steering Committee
QM Consultant
Sub-project
Sales & Distribution
Sub-project
Production
Sub-project
QM
Sub-project
Finance
Team
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a
Swisscom
Quality Assurance
RICEF, SAP Infrastrukture and SAP Basis Services
MM/WM Consultant
Sub-projectMaterials Mgt.,
Procurement, WM
GEISTLICH
HR Consultant
Sub-project
HRM
Sub-project Validation
Sub-project
Controlling
Rapid Decision Board
Swisscom
GEISTLICH
i2S
FI Consultant
Integrationsmanagement
RICEF, SAP CC, SAP Infrastructure and SAP Basis Services
Change Management
GEISTLICH
Prozessliste / Process List
Prozess Name / Process Name
Scop
e De
finiti
on
GMPx
rele
vant
?
SAP
ERP
Mod
ul /
SAP
ERP
Mod
ule
SAP
Base
line
Szen
ario
/
SAP
Base
line
Scen
ario
FICO Enterprise Management & Support / Finanzen & Controlling In Scope NO
VERK Sales & Marketing / Verkauf In Scope YES
EINK Supplier Collaboration / Einkauf In Scope YES
YES EINK_002 Procurement Contract / Kontrakte In Scope NO MM 133
YES EINK_003 Consumable Purchasing / Beschaffung nicht lagerhaltige
Artikel (Verbrauchsmaterial)In Scope YES MM
129
YES EINK_004 Procurement without QM / Beschaffung ohne QM
Procurement of batch managed stock materials / Beschaffung
chargenpflichtiger Lagermaterialien
Procurement of warehouse managed stock materials /
Beschaffung WM-verwalteter Lagermaterialien
In Scope YES MM
130
NO EINK_007 Procurement of pipeline materials Out of Scope Yes 903
TBD EINK_008 Procurement of external Services
In Scope No
904
YES EINK_012 Rebate Agreements / Lieferantenrückvergütung In Scope NO MM
YES EINK_100 Master Data / Stammdaten In Scope YES
YES EINK_200 Reports / Berichte In Scope NO
MAWI Supply Chain Planning & Execution / Materialwirtschaft In Scope YES
PROD Manufacturing / Produktion In Scope YES
ENTW Innovation Management / Produktentwicklung Out of Scope YES
QUAL Quality Management & Compliance / QM In Scope YES
PERS Human Capital Management / Personalwesen In Scope NO
INST Plant Maintenance / Instandhaltung Out of Scope YES
ifax Zahlungsbedingungen
Timeline Organization
Scope Method
Project Management / Integration Management
Realization Phase
04/12 05/12 06/12 07/12 08/12 09/12 10/12 11/12 12/12 01/13 02/13 03/13 04/13 05/13 06/13 07/13 08/13 09/13 10/13
MS60
Go-live
MS10
MS100 MS140
PHAS
E I
MS10: Contract sign.off
MS20: End of project preparat ion phase
MS30: SAP basic training completed
MS40: Validat ion plan and templates approved
MS50: SolMan setup incl. BPML, BP documents and templates
MS60: FIT/ GAP Analysis, Blueprint, Prototype approved
MS70: Final Blueprint in SolMan
MS80: Sign-off URS, FS, DS and RA
MS90: Sign-off TS and Data Migrat ion Plan
MS100: SAP ERP system configured and tested
MS110: IQ, OQ & PQ successfully completed & signe-off
MS120: Go-live @ Geist lich Pharma AG, Switzerland
MS130: Sign-off Validat ion Report
MS140: Project Closure
Final
Preparation
PHAS
E II
Project PreparationFIT/ GAP Analysis,
Blueprint & Prototype
Go-live & Support
Stabilization
Change Management
Create Validation Plan &
Templates Valid
atio
nSo
lMan
Project Preparation Design Operations Setup OperationsHandover to
OperationsOperation & Optimization
Contract
Sign-off
Training
MS20 MS30
Kick-off
MS120
MS50 MS70
MS40 MS90 MS110 MS130
Create Validation
ReportIQ, OQ & PQ
Create & Review TS &
Data Migration Plan
Create & Review URS, FS, DS
RA
MS80
Project Management / Integration Management
Realization Phase
04/12 05/12 06/12 07/12 08/12 09/12 10/12 11/12 12/12 01/13 02/13 03/13 04/13 05/13 06/13 07/13 08/13 09/13 10/13
MS60
Go-live
MS10
MS100 MS140
PHAS
E I
MS10: Contract sign.off
MS20: End of project preparat ion phase
MS30: SAP basic training completed
MS40: Validat ion plan and templates approved
MS50: SolMan setup incl. BPML, BP documents and templates
MS60: FIT/ GAP Analysis, Blueprint, Prototype approved
MS70: Final Blueprint in SolMan
MS80: Sign-off URS, FS, DS and RA
MS90: Sign-off TS and Data Migrat ion Plan
MS100: SAP ERP system configured and tested
MS110: IQ, OQ & PQ successfully completed & signe-off
MS120: Go-live @ Geist lich Pharma AG, Switzerland
MS130: Sign-off Validat ion Report
MS140: Project Closure
Final
Preparation
PHAS
E II
Project PreparationFIT/ GAP Analysis,
Blueprint & Prototype
Go-live & Support
Stabilization
Change Management
Create Validation Plan &
Templates Valid
atio
nSo
lMan
Project Preparation Design Operations Setup OperationsHandover to
OperationsOperation & Optimization
Contract
Sign-off
Training
MS20 MS30
Kick-off
MS120
MS50 MS70
MS40 MS90 MS110 MS130
Create Validation
ReportIQ, OQ & PQ
Create & Review TS &
Data Migration Plan
Create & Review URS, FS, DS
RA
MS80
4. Project Approach Timeline, Organization, Scope, Method
Project Approach
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
18
Swisscom
GEISTLICH SwisscomGEISTLICH
Project Management
CO Consultant SD Consultant PP-PI Consultant
Sub-project Validation
Team
Sw
issc
om
Steering Committee
QM Consultant
Sub-project
Sales & Distribution
Sub-project
Production
Sub-project
QM
Sub-project
Finance
Team
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a
Swisscom
Quality Assurance
RICEF, SAP Infrastrukture and SAP Basis Services
MM/WM Consultant
Sub-projectMaterials Mgt.,
Procurement, WM
GEISTLICH
HR Consultant
Sub-project
HRM
Sub-project Validation
Sub-project
Controlling
Rapid Decision Board
Swisscom
GEISTLICH
i2S
FI Consultant
Integrationsmanagement
RICEF, SAP CC, SAP Infrastructure and SAP Basis Services
Change Management
GEISTLICH
Prozessliste / Process List
Prozess Name / Process Name
Scop
e De
finiti
on
GMPx
rele
vant
?
SAP
ERP
Mod
ul /
SAP
ERP
Mod
ule
SAP
Base
line
Szen
ario
/
SAP
Base
line
Scen
ario
FICO Enterprise Management & Support / Finanzen & Controlling In Scope NO
VERK Sales & Marketing / Verkauf In Scope YES
EINK Supplier Collaboration / Einkauf In Scope YES
YES EINK_002 Procurement Contract / Kontrakte In Scope NO MM 133
YES EINK_003 Consumable Purchasing / Beschaffung nicht lagerhaltige
Artikel (Verbrauchsmaterial)In Scope YES MM
129
YES EINK_004 Procurement without QM / Beschaffung ohne QM
Procurement of batch managed stock materials / Beschaffung
chargenpflichtiger Lagermaterialien
Procurement of warehouse managed stock materials /
Beschaffung WM-verwalteter Lagermaterialien
In Scope YES MM
130
NO EINK_007 Procurement of pipeline materials Out of Scope Yes 903
TBD EINK_008 Procurement of external Services
In Scope No
904
YES EINK_012 Rebate Agreements / Lieferantenrückvergütung In Scope NO MM
YES EINK_100 Master Data / Stammdaten In Scope YES
YES EINK_200 Reports / Berichte In Scope NO
MAWI Supply Chain Planning & Execution / Materialwirtschaft In Scope YES
PROD Manufacturing / Produktion In Scope YES
ENTW Innovation Management / Produktentwicklung Out of Scope YES
QUAL Quality Management & Compliance / QM In Scope YES
PERS Human Capital Management / Personalwesen In Scope NO
INST Plant Maintenance / Instandhaltung Out of Scope YES
ifax Zahlungsbedingungen
Timeline Organization
Scope Method
4. Project Approach Systems
Systems
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
19
Project
Preparation
Blueprint &
Prototype
Realization Final
Preparation
Go-live &
Support
CSV of
SolMan (e-signature)
Training
Project
Team
DMS for
Blueprint
Build Prototype
GRC
Evalua-
tion
DMS for
Development
& Testing
Customizing
Development
Testing
Setup
Access
Control
DMS for
Data
Migration
Data
Migration &
Enduser
Training
Go.-live
Access
Control
Incident
Manage-
ment
Go-live &
Bug-fixing
Constant
use of
GRC
SAP
Solution
Manager
SAP
ERP
SAP
GRC
4. Project Approach Systems Overview
System Overview
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
20
SAP GRCas central system access and
authorization mangement system
SAP Solution Manageras Document Management System (DMS)
for process & systems documents
SAP ERP
HR/WF
SD
PP/QM
MM/WM
FI/CO
LIMS
e-Trans (DHL)
Faxserver / Mailserver
KABApresento.pro
Time & attendance data
SAP GRC
OpenText
SAP SolMan
CRM (MS Dynamics)
Document
Scanner
Barcode
Scanner
Various Interfaces
4. Project Approach Systems Overview
System Overview
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
21
SAP GRCas central system access and
authorization mangement system
SAP Solution Manageras Document Management System (DMS)
for process & systems documents
SAP ERP
HR/WF
SD
PP/QM
MM/WM
FI/CO
LIMS
e-Trans (DHL)
Faxserver / Mailserver
KABApresento.pro
Time & attendance data
SAP GRC
OpenText
SAP SolMan
CRM (MS Dynamics)
Document
Scanner
Barcode
Scanner
Incident/Change
Solution/Change
4. Project Approach Systems Overview
System Overview
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
22
SAP GRCas central system access and
authorization mangement system
SAP Solution Manageras Document Management System (DMS)
for process & systems documents
SAP ERP
HR/WF
SD
PP/QM
MM/WM
FI/CO
LIMS
e-Trans (DHL)
Faxserver / Mailserver
KABApresento.pro
Time & attendance data
SAP GRC
OpenText
SAP SolMan
CRM (MS Dynamics)
Document
Scanner
Barcode
Scanner
Authorization
Authorization
Request
5. Key Success Factors
Key Success Factors
• Clearly defined scope in terms of business processes as well as interfaces and
developments (BPML, RICEF list)
• Process driven (based on BPML) requirement definitions, system configuration
(customizing), developments, documentation, testing and training
• Business team project manager sub-project leader key user
best people for best results
• Business priorities have been adjusted to focus on the Tiger project as a major
business initiative of the organization
• Project governance (project handbook) set into place (timeline, escalation,
communication, reporting, controlling, templates, etc.) and communicated to the
entire team (Kick-off)
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
23
5. Key Success Factors
Miscellaneous
• Commitment of top management at all times
• Focus on SAP Best Practices scenarios to keep development effort as low as possible
• Build-up SAP CC and use of Incident Management to capture issues during testing
phase, go-live and daily operation thereafter
• Intensive testing cycles (functional testing, authorization tests, end-to-end
integration testing)
• Dedicated project space enabling and integrated project environment with short
decision path
• External coaching and advising i2s SAP DE PWC SITS QA to review critical
milestones as well as to benchmark, execute a project audit and a Part11 assessment
• High transparency of project risks and fast deployment of risk mitigating actions
approved by the Rapid Decision Board (RDB)
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
24
6. Conclusion The six golden rules
Conclusion
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
25
External consultants with profound SAP, process
understanding and industry experience within a CSV
environment.
Committment to SAP Best Practices kept as strict project
guideline throughout the project to keep developments and
scope creep at minimum level.
Detailed and extensive project preparation to set the right
foundation for the project.
Is a lean and validated SAP ERP implementation in a pharmaceutical SME possible?
Yes, if the following six (6) requirements are fulfilled:
6. Conclusion The six golden rules
Conclusion
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
26
It has to be a business-driven project and empowerment at
all levels.
Comprehensive documentation of all process definitions,
system settings, developments, testing, data migration and
training activities throughout the entire project lifecycle.
Use of SAP Solution Manager as central process and system
DMS with electronic review and sign-off procedure
complete controlling of deliverables.
SAP
Solution
Manager
PQ
OQDQ
URS
FS
DS Unit Testing
FunctionalTesting
Integration & Acceptance
TestingGxP
Assessment
RiskAnalysis
IQ
BC-SetTechnical
Documentation
7. Benefits Time, Quality, Cost
Conclusion
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
27
QUALITY:
• Fully validated processes and
systems
• Full traceability
• Product distribution in
compliance with market
registration
• Rigid user authorization
control
• Real stock transparency no
out of stock situations
• Fully integrated process
ROFO S&OP MRP
Production Distribution
TIME
COST QUALITY
COST:
• Stock reduced by 20 % on SKU
level freeing 20 % storage
capacity avoiding warehouse
expansion (cost savings of
CHF 1.0 Mio)
• Stock value reduction by CHF
1.5 Mio
• Coverage differences at
month-end has been reduced
by 75 % due to accurate
product cost calculation and
cost allocations
TIME:
• Overall month-end closing time reduced by 30 %
• Vendor invoice approval time reduced by 50 % 100 % cash discounts benefits
• Purchase order approval process time reduced by 50 %
7. Benefits Time, Quality, Cost
Conclusion
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
28
TIME
COST QUALITY
CONCLUSION:
Even though Geistlich Pharma AG is using SAP ERP less than one (1) year significant
benefits of the SAP ERP implementation have been realized and further are expected.
Therefore the overall project return on investment will be between 2 - 3 years.
7. Benefits Outlook
Outlook
Future business benefits planned
• Rollout to subsidiaries in order to fully integrate intercompany processes.
• Rollout to other legal entities
• Planning accuracy by implementing concurrent planning, VMI-process incl. interfaces
to external warehouses.
• BI/BO to support sales and financial controlling and to optimize the sales & operation
processes.
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
29
Questions?
Thank you for your attention!
© 2012 SAP AG. All rights reserved. 31
Your opinion counts!
Please give us your feedback about the just
attended session as well as about the
event in total via our Event App.
Please rate:
-Session Content
-Speaker
-Event in general
Give us your feedback and win 1 of 10 official «brazuca» match balls
originally signed by Ottmar Hitzfeld
The even ap is available
for free in the following
stores:
Contact
Contact
Geistlich Pharma AG
• Dr. Renzo Salzmann
• Director Technical Operations
• +41 (79) 709 61 34
Swisscom IT Services AG
• Daniel P. Kuhn
• Senior Project Manager
• +41 (79) 620 44 74
20.0
5.2
014
SAP F
oru
m 2
014 -
Geis
tlic
h P
harm
a A
G
32