school-to-school collaboration for transformation david triggs … · leadership, management and...

17
School-to-School Collaboration for Transformation What can Federations learn from current and recent policy and practice? Monday 1 st December 2003 British Academy, 10 Carlton House Terrace, London SW1 David Triggs Greensward College Greensward’s experience SST – Family of Schools SCITT SEEVEAZ Beacon School Twinning arrangements Teacher Training Status School Improvement Consultant Executive Principal Cisco Regional Academy Characteristics of an Executive Principal Capable of using authority ‘safely’ Capable of ‘building capacity’ of Leadership Teams First class mentor, coach, trainer Clear educational vision and school improvement model High level consultancy skills Extensive ‘networker’ Level 5 Leader • Impact Greig City Academy Greig Exclusions 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 Jan Feb March April May June July August September October November Greig City Academy Attendance Figures 0.8 0.82 0.84 0.86 0.88 0.9 0.92 0.94 Jun- 03 Jul- 03 Aug- 03 Sep- 03 Oct- 03 Nov- 03 KS3 Ks4

Upload: others

Post on 10-Feb-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • School-to-School Collaboration for Transformation

    What can Federations learn from current and recent policy and practice?

    Monday 1st December 2003British Academy, 10 Carlton House Terrace, London SW1

    David TriggsGreensward College

    Greensward’s experience

    SST – Family of Schools

    SCITT

    SEEVEAZ

    Beacon School

    Twinning arrangements

    Teacher Training Status

    School ImprovementConsultant

    Executive Principal

    Cisco Regional Academy

    Characteristics of an Executive Principal

    • Capable of using authority ‘safely’• Capable of ‘building capacity’ of Leadership

    Teams• First class mentor, coach, trainer• Clear educational vision and school

    improvement model• High level consultancy skills• Extensive ‘networker’• Level 5 Leader• Impact

    Greig City Academy

    Greig Exclusions

    02468

    1012141618

    Jan

    Feb

    March Ap

    rilMa

    yJu

    ne July

    Augu

    st

    Septe

    mber

    Octob

    er

    Nove

    mber

    Greig City Academy

    Attendance Figures

    0.80.820.840.860.880.9

    0.920.94

    Jun-03

    Jul-03

    Aug-03

    Sep-03

    Oct-03

    Nov-03

    KS3

    Ks4

  • Greig City Academy

    % of staff remaining in post

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    2002/ 03 2003/ 04 2004/ 05

    Target

    Act ual

    Conditions for success

    • Schools/LEAs must commit to engaging an Executive Principal and a Principal

    • Training of Executive Principals• Training of potential Principals• Engagement of the Community Action

    Network• Funding for each projects

  • Trevor BaileyWorle School

    ‘Every Child MattersA School and Federation Perspective’

    Weston Education Partnership

    •Members: 4 Comprehensive schools, 2 special schools, 1 SLD one MLD, and a PRU.

    •All 4 comprehensives will have had new Headteachers in the last 26 months – two appointments pending yet to be made and an acting head in post.

    •Working collaboratively since Sept 2002.

    •All 4 schools more than adequately populated – not an issue.

    •Governors supportive of collaboration.

    •Holiday seaside town with vastly reduced visitor numbers.

    •Recent industry closures has resulted in reduced employment opportunities.

    •Most current employment opportunities are low level service sector.

    •A couple of areas of high deprivation with associated social problems

    •Poorly served by services from youth clubs to cinemas to police presence. (proximity to Bristol) Commuter belt for Bristol

    •Huge housing development planned – private and HousingAssociation

    •Excellent road, rail, air links to national infrastructure.

    •Some small areas of SRB funding

    •Culture of low aspiration and poor progression to higher level courses

    Weston: In need of regeneration

    •Learning in Weston not the first choice for a significant minority at 11+ and 16+•Underachievement – the need to raise standards•Lack of understanding of and aspiration to HE•Disjointed provision and unclear progression•Budget issues•Loss of employment and lack of inward investment•Local council’s “New Vision” for Weston•Interconnectedness between prosperity and high quality learning•Rapidly growing town with pockets of severe deprivation•Need for improving skills base•Some links with teacher training institutions and BristolUniversity.

    •Three of the schools are specialist and between them cover virtually all curriculum areas. Other school is applying to be specialist

    Weston: The Educational Challenge

    Weston-super-Mare Town Perspective

    The Headteachers’ “Burning platform”

    There is a lack of aspiration in the town.

    Low self esteem, a low regard for the worth of lifelong learning / education results in poverty of ambition.

    The schools see regeneration as having to happen from within thecommunity.

    We believe the schools can lead this by addressing post 16 provision, lifelong learning provision and leading the town in gaining a sense of dynamism.

    Achievements to Date

    • Close partnership, openness and trust.• Joint governors’ group• Strong LEA support• Partnership with Weston College• 163 students on link courses, including students from special

    schools• Strategic group and subgroups in place• Inter-school review of teaching and learning pilot• Sharing staff specialisms between institutions• Students and staff from Special Schools and PRUs accessing

    facilities and staff in the 11-16 schools• Joint and specialist INSET

  • Collaboration and Networking will not provide the necessary “Hard Edged” Leadership, Management and Governance structures that will enable schools to become agents of systemic change.

    Provide the highest possible quality of Education in all partner schools.

    However, Federation will give schools and teachers the capacity to:

    Be responsive to the needs of individual learners and offer wider choice.

    Act as agents for regeneration and renewal in their communities.

    Raise the collective game, be research driven and operate at the cutting edge of practice.

    Why Federation?•A hard-edged commitment between schools to work together in partnership to achieve the agreed strategic goals.

    •A core curriculum development programme managed on a Federation-wide basis to progressively enhance and extend the range and accessibility of curriculum available to students and staff.

    •An enhanced 14-19 curriculum, embracing both A level and vocational studies to provide increased flexibility of provision to students at a critical stage of their education and transition to the world of work and higher education.

    •A Federated approach to some of the key leadership, management and staff development initiatives, envisioned under LIG and excellence cluster, but made even more powerful through the process of joint and integrated action

    Teaching Learning

    Choice and Opportunity

    Raising Aspirations

    Putting the Learner First

    A Collegiate Academy, open to all, with teaching and learning at its heart and a focus on improving the achievement, attainment and progression of young people.

    The Weston Federation: An empowered Learning CommunityPROJECT STREAMS FOR FEDERATION IMPLEMENTATION

    Leading learning

    Initial Teacher Training

    ICT infrastructure

    Learner Support

    Virtual Learning Environment

    Transition Management and Organisational Change

    Learning Organisation

    Learning partnerships

    Stakeholder Engagement & Communications

    Continuing Professional DevelopmentVision

    “Towards 2008”

    Governance and Funding strategy

    At the heart of the Weston Federation is the intention to create a unified

    and integrated approach to Learning and Teaching. By working together

    in Federation, the schools believe that they can improve standards

    substantively over the levels possible with their standalone resources,

    even after taking into account the incremental resources of LIG and

    excellence cluster grants.

    •Every individual understands and appreciates the meaning and power of learning for themselves, their future and their relationships with others.

    •Every individual has an appreciation of how to develop and utilise their learning to enable them to achieve fulfilling personal goals.

    •Every individual is equipped to play a full and active role in society.

    Federation Culture and Ethos

  • •Federation philosophy, identity and practices are known, understood and respected by the members of its community.

    •Leadership and Management are recognised in taking a leading role in promoting and fostering progress in a manner consistent with the agreed values.

    •A willingness to seek out and work in new ways to ensure that all individuals are helped in their continuing professional development and to develop a work-life balance for all its members.

    •A first choice of learning for the local community.

    Federation Strategy Every Child Matters:Green Paper Proposals

    • Supporting parents and carers

    • Early intervention

    • Accountability and integration

    • Workforce reform

    Too Many Visions, Plans, Strategies, Fiefdoms and Cooks?

    Scho

    ol

    LEA: StandardsEWS SEN

    CAMH

    S

    GP services and Primary Care Trust

    School Health Service

    Social Services

    PoliceChildProtection

    Acute Hospital

    Trust

    Connexions

    Yout

    h Se

    rvice

    Volun

    tary A

    gencie

    s

    Parents &Carers

    The Solution

    Full Service Extended Schools

    in

    Full Service Federations

    Joining Up The Thinking

    Federation Vision

    Goals

    Aims

    Obj

    ectiv

    es

    Targets

    FederationSMB

    FedTeam

    CAMHS

    Parents & Carers

    Health Services

    Social Services, Housing

    YOT & Police

    Voluntary Sector

    Connexions andYouth Service

    LEADfES

    Federation Team

    Advantages

    • Creation of multi-disciplinary teams• Sharp end staff from different disciplines talk to each other

    and work together as a team• Break through bureaucratic barriers• Quick, immediate responses to need• Common vision, goals and targets• Clarity• Accessibility of support mechanisms• Expertise on site• Children’s needs before system needs

  • David Hargreaves‘Innovation for Transformation’

    We are at our best when we are at our

    boldest …and we have not been bold enough.

    Tony Blair, Conference 2003

    I know the old top-down approach won’t work any more.

    Tony Blair, Conference 2004

    THE NATURE OF INNOVATION

    Radical innovation

    Far from existing practice

    Incremental innovation

    Near to existingpractice

    Major change

    Minor change

    A typology ofTYPES OF INNOVATION IN PUBLIC SERVICE

    ORGANISATIONS

    Transpositional

    Organisational

    Methodological

    Scientific

    Technological

    Radical Incremental

    Distributed innovation

    • the go-it alone approach• the modular approach

    segmentedsequential

    • Independent innovation means individuals seek to invent the wheel for themselves – and duplicate

    • Modularity means the participants collaborate to create an Apollo

    What are ‘good practice’ and ‘best practice’?

    Innovation is best achieved through collaborative networks

    The same networks are the most effective way of transferring the emergent good practices

  • INNOVATIONVALUE

    RISKSSURMOUNTED

    NUMBER OF SPINOFFS

    HIGH

    HIGHLOW

    LOW

    What will you do with your new knowledge?

    • Keep it – Steal it• Sell it – Buy it• Share it – Share it• Give it away – Trust

    An open source network of schools andTeachers would produce a peer-to-peer

    systemof knowledge management that is…

    • decentralised• distributed• disciplined

  • EDUNOVA

    The Levers of Transformation

    IPPR Seminar “Collaboration for Transformation”1 December 2003

    Graham Walker

    The Levers of Transformation

    • In summary• Gap analysis• In detail• Actionable first steps

    © Edunova Ltd

    The UK education system is ready for transformational change

    The good news is:• Many know that transformational

    change is needed and that this need will increase over time, rather than level out

    • Many excellent improvement initiatives over the last 10-15 years have prepared an enormous number of practitioners for transformational change, provided it is led sensitively in the best interests of the learner

    • A major capital commitment has already been made for the very necessary renewal of the buildings and ICT infrastructure of UK education system

    The challenge remains:• There is little shared understanding of

    the comprehensive nature of the transformational changes that are needed and of the guiding principles that should define them

    • There is little understanding as to what it will take to make transformational change happen successfully

    © Edunova Ltd

    The experience of many major programmes suggests the following levers of transformation for benchmarking the effectiveness of government reform policies

    • A recognised imperative for change• An inspiring and unassailable vision• Sufficient resources of effective leadership• A culture of continuous learning and renewal• A balanced portfolio of transitional investments• A system-wide transition strategy• A sustainable steady-state economic model• Responsive support structures, processes and measures• Actionable first steps

    © Edunova Ltd

    There is some way to go before we can say that we have an effective strategy for transforming our UK education system

    Actionable first steps

    Responsive structures, systems and measures

    Sustainable steady-state economics

    System-wide transition strategy

    Balanced transitional investments

    Culture of learning and renewal

    Sufficient effective leadership resources

    Inspiring/ unassailable vision

    Imperative for change

    Ease of completionPresent positionLever of Transformation

    © Edunova Ltd

    Inspiring / Unassailable vision

    Inspiring/ unassailable vision

    Ease of completionPresent positionLever of Transformation

    Inspirational Purpose

    Methods & Tools

    Structures & Goals

    An inspirational and unassailable vision will enable all stakeholders to unite with a strength of purpose that will motivate and energise all the activities that have to happen.

    By focusing single-mindedly on the purpose, we can help individuals work together to overcome the barriers that inevitably loom large in our day to day activities.

    That clarity of purpose is currently not present in the system. The good news is that it is relatively easy to develop and agree.

    © Edunova Ltd

  • Sufficient resources of effective leadership

    Sufficient effective leadership resources

    Ease of completionPresent positionLever of Transformation

    Illustration of the challenge at secondary level

    •Circa 4000 secondary schools in England and Wales

    •Circa 2.5-10% of head-teachers are truly outstanding school principals (and the equivalent percentage of similarly qualified senior managers)

    •Need a major step change in the aspirations and performance of our core education system

    •Need to catch up with and then keep up with fastest changes in human history

    •How to leverage the leadership skills of the few for the benefit of the many?

    Current initiatives, whilst well intended and based on the right principles, are delivering patchy and relatively incremental changes, with no clear definition of end goals and timescales. No coherent way has been found yet for rapidly transferring innovative know-how in the normal course of school business

    Hard-edged collaboratives have the potential to:

    •Leverage scarce leadership, management and other intellectual resources across the system

    •Ensure that the process of change is directed and led by practitioners, with the focus on the learner

    •Research, develop and disseminate new solutions as part of the normal course of school business

    © Edunova Ltd

    A culture of continuous learning and renewal

    Culture of learning and renewal

    Ease of completionPresent positionLever of Transformation

    Currently although there is a spirited debate and experimentation amongst practitioners regarding the nature and benefits of “learning organisations” , this is not yet backed up by relevant policy priorities and national investment programmes

    Surely our schools should be supported in their efforts to become learning organisations?It would be relatively easy to launch a national programme to foster a process of discovery and understanding, as so much has been written and understood about this subject over the last few decades

    RESULTS

    Inspirational Purpose

    Methods & Tools

    Structures & goals

    Skills and capabilities

    Attitudes and beliefs

    Awareness and sensitivities

    Source: The Fifth Discipline Fieldbook(PeterSenge)

    DOMAIN OF ENDURING CHANGE

    DOMAIN OF ACTION

    © Edunova Ltd

    A balanced portfolio of transitional investments

    Balanced transitional investments

    Ease of completionPresent positionLever of Transformation

    Currently, unprecedented levels of investment are being committed in the areas of new buildings and technology. Similar commitments have yet to be made to the new learning frameworks, leadership and staffing arrangements that will be critical to realising the best value from these investments.

    Pathfinding collaboratives can be used as development agents to envision, develop and test the learning frameworks, leadership and staff development arrangements that will best serve the learner in the schools of the future. These can form the blueprints and working exemplars for those that follow.

    Individual transitions

    EndingExp

    loring

    Begi

    nnin

    g

    Designi

    ng

    Lead

    ing

    Realising

    CurrentState

    FutureState

    Organisational transitions

    Organisational readiness and business case

    Vision for change

    Culture & Change

    Organisational Development

    Communication Strategy

    Leadership & stakeholders

    Individual & Team Capacity

    …..There is no simple solution to this transformational challenge

    © Edunova Ltd

    A system-wide transition strategy

    System-wide transition strategy

    Ease of completionPresent positionLever of Transformation

    Currently, there appears to be no explicit national strategy for moving safely and securely from the traditional classroom-based learning model to one that is focused more on the needs of the individual learner.

    A nationally facilitated and nurtured path-finding strategy is needed, using “hard edged” collaborative partnerships to develop, test and demonstrate the required new solutions, and then help the early and later followers to catch up. The path-finding strategy needs to be organised to motivate bold but safe transitions, and to reward success with greater freedoms and powers.

    100% New Learning Paradigm

    100% Traditional Learning Paradigm

    0% New Learning Paradigm

    0% Traditional Learning Paradigm

    Time

    © Edunova Ltd

    Sustainable steady-state economics

    Sustainable steady-state economics

    Ease of completionPresent positionLever of Transformation

    Outcomes: A transformed education system will deliver educational outcomes for young people and those in their communities far in excess of today’s

    Running costs: These will be greater than that of today’s because of the need for:• a more flexible and learner focused curriculum• a more adaptable and learner focused staff, with pay and conditions better aligned with private sector• the regular renewal of the ICT infrastructure and ICT-based learning applications

    Transition costs: These will include:• New buildings and ICT• New curricula and support tools• Staff development and change support• Reform and realignment of other support organisations

    This economic case for Transformation can be made (Perhaps it has been made?). Currently, however, it has not been communicated. Its continuing absence leaves

    stakeholders sceptical about both the resolve and the execution of the plans.

    © Edunova Ltd

    Responsive structures, systems and measures

    Responsive structures, systems and measures

    Ease of completionPresent positionLever of Transformation

    Structures, systems and measuresinclude:

    •DfES

    •National Curriculum

    •National standards agenda

    •Ofsted/HMI

    •TTA/HE/NCSL

    •QCA

    •LEAs/LSC

    •Examination boards

    •and many others

    All have to be re-designed to respond to the needs of the transformed schools of the future

    Currently, little has been done structurally to enable all of the functions listed to respond to the emerging new order. The scope, criticality and labour-intensity of the required changes cannot be overemphasised. To some degree, some of the funding needed at practitioner level within schools will have to be met by the dividends from the reshaping of the support sector

    © Edunova Ltd

  • Actionable next stepsAn agenda for the next political cycle ?

    • Recognise the need for an organising framework for system-wide transformation• Develop that framework, the key elements of the transformation strategy, and the

    outline economic case for system wide transformation• Mobilise a critical mass of path-finding “hard-edged” collaboratives (say 40-50

    secondary collaboratives of 10-15 schools; and 80-90 primary collaboratives of 20-30 schools) to research, explore and deliver transformational solutions that point the way for others to follow. Ensure that they are adequately funded and supported to move as quickly and expeditiously as possible.

    • Monitor progress at 18 month intervals. Stabilise or reduce funding for low achievers or those falling far short of committed targets. Enhance funding and support for those succeeding.

    • Nurture and support these programme through a strategic collaborative unit reporting directly to the Secretary of State.

    • Launch other selected national programmes to help pave the way for the following implementation cycles (eg a national “learning organisation” discovery programme)

    • Refine the economic case in the light of path-finding experience• Plan the next two 5-year cycles of the transformation process

    © Edunova Ltd

  • Jenny MossThe views of Westhaven Special School, a member of the

    Weston Education Partnership, on the role of a special school in a developing Federation.

    Weston Education Partnership - WEP

    A Federation of four secondary and two special schools.

    Westhaven School

    • A 75 place special school for pupils aged 7-16 years, with a wide variety of barriers to learning.

    • School Achievement Award 2003• Investors in People 2003

    Ofsted Report - June 2003:

    ‘Westhaven is a good and improving School’…• The quality of the teaching is good overall and very good in

    three lessons in ten.• Very good relationships between pupils and staff.• Overall the range of learning experiences is good.• Very good links with parents and carers who are able to

    contribute well to pupils’ learning.• Excellent leadership and management.

    Pupil Outcomes at KS4

    GCSE 2002 &200390% of Year 11 pupils gained at least one GCSE A* - G (3 times

    the national average for similar schools)25% of Year 11 pupils gained 5+ GCSEs A* - G(40 times the national average for similar schools)

    Value Added Tables 2002KS3 – 4 102.7 – the highest score of any maintained secondary

    school in the LEA

    Weston Education Achievement ZoneWEAZ

    Weston Family of Schools + Excellence Cluster

    DfES Conference – Innovations Unit

    Essential requirements for a successful Federation:

    1. Aspirational Vision2. Wholehearted commitment of all schools and

    Governing Bodies3. Support and encouragement of LEA4. Support and ‘start up’ funding from DfES5. External consultants to provide capacity, drive and

    ‘know how’ - Edunova.

  • WEP Benefits to Special Schools:

    • Equal Opportunities for all• Inclusion in all appropriate activities• Acceptance of special schools• Common timetabling and INSET days• CPD opportunities for staff• ICT developments• Access to specialist schools staffing e.g.Drama GCSE at Worle• Equal representation on Strategic Management Board• Economies of Scale in Purchasing/Sharing Staff/Minority Courses• WEP to be based in Westhaven.

    WEP Benefits from including Special Schools:

    • CPD Opportunities: such as Behaviour Management, Differentiation, Working with parents/carers, Planning and delivery of individual learning programmes.

    • ITT Development of new strand to include special school experience, plus CAMHS and Social Service dimensions.

    • Multi-professional and Inter-agency working: Integration of service providers such as Social Services, Health - therapists, CAMHS, Connexions etc.

    • Flexible Placements e.g. NVQ1 Catering

    Additional Advantages for WEP Members:

    • Strategic planning at a local level• Wide variety of expertise available to all schools• Common timetabling and INSET days• Multi agency working - extended schools• Access to new technologies - development of a 21st

    Century curriculum• Economy of scale in awarding contracts: Catering,

    Grounds etc• Attraction of further initiatives

    Barriers to participation by Special Schools:

    National• Lack of recognition of all

    levels of achievement in value added and league tables

    • Initiatives which exclude special schools

    • Perceived values of status of special schools

    School Specific• The ‘Day Job’ - essential

    involvement of external consultants

    • Capacity of schools to release staff

    • Territorial views of some governors - Loss of identity or Dilution of expertise.

    WEP The Future 2008(Crystal ball gazing!)

    • WEP NVQ provider• All federation targets met (and exceeded)• Management of all SEN• ‘Out of the box’ thinking and innovation• Blurring of barriers between schools - joint placements

    commonplace• Diverse individualised curricula developed• Closer business links to align WRL with NVQs

    The Weston Education Partnership will transform secondary education by

    collaboration, to ensure equal opportunities, inclusion and access for all students in

    Weston-super-Mare.

  • Sally PowerInstitute of Education

    ‘Lessons from the EAZ initiative’

    The research• 42 month study funded by the Economic and Social

    Research Council• Survey and case study data, largely from the early

    zones• Also informed by SEED-funded 3 year evaluation of

    Scottish New Community Schools

    • Key issues• Within zone collaboration• Collaboration beyond the zone

    Within zone collaboration

    • Staff generally very positive:‘…It’s been quite useful to think in terms of being

    part of something bigger than just one school. It’s been good knowing that there is a network of people working on the same sort of thing, and to have contact with them, and to find out what’s going on in other schools. ... You can feel quite isolated here.’

    Main EAZ benefits: Greenbrook

    8%0%EAZ team support

    10%4%Professional development

    8%11%Experimentation

    47%44%Collaboration

    34%56%Resources

    20022000

    Issues: Time

    • Time spent in meetings‘… to be quite honest, the school is better with her in the

    school … the roles need to be considered quite carefully … if she can demonstrate that they EAZ has done lots of wonderful things and she wants to share that then that's great, as long as that doesn't actually interfere with the daily running of the school.’

    ‘…. it [the cluster meeting] hasn’t been particularly successfulbecause it’s – ‘oh, it’s an EAZ meeting. It’s like - oh, I’ve got to turn up’. But I’m just paying it lip service. And there is that feeling within the staff.’

    Issues: Social or substantive?

    ‘…We have meetings between schools .. where we get to have a good gossip and see what’s going on elsewhere … I mean, it’s not been overwhelmingly useful, but it’s been pleasant.’

    ‘… I’ve made really good friends in other schools because of it.’

  • Issues: Peripheral or permeating

    • Network ‘insiders’ and ‘outsiders’‘…I’m aware that some people have been more

    involved in what is going on in the zone than others, and I suspect that some people have even got time off within the school to follow EAZ initiatives, but quite how that relates to anything that goes on in my classroom, I’d have to say I am pretty vague about.’

    Collaboration with non-Zone schools• Generally problematic

    –The arbitrariness of whose ‘inside’ and ‘outside’

    –Differential resource levels–The effects of inter-school competition

    On sharing good practice…

    ‘...It's like being a prophet without honour in your own country …You can’t go to other [non-zone] schools and say ‘Oh, we’ve got lots of money, and we do wonderful things [with it].’ We get a better response on the other side of the country than the other side of town.’

    Factors that appear to hinder collaboration• Different governing arrangements, in particular

    for voluntary schools• ‘Arbitrary’ inclusion• High staff turn-over of key personnel• Heavy time commitment• Competition between schools

    Factors that appear to foster collaboration• Having designated ‘collaborators’• A relatively small number of schools• Clarity over resources and mutuality of

    benefits• Clear focus about the purpose:

    Collaboration for what end?

  • Kathryn RileyInstitute of Education

    ‘A bottom up approach to change’

    Context

    • 1998 > Plethora of initiatives

    • EAZs – raise standards of achievement in areas of deprivation

    • Expected, at one and same time, to be ‘creative, flexible, innovative & safe’ (Riley & Watling, 1999)

    • Some smaller initiatives (mini-EAZs) operated between the cracks

    • WRaPP: Woolwich Reach & Plumstead Pathfinder EIC Action Zones (18 schools)

    • Two evaluations: 2002/3

    • Staffing context: • High turnover, agency,

    overseas, inexperienced middle management

    • Community context: Deprivation, refugees, families experiencing multiple difficulties

    WRaPPWRaPPWRaPPWRaPP 20022002

    • Schools responded positively to WRaPP’sbottom-up approach

    • (Balance between schools’ identified needs: new horizons e.g. Accelerated Learning)

    Targeted funding

    Development strategyfor teachers

    Change strategy for school leaders

    •Approach

    Questions for 2003Questions for 2003

    Impact on learningoutcomes?

    Spread of good practice amongst

    schools?

    impact of WRaPPprojects?

    Impact on pupils& parents?

    Success of training& development

    activities?

    Impact on teachers’ views & practices?

    Questions

    • Great enthusiasm: particularly professional opportunities

    • Project leadership: highly supportive

    • Senior staff : practical support for pupils with emotional & learning difficulties, additional resources for attendance etc

    • Primary: WRaPP major tool for school improvement

    • For secondary: network & source of professional learning

    • WRaPP approach helps reduce confrontation.

    • It creates opportunity for dialogue & enables people to talk about feelings & say to pupils, ‘teachers get upset when you…’.

    • We are all enthralled by WRaPP.

    What did teachers say?hat did teachers say?

  • Accelerated LearningAccelerated Learning

    • Embraced with considerable enthusiasm across schools

    • Appears to have rejuvenated staff & motivated pupils

    • Accelerated Learning has helped create a climate of respectful learners. …..Teachers learn to identify what is getting in the way of learning.

    • … I feel liberated by AL. I used to think that listening to the teacher meant that children should sit with their arms folded. Now I recognize this isn’t the case

    What did we see? PrimaryWhat did we see? Primary

    • I observed a Year 6 literacy lesson. Her classroom was magnificent - colourful, creative, imaginative, exciting, loads to look at and read.

    • Key pointers and signs around - an Aladdin's cave! Such a stimulating environment.

    • She used accelerated learning warm up/energising techniques at the beginning; all children involved & using whiteboards to make notes & try out ideas.

    • They were addressing the argument 'is homework necessary?‘

    • I came out feeling very energised!

    What did we see? SecondaryWhat did we see? Secondary

    • I observed a lesson given by an English teacher who had attended the ‘Art of Learning Training’ – on techniques for note-taking through work on Macbeth.

    • The lesson was energetic & vibrant & focused on the left & right sides of the brain.

    • The students were engaged & interested.

    • One boy said, 'My ideas are running around my head and I'm trying to catch one'.

    Evidence of Impact:Evidence of Impact:SuccessSuccess IndicatorsIndicators

    • Changes in:Perceptions: attitudes of teachers most closely

    involvedBehaviour : classroom practices & learning environment of their pupils

    Improvements in:Attendance: Absences in WRaPP primaries reduced.

    Greatest strides - schools with high levels of involvement Performance : Wide variation between schools, but those most closely involved, on faster upwards trajectory

    What are the implications for change &

    improvement?

    Change process

    • DirectorJill Jordan

    • There is a feeling that teachers are being acknowledged & recognised as people & have learnt skills that they will use in all aspects of their life

    • Professional Development is valued & linked to further study & research based on classroom practice (e.g. MTeach)

    • Teachers receive support with research, individual mentoring & an opportunity to be part of a live, experiential learning community (GTF)

  • • Development opportunities & networks

    • Change Leaders…. There’s never been anything here before about my development.

    • It was unlike anything I’ve ever been on. It provided me with the skills for listening & communicating, putting things into context. ..… I can now identify stages where people are at in the change process….I recognize the patterns in myself. …. It helps me understand why some people struggle to change.

    What inspires teachers? Change modelChange model

    – Research on effective reform & change - development dependent on number of factors:

    Climate of trust Activities focused at changing teachers’ ideas & practicesOpportunities & time for collaboration & networkingFeedback & evaluation

    – All these characteristics present in WRaPP

    Experience

    Reflect

    Personal capacitybuilding

    Experiment & change

    Facilitated time toreflect

    Support to conceptualise

    Make sense

    Change