sequencin in architecture
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
1/66
UNIVERSITY OF CINCINNATI
Date:___________________
I, _________________________________________________________,
hereby submit this work as part of the requirements for the degree of:
in:
It is entitled:
August 17, 2006
Cynthia L. Bubb
Master of Architecture
School of Architecture and Interior Design of the College of Design, Architecture, Art and Planning
Sequence as Structure: Ordering the Body, Space and Architecture
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
2/66
Sequence as Structure: Ordering the Body, Space & Architecture
A thesis submitted to the
Division of Research and Advanced Studies of the
University of Cincinnati
in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of
Master of Architecture
in the Department of Architecture and Interior Design
of the College of Design, Architecture, Art and Planning
2006
by
Cynthia L. Bubb
B.S., Miami University, 1998
Committee:
First Chair: Michael McInturf
Second Chair: Arati Kanekar
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
3/66
Architectural sequences have often taken the form of linear spatial
progressions. In the twentieth century the naissance of cinema, wherein linear
progressions are interrupted and manipulated according to the elastic properties of
the medium, suggested new forms for architectural sequence. As a result Modern and
Postmodern architects appropriated cinematic concepts to architectural theory and
design. In particular, Le Corbusier and Bernard Tschumi explored the implications
of the frame, an intrinsic component of cinema, as a viewing device and structure
to order architectural sequences. The methodology adopted for the design of a
ferry terminal in Boston, Massachusetts reflects the influence of Bernard Tschumis
theoretical exercise, The Manhattan Transcripts, particularly MT 4: The Block.
Represented in diagram, the interaction of space, movement, event and an additional
factor, time, conveys the concurrent development and influence of four spatial
sequences on the design of the terminal.
ABSTRACT
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
4/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
5/66
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to thank my family and friends, in particular Mom, Dad, Julie, Terry and Jileen, for
their love and support this year and the past five years.
Thanks also to Aarati Kanekar, Michael McInturf and Gordon Simmons for their advice and
patience throughout the thesis process.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
6/66
Table of Contents
List of Illustrations
Illustration Credits
Introduction
Chapter 1: Structural Analysis of Sequence
narrative sequence
the manhattan transcripts
maninpulation of the frame in slow house
Chapter 2: Linear Progressions to Montage Collisions
linear progressions
cinematic sequence: the changing point of view of the spectator
from cinema to architecture
architect as director: villa savoye
Chapter 3: Sequence and Uncertainty
the situationist international
constants new babylon
yokohama port terminal
Chapter 4: Conclusion and Design Methodology
Chapter 5: Design
Site
Program
Appendix
CONTENTS
| i
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
7/66
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
Introduction
Figure 0.1
Photograph of Barcelona Pavilion
Figure 0.2
Photograph of Barcelona Pavilion
Chapter 1: Structural Analysis of Sequence
Figure 1.1 [Notes by Cynthia Bubb]
Second Floor Plan of Slow House
Figure 1.2
Model of Slow House
Figure 1.3 [Notes by Cynthia Bubb]Slow House Plan and Section Drawing
Figure 1.4
Slow House Section Model
Chapter 2: Linear Progressions to Montage Collisions
Figure 2.1
Poster for Berlin, the Symphony of a Great
Figure 2.2
The Carceri: An Immense Interior with Numerous Wooden Galleries and a Drawbridge in the Center
by Giovanni PiranesiFigure 2.3
The Acropolis, First Sight of the Platformby Auguste Choisy
Figure 2.4
Diagrams of the Acropolis by Sergei Eisenstein
Figure 2.5 [Notes by Cynthia Bubb]
Ground Floor Plan of Villa Savoye
Figure 2.6 [Notes by Cynthia Bubb]
| ii
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
8/66
First Floor Plan of Villa Savoye
Figure 2.7 [Notes by Cynthia Bubb]
Second Floor Plan of Villa SavoyeFigure 2.8 [Notes by Cynthia Bubb]
Section of Villa SavoyeFigure 2.9 [Notes by Cynthia Bubb]Photograph of Villa Savoye
Figure 2.10
Photograph of Villa Savoye
Figure 2.11
Photograph of Villa SavoyeFigure 2.12
Photograph of Villa Savoye
Figure 2.13
Photograph of Villa Savoye
Figure 2.14
Photograph of Villa SavoyeFigure 2.15 [Notes by Cynthia Bubb]Photograph of Villa Savoye
Figure 2.16 [Notes by Cynthia Bubb]Photograph of Villa Savoye
Chapter 3: Sequence and Uncertainty
Figure 3.1
The Naked Cityby Guy Debord
Figure 3.2
Memoiresby Asger Jorn and Guy DebordFigure 3.3
Psychogeographic Map of Venice by Ralph Rumney
Figure 3.4
Photograph of Yokohama Port Terminal
List of Illustrations | iii
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
9/66
Figure 3.5
Photograph of Yokohama Port Terminal
Figure 3.6
Photograph of Yokohama Port TerminalFigure 3.7Photograph of Yokohama Port Terminal
Figure 3.8
Photograph of Yokohama Port Terminal
Conclusion
Design Project
Figure 5.1 [Diagram by Cynthia Bubb]
Program, Sequence & TimeFigure 5.2 [Diagram by Cynthia Bubb]Commuter Boat Routes
Figure 5.3 [Diagram by Cynthia Bubb]Proposed Inner Harbor and Commuter Routes from Fan Pier
Figure 5.4 [Diagram by Cynthia Bubb]Fan Pier
List of Illustrations | iv
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
10/66
ILLUSTRATION CREDITS
Betsky, Aaron. Scanning the Aberrant Architecture of Diller + Scofidio. New York: Harry N. Abrams, Inc., 2003.
Curtis, William J.R.Modern Architectur e Since 1900. New York: Phaidon Press Inc., 2003.
Ferre, Albert and others, eds. The Yokohama Project: Foreign Office Architects. Barcelona: Actar, 2002.
Ford, Simon. The Situationist International: A Users Guide. London: Black Dog Publishing, 2005.
Futagawa, Yukio, ed.Mies van der Rohe: German Pavilion & Tugendhat House.Tokyo: A.D.A. Edita, 1995.
Katz, Lois and Jessica Berman, eds. Piranesi: Drawings and Etchings at the Avery Architectural Library. New York:Meriden Gravure Company, 1975.
Penz, Francois and Maureen Thomas, eds. Cinema & Architecture: Mlis, Mallet-Stevens, Multimedia. London: BritishFilm Institute, 1997.
Sbriglio, Jacques. Le Corbusier: La Villa Savoye. Basel: Birkhuser Publishers, 1999.
Tschumi, Bernard. The Manhattan Transcripts. 2nd edition. London: Academy Editions, 1994.
| v
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
11/66
Introduction
Sequence, as defined by literary critic Roland Barthes, is a logical succession of nuclei bound together by a
relation of solidarity: the sequence opens when one of the terms has no solidary antecedent and closes when anotherof its terms has no consequence.1 Developed in response to narrative sequences, the definition translates equally
to architecture and film. The thesis investigates the impact of cinematic approaches to sequence on architecture and
proposes a methodology derived from theoretical and built precedents. Specifically, the methodology adopted for
the design of a ferry terminal in Boston, Massachusetts reflects the influence of Bernard Tschumis The Manhattan
Transcripts.
The development of sequence through history provides a basis for understanding manifestations of
sequence in modern times. Often architectural sequences took the form of linear progressions.2 However, a radical
shift in the conception of space at the turn of the twentieth century, heralded by art and architecture critic Anthony
Vidler as an explosion of space,3 conveyed the potential of nonlinear progressions. Russian film director Sergei
Eisenstein compared cinematic and architectural space in his analysis of architect Auguste Choisys description of
the Acropolis at Athens. In doing so, Eisenstein paralleled the experience of walking through the Acropolis to the
peripatetic vision of the camera. The concept of peripatetic vision, along with the spatially complex renderings
of Piranesi, directly influenced Modern architects conception of space. In Mies van der Rohes iconic Barcelona
Pavilion, there is one sequence of direct vision and one for the experience of the body.4 The idea of conflict or
disconnect between body and vision also influenced the work of Le Corbusier. His development of the ramp as
architectonic promenade, particularly at the Villa Savoye, embodies this concept.
In the late 1950s through the early 1970s, the Situationist International explored concepts of space and
sequence as part of a political agenda. In turn the Situationist concepts of drive, urban wandering, and dtournement,
montage, manifest in their writings and social experiments influenced a generation of young architects. The concept
of drive, in which the Situationists aimlessly wandered the streets of Paris open to any event that might interrupt
| 1
Figure 0.1Mies van der Rohe, German Pavilion,International Exposition, Barcelona,Spain, 1928-29 (reconstructed 1986)
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
12/66
their journey, influenced architect Bernard Tschumis interest in event architecture and the relationship of events to
sequence and space.The first chapter of the thesis, Structural Analysis of Sequence defines sequence from a structural point
of view and serves as reference point for later chapters. The chapter begins with a comparison of architect Bernard
Tschumis essay Sequences and Roland Barthes essay Introduction to the Structural Analysis of Narratives
and establishes a link between Barthes four functional narrative units and Tschumis internal and external relations.
In Tschumis essay Sequences, he identifies three relations within the architectural sequence: an internal relation
that deals with the method of work, such as transformation, and two external relations, spatial and programmatic.
The second part of the chapter analyzes Tschumis theoretical project, The Manhattan Transcripts, according to the
logic of Sequences. The chapter concludes with the application of sequence and the frame to Slow House, an
unbuilt vacation home by architects Diller + Scofidio. Slow House embodies a calculated and controlled approach
to architectural sequence that contrasts with less defined, open-ended approaches to sequence identified later in the
thesis.
The second chapter of the thesis, Linear Progressions to Montage Collisions, recounts the development
of sequence in architecture up to the Modern era. The chapter concludes with Le Corbusiers Villa Savoye in
which the ramp as architectonic promenade represents an innovation in the approach to sequence. On the ramp,
the spectator experiences a vertical and horizontal relation to architectural space. Likewise switchbacks enable the
spectator to simultaneously reflect upon the route taken and anticipate the final destination. The view destination at
Villa Savoye anticipates the relationship of view to Slow House and the use of the frame as a structural element in
Tschumis The Manhattan Transcripts.
The final chapter of the thesis, Sequence and Uncertainty, explores the liberating potential of sequence.
In contrast to the prescribed routes dictated by the architects and architecture of Slow House and Villa Savoye, the
Situationist International exploits the potential of open-ended, loosely defined sequences. Rather than a view or
other destination, ambulation is the object of the open sequence. In particular, the architecture of Yokohama PortIntroduction | 2
Figure 0.2Mies van der Rohe, German Pavilion,International Exposition, Barcelona,Spain, 1928-29 (reconstructed 1986)
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
13/66
Introduction | 3
Terminal by Foreign Office Architects invites drive, or urban wandering, advocated by the Situationists.
The thesis analyzes precedents according to internal and external relations in order to clarify the roleof sequence in each project. As a result, it is possible to divide the precedents according to two extremes. At one
extreme, the architect manipulates sequence for control over the position of the body, viewing angle and other
variables within the scope of sequence. This extreme is exemplified by the ramp sequence at Villa Savoye. In contrast,
the opposite extreme facilitates freedom of movement, of view and interaction through options and freedom of
choice. As such, it is exemplified in Tschumis event spaces and Constants New Babylon.
The relation of sequence to movement represents a compelling opportunity for architects. The thesis
includes drawings of three dimensional sequences, but the progressive, constructed nature of sequence translates
especially well to model form. Notably, Diller + Scofidios model of Slow House communicates the consistently
changing relationship between body and architecture achieved through the curve and slope of walls. The
representation of sequence presents a particular challenge to the methodology and design of the thesis building
project.
Endnotes
1 Roland Barthes. Introduction to the Structural Analysis of Narratives, in Image, Music, Text, translated by Stephen Heath, (NewYork: Hill and Wang, 1977), 101.
2 Bernard Tschumi, Sequences, inArchitecture and Disjunction, (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1996).
3 Anthony Vidler, The Explosion of Space: Architecture and the Filmic Imaginary, in Film Architecture, ed. Dietrich Neumann(Munich, Germany: Prestel-Verlag, 1996), 22.
4 Bernard Tschumi, Sequences, inArchitecture and Disjunction, (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press), 199.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
14/66
Chapter 1Structural Analysis of Sequence
| 4
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
15/66
Structural Analysis of Sequence
Structural Analysis of Sequence | 5
In the essay Sequences, written between 1981 and 1983, architect and theorist Bernard Tschumi
defines sequence as a formal structure that supports the interplay of space, event and movement in architectural
compositions. The subject and tone of Tschumis essay owes much to French literary critic Roland Barthes essay,
Introduction to the Structural Analysis of Narratives, first published in 1966, in which Barthes systematically
dissects the narrative into composite literary units and sequences. Comparison of Tschumis Sequences and
Barthes Introduction to the Structural Analysis of Narratives, reveals the origins of Tschumis interest in sequence
and the difficulties inherent in translating narrative techniques to architecture.
In Introduction to the Structural Analysis of Narratives, Barthes compares narrative analysis to linguistics.
In linguistics, there is nothing that is not to be found in the sentence.1 Though narratives exhibit characteristics
of sentences, they are composed of narrative units that may be higher than sentences, such as groups of sentences,
or lower than sentences, such as individual words and even elements within words. Though a hierarchy exists among
units, Barthes contends the removal of a single unit, no matter how insignificant, alters the narrative.
In the process of his analysis, Barthes identifies four functional narrative units. The first function, the
cardinal function, constitutes a hinge point in the narrative. According to Barthes, the cardinal function must open,
continue, or close an alternative that is of direct consequence for the subsequent development of the narrative.2
An example of a cardinal function is: a phone rings and someone answers it. The action is cardinal because, in this
instance, not answering the phone would significantly alter the course of the narrative. Catalyzers make up the second
functional unit and fill in the narrative space that separates cardinal functions. In the example, the process of walking
across the room to answer the phone and lifting the receiver are catalyzers. The third class of functional unit, the
integrational unit, comprises diffuse concepts such as mood and metaphor necessary to story development. The last
unit, the informant, situates the narrative in a particular time and space.
Barthes functional units combine and overlap to create nar rative sequences. In a definition quoted by
Tschumi in his essay Sequences, Barthes refers to sequence as a logical succession of nuclei bound together by a
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
16/66
relation of solidarity: the sequence opens when one of i ts terms has no solitary antecedent and closes when another
of its terms has no consequences.3 A narrative sequence is always nameable, such as Having a drink.4 Structurally,
sequences may overlap and in doing so create distortions and expansions in the narrative. Alternately, units in
particular sequence may be separated from one another by the insertion of units from other sequences. For example,
a simple process such as sitting on a chair or reaching for a glass may be initiated in one part of the narrative,
interrupted by monologue, flashback or other narrative device, and completed in another. While Barthes narrative
units correspond logically to similar concerns in architecture, identified by Bernard Tschumi as program, space and
movement, the space-time constraints of the three dimensional environment inhibit direct translation of narrative
sequences to architecture.
The expansion and interruption of sequences are two conditions, among many, considered by Tschumi
in Sequences. Tschumis essay reads as an extended definition of architectural sequence. According to Tschumi,
architectural sequences include or imply at least three relations, one internal and two external. The internal
relation deals with the method of work.5 It is described as a device or a procedure, such as transformation. A
transformational sequence usually relies upon rules dictated by the architect such as: compression, rotation, insertion,
and transference. Additionally, transformational sequences can display sets of variations, multiplications, fusions,
repetitions, inversions, substitutions, metamorphoses, anamorphoses and dissolutions. Potentially, the sequential
transformation becomes its own theoretical object.
The two external relations are spatial and programmatic. The spatial sequence is the most accessible
and recognizable of the three relations. Whereas transformational sequences may or may not translate to actual
experience, spatial organization is readily accessible to the individual in space. All spatial sequences emphasize
Structural Analysis of Sequence | 6
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
17/66
a planned path with fixed halting points, a family of spatial points linked by continuous movement.6 Examples
of linear spatial sequences include Renaissance churches and transportation terminals. Like the transformational
sequence, Tschumi identifies the spatial sequence as mostly within the control of the architect, especially in the case
of linear sequences.
The second external relation, the programmatic sequence, is characterized by symbolic and social
connotations. Tschumi organizes programmatic sequences into three categories: programs indifferent to spatial
sequence, programs that have a reciprocal relationship to sequence and thus reinforce sequence and programs that
conflict with spatial sequence. Throughout the essay, Tschumi extends the traditional notion of architectural program
to include events, scripted and unscripted, that occur within architectural space. In doing so, the programmatic
sequence extends beyond the control of the architect and allows for events and sequential interactions that are
unplanned. Thus, unlike Barthes rigid narrative sequences dictated by the author, the architectural sequence must
account for the unanticipated actions of individuals.
The implication of the individual in architectural space is uncertainty. Tschumis note that in architecture
meaning is derived from the order of experience rather than the order of composition identifies a significant
difference between narrative and architectural sequences. Even in ritualistic spaces that dictate a controlled
experience, absolute control is impossible. As a partial solution to the problem of control, Tschumi proposes the
frame. Within Sequences, the frame is ambiguously defined as the moments of the sequence.7 The frame is
both the framing device, conforming, regular, solid, and the framed material questioning, distorting, displacing.8
The implications of the frame in architecture, and Tschumis work in particular, are evident in Tschumis theoretical
project, The Manhattan Transcripts.
Structural Analysis of Sequence | 7
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
18/66
Endnotes
1 Roland Barthes, Structural Analysis of Narratives in Image, Music, Text, translated by Stephen Heath, (New York: Hill andWang, 1977), 82.
2 Ibid, 94.
3 Ibid., 101.
4 Ibid.
5 Bernard Tschumi, Sequences, in Architecture and Disjunction, (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1996), 153.
6 Ibid.,155.
7 Ibid., 166.
8 Ibid.
Structural Analysis of Sequence | 8
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
19/66
The Manhattan Transcripts
Bernard Tschumis The Manhattan Transcriptscomprises four theoretical exercises. Intended for display, the
Transcriptswere shown in the Artists Space in New York in 1978. According to Tschumi, the organization of the
Transcriptsrelies upon sequence. Tschumi defines sequence as a composite succession of frames that confronts
spaces, movements, and events, each with its own combinative structure and inherent set of rules.1 The frame
includes theframing device conform, regular, solid and theframed material, which constantly questions, distorts and
displaces.2 Occasionally the framing device is also distorted, as evident in an analysis ofMT 4: The Block. Analysis of
the first Transcript,MT 1: The Park, and the last,MT 4: The Block, reveals the development of sequence from the linear
relationships inMT 1 to the complex, fragmented relations inMT 4.
Tschumis three relations manifest in the tripartite division of the Transcriptsinto movements, spaces, and
events. The first relation is internal and refers to a device or procedure. There are two external relations: spatial and
programmatic. Procedures associated with the first relation in the Transcriptsinclude: transformation, indifference,
reciprocity, disjunction and conflict. Transformation permits the extreme formal manipulation of the sequence,
for the content of congenial frames can be mixed, superposed, faded in or cut up, giving endless possibilities to the
narrative sequence.3 Indifference dictates spaces and events function independently of one another. And reciprocity
is defined as not a question of which knowing which comes first, movement or space.4
MT 1, The Park, represents a linear sequence of spaces, movements and events dictated by the short
narrative/event at the beginning of the Transcript.The most accessible of the three Transcripts, The Park is a
recognizable place, Central Park in New York City, and setting for a program of murder, manhunt and capture. The
theme of murder throughout the Transcriptsunderscores Tschumis interest in unprogrammed events and movements
that occur in architectural spaces. The organization of each of the The Parkseight pages is consistent: three groups
of three frames, equally spaced on a page. The organization suggests a vertical as well as horizontal relation of
space, movement and event. The smallest sequential unit is made up of three frames, each dedicated to either
program, space or movement. Program is represented through photographs and, read vertically, resembles a filmstrip.
Structural Analysis of Sequence | 9
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
20/66
Movement, when it occurs, is drawn in plan. Architectural space, in this case at the scale of the city, is represented as
plan and also, near the end of the Transcript, extruded as an axonometric. InMT 1, architectural space is acted upon
and the resultant space embodies qualities of both program and movement.
In contrast to the temporal, linear development ofMT 1, the spatial development ofMT 4, The Block, relies
upon devices initiated by, but separate from, program and movement. The descriptive paragraph that precedesMT
4 emphasizes the setting and characters over the narrative tone assumed in other Transcripts. InMT 4 the program,
represented in photographs, refers to an activity associated with a member of the cast. Initially, as inMT 1, there
is a close association between program and movement. However, as the Transcriptprogresses the relations within
sequences becomes increasingly complex. The dissolution of the frame by the final page of the Transcriptyields the
most fragmented manifestation of all the Transcripts.
Endnotes
1 Bernard Tschumi, Illustrated Index: Themes from The Manhattan Transcripts, in The Manhattan Transcripts, (London, England:Academy Editions, 1994), XXIV.
2Ibid.
3 Ibid., XXV.
4 Ibid.
Structural Analysis of Sequence | 10
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
21/66
Slowhouse
Structural Analysis of Sequence | 11
In Slow House, pictured on the cover of Progressive Architecturein 1991, architects Elizabeth Diller
and Ricardo Scofidio investigate the nature of a vacation home. The architects describe the motivation
of slow house as a door that leads to a window; physical entry to optical departure.1 As evident
through the abundance of drawings and models dedicated to the project in addition to the architects own
descriptions, the design of Slow House translates an ordinary sequence of events, the journey from the
city to the vacation home, into a relatively complex architectural idea.
Conceptually, Slow House begins the moment the vacationer departs the city and ends when
she arrives at the ocean view, visible through the picture window that dominates one end of the house.2
In the words of the architects, Slow House represents a passage from artifice (the city-culture operating
at its most apparent) to nature (the view-culture operating at its most subtle)3
Fittingly, the sequence
of journey from city to nature is filtered through a series of lenses: the car windshield, a picture window
and a television screen. The car enters the two acre site and stops when the road terminates by deflecting
upward to support the roof plane.4 To ease the transition from car to foot, the front of house consists
solely of a garage door that measures four feet wide by eighteen feet high. The presence of the garage
door facilitates the smooth exchange of one viewing lens, the car windshield, for another, the yet unseen
picture window. In this way the architects reinforce the theme of artifice that pervades the house; an
intermediary, the viewing mechanism, always exists between the individual and the nature. Past the entry
a vertical edge/wall divides the receding passage; one half curves to the right and leads up to the social
spaces, the kitchen, dining and living rooms, while the left path remains level and leads to the bedrooms
and baths. Maintaining the theme of journey to view, either choice of path ends at the picture window
with a view to the shoreline.
Besides the functional separation of private and public areas, the left and right paths reinforce
the sense of anticipation that began when the automobile first pulled away from the city. According to
counterweighted stair
deck
fireplaceskylight over bed
picture window
video camera
monitor/tv
living area
skylight over bath
fast stair
80-foot countertop
void to below
mobile dining table
dining deck
skylight over bed
w.c.
skylight over bed
kitchen
skylight over sink
80-foot countertop
dining for two
void to below
slow stair
pivoting entry door
Figure 1.1Slow House, second floor plan withnotations.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
22/66
Structural Analysis of Sequence | 12
the architects the split passage deforms the model of classical perspective,5 an ideal reinforced by
the decelerating curve6 of the north wall.. Starting plumb at the entry point of the house, the wall
leans a quarter inch for every foot of its length until it reaches a maximum twelve degree incline at
the picture window. The curving wall literally extends the sequence in the same way that a film extends
a dramatic scene, in order to build anticipation in the viewer. As the wall section changes, beds, baths
and fixtures poke through7 visually supporting the incline. An eighty foot long counter protrudes
from the south wall and supports a range of programs along the wall, including mechanical and
electrical requirements of the kitchen. Collectively, these spatial transformations reinforce the sense
of expectation identified by the architects as inherent to the idea of vacation home.
Appropriately, a feeling of placelessness pervades the written descriptions, models anddrawings of Slow House. Context, mentioned generically as a two acre site with an ocean view in the
Hamptons, matters less than the cultural, iconic relationship of the individual to a vacation home.
Materiality, whether subdued in order to reinforce the importance of the aforementioned windshield,
picture window and television or simply because it is unimportant to the final effect of the building,
is mostly absent from drawings and models and described only briefly by the architects. In one model
the garage door/front of the house is painted red possibly to signify its importance as a transition in
the overall sequence. The planned construction of the house resembles that of a boat a stressed-
skin structure made up of twenty-seven vertical bents8. In turn the bents are clad horizontally with
2x4 lumber finished on the interior with two layers of plywood and on the exterior with one layer of
horizontal planking over plywood. A series of windows puncture the plumb south wall of the house,
but the only real view out of the house occurs at the end of the one hundred foot wall, through the
picture window, toward the horizon.
Figure 1.2Slow House, model.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
23/66
In Slow House, the architects realize their vision of the body and space as interdependent
constructs, inseparable from the cultural forces which have shaped them.9 Effectively, both body and
architecture are altered in anticipation of the final view. Parallax, induced by the curving north wall and
protruding objects, induces awareness of the body as the final view destination comes into sight. The value
of this rethinking of traditional elements is eloquently described by a juror who reviewed the project for
Progressive Architecture:
Many architects have a weakness of having an incredibly obvious relationship with a view, and
what I like here is that the house is a kind of mise en scene. It manipulates the view; the house
both blocks and finally exposes the view, and I think thats probably itself an experience, and
probably a way of avoiding boredom and monotony.10
Structural Analysis of Sequence | 13
monitor
car windshield
Figure 1.3Slow House, plan and section drawings withnotation.
Figure 1.4Slow House, model with section cuts.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
24/66
In conclusion Slow House collectively exploits the potential of the internal and external relations of sequence.
The programmatic sequence resembles that of a traditional vacation home but with modifications that reinforce the
theoretical ideas of the architects. In turn, the spatial sequence dominates the house from the moment of departure from
the city to the moment of arrival at the picture window. As such, a series of compressed spaces, beginning with the tight
quarters of the cab and maintained through the split curves of the plan, heighten the experience of release at the picture
window. Likewise, the architects allow the incline of the south wall to penetrate and inform the programmatic space of
the house. Thus Slow House employs the transformative potential of sequence to reinforce its theoretical and experiential
objectives.
Endnotes
1 Elizabeth Diller & Ricardo Scofidio, Flesh: Architectural Probes, (New York: Princeton Architectural Press, Inc., 1994), 225.
2 Ibid.
3 Ibid.
4 Ibid.
5 Ibid.
6 Ibid, 248.
7 Ibid.
8 Ibid.
9 Ibid, 39.
10 Ibid., 240.Structural Analysis of Sequence | 14
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
25/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
26/66
The use of sequence as an ordering device is constant throughout the history of architecture. Spatial
sequences have often followed the logic of linear progression wherein no movement contradicted the logic of the
progression. In the twentieth century, the linear sequence was visually transformed through the elastic proper ties
of cinema. In turn, the sympathetic relationship between architecture and cinema urged architects to consider new
forms for the architectural sequence. No longer limited to linear progressions, architects applied contradictions,
interruptions, compressions and other transformative operations to reflect the bodys new complex relationship
to space.
Linear Progressions
Notable examples of linear progressions include the Basilica of St. Peter in Rome and two villas by Andrea
Palladio. St. Peters sequence, recognizable in plan, encompasses the access doors, movement into the atrium,
passage through the basilica doors, movement through the nave and finally, arrival at the space of central system.1
Effectively, the visitor experiences pressure at the access doors, limited liberation in the atrium, a sense of restriction
or opposition from the atrium walls, short pressure at the basilica doors, liberation in movement through the nave,
and, finally, contemplation in the final space.2 In contrast to St. Peters, the sequential manipulation at Palladios
Villa Rotunda exhibits complexity of space that requires a sectional as well as two-dimensional understanding.
Luigi Moretti writes that in the density of light, the volumes go from portico to hall in the order of maximum to
minimumin dimensions, the order is medium, least, greatest.3 Thus, Villa Rotunda demonstrates the potential to
manipulate the sequence of volumes in opposition to the plan sequence. The final example, Morettis discussion of
Palladios Villa Thiene, exhibits a systemic logic. Alone, Morettis written description is barely adequate as a means to
describe the complexity of the space:
In their pure dimensions, the sequences can be equated graphically as circles whose radii are proportional to
Linear progressions to Montage Collisions
Linear Progressions to Montage Collisions | 16
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
27/66
the sphere corresponding in volume to each surrounding and whose center coincides with
the center of gravity of the volume itself and is marked at the distance which in proportion
this center has from the base plane of the spaces, that is from the level of the plinth.4
Historically the linear spatial sequence, without the modern influence of vectors, overlays and
transformations, nonetheless facilitated complex and intricate renderings of space.
Cinematic Sequence: Peripatetic Viewpoint of the Spectator
In Montage and Architecture Russian filmmaker Sergei Eisenstein asserts a
correspondence between architecture and cinema in Auguste Choisys Histoire de larchitectureand toa lesser extent, the enigmatic perspectives of Giovanni Piranesi. In Histoire de larchitecture, published
in 1889, Choisy interprets the Acropolis at Athens as an early manifestation of the picturesque in
architecture and planning. In so doing, Choisy is the first architect in modern times to suggest that
the buildings at the Acropolis, represented through his own plans and perspectives, owe their design
and placement to the first impression or picture they present to the moving spectator.5 As illustrated
by Choisy, the Acropolis depicts a sophisticated symmetry related to balance rather than mirror image
reflection. Choisys radical assessment of the Acropolis inspired Eisenstein to contrast the two paths
of the spatial eye: the cinematic, in which an immobile spectator follows an imaginary line among a
series of objects using sight and mind and the architectural, in which the spectator ambulates through
a series of phenomena visually observed in order.6 Reflecting on Choisy, Eisenstein suggests that the
walk through the Acropolis at Athens exposes the innate correspondence between architecture and
cinema. Furthermore, he proclaims that Choisy provides a magnificent picture of the construction
and computation ofa montage from the point of view of a moving spectator.7 Eisensteins
Linear Progressions to Montage Collisions | 17
Figure 2.1Graphic montage to promote the filmBerlin, the Symphony of a Great City.
Figure 2.2Giovanni Piranesi, The Carceri: AnImmense Interior with Numerous Wooden
Galleries and a Drawbridge in the Center.,Etching.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
28/66
cinematic reading of Choisys work at the Acropolis effectively inscribed the bodily movement of the
spectator into architecture in the twentieth century.
In addition to Choisy, Eisensteins was familiar with the drawings of Giovanni Piranesi.
Piranesis dark, labyrinthine perspectives suggest the disorienting effects of parallax, the apparent
change in position of a body due to a change in position of the observer. In his introduction to
Montage and Architecture, Yve-Alain Bois writes:
Through elaborate disjunction of plan and elevation, which leads to a vertiginous
fragmentation of architectural space, Piranesi deprives the spectator of any center of
reference, of any definitive climax, and initiates the rupture of the modern movement in
architecture.8
In addition to projecting a new image of space, the cinematic sequence implied a greater degree of
control for the architect over the spectator, similar to that a director over a film and audience.
Cinema Architecture: Le Corbusier
Le Corbusier was also influenced by Choisys account of the Acropolis, but in contrast to
Eisenstein focused his critique on Choisys second perspective image rather than the entire sequence.
The second perspective places the spectator in front of the statue of Athene Promakhos with
the Erechtheion and the Parthenon in the background. For Le Corbusier, this view demonstrates
the flexibility of Greek axial planning9 in which the asymmetrical plan composition exhibits
equilibrium when viewed in perspective. Furthermore the dialogue between plan and perspective
at the Acropolis permitted a return to the original bodily and sensational sources of the plan.10
The implication of bodily movement in architectural design, exemplified in Choisys drawings of the
Acropolis, directly influenced the development of Le Corbuiserspromenade architecturale.11
Linear Progressions to Montage Collisions | 18
Figure 2.3Auguste Choisy, The Acropolis, First Sightof the Platform.
Figure 2.4Sergei Eisenstein, diagrams of the successivepositions of the Acropolis as described inperspective by Auguste Choisy.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
29/66
In The Ramp as Architectonic Promenade in Corbusiers Work, Jrgen Joedicke asserts
three metaphors for the ramp as architectonic promenade. In its most basic incarnation, the ramp is path.
At the Villa Savoye, much as in Choisys narrative of movement through the Acropolis, Joedicke
provides a first-person account of movement up the path. The essential transition points in the
ascent to the roof garden, including the entry to the Villa, the beginning of the upward path, and
the final vista that is pictorially framed on the roof garden, are vertically aligned. In contrast to the
symmetrical position of the ramp in the interior of the building, the second vertical link, a curved
staircase, is shifted asymmetrically. As at the Acropolis, the perspective view of ramp and stair from
the main entrance communicates a more balanced symmetry. Near the apex of the ramp at the Villa
one looks back through the glazing into the interior of the house, onto the ramp which one hasascended early.12 At this point, the ramp is montage; it implicates memory as well as movement.
Equally, the window frame that marks the end of the ramps ascent serves as a montage element by
communicating different views based on the position of the observer. The ramp at the Carthusian
monastery of Ema, visited by Le Corbusier in 1907 and a source of possible inspiration for the ramp
in his own work, functions similarly. Moving upward on the ramp, one is able to look out through
large apertures enclosed with semicircular arches on the path one has come.13 The ability to look
back is an essential attribute of the ramp as architectonic promenade. The third metaphor for the ramp
is a manifestation of three-dimensional Corbusian space. According to Joedicke, Corbusiers work is
limited to three fundamental dimensions of human perception and human experience: length, width
and height.14 Time is not included because it is not a quality of space; it is a characteristic aspect
of the successive perceptions of man passing through one space after another.15 Beginning with Le
Corbusier, mans movement through space becomes a guiding principle for architecture, particularly
modernism, not just in movement in and through space but also in the alternation between
movement and being stationary.16Linear Progressions to Montage Collisions | 19
1
2
3
4
5
foyer entrance from garage
6
Figure 2.5
Le Corbusier, Ground Floor, Villa Savoye.
Diagrams correspond to images on p. 11.
Figure 2.6
Le Corbusier, First Floor, Villa Savoye
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
30/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
31/66
Contents | 21
In the Modern era, architects interest in sequence owes much to changes in the perception
of space initiated at the turn of the twentieth century. Auguste Choisy rediscovered Greek
asymmetrical balance in his narrative of the Acropolis at Athens. In turn, Russian film director
Sergei Eisenstein, who was also a friend of Le Corbusier, described in Choisys narrative as the first
cinematic sequence. The comparison of architectural sequence to cinematic sequence initiated a trend
through Modern and later Postmodern architecture in which architects exploited the potential of the
peripatetic viewpoint of the mobile spectator instead of a single, fixed point of reference.
Endnotes
1 Luigi Morreti, Structures and Sequences of Space. in Oppositions 4. (New York: Wittenborn Art Books, 1974).
2 Ibid.
3 Ibid.
4 Ibid.
5 Ibid.
6 Anthony Vidler, The Explosion of Space: Architecture and the Filmic Imaginary, in Film Architecture, ed.Dietrich Neumann (Munich, Germany: Prestel-Verlag, 1996), 22.
7 Sergie M. Eisenstein, Montage and Architecture, introduction by Yve-Alian Bois,Assemblage 10.
8 Bois.
9 Anthony Vidler, The Explosion of Space: Architecture and the Filmic Imaginary, in Film Architecture, ed.Dietrich Neumann (Munich, Germany: Prestel-Verlag, 1996), 23.
10 Ibid. Linear Progressions to Montage Collisions | 21
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
32/66
Contents | 22
11 Sergie M. Eisenstein, Montage and Architecture, introduction by Yve-Alian Bois,Assemblage 10: 113.
12
Ibid., 106.
13 Jrgen Joedicke, The Ramp as Architectonic Promenade in Le Corbusiers Work, Daidalos 12, (June 1984):105.
14 Ibid., 108.
15 Ibid.
16 Ibid.
Linear Progressions to Montage Collisions | 22
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
33/66
Chapter 3Sequence and Uncertainty
Contents | 23| 23
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
34/66
The Situationist International
The Situationist Internationale (SI), founded in 1957 by French philosopher, filmmaker
and activist Guy Debord, interpreted the work of Le Corbusier and the Modernists according to a
post-war avant-garde political agenda. Like Corbusier, the Situationists were captivated by cinematic
techniques, especially montage. However, direct transference of cinematic concepts to three-
dimensional space, as cautioned by Russian filmmaker Sergei Eisenstein, proved prohibitive and so the
Situationists attempts at architectural montage (dtournement)never developed much beyond theory.1
Instead, the Situationists contribution to sequence primarily derives from their nonlinear experiments
and their obsession with the present. In Theses on Cultural Revolution Guy Debord, The
Situationist goal is immediate participation in the abundance of life, through the variation of fleeting
moments resolutely arranged. The success of these moments can only be their passing effect.2
Concern for the provisional and present directed the Situationist practices of urban
wandering (drive), montage aesthetics (dtournement), and construction of situations. Drive, French
meaning drift,describes the act of navigating the city and unforeseeable accidents of its surface.3
Like the sea, the city contains constant currents, fixed points, and eddies which together render
approach and exit of certain zones very difficult.4 Combined with drive, these features represent
the Situationist concept of psychogeography: the study of the specific effects of the geographic
environment, consciously organized or not, on the emotions and behavior of individuals.5 Guy
Debord represented the psychogeographical city in The Naked City, a map of Paris created in 1957
that illustrates the push and pull of various neighborhoods on the urban explorer. In contrast to the
veritable success ofdrivein the built environment, the SIs translation of dtournementwas limited to
graphic representation.
Sequence and Uncertainty | 24
Figure 3.1Guy Debord, The Naked City, 1958.Psychogeographical map of the Paris.
Figure 3.2Asger Jorn and Guy Debord,Memoires, 1957.Montage/collage of paint, text and image.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
35/66
In addition to graphic design and the construction of Situations, the architect Constant envisioned
a futuristic city shaped by the Situationist critique. Constant based the design his utopian city, New Babylon,
represented in drawings and physical models, on the political and social messages conveyed in Guy Debords film
Society of the Spectacle. In Society of the Spectacle, Debord characterizes existing architecture as a confining force and
complement of the bourgeois world that holds one in place.6 In contrast to existing architecture, Constants New
Babylon resists stasis by promoting leisure and walking as the main activities of the city.
Constant envisioned a future society characterized by leisure and freedom of movement based on his belief
that automation would eventually free people from work. Likewise, New Babylon represents a reaction against the ville
verteor green city of the 1920s and 1930s with its isolated high rises that thwart direct contact and shared activities
among people.7
In contrast to the green city, New Babylon creates social spaces where the inhabitants of the citymingle and interact. Suspended high above the earths surface, the New Babylon accommodates humanitys nomadic
wanderers8
In New Babylon, Constant translates the Situationist concept of driveinto architecture. Specifically,
he resists the fixed nature of architecture in order to realize a structure characterized by change and the result is
a playful megastructuralism.9 Despite its large scale, Constants renderings communicate labyrinthine spaces
that recall the drawings of the nineteenth century architect Giovanni Piranesi. Like Piranesi, in place of optimal
orientation preference is given to a loss of orientation conducive to adventure, play and creativity.10 Symbolically,
the labyrinth does not represent a path toward a single goal, but rather a web of many unknowns and variables.11
Though architects, such as Le Corbusier, possessed similar interest in montage and movement, Corbusiers controlled
path and point of view, as demonstrated in the sequence at bourgeois Villa Savoye, contrast sharply with the
Situationists free wanderings and anti-bourgeois sentiment.
Sequence and Uncertainty | 25
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
36/66
Endnotes
1 Thomas McDonough, Fluid Spaces: Constant and the Situationist Critique of Architecture, in The Activist Drawing: Retracing Situationist Architecture fromConstants New Babylon to Beyond, ed. Catherine de Zegher and Mark Wigley (New York: The Drawing Center, 2001), 101.
2 Guy Debord, Theses on Cultural Revolution, in The Activist Drawing: Retracing Situationist Architecture from Constants New Babylon to Beyond, ed. Catherine deZegher and Mark Wigley (New York: The Drawing Center, 2001), 93.
3 Ibid., 95.
Sequence and Uncertainty | 26
Figure 3.3Ralph Rumney, Psychogeographic map of Venice, 1957.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
37/66
4 Ibid.
5 Simon Ford, The Situationist International: A Users Guide, (London: Black Dog Publishing, 2005), 34.
6 Thomas McDonough, Fluid Spaces: Constant and the Situationist Critique of Architecture, in The Activist Drawing: Retracing Situationist Architecture fromConstants New Babylon to Beyond, ed. Catherine de Zegher and Mark Wigley (New York: The Drawing Center, 2001), 94.
7 Ibid.
8 Ibid., 93.
9 Ibid.
10 Xavier Coates, Le Grand Jeu Venir: Situationist Urbanism, Daidalos67 (1998): 76.
11 Ibid.
Sequence & Uncertainty | 27
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
38/66
Yokohama Port Terminal
In 1995 the commission for the design of the Yokohama Port Terminal was awarded
to Foreign Office Architects (FOA), a young husband and wife team based in London, England.
Alejandro Zaera-Polo and Farshid Mousavi, 31 and 29 respectively when they won, previously worked
for OMA. According to Lucy Bullivant, It was the concept of a space where travelers and citizens
could interact, of the city penetrating the ocean, that ultimately won them the competition.1 The
organic form and looping circulation of the terminal extend the public realm of two nearby parks
out into a harbor. Likewise, the building is a gateway to the city for thousands of visitors, including
those traveling on the sixty cruise vessels that dock at the terminal each year. The design of the port
terminal not only addresses the technical requirements of an international port of call, but also the
social challenges inherent in public places.The design concept of the Yokohama International Port Terminal reflects FOAs philosophy
to extend cultural and technical boundaries.2 According to Zaera-Polo, FOA considered the terminal
an extension of Yamashita Park onto the Bay as well as a hybrid between a park and a building,
a landscape and a structure.3 In order to meet the technical challenges of the design, the architects
used computer-generated local vector systems similar to those used by naval architects. In addition
to the difficulty of communicating a non-Cartesian based design to the building community, the
project was complicated by the citys decision to split it into thirds and award each part to a different
contractor. Though the involvement of multiple contractors and manufacturers challenged the
architects ability to maintain consistency over the course of the project, the simplicity of the projects
palette (glass, steele and Brazilian Ipe for the decking), ultimately yielded a unified building. The final
terminal combines landscape, terminal and circulation in a dynamic, origami-inspired building.
The concept of flow through, around and over the 1400 foot long terminal emerged as a
key programmatic consideration in the design process. Locals and travelers alike are compelled into
Sequence and Uncertainty | 28
Figure 3.4Yokoham Port Terminal
Figure 3.5Yokoham Port Terminal, aerial view.
Figure 3.6Yokoham Port Terminal, view from the deck.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
39/66
an organic system of surfaces and voids.4 Pedestrians move through the building by way of the
glass lozenge5 elevator centrally located in the building or one of ten gently sloping ramps that flank
central spaces and lead up to the 120,000 square foot roof deck and down to the parking area for 400
cars. The roof deck, the most artful space at the terminal6 includes a 500-seat amphitheater, grassy
knolls, plantings and sunshades along one side. The ramp system helps make the terminal an exemplar
of universal design considerate of Japans aging population. Car passengers, whether departing or
arriving, drive onto the roof deck and then snake their way down to the lower level parking. However,
the pedestrian remains the central concern in the Mbius strip building with uninterrupted
expanses of floor space that invite aimless wandering,7 reminiscent of the Situationists drive
experiments in the mid twentieth century.Though the buildings urban and pedestrian considerations are the main interest of this
thesis, the technical challenges inherent in the nature of the building are also important to note.
First, it was difficult for the architects to reconcile the spatial requirements for ship boarding with the
existing site conditions. In order to accommodate the uniform gangplank size of docking vessels, all
decks of the terminal needed to be equidistant from boats anchored on the apron edges. In response
to this condition, FOA cantilevered the terminal 10-16 feet on one side and up to 56 feet on the other.
As a result, though the terminal building is pretty much symmetrical, it is not centered on the new
pier, a 162 foot landfill strip surrounded by an apron with ship mooring. To provide visual balance,
FOA placed boxy offices and shops beneath the inboard ends of the longer cantilevers. The unusual
construction of the terminal allows for its three story structure, including underground parking,
the ground-floor passenger terminal and the rooftop plaza/park. The column-free structure of the
building has two parts: folded steel plates that accommodate transverse loads and bridge-like steel
girders for longitudinal loads and support of the cantilevers. The girders, basically large-scale folds
Sequence and Uncertainty | 29
Figure 3.7Yokoham Port Terminal, view from the deck.
Figure 3.8Yokoham Port Terminal, vehicular entrance.
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
40/66
reminiscent of Japanese origami, are trough-shaped and hollow in cross-section. In contrast to the massive
steel framework of the structure, the featherweight finish materials and appurtenances attached to it8
include: untreated wood-deck flooring, faceted glazing, cable-stayed scrim and a system of projecting steel
triangles across the largest transverse spans.
The sequence of movement through the Yokohama Port Terminal dictates much
of its design. However, instead of orienting the circulation in the most efficient, economical direction,
the architects intentionally meandered and looped it to allow individuals to wander. The curves and
undulations of the roof, walls and floor planes literally soften transitions in the building and blur
distinctions between city, landscape and building. The biomorphic roofscape defies Bernard Tschumis
contention that spatial and programmatic sequence rarely overlap.
9
Endnotes
1 Lucy Bullivant, Yokohamas Custom-made Ferry Terminal, inMetropolis22, (2002): 101.
2 Ibid, 105.
3 Ibid, 101.
4 Peter Slatin and C.C. Sullivan, Open Architecture inArchitecture92, no. 2 (2003): 69.
5 Ibid, 69.
6 Ibid.
7 Ibid, 69.
8 Sullivan, 2003, 72.
9 Bernard Tschumi Sequences inArchitecture and Disjunction. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1996.
Sequence and Uncertainty | 30
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
41/66
Conclusion and Methodology
| 31
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
42/66
Conclusion and Methodology
Contents | 32
Literature and cinema progress through complex interactions of sequence: mind and vision are
stimulated to assemble disparate elements, depicted in different times and spaces, into cohesive wholes.
Because the language of film and literature are universally familiar, writers and filmmakers sometimes
manipulate expectations through incomplete, contrasting, and unrelated sequences. The functional
requirements of architectural sequences preclude the direct translation of literary and cinematic concepts
to architecture. However, the adaptation of cinematic techniques in architecture, illustrated at Villa Savoye
and other precedents reviewed in the thesis, results in complex, dynamic interactions of the body and
space in architectural.
Despite the constraints of real time and space, architects like Le Corbusier, Diller + Scofidio,
and FOA, frame complex sequences that incorporate vertical and horizontal relations. The fragmentationof experience through diverse paths allows the architect to reflect, anticipate and interrupt the visual
path without necessarily contradicting the forward progress of the body. At Barcelona Pavilion and Villa
Savoye, the architect directs the experience of the individual much like a director manipulates the audience
in a film. In contrast, the Situationists, an avant-garde movement in Paris in the mid twentieth century,
rejected notions of control in favor of freedom of movement and experience. In place of the nuanced,
directed paths of Mies van der Rohe and Le Corbusier, the Situationist city of New Babylon includes
wide-open spaces and labyrinthine passageways that encourage rather than dictate movement. In contrast
to most architecture, the non-progressive spaces of New Babylon discourage representation as a cohesive
whole. Instead, the journey becomes the objective rather than the destination.
The methodology adopted for the design of a ferry terminal in Boston, Massachusetts requires
thoughtful consideration of users, site, and the internal and external relations of sequence identified in the
thesis. During the site selection process, census data was used to create user profiles for two sites under
consideration. Once Fan Pier in South Boston was chosen as the location for the terminal, it was possible
Conclusion and Methodology | 32
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
43/66
Contents | 33
to organize users into four main groups that recall the cast assembled in TschumisMT 4, The Block.:
Commuters: habitual weekday users of mass transit. Generally, commuters travel during
morning and evening peak hours.
Convention Goers: people traveling from Logan Airport to hotels in the Fan Pier
development, South Boston, or directly to the new convention center.
Tourists: local and out-of-state visitors drawn to Fan Pier by the new Institute of
Contemporary Art, the Harborwalk, Tidal Pool and Park and the Childrens Museum.
Non-travelers: people other than travelers.
The amount of time spent in the terminal varies by user group. Commuters spend the least
amount of time in the terminal because they are the most familiar with the boat schedules, the layout of
the building and may purchase monthly passes that enable them to skip the ticket window. In contrast,
tourists spend the most time, besides the non-travelers, because they are least familiar with the building
and schedules and need to queue for tickets. Represented in diagram, the tourist path is a wandering line
and the commuter line is straight with an arrow that indicates direction. Both diagrams recall precedents
from the thesis; the meandering line corresponds to the organic sequences in the work of the Situationists
and at Yokohama Port Terminal and the straight line to the controlled ramp sequence at Villa Savoye and
the view sequence at Slow House. The extended time of the open sequence and compressed time of the
linear sequence correspond to different relations described by Tschumi Sequences. The meandering
line and extended time allow greater contradiction and variation in the sequence, such as the treatment
of space indifferently or in opposition to program. In contrast, the compressed time sequence limits the
terminal to its functional ideal. Contradiction or opposition that thwarts the progress of the compressed
sequence threatens the success of the building as a transit facility. The path of users through the terminal
was diagrammed in order to identify relationships among the user groups and the potential interplay
Conclusion and Methodology | 33
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
44/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
45/66
Project: Method | 35
Conclusion and Methodology | 35
Figure 5.1
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
46/66
Design Project
| 36
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
47/66
Site
Contents | 37
The thesis site, Fan Pier in South Boston, was chosen from a short list of sites identified in the
BRAs Boston Harbor Passenger Water Transportation Plan, issued in 2000. The accessibility of development
plans for Fan Pier, its adjacency to cultural and economic developments, such as the new Institute of
Contemporary Art (ICA) and the Boston convention center, and existing transportation services like the
Silver Line, recommend it above other sites. In August 2005 the 20.5 acre Fan Pier parcel was sold by
the Pritzker family who owned the land for twenty years but failed to develop it beyond parking lots, the
Federal Courthouse and most recently, the ICA designed by architects Diller + Scofidio. In the Boston
community, the sale ignited hopes that development would move forward and transform the South Boston
Waterfront from an industrial port to the citys next commercial and housing frontier.1 However, the new
owners, like the Pritzkers, face an estimated $1.2 billion in development costs.
The Fan Pier project, as described in the1998 Fan Pier Development Plan, proposes eight
commercial buildings and the new Boston Institute for Contemporary Art. In an addendum written in
2000, the maximum building height of the development was reduced from approximately 300 feet to 244
feet. Likewise, open space was increased to 56.8% of the site. The site program includes:
One hotel (650 rooms)
Residential (675 units)
Office (1.233 million square feet)
Retail
Civic and cultural amenities
Major cultural spaces anchored by the Childrens Museum, New England Aquarium, and
Island Alliance
Site | 37
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
48/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
49/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
50/66
Contents | 40Site | 40
Figure 5.4
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
51/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
52/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
53/66
Contents | 43
Cycle time: 60 minutes (S. Shore)/120 minutes (N.
Shore)
Fleet required: 2 boats (S. Shore)/4 boats (N. Shore)
Ground Transportation to and from Fan Pier
Hyatt/Airport shuttle
Headway: 15 minutes
Frequency: 4 vehicles per hour
Capacity: 20 passengers per bus
Hourly capacity: 80 passengers per direction
Cycle time: 30 minutes
Fleet required: 2 buses
Downtown circulation/North Station shuttle
Will operate along the resurfaced artery
Connections to Aquarium Station (Blue Line), Haymarket (Green Line, Orange Line,
Express buses), and North Station (Green Line, Orange Line, commuter rail)
Headway: 10 minutes
Frequency: 6 vehicles per hour
Vessel Capacity: 60 passengers per bus Hourly capacity: 360 passengers per direction
Cycle time: 40 minutes
Fleet required: 4 buses
Program | 43
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
54/66
Contents | 44
Fan Pier Berths
Two berths available for commuter vessels
Two berths available for inner-harbor water transportation vessels
Two berths available for 9 arrivals resulting in total of 18 passenger discharges between 6:00 AM
and 9:00 AM
Additional berthing for smaller vessels, including water taxis
Fan Pier berths capable of handling new high speed catamarans, the largest of the commuter
fleet with capacity of 400 passengers
General Terminal Design Criteria
All terminals should, to the degree feasible, accommodate multiple ferry functions to provide
intermodal transfer opportunities
All terminals must be fully accessible
Public landings and water taxi docks should be included and maintained at most primary and
secondary terminals
Landside support facilities should include ticketing, waiting, information and restrooms
Terminal functional designations
Primary: High volume, multiple use, hub/receiver location
Secondary: Medium volume, limited use, spoke/feeder location Water Taxi/Cultural Loop/Public landing: Low volume, limited use, may be combined with
public landing for touch and go use at multiple locations.
Ferry Route Service Functions
Transit Ferry Services: provide point to point, scheduled, year round, peak hour plus off peak
services including inner harbor services currently known as shuttles, outer harbor services
Program | 44
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
55/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
56/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
57/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
58/66
Slatin, Peter and C.C. Sullivan. Open Architecture.Architecture92, no. 2 (2003): 67-74.
Tschumi, Bernard.Event-Cities: Praxis. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 1998.
Tschumi, Bernard. Illustrated Index: Themes from The Manhattan Transcripts. AA Files (July 1983): 65-74.
Tschumi, Bernard. The Manhattan Transcripts. New York: St. Martins Press, 1981.
Tschumi, Bernard. The Manhattan Transcripts. 2nd edition. London: Academy Editions, 1994.
Tschumi, Bernard. Sequences, inArchitecture and Disjunc tion. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1996.
Tschumi, Bernard and Irene Cheng. The State of Architecture at the Beginning of the 21st Century, ed. Bernard Tschumi and
Irene Cheng, 11. New York: The Monacelli Press, 2003.
Vidler, Anthony. The Explosion of Space: Architecture and the Filmic Imaginary. In Film Architecture, ed. DietrichNeumann. Munich, Germany: Prestel-Verlag, 1996.
Bibliography | 48
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
59/66
Appendix
| 49
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
60/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
61/66
practice, Koolhaas cites his involvement in the IBA (Internationale Bauausstellung). He and Oswald Ungers disagreed
with the decision by Leon Krier, Aldo Rossi and Josef Paul Kliehues to make of Berlin a test-case city for the
reconstruction of the European city.6 Eschewing a traditional approach to rebuilding the city, Koolhaas envisioned
Berlin as a sort of territorial archipelago,7 a system of architectural islands and voids (forests and lakes) in which
the infrastructure could play without causing damage.8 Koolhaas concedes that maintaining open space in or near
the city opposes the current frenzy to fill, to stop up9 urban space and so may at first seem an unpopular solution.
However, besides the aesthetic virtues of maintaining open space, he provides two pragmatic reasons urban voids
should be one of, if not the only, principal lines of combat for people interested in the city.10 For one, full volumes
and agglomerate shapes, the familiar domain of architects, are less easy to control than open space. Secondly,
emptiness, landscape and space can draw quick support compared to the controversies that usually accompany
proposals for the built environment. Koolhaas embraces the much-maligned conditions of the modern city, including
the urban fringe, and advocates interpretation of the city through existing context. Thus, the decreased density and
voids that identify the urban fringe should be exaggerated, maintained and reinterpreted in time as the fringe becomes
more closely identified with and even consumed by the city.
In contrast to Koolhaas proposals for the preservation and exaggeration of voids at the urban fringe, Wolf
Prix, the founder of Coop Himmelb(l)au advocates the realization of space within the city. Prix identifies space and
space-making, as opposed to Koolhaas preservation of existing space, as the new domain of the architect.
Wolf Prix attributes the tendency to fill up urban voids, identified by Koolhaas, to the privatization ofurban space in Western cities. Without sufficient funds, local authorities are unable to play active roles in urban
planning and so take a back seat as private investors pursue the most valuable real estate in the city. As such, it is a
game whose end is easily predictable: architecture will end up as infrastructure built to maximize profits within the
global economy.11 In contrast to Koolhaas, Prix argues for a vigorous new urbanism in which architects reinstate
urban space within the city. As the urban background (the interstitial and few unclaimed territories in the city)
Appendix | 51
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
62/66
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
63/66
Henri Lefebvre, and the writings, films and politics of Guy Debord. In Theory of Everyday LifeLefebvre avows the
right to the city as a place of pleasure and enjoyment independent of the imperatives of the economy.15 His
characterization of the city encouraged the Situationist view of urban space as the site of the individuals struggle
against alienation.16 In the article Theses on Cultural Revolution, Guy Debord identifies the Situationist goal as
immediate participation in a passionate abundance of life, through the variation of fleeting moments resolutely
arranged.17 Debords fleeting moments correspond to the groups interest in situations. Sitatuations are defined
by Debord as the construction of a transitory microenvironment and the play of events for a unique moment
in the life of several persons.18 In practice, situations emerged from the concepts of drive, urban wandering, and
dtournement, related to montage, explored later in this thesis. In turn, the S ituationist critique of society and urbanism
anticipated New Babylon, a futuristic utopian city largely based on the political and social messages conveyed
in Debords film Society of the Spectacle. In Society of the Spectacle, Debord describes urbanisms freezing of life in
response to capitalism at the expense of restless becoming in the progression of time.19 As such, architecture is
characterized by a predominance of tranquil side-by-sideness, a confining force and complement of the bourgeois
world that literally held one in place.20 As evidence of urbanisms confining force, Debord refers to a study in the
movement of a young bourgeois woman is mapped over the course of a year and revealed to be a small triangle
with no deviations.21
The design of the futurist city New Bablyon attempts to reconcile Situationist theory to the built
environment and create an architecture of presence.22
New Bablyon, conceived by the Situationist architectConstant, envisions a society shaped by the Situationist critique. Constant believed that automation would free
people from work and lead to a future characterized by leisure and freedom of movement. Suspended high above
the earths surface, New Babylon would accommodate humanitys nomadic wanderers.23 The spatial concept of New
Babylon opposes classical models of the city and the ideals of functionalist urbanism formulated at the CIAM in the
1920s and 1930s. Thus, New Babylon represents a reaction against the ville verteor green city with its isolated high
Appendix | 53
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
64/66
rises that thwart direct contact and shared activities among people,24 a critique later echoed by Rem Koolhaas in
his essay Toward the Contemporary City. In contrast to the green city, New Babylon creates social spaces where
the inhabitants of the city mingle and interact. As mentioned, in New Babylon, Constant attempts to translate the
Situationist concept of driveinto built form. Specifically, he resists the fixed nature of architectures in order to
realize a structure characterized by change. The result is a playful megastructuralism.25 Besides being large, the
space of New Babylon appears labyrinthine. Recalling the drawings of the late nineteenth century architect Giuseppe
Piranesi, in place of optimal orientation preference is given to a loss of orientation conducive to adventure, play
and creativity.26 Symbolically, the labyrinth does not represent a path toward a single goal, but rather a web of many
unknowns and variables.27
The work of Rem Koolhaas, Wolf Prix, Constant and the Situationists resist aesthetics as the prime
motivation for urban projects. Though their philosophies differ, their sensitivity to urban space results in solutions
that relate contextually to their environments. A similar approach is employed and eloquently expressed by Akram
Abu Hamdan in Thematic Architecture: Significance + Urban Interaction. Hamdens practice is defined by
buildings that generate urban space and buildings that are of themselves urban spaces.28 Equally, he engages work
with the conviction that, the issue of human interaction is much more valid than that of aesthetics and that style,
trends and treatments pertaining to artistic expression should emerge as by-products of this interaction and not be at
the core of it.29
Appendix | 54
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
65/66
Endnotes
1 Bernard Tschumi and Irene Cheng, eds. The State of Architecture at the Beginning of the 21stCentury, (New York: The Monacelli Press,
2003), 11.
2 Kate Nesbitt, ed., Theorizing a New Agenda for Architecture(New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 1996), 322.
3 Ibid, 323.
4 Rem Koolhaas, Toward the Contemporary City, in Theorizing a New Agenda for Architecture, ed. Kate Nesbitt (New York:Princeton Architectural Press, 1996), 329.
5 Rem Koolhaas, Toward the Contemporary City, in Theorizing a New Agenda for Architecture, ed. Kate Nesbitt (New York:Princeton Architectural Press, 1996), 329.
6
Ibid.
7
8 RM
9
10 Rem Koolhaas, Toward the Contemporary City, in Theorizing a New Agenda for Architecture, ed. Kate Nesbitt (New York:Princeton Architectural Press, 1996), 329.
11 Wolf Prix,, in The State of Architecture at the Beginning of the 21stCentury, eds. Bernard Tschumi and Irene Cheng (New York: TheMonacelli Press, 2003), 18.
12 Ibid.
13 Ibid.
14 Xavier Coates, Le Grand Jeu Venir: Situationist Urbanism, Daidalos67 (1998): 74.
15 Ibid.
Appendix | 55
-
7/29/2019 Sequencin in Architecture
66/66
16 Ibid.
17 Thomas McDonough, Fluid Spaces: Constant and the Situationist Critique of Architecture in The Activist Drawing, ed.
18 Xavier Coates, Le Grand Jeu Venir: Situationist Urbanism, Daidalos67 (1998): 74.
19 Thomas McDonough, Fluid Spaces: Constant and the Situationist Critique of Architecture in The Activist Drawing, ed. 94
20 Thomas McDonough, Fluid Spaces: Constant and the Situationist Critique of Architecture in The Activist Drawing, ed. 94.
21 Ibid.
22 Ibid, 93.
23 Ibid, 93.
24 Ibid.
25 Ibid.
26 Xavier Coates, Le Grand Jeu Venir: Situationist Urbanism, Daidalos67 (1998): 76.
27 Ibid.
28 Akram Abu Hamden, inAnytime, ed. Cynthia C. Davidson (New York: Anyone Corporation, 1999), 29.
29 Ibid.
Appendix | 56