should the state play nanny? bob reitemeier chief executive the childrens society london 26 november...
TRANSCRIPT
Should the State Play Nanny?
Bob ReitemeierChief Executive
The Children’s Society
London26 November 2004
With children, for children, with you
What do we mean by ‘nanny’?
• The state, the parent and the child
• Policy areas, eg Choosing Health
• Regulation of industry / Influencing behaviour
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
“Nanny” – Oxford dictionary
Noun:
1. A woman employed to look after a child in its own home.
2. A female goat.
Adjective:
Interfering and overprotective: the nanny state.
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
The relationship between parent & child
• Every Child Matters and the Children Act
• We must do better
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
The roles of the state
• Enabler
• Corporate parent
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
The state as an enabler
• What is the role of the state as an enabler?
• What is causing us to revisit this role today?
• What should change as a result?
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
The state as an enabler
• Providing restrictions, eg physical punishment of children
• Providing an enabling environment within which parent – child relationships can prosper.
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
Why revisit the state’s role today?
• Beyond children’s services reform.
• Changes in what we mean by ‘childhood’
• Welfare state => Thatcherism => Today?
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
Family THEN NOW
Mortality: under 5 yrs old (1960) 27 per 1000 7 per 1000 (2002)
Mortality: under 1 yrs old (1960) 23 per 1000 5 per 1000 (2002)
Proportion of lone parent HHs (1971) 3% 6% (1991)
Divorces (1950) 40,000 157,000 (2001)
Children under the age of 16 (1971) 14.3m 12.1m (2000)
What is different?
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
1951-55 1996-00Births: Outside marriage
15-19 year olds 141,000 258,00020-44 year olds 837,000 1,160,000Total 978,000 (6%) 1,418,000 (42%)
Within marriage15-19 year olds 499,000 31,00020-44 year olds 14,266,000 1,922,000Total 15,743,000 (94%) 3,371,000 (58%)
Births to teenage mothers 59,000 (2000)
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
What is different?
Drug Use 1998
2003Used drugs in the last year
11-15 year olds - all drugs 11% 21%11-15 year olds - cannabis 7% 13%
16-24 year olds - all drugs 29% 28%16-24 year olds - cannabis 29% 26%
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
What is different?
TV, Computer, Mobile Phones
Access to TV 99% of households have access to TV
Access to computer 4/5 CYP have access to home computer
Access to internet >50% of CYP have access to internet (home)
Mobile phones <20% of primary age CYP have phones
60% of secondary age CYP have phones
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
What is different?
Diet and health
Obesity Childhood obesity - tripled in last 20 years
Food industry Global advertising budget is $40 billion.
Advertising: Greater than the GDP of 70% of countries.
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
What is different?
Nuffield StudyNuffield Study: Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, Nov. 2004
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
1974 Boys 1974 Girls 1986 Boys 1986 Girls 1999 Boys 1999 Girls
7.6%
6.0%
12.1%
8.6%
16.7%
13.1%
11.1%
6.6%
8.3%
5.7%
16.9%
7.1%7.8% 7.8%
13.3%12.8% 13.4%
20.4%
Behaviour Hyperactivity Emotional0.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
% with difficulties
Stress and mental health
Norwich Union Healthcare study, 400 parents surveyed, all with children between the ages of 5 and 15:
78% felt their CYP were under greater pressure than they experienced.
24% felt out of touch or distant from their children.
74% worried that lack of communication in families => problems.
58% did not know where to go for help.
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
What is different?
Data we do not yet have…
ADD / ADHD and its link to diet, artificial additives, zinc, fatty acids, genetic predisposition…
The increasing levels of anxiety experienced by teenagers – is the same phenomenon occurring with younger children?
What is the cumulative impact of ‘environmental’ changes on our children?
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
What is different?
What should change as a result?
Parents and children require more and different help than is currently provided.
– Childhood, and therefore parenting, is more complex.– We need to better understand the needs of both.– We need to better understand the rights of both.– We need to better understand the environment we live in.
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
What should change as a result?
• Enable the individual relationship between the child and the primary carer to develop.
• Emphasise the first year of life, eg brain development and stress.
• Enable and support the parent – AND involve children!
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
What should change as a result?
• Invest significantly in community facilitators.
• Parent to parent works better than state to parent.
• Present children positively – by the government and the press.
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
Love and care for our children.
Enable parents to be better carers, better teachers.
Every child should be made to feel precious.
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
This does not describe a nanny state.
This is a caring state.
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you
The Children’s Society
With children, for children, with you
We look at the world through the eyes of children and
never flinch from what we see.
Mortality rates: www.unicef.org/infobycountry/uk-statistics.htmlBirths 1951-2000: Births, 1938-2002, Office of National Statistics.Population: Social Focus in Brief: Children 2002, Office of National Statistics, 2002.Drug Use: Department of Health Statistical Bulletin: Statistics on Young People and Drug Use
1998, Office of National Statistics: 1998.Department of Health Statistical Bulletin: Statistics on Young People and Drug Use2003, Office of National Statistics: 2003.
Access to Technology: Social Focus in Brief: Children 2002, Office of National Statistics: 2002.Obesity: House of Commons Obesity Report, Health Committee Press Release, 26 May 04.Food Marketing: Broadcasting Bad Health: Why food marketing to children needs to be controlled, A
report by the International Association of Consumer Food Organisations (IAFCO)for the World Health Organisation consultation on a global strategy for diet and health, IAFCO, July 2003.
Parents on Children’s Health: BBC on-line report on the Norwich Union Healthcare study, October 2004.
List of Sources
Should the State Play Nanny?
With children, for children, with you