should we perform mass screening for af€¦ · paroxysmal af than chances of catching non...
TRANSCRIPT
ShouldweperformmassscreeningforAF?
IsabelleNaultMDCardiacElectrophysiologist
IUCPQ
ScreeningforAF
• Whoshouldwescreen?
• Howshouldweperformscreening?
Wilsoncriteriaforscreening
• CondiEonshouldbeanimportanthealthproblem• NaturalhistoryofthecondiEonshouldbeunderstood• ThereshouldbearecognisablelatentorearlysymptomaEcstage
• Thereshouldbeatesteasytoperformandinterpret,acceptable,accurate,reliable,sensiEveandspecific
• Thereshouldbeanacceptabletreatment• Policyonwhoshouldbetreated• Diagnosisandtreatmentcost-effecEve• Case-findingshouldbeaconEnuousprocess
AF:FrequentHealthproblem
• LifeEmeriskofdevelopingAFinpaEents>40yis1in4
• Lloyd-Jonesetal,Circula4on2004• FromtheFraminghamHeartStudy
• Upto75%ofpeopledonotexperiencesymptomswhileinAF
• Israeletal,JACC2004
Stroke:Importanthealthproblem• 20%ofCVAsareaZributabletoatrialfibrillaEon
• DuringAF,anEcoagulaEondiminishestheriskofembolismsby2/3
– Hartetal,AnnInternMed2007;146
• 25%ofCVAsarecryptogenic,orofundeterminedsource
– Hartetal,LancetNeurol2014;13
• WithAF,theannualrateofCVAsis4.5%– ArchInternMed,1994;154:1449-57
PrevalenceofsilentAF
• DependsonthescreenedpopulaEon– Age– Comorbidity– Recipientofpacemakerordefibrillator– RecentCVAorTIA– Historyofarrhythmia
• HoweverdependsmostlyonduraEonofmonitoring
SEARCH-AF
• 1000paEents,age>65y• Pharmacyscreening• iECG
– AliveCorKardia• NewlyidenEfiedAFin1.5%
Lowres et an, Thromb Haemonst 2014
OpportunisEcscreening
• Screenedsubjects– OutpaEentclinic–WatchBPandAliveCor– ≥65yearswithdiabetesorHTN– 1.17%incidenceofAF– Increaseswithage(0.1%<65years,0.9%65-74,3%≥75years)
• 65yearsandmore– SystemaEcreview–30studies– 1.4%,numberneededtoscreen70
Chanetal,Circula4on2016
Lowresetal,ThrombHaemost2013
STROKESTOPStudy
• PopulaEonscreeninginpaEentswithoutknownAF
• Individualsbornin1936-1937(75and76yattheEmeofthestudy)inSweden
• 13331invitaEontoparEcipate,53.8%accepted• IndexECG,twicedailyECGwithhandheldECGrecorderfor2weeks
• NewAFdetectedin3.0%ofpaEents• 0.5%ofnewlydiagnosedAFwasfoundonindexECG
SubclinicalAF
• 65yearsandmore– WithelevatedNTproBNPorLAEandCHADSVASc≥2orsleepapneaorBMI≥30
– 256paEents– ConEnuoussubcutaneousmonitoring– Meanfollowup16±4months– AFdetecEonrate34.4%(duraEonfiveminutesormore)
Healeyetal,Circula4on2017
Long-termmonitoring
Embrace,NEJM,2014
Compliance:82%ofsubjectscompleted>3weeksofmonitoringPopulaEonofpaEentswithcryptogenicstroke
AnEcoagulaEonbegunin18.6%ofpaEentsintheexperimentalgroupvs11.1%inthecontrolgroup
PrevalenceofsilentAF:PaEentswithPacemakerorDefibrillator
Dilaverisetal,ClinicalCardiology2017
ConsequencesofsilentAF
• Onestudy5550paEentswithasymptomaEcAF
• Adjustedstrokeratein1460untreatedpaEents:4%comparedto1%inmatchedcontrolwithoutAF
• StrokeriskintreatedvsuntreatedpaEents:1%vs4%
Martinez et al, Thrombos Haemost 2014
SCREENING/MONITORINGDEVICES
Holter
Recording duration 24 hrs/48 hrs/7 days depending on model
Cardiostat-IcenEaConEnuousrecordingduraEonupto14days1leadShowerresistantReplaceableelectrodes
Ziopatch-iRhythm
Continuous monitoring Duration of monitoring up to 14 days Repositioning not recommended
Not available in Canada
SEEQ-MedtronicContinuous telemetry system Data transmitted to Medtronic analysis centre Analysis/notification 24/7
Not available clinically in Canada
Monitoring duration up to 30 days
SpiderFlashExternalLoopRecorder(ELR)EventrecorderRecordsupto40days(lithiumbaZery)or15days(alkalinebaZery)Upto25hoursofECG2leadsOthercompanieshavesimilarproducts(KingofHearts,Braemar)AnalysisbymedicalelectrophysiologytechnicianmaytakealotofEme
InternalLoopRecorder
EventmonitorBaZerylife:upto3years
AliveCorKardia
ApprovedbyFDAandHealthCanada
SEARCH-AFstudy1000paEentsPharmacyscreeningNewAFdiagnosisin1.5%AutomaEcAFdetecEonalgorithmSensiEvity98.5%Specificity91.4%
Lowresetal,ThrombHaemost2014
iPhone80paEents:40sinusrhythm,40AFComparedtoECG
Filterandrecording2minutes:SensiEvity87.5%andspecificity95%Filterandrecording5minutes:SensiEvity95%andspecificity95%
Krivosheietal,EuropaceMay2017
CardiioRhythm
AFdiagnosEcbasedonabsenceofrepeatpaZern
CardiioRhythmsensi;vity93%,specificity98%,PPV53%,NPV99%AliveCorsensi;vity71%,specificity99%,PPV77%,NPV99%
Chanetal,Circula4on2016
PULSE-SMART
Pre-andpostCVETwo-minuterecordingComparedtotelemetry
McManusetal,JCEJanuary2016
AliveCorvsWatchBPOfficeAFIB
Chan et al, Circulation 2012; 135
*Photo not indicative, device tested Watch BP Office and not Watch BP Home
Freedman et al, Circulation 2017
Newtechnologies
• Thetechmarketisextremelyinvestedinhealthandagreatmanyofthetoolsthathavecomeavailablearethesubjectofmedicalstudies
• Wecanexpectothertechnologiessoon– Watches– Bracelets– Smartclothing
• PosiEvescreeningrequireECGconfirmaEon
Smartphones
• 64%ofadultshaveasmartphone
• 50-64years:54%
• >65years:>27%
http://www.pewinternet.org/2015/04/01/us-smartphone-use-in-2015
ShouldwescreenforAF?
• AFisooenasymptomaEcorpresentswithatypicalsymptoms
• Thereisatreatementproventoreducemorbidity
• Therearecheap,noninvasive,availableandreliablemeansforscreening
• SoYES!
CostEffecEveness
• BasedondatafromSTROKESTOPstudy• Casebasedscenariofor1000paEents(75-76Y)• 263lesspaEentswithundetectedAF• 8fewerstrokes• 11morelife-years• 12morequalityadjustedlifeyear(QALY)• 4313€perQUALY• 6583€peravoidedstroke
Aronsson et al, Europace 2015
ESCguidelines
Argumentsagainstscreening
• ThereisincreasingevidencethatthereisliZletemporalcorrelaEonbetweenAFandstroke
• AlthoughweknowanEcoagulaEonreducesstrokeriskinpaEentswithAF,wedonotknowifanEcoagulaEonalterstheriskofstrokeinpaEentswithshortduraEonsilentatrialarrhythmia(ongoingstudies)–theduraEonthresholdforanEcoagulaEonisnotyetclear
• Maybetheanswerfornowliesinthemethodofscreening
• LongduraEonmonitoringinpaEentswithoutpreviousstrokeinwhomshortduraEonAFisdetectedmaybringmorequesEonsthananswers
• LongduraEonmonitoringforAFinpaEentswithESUSisrequired
• InpaEentswithoutstroke:
• Thereis86400secondsinoneday.
• Chancesthata30secondsmonitoringwillcatchashortduraEonnonsignificantAFisquitesmall.MorechancesofmissingparoxysmalAFthanchancesofcatchingnonsignificantAF.
Screening
• OpportunisEcscreeninginpaEents≥65YORCHADSscore≥1usingashortduraEonrhythmstrip/ECG/pulsetaking– HandheldECGseemsthebestapproach–othermeans(pulsepalpaEon,pulseoxymetry)needECGconfirmaEon
• LongerduraEonscreeninginhighriskpaEents–aoerESUS–nexttalk!
• AreasforconsideraEonforlongerduraEonalthoughnorecommendaEon– Sleepapnea,heartfailure,largeleoatrium,highPACburden
Finalword
• ScreeningforAFshouldbeperformed• DuraEonofrecordingshoulddependonunderlyingriskofstroke/AF
• ThereisanurgentneedtobeZerdefinetreatmentthresholdforshortAFepisodeslessthan24hinpaEentswithoutpriorstroke
• Withtechnologicalprogress,conEnuousmonitoringwithwatches/braceletswillsoonbeavailableandthequesEonwhethertheAFburdenneededtoiniEateanEcoagulaEonwillextendbeyondthepacemakerclinic