shape optimization of shear panel damper · pdf filepanel damper considering plastic energy...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION
Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.)Junki Nozoe
![Page 2: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Background
• Main difficulty in optimization of building structures:Structures are not mass products⇒ cannot spend much cost on optimization
• Shape optimization of special structures (long-span truss, free-form shell, etc.)
• Structural parts are mass products⇒ optimization of parts of building frame
![Page 3: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Objective of Study
• Optimization of steel panel dampers for seismic response reduction of building frames.
• Shape optimization of opening of perforated panel using conventional steel material.
• Parametric representation of hole shape using radial basis function.
• Combine heuristic optimization algorithm and FE‐analysis.
![Page 4: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Shear panel damper with openingLow-yield steelExpensiveDifficult to obtain
Normal steelInexpensiveEasy to obtain
Opening Boundary shape
Shape of panel is defined using Gaussian functions and Bezier function
Maximize plastic dissipated energy under constraint on equivalent plastic strain
Use normal steelReduce stiffness and strength with opening
![Page 5: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
2
22
2exp,
k
kkk r
yyxxyxg
Gaussian function and Bezier function
n
iij
n
j
nj
ni qyBxBy,xP
0 0
iinin
ni xxCxB 1
Two dimensional Gaussian function
center
Standard deviation
Bezier function
Control points
Bernstein polynomial
![Page 6: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Boundary representation using level set function
y,xPyxm
kk y,xgΦ
1,
αyxΦαyxΦ
Φ,if0,if1
) ,(max50 yxΦ.α
Level set function
Add Gaussian function and Bezier surface
FE-model of structures mesh
Maximum value oflevel set function
![Page 7: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Index of ductile fracture
Simple measure using equivalent plastic strain
FE-model ofstructures mesh
Non-smoothboundary shape
Unrealistic strainat boundary
Exclude boundary elementsfor checking fracture
![Page 8: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Analysis of steel panel damper
Yield stress = 235 N/mm2Kinematic hardeningHardening coefficient
= 0.05 E
Vertical disp. = h/2000Horizontal disp. = h/200
FE-analysis using ADVENTURECluster
Locations of opening
![Page 9: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Design variables
2
22
2exp,
k
kkk
r
yyxxyxg
n
iij
n
j
nj
ni qyBxBy,xP
0 0
iinin
ni xxCxB 1
!!!iin
nCin
Two dimensional Gaussian function
Bezier function
Center Design variable
Std. variation Design variable
Opening
Control points
Fix control points
![Page 10: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Parameters of Gaussian functionCenters of Gaussian functions Standard model
Discretize locations of center pointsand std. variations near the standard model
1/4 part model
Variables: std. dev. and x,y-coordinates; three for each point
![Page 11: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Optimization problem 1
JJ
Jmax
pˆ
MaximizeRE
F
0max
max
subject to 1
1,2, , 1,2, ,i i
RgR
J d i m
JJ
Larger reaction → larger plas c energy dissipa on
Specify lower‐bound of reaction
Specified value ofreaction
JpE : dissipated energy before reaches the
specified value Jmax
Discretize variables into integer values
![Page 12: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Tabu search (TS)1. Randomly generate initial seed solution
Initialize tabu list T as empty list2. Generate neighborhood solutions N = { Jj
N | j =1,...,q }3. Evaluate objective functions and constraints
(penalty function for constraints)4. Best solution in N that is not included in tabu list T
⇒ Next seed solution5. Add the seed solution to T6. Go to step 2 if termination conditions are not satisfied;
otherwise, output the best solution satisfying constraints.
![Page 13: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Parameters of TS1. Number of variables: 122. Number of neighborhood solutions: 123. Number of steps: 204. Length of tabu list: indefinite
5. Carry out TS three times from different random seeds.6. Total number of analyses: 12 x 20 x 3 = 720
![Page 14: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Optimization using ADVCluster
Modify variables
TS Algorithm
(1) Bezier function, RBF(2) Compute level-set function(3) Find non-existent elements(4) Submit to
ADVENTURECluster
Preprocessing (Fortran)
Simulation usingADVENTURECluster
Postprocessing(Perl Script)
(1) Convert binary data to text data using‘hddmmrg’ tool.
(2) Compute reaction, maximum plastic strain, total plastic energy
![Page 15: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Optimization result
Dissipated energy
Maximum plastic strain
Maximum reaction
Cycles
Initial 15.10 0.539 354.24 1.00Optimum 53.21 0.539 476.50 3.43
Dissipated energy
Maximum plastic strain
Maximum reaction
Cycles
Initial 19.33 0.306 402.08 1.00Optimum 43.94 0.306 455.94 2.59
Panel A
Panel B
![Page 16: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Optimization result
Equivalent plastic strain
Initial OptimumPanel A
Panel B
![Page 17: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Optimization problem 2
JJ
JJ
maxmax
pMaximizeR
EF
0max
max
subject to 1
1,2, , 1,2, ,i i
RgR
J d i m
JJ
Specified value ofreaction
Number of cycles may be large before dissipated energy reaches specified value
Dissipated energy in first cycle
Carry out analysis only for 1st cycle
![Page 18: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Optimization result
Objective function Energy (kN m) Strain Reaction (kN)
Initial 137.0 79.7 0.569 1021Opt 1 310.2 125.7 0.269 1507Opt 2 297.1 124.5 0.283 1483Opt 3 264.8 81.0 0.307 995
40 x 48 x 3 = 5760 elements
Initial Opt 1 Opt 2 Opt 3
![Page 19: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
FE‐analysis with fine mesh
Objective function Energy (kN m) Strain Reaction (kN)
Initial 131.2 84.14 0.5994 1070Opt 1 233.4 126.4 0.3573 1516Opt 2 214.6 124.1 0.3893 1485Opt 3 167.2 82.63 0.4817 1026
80 x 96 x 6 = 46080 elements
Initial Opt 1 Opt 2 Opt 3
![Page 20: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
FE‐analysis with fine mesh
Objective function Energy (kN m) Strain Reaction (kN)
Initial 128.2 215.7 1.572 1070Opt 1 229.5 326.5 0.938 1517Opt 2 211.7 319.9 1.018 1485Opt 3 165.3 212.4 1.252 1026
Objective function Energy (kN m) Strain Reaction (kN)
Initial 131.2 84.14 0.5994 1070Opt 1 233.4 126.4 0.3573 1516Opt 2 214.6 124.1 0.3893 1485Opt 3 167.2 82.63 0.4817 1026
1 cycle
3 cycles
![Page 21: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Analysis after Re‐meshingInitial model Optimal model
Number of nodes = 45,792Number of elements = 29,752
Number of nodes = 46,806Number of elements = 30,460
![Page 22: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF SHEAR PANEL DAMPER · PDF filePANEL DAMPER CONSIDERING PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION Makoto Ohsaki (Hiroshima Univ.) ... Analysis of steel panel damper Yield stress](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020803/5a9e38847f8b9a6a218c4ef3/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Conclusions
• Energy dissipation properties of passive dampers can be drastically improved through optimization using local search of discretized variables.
• Cost and time for physical tests for development of devices can be reduced using EF analysis and optimization.
• Appropriate choice of optimization algorithm.