shhm siaa - national bureau of economic research · shhm owixiow siaa arnina tut1jo fl151q gma...

43
arnina siaa owixiow SHHM UX5JAM GMA fl151q TUT1JO :ATAC OSIDIM MI MOIa5IdaIU siaauuosi IO aaaosi JHT 3210M UMA YTIHMHDOSIHTHH atiodol .1. AmM zniqu2 nsltG aVOa wq&I nthoW llD5IAd35I DIIVIOMODJ TO IJAHI5IIJH JAMOITAM 6un3vA afloeuiIonzaBM OOI 8EIO AM 3gbhdrcmD VQQI onut o1thT. mthA aorbi1hO ivS b1aoioD !us nnuU miT iotoC) r1ii)I oth ajliM AnzrIt alorituB fiT bun nottu2 nilot 4o51 IadfnSI aaio2 1oto w1IouM ainasU gmdb!oD iqolonN eniiouDoM hado5l him etnornrnoo Ixftq!od ioI unoiufi auan3D a.u ffi to aibuia 3!monooH io1 ioin) 3fit lo 'finta edt oimonoo ioTl ietne3 edt is bet3ubnoo asw domeaei airiT .leqsq airit to afisib ieihse no ano!aau3aib •11113101q awoll&1 rfoiseae2 usewfi waneD edt ru atnsqnthsq etew atodtus edt elidw aeibuia 'nw ns iii ion oh bus aiodtun edt lo eaodi ets eied beaaeiqxe anoiaul3noo io nibrxfi anoiniqo aidT .rloiseae5l oimono3H lo un5uIfl IsnoitsM edt 10 useiuH auaneD a .u erli to awex' edt i3effel .noiissinsiO Ishtaubnl ni rrmioiq d3issaet atMJRMIo hsq ai teqzq ot ion ixet to anoitoa horl2 .bevteaex atr1Fi hA .nniqu2 rml'cU bus ahacioM .t !mM d VQQ I 3 ,tibaw hut inch bebivoiq noiaairrrt3q tioilqxe tuodiiw betoup ed '(Em arIqsismq owt bee3xe .eoiuoa edt ot novia ai eouion © 2nibuloni

Upload: others

Post on 17-Sep-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

arnina siaa owixiow SHHM

UX5JAM GMA fl151q TUT1JO :ATAC OSIDIM MI MOIa5IdaIU

siaauuosi IO aaaosi JHT 3210M UMA YTIHMHDOSIHTHH

atiodol .1. AmM zniqu2 nsltG

aVOa wq&I nthoW

llD5IAd35I DIIVIOMODJ TO IJAHI5IIJH JAMOITAM 6un3vA afloeuiIonzaBM OOI

8EIO AM 3gbhdrcmD VQQI onut

o1thT. mthA aorbi1hO ivS b1aoioD !us nnuU miT iotoC) r1ii)I oth ajliM AnzrIt alorituB fiT bun nottu2 nilot 4o51 IadfnSI aaio2 1oto w1IouM ainasU gmdb!oD iqolonN eniiouDoM hado5l him etnornrnoo Ixftq!od ioI unoiufi auan3D a.u ffi to aibuia 3!monooH io1 ioin) 3fit lo 'finta edt

oimonoo ioTl ietne3 edt is bet3ubnoo asw domeaei airiT .leqsq airit to afisib ieihse no ano!aau3aib •11113101q awoll&1 rfoiseae2 usewfi waneD edt ru atnsqnthsq etew atodtus edt elidw aeibuia

'nw ns iii ion oh bus aiodtun edt lo eaodi ets eied beaaeiqxe anoiaul3noo io nibrxfi anoiniqo aidT .rloiseae5l oimono3H lo un5uIfl IsnoitsM edt 10 useiuH auaneD a .u erli to awex' edt i3effel

.noiissinsiO Ishtaubnl ni rrmioiq d3issaet atMJRMIo hsq ai teqzq

ot ion ixet to anoitoa horl2 .bevteaex atr1Fi hA .nniqu2 rml'cU bus ahacioM .t !mM d VQQ I 3 ,tibaw hut inch bebivoiq noiaairrrt3q tioilqxe tuodiiw betoup ed '(Em arIqsismq owt bee3xe

.eoiuoa edt ot novia ai eouion © 2nibuloni

Page 2: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

unopcuabawcqn DA!uanb!u&@nu!'1cr&wJq 1411EK YT3TO tti!6U ynauvflUTAGL2T4 IN T2805 RffiS-DIflGmJCL 2W X5JJJG LCmJ2AJA&ui& 44t fluTAcLaI{A flIJIACL2JjX oj, jicuu&GBI4IMCU4 0j C0U0IUiC2 DCLI4UJGUi OL ECOUOW!C2

LAISW ] JfOCLf 2 DAIJU nbiu&

AUgp0w

!2 jcaa wm 'ox. orgbn{ bucc 2nca4iuE & J&LCL LOJC LOt iqioaAucupc apocjca JU cucwpu mstjcnb

jnpcat uuq jonca wm4cnLa cuq jo LGW&J 20 (ThCL pwc jocrp OACWfl wc bctaaçcucc !U untjcnba

bLoqnccta &c jcsa Jrnt1&jjA b&aacq on 40 bnLcp&2GL2 2 JOtAGL onjbn bucca JJU "1W tG

W&L!U&j coaja JDJ&A 911 !mbOLWlU WJG !U GUGIS{jJJ b&gcur jpc JO/ACt bLoqncpou coafa J,oL jmc

LCUJ&!U2 nucp&ncq or. rncLCs2ca inip bju a!sc 14oL jj pn jpm ol, pc btoqnca &uq qccpupJ

Jo/Ad. orubru bqcca j.q&r.u&J coat 9uq flit mw4cnba sac tapm&tq Lot CSCJJ bjmiç jjjc uiqcnb

ap.riqmsj ijlcjoi.a couiupnc o ipc butt qiabcLaow LOt jj pni pAo btoqciqa' J&LC bLoqilecta JJ&AC

aujc bgg 0LWC bt1cc MPflI0u "1W P!P LLcdncuc?! antapu jjrnj IIUqCLJAIJ 41u1C-UJA9TflU4

MOfffl pt cucwccq p) bcacjA L9UOW IJJOACUJCIIW wp-bicC mq joiA-bqcc bpmça ztnnru q.rc

OAOL iwc bjut p.mJaon b&gcum iuqc&ic mote bCL2!24CUCG Ju w bucrn ojuqpuqmj bj&rua tjnu

OACL w J ô23J OWl bcuoq jpc mnonui oLbuce jcictoEcucgA AWica arrpawiuwjjA gcr.oaa btoqncw

JJOWOGUOfl2 unurqpcuu.cq ooqa ff tCjiCa on micto q&j& om pc n•a• Gnt% o\isctt

UJ&4C{ p? srnq?siu on;brg butt uuq br.icc-msaiinj C024 wstjcnba a qsc bjwu JCAQJ ior. w!14CCu

jpia b&b;t br.otiqca cmb1ucsj cnqcucc oh w CXfCU4 obLoqnccL petCL0C1JCJO !' w orrbn

VB2JMVCI

JhJqfla4t4SJ OLiJ!flfl0U1FF J402 ['JØ D40V" TOO!1411E1{ J/0LJCTU bCL J40 QOX?&4C i jçopcia q DAJSIJ 3nbiusHCfCL0tUC!A mig j.oacV\J!0L0 iv J{0JC2 °LOnibrn Ji4C6 &iiq JAJ&tJmb D!abGLaJoU In

Page 3: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

noit)ubotnl .4

bethmsxe noianemib edt lo aae1bisei ,iath 315 stsb oioim ie3ubolq lo aeiinthl uommo3 owT

eaerli bus aehiaubni aaoios oh 'edt as '(1taubni einsa edt thdtiw turn as ielIib neflo aieouboiq

Iatiqsa bus esia iii 00i38115V be511130331-!13W aebiaeR .eiiut lo abOfleq wioI 19V0 3V1 ViLla 1183 ae3oeleThb

aetsi tfioiq ieouhorq ni 'iiene3oieted evianetxs betnemuoob evsd aeibuta !s3nlqme 30e3e1 ,'CiaIIeirn

aeiutibneqxe UiMI .2313010114333 beanavbs lo ooiiqobs edt ,aetsi dJwoi aei3i1icJsdoiq eiulisl

lo 1101381urn11335 aiill dliw InebionioD '.noi3sansqmoo iodsl bus ae3si div/mB bits atevel 'livilauboiq

aoimso'b 'çtaubni bus unit lo alebom Isoiieioedt lo tuemqo!eveb edt need asd ecuebive tsoiiiqme

alebom eaedh ebivoiq tsdt atnenoqmoo 'eI edT .amettsq ts3niqme edt lo emoa 3niuislqxe lo eldsqso

as beleborn netlo flzene3o1eted level-mill lo 3311102 £ :31)111301 stab edt nislqxe ot iewoq iiedt dtiw

gnicnse1 level-ffrxil tneiellib ot bsel tadt aA3oda 3itsioutaoibi .t1°111 itoiioiiboiq ni aeaneieThb

tiieiaitleiii lo tim gnitioa edt toeveiq to wola tsdt ttaoo '(1309 bus ,ailtsq 'tivitouboiq 10 in&olaevrn

aisauboiq iiIei3ifle moil

nnil ci atoda 313n3n'(aoibi ,a3203 iii '{nene3oieied level-unit lo noi3snidmoo edi elidW

ounsrncb edt 3ninislqxe ni tnstioqnii '(1ev ed ot iseqqs floitoelea ieAism b aaeooiq a bus ,aeitivitouboiq

wod no 63113biV3 oitsmeta'a ai eiutsietil edt moil 3thaaim al tsdw !eIuhith bus dtwoig mill 10 axneitsq

aieauboiq '(d begisd3 aqu*rsm bus eeonq tuqtuo edt '(1ls3i1ioeqa ;tejhsm tuqtuo edt 333118 aeoiol eaedt

lo '(tIuOfllib edt ot 1)33813 ed 1183 bio3ei lsaniqme edt ni qs aiilT .emit ievo uioitiiIoVe iiedt bus

ts 10 auoitoea-aaoio eviisineaeiqe1 iol 1is1uoinsq aieouboiq Isubivibni id ae3Fiq tuqtuo 3uhuasem

ni uoilaeup 3nibnsta-gnol edt ol tnsvelex 1ltoeiib oats ai eanebive aidT emit iii lnioq 9110 118113 eiom

.anaclol .ennuU ae3ua,sThb lfloiq no (ô8Q1) leII3uM :ebuI3ni elsa srnb lenag level-unit 10 lnslq no 'lei isuil asibul2 bus grednsizbij ,asis ubwoi no (ÔQQI) dnib2 bus ,isgnzwnlsH eivsU ,aelsz emhsi bus sbwoi3 no (28Q1) noaleums2 bus

llodqmsD bus ,nstlul-1 'olis8 ,noilqobs 'olomboj no (*QQI) eunuCi ,inennaevni CM no @221) Sfl3lA bus (1221)133312 bus aivaCI baa ,a,neie1tib '(tivil3ubolq ao (22I) 3uod'(f bus ,(22I) aetq bus 'MIO .(tQQl) vseM bus asilailnO ,(221)

.2335w no (1221) isgnswnlsH

uoadmsl (821) 3ivousvot ebuloni aisouboq 3uosns '(onaioifle lsiansisThb ibiw lixe bus 'flus to abbots oiinsn',U .(eQQl) coin'! bus uoeoi,i bus ,(2Q1) srsdnsqoH .0221)

.1

Page 4: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

lnoioillo 3IO11I 2333fl31 annil omoa lo s3nsrrnoheq tiloiq ioFisqua sift isilloriw lo floilssmsgio Lshlaubth

(EVQ1) sisamsU ssa) owt sift lo noilsnidmoo £ 10 ,aqmhsm isdid 3315113 ol vilids sift ,non3ubolq

311221 aS Io lnsmaasaas tosliG .((Q8Q1) ssaitstsmilo8 bits (à8QI) islbuM .(VVQI) itsmsl!s

aqwhsm bits aiaoo ,asonq no sisb ojoim

I1isnsgolstsd isouboiq lo lnsixs sill no esnobive Isoniqms sbivoiq ot ai isqsq aicft Io 1s03 silT

iltod titsmu3ob eW .aqmhsm bits asonq tuqluo ni Viens3olslsrI sift '(11s3flioeqa tstsm iuqiuo sill iii

alDubolq nestüdl ioI lsvsl insiq eth is aqutsm bits as3nq UI airisflsq asilsa-smit bits 1511011332-22013 sill

no auoo oW .boiisq V821 -EöQ1 silt isvo asiulosmunsM o auaneD .

a. u silt mon nwsth stsb no gniIsi

03 sub asonsisulib s3nq e1diaaoq as chum as ,svomsi ot isbio lii ai3IJbOlq bsiutosluitsm auositsomoil

sbiw asbivoiq II .anoransmib lsisvea cii Isuatmu ai samoa stsh sdT .Ibali tuqluo sth cii Disno3ololsil

bsvi1-no1 10 53151 5th taut ot betimil ton at bits vtaubiti its itt alitslq lo nOilaea-aaOl3 3113 lo sgsisvoa

is 1atuqth Isiisism lo ooFiq sth '(llslu3irxsq , aeldsiisv taos tnsnoqmi 33111321103 ot au wolls II .

aisouboiq

ow 11sni9 .aisouboiq gnoms 'nsnsgoiolsr1 1203 io1I 10111103 aqwhsm Isvsl-inslq isilt 02 lovol inslq sift

bits 3ao3 sshq o soitetaiaisq sth titemnoob bits emit 13V0 atnslq gniiinoslunsm Isubivibth s3sIt ff83

arnsilsq qwhsm

,itsi'1 bits (OVQ1) IilsbniA bits isl3iia ,

(1 bQI) islgit8 grnbulorn asibuta louIse lo isdirwu A

22013S '(IlsilflstadIJa 'çisv 1153 boog s lo soiiq silt lsift bstitsmuoob svsil (QVQI) isausdblosS hits saiW

itsm iol 1(ilaubni as iii alitalq 3nululoslunsm aaoios ns3 asonq tuqluO .aisllea 10 aistud titsisThb

iloissa 43111 aisouboiq aaoios noilsiisv iIsiip 10 '(lisnS3OlStsiI touboiq bonsadonu gnibu1ath aiioassi

.atsthsm oulqsiosg 18301 22013S itountsqmoo 10 ataoo nOui3ubOIq itt asonsisThb 10 21511w2it03 '(4 ataoo

lo inolxs eth as laut £ofl5 insm5lJJassm 10 rnnoqsi lo iluasI s as slsb obJEt lii sails oals liso II

bus nisiansiofl .noiaisqaib sQhq lo psnuo non io sno snimsxs ci eisa slab otim say asibwa Isohiqms 3115351 IsmvsZ £

ol asluob sib guocns znoiiibnoo bnsmsb ni aaonsmThb sau bus asluob suiliis oiliosqa no asoiiq 15)1311 snimsxs (tsQQl) 202 uoilsiisv sati (QQ!) aflsdosi bus snnuU bus (1Q21) aaxsSt bus nsdsnasiB .noiaisqaib sohq 10 aaigsb sib ni asonsiaThb thslqxs

bssid bus awlisioi siji uoius asonsisThb S3IIq nisiqxs 03 ajsAiszn oidgsigosg ilsina aaoios aiolilsqmoo to isdmiin sdl ill nislqxa ci nsimoslunsm lo isdmun sib iii nohshsy asnsa-smn san (EQQI) aasns}4 bus eniggiW .'(Isvil3sqasi ,aisiuloslunain

Page 5: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

oth Its ioI Inavolsi od 111w noilsnslqxo o1n1a on , atouboiq 220135 5V ot 1lothl si nolaloqaib oonq

,o1oniloot silt lo alisiob isluornsq orb no bnsqob 111w noitsnslqxo silt bsoranI .'cbsna ow alouboiq

silt sslnsgio oT .touboiq ilsso ot nlslisq lnth aAooda mobnn bus ,noitlloqmoo ls±lsm bnsmob

qmhsm bits oiiq anlilaiuzrxitaib 110 215301 ow buta ow at3ubolq lo ogrisi bsoid orb iol oonsbivo

tnotxs oil oT ion oh Isilt asonoisThb 'çioiiansn mon ornul IOVO taiaioq t&lt lovol inslq silt IS 23311510Thb

22013S asoitsiollib moil sabs '(oil '(13±1 al ti ,laialoq asonoioThb qwlism bits onq bs'noado tails

lnuioirila isibo 10 ,noiñtsqmoo IstIsm anoitibno3 brismsb '(li1sup ioubrnq ,'oIonilost at aisouboiq

10 aAooila mobnsi bolslstroonu 3i 1asi1noo nI .srnit lovo (lwo1a sitsiI3 tO liislafloo SIB tsth atotosi

asonstaThb qwhsm bits soiiq nails '(lisns3oistsil tooubotq lo asoiuoa nism silt ots axons tnomsiuassm

.'(loliamn3 od ol '(IsAil otom iloum ots

otipnii 00102 aoaauoaib noitooa brioooa silT .awollol as bssinsgto ai toqsq aiilt lo tobthainoi oilT

bits sonq luqtuo tol lnsvslot 315 3sth slsb tnomilaildslao zsintt,uwM\o uiznC) oil lo aoitanolostsclo

aaotos noitsiisv oonq tuqluo lo arnottsq out asstI&ffiiiIua noilosa biith silT .lnscnsmassm qwhzm

rItwol oilT .aooiiq bns asia tnslq nsswtod noitslonoo silt bus smi3 tovo oonotaiatsq iioill atsoubotq

-eaoio sill alnsastq noxlooa ilflul oil bits taoo Isataism lovsl-lnslq lo nollsmilas Sill 2551151fl01152 noitooa

aquiism lnslq iii ainotlsq aonsa-orml bus Isnoilasa

stat! tiisunladdataa auansD dliv, tnswnuassM soft'! luqinO .11

ot lnstioqmi ai ti atsouboiq aaotos aeoitq tuqtuo lo snoansqrnoo hu1niussm olsm ot tobto iii

nwsib 0-is slsb ouT atnslq lo todmun £ d boaubo-iq sin tails aboog Isoitnobi '(llsoia'(rlq iltiw nigod

lQubolq-llum bits sigina to iiIids sill in as3nslsThb aliolqxs (1221) bisqsd2 .alouboiq lsoilusosunsilq ioI asonswThb sonq sornaa liatsi norns snhlosB s'nsa-llsa bus 11th b sohq s3snvs sift in asonsisThb nislqxs 01 slsnimiioaib soi-iq 01 annfl

swq mon noiaisqaib soiiq thsi daiugniiaib 01 Rsl s aqo!svsb (2821) iioddA .lsiisin oifftlfl205g slgitia £ in anailsia bits (8821) nsaajmoo}1 its'! .',1aubni lnsrnso .2.1J sift ,ol asohq luqlno 0111 asi!qqs bits slsb maim sill in ions lnsrnsmassm

him d1tU bits (QTQ1) tsausitbsX bits ,saiW Ilsi'! .noaaisqaib sohq no noilsitni lo jasibs sill bma (tQQl) nobbiaT bits dasj .noraisqaib sonq nislqxs 01 doissa ismuallOa 'Iloo bo aisbom say 0821) sasW

Page 6: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

uwc sug' 2111cc zc flu 10 2wqA cpsutc2 !u s bLoqnccLa1 bL!CG OAGL flw W!2 SJ2O sp4cctcq we act oi. bLoqrTcf2 c 2wqAjpc unwpct 01. bLoqricta lL Jt4J!c dnguqtA QSfV 12 C0JJCC(CQ uq mc urnupci. 04. hLoqnccL2 COACI.cq JJWAC pOIJI IflJjCu OACI

hLiccr JJJI? gAbc 04. S2LGtSf IOU JM52 pOMCAGL 2ponJq IJO( ccutc coLLcJsuou w S bjsur, bucc 5CL022 CCI12112 Xc5L2

ft mc coujujou iunycz bucc ijncuntc oACi. iyc Xcn suq bJ!1112 qo not acjj iqcurxcs 2pSLc2 o4. onjbnr si cSqJ 04, tP CJIIJGLCUIgjj bjsug 2C11 r cncqX mc 25111; bL!cc si gijA bollif I t!WG IAC CtIJ 02CLAC 01022-2cCf!0usJ 1.5511011 !U OlE bjsiu onjbng bLICC2

,, JP!2 SlJUflUJ SACLSC buc; 22 s &TSIJUIA-MCItjUcq sAcLstc ol mc bL!cc 04, cscp OijIf 04,01111)111 2Oq OAGI. tpc Acw EAcu 24.

qicac 12 5 2cAcu-qt 21C bLoqif Cl 1W tC CXCGbt!OIJ 014 C0acG ffiOOJ JppLca suq C0LLflS1C )0XG2

uctAabLwe counstcq p0(G2e mob!. S2OIIUG LGSqA-wtccq C011CLC10 suq pn-bistc 21CC] csuw2 pseji o

cottojf jpqapcq mooi sbbstcj zypuca psqooq osjc uo.S jnqmooq bIAMooq aogooq bjAmooq

jJJt bsu pLcsq' Losaicq c01j6c cogou 2jicct!U suq sjcq 14SPL!C2' TOO abnu b0!1C21CL pjcuqa !W

JJJ!2 2WtlA !ll CZSUJ!UC oiitbiit bL!cc q2bcLa!ou 9CL022 1DSUU149CWLjiJ bju12 14tTh J3 btoqncta:

we bjwt suq j9L ffiP!CJJ CZbCIJq!WLC uq dnsupjA qsw SLC cojjcetcq

IMO McjJ-qc14jiJcq UJSLCLI9J iiibiita qJ9 VCCOffUt 140!. 5 aiiqjcsiit 14LSCIIOU 014 tOWj WSICL!S! CYBCIJqIWLC2 W

SAGLSC bucc o WStCLlSJ2 140!. !uthor.wut wbnt Ipe bLoqncta me JISAG cpoacu to awqA sjJ pSteouc OL

o rnbrjja bnLcJm2cq 1404. qcwcq 4.5/A WStCL!91 CStCOUC2 L!i!2 9110M2 ff2 fO cOIJ2tLffct s b!suL-thccnJc

ycrntsctrnsz sjao cojjcci qsw 011 tJJG bjsut, 2 CZbGUqWLC OU UJSICL!SJ !UbfftB guq tpc bpA2ICSJ dnsutzA

bisut 1152 m350145111 O COULO] 140!. AS!. 1011 111 UtcLis bL1CC2 5CL022 C2ISpJI2jJIJJCIJIW JJJC o\

I11CC £5/A IJJSICLISJ2 CSU 014(041 SCCOff Ut 1404. WOLO tpsu o LCLCCUI o btoqnctiou 002j2 !U S WS1JI1CWL!U

ju oLqct to combnc wnjmba 9tL022 bLoqnccLa lj 12 1J0CC229LA 10 COIJILOf 1404. COat AsLsqow

o 2prbwcUt2 to qic smjiwj dnsut 014 ofltbflt 2JJ!bbC(1 140L ACLA q s8LGsIcq bLoqncta rn CSCJJ C9412ff 2

014 mc520LC flJI2 5JJ0M2 na to couatLnCt S bjsuj-abccqjc sjcwc buce 92 WC LStIO 014 tP SIJUITSJ ASJflC

52 mcjj sa wc bp?2!csJ dnsut!tA bLoqnccq 140L S 2ff20t 014 powocucoria btoqcrcta mtp mcjj-qcjjucq 1111!t2

c2t9p1!2!JUJCUt 4.01)01.12 tjIO MjRC 014 apIbWOIJCa o osep 2cA0U-qib 2K bLoqncb wsucq1scwi.eq 141 pC bjsut

couqnct;q iu we AesLa Q3 Tocx Toze Töxx TaS Tô8.x va bsu oj1 we coimnr CSCjJ aRLAGAOq

144.0W W fi 2 C"' MP!CP it S 21ILAOA 014 5JJ WSIJ1I145CWL11J CatSpj!2JJU101142

Page 7: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

his1 al al3ubolq nasnith 3th lo 11353 .aSilOSlsO 1iib-fl3'182 Isisvoa 18V0 a3lssis 815 iloidw

moil Iluasi isilt 283n513111b oonq ,aldiaaoq as 113um as ,atsnimils 01 ff320113 nssd ansi bus anosn3aomorl

ns3 ow slsb 21111 illiW V.vjo81s3 touhoiq 1iib-nevoa 8th 111 aioouboiq noms 1tonsgoialarl luqluo

iovo noiludFilaib sanq 6th 10 aflurla .a33hq luqluo bvsl-lnMq In noiludhmib Iznoilooa-aaoio ath 3sxlsns

anoiludiflaib 'hs8 lnswuuib silt rluoith aioauboiq isubivibni 1o Inamovoni 8th bus 81I1t

levod Uzslc edt Is aineflsc nlaFi'1 .111

a33r111 tuqtuO iii noiishsV noiloe2 -aaoiD .A

I oldsT iouboiq iloss iol asoriq tuqtuo ni ath 3Si1SfflUW2 3w 110i3332 aIIII flu

bammiit ath ai taiil 3111 .1s3'( 11353 ni aiioiludhlaib saiiq iuqiiio ath lo aailaitsla 'ClsuhIiIua 3UII anoqoi

ml 153'( ifoso ml auoils'noado lo tnsoiaq 3vi1 lasilgirl bus 1n83loq svil ttowol 8(11 231818b 43111w

jzoilshsv lo 1n313il13o3 ath ai siuassm b0o332 MIT .stsb ath ml al8illuo lo 133118 8th 8V0(fl31 ol 181)10

£ al ojIalIsla 'isrnmua Emil 81cr .001 'd bsulqillum nssm cth ol noiizivsb btzbnzla 8111 In oiist oth

II .stsb ath iii aisilluo bits alOna lnsmaluas6m ol 121Jc101 srnm ad at Isoli1 21 tsth noiatcqaib lo oiuasam

oth d babivib uoiludiflaib 8th Ia alitfloalsq thOl bus thOQ 8th noswl3d sofIaloThi) ath as botaintanoo al

220135 28111253111 no!al8qath owl sill 3o 3151EV ogsiavs 3111 arIoq8I 81(151 6th lo ff11111103 mmli 8111' .nslbom

no bcazd noiaiaqaib laswol 01 1aodid moiI 31dB) 8th ml baAnn ais atouboiq 8th bus aiso sldslisvs us

8.swas3ifl noiaioqaib taudrn ath Ia sulsv 8518VS 6th

01 2 isvo s1ssigs us ai aexod beisgimoD .aiouboiq ligib-asvaa owl to slsgslggs 115 doss ss aohdth bow bits salto) a

.louboiq sift lo san bits sift d bsmbb siz izrft asnogslso Iigib-nsvsa 11

siariw anh1ssfia 1101103 :lqsoxs alouboiq lit idi V8Q1 bus EâQI usswiad asauaaao zia sth Ia doss mail sldslisvs ai sisU bus ,gcthooft iso boowbisri .boowtq boowftoe ,sldsiisvs Ion sis V821 bus Eb21 sisriw ,abnaid islas'<loq ,sldsiizvs Ion ai V821

a,sa' gniaaim silT .V21 isfis sldzhns Ion ai sisb aisriw ,viso nil bus ,sldsiisvs Ion ais T821 bits 821 sismiw ,ini qawan liz isvo noiIinjfsh Instaianoo £ jointanoo 01 sidiaaoqmni ii sbsmn rioiilw asboo Iouboiq Iigib—nsvsa sili to noilinitebsi moil ILuast

lnslaiaIloQ bsloinlanoo svsd aw sasa riots nI .alss'< atianso isis! sift ni bslsgsiggs sit abiiboiq ,izisnsg UI •'C 2112(183

'd baouboilni amstdoiq bloys 01 an awolis ajift bus isa' doss molt annol 'snua isnigiio sift no bsasd anoiimitsb Ioiiboiq SVQI UI asboo 312 sift ni aagnszb sisoa-sgisl

.iaqsq aith iii asidsl giiinistiisi its ni noiaisqaib 3S15V5 iaswoi 01 leadgid molt aiouboiq lo giiiinsi ants thsinizm 111w eW

a

Page 8: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

Q

pGCVff2C 3 32 JG22 2cU TAG 40 OnrpcL2 tlfllJ 1P UL!4JJWGLIC wan

AILUflIJA iqcuricsj sug LJJG CPOICC 0I UOLUJUIISUUOU JJS2 00 GIJCCt on mc Ic2flJtV (JIlL bLccLGUCC 40L tc geometLic Diego2npU.5cI mc oi qs nqnncpc DicU 0I m buccr pi tp!2 twrmc DL!tpmcqc uq tcowcujc WGU2 0 WG bLicc2 9LC

JJJI2 12 iqcnr VI *0 U0LUJVJ3S3II pX 4IJC VL3LIRIJCt!c WD 04 jo bucce TU CVCJJ XCVL VU VJLCLIJV4TAC UOLDJWJ3SUUOU ! 10

10 DGSIOU (J) bLOAiqG2 VU WtL0flCU0U 40 JCCLUCJ qcu2nA sUg LGLC22TOU C2IIUJSIOL2

on tyc LOfl21 qr2bcL2Ton WGV2flLC•

pigp-bL3cc OIU1!CLV JJJc VAGLV2Q C0C1JjC3d111 0 AVLLV1IOU OACL Iô23-JoX 32 1ÔÔ /AP!CP 32 TU JTUC *JIG bzoqnct tsupu2JJJG coqijcicw o nusuoU LOL ?orJzAooq blXthooq 32 nun2nsJJA J!LC In One Xcn pccsn2c o s 2w3JJ nnWpcL o

flJG qcuafl }" iJ Aesi. t. ! C2tiWiftCti 92:

9JJCL tJJC IJJW4I2 2JU !2 tJJC 01, IJJC comctuc ifiCif U LLICC OAGL jj biVut2 lu lIen

qJG qcu2tA 01, t%I = () - U.S(\I ()) MGLC U ! tiJG unwpet oj bJifut2 !U lIen uq W ICLW

bjuta bL3cc 1" lIen .! uousrnpcq pA tire cowctL!c wesu bites pJ lIen bccqjcifJJA flC C2tJTJJStC

GUCL91 bucc-JcAcJ CJJ9UG2 20 tC 2CbifLiftC CL022-2CCi30U buce q32iLpnuou2 c911 pe cowbncq ccp

coimtinct jccwq qdu211A 92pIBtc2 1,0L cscp btoqnct u ccp )icifr10 P3 otqct to ICUJOAC me cjjcctoamuwsnc tpc AGifLJA bL3cc q tqpnpou WOLG pqA pont b1ifc!u IJJflCp 2PJTCWLG 0U tIJO qsw liC

bnticnjnjA we P!P" UJOIUCIJt2 01, e OL MJJCtJJCL mete eqat qqjcLcut woqca• i' otqci. to

wqfl2tLJC2 ifUq ifCL022 IIUJe Pitt tjic? qo uo bLoA!qc cowbiete b!cmLc 01 WC bL!c;

JJJC COCiJjCiCU 01, ASLJSIJOU if ug LOpIT2t qiabeL2Jou WG9211L5 C9IJ pe €9 2!IA cowbiftcq 9CL022

2ftt2 U L9UjqU wt cpq OccflL monjq pe qite to aumij woAewcut2 W tJC 2mJJUJ9LA 2t9fl2t!c

o bioqnct 1,LOUJ P!tp to jam (ff2bCL2OIJ ! tifPIt J moiijq pc AILW9JJA tjJC 29mG ID CAGLA lIen q

54X 1,OL tJJG (jIJJ.CLCUi CCU2fl2 ACna' Millie IJCM2bLIilt ASLIC2 1,L0UJ T5Q 0 TQ F 2 if LC2tTjt' W L!111cmg

Acnr EOL CY9WBJC w° topnat q2beL2ou IJJGS2flLC 1,OL jrnLqnooq bjAmooq tgjje petMecu 333 suq

jpe ccouq bifgcLu 2 tjlift m swornsj o, qabctaou 1,OL giAcu bLoquct 12 2jWflifL 9CL022 qlC qq1,CLGIJL

GflLcwcr m LOpitat q2bcL2Iou wcsarn.c ifAcLa8G2 534 1,OL pnqooq bjAitooq suq T42 1,OL ucM2buur

2CCt!0Il9j qi2beL2rniY put mc wmtuqc 01, qic q2bCL20u A9LIG2 anpatifut!9jjA 9CL022 bLoqnctw Vt tPC

JJJG wt bSUCLIJ GAiqeut j1L0W tifpje I ! Wt G9CJJ 01, tJJG btoqncta 2 Cp9LifCtGLGq pA CLO22-

Page 9: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

1

jpr wc2c uto bLOqRCI2jca o bt!cG 02CLAtIOU lU GUcJJ ?LGSL PU' W ms) 9COI1UJI Ot LUG 4CI W9 W qGua!O G2t!W91C2 BLG mote ASL!SJG OACL timeoqlcL uto btoqnctr P5RMOO bj?uooq suq cojou apeequ p91s CMGL bioqncsLz suq buce op2suspouv jpcA esep ps; si

BOL oi c btoqncia ptcvq cotLu9zcq poxcaa coucLCLG sug sojiuc SAC St }G921 Uo OpCLAStlou2 iu cscp ACm? jyc

umG-!uAsL!sut cpnvcicuatic ancp sa btoqrrcr dnsJ!A msl pe su pnboi.wuc coutupntot (0 (JIG JJJJ JCACJ

W4CG (JIG WG5U buce) !a ctqqGrn m cscp AGSL 0L pnqtooq bjlmooq jpia ancaa acme

sctoaa lena !a CJGSLJA GA!qGU(• VW0 S accoq JIJJIGL-bLICG IIIOqG si Sbbtor!ws(cIA j (sbbtonmstcjl

lcnal EAGU in (JIG2G csaca 2GAGLSJ apJsJJnrpca Ste LLGaGIJI JJJG aml!JSLIA UI ipc OAGLSJJ LSUG 01, bucca -

bJA/Aooq (bSUGJ s) suq cotton apcG(!u (BSUGJ p)' SJ2O 2JJOtA tJIG moat ASLIS(IOU In (JIG qGna!(!Ga sctoaa

anbborj (JIG UOUbSLSWGILJC Ga(IUJSt!01113 BIG (MO btoqncta ffiutJI (JIG JI!WJJCa( (J!abCLaiOI? pnqooq

cpoacn to absu mc act LOW JIJJI (0 JO/A cJ!abGLa!OIJ suq PGCSII2C (JIG1 jisq 2IltLIc!GUI OP2GLAS(!OIJ2 tO

cotton 2JIGGApI ptesq counsicq poxc& tcsql-mpccq couctc(c snq saojwc- jpcaG btoqncta MGIG

u8citca 15-11, &sbp (JIG catnnstcq qcu2qca tot b t cscp lest ot pnqooq bjAMooq

MG!JI( (liSt ASL!Ga WtCt2CJ1 w IJIGJL (JJ2tSIICG tom W

ont2qc 01, (JIG psnqMiq(JJ Ste 1AGII if /AG!JJ( 01, SGLO MJI!JG W0 EA!tJI!U (JIG pSuqMq SLG !AGU if

exocuonal abcctjcq psnqft4qqJ \t 05 Gscp 0meV snq seto opcuti2c jpia unbpca qni C2CLASflOU2

n' incuou %(.') Ja sn piqcsot IfiUCUOU (pSi irc mc ASJflG OUG !t t' * snq sic

%e(1% = - , x( t' * -wCaS

antmirnpon !a (ifJCGU OAGL sj bisnie !u AGst V hOE vY MG 112G me EbifIIGcpuucoA (IoQo) rcLucJ:

MJIGLG u xa Sn otqctcq AGc(oL Oj, nounspscq ontbnr bLJcca' vj !a mc rctuci wuon snq w

=E' ?(w.—tux)

Page 10: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

2

WG bLOqIICR !U b306J2 (s) suq (j)

OWG 0J Wi WpJgA mBA 2!UJb1A tcijccr usc iscr wr we 2swbfc 2SC2 ill CACI) ACVL HIG jgLgcL IOL WC2Q 4911L btoqrtcr

jpc bjifut cpooac2 Lucc jo wnw!sc bLopt pA cdnsuu IuifLiuifJ LOACUUC suq WifLJTJifJ COSt BOW fiG

irnidirn qricLcucwtcq bLoqnce 1,ifcplt if qcunuq cjsatrniA 1,OL ! bLoqncI o \" suq WifL!Uifj COat irJ

I OLQGL to CiftGOL1SG fiG IZICCIA BOflLCG2 01, Lace AifLIif(!01J ifBBIIUJC Gscj.i bjsist btoqncca s

9TJJOIJ bJifilta AGI2flB AGSL-abcc!11c !q!oaAucwr!c q1,1,GLcUccr

bcuoqa JU OUL iftif ifuq WGifBITLG tO Mint GXCGUt fIG Lace fft1,GLGCG2 LGIJGCt bcuinucuj UUJG-IUASL!ifIJt

tomifLq flUqGLawUqW fiG BOIILCG 01, fIG CLO22-BGCt!OIJif! qabGI2OU thfl cxbjoit c wnitthjc tune

apocjca OL WGSBIILGWGUI OL LGbOI.q118 GLLOL2 Ill tuG ASJflC OL dnsuptl oj, 2p!bmGuta q&rr V IJLBt ash

COata SaaOCSGq ttitp CJJVU&1U& LLICCa qnt LGVIJt in LLOqIICGL2 tcabouqus qiuci.cunA to coat oi. qcunuq

bLoqnccL2 qctciicca !U tJJG COWbGt1I1AGUGB 01, OlTtbflt WSLJCGtB 5CL022 bLoqnccLa cxbpcit sql.sTatuJdut

2GBLCjS C02t2 pA COU2IIUJCL2 mpcp CS!) GUGLZtG Lute pabctaou CACTI intp iqdupcsu C02i2 sctoaa

u bioqiictiou coata SWOU bjsuta tInt SW bsmA ot pqjA bsaacq ou tO C0U20WGt2 P!P

iot jpie mqnquit AnWtou u dnsJ!A tt a 1101 csbrntcq pA q OLGUCCB u tpc bioqnct qctju!qou'

acCt!OinJ ASLWtJOU ! bjsnt orrtbnt bucca si cAcr.A borut p1 tpuc JJIGLG SLC wsnA boaaipjc cibusintrone

0Ac1511 tSJDJG T sug UULG J mqicsic CJGSLJA W51 1,OL I1 01, W bLoqncie IJJGLG 12 CL022-

2111 bLoqncja

2AWUIGtL!C q!BtL!pflt!OtJR suga 52 2CC!) 1" tifPJC J IflAG tile JOMG2t OACLSjJ JGACfB 01, qiabctaioii 5WOIJ LJJG2G

IJJGLG SLG 20mG 0J WSLJCGi2 MUJJ couaiatciitjA P!PGL Lacer COUCLGtG SUf if2OjIUG Ste WOW

LLOqIICCLB BOW 01, tpcac LLOq1TCt2 SLG aojq u Bins jj C0Lifbp!C WSLICGIB if uq 1G 2JCGMIJG22 corijq ifuac ft

C0LLI15tGq 0)1G2 12 btcacuj III CAGA Acsi IUCI!CSqII fiC COIJBJ2tGIJL LLG2GUCC 01, BOWG P!P-bL!cG

2IWSL 5CL022 fIG qifleLcut AGSLr13 flJ bifLt!C015L tPG 2JCGMIJGB2 01, tJiG qduaItIGa 1,OL )LGVCj SIJq

jpc Lcwsiuiu bLoqrictz U bsucp (c) qnonp (001, f&ILG j apoa Lace qenagica fiSt SLG mote

o bate qiabctaiou O2GLAGf 1,OL tpIa btoqricr

Page 11: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

stint lsvsl-lsAism lo sausQsd sath bus aiuslq aao'ios ass tao3 1sthism bus nouasIs basrnsb

315 1Ei11 2)130112 si1sisg'aoibj bus ,(') strut isvo sgnsils iou ob tsilt aiototh siiosqa-luslq t( 'a) 2133113

:az nsflnw od IIZ3 sonq iuqiuo a'inslq sib lo go! silT .(?) boiisq stall bus iuslq £ ot ailiosqa

•3 + + = 'D1lUt\ + (çt\tt')M =

10 asgusilo sonq Iuqui uommoo ot sub alaoo ml asgnsdo as agniilt tloua tosfisi aiotosl lovol 13)115111 silT

bsxil ots 1w! aiuslq aaoioc '(isv taut 2101351 tssflsi Iliw silT .loubolq sill iol busmsb ls±ism ml ailida

aisouboiq guoma ti1sup touboiq cxl asonsisThb sbulsni aso aiclT .smll svo '1wo1a 'ISV sgustlo 10

ts)hsm Isool sill lo aasusvititsqmoo sill cii asoriaisThb 10 1octsioi1Is sviisuboiq cii assnerislith lnsl2insq

s istls lath aiotosl gursv-smii ha tosllsi 111w 2)130112 ottsiou'aoibi silT astsisqo tuslq sill ilaidw ml

bsvisado silt ml noin gnthoqsi lo tuismsiuassm as hlsw as 'gioctasls bnsrrisb 10 taos lsiiigism atiis1q

Itos1isq slguia £ ml ii guihlsa bus touboiq Isoitusbi us grnouboiq sis atnslq sIsfIw saso sill aT .asoilq

nisflsq tsth aiotosl ls)hsm d '1no bsnislqxs ed bluoda asonq bs'nsado usd1 tsiism iuqtuo svnusqmoo

.uoitshsv soriq lsvsl-tuslq cxi Iluasi tsilt ( ) 810115 uoilsgsiggs 10 tusmsiuassm bus ) 1ss'( tailt ml

-32013 us bus mon gniaiis asoiiq ml asousistlib lnslq-usswtsc! tasusmisq iol slrn on sd bluoila sisilT

oth aasaas 111w oW .210115 guitioqsi bus insmsvjassm tosflsi bluoila asoriq cxi noitsiisv lsiioitosa

a thod ihiw omit isvo uoilsiisv sonq taslq-nithiw auaisv noilsiisv sonq taslq-usswtsd Ia socxsfloqcm

.smit isvo arnottsq gnisriq lsvs(-tnslq lo soustaiaisq sib no soasbivs bus noiliaoqmoosb ssnsrisv

iii floilsilsv iuslq-aiilhiw bus -usswlsd lo inuoms silt lioqs1 shdst lo aumuhos owl iaiil silT

noiaisqaib taswol ot lasdgirl mon sldsi sib nwob gaivom 321jq .tusbivs sis azrxsitsq lsisvs2 Mç

a 2E b3bubni ion 8Th 2101321 Iavsl-isAisin IlOffltflOQ 02 153'( sf323 at soiiq nzsm onlsmoag sift lao alan §1(1511Ev aisfI' lo zsdmun llama oil lo oausoad bobubni ion sis ,ana nil bus 23iidal 100w ,aiaubrnq owT .'Qiltdshsv sohq lo soiuoa

.aldslisvs auzisa-smul liosla sift 10 amoilansado

Q

Page 12: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

To

c&rcotrsrn mc imbotwucc oj, iLncwj uq wIJqom jpaoa !u 8cucLsphJ Lute qithciaiow

bjsw OAGL qwc 1C UCfl 2f1p2CCtiO11 MC 21111111191!SC We IJJC-2CL!Ca LCL2!atcuc; ouc asA Oi(.

OL qcurnuq 20CJC2 OL Line WCSi1LCUJCU cuoLae tJJcIJ £JJCLC 2OJ1J J)C 110 bcLaircucC ! W Lff1JJCW2 O

91J2C2 aojcjA jLOW LJSUt-JGACJ pocjce mr sic not cLwJJA C0LLCJtC OAGL IuJC 211CJJ qo2AucLfc coat

jocsuou rn mc LL!cc q!atL!pnqou apoajq tciiq to bciarat OACL 1fl11C in cousa' i mc LL!cc AnispquA

mc dnffjfl o s bjsnr, a ontbnt 01. CIJjCCIJCA qnuwc ijrnt mc bjut wsX psAc mc a

oACI. I!UJC Lute pcjcLocIJciA niaca p.om ancwwj pctota qrnr sic ajo to cpwc atci. jJuic ancp

bLoqncr JJJG2C tMO aOffLCCa JJSAC c!uCLCUt iubjrcspoua Y0L c BCL2!2tCIJCC oj, qic bJffuc-JcAcJ bsucum

qffjcLcur cowpmspou o bcwrnucut pcunccu-bjsut qicLcucca 9uq cfloaXucwqc iycroa oL ccp

J)f3jC 5 !UIICIC2 IjiSt tile CL022-2cCr!O1Th q2bcI2ou op2cthcq ill tBPIC I suq iftntc I 9142C2 om

cucwt1ug bL!cc q!2LCL2!0W

LOfC 0L rUflc-ASLAWg qcwsuq 01. coat couqxpoua t c Ljwt JcAcJ 2 MGJJ S2 uoiac to bjsA S LOJG !

ow ASLISU0n sa w pctfficcu-b!sut LUte qccuccr LOL rpcac bLoqacta qiCLC a s botcnpsj?1 slteL

p0XC slig ucmaLuur) ot wow (coJ1Icc osjc uooLw conCLcfc aoumooq LjAitooq sug saojiic) to

tcwvuw btoqsrct& t!UJC-2cuc2 ASLWtIOIJ !U CSCJJ bjsut,a bL!cc coutU!prltca n wimp (;tcsq' counsicq

natp jnc bcuxrnucur qccucca p1 qcurnuq c1321!c!t!ca OL UJSLI1JSJ 002t2 sctoaa bjsuta EOL tile

JCACf ¶UCLCU2 SOLOn blsura SLC fJJc UJS]OL 200LCC 0j cLOa2-acctlou Lute ASiWflOW JJJI2 !2 COUaiatcIJt

mc pctfficcu-bJSut ASL!Succ ! jSLGL m' ti1c NJWW-blsut nuvucc rnqicsjrn qist bcujjsucu bucc-

LLoqnctv EOL tile tjmcc ppcat qraLctnou LLoqncjr pnqmooq L}AMooq' bojAcatcv snq cogou wpuc

qccpuca wimp WOW LSbiqjA mu mc M!tppI-bwut ASL!succ Aon WOAC uw pp to q!abcIa!ou

bimita aug i tiusc-acuca Anisflou rn Lucca OL cifeji bjsur 2ccoug' mc pctMccu-bJSut nuaucc

LLoqncta potp AflwzJCca qccpuc anpatsutwjjA uqcSqu 2WSJJCL qcLducc2 p1 tpc sAcLS8c Lute 901.022

Page 13: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

H

V i"t '-21 PC ! ob;ijgou U t/AO sqisccut CCU2IT2 ACn2 tO PC !UtIflQt(I !U tP2 C!JCffjfiOU2

cAiqour j1t2t' mc bLopsp!J!tli oJ LGWøuJu p!p-bL!cc bwqnccL !2 &CstCL tpsu monjq pe U'qcsucq pli

bo0112!U LJL2t on mc £L&112OU LStG2 O Jii-bticc bLoqnceLa U' cO!IIUJIJ2 J3a /O bucuj2

nor Lclccueq

bLobogion !2 2Tthsluc5IsqA qIjctdul 5 OL 5 LcJeAøur rniq qcuoic 032dB 1AJICIG mc plibomcna !2

Jpe anne bsgctn aponjq pe opaettcq ps cojonine -Q suq 00J1I111112 ffiG tear ipsu GCJI subjc

lien siscj IF UL coJmJJIl Oj Wpjc 3 2JI011J(I pe 52 me ccouq cojrnzm 2' suq mc rjtrnj cojfluilu •5

mst } =oe men mc bLopp!J!tli ° c°M U' usiA dclsu!Ic U' lien t + \ J2 U'qcbdnqcnt o1 mc jocspou U'

V2 psaJ2 J9L combstaon !t II btce Afl!ut!0u M!tPU' AesL !2 qoc to qJoaliucLffqc 2p0cJ2 20

in liens. LGIJJ5IIJG(I mcLc U'

donutca U' lion j o bcwcut tcwsiucq mc.c in lien t+ y vio Q3 5 bciccur oj tile lom-bL!cc bjauta

bucc qiaupngon suq onA bctccut puq tpjcu £0 mc iot drtnuijc o bsuta w we nJ!qqje uto

n me ppcat bucc dnniJc2 Aena NGL j beiccut psq qtobbcq to mc unqqjc tmo dnnqjca oj m

sjj pnqmooq bjlimooq bloqoceLa w tJJ ppear bL!cc drwr.qjc U' 00112112 lien t 83 2 betcent LCIIJ3JIJG(I

mLq dnnqjce 01 m btcc CJi2uLij)fltiOU !ntO 2rnJd cstcotA JJJC UL2t LO/A 0 m tpjc !uq!051c2 msu

otpct dnnqjca in qic 1:oflom!n ceuana licn jo 2PIJbJ!I2i mc tupjc mc jisc ffLGEtC(I mc accouq unq

mp!cp mcli mete jocstcq U' ccnna lien suq men Lcbol.j2 mc bLobouJon mut WOAG to cscp 01: mc

Anlsucca tebotucq U' jspjc 5• jppje 3 q!asLcstca biunra pA me dclnu!Jc oJ, mc bL!cc qiatLJpnuJon JIJ

jjicac rLSIJR!t!On L51c2 SLO JG2 JIJCCJli to pe succucq pli 21115JJ mcsantcwcn 01. tcbown CLL0L2 ms" mc

11391 21101n1n15c IF uJoAcuJeut 01: bjsuta smou qxjjctcnt dnstqjca o, tpc bL!cc qiatuprnion (ThL t!mc

ffiC exbjotc qic bcLa!atcucc u qie ontbni bqcc qs2tupnhiouB pA comzincpn 1L3132!t!On 1133tL1002

11 U' b4cM b91$1.U2

Page 14: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

IS

DUG 10 2UWfl UUWpGL OI 02GLA!fT0U2 ip; bLopspu!r!G 40L tt.O0J bbflGJ 1yL!C2 ftc uot bicciacjA c2punfcq

OACLJJ We LL9IJ2IflOU LSjC2 piqcsic mote bcLaT2tcucc ! tJJC LSUJCW o bjw bucc2 W !2

sis qic nbbct W!Ja O ¶C bL!CC q!rpnqoIr

WifU 5? LLffIJ2!t!01J2 0111 O JOM-BLICC CS1eOQi SIC jao he VJJA meptcq onstq jpe unqqjca LSIIJCL

iI WC JOMC2 huce drrngijc 2 ACSL2 J91Ct VII 0j 1J102C ILSIJ2IUOU 1StC SIC IJ!Uc9UtP q!ueLeut

dcwtpjc o qsc bce qiacupnqou ii ACSL r petmecu 3g g betceui (saojpie) uq 3 BCLCCUC (uemabuut)

we &!ce qiarupntou suq oL ouc btoqnct mc btopvpijiuc2 Ste ednç ymou tpe bpijie u me jottcat

bL!CC2 J10L g 0j tile T 3 bLoqnctr HAG Ot fIG btoqnci2 JJS/IG II!PCt bLopffp!ptA ojbjSur2 mOA1u nb pi

cgtcor.Aa e btopffp!Jfl 0j WOA11J to jomet btcca ía LeS1eL 111911 tpe btopffpqrtA ot mOArn to pxpct

onjq pe Weuentcq pX wuqom bqcc moAcmeutr JjpL b1snja fISt WOAG ont O4 me miqqc-buce

bioqncit suq fIG qpjetcuce a 2í1lfljC91U tot 1CAG1J Oj tile btoqnct? uqcstm ulOLc bet teuce (p511

111 P!W 2t00C JIG btopspqfl o temp1u w we mqqje-btice cSTCoLA excecqa R ot sii

hG 03112!t!OU L91G2 J0t bjSut2 HSU BL!cea pi me miqqe tno dnstjqc2 oJ me bqcc qtqp'u"

bticiu bggctur

qatupnriou aneata IJIST atLflCtrlLSJa LSfICL tJJSIJ bliLeji qoaAuctsuc tOLC6 SIC 91 M04C UI qC1eUJ1J11UI

WO1JJ file BL!CC qlauipnpou OACL 1!We' IPC bet2iajeucc ot bjsuta !l w il!&J1-bL!cG bnt ot we

JOM buce dnsuijc J0L IJIC ttffIJ2!t!012 10 pe qute ?oj€IA pA tuuqom ycior ff.Jlqe b!suta c1enjk mote

cteotA btcqomm&uqA mate uto e miqqjc o1 we bqcc qattpntou put tnt too te/ls IUGAe !U10 me

cstcotA !2 2flpatSUtiSJJA jeaa fIsu 52• .LP!2 iuibjica m' ipe bLoquceLa 1p91 IJJOAG 0111 OJ fIG pPbt!ce

dnstpjea qoea UOt qqer. ai8iIiucSutjA tLOUJ •2 Mil!IG we bLOPSPIJIA Oj UI0/U 11110 fIG JO/A buce

2 ecouq5 ot msuA oJ m tpeeu bLoqnctr we bLopspptA oj moAJu to m mqqjc n1o

g3 jrntqmooq bJAMooq hOt SJJ oj, e btoqnct2 W tU!t!OU LSIC !2 a!U!t!cS1ItIA qctern ms"

tile LSU0W IJJOAGWGUj 0j buccv JIG bLopapqgA ASL!c2 pom s jO/A Oj 3g oi saojrnc to s JI1JJ oj

Page 15: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

flqcwsuq OL btoqnct dnsiiO quJcLcucG si wc bisur ICACI siq IPCLC SLC ACLA WM OL ACL) 2111!JJ iqzo2AuCLsfic 2OCfC2rpc p PC2t lCCi oIbLicc ba2!2ICUCC St IIIC bISIJI ICACI' t 2fl22C2t2 filE bLIOC C4I2bCL2!OU SL!2C2 IJOUI 2111B11 bcL2!210u1 COlt'

jyc ouc lgounucuf cxcbfrou 10 UJ!2 COUCJII2IOU !2 IJCInbLIUL nJ! bLoqaci p52 flic Jo/ACaL OACLsJJ bLics qilbCL2iou PIlL

cojmue Oj LPW 5 E GACA bLoqnct mc pctmccu-bjsut 2Sc A514511011 12 !SLCL tSIJ W totS! MItIIITJ-

m!tP!u-b!sIJi iqio2AucLsiic A9t!541011 ! 2!SC 0L IJJC bLoqncta 111 tjqa awQ 12 amnUJsLiscq ! m JS2t tmo

qcmuq 01. C02f 2JJOCJC2 OACL t!mc JJJC 1U1b0145UCC oj bcr.wsucut pcuAcdu-bfsut 2JXC GLGUCC2 ACL2II2

comppnqou o bcuusucut q1JcLducc2 u coa or. bLoqnctyqQ GUtCCU bLoqnccL2 suq lqo2XucLsnc

JJJCOLCUCSJ woqcja o rnqnarA CAO}IUjOIJ ogcu 8CIJCLSIC qucLcucc in bLoqnccL asc w s

C O"th"t EL!CC2 suq bL0flCCL 2!Sc

tcqnctiou in mc r.cjsptc mjbogrnjcc o bcuxrnucut to iqoaAucr.spc Anrffqou !u mc bncc qsw

,ujboi.tsur JJJC Lcqnctou u tOIffJ ql2bcL2oU S2 Etc IJJOAC qoitu tP iama Wpjc2 j suq 5 IC2flJt2 JLOW S

EttP Jqo2?wc1sflc poqce put LStJJCL OUC2 /*JJCW 2cLsJJ)i-C0LtcSCq 2IUICWLSJ WCIOL2 51.6 11101.6

qoacjA sbbLoscp r.suqom .110126 JJJ2 anc2ta iPt br.oqnca MUJJ JSI2GL bce q2bcL2ou 51.6 lOt 0102

004U COIJCLGjG' 2oMooq bjAitooq' snq Esaopuc JJSAG J622 bcL212cucc suq tLSU2jtioU 1.9102 tpst WOLO

tJJG tJJLCC 1SpLC bLoqnctae suq !U 6513W JU CIJCLSJ' fiG JOMCL qi2bGr2iou btoqrrct2 ancp 52 cocc osjc

P!P02t J0L fIG bLoquct2 Th!iJJ 1110 JSLC2 OACLVJJ J0A0J2 O bUCG qi2bcLaiou ancp 92 pscjmooq bjAMooq'

(cojr 5' suq ) sctoaa br.oqncte' one sqqipousj bsucui 12 ciuqcur qcLcc o bcL212t01c0 12

jicu cowbnrn c bLopsppqc2 O LCIJJSWJU 1 fl 291116 dnswjc o giG bucc qiaaipntiou

fIG qatpngou 12 too aWSII

I2t4flfOU a 100 }flG LGJStMG to r.snqom cpsilcc' uuq tIle br.opspqxA O WOAW to c Ogler. 15!! oj,

opacr.tcq in bngcrrjsr.' mc br.opsptA o Lcmsw!u 11' w p!pcat or. jomcat dflsuJJc o, tpc br.icc

sCtOL2 tint CJJSIJWG 2JOMJA GAOL 1!IUG SLG Lc2bon2!pJc OL 20mG o IpG hUGO j1c1CL0cIJc!A 11191 12

cona!2fcnt !tP bnr.cjA iqio2XUcLstzc ajJoCjc2 Rcucr.spn buce qthcL2iou suq 2flc2j tpsc 2tLflGWwI

Page 16: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

lasal 1s 10 .lnansirnaq iol aloi insrioqmi fiB gni3saibfli nel lo iotosl a d aaaso amoa iii flOflSitBV lnsiq

nail flvfl3ubo1q 10 3512 Jnslq thiw balsI5no3 ala aaonq iuqiuo II .aaonaiaThb asia ,gnivlova tlwola

mifions ad 'sm anoitoaa owi aiD ni balnarnu3ob aeanq niqflo ni aonaiaiaiaq bits 'Oianaoiatad aiD

.asia ni aa3nalaluib lflalalalaq aalnsriag isdil aaeooIq gni1iobnu aiD Io flOIlslaaIrnsm

3iqluo oi balslai l1aoi3sma1aa ad 111w asia inalq lath 33qaua 03 &it02531 Iaiavaa 315 aiailT

lluaai £ as tawo1 ad 'sm aaonq iiath nail alatsm aviiilaqmo3 aioin ,iagis! 3'fl32 alflslq lagIsI II .aonq

315 (adl aws3ad lathia ,alaoo noiialJbolq iswol avail ainslq iagisl II .noililaqntoo beasal3ni ai!l lo

(EVQI) siaamaU) aiaasiloiuq o3 no baaasq ad 'sm aaarb ,aaifflOflOO3 ats3a liolqxa £153 10 lnaiailla alOffi

lallama aihiw aloubolq basibisbnsla ,auoanagocnoi iiav a3ubolq airislq iagisl 11 .((VVQI) nsmsi!a bits

asia illiw 'isv '(Sm aa3hq bus alaoo nath ala)hsm ad3th a'naa bus aiouboiq 1si3aqa aiutosluusm alnslq

.((O8Q1) 1anoq ,

(VVQI) iano bus aavsD)

basilsimon a'tiIslq aiD lo go! aiD aaaigai aw qudanoilslai asia-a3ilq suqluo aiD asiismmua oT

bus 153'( ni bsts3oI 21 lflslq aiD ilauilw flu slitisup asia aiD iol aaldsrisv 'mrnnb no t aohq luqluo

asia lns!q aiD lo aaliilsup aaoios aa3nq nsam lo '(lilsupa aiD lo alaal oiflamaisq alquiia laubnoo

aaath ni Js aldsl cii barioqat 315 ansam lo 'fllaiips 101 aiaal bits allua5i ftOiaaalgal silT .noiluditaib

tatho edT .alitisup asia laallsma aiD iii aohq usain sib aiuaaaiqai bus lqaoialni sib ai A anoiaaaigai

,lnth wocla Alo ealscmlaa silT .aslthsup ngtsI saiD aD tol aiD mon anoilsivab 3naaaiqai alnaiofllaoa

lfls3ilingia aiT usam aiD avods aanq svsd naouboiq laallsma aiD .aiii!oasg lo noiiqaaza aiD iDiw

a3hq usam aD iii amloab insoilingia '(lisoilailsIa £ alsoibth alnaioffiaoo teibo aiD ml aaisruilaa sviisgan

%noiilsdlaib esk agiT .nas' Ha aarnos ban3ado aI,v81 luqluo 1581 to noirudiflaib eth moil bal3irIianoo 315 aelitIaUf) silT ' thse milhiw anoiisvieado ailT .aatsupa 1253! bojilgiaw diiw bahsmilaa am anokaalgsl SilT .flSa'( auaiiso aaoias aidsia '(ISV 315

au ni eufgiow 3imnaqa-alinsup as bow au oaodi bus olinsup oth nithiw noilsivab bmbnM2 ad! alsmilas 03 baau aus a!itisup

- .20012231gM

Page 17: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

buccmc qcuJBiJq 014 mc UCffL-pA R2CL2' WCfl WCLC WBA PC bCt2!21C1J1 bL!CC PC1CL0CUC!A Act no C0LLC!StioiJ pGIMCCU V bJsur,2 2!SG ViJq

ontbnt p. Vfl C021 iq bqcc pcteLoeue!A fl!2C2 vj Ipe IJLUI' WWGL gpVn bjuc JGAGJ n we 2ISC 04, csu hIVUR isiteiX LGLJGCI2uiwa• cvii bfaut2 tcuq to pe COIIRLLITCLCq 11C9L c iOtt!0U 04, mc 4poq bLocc22iut OL pcAetdc bjur qnt Mlii bnicpgac pica

C9U2 12 IIUII2Iflj pccgne mjiijc LJJCLC Vie V JVLC UI1WGL 04, bjsutv meA SiC A!LVJWJJA VJJ onicq pA S 2W511 UflWpCL 04.

bLoqnct2 aLnqieq JJLCuonbgLgwciuc tCLC2210U2 04, buce 0U ontbnt' MJJ!CP cJGSLjA !11n21L5(C ipe neStiAc CL022-2CC1101flJ COLLCjVLIOU' 10L 211 014mGct022-2G001m1 2se-bucc Lcstiou2p!b itpicp 12 znwumuscq 111 npc lcopcl.p unq anbum (j) bLoAiqe bicfms2 04, mcIIJG 21se ¶4.14GLGVCC2 SiC 20 bCL2I2ICUI 0ACL 11I1JC It 12 niiweiA mr ontbng WGS2flLCIJJCUI CLLOL2 bjsA s WCmc wcsantcq OIUIXIt JGAJ IUcLGS2CV flCCSR2C IIJC tine CL022-2GC1!OIJVI 21Se ASLflt!0IJ J2 20 JSLtC EU We WS1Jft4,SCwuIJ qstW gyqmoijc 1° mc obbo2irc qitectiorn JJJC unIJiu1qc 0 me p152G2 Miii CttGU2G 52 w LifilO 014 WC ASLISIJCC 04, mc tine orttbnt JCACJ towuoqncc V 2bnLIon2 IJGVUAC cOLLCJVBOIJ petMecu buce sizq OITtIMIt 14. tiJC title ontbnt c0e4.IjcIeiJt 12 ucSflAc meu mc jmo P!2c2con2tLnctcq 52 mc 1.5110 OJ flJflG 04. 2pfbUSCUt2 10 ontbrii 20 W1 WGS2nLGUICIU CLLOL2 HJ OntbIIt Ste usu2wlueq to buce 511(4

cxbjgimtotA AniSpJc 511(4 A1i p152 WG COG4,IjCiCUt ou ontbiit tostq tC10 pG 2couqPI2 fl!2e2 tom me sct mgi btice 12if L6 2npleCt to uto 2OULCC2 04. p102 JJIC LjL2i 12 me wuquq CLLOL-IU-AVLiVpJC2 P152 IPSI LG2ffff2 4,LOIJJ WI2IIJGS2RLeWGIJ4 04, SI!

jpc n2e oi dnsgi1c Lcte7210112 ! L0Pfl%t tO WCSSflLGWCUt GLL0L% 111 OnIbIII 2uzble LGLs22!ou2 014bisut buce on ontbnt

bjsnt bcLa2 OAGL t!UIC suq ¶C CACJ o1, s bjffu,2 ontbnr bucc 2 Uct1AcJA C0LtCJfGq "4W tP bjsut.a

op2ctAcq cL022-2cct0USJ bqcc ASLIStIOU !2 uot 2iwbjA suqow uo!?c D!acLcUccs us onthrn bucca sctos

OACLSJJ q2bcL2011 JJJcaC uqiu jJII4JJCL LCRJ1,OLCC tJJG COUCJfTSIOU 01, qJC mci ona 2CCf IOU tJ1S W

110 VUJJJCS1Jt 2!Sc-bL!cc COLLCISI 01? S20J1UC suq UCMSBLIUt SIC tpc tThO 1,014 /AJJICIJ JJGLC 2 AGA jifljc

zccjJoU ontbsrt buccs GCJIUG "4W bjsut 21S9 1,oL tcu o qic tpizjccu bLoqnctr aiio 01, WC bLoqnciz mup

135A9 Aatcwsvc bucc qccpucs tpst couunc UCLO22 tIJC MjJO jC 2!G q!tL!prn!0w OAGLS 11 !'J LIJC CL022-

bAMooq cogou 2pcctrn coimstcq poxc2 SUq cOIJCICtc• fIG LG2IIJI2 iJqcStc tJm JC2C 1,OIIL btognct2

nrc jncat t0 dnsgqce pmc cdrwj bLIccs ('cf =k Lclcctcq 1,014 1,OflL Oj, qic bLoqnciz pnqooq

(\=ç =\f) LP! pXboqica2 ! tcl•cctcq 1,OL g o, tpc jo bLoqnctr EwSlJA tpe pAbotpcan wtbisuta u

tpc rnqnatA pA tcauu qm bJsnt2 P qic 1LGC JSLgG2t dusuilca pate stcwc BLJCC2 tpsi SLC cdcisj

!u bJSU xc jjc ucxj teat c pAbotpcan wt nrc bLice qqjcLcucca 5142G oujA 1,014 w usijcat bisuta rn

OACLSJJ bqcc qabcLaou j13C LCWSIIJ!u8 j hoqncra Sjj 213GM 2!WIJ!UCSUt bL!CG (JGCflUC2 4W uCLGSC2

bLOCJ1ICI2 crccbt iw C51J2' tsaojruc sUq I3GM2bL11t fIG JSUCL it0 5146 fIG bLoqncta m!tp W IOMG2t

tcatcq sUg w b-aw1!at!c a tcboutq w cojmnu o tpc tspic jpc pThotpcaia !2 tclccicq 1,014 VjJ

LPC jJAbOqIcaIa tpst we mesu bucc a COU2WIJt 5CL022 tPG 1,0014 dnsr.tqca (t =='%"=o) !a

5CL022 (JIG 2JXG q!atLpnt1owJ

Page 18: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

'1th3ilsm3ta1a 'cay ataoo noit3ubolq isthedw OitlfflEXS ow noit3sa inn 343 itT .noiiasa-aaoio ath iii osia

all bits asiiq iuqiuo lo msflsq lscioitosa-aaon oth iol noiisnslqxs oldiaaoq ono as aiiislq aaoi3s

.30113 iovo oonoiaiaioq

teoD IsnigisM 1svsJ4wd .111

111 '3isnaoioia4 od laum 'olofxogololocI soiiq lo noiisnslqxs 'fls lo Jrnnoqmo3 instioqrni ciA

4oisoaoi aith lo tisq aA .noiaioqaib soiiq k asthma Laoliiqms izom moil iiisacls al stab iaoo i3'( i203

bsi3trIianoo bits stab lonsq lavol-inslq oth niau alabom noiioitiiI 3203 boismitas ovarl ow 33oo1q

oth bits aoohq 103351 cii asonsiollib nu3oofloi iso' bits inslq 'd '0" 3s43 3203 laufi3Iscn lo aslamitas

ois stab inomilaildatas 2112fl33 sill lo aouanotoslsd3 ouprnn lslovoe .tuqtuo tnslq lo xlm bits loyal

.iuqtuo ono nath siom oouboiq atnslq Ha '(llsufliv iaiFl .23203 noitouboiq ni1obom iol insiioqml

03 20 bsol bhsow tbina ow 'çoo3so touboiq oth cxi ion ai lath inslq silt lo iuqloo oth gnhoni '1qml2

asw iuqiuo boiiicno oth 134304W no gnibnoqsb bns iuqtuo tnalq Istot oismliaoisbnu 'ilsoi3ama3a'a

to biswqu ot bad 111w ,ni boiaoiotni 31.6 OW iuqiuo 343 cljiw boislaiioo (13Vii5aii 10 '1oviiiaoq

istho Its lo atnomqula silt otsgoigs ow aith iol trniooos oT .aiotamsisq olsoa ni asid biswnwob

lovol-'claubni its 431w aith otaflob ,ioqnto 'çtabnoosa e1nia a olni tnslq sill ni bomloalucism atouboiq

sis ow bnooo2 .alsbom t203 toiiboiq itlum too cxi Ioitnoo Isnoilibba its as ii obu[3ni bits xobni oonq

sea) slab oiokm 41kw asirnonooe sIsoa baa '(flYl ouboiq lo lasmaiuasam eth iol anoilsoilqmi asrl oak gaibait airif grifl lo salt', sill gaitalleb '(4 beloanlanoo ai liiqluo Issi aaoilitoilqqa leom at

. ((ÔQQI) aerloilnO baa efleIA baa (QQ1) ilodclA

eeilqcai alnaiq eglal 101 iawol 31S asong tuqluo lath gaibail ,uO .xsbni eoiiq lsvel-yiiaubai flOitliflOO '(4 ainemqida laalq 10 .llacne ot evualal nsoubolq °v 10 'ivilouboiq baa Iuqluo sift slarmlasisbitu 11kw totaftab sOIiq aommoo £ lo 321J ath lath

eth to asOilq 541 alosltsi '(18181I1305 lolaflab ltiqliio sift Ii asibiila lavsl-'t1aiibiii iii isdwsmoa belagilim ad '(am mstdotq aidT

.eau tuqak baa luqluo 'Cuaubni lo AIU4 eu ioI lnuoooa [Liw '(541 sofia aieouboiq sgmL

esiismcnua '(lqmia 111w ow siad baa (3421) aaiqua iii bsdiioaab 318 alabom noiloaift 1200 sift lo aliflsb slslqmoo sill' .abothsm noilami lee baa lebom ath 1o eloaqea laafloqmi emOa

lo atevel isilgid evad 01 bast eluslq egial eauaosd balaIaTIoo '(lsvilieoq ed 11kw luqluo bebuloni bits ballimo eu lateiteg iii beasid biswqu auth baa aaoiaaslgol aoitoaul 3203 iii luqluo no ia,ioiIIsoa ath iii asid lnswqu as 01 basl 11kw easilT .aiuqiuo thod

.1200 lanigiam lo eslamnas

bl

Page 19: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

U

OL qCCLCS2C !W bimz 21tCpA cotbowuoij OL 19L20 ULW2 11410 CSU poaon. St JOMCL !11t©LC21 L51C2 ft t11!2 !2 LUIC WU tP© mcnntcmcut iS2 conjq !UCLC52c2wSjJ suq JsLEc bjsutr p bLscricc mc bLIcC 0% cvbrwj 12 jqccjA to qcqiuc miip bjsut sc pecsnc SLG bjmue SW ogen oMuagOflL nuq;Lc211u151c 0 J01J2-LflIJ WWLtpJSf p41! !IJCLS2C !MiJJ bjsut 2!SC JY!2 !2 ILUC 522flW!U cSbij5J bucce SW igGutics! %01.

a jnci bjsup JJSAC moLe cubitsi !UWU2!AC ret 0J021c2 OJIL !U5P!1!O (0 WC!2flLC csbiwi cXbGUqitflLC2 111G5U2

onrbnr siiq' !U jJJG 1JCXI 2CC{IOI? 52 511 sqqipousj ASLISPIC tO cxbjsiu IlflLJ(flb qIcLCucc2 5CL022 bisuir

WC poojc ajiie 0% WC bJsur,2 csbirsj in 2CAGLSI 1A5A2 pi tPC C02t moqcj !t 12 I12C 52 511 iU2tiflWCUtS! AflIspjC lot, mc bjsut2to coinruict bcthcumj-TuAcuroLA csbiruj 2tocJc2 1.;OL wor 0J mc bJsuL2 !u mc asnsbjcr c qo ITUpIC we snqspjc !IqoLurnqou on!2 ciicsjjX OIIJX cocctcq 1.;OL pt2c bjsurz ou su sulinsj p5212 (s butt oi.; qJc Nuust tnjQ o\flcstni(,c1qrns%) ! nor bo22!pJcCOIJltOJ j9L bo22IpJC qCLCUCc2 !U tSb!tSl C0212 pCLMCGII 2!tJtjC SIJq IJJllJti-bJslJt boqnccv Vt20' CCWf12C IUAC2rWCUr U0 qsrsABLISpJC2 suq OWCL coulboucur2 o mc 2CLAICS bLICS' me ijj iucjnqc SI) 0ttUCL2pib-AbC A5LI5)C UI mc C021 ltiuCIlou ujoqcj tocouerLncr bjsurjcicj 2CLMCC bucc2 4L csbiwj rpsr sqcdnstcjA tctjccjcq bjsur-JoAcJ ASUSflOU lu c obboi.uiurrA C02t O puIq2' in

e!.cu mc JsL2c tuwbjc 21sC2 uuq UfflUGL 01.; btoqncr MG cxuunuc !u m2 btolcct Ii itocqq pc 511 CUOLWOII2 132j to

rncnqcq to eonttoj L boaeipjc tift1:CLCUCCC !11 csLwj bLiccee OL qicLcuec2 U WC msA tint CCUIL9J ojjjcc

qcmsuq cdnst!on2 JImA 9j20 CJJI1:t OACL tWJC• \f 211Jc-ffl1Jt\WflJtJ-flUJt OMUCL2JJ!b qnumA 9J2

(I!2t!U11!2P C9112112 Acs12' flJC2C SIC !UtCLSCtc 4W WC 1SCtOL bucce to tccornsc 11151 Ct0L

J9J)OC WSTGLjSI2e snq C1JCLA' ACEL CjjCCt2 SIC C0I1tL0JJC J,OL ffiltJJ S 2Ct 0j t1C qmmJJ2I)' qnt

M !2 IJIC oiitbiit 0j Sf J OIJICL bLoqnct !' tP bjsut' C02t !2 qcijucq 52 tpC cxbeuqitntc on

S LC G bqcca 01: JSpOV mStCLSj sug CucLA' e tpc ontbnt ICACI oj, we bLoqflct me SLC awqArn8 snq

jpc p52w ,jou-urn,, coat woqcj 12 c b"1 b" ' W D ri) MJJGTS IJJC 1J121 WLCC SthJIJICUIC

coat suq OACLC2I!fllStC UlStJCIIb2 JIIOLC 1:OL JSLRC bjsutw

C2UWSLC 01: WSL11J9J C02t IA!!! !UCLCS2C 11W bisut 2!SC jcsqiu 112 10 botcuusjjA nuqctcatpisstc Wnusj

bcLpsb2 WOW JJJIBOLISIJtIAe 2111CC J5LC bisuta if LG G11GL9JjA IJJOLG csbitsj !utG1J2VC tJJC piga 111 0111

WSL8IIJS] COat J)CCSII2C USC CXLSIJ2!OIJ !u CSb!WI Coda MICJI IIJCLCS2C2 !u OfltbIJt "111 nOt pe csbtrrtcq'

wbnt2' fiCCSR2C 01: USC W22 csbrtsj qsts me mijj 2A2LCWStICSIIA 11UCLC2tU1StC 010!CACI 01: 5 bjsnt1e

cocctCq' BCCSI'TeC 011 W!2e C021 !2 qcucq 52 C bjsut,a cxbcuqtntc on nntcqsja lsPOL' 5110 cucLfl

bLsut !u UJOCt Acne pnt 110 !11t0111191!0U 011 bjsnt acLncc BL!CCC 01 CXBCUCJItITLC2 on csbitiq nbnt e

boot mtoJ.unpou on w bjsut,a csbtsj 1120' D5t5 1:01 USC poor flJRC 01: csbiwj 2104(2 !2 5A5fl9JC pA

1911112 tInt ififOM cetnusteg W5L!119I C02t to ASA "4tI 111020 1:SCtOL blicer jpILq MC fISAC LCjSUACJA

spjc to COU2tLflCt bjsnt-abccitjc bL1cC2 1:01 WStCLIS!2 jSpOL' suq CIJCLA suq flt!J!SC UCY!PIC piI1ctoUSf

Page 20: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

18

vlPa!Wt!oU ccqrmu bJsur2 'w mote cubrwj LC JLtCL uq pSAC pIJJ;L ASL!SpjC O2j? LSWCL W'J UGWSL!AC 52 Ii MOflj PC R !t LCLJCC1CASL!SC rnbnjr V2 S LC2IIJt C2tIWSLC2 O4 tJJC C021 CJS2tTCgA /A!W LC2bGCt to cbiwj CLC CHCLVIIA bo2inAC LGUGCLWR mc

b!LSWCGL jIJCC Offtbflt sug LCUCCL2 IOH-LfllJ qicI.cUca2 !U bjsur 211C LSt}JCL tJJSIJ iJJC 2JJOLI-LflIJ 2flP2tTwUOu CI/ACGU xcq nq

SLO qouzimrcq pA CL022-2CCITOU!J ASLISIIOS swou bLoqnccL2 2flc n mc C'"2 o\ywstcscuwst qsw' csbijsj scj 52 S 2CSf CIJIC (4515 !2 IPC LPCOLGt!CSJIA COLLCCI OIJC• E21!W51C2 OI( tJJC 2JJ01.t-LI3J woqcj MCLG 1111251!2lflCtOLA CC5fl2C ID WICLO (4315 2cf2 jJJ5t

m!UP1J!SG cxbcuqiuac OH IPG2C IJJLCC A3LT5JC Wbflt2 2nplccr to s ipcq csb!WJ 21OC ID W2 CS2C tP tOtSJ coat NS WCS2flLC TMstnwcur c b" b" (5 ig 'S b vj jpza sbbtoscp !a lnatnjcq R bjsuja cpoO2G jspoc UJStCLT5J2 311(4 cticifl iubcrr2 to

ffiC SJ?O C241U15t6 2JJOU-L1W C021 Woqeja LPSt ucpq w poor J' W bjsut4a cSbIJ ?tOC 52 55 5(4(41110W]

qstse !11 cucLffJJA csq o nbmstq pS2Cq 02LJJSiC2 oj tctnum to acifica pCCSII2C WOLG GWC!C1U

ccouomicr 211m1SLIA nuopactcg CIJJCICUCA glijetcucca' ttpicp 114ff tcuq to qomnmjc lu 0t022-2CctrnhJ

llI LC2DJI U S qomwtng p152 III onibnt coo jcicut suq ¶11 nbffiSLq P32 !' UJiC2 Oj 2CSJC

qcA!ifq0u2 f)CtMCCU O2CLACCj suq bJSUIJCg ontbtit C5fl20CJ pX tsiiqoui gcuisuq ot rnbcg anbbjX apocj&

ontbne ffiP!CP csu sine p.om IUJBLOBCL qcJJstiOu (M11!Cp 12 BOt S bLOpJcw J 05Th CJiftS 2Cr) OL pow

cL!11cp02 q HSfl2WSIJ (JoRQ)' sug NS!Lc22c (iooo) OL qacnaaou) JIJ CUCLifJ WCS2ThLCWCU OLLOL Ill

tJJG C02t WuCr!OIJ wq Wrn p52 !tJ Cat U15t02 OJ LCf1Lu2 jO acsc OL mSL!uuJ coat (ace (m2®

JJc1cLocucitA sIJq IJJCSaIILCWCiJt CLLOL IU OflthflV BOW 0515 csq to P!S2 ! ofllLnt-LcJsrcq bSLsWGrCLa !U

jMO bLopjcwa tpsr cifu 5420 !u bLoqnctou usogca carussrcq mrp WICLO gt no nuopactcq

naJJ nA scLOfl bisuta MItis qrcLcucca ! scrot bL!cc2 oritbrg jctcja suq ornbnt W!X

/AJJCLC tj.JG O°Y JCUCL2 SEC ff10 Coat jJlUCtIOU bsLsuJctcLa Wt SEC C2tlUNjCQ E2tW't°1 UJSL8IUSJ C02t

= . = + + Atwf + E )w" +C. cMuC C•

SEC couartnctcq sa:

"irv coar 2SLC cdrwqoua oL usstcqifja sug CucLA Ear!usra o s bjsut,a UJ5LJVJ coar oi. ourhift

jpc omblEIcs! moqcj 11202 WC L5IJ2JO IjflJCUOIJSI J9U0 sug C2WJJStC2 ff59 C02t UflJCUOIJ tO9CPCL

crbcuqrrn.Ca SLO sjocstcq

Page 21: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

To

O1 U2fLflUJGIJW A9u9p1G2 sJ20 jcq to 2flp2W11h1v1 !UCLC92G2 ! WIJqnq GU.0L2 OJ WC COCWC!GU122I18C2tGq p) GLIIICJJG2 suq H9n2111n1 (ras@ qqtouJ pJ2ILflWGUI2 Pt W LC20J12 MGLC ACL) 2!W!jSJ? '12 cxbccrcq tfJc 112Coi pujc njnc btoppj) pccmc wc !U2W1WGUt2 9Lc tsiLlA boov I' 9qqqou 10 CSbWJ MG fl2C J!G AVIflG2 O1, ontbnt 2qujctcucw C1WEGL9fTIJ IPG WGflflLCWGUI CLLOL bLopJGw !u onrbnt uq sucujbr2 10 1u211.nmcuI wc i.omq ni bjsur ontbnt BLC

fIG LGIIILIJ2 to 2CffJC G21!UW1C2 &OW W qwc-qiGLcuccq qw nc iwbj9n2ipJX pjr ncp !2 COU2I2iCUI 1MW

OflL IIIjCLC4 12 11.1 COjJ2tfltjW bowj cajJWUjGa Ut WSLthIflJ Coat 0L GSCJJ bpi; jps: iccousc qi; bjwa,

LC2RJL2 !a to joq nuopaecq petcLoeuc!A caect !uto me acsjc-eisicq coat bnswGteLr QIAGU qmt

OI W! BSBGL me PAW LCIA on tllC 2fl1� t!mtea OT tile C02t UUJCt!OU JJJG W!IJ W! PA!!! ILCCt OlE

COU2!atdUt !W J!Pt mGg2IILCWeIJt GLIOL LLOpJCIIJ2 !U tJJG cLoaa-acct!ousl oiitbiit qstr pi m LCW9i1JCL

COU2tSTJt LGWUJ2 to acjc J10L bjffiua !u m jacat one ot tmo dnsi.pjc o w qiatLipntiou nBa !

IJCLe21J LCWLU2 tO ac!c 9tLO22 moat ° mc bput aXG qiatupntiou MIJUC tI'C IA Caffiiiftea rnqicte

AffLWt!OU !U tJlC (jfftff bLoAqc tpC W02t bjsnvpje c2t1UJffte2 p ciiets W 2flK C2tII11Te 2P0M 2!1t

VIIJOIJ W qIUL11t C2IJ1fftOL2 tile 2fl1� IA cat?J.JfftoLa tpst cxbjoit tile C1022-2GCt!OU

qitjceijceq qwt narn qie bjsut1a csb!t atocjc sa ff11 IJ2tmIJ1eUt j9L t}Je LOMJ W OtTtbllt

ffgcmbt to couctj 491 potp 20flLCC2 OJ f)jff 2 tAG j2o ffbbjA tJle JU2tLflhJIeIJtff J AffLWJC G2tIIlJfftOt to tJJC tulle-

tUJG qctcIJcea' il' csac uAe-XeffL mqj tcqnce JXIt not CJIIIJIU!tC tp!2 btop1euv jo

bLopJcw q!IJeLCUcc eatITJlfftOLa CSIJ CXffcL9TC tJJC pS2 JLOW meSalTLeWcIlt CILOr flJC naG 0j JOIIRGL

ill Ut-!U• Lipcpea (JoBQ) eLcpea ffuq HS1T2UJffU (TQ) apotA tJJSt /Apfle LCWOAiIJ OIJC

GJIIJJWStG blffflt-2bGcUjc tlUlG-ItIAffIIff Ut JJetGLoGIJefl W W coat IJlIJct!OU MG G2tlWfftG mc coat Ipuctiou

cwoV 1JJ12 IA C2tiUJSTOL LG11C2 bWJNLIJA 011 tLO22-2CC0IflJ AU1!fftJoU Ill TJJG quw ccouq' J0

mac mc bjsut1a pcumuJ-ot-AcsL csbiti tocic ff2 ff11 !UatLfluleUtff I AffL!ffpc 40L ontbiit FWG qie 2fl1�

ffttembt 0 COIJtLOJ tOL IJJCS2flLeWGtIt GLLOL SL12!IJ tLOW qcAwttou2 PCtPACGU bjffuueq suq scw ontbnt e

ffiC catmnte w coat uioqe n2 we aeem!uA mIle jvteq LCLeaaiou (2nK) eatmntoL pJ ff11

tile!I. IIJffqCITba

CCOIJOIIIIC2 MC gte fflCG!A to nuqctcatmnte m 111ff LUffJ C02t 0j JSLC btoqnceta uq tpna oAeLeatnjmte

btoqnccia Mjj pe 4ffLCL suq JIffAG !0M ffAeLffG coat ll e OACLeaqiiIffte mc qetec oj acsjc

Page 22: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

Moor !btrntq vptc !2 HOE rncjnqcq pGcn2G IPC qsw MS2 too !UCOmbl©fG to cawrc wc C02r uioqcy

COttOU aJJCGtllJ JG C9jG G1flt!c!Q CASJflStC St WC mesna 01; mc qstu' cdnsja j .4Q) sug

iwbotwut 1;OI WLCC 01; mc bLoqncta MJIJJ JSLG coat qccpuca' pscjooq bJAMooq bolAcateL LypL!c aug

1N2 cLOa-aGct!OuSJ qccpuc ill IJJSL!uSJ coat LGUGCI2 if URIJJCL 01; ICtOLa 2CS!C G1;1;CCt2 SLG

btoqrrcta mitii tile JSLG2t bqcc qccflhic& WSLUJ91 coata SLC J0?AGL JL jSLG bLoqnccLa

a?atCuJStlc ASLliftiOU in mama coat- OACL91I J;OL 111021 01; tG LMCJAC biogncta aug 1;OL 01; ¶

ijuaj jMO bLoqncta nopuc aug ucMabLmt' pate no aAatcwspc ontbnt BLIeG bagcw put po JJS/IC

biauta !U tP mqgJc 01; tilt a!SC (J!2tL!P11t!Ou' put a IJJHCJJ IJJOLC aAatcmsiic gccpuc !u onthut bqcc jpc

COLLeJatIOn GtiACCI1 OrltbtTt bLIce aug asc ill J)pJC f J152 S a!!!.Jt gccpuc WaLuaI coat 1;0L

bagem ni maI2!uaJ coat 5cL022 m 2se giatupntiolr Pflt w!a iao bawjjcja w uqw 01; 5 /ACifJC

jpe aamc bLoqncta s-jao pag aucifut qccpuca u ombm bucc JU can goca not pate a a!rnucaut

tjtat ten bLogucta pateg p1 tpc tapjc tpcle !a S 2iUtIjC91Jt qccpuc !IJ I1JaLUS1 Coat 1;OL G!JJt 01; tJJtUY

bagicnsLjA tpe 011C2 /A!W JJJJ bL!cc gabcLaou' mSL!IJSJ coat 1;5JJ2 M!tJJ nJcLcSaca w bjvut j' ow

we bLogffcta pecanac It bnajjeja we battewa opactcg jpL ontbni buce hOt moat o, we btognctaa

JJJG IJJSI2WSJ coat ASLJStIOU opaettcg !U jSJ)JG 2tLaRpqoLtAaLg to 2IIUJIJJSLISC 1;OL ffl0t 01;

MIll biant aisc

we dnntrjca 01; tpc arse gnLipntJon aa a maA o anwmaqsu8 tpc cLoaa-acctiouaj WSLflJSj coat tniatiou

geometuc mean oj maLma coat !u tpc aame Aesu jpra ra LCLC22C on a act 01; qnmusA ASL!aplca 1;OL

u - nu(IX (1;rJ' MIld ! tile oj bjaut-jctcj mai2!uaj coat nonnapseg pA m jog 01; we

asc atU IPJG Ia iqeutica! to japje jpe qebcngeut A9t!SJDC a u =

jppjc br.otiqca aummaLA mcaantea 01; tpe ASL!at!ou In eatuiatcg WaL8!IJSJ coat aci.oaa we bjsut

not pe a aeLlofla bLopjcur

acaic 01; obetaqon aug actot bL!Ce2 aug not aebaLatpJ petetogeuc1tA anq acaje batamecei& tpa aponjg

Page 23: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

bJsur2 onrbiii wix suq croL buccvfiG 2CJC CJg2tiC!A !2 qczjucq S2 2E = (s I"C\9 I"(5 + 9 I"C\S I"K )•i B°P °I 'P 002f GJ2f!C!t!G '-' '4W rpc

coat qatca uq tjia 12 GXbJoLGq ill qic lieu aect!ow

tile &oqncta jpia 2cle2t2 qrnt qie joztct ontbnt btcca cjnLcq pA ine bisuta unA LGUGCt nuqetjArn

coe1,Ijc!dH2 111 tpie 2 • MIl].! tile UCt CJJpCt pCUI JOML WflIIlffJ C0212 OL jSLC bisuta Sfl pin tptce oj,

tyctota coutLipifte to anpawuqsj cr.oaa-accpous ASLfftf0ll !u WffLUS coar 82 cAlqduccq pA jpc

COIIIUCLM tP!2 a tfle 9ct tint JSI2eL bpiita ffPJIO2t ffftnAa bsA P!PCL /ASC2• J)JCGIJ tOCtJJCL' t11C2C

coIJCLetC osjc uooL!ut sug aogooq bJAMooq Mll!CJJ Miff JOMCL tpc 1IIffLpEf 002i 01, JSJ2GL bLoqsTceLv

I bi.cca qecpuc mrtp bpiu arse 1,OL msuA o qle bLoqncta bffLucnJffLIA comstcq poxca co1,eca

aise !ucLeffaca ESCtOL bLice qeLeuccz ffj2O coutupnte tO JJGtGLOelJcltA ill bivut WSLJIJffJ cOatV

WOLC Oj pOtJJ ontbllt2 suq M tilla M!JJ cOlJtL!pfltG to s qecjiiic P jG IlJffL!USJ C02t 0j oiitbiit sa

M4JJ IOMCL tile UJ!LJIJSJ COat 0j tJJG bLoqnct zAG SLG j1ocnarn ow 2W 1ffLGL bsuta cueLsIIA bLoqilce

bioqncta c rjuq U!tjC9llt eCOLIOIJJIG2 o acobe mpicp mjbpca tint !ucLeff2ca rn tjlG bjsuta, OtjieL ontbnta

saect Off L WffLiIlffJ Coat G2tUJIStG2 !2 tJILOI1JI GCOIJOWIG2 01, acobe EOL Air.trmijA sjj 01, tG

ScLoaa-bjffut qqeteucea 111 llJffL!ufff coat qne to sjj 2011LCG2' tp!a ! IJu v accouq msA tpt acsjc

Cftt2 oJ qie utccbt oj tpc coat jpuqiou sctoaa bjsuta EOL Off L bathoace 'P!P ic to sccornjt 1,OL

Miff CSbWLG potji tLIIG 2C&IG GC000uh1e2 52 tAGfl sa tji GIJCCI 0 ffuopaeLAcq pcteiocuciQ tfft L9211ft2 P

qrnt pCLGsBea iu bjsut else SAG }te G1,TCt oil UflL coar v qiacriaacq spote' qie acsc cjsaticiQ

csua cou.nstcq poxea co1,1,ee suq S2OJWG tpe acffjG eLsaticitA flea GtMGGU j •Q3 suq j wqicfftiu

I Ø flJfl C0lJtLlfltlU to s qecjrne ILL unLiusl coat MItJI bjsiit 211C• BOL tile tPI tOffb oj bLoqncta'

aogooq bjA#.ooq suq uemab uC ØIG acsjc clnt!c!tA st qie ines Ha Oj tpe qsts ASL!€2 LLOW T3 to

1,OL tpe tptce bLoqffcta Lc2bGct!AcIA LOL s aecouq &octh o bLoqffcta pLcffq oaJc uooL!u coIJcLctg

Page 24: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

aqu*isNl 1sv9J-tnslq .v

tnslq £ oiai 23203 Isnigism botsmitao bits aonq tuqiuo barnassm 0th smdmo ow iioitooa aisIl ci

as bombb ai qmhsm adlnslq ouT .amotisq aonoa-oxml bits lsnoitooa-aaoio au asiismrnua bus qithsm

iii 'Iioi1as1o bnsmob z' inslq 21 ondw (t\\. - V) n\ - as boioiqiolni ad nso 113111W ( Dfl \ g'k ) n\

oth ,atoubrnq Thom id asia inslq 1131w 31111331) taco Isnigism bits oonq Iuqiuo oil thod ooth2 . iso'

ô oIcJsT .'(lbiqn ernm aonilaob oldshsv doiiw toofloi IIiw qu±sm oth ml noitsiisv Isnoiiooa-aaoio

ouT .noituditaib asia inslq oth lo ealinsup oil 220138 aqinlism egsiovs ill oanoiaThb oth aoshsmrnua

oil moil flOilsiVOb a as boaaarqxo 21 qithsm oil bits a bus 1 aoldsl o3 Isotturobi 21 aidst ath Ic Ismiol

.iso unsvoloi ath ni itsam 3ntomoog

ovsul aunslq ieis1 II asia lnslq thiw san ot aqmlism uoaqxa uuIgim ow anoassi seith 31s oiocIT

o3 aldslisvs at3uboiq ovitsmouls iowoI sis sioth oIqrnsxo id •oausood aoiuioitasls bnsmob iowol

as los bits 23203 Isnigism Inaiollib avsul alnslq 11 .asia inslq thiw ath bluoula aqmhsun nail aiaasrlowq

lo*tsm thiw oasoiorn 111w aqutsm nail laAism Iuqluo boog-auoonogomorl £ uI aiolitsqmO3 lounuoD

lstiqso owasom o3 3i1idsni iuo moil gnilluaai aatsmilao laoo Isnigism ni asid 111sn1 °oisu1a

Isliqso 510m ois alnslq ognl 'Ii asia lnslq thiw qu±rsm oth ni oasoionl us aisionog 111w aoiulibnoqxs

ainslq iognl II .osia tnslq 1131w 31111331) o3 aqu±ism t3oqxo o3 noasot ouo tasal Is ai otoulT ".ovianotnl

lisma usth aiomaqmoo atom aosl ot iloAiI ais '(oil austsm ouiqsigoog bstsluqoq atom iii aisioqo

bits Iouboiq lath tol aaifloilaslo bnsmob ioulgiul 33s1 auth bluoula bits aiaauboiq bausloai-'(Ilsoiulqsigoag

.aqwlism rawol svsul

ant Us nanh 1!abom lofrIuoC) orb nil bomuaas as ,33iiq tsAism omsa orb Is louboiq Isoitnoti us gutilsa ots ainsig Its II o lusiaxanoorn al ainiT .nono luomowasom mobnisi ruoi1 oaim or ovsnl bluow o3nq rnqlno iii noilsiisv IsflOnt3oa-22rn3 bovisado

.aiouboiq orb to laom ioI £ bus sidsi nil boiuomuoob ainsttsq oonsIaialsq enD

Istiqso aluslq orb iO oI orli guibubnil uoiaaoiaoi qutism orb otsmliao oats ow ,ow lsiiqso ni uoitslisv ioI Iofluo3 oT wtqs3 tori ob astsmitao 1203 Isnigism anti lEnD losl orb o1 aloflnoo ainiT .astdshsv 'io1snsIqxo 25 oisiipa air bus Aoola

Istiqso a'tnislq orb ievoo ,IW1 griot enD ni 1laum olsmujae ow qutsm 3111 bns ainistq ash lo 'Qianislnii Isliqso orb nit o3noleThb ml aldstisvs rosia atqmsa 3113 el anoijouba-i nil aitua,i emil bus VÔQ1 bus £ôQi iol oldslisva ion at sIsb tote tsiiqso anT .aiaoo

.wolad baaaijozib ci enoiaaoigai oil nil lstiqso gnibubui to 133113 silT .euoiaaeigoi qutism orb

U

Page 25: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

sill lo zia ioi .aI3ubolq £1 sf11 aaoios '(llsiluslaciua aoFisv qidanoilsIel sSia-qU)llsm silT

sioth ,lunqawsu bus boow1q boowñoa 4uhoofl Iso ,33Tlo3 bsoic1 a3i1dE1 buolcJ 13la3'(Ioq alouboiq

oth aaois oiuolouom usilo ai oasi3ui sill bus ssia iuslq rlliw qutsm sth xii 325513rn lusoflingia a ci

agustlo lusoiltugia on avail .suuLoasa bus auilosIla uolloo alouboiq I sill to owT .esimmub casio asia

bus asxod balsairnoo auso boowiq boowbisil ,alouboiq wol Isufi silT .asia ruslq riliw aqutham ni

.asasoioui asia lusiq as illusoflinaia snuloab lsth aqwhsm 51511 .slslouoo

ow as luooisq OV '<d asrnloab lath qitham s thiw saao lsuaunu laom ath ci boow1q boowbisH

sonq 3com ath thiw Iouboiq oth ocis ci chiT aluslq lo slinsup lasaisi ol laslisma ath molt ovom

ciii .( altisi) uOiIsilsV soiiq 31151q-IiifIliw ol lusiq-naswlad o oilsi lasilairl oth bus (1 aldsi) uoiaiaqaib

luqIflo Io 'i1sup sth ui uoiisiisv Isilusiadua 3com sill asul cull ,alouboiq lo Isa 1110 guoms ,lsill '(I3)liI

ui guisilsiosqa ainslq sgml sth filiw iuolaiauoo ci suiloab qithsm bus ooiiq ath bus alnslq aaoios

bssilsioaqa avisa clnclq islisma aIiilw asluliladua saolo sis doifiw ,atouboiq '(libommoo basibisbusla

ath sisila slsiouoo bus asxod 1auso auigism guimloab thiw alouboiq saith ntho silT .aiaiism axiom

lsnoiloaa-aaoio oth wilT ala±ism oiilqsigosg lisma 'IavilsIsi ui bloc ais 'ath lath aitilasl uOffimOO

thod xii suuloab silT .noililaqmoo qinlism Isool ui aaouaiaThb loans] uso ô aldsl ui uoilsiisv qutsm

'(Isanab aiom guiwiac atnalq isgisi rlliw lualaianoo ci uoiiudhlaib asia ath aaoios qithsm bus aaiiq

bloc louboiq istho silt lath ,iavawod a3on oW .ala*ism oidqsigosg avililaqmoa siom bus ,bslsluqoq

ci sioth aausoad ldiaaoq bails avilulsqmoo drib lo sousbiva worla lou asob bssid 1alstsm llsiiia xii

.aiaouboiq bss]d axioms uoilsilu5isllib louboiq sIom

avail auuIoasg bus guibasda riolloo ,aqutsm ui noilshsv balsisi asia on thiw abouboiq owl silT

boowbisrl sliJ .axnansq iaoo bus aonq gniIisbuu lusiellib 'isv 1w! aqmlism lb lava! laawol eth

ol buslq-uoswlad lo olin rigid a bus uoiaiaqeib aonq lb asigsb ilgirl a earl oiidsl uolloo boow'(Iq

a gui'slq ci aiaouboiq guoms uoilsiisv ilsup boviaadouu lath guiiaaggua noiisiIsv ooiiq luslq-uiilliw

lasgisi ob laslisma ath molt lnsoisq 8€ 'd dial oiidsl uofloo lo sonq sgsiavs silT .aIoi lusoiingia

ES

Page 26: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

tilsup thiw insleiano3 thss leoo lsnimm ill srnl3sb £ 'ci boilotsm '(138013 21 eiiIl 111(1 !alfiEIq lo olinsup

oth fir .23S12 tnslq 1o egitsi silt 220138 lnslanoo 'his1 bits 115012 sis lsth 2qmhsm iii gnilIIJ2sI iioilSfl5V

4203 151113mm iii easolom 343112 £ bits noilsnsv eonq 3135m632'<2 Ofi 21 313111 ,srnloas3 easo istho

stia lnsisIMb giloms asansisThb qinFisM .atnslq isgIsi ioI ,asonq ho ebln3 isilgiih moil gititluasi

.mobnsi issqqs 31nslq

svscl math lo his lsth ai bssirlt nomntoo silt !aqlthsm 3itIasslon! 1111w aloijboiq xia oth xo

3111 .33513V8 no 45th asisothin sldsT iii 1 tnei3iflso3 silT .1203 Istilgism iii asnhI3sb lsilnsladua

iol 3203 sth nsth tswoi lnsoisq âô bits O itscwlsd 21 ns3uboiq lo slitisup Jasgisl sth ioI taoo Isitigism

tuqluo shill 21 sisill iloitlw io'1 .Iniiqawsit 1o notlqooxe oth 1111W .

aioauboiq lo sliiisup lasllsma sth

iswol lo rmoI sth iii ieAism iuqiuo sth ot xlguoiilt beaasq '(IIsiflSq 318 21203 iswol 323111 jioilsnsv eoiiq

113111 nsill bnsmsb ollasloni oiom cosi 1543 aioauboiq sgisl 431w lnslaianoo al msnsq aidT .asohq

isdgxcl iii '(ilsiflsq bits asonq tuqluo iswol iii '(llsinsq b3133fls1 318 21203 iswol IISIIT .alsvii islisma

louboiq bits gmarnsvbs sisdw 23110 SiB ,331103 bus bsaid alouboiq oth lo owT .aqithsm

tuqlno 343 ioI busmob oilaslsni 31001 ol bssl biuoo bits ets)hsm ieIfliJaitO3 iii sloi £ '(sIq itoitsitrisisluib

elsibsrrnelrn as bloa '(115131133 3m aloubozq 311111150131 iuol silT .aieouboiq lsnoitsn sis1 sth lo

grxiau sth lo '(bula bslislsb siam luothiw 18313 ton ai Ii bits annil wthulosknsm istho 01 alsiislsm

• aisouboiq Ilsma 211215V sgisl '(ci bsos asilioilasls bnsmsb b rnsltsq sth tuods tosqxe 01 isrlw asnlaiibiti

3Ilsion'(aolbl moil 1111251 1150 alnslq 220135 aqwFism bits aeilioilasls bnsmsb ill asonsisThU

.aioioit Isiuloulla istho to '(tilsup iouboiq iii asoitsioluib tflslq-aaoios tnsusirnsq siom moil tO 2)130112

iii anoilsuloulb 'çiot anst aunsv aioiasl ofliosqa-trxslq lnsnsmisq lo sonstioqitti svilsIsi 543 '1itnsup oW

sa3rlT emit iovo anoiludittaib quAism oisisqsa ath ilguoith astsi noiliansti gninimsxs 'ci qmhsm 543

ocu ,athgizzn gthah xii jnuoo3s 'sm iMb sHsiisv toflnoo tsnoiiibbs £18 25 bo1a Isiiqso 25f18!q sift obuloni oats ow usfiW alnatq ogisl iöI qmhsm boassioni silT . sldsT iii bsnoqsi saoili ff843 '(list nsiadua jQffi 3211 aiouboiq X12 32343 iol aqIDhMn

•thislq isgml iii aiuqni Isiiqso siom oi sub oil ol issqqs ion asob s'n,ado SW 15113

Page 27: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

L31G2

WH2bL!U1 !2 qLobbcq tiOffi £P!2 WPJC CCSfl2C WCLC MCLC !U2nWC!CU1 Op2CLflt!0U2 10 btcccjX C2t!llfltC IPG ILVU2II!OU

2ILfICWL91 J9CrOL2 StC 20JJ rwboiatg iii ccornstu jOI qIJ9LCUCC2 UJoU bjsut ! IJC P!J uq JO/A

unboraui orn.cc oj wLJcnb AfliffDOU WJ LPG? flG oj, ontbnt bLICC ALWj1OD pnI LIJS I bcLijcur

jpc uubpcsqou o, ipeac BSUCLU2 2 qnj tuqow apocjce OL uonc !u we qsm sic IJJOLC

qiarLTpnqOtr

unjj pAboqac 0j LffIJO1JJ IJJOACWCIJIZ J10L bpnsI2 wPcw w we mqqjcwo dnnuje Oj; IPC IJflLJCFIb

boJAc2IcL pJcuq2' coffoll apecqut coijpc os U0OL!U' suq ogttooq bjAmooq' MC CifIJUOI Lclccf tpc

Lsuqom IJJOAGIJJCUj2 JC22 OJJCIJ MIffJ flit UJSLJCIIB2 wt !W we orgbrit bucer hOt IJAC bLoqncW

mote pcdncucjA COU2!21CU1 MIflJ LifUqOw m0ACWCU7 !U mLJCflb2 jp te' itt tclccr c pXBowc2i2 oj1

ontbrn BL!CC2 !U WPIC 3' IPC 1LS1J2!t!01J2 1,OL b1uI2 !U we miqqjc oj IJJC mstjcurb qJ2IUpIlUotJ SIC WflC

bjXitooq' cSu2' cottcistcq poxca' iq couctcrc) ccouq' mpcu combncq MUP mc 1W1J2!t!OU I$1C2 1,OL

mc Lcttcucc bucun OL w Btoqnc 1PI JJSAG JO/AOL IJJSLJCIIB2 0L IJJC jsi2c blifula (pstqttooq

opctcq ft4t uugom moAcmCUI2' iJ 1,LCdIICUCJA excecqa 20 jpctc 2 SJ20 U0 OpAJOfl2 q1,(CLC1JCC !U

dnnqjc OL LCJJUU!1J !U we joiteat UJ9LJCITB dcwr.pjc arkrcsuqA qJ1,CLCIJ1 IJJSIJ EJJC '32 qm: onjq po

apocjcr hOL sj pnt ouc btoqnc' oimooq bjAmooq' ipe btopspipA o1, LcmspJu mP!PC2I JJJSLJCIIL

bcL2I2lcucc ! Wc Wff a o we mnjcnb qialLipfluou j9L w tqspou 10 C qqteri bntcjA pA qoaAucLqc

jtto bsucwa sic ctrqcur h!L21 97 c oc.icq we buce qraiupnpou' flJCLC !a 100 1JJ1TC

WOACIJJCIJL2 JJ wnjcctbr

pAbocpcaa flfll Ipc CL!1J2!I!OU WIC2 SIC cdnsj 10 IPO2C iJNI ttonjq PC CIJCI$1C pA bIILCJA rsuqom

qiLipnpou' uq T3ô jnq mocq 10 WC j0ffiC21 &ISLUJC JJJC wpjc Sj20 LCbOLI2 tci LC2UJI2 1,OL tpc

P!PC2I iiistjcith dII&UIJC LIAG ACL2 JICL' 38X pq UJOAGq 10 ¶C uJqqjc i/to dIISLiJICa oj, fiG wnjcflb

tpsi' 01, w 32 BCLCCIJI o we bjvut2 IAUp we pIpCaI wffLJCflJ)2 in AGffL t' o ww teiirniueq in qie

sic amiiinstscq !U IffPJC S' /ApJCP JJ97 fl 2SIJJG 1,OUJJ!1 ff2 IS])JC 3 1P UL2I LO/A 0 IIJO IUPjG 2JJ0M2

Page 28: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

SQ

tpG lnoqncte uq qccjirnu wsLumJ toete bj &u ,wboi.wut LOjG I'j €ucwpug qic urnjcrth bsucwr

JCACJ bqcc-coat 11191JC11B2 jC UmLJCffb LCUJff 1112 IT1JCJflIJC OL !11CLCC2 MIIJJ bjsig 21SC j0L Sfl pilL. 0ilL

BJ9IJL-2bCC!UC C2ji9C2 oj WffLWSJ coat' uq Cfli!iiC qmc-acca siiq cLoaa-accciouaj b9ucw2 o bjsiu-

10 cxbjotc ! BL!CC q9LC111J2 SLC C021 pff2ccj ThC C21!WSIC COai WUCL!OU IJJoqCja' COIJ2tU1CL

OACflJJ hL!cc qabcLaou !IJ OJIL &onb' JLC bLoqnccLa JflAC JOftCL OIILJMIL bucca

bqcc qJabcLa!olr hOE 9JJ bLoqncta cxccbt ifaojUc sIJq IJcmabLIut' CJJG f/tO bLoqilcIa tAitJl iJlC JCS21

P!811 ECdlTGUCA' 2ilC2flU f}lif nuqcLJAu Ule-mAifliff Ut 24L11CIThifJ 1ifCj0L2 COUfLipige O q.16 ontbn:

p bn cnjsV IJ!P-b14CC bjffuta tcuq 40 LCIIJ U P!P bL!CC ff11 !om-bL!cc bJ9ut EGmif LU jom bLICC ttq

bCLaiacIJcc U C btiqu oj, nqyqqnsj bjif 1.142 qrnnmonjq PC 8CUCnICq pA bflLcJA i.uqom LUOACWCUfV

bLoqncv bSttCLIJ2 Oj WOACUJCIJj tJJIOUJJ USC BLrnC q!atupnuou OA€L jmsc LCACSf tintwe" !2 UIOLC

qlabGLaiou AifliCa anpatffUr!snA ifCLO22 bLOqlICf 2 JMII 12 LGIifIIACIA COU24ifIJL OACL LITUC 0L if ISA abccujc

tpatccu jJOmocUcOn2 mifuncwLcq b10qffC12 JJJC qsw LCACVI Lint SC SUJOBIJI 0 UJ1CLO-JCACJ bL1CC

qJC!L BCL2!2tCUCG OACL qIUC' C0L1CSflOU H4tJ1 bLoqilect 2SC' ifug COLLCIifL!OU N4L bLoqrIcpou C02j2 OL

p 1J112 b9bCL Mc crbjot qsw ou ontbnt btcca st mc bjaut-jctcj to awqA qjC qxebctaou ot bL!cca'

iir WmIIJJ8LA ifug ci""

if uq jomcat wnjcnb blifuiw

msLJCnb q2tLpnto1J WOLC jqccjA' ¶CLC 12 aLLfJ if beusnucut cowboucut ijrnt ! iqCuLifpJc WE WC jJ!JJc2L

LUff qcsTb AifLISfIOW ftJJ1f c W Jif1CL qo2AucLiftc AifL!SUOU W5JC62 WOACWCUL2 ifUJOIJ dclifuIJca OJ 1P

Aif14S1!0U LU 1/tO COIIJbOIJCUL2 ffuq JCSAC2 if JSJ2GL LOJC 0L q02AIJc1fftc 2JJOCJC2 ff2 LJIC 20JILCG

CLMCCIJjjUfl qcLcuc LU cOaL2 thOu 11.10 LUff Lpb CUCCLIAC!A ucta oat macp oj, mc pctmccu-juu

wnjcsth fLSIJ2!f!01J2 ff19 IJOj aflEbLialut J W pCwCcU-IjLlJJ AifL!ift!0U 1J bqc;a ffL!2C2 JSICJA tjom

ffcLo2a tjac aLSO cpatqpatou suq LJJC uJboLwIJcc o bcuusucut pcjmccu-b!ffut qqjtcucca 1" 21SC' w

untjcnb W!12 04 fc q12tL1pntow (3!ACIl 0111. CifLIIGL zjuqpsa Oil tjSC qccpuc JU bL1cca if uq IJJffLgIIJSJ C0212

Page 29: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

01 00115301 onisa oth 01 thsmol or boor t3ubolq tao to! aqtthsm laawol boa iaodu1 0th thiw arnslq orIT

0th 10 alrislq iol oonotainoq lo soiob oth d3uodrls 21so' rfloloIIib iii anoi3udhraib laooiiooa-aaoio oth

3i3n3wao!bi rsth gnitasggua ,ooiiq ruqruo oth thiw 21 ii as noi3a as ton ei noirudiijaib oth lo olbbim

ooi-iq iuqnso niisiono iii ots oth oath noitsitav qwhsm gniistonog lxi instioqmi 01010 015

.noitsitsv

aaoioa o3nafmolloq 33)11510 tuqtuo ni 'flionogotoroil eth alrlgilclgid tollo ow oonobivo orIT

ovsd ow aio1loa aaoiaa woonoomorI (133oboq 2k bubotq boiinoslunsm on olizlW .aiooxcbotq rnotoulib

Isirosiathia ataixo ioth aeaso eaoth iii novU .mxon rath ot olcfiaaoq 25 eaolo as 31003 or aI3ubolq noaoilo

• ibma ow aroxJbolq oth lo taom tol arnslq aao13a aqithsm baa aoonq tuqiuo ru noitaitsv izuoraiatoq baa

s ataoo noironboiq boa asirioitaslo bnameb ni '(ti000aolorsH ieouboiq $uui'(hobnu tacit aoxiasrlqms airlT

lsviJslsi oh novo acnoiraq qutsm baa onq lovol rn3im lo arasnhrunorob rnanoqmh od or 'Oo)1il

. aio±iam aboog auoscxegomoil

ar3ubolq 22013S aqirlanoitalot qwham boa 4203 ,oouiq oth of aooaonThb ,iovowoxl ota suocl'I'

•lla to! afloilsvuoado oth thiw tnolaianoo si lath nohtsna!qxs lamromra olgnia a or rnhoq tormso ow boa

'dlsirrisradua i5IIib 'otaubnh oth lo asxmso! lawrouxia gth1iobnu oth lath a3aoguia Vinovhb aith ,tsthaSl

baa ogial !o aaonovirirsqmoo oth of aoonotoThb aoxod botagunoa ni e1qnusxo toT .ai3ubolq 2a013S

ath thiw tnotaiano3 315 arao noiroubotq lii asonotollib llama thiw bothdmoo aJoAtsm oirlqstgos llama

ognl lo alaoo lsaigusm towol l1sirixa1adua oth 1tasulruoo nI .ainalq ogial to! anigism baa aoohiq iswol

oldianoqasx od 'tam aruiainovba rlauotth bonoqqua 2330113 oman bnaid thiw bonidmoo .aiooubotq ooIloo

llama eth llarn9 .atooubouq eats! oth lb aqxtham tozlgicl 'lina3fiinaia 1usd aoonq towol ItrIgi1a oth tot

Isailnebi ioI noiaieqaib 331iq o1sisn ol beau need evsd 21203 doisea io'<ud riliw alebom ,(1ôQ!) ielgil2 riliw gninnigefl gibbs aeoneiMeThb laoo Isnigism doidw iii alebom qoleveb (€89!) eelMM bns noalisD bns (QVQ!) munsgniosl .alouboiq

bslsielloo-'(IIsnea .21203 zbnea to noilsnidrnoo a eau (QQ!) ddo$1 thus aamfiail .noiludi,taib sohq edi ni betoeflei em aisilea iA .aiooubotq gnoma aaoneiaThb litoiq bns ooiiq lnelaiaieq aisienag 01 aiernuanoo d aeasilaiuq laaqei bns aAooila 1203 mmii

818 02 bus alouboiq 100 22013$ ieThb 01 10 lrmlioqmi eis alaoo iloisea i,dl,dw no eanebive '(ifS evsx! Ion ob 3W 3n323xq •evisado ew airieflsq cdl iol eta aI,bOiII eaeth lnsvalsm wod luo<Js anoraubnoo '(ifS wsib 01 aIds Ion

Page 30: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

asia inslq iliiw aqinhsm bus 1ateoQ ,aanq lo uoilsl5noo wol bus aorsi noitiansn rlirl uoiaiaqaib oonq

ath am aaion lo aaoiuoa iatho bus atoda mobusi doufw ui aaaooiq £ taaggua namlax auxi!oas ath iol

.'iausgow1ad latsm flsqiuo lo aoiuoa iusthmob

aiaouboiq lsth (EVQ 1) stoamaG d ba3sluains waiv sub tioqqua aguibufi IS3iliqms iiio ,I!5i51O

iatsm lo aaauavnnaqmoo sub wsiv aw woil ioI auoilsoilquni taut aiub 3sth bus '(QusiOffiO 113th fll iaThb

(I1sitxsq tassi 3s am aa3u5laIIib 13u3i3ffi3 325th tsth oouobiva abivoiq aw uoiIibbs uJ .aamooluo

ath atatsm J3ubolq usm ui 21203 lawo! avsu! 1rio ion aiaouboiq agrsd .aaoiiq iuqtuo ui bsiosflai

tow !soiiiqma bus !sonaioath iaufrnfi lo eulsv sub laaaaua atluasi suiT aeohq tuqiuo iawo! svsul oals

bus noil3ubolq sub Auil nsa bus iñsuaoiaisul iaauboiq taubni-nithiw lo aanataixa sub assiuio33i isth

.auoiaioab a'umil sub o eabia busmab

Page 31: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

293fl919'ISSl

badailduqitu tttoiS\o zt%cr,rnK tk hnts noint½G hS miboi'k ,(2821) .A asmodT floddA 'naiovrnU bisvtsH noiJsfloaaib

. U .#l

t,rioitouboiq lo aia1sitA oth bits ,tuqtuO his5l .itoiaioqaiU oFA ioouboiW' (SQ21) .A asmodT 1floddA .thgsK 'iitboic\o ntnuo\.

gitnutosIuitsM (Ii aotfrlsrr(U 'jjvj33jjbojq" ,(22I) 1!edqmsD bivsU bits ,itetluH aoLisrlD ninsM lis8 .V-V81 .qq zimonomot\fl 'ñK itconcna no vmofik tn½ooia "MilaN

B. U 0th iii itoijsitinijiaaiQ 83j1q svilitsqmo3" ((taQQl) .J ioitsM ,oao5l bits ,itiwva8 ,niwaitoiofl £8ô-€ô .qq .4

. oH

, O1

. loV ,cnoncna nfliloS \o \snuot ",çflaubitI ornhiA

",aistsM botsliito3noD iii itoiiiioqmoD bits 'ün3" ,(1 221) aaio5l .

D jq bits 3 thoniiT ,nsdsnaoi8 .QOO1-VV2 .qq ,toH ,22 .loV ,'moncn?s \½i\oc\o \tsnio\. ' \tscuot ",rioiaioqaiU sohq muhcliliupll oioioaiU" (E8Ql) OO1AOM itotaoi .51 bits .A itriot ,itoahsD

.EQts-O8t .qq ,E .oH ,1Q .IoV ,vcono \ii\ok

", aniiis8 vilidoM oX aioins8 'olri3 moi9" ,(VVQI) iotio .3 losdoiM bits .3 bisdoiil ,asvsD .1 ô1-I &

. qq , .oH ,l2 .!oV ,nimoncna\o \tnsot yisttQ

"3shsM s3itswaitI e!idomojuA its iti noinoqaiG coWl" ,

(b821) tacW .

a aslauoU bits vaB ,'(dMsU .8EP81ta .qq ,.oM 4aQ .loV ,'mono3 \tiiloc\o \cwuot

.B.U thdiiw bits itcowloci itoiaicqaiU cgsW" ,(1221) ,aitswi11sH itdot bits .1 itovoiB aivsU ,vmoncymotifl t'WitK 3imono'a no tisssk %%lUioolü ",bS-€ôQ I aiitsN grnwlosluitsM

.081-UI .qq ,(.abo) itolaitiW bioThfl bits 'o1is8 11 thnsM

b& nomO cot ,(à221) ilIJILOB flooB bits ,ioitswz31sH itriot •

.t itovoiB ,aivsU .aaeiq TIM :ogbhdmsD

oiiioiitsisq-itoM A :bitslisilT iii anoitudiflaiG omooitl bits 233ç1q ooi51" ,(2821) augnA ,itotsoU yE-I .qq ,22

. by \scuot itnoncn'R ' ,aia'1sitA

tnt 'utJ'p \t*cuiot ",oiioq oiIths'l bits ,vjlsvisl icAisM ,oimomi2 'çuaubitl" :(EVQI) bboisH ,sioamoU .01-1.qq 1 .oM ô.boV ,nmoncna

stT ",aohlaubril githuiosIuitsM .a.u iii oaU oboitibooT bits oA iitslq" ,Q22I) 'diomiT ,oitituU .22-88 .qq ,E oH ,S .IoV ,timoncn'ã\o \tnot

as itoiliioqmoD loehoqml bits ,bitsmoU aiaoD" ,(2Q1) aflodo5l I hsM bits thorthT ,oititisU ,no\ms\ntiO nzthnX M StnnZ \\q iii "goj1q tuqiuO bovoJ-iitslq 10 ainsnirzrtoioU

.eieibai!di$1 oimebsoA iewutN .(. abe) beiñgei2 .

LI bits fb3ai5tbLJA flu

QS

Page 32: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

• a.u lo 3luhisl bits xl3woi() 34T"

, (8821) noaSms2 0mJ bits afl3doM .1. tsM thomiT 311nuU

• 8Qô-1 Vô .qq ,t. oW 4s01

. loV n\scsonna\o \mw* c\ituQ tt "ains1q gniiutoslunsM

iol towsrrisi A :a3imsxpQ vilaubitl tooml3q-vojhsM1 (aQQ1) aMsq bFiA bits bisdoiM 1itoaoii3 £8-Ea .qq ô .IoV z\b*ia imono \ 4mW !soFiiqm3

3fIt bus x3itoLoiIId lo±sM noi3srmo1uI lo '(illidsiuG arfF" ,(eQQl) doS! IaslsSI bits miltiA jismclaFl .ÔE-Qi .qq , 1 •o14 ,ôE .IoV 'u*,5k imono 1no½nsn1n1 agniq 10 exiE

•S bits iotsi11ifluI .M z mscono'R\o ioocbtnM "aaIJ2eJ sisa 3Lmoito3H" (ô8Q1) ivS ascbiIhD •bitslloH- iltioW :rusbtamA (.ab$ acrloilnO ' 1twwot "stsQ 1oitsI iti aoldsnsV iii aion3" Ø8Q1) itsmausH .A.!. bits 1ivS a3d3i1hO

.811-EQ .qq ,IE .!oV ,nThiono ' \stnwt "8821-2VQ1 :'xaubnI ilanal iii iiivitouboiq nni9 ,(aQQl) vogosi misH bits ivS a3if3i!i10

*

.€o-evi .qq ô .IoV 1zmowna

•qq . .014 ,øà .loV nmncma "shcJi1iup3 miS! anoJ iii tixH bus 'tn3 (Q2i) oguH ,flsdit3qoH •oai i-xti i

•qq , E

.

oW .

by tn\smoncna "q'taubnI lo noiiuiov3 sift bits 1101133132' ,

(8Q1) its'(oa oivonsvoL .OVâ-2tô

\o \wwot \sw5 ,soitsunolisq iusi bits 1aoimonoo3 sqoo2 1UIM (ôQ21) doist ioT ,

eMsIN

.qq E .o11 J .loV ,nimonot

itoriw aoismita3 s!sa3 riommo3 lo onstaieuoouI silT" ,(ôQQ 1) asrbilhO ivS bits •

doAsl toT ,sltsL)I 11 .loV nmoncn'R tsikqK\o \mwt "auonsgobit3 bits bsvioadonU an 283j1q nsqtuO

.1ôE-EE .qq

aia'(lsitA lsoiiiqmll nA :uoiisftitl bits aaoh lo ioivsrlafl silT" ,(QQ1) nobbiaT lsthsu bus lusZ ,rlosj .Q8E-Q4E .qq , .

oW OO1 .

by ,'csono \t\\ok \o k,xnwt ",slsCI ahCI batsgsigsaiU 10

",anoiiibitoD istsM itisnsouU bits ataoD Aitu2 thiw itoiiubov3 'çlaubuF' ,(1QQ1) .3 IsV ,itoadmsj ô21 -IVI. qq ,

I .

oW ,Q .

loV ,n sins%1O \th\zbM \o \timsot

wsM - nvn3ubo no litsmiasvflI Q25! lo iosqmi silT" ,(IQQI) lagsi8 blsuoG bus IitsiI ,iadita3doiJ .Q-EO .qq ,2 .IoV ithptsI imono ",sisu cISU-thZSI bstiJ gitialJ sousbiv3

edT sn 'cdW :sisCI 1sits no asisuthad IsitoiloeB-aaoiD bits asFis2-smiT" ,(OQQI) asup3st ,saa5IisM (.abs) aswuaailT

. 1L bits ,isbbil .C) 1oflsH .1 iii ".c!supa ad '(silT bluoil2 '(4W bits tuatauuiG

.(brislboH-ilnoW) .V.fl aisilaildijq ssitsioe isivsal3 ,ZSbQ ditM io&X tnn ttü \st1 aasi '(iIaIsVLuU sgtwidmsD :ogbndmsD

, rn5k noJ th si zko

, (ô82 1) .3 aiitnocl ,ISIISUM

oc

Page 33: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

anons3rnumrnoo3bT sth iii iiviiouboiq lo aoim (U 3dT" ,(O2Q1) tq bFiA bits fl3V3t2 .0 11O .V21-EbS1 .qq .ô ,4O .!oV *asmoncna "ci1aubriI ta3mqiupa

wt1\o \tnw* "flOnstn33noD Isiflaubitl mon aoaaoJ bus anisE) 31!T" (VVQ1) iiis2 ,nsuxsiloq .EO-2SS.qq 4 .oM ,O .!oV ,nimono3

•aa,i sM1 3db :toY w3M Th1 MO) ,(0821) .a lasrbiM ,13noq

JaomlA iii a3on5wIIiU hq" ,

(QVQ 1) l3ausrlAaaS blsiI3iM bus 321W .

A bivsU .W ncfot ,s1q .11 £-28 I .qq ,EQ

. loV n½moto'sa\o \svniot st ",ato)llsM ovnn3qmoD

\o \wuot °,noiaiaqaiU sthq muiidi!iup3 lo I3boM olqmx2 A" ,(QVQI) .9 n1ifIn31 ,rrwusgni3SI

.88-18 .qq .oM ,V8 .!oV

",3S1Z icojthoiq bus ,aqwhsM ,h'1 iuq3uO" ,(O22I) sniqu3 ns1U baa .

t 1mM ,aflsdoR .1 Q-QOQ .qq ts\E

. acM ,Ot

. by Mtoi brn nsqp1 'usWs5l concn

ooAttwM sV1 ni bus 3lmoInia lo a3Lbut2 ii1wbaI-iotnI" (2821) bisrboi2 ,33an315m1138

.bnslloH-dflol4 :msbisiarnA ,(.abs) gilliW .51 bus 332n31s1n1132 .51 .no sntiO \thtuáM\o

\tnt\ok \o \iwuot "jxoiisiui1noD !istsSl bus noiisllimFl3aiU otht1" ,(I 221) saibitA .bisqsi!2 .E-OE .qq ,1 .oM ,2Q .boV ,'cono

.o14 taô .

IoV ,'tccotcx$. \½ii\cA \o \)tmot "noitsnno1nI 10 a3imono33 31fF" ,(1 021) 3gloeD ,iabgi3a

.qq E

toY woW % ntaitn1 \! ioi'rni\s uY (OVQI) hlsbrii)1 .N aamst bits .1 ogiooD ,iabgii3 223q ViaiovinU sidmuloD

berlailduqiw thw* nttrntM 233 %nQMK tsoinszQ u*wM bsw ¶a*1 (taQQ1) nsl'(U ,sthqis2 .'(iiaI3VfflU 33533 smsvbannaq air!' ,fl01t5t13221b .U.jN

iii ",33113biv3 ath gniaaoaaA :thwoiO y11vi33uboq bits '(nan3goataH" ,

(0221) .51 aanisl. ,iuod'T tsm 'Witnft3o1S ,wownft \o zsnsfl cynifl .ttoD tt3p\s'f%ü ni noim\o'a \&Q%MbZI

2231q ViaiovuiU lnolxO :biolxO , ( .abe) fljocF(T I bus aliedo5l .

M ,suThrQ? s*uM

\tWflU\. "josial mcxii OQfIabiV3 110i3s11111 bits noiWIOqatU o*iT ,(8821) 5251311T ,iiaaaimooH usY .ME1-EOEI .qq ,O .oW ,0Q .bov 1çnonoiilo

",aio*isM 153j315335fffl&Iq iii iioililoqmoD 33hq" ,(E221) aaortsM tiacboSI bus 14 nevoi2 ,anigiW .03ff11111

1€

Page 34: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

I slOT

issY d aoiiudiitaiU thCI iuqruO lo asiuasaM 'cIsrnfnu2

nsoM bommhT (noitshsV 1o tn3iofflooD)

[cwacoM noinoqaiQ iwdoSI]

n3M V821 £821 VVQI £V2l VôQ1 €ôQ1 touboic

£28. VtV. BR. V*€. £2. tt. boow'(I boowthsH (OVSV) (0ô.eô) (0V.0V) (21.02) (28.8V) (VQ.QV) (14.08) ((eiuesem sosltta) ft .pa\Z) R4€S] [lEK] [QV&1 [ttM] (tCS] (OttS] [E1S]

QVV. ati. lot. ttt. bflala i31as'loq iwq2 ?00l (V8.Et) -- (28.Qt) (10.F) (le.te) (O0.8t) -- (.b .niflZ) nonoD dtiw [8tE.l] [808.1] [801.1] [90.1] [F1KI]

V08. F08. EtF. 8t. 00€. boillA S gn1333112 nonoD (l0.oE) -- (Qt.R) (11.8V) (OtSt) (Ot.rF) (EESt) (.b' .niI\Z) aohdti [OeE.l] [8t1] [try.!] [at!.!] [120.1] [20.1]

trt.v IrV.O 0!Qts V0tS £QrS QtrS boW b3rIainiI (0*St) (E8.EE) (08.81) (E0.t.E) (Eo.VE) (rO.OE) (20.F€) (.b'c .nil\Z) aondsI IeisqqA (1t2.] [121.11 [IVo.] [082.] [202.] [yb.!] [IEQ.]

F0. 210. tb. ansD 18312 3tslqnlT (8t.tt) -- -- -- (oQ.Fr) (22.0€) (0.O) (Issla lo zod asd\O00IZ) [EtO.] [Qro.] [toO.] [COO.]

tVF. 80I. V2. 821. By!. FO!. bnoiansqatidW (t8.lE) (QV.EE) (Co.QF) (rO.8r) (22.tr) (Ft.oS) (OE.tt) (41\Z) [QEa.] [0t8.] [02t.] [oto.] [EQt.] [Itt.] [tVK]

!SO. 8€t. 12€. Ot. s€r. t. gniqqizl2 b31z8irnoD (21.1€) (21cc) (10.2€) (CV.Vr) (F22C) (VEEr) (2t.lr) (not notla\000lt) aioiiistnoD [QEt] [tot.] [8tK] [Qtt.] [Eta.] [Eat.] [Vit]

bOOS 02S ttQ.r 014. £0t. £0. aafoD bsiaso2 (1&Vl) (1r1.tr (Qts.Vl) (80.01) (tC.M) (lOt!) (IKOI) (.dI\Z) [0K] QEt] [F2E.] [89.] [toE.] t2t] [20K]

21K FOr. ttl. tt1. gniioofl AsO boowbisH (Ot.FE) -- -- (tO.t8) (0821) (8KtsC) (FtC!) (S bisofl) [1K1 [tBo.] [r8r.] [2E.] [nE.]

£t0. 80. 810. t!0. MO. 315lonoD bexiM-'cbssl (QF.Q1) (Or.VE) (8E.t!) (Qt.E1) (tS.tl) (rr.E!) (0c.0.c) (.b' oiduo\3) [EtC.] [tK] [ttt.] [IrE.] [Ott.] (81€.] [8$.]

9!. 880. ttO. 8t0. boow'lq boowfto2 ioiietnl (cE.rE)

— -- (Ettt) (ItS!) (0a.M) (0r.rn (aiasd "8\E S .pMZ) [OrE.] [SOt] (28€.] [FcC.] [olE.]

£t8fl lQt.QC 000.tb VEC2 BOlt 0E8.F sniloasO iwoM (Vn.Q) (tl.8) (rr.o) (OE.a) (tt.11) (roll) (Ott!) (lsnzd\Z) [rn] [tO!.] [CC!.] [Qt!.] [bar.] [FOE.] [tOE.]

08r. tM o1. nt tniiqawsM (tC.o) -- -- (8KF) (FE2) @1.8) (1KV) (not noda\000!Z) [oM.1 [GM.] [10!.] [VU.] [O!.]

Page 35: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

0•0

0—I

0_s.

c_s.

0t.0_a-

0-u

c_s.

0_s

E!G I: DC02!A G3tW9C O jJG bLCC D!flqPflc!oU

rae our ..aw *j.ai-c —c-s —c.u —c—i —c-s oo cs c—i c-u c-s .rc

cnoI. epsenIC V vnlea npqap)

—50-0

cti

c-s

0_S

0-a

0_u.

0-s.

0-9

OCLJatthI—IeLqA400q IA'ocq

I S—4 0rae oiw u-c.n )t weI

Page 36: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

E!aITLC I(coUct DCXn!A Gapuisçc°L ;pc BL!CG D!2c14pn;!ou

—00 —0-i. —0z 000•0•'04.05030-iUtU.SU.S.Ot.U.n.40..14

.15.434..42

0405.030-i.

05•00oa.

JtJ.00 120 tO'

c)IIttIJU0 bflU SLeflq

roe 01W 4gJ ,Aa saj05 O* 00 00 .10

00120K?'

q)cowlaoxoq ess,bbiua cot'swl.ao.a

— roe o.w UOW at rJ-"—0.0 050_S

Page 37: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

U

ESITLC j(cou;-): DGtIa!;A 62;rws-ç; o ;p EL!CG D!acL!pnc!ou

roe our 4.0W A_a WS*J-.--0* —03 —05 —Oti iro irj Ot 0*3 0t

—0-s00. —0•4

0•5irs.0*0-w-a-c0-s0•5ire.40.14

4-s.

.rc-fleus,t7

esq7'. v.jcxeq CaucLase

S

3

V&0I. QSSOflLIO

rca Dur 41.0w jea j—0't 05 0-0 0-5 0-* 0•c

Page 38: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

aldaT

1uqnO bus 33j1q îü zxoilsiisV ins!q-ththiW bus n33w138

(usam isa' molt noisivab s bsnatqxa aohq tuqiuO)

ins!q-nhutjw ,1151q-ns3wjaa nmlq-thaiw juslq-naswiea 13Ub01'T

33nshsV SOIISIISV aonsiisV aanshsV Qrxl Qal *qnl

E. QM. boowyN boowlyxsH

8.1 X. IN. ioiaa'4oiwqe OO! nofloD iIliw afineiB

Q88. Q1I. ÔI. 8thtseil2nonoD a3fldS baillA

BE. OIU t40. bsai8 nsq a3kIW

V8. Q8E. I StO. I EQ. thqqffl2 beisgunoD aisnisinoD

0. ons o. VI0. aoTloD betasoB

0€?. I V8. Qt0. 00. 3nilooFI AsO boowbisH

08g. eta. OO. tb. oIol3noD iaxiM-tbsaM

Ba?. .I ISO. £10. boowxN boowfto2

1. è00. t0O. aniloasf) ioloM

44E. VB$. £00. £00. uthqaw3M

Page 39: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

- qo uoz Lclccg tjmj w bLoboi,jrou cdnej2 ' si gpo ' rrnLIcsucc JCACJ p - qo UOj LOIGCI qng gpo btobowou cdsrsia '32 1 tJJC '02 2Iqpcsucc JCAcJ

L40M2bU1u '238 '38?, '0.11 'Jb3 '.110 '00.1 '000 '39.1 '.133

W010L b2OJIIJC '308 '303 '500P •530 '213 '30.1 149 '499, '388

pJICL!OL ajjmooq bjkitooq '483 '440, 0Q.1 '181 220. '39O 'ITO '432, '499

gcsql-uiwcq coijotoro '202 '40.1 '088 '109 '203 '313 '000 '439 '4.12

HsLqMooqOslcooL R31 '3.1?, '104 'J85 '952 '1O3 '130 '42.1. •4T3

KOS2LCqCOaGC '450 '438, '133 '1,14 '90! '332 '138 '420, '404

COU(SIIJCL2

coanstoq abbnj '201 '433 '0.12 '18,1 '210 '104 '0.13 '302

ft,pjIcbsupLcsq '20! '3.14 '152 '148 '23.1 '312 '083 '383

.vubjstc 2iCCj csu '210 '503 '008 '1.12 '231 '103 '042 '403,

uzpcq iooj sbhsLcJ 14SUC2 '230 '325, ll8 '5O2 '24.1. 'I4.1 '025 '398,

jppLic2COUOU 2JJCCLIU suq Sjj!cq '238 '404, '028 '113 '1.13 '093 '522

!W COLiOU

1oo abw bojAcaroL pcuqa '432 '210. '022 '124 '.142 '000 '13? '308 '228

HstqmooqbjkMooq '83? '141 '054 '110 '.110 '1.11 '030 '330 '235

wt+!Ut+\ dnsLpjc2 t+\ iut+ t+idffsIqjc IMO dnsuc ju dnsuc w dnw.tgca !U dnngqc dlmu!jc dantitca u dsmujc u

btoqnct H!UC21 Aj1qqG rOMoat H!P6at N!qqIO LMO OMC2I H!IJC2t ypqqjc LMO rOtAC2tbuco dnsuqc u Acsi. tBISUt2 w w°

b4cc dasugc p1 ACSLb11U2 flJ gpo uiiqqjc MQ

bucc dnsugc !U AcsthISUt2 !11 LJJC fOMG2t

ILSIJ2II!Ou Jf5Z02 fCLO2 OtubiTi b4cC O14!1C2

ISPIG 3

Page 40: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

O1OL s2OIWC

JGACJ

(.03Q)-t3� 8J

(to® (ooo) (too) (too)-t04 t03 t08 •002

IUtct!OL 20JM00q bjAmooqtoso) to3j) ton) (tao)Oo*s -033 -0O1** -113** 1? QO** !.X1X+ 520 418 •!3

csqX-mzcq couciss(.003) tooi) too't) Coo?)04Q** -052** -t?o** -0bQss 155O?n 1Jo•O3** M�0** TJ3QO t4

stqooq OSJC U00LMCoto) (o'14) (o'tQ) (o't)

lOXs* -735*s -T3T* -1.X2*s

ton) ('ots) tom) (oio)O4.*s -03J -o,so** -o8a 858*4'

COIJWIUCL2

COLLfl9t6q 2p4bbIJ(too) (.oii) torn) torn)13Q** -!1O** -!8** -540* S4SOO** nni gg4 4?S1

MJJ!i bsv ptcsq(oii) tort) tora) tora)•001*. -.ne -.13Oi* 11.oo** •0Q 580.X •O2

I!UbIEG 2ICCf

1jJJCq Mooj ¶fbbSLCl PL!C

(•2) toas) toso) toao)01X -•03 -OQ1** -'0*0.

toQo) ('ooo) toss) COB?)

'581.. -'338.* -343** -43Q..

WPL!C2

cottou apcctd suqto?® taxi) ton) tax®'513*. -'P0*. -'354*. -30** 33,s •0o

4tJJ COffOIJ

100 gbnii bojlc2LcL pjauqa('o2Q) (•oxs) ('o.x) toQo)'500*. -'023 -•5?B** -4?0**

(•j)'255*.V

toss)-'412*.

V

(.)-'533*.V

(.)-'032*.V

J•43 !0'50** 13'31** 3Q5 '1?

cbcuqous t(afUUqsLq CLLOL2 ! bstcuwcc)nthnr bUCC DHIIPLGUCC2 pA 2!SC OUSU!1C

IPPI6 I

** 2!D!UCUU1 St jjIC a = 0? JCACf * 2!WII!L!CSIJL St

wcMthLrni

tpca= 'JCost) COW) toss)•054 -taR

•53 '51

QX

'12 024 001

gosatcq COC6

I '.x'II '2.1

2'21**

580 0?

'31 .525 04

135 40

I W

.515 '01

5'04

stqmooq bjAmooq.onq

QO'02** 3140*. T0'82** 401 33

\?=W=\'=o =\='' \=V oc g

Page 41: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

** 2!UiUC9IJL t CJJC = 02 fGAGJ * 2!k!LICSTJL 1 jJJC U = J I6'C1

Cocw) C0QQ) to8?) CoQo)008** -041 -128 -50i**

WOIOL 92OflUG

Cow) Cots) (*jg) Cots)-023* 0?O** OX2** 054s* 0R4 018 •03

utcqoL 2OMOO bAtaooqC02i) Coos) CoQo) (•oa)38t** -3?S -21!** -2Q5** 3TS5** 5t133*s IQS ?�

gGsqA-uJwcq COIJOLCICCorn) (ots) Cots) Cois)•000 -030*s -03S* 0!2 Q*42** irson 1Q05** QO't? 01

stqmooq oar IJOOLMC0Q3) (*oss) Cog® Co84)531*s

-.102** -25*. -314** 00,X 500 11

gos2icq cogpcCoss) Coss) Coss) Co3o)113*. -lOT.. -JSS*, -S55*s !0Q8.. IflS*. Q3S 08

COUWfIJCL2

COLUfStGq 2JJ1bbRJCots) Con) Con) Con)•OSQ.* -058** -05Q** -023*. 10?Q** 4303 01

MJJ!(6 b&iipcaqCoit) Con) Con) Cow)13?.. -131*. i85** -531** QV2o** 5213*. iFS?.. 3Q38 00

iwbisrc 2LC0J 09112Co32) Con) Co45) Co'u)-034 055 •032 08T**

t9PLCCOUOIJ 2JJCC111J aug sfltcq

C0Q2) Coss) Coso) CosQ)ss4.* •535 ..4fl -$48.. 012.. Q*O4** 053 5OX •11

/#JW 0011011

1OOà 2blllJ bofXczwL pjcuqaCoe® Coss) Cos?) CosQ)

- 3?4 -?5?.* -QQ?*.

301st

VCost)-514*.V

1315.. .IQi.. 5Q8 5o

Dobduqu An!ap1c: u yç"(arsuqstq CLL0L !IJ hsLcuIpc2c?)

NSI2IIJBT cor DIIJPLCUCCZ pA 2!' Ofla1J!I0JPPIG

MCM25LUJL 040 45 •34

IRQ

Hnqooq bjAmoog

rio QQO 01

\,LOcVCt

(.I0Q)-520..

\:.3R1** 086 031 5.55 0?\t=V=\=o W=V=\' '=\' ocw g

Page 42: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

** 2!Ufl!C&ut St IJJC = 02 JCACJ' * 2!IJ!UCSIU t LJ U = •1 JCAQf

(1J45) (O?o) UOXQ) UO�8)MCM2bUIJt -.O8Q** 012 !40* i8*s 3'?3n 4R5s 3 42 S

NOfOt 8520jfflGtot?) tote)010 -053

tote)-030

tote)-035 0Z 01? O MR to

iuo ogooq bjAMooqtoes) toi)-03+ 58&.

(*oxi)3O**

(uss)tS** 50Q1** 5103s* FC4S*s 121 45

gcsql-irnzcq COUCLCtG(oto) tors)os.* •oJa

ton)-O55

tori)-MoOn ltQQn SW53 r8h+ 204? o3

HqtOOq OSJC 4JOOUUtoes) t080)-7?O** 105

toBt)•.X**

toB!t)510n T3Xn 133* 0•OX 500 tQ

gog2zcqcoucctos3) Case)*O?0** •04?

toso)M41

toar)•JJ?n 3.13** (22* .VQ2n 211 MS

COUW1UCL

cowstcq ajnbbrn(too) tots)•iJS OoQ

torn)T24.

torn)-•J80n 1408?** QQOOn ifl2n 4303 73

MptG bwz ptcsqton) tote)-0?.1** •0?4**

tow)090**

toi)J08** 1o20** 284** Q45** 5238 MS

iwbisrc Sjccf C5112

toss) ton)•oti -'oa

('on)-'024

to3s)-os+ 1XQ VOl 220 01

jypLrn2

COUOIJ 2JJCGf1IJ suq SJcqtoo) toxo)•0J4 •O50

tosr)-•05X

toss)O2Q 083 1*2? 035 SM Mi

mnp cottonl0O bnUhoJXcetcLp[cuq2

toxo) toxs)-FQ3** 5JS**

tax®iox

toxe)flSn 043 O'82 528 •02

to24) tos3)'305** 3Oe**

toes)*22i**

(.oet)-'x0OuLqmooq bj?ooq

b.Ot*Ct34'Ol** SORO,, 3'28* 5,15 '3't=W=V=o \=W=\S' \=\ O K5

cbcuqcur ASL!splc: U (\ \ JIC *(2tSnqstq GLLOL2 !U bIcuUpc2ca)

kAlSLJCflb D!UPLGUCC2 pA 2!tC Ofl91.t!1C

LUPIG Q

Page 43: SHHM siaa - National Bureau of Economic Research · SHHM owixiow siaa arnina TUT1JO fl151q GMA UX5JAM MOIa5IdaIU MI OSIDIM :ATAC JHT aaaosi IO siaauuosi YTIHMHDOSIHTHH UMA 3210M AmM

S - go not LcI•6cf ipsi ipo btobowou 6dr1912 st rpc o2 nmucsucc J6ACj p - go uoj Lc1;ct LJJSt tJJG btobou!ou cdns'j 5 S flJC '0? 21IJ!UCWJCC II

LAIOgOL 92OJWC J01 O? RX3 '110 433g

1IJ$401 2OMOO bfAMoog •tU 3?3, 1aQ J3? ?23, 'J?4 'thjçcsqA-wpecq COUCLCIC 3ÔQ *SQ, 15Ô 184 'QJ't 505 0Q

SLqOOq Osy U°°'4" tXQ isa, 'Oô? ?QS 1ô1 '03.1 333. Q30

otq C0J45G ?O2 3Ô8 'OM s?o '2ct3. S0.XP 0ôct 10Q, R00

COIJWIIJCL2

oLL1ISicq 2p!bbnJ 4ÔJ i10 '0ô 133 QJJ 5??P '0.1? 48S i38

ffjflicbsupLcsg ?41 3Q3 0ôQ TQ4 Q31 504 '0ô8 3.IQ

iwbjic 2rccJ csu ogg T? 3?S '083 3Ô3

SpUC2C°W" 2p€Gt1U sug Ji!1 400g J33

M!W COflOU

100 2bu bOPC2LCL jCIJ2 4QÔ 438 0o4 31O 112P uç 308

siqmooqbjAmooq cjg 81, .jJJ 111 0.IJ 5J4 114

p'wt--1 drw'4!jca t+\ t+% !u+\dcni.tqc uto w dcnapjc us dini.qjc pi dnsuic &nuqca us dnzuiic

wqnq LAINEI!C rOMGt H!WIJG2( gq}c tMO fOMG2L p621 y.jxgqjc fMO fOMC2jwnjcrih dnsuxjc in Acst t

b19112 P' LJ P!V1JGL

muqcnb danpjc2 in Aest t4116 mqqc IMO

wsqcnb dsmu!Jc rn AcSL

b19U12 us rye j0M624

LL9112!t!OU ff9162 CLO22 OJrn4!Ic2 Oi 4110 qsqmb D!24L!PJU!OU

L3PIC .1