shell structures - facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · applied...

45
F2016abn Membrane, Nets & Shells 1 Lecture 13 Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture Denver Airport – Birdair.com APPLIED ACHITECTURAL STRUCTURES: STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS AND SYSTEMS ARCH 631 DR. ANNE NICHOLS FALL 2016

Upload: others

Post on 15-Mar-2020

22 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 1

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

thirteen

membrane, net &

shell structures

lecture

Denver Airport – Birdair.com

APPLIED ACHITECTURAL STRUCTURES:

STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS AND SYSTEMS

ARCH 631

DR. ANNE NICHOLS

FALL 2016

Page 2: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 2

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Membrane and Net Structures

• form follows

pressure or

tension

Page 3: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 3

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Membrane and Net Structures

• types

– fabric

– cables

– pneumatic

– inflated

http://nisee.berkeley.edu/godden

Page 4: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 4

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Membrane and Net Structures

• sensitive to aerodynamic effects of wind

– fluttering

• stabilization

– rigid supporting framework

– prestressing of surface

Page 5: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 5

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Membrane and Net Structures

• tensile stress and

tangential shear stresses occur

Page 6: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 6

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Pneumatic Structures

• internal pressure

– air-supported:

entire volume

– air-inflated: cavities

• ribs

• dual walls

Page 7: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 7

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Air-Supported Structures

• pressure slightly

higher than

atmospheric

• light loads

• greater spans than

air-inflated

Page 8: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 8

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Air-Inflated Structures

• higher degree of

pressurization

• pressure doesn’t

directly balance

loads

• buckling or folding

results in collapse

• flexibility in space

Page 9: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 9

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Loads & Behavior

• snow accumulation

– shape

– heat loss

• avoid large

concentrated loads

• wind loads

– suction

– tension

– “buckling”

Page 10: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 10

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Membrane Stresses

• pressure is constantly applied stress

Page 11: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 11

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Membrane Stresses• enough pressure to prevent folding

• large radius, large stress

Page 12: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 12

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Supports

• air-supported

– need airtight

seal

– resists uplift

and thrust

– “inverted” arch

– containment

rings

Page 13: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 13

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Profile Selection

• lower profile

– higher stresses

– lower air volume

– can be used to avoid

wind pressure effects

Page 14: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 14

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Air-Inflated Members

• prestressed in

tension

• structural stresses

added

• increase in tension

Page 15: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 15

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Punctures

• fracture or rip from redistribution of

stresses

• air-supported

– low pressure

– gradual deflation

• air-inflated

– isolated cells deflate

• design in suspension

Page 16: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 16

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Net and Tent Structures

• low curvatures, high stress (big radius)

• avoid flat areas

• carefully place high & low points

Basic Types of Tensile Structures (© Tentech)

Page 17: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 17

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Support Conditions

• compression masts

• uplift at ground

• free edges can

be stiffened with

cables

• stress reduction

at high points

by a cable ring

Page 18: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 18

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Form Development

• modeling

• software

Page 19: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 19

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Materials

• strength

– tear resistant

– bi-directional

• durability

– ultraviolet

effects

– creep

– corrosion in metals

Page 20: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 20

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Shells

• similar to membranes, domes & vaults

• THIN

• rigid

Page 21: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 21

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Shells

Empire State Performing Arts Center, Ammann & Whiney

Page 22: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 22

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Shell Types

• shape classifications

– developable: • singly curved (vault)

– synclastic• doubly curved

• same direction

– anticlastic: • doubly curved

• opposite curvature

– free form

Page 23: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 23

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Synclastic

• surface of revolutions

Page 24: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 24

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Shell Stresses

• in-plane

– tension

– compression

– shear

• insignificant

bending

• suitable for distributed loads

• can’t handle concentrated loads well

Page 25: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 25

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Spherical Shells

• arch of revolution

• compression

• some tension

– “bow”

Page 26: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 26

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Forces in Spherical Shells

• similar to plates

– two directions of forces

– shear

– maintain curvatures

• meridional– arch direction

• hoop – radial direction

– can see tension

• holes redistribute stresses

– edges need reinforcement

Page 27: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 27

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Meridional and Hoop Forces

• meridional force per unit length:

• hoop force per unit

length:

22 sinRπ

WN

cos

cosRwN θ

1

1

Page 28: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 28

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Distribution and Concentrated Forces

• size distributions

• concentrated force

causes

R.

R)'cos(

620

4951

N

0.6

2 R

Page 29: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 29

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Support Conditions

• absorb horizontal thrust

– tension ring

– being pushed out

– need to be continuous

– can be used as foundation

• top (crown) rings

– in compression

Page 30: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 30

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Support Conditions

• buttresses

• edge restraint effects

– deformations different

– fixed edges• bending stress

• deep section

– pinned edges• still induces bending

– post-tensioning helpsstiffen

Page 31: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 31

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Buckling & Lateral Loading

• instability

– compression

– moment of inertia

– low stress levels

• local

• snap-through

• lateral loading

– shear

Page 32: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 32

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Annunciation Greek Orthodox Church

• Wright, 1956

http://www.bluffton.edu

Page 33: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 33

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Annunciation Greek Orthodox Church

• Wright, 1956

Page 34: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 34

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Cylindrical Shells

• can resist tension

• shape adds “depth”

• not vaults

• barrel shells

Page 35: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 35

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Kimball Museum, Kahn 1972

Page 36: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 36

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Kimball Museum, Kahn 1972

• outer shell edges

Page 37: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 37

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Kimball Museum, Kahn 1972

• skylights at peak

Page 38: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 38

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

• saddle or “ruled” shapes

• surface generated with straight lines

• tension follows “cable drape”

• compression follows “arch”

Anticlastic Shells (Hyperbolic Paraboloid)

Page 39: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 39Lecture 13

Applied Architectural StructuresARCH 631

Anticlastic Shell Behavior

• edge conditions offer restraint

– tie rods useful

– shears

Page 40: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 40

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Zarzuela Hippodrome, Torroja 1935

http://www.arch.mcgill.ca

Page 41: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 41

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Zarzuela Hippodrome, Torroja 1935

Page 42: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 42

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Heilmajer Memorial Bandstand

• Kramer, 2002

Page 43: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 43

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Heilmajer Memorial Bandstand

• Kramer,

2002

Page 44: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abnMembrane, Nets & Shells 44

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

Heilmajer Memorial Bandstand

• Kramer, 2002

Page 45: shell structures - Facultyfaculty.arch.tamu.edu/media/cms_page_media/4350/lect13.pdf · Applied Architectural Structures ARCH 631 thirteen membrane, net & shell structures lecture

F2016abn

Videos

Membrane, Nets & Shells 45

Lecture 13

Applied Architectural Structures

ARCH 631

BC Place roof replacement

Canada Place roof rehabilitation