sgcc peer connect webinar: benefits analysissmartenergycc.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/peer... ·...
TRANSCRIPT
SGCC PEER CONNECT WEBINAR:
BENEFITS ANALYSIS
June 5, 2013
Today’s Presenters
Barbara Leary Sr. Director, Marketing &
Communication
Florida Power & Light
Company
Jim Meadows Director, SmartMeter Project
Pacific Gas & Electric
Company
Patty Durand Executive Director / Moderator
Smart Grid Consumer
Collaborative
Housekeeping
• You will receive a copy of the slides
– To the email you used to register
• You can ask questions as we go along
– Simply type into the question box, as we will explain or raise questions during the Q&A
• We will answer all the questions submitted
– If we are unable to get to all the questions, they will be answered individually after the presentation
Questions & Audio
• If this is what you see – Click on the
orange arrow to expand your
dashboard.
• In order to ask questions over the
phone, please log in with your Audio
Pin
• Click on the + sign to open up the
questions box.
• Use the Questions box at any time to
type questions.
• We will answer questions during a
Q&A near the end of the call.
• Yes, you will receive the slides after
the webinar.
Agenda
1. Benefits of grid modernization
• Third-party perspective
2. FPL Energy Smart Florida
• Realizing benefits
• Operational efficiency & reliability
3. PG&E New Products & Services
• Enabled programs
• Smart grid journey
4. Q&A Session
Grid Modernization: Investments paying off
• Operations and Maintenance Savings: Utilities are realizing
13% to 77% reduction in meter operations cost --- and 12% -
59% reduction in vehicle miles driven, fuel consumption and
CO2 emissions --- from deploying AMI systems. (Source: Smartgrid.gov. “Operations and Maintenance Savings from Advanced Metering Infrastructure, Initial Results.” Dec.
2012)
• Reductions in peak demand: Utilities offering time-based
rates, AMI and customer-based systems are realizing as much
as 37% reduction in peak demand during peak hours. (Source: Smartgrid.gov. “Demand Reductions from the Application of Advanced Metering Infrastructure, Pricing Programs, and
Customer-Based Systems – Initial Results.” Dec. 2012)
• Reliability improvements: Utilities employing distribution
automation, primarily automated feeder switching, cut the
number of outages by nearly 50%, and reduced duration of
outages for their customers by as much as 15%. (Source: Smartgrid.gov. “Reliability Improvements from the Application of Distribution Automation Technologies – Initial Results.”
Dec. 2012)
Grid Modernization: Other benefits
• A smart grid reduces CO2 emissions: A fully-deployed smart
grid could reduce CO2 emissions from the electricity sector in
the U.S. by 12% - 18%. (Source: Pacific Northwest National Laboratory. “The Smart Grid: An Estimation of the Energy and CO2 Benefits.” Jan. 2010)
• A smart grid gives consumers control over their power bill:
AMI and customer-based systems allow consumers to
understand how much energy they are using at any time and
reduce that usage if desired. (Source: Smart Grid Consumer Collaborative. “Consumer Benefits Fact Sheet.” 2011)
• A smart grid enhances our energy independence: Smart grid
safeguards our nation’s position at the forefront of the world’s
transition toward a clean energy future. (Source: Smart Grid Consumer Collaborative. “Consumer Benefits Fact Sheet.” 2011)
Grid Modernization: A market opportunity
• $494 billion in cumulative revenue: The market for smart grid
technologies will grow from $33 billion annually in 2012 to $73
billion by the end of 2020, totaling $494 billion in cumulative
revenue over that period. (Source: Pike Research, part of Navigant. “Smart Grid Technologies.” Q1 2013)
• Smart grid sensors are big business: By 2014, research firm
IMS Research predicts that the smart grid sensors market will
more than double in size from estimated 2012 levels, with
annual revenue topping $100 million for the first time in 2015. (Source: IMS Research. ““The North American Market for Smart Grid Sensors – 2013.” June 2013)
• Renewables show big potential for business: According to
Ernst & Young, the U.S. recently unseated China as the most
attractive country in the world for renewable energy investment. (Source: Ernst & Young. “Renewable Energy Country Attractiveness Index” (RECAI). May 2013.)
Speaker #1
Name Background
Barbara Leary
Sr. Director, Marketing & Communication – Florida Power & Light Company
• Joined FPL in March 2008 as Senior Director, Marketing & Communication, in Juno Beach, Fla.
• Responsibilities included leading the team that provided communication support for Customer Service, Distribution and Transmission.
• Led strategy and execution of customer education program for FPL's $800 million smart grid rollout, which included 4.5 million smart meters.
• Formerly held corporate communications management positions with BASF Corporation, Lexmark International and Ketchum.
10
• Vertically integrated, retail rate-
regulated
• 4.6 MM customer accounts
• 24,057 MW in operation
• $10.1 billion in operating revenues
• $34.9 billion in total assets
• Lowest bills of all 55 utilities in Florida;
highest reliability
Florida Power & Light is one of the largest utilities in the U.S.
Florida Power & Light(1)
(1) All data as of December 31, 2012; operating revenues for the 12 months ended December 31, 2012
11
• Reduce outages, improve restoration and enhance service for our customers
• Provide customers with information to better manage their energy usage and monthly bills
• Achieve operational efficiencies and savings to help keep customers’ bills among the very lowest in Florida
• Continue to integrate the use of new technologies in all aspects of operations to optimize their value
Our objective for Energy Smart Florida was to deploy, from power generation to the meter, advanced technology that would provide a solid foundation for long-term service improvements
Vision
All customers will benefit from FPL’s investments in smart grid
12
Energy Smart Florida integrates a range of advanced technologies that enable tangible customer benefits
• Completed to date:
– Installation of 4.5 million smart meters for residential and business customers
– Installation of more than 10,000 intelligent devices
– Enhancements to centers that monitor the performance of the grid
13
Transmission/Substation Intelligence - $79
Distribution Intelligence - $40
Accelerated smart
meter deployment - $37
Commercial/Industrial Meters - $24
Enhanced Performance and Diagnostic Centers - $11
Other (incl. Home Area
Network Pilot) - $9
Our $800 million smart grid deployment was supported by a $200 million DOE grant; the remainder (about $645 million) is funded through base rates
Incremental Investments Funded by the DOE Grant
($MM)
N = $200 million
For the smart meter deployment, we made our case to regulators
based on anticipated operational efficiencies
14
• Ability to prevent many outages and restore power more efficiently
• More information and control for customers – Smart meters provide customers with information to help them better
manage their energy usage and monthly bills
• Greater convenience – We no longer need to access customers’properties every month to
read their meters (99.9% remote billing read rate)
• Enhanced customer service and greater efficiency – Both customers and FPL reps have detailed usage information to
resolve issues more efficiently
– Smart meters enable us to reduce electricity theft - a cost that is borne by all customers
– We will no longer need to estimate bills due to meters being inaccessible to meter readers (reduced estimated bills by 367,000 in two years)
More than four million customers with activated smart meters now have the ability to make more informed choices about their energy use
Initial Benefits
15
Project Status
• Completed installation of 4.5 million smart meters and the DOE-funded smart grid enhancements
• We have completed the initial integration of smart grid technology into our operations
• We are finding new ways to derive the full value from our investments for our customers
16
Smart grid and smart meters are delivering on their expected benefits
Current Functional Improvements
Operational Efficiency Grid Management Customer Service
Improvements
• Remote Meter Reading
• Enhanced Theft Detection
• Meter Reading
improvements in read
rates (99.9% remote billing
read)
• Billing improvements using
remote readings to
complete service orders
•Real-time Monitoring
•Predictive Maintenance
•Outage Prevention
•Outage Identification
• Energy Dashboard
• Proactive Ticket Creation
• Outage Verification
• Restoration Confirmation
• No longer need to access
property every month to
read meters
• Reduced estimated bills
by $367,000 in two years
17
Automated
feeder
switches
prevented
200,000+
customer
interruptions
Saved 42,000 customers an average
of two hours of outage time through
our ability to ‘ping’ the meter
More than 800,000 customers have used the
Energy Dashboard
More than 250,000 customers have already benefited from
proactive ticket creation (“last gasp”)
Speaker #2
Name Background
Jim Meadows
Director, SmartMeter Project – Pacific Gas & Electric Company
• Been on PG&E SmartMeter Project since 2002.
• Developed the business case and regulatory filing for Project Benefits Realization mechanism.
• Served extensively during the planning and deployment of SmartMeter infrastructure installation: mesh network equipment, mesh electric meters, gas metering equipment.
• Provided expert policy testimony to the California Public Utilities Commission on implementing a SmartMeter Opt-Out program.
• 20 years of experience as a capital project manager.
19
Ranked the greenest utility in the United States in 2009 and 2010
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
• 6 million customer accounts serving 15 million people
• 70,000 sq mi with diverse topography and climate zones
• Integrated utility with generation, transmission,
electric and gas distribution to:
• Service to retail customers; as well as
community choice aggregation customers
• 70,000 solar customers
• De-coupled revenues / sales
20
SmartMeter Rollout
PG&E:
10 million meters
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
2005: PG&E field pilot
2006: Full meter deployment begins
2007: Customer online access to interval usage data
2008: SmartRate (CPP) tariff
2009: Remote electric connect / disconnect
2009: Outage management integration
2011: Operations center opens
2012: Opt-Out program
2012: Green Button
2012: Net metering (solar)
2013: Home area network
2013
21
Today: My Energy Customer Portal
2012 Results: 244,000 visits per month
129,000 new (1st time) visitors a month
• View by year, bill or day
• Temperature overlay
• Energy user by hour
(electric) or day (gas)
• Secure customer access
• Similar home comparison
2.3 million My Energy accounts
22
Today: Energy Alerts
California uses a 5 tiered usage structure. Higher
tiers have higher rates.
Energy Alerts provide customers an early warning
of high usage
• When actual usage-to-date crosses higher tiers
• When usage is forecast to cross higher tiers by end
of billing period
Delivered via:
• Text message
• Outbound phone call
Over 77,000 of PG&E’s customers signed up for Energy Alerts
23
Today: Green Button for Customers
• Download up to 13 months of data
• Send personalized energy to third parties
• Open source format
Since its launch in 2012, over 82,000 customers have clicked
the Green Button to download their data from PG&E’s Website
24
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
12 A
M
1 A
M
2 A
M
3 A
M
4 A
M
5 A
M
6 A
M
7 A
M
8 A
M
9 A
M
10 A
M
11 A
M
12 P
M
1 P
M
2 P
M
3 P
M
4 P
M
5 P
M
6 P
M
7 P
M
8 P
M
9 P
M
10 P
M
11 P
M
Kw
h
Prior to SmartRate Event
July 7th 10 Day Average
Critical
Peak
Period
Today: SmartRate Peak Price Tariff
More than 117,000 customers currently enrolled in the SmartRate program.
2011 Results: 13% load reduction, 94% plan to continue
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
12 A
M
1 A
M
2 A
M
3 A
M
4 A
M
5 A
M
6 A
M
7 A
M
8 A
M
9 A
M
10 A
M
11 A
M
12 P
M
1 P
M
2 P
M
3 P
M
4 P
M
5 P
M
6 P
M
7 P
M
8 P
M
9 P
M
10 P
M
11 P
M
Kw
h
During SmartRate Event
July 8th July 9th
Critical
Peak
Period
25
Impact on Utility Operations
Electronic Billing: To date, eliminated more than 600 meter-reading
positions and reduced delayed bills by 78 percent
Remote Connect / Disconnect: Reduced average time to restore service
from 73 minutes to under 4 minutes
Meter Power Status Check: Pro-actively check meters for outages before
issuing field orders
Outage Restoration Validation: Provides critical data to help scope outages
and restore power more quickly
26
• Home energy
management
• Plug-in hybrid electric
vehicle SmartCharge™
• Integrated renewables
management
• Integrated local
generation and storage
• Distribution Automation
• Automated meter reading
• Automated service
connect
Smart Grid Journey
Today Integrate existing
services to new platform
Future Enable future services and foster innovation
Near Term Transform existing services
Years
Cu
sto
mer
En
gag
em
en
t
27
Variability, Unpredictability
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Hour
MW
Average
Each day is a different color.
Day 29
Day 5 Day 26
Day 9
Source: CAISO
PV Solar
Wind
Cloudy Day Output
PG&E is committed to making a policy mandate of 33% renewable
generation by 2020
28
SmartMeter™ Customer Benefits
Enable the Future
Put in place a platform for innovation
Choice and Control
Provide our customers greater choice and more control over their
energy bills
Customer Service
Provide our customers more convenience and
better, faster service
Faster power restoration
Faster startup of service
after moving
Faster problem resolution
Better billing
Complete energy usage information and analysis tools
Proactive Energy Alerts
New pricing options
Better options for customers to manage their energy use
Distributed generation and storage
Support demand from electric vehicles
Enable renewables
Takeaways & Questions
2013 Annual Members Meeting
• Save the date:
September 24 & 25, Washington, D.C.
Pepco Headquarters, Edison Conference room
• Alignment around the Consumer Value Proposition: The
Smart Grid Value Proposition clearly indicates the Smart Grid’s
unique value-creating features or in other words, a consensus of
the sum total of benefits customers will receive.
• Important to have a strong value proposition so benefits can be
expressed from the consumer’s perspective and the industry
can collectively talk about the experiences and benefits that
consumers will have with grid modernization.
Last but not Least: Smart Energy Corps
• Smart Grid awareness is still low: We know more than 75% of
consumers haven’t heard of smart grid or don’t know what it is
• SGCC is in a unique position to “do something about it”
• Smart Energy Corps will create a national,
credential/certification program to “train the trainer” to teach
electricity and smart grid literacy to youth, adults, community
groups
• Program development and launch planning currently
underway – contact program lead Annie Haas
[email protected] to get involved
Thank you! You will receive a copy of the slides to the email
address you used to register.
Barbara Leary Sr. Director, Marketing &
Communication
Florida Power & Light
Company [email protected]
Jim Meadows Director, SmartMeter Project
Pacific Gas & Electric
Company [email protected]
Links to Resources: Florida Power and Light Company’s Energy Smart Florida resource library:
• http://www.fpl.com/energysmart/medialibrary.shtml Pacific Gas and Electric Company’s What is Smart Grid website:
• http://www.pge.com/myhome/edusafety/systemworks/electric/smartgrid/