science drivers for the square kilometre kilometre arrayaramis.obspm.fr/ska/meet/steve-jun09.pdfska...

41
S.A. Torchinsky 1 SKA Science Drivers SKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 Science Drivers Science Drivers for the for the Square Square Kilometre Kilometre Array Array Steve Torchinsky USN/GEPI SKADS Project Scientist www.skads-eu.org

Upload: others

Post on 25-Sep-2019

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 1SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Science DriversScience Drivers for thefor the

Square Square KilometreKilometre ArrayArray

Steve Torchinsky USN/GEPI

SKADS Project Scientist

www.skads-eu.org

Page 2: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 2SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKA Key ScienceSKA Key Science

Tests of gravityEpoch of

Reionisation Cosmic Magnetism

Cradle of Life

Large Scale Structure

Transient Universe

The Unknown

Page 3: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 3SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Chris Carilli & SteveSteve RawlingsRawlings, New Astronomy Reviews, Vol.48, Elsevier, Dec. 2004

SKA Science BookSKA Science Book

http://www.skads-eu.org/p/SKA_SciBook.php

Page 4: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 4SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Strong Field Tests of GravityStrong Field Tests of Gravity

Binary orbit permits determination of masses

Relativistic effects permit (re) determination of masses.

ALL MUST AGREE

http://www.jb.man.ac.uk/~pulsar/

Page 5: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 5SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Strong Field Tests of GravityStrong Field Tests of Gravity

Large surveys will find exotic binarys–

~20 000 pulsars in the galaxy

Nearly edge-on Pulsar –

Black-hole binary (at least one)•

Probe eg. Frame dragging, cosmic censorship, no hair theorem

Pulsar timing array–

Gravitational wave background

Page 6: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 6SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Probing the Dark AgesProbing the Dark Ages•

When did the first luminous objects form?

How did they form and over what period of time?•

SKA will detect the Epoch of Reionisation and map

the evolution history of the first luminous objects

Di

Matteo

et al

Page 7: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 7SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Cosmic MagnetismCosmic MagnetismFaraday rotation of > 107

polarised background sources

Origin of magnetic fields–

Dynamo?

Primordial?

NGC 891 NGC 891 (Krause)(Krause)

M 51 M 51 VLA+EffVLA+Eff 6cm 6cm (Fletcher & Beck)(Fletcher & Beck)

Page 8: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 8SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Large Scale StructureLarge Scale Structure

Billions of galaxies!

Page 9: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 9SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Baryonic Acoustic OscillationsBaryonic Acoustic Oscillations•

Improve signal confidence by measuring wiggles in separate redshift

bins

A catalog of a billion galaxies•

Position and redshift

measured simultaneously

There are fluctuations at all scales but there is a preferred scale of around 1 deg.

Page 10: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 10SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

1%

ComplementarityComplementarity with Planckwith Planck

Page 11: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 11SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

G. Bryden

/ NASA

Cradle of LifeCradle of Life•

Protoplanetary

disks resolved to Earth-like orbits

Organic molecules–

methanol (834 MHz)

acetaldehyde (1.1 GHz)–

acetamide

(9.2 GHz)

cyclopropenone

(9.3 GHz)–

propenal

(26 GHz)

Extrasolar

planets

Page 12: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 12SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

ProjectPhoenix

AllenTelescope

Array

SKA

Jill Tarter

SETI at leakage levels from nearby stars

eg:• planetary radar• Interplanetary

communication• Interstellar

communication

Indicators of Indicators of Extra Terrestrial IntelligenceExtra Terrestrial Intelligence

Page 13: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 13SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

TransientsTransients

Start recording…

Page 14: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 14SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Transient signalTransient signal

Page 15: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 15SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

TransientsTransients

Page 16: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 16SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Transient signalTransient signal

Page 17: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 17SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

TransientsTransients

Pulsar is a special case of transient phenomena (periodic)

Giant pulses•

Supernova

Bursters•

ETI

requires:• fast time constant• memory buffer for post analysis• wide instantaneous, fully-sampled FoV

Page 18: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 18SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Transient signalTransient signal

Page 19: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 19SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

The UnknownThe Unknown•

New discoveries always result from observations in new parameter space–

sensitivity

spatial resolution–

spectral resolution

polarisation–

time domain

observing speed (multibeaming)

eg. CMB, pulsars, extra solar planets,…

SKA improves all of these

SKA is designed for the Key Projects but with an overriding design philosophy of flexibility to maximise

the likelihood of new discoveries

Page 20: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 20SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Chris Carilli & SteveSteve RawlingsRawlings, New Astronomy Reviews, Vol.48, Elsevier, Dec. 2004

SKA Science BookSKA Science Book

http://www.skads-eu.org/p/SKA_SciBook.php

Page 21: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 21SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Cosmology, Galaxy Formationand Astroparticle

Physics

on the Pathway to the SKA

Hans-Rainer Klöckner, Steve Rawlings,

Matt Jarvis, Angela Taylor (eds.)

Co

smo

log

y, G

ala

xy F

orm

ati

on

an

d A

stro

pa

rtic

leP

hys

ics

on

th

e

Pa

thw

ay

to t

he

SK

A

Available online:

www.skads-eu.org (click “astronomy”

and

“LOSKA2006”)

Page 22: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 22SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Simulations for the SKASimulations for the SKA

image by D. Obreschkow

Page 23: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 23SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

Simulations for the SKASimulations for the SKA

Effort in SKADS:•

Catalog of continuum sources (250 Million sources)

Epoch of Reionisation

(tomography from z≈15 to z≈6)•

The Cosmic Web

Pulsars

See SKADS Simulated Skies website–

www.skads-eu.org/p/s-cubed.php

See Proceedings of the Pushchino

Meeting–

www.skads-eu.org/p/memos.php

And others listed there, available on astro-ph

Page 24: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 24SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKADS Simulated SkiesSKADS Simulated Skies

s-cubed.physics.ox.ac.uk

Page 25: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 25SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKADS Simulated SkiesSKADS Simulated Skies

www.skads-eu.org/p/s-cubed.php

Page 26: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 26SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKADS Publications (1/4)SKADS Publications (1/4)

Page 27: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 27SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKADS Publications (2/4)SKADS Publications (2/4)

Page 28: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 28SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKADS Publications (3/4)SKADS Publications (3/4)

Page 29: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 29SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKADS Publications (4/4)SKADS Publications (4/4)

www.skads-eu.org/p/memos.php

Page 30: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 30SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKADS Science and Technology SKADS Science and Technology The Universe

Our understanding of the Universe

Sky Simulation (DS2T1)

Convolution with the telescope (DS2T2)

Network simulator (DS3T3)

Technology development

(DS4)

Technology demonstrators

(DS5 & DS6)

observations

brain power

Catalogs, images, EM fields

voltages

mea

sure

men

tsan

dsi

mul

ated

pe

rform

ance

Request spec change

BENCHMARK

Backend data

Data imaging (DS2T2)

Simulated telescope image

Data analysis (DS2)

science goals achievable?

Page 31: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 31SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKADS Science and TechnologySKADS Science and TechnologyThe Universe

Our understanding of the Universe

Sky Simulation (DS2T1)

Convolution with the telescope (DS2T2)

Network simulator (DS3T3)

Technology development

(DS4)

Technology demonstrators

(DS5 & DS6)

observations

brain power

voltages

mea

sure

men

tsan

dsi

mul

ated

pe

rform

ance

Backend data

Data imaging (DS2T2)

Simulated telescope image

Request spec change

BENCHMARK

Catalogs, images, EM fields

Data analysis (DS2)

science goals achievable?

Consider trade-offs

NO: not technologically feasible

NO: too expensive

YES: We can do better than that !

SKADS Design & Costing

Page 32: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 32SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKA Design and CostingSKA Design and Costing

SKADS final deliverable “Designed and Costed

SKA”•

First memo: detailed design–

www.skads-eu.org/p/memos.php

SKA Memo #93–

~1.5BEuro

Development of costing tool: SKACost–

Designed and costed

components and subsystems

Data base for costing different SKA implementations–

SKADS in collaboration with International SKA Program Office

Page 33: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 33SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

1st

MCCT School

Medicina

23-29 Sept 2007

Wide field imaging and calibration

Groningen 2-7 March

Synergies with the SKA

Bonn 14-18 April 2008

Deep Field Imaging with SKA

Cambridge 25-29 Aug

Radioastronomy

and the New Instruments

Siguenza

27 Aug –

4 Sept

Multifield

and multibeam

science with SKA

Oxford 15-27 March 2009

Increasing the evolution rate in radio astronomy

Paris 24-28 August 2009

Towards 3rd

generation calibration

Nançay

27 Sept –

10 Oct

Training the next generationTraining the next generation

Page 34: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 34SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

EMBRACEEMBRACE

Electronic MultiBeam

Radio Astronomy ConcEpt•

Aperture-Plane phased-array

500MHz –

1500MHz•

Linear polarisation

160m2

at Westerbork

90m2

at Nançay

Page 35: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 35SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

EMBRACE at EMBRACE at NanNanççayay

Page 36: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 36SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

EMBRACE at EMBRACE at NanNanççayay

Page 37: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 37SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

EMBRACE at EMBRACE at NanNanççayay

Page 38: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 38SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

NanNanççayay BeamformerBeamformer ChipChip

Page 39: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 39SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

EMBRACE observations of the SunEMBRACE observations of the Sun

Page 40: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 40SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

SKA Key ScienceSKA Key Science

Tests of gravityEpoch of

Reionisation Cosmic Magnetism

Cradle of Life

Large Scale Structure

Transient Universe

The Unknown

Page 41: Science Drivers for the Square Kilometre Kilometre Arrayaramis.obspm.fr/SKA/meet/Steve-jun09.pdfSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009 SKA Science Drivers S.A. Torchinsky

S.A. Torchinsky 41SKA Science DriversSKA information day, GEPI, Meudon, 16 juin 2009

ContactContact

Steve TorchinskySKADS Project ScientistUSN/GEPI, Observatoire de Paris

Phone: +33 1 45 07 75 02Email: [email protected]: http://www.skads-eu.org