simulation and optimization of automatic generation control under deregulation

8/3/2019 Simulation and Optimization of Automatic Generation Control Under Deregulation

1/29

$&% !%%

&%% #% %#

#&%

!%#

%#&%

#8.,05407889028,703472,2,3,0/-;03902,8-03

2,/0:541.43974,70,893907.4330.9438-09003902,..43974,70,

2:8920099843/02,3/,3/988.0/:0/3907.,3054073282,9.

-09003900307,943,3/4,/.,3-04-807;0/-20,3841,/0;,94331706:03.(%8-,,3.3-090034,/,3/0307,943.,3-0,.0;0/-

:83:942,9.0307,94343974

39830/070:,90/03;7432039904507,943415407889025480

831.,39574-028415:7090.3.,3,9:70%082501706:03..43974

84209208 -0.4208 .,033 03 25020390/ 43 90 570280 41 57.0

-,80/4507,943,3/2,709/7;03/02,3/%0-,8.570280419070:,947

54.08 8 94 ,4 .42509943 ,243 0307,9478 ,3/ 94 .70,90 2,709

.43/9438 3 90 80.947 8003 ,8 30.088,7 .43/9438 147 3.70,83 90

011.03.4100.97.0307574/:.943,3//897-:943411073,40757.0

076:,9,3/247080.:70574/:.9

%00330073,850.98415,333,3/4507,943,;0-003701472:,90/3,

70897:.9:70/ 5407 88902 370.039 0,78,94: 088039, /0,8 702,3 90

8,20%4 2574;0 90 011.03. 3 90 4507,943 41 90 5407 88902 84202,47.,30839490897:.9:704100.97.5407:9908,;0-0033974/:.0/

-20,3841/070:,93903/:897,3/450339:59457;,90.42509943

%0:9908344307430307,94397,3828843,3//897-:9433890,/

9070 ,70 9700 /1107039 039908 ; 0307,943 .425,308


2/29

%#$897,3828843.425,308,3/$8/897-:943.425,308

8 9070 ,70 80;07, 8 ,3/ $8 3 90 /070:,90/ 897:.9:70 ,

$,8901700/4294,;0,.4397,.99,314797,38,.94341

5407$2,,;0,.4397,.99,3,34907.43974,70,$:.97,38,.9438,70.,0/-,907,97,38,.94389097,38,.9438,;094

-0.0,70/974:,325,79,0399.,0/,33/0503/039889024507,947

$%0$,894.43974,3:2-074184.,0/,3.,7807;.0843041

. 8 30 41 90 2489 57419,-0 ,3.,7 807;.08 8 90 4,/

1706:03..43974%02,34,41908942,39,3074890,/89,90

0774781471706:03./0;,943,3/2320:38.0/:0/90305407148

-0900330-473.43974,70,8990020703.04190/893.9418%#$8$8,3/90

$2,34190,3.,7807;.0841,'079.,3907,90/&99'&

,;0,/1107039 740945,,3/03.0,;094-024/00//11070393 90

70897:.9:70/47/070:,90/03;7432039;079.,3907,90/:9908344307

089

3985,50701472:,909094,70,/3,2.24/0$50.1.,014.:8

43 90 /3,2.8 ,3/ 5,7,20907 4592,943 %0 .43.059 41 , $5,79.5,943 2,97 ! 8 5745480/ . 058 90 ;8:,,943 ,3/

2502039,943 41 90 .4397,.98 %0 31472,943 14 41 90 .4397,.98 8

8:50725480/439097,/943,88902,3/9082:,943870;0,8420

390708935,990738

!%#


3/29

&%%#%%#

034,/390889023.70,8089:7-308500//7458-01470904;07347.,3

,/:899035:9890.,30390;,:0418500//0.70,808900774783,

-0.420882,07,3/905489438414;07347;,;009.4809490706:70/548943942,39,3.4389,398500/40;0790.4389,398500/349-090

8095439,3/9070-0,3411809944;07.42098574-02,33907,9478

,//0/.,:942,9.,,/:89900307,943947089470901706:03.94

983423,;,:0%88.0208.,0/,:942,9.0307,943.43974

%074041894/;/0904,/8,243908890289,943,3/0307,947

94 ,.0;0 2,2:2 0.4342 ,3/ ,..:7,90 .43974 41 90 8.0/:0/

3907.,308 41 9030 5407 0 2,39,33 , 70,843,-9 :314721706:03. 4/073 5407 88902 30947 .438898 41 , 3:2-07 41 :9908

3907.4330.90/940907,3/540780.,30/-09003:99084;0790308

-.90,70.4330.90/:942,9.0307,943.439745,8,;07

25479,39 740 3 5407 88902 ,8 98 2,3 740 8 94 2,39,3 90 88902

1706:03.,3/903014,99078.0/:0/;,:08/:733472,5074/

:942,9. 0307,943 .43974 9 572,7 8500/.43974 ,.943 , .,30 3

88902 4,/ 708:9 3, 890,/ 89,90 1706:03./0;,943/0503/3 :543

4;07347 /7445 .,7,.90789.8 ,3/ 1706:03. 80389;9 41 90 4,/

0307,93 :398 43 8500/ 4;0733 .4397-:90 94 4;07, .,30 3

7,943 770850.9;0 41 90 4.,943 41 90 4,/ .,30 #08947,943 41 90

889021706:03.943423,;,:0706:7088:5502039,7.43974,.943.

,/:898 90 4,/ 7010703.0 809 5439 %0701470 90 572,7 4-0.9;08 41 90

,:942,9.0307,943.43974,709470:,901706:03.94903423,;,:0,3/942,39,3903907.,305407-09003.43974,70,8,9908.0/:0/;,:08

- ,/:893 90 4:95:9 41 800.90/ 0307,9478 %8 1:3.943 8 .42243

7010770/94,84,/1706:03..43974


4/29

80.43/,74-0.9;0894/897-:9090706:70/.,3030307,943,243

90:398942320904507,93.4898

0307,9433,703907.4330.90/540788902.4257808419072,/74

3:.0,7,3/,854070307,943:.0,7:3984394907011.03.,70 :8:, 059 ,9 -,80 4,/ .480 94 907 2,2:2 4:95:9 9 34

5,79.5,943 3 88902 ,:942,9. 0307,943 .43974 ,8 5407

0307,9438/0,14720093;,734,//02,3/40;078:.5,398/4

349 5, ;07 831.,39 740 3 41 , ,70 5407 88902 83.0 9080

5,3981472,;0782,507.039,041949,889020307,943,85,398,70

:80/ 94 2009 50, /02,3/8 43 %:8 90 3,9:7, .4.0 147 1,8 43

09079072,47/74:3983 3907.4330.90/ 5407 88902 .,3 -0 .438/070/ ,8 -03 /;/0/ 394

.43974,70,8.,70.4330.90/-9030830,..43974,70,,0307,947

8098,70,88:20/941472,.40703974:5%054078890288:-0.90/94

4.,;,7,9438 41 7,3/42 2,39:/08 ,3/ /:7,9438 03.0 98706:70/ 94

.4397490/0;,9438411706:03.,3/90305407410,..43974,70,

3 ,.9:, 5407 88902 4507,9438 90 4,/ 8 .,33 .4393:4:8 ,3/

7,3/42890,-941900307,9439497,.90.,334,/8290//:09458.,90.3.,.438/07,94389070708:98,32-,,3.0-0900390

,.9:, ,3/ 90 8.0/:0/ 0307,943 6:,39908 %8 2-,,3.0 0,/8 94 ,

1706:03. 07747 0 90 /110703.0 -09003 90 ,.9:, ,3/ 90 83.7434:8

1706:03.%02,39:/041901706:03.077478,33/.,9434140

905407889028.,5,-094-,,3.090,.9:,,3/908.0/:0/0307,943

%0570803.041,3,.9:,8.0/:0/0307,9432-,,3.0;0878039,94

889021706:03.0.:784383,..47/,3.094908341902-,,3.0,3/,.9

9470/:.0902,39:/041,.9:,8.0/:0/0307,9432-,,3.0

.4397483,2,/0:541903014/0;,943,//0/941706:03./0;,943

090/-,-,81,.9474:/,..425890/0870/4-0.9;0%8.43974


5/29

83,8343,8,70,.4397407747807;08943/.,9003949,

0307,9432:89-07,80/474070/3,.43974,70,

3,33907.4330.9439070,702,3.43974,70,80,.41.5071472898

9 90 4-0.9;0 41 2,39,33 902,39:/0 41 ,70, 4397477478:11.039.48094:83;,74:8.7907,

3 47/07 942,39,3 90 1706:03. 8:11.039 .4809498 83.7434:8;,:0

4;0790039703907.4330.94390.447/3,9434190.43974,70,8,.94388

706:70/80,..43974,70,8,7083907085438-91474,/1706:03.

.43974 0110.9;0 20,38 ,70 300/0/ 1472439473,3/ ,880883 0,. ,70,8

5071472,3.04198,557457,908,7034,/1706:03..43974

4/07354078890230947.43889841,3:2-0741:99083907.4330.90/940907,3/540780.,30/-09003:99084;0790308-.90

,70.4330.90/:942,9.0307,943.439745,8,;0725479,39740

3540788902982,37408942,39,390889021706:03.,3/9030

14 ,9 907 8.0/:0/ ;,:08 /:73 3472, 5074/ :73 ,70 97,38039

/89:7-,3.0,3/020703.088-5,880/,3/4907020703..43974

9,084;07 %0 83.743,943 41 /1107039 88902 94 3907.4330.90/ 88902

/0503/8:543;49,02,39:/01706:03.,3/5,80806:03.03/0/0;,943 1742 90 3423, ;,:0 41 1706:03.47;49,0 0,/ 90

8890294949,.4,58003.0,8,30/25479,3.099074941

3907.4330.90/889028,3/

9780380413907.4330.90/88902,:942,9434190.4397488902,;0

,74:80/ 3:2-07 41 .43974 897,9008 089 94 ,.0;0 -09907 5071472,3.0

:09434330,7941540788902889025,7,209078,70 30,70/,74:3/

,3 4507,93 5439 ! .4397407 8 0307, :80/ %0 /8,/;,39,0 41 !

.439740789,9902,902,9.,24/04190.43974574.0882,34908947

2,-094405038;039072841.425:907574.088354078,3/20247

!071472,3.041:3/073472,,3/,-3472,.43/9438


6/29

&3/073472,.43/943890,.,70,,-094.,774:998.439744-,9438

890,/89,90.4770.9;0,.943418.43130/9490,70,07090/01.947

0.088 41 0307,943 4..:78 3907 ,70, 5407 97,381078 ,70 2,39,30/ ,9

8.0/:0/0;08,3/889021706:03.80/.4389,39&3/07,-3472,.43/9438430472470,70,82,-0,-094.4770.914790

0307,9434,/282,9. /:0 94 38:11.039 0307,943 70807;0 43 3

8:.,30;0394907,70,8,8889-5072993903907,70,8540797,38107894

/0;,9017428.0/:0/;,:08,3/-,43889021706:03.94/05,791742

98 570 /89:7-,3.0 ;,:0 ,. ,70, 5,79.5,908 3 1706:03. 70:,943 3

5745479439498,;,,-070:,93.,5,.970,9;0949,9414;07,88902


7/29

!%#

#&%

%000.97.92,709,8050703.0/034724:8809-,.83/0;0734390

57428041/070:,943 3 9047 /070:,93 90 00.97.92,7094:/3.70,80 90011.03. 41 90 3/:897-574/:.3 00.97.9,9 407 .4898

,3/5,8839480.4898,;384394.:8942078

47 90 00.97. 3/:897 /070:,943 20,38 90 0307,943 547943 41

00.97.9807;.0-0450394.4250994340;079097,3828843,3/

/897-:943 41 90 00.97.9 702,3 70:,90/ ,3/ 4:7 4., :99

.425,3 .4393:0 94 /897-:90 00.97.9 94 :8 ,3/ 574;/0 .:894207

807;.0894:8%00307,9434100.97.98-03/070:,90/.20,38

0 ,;0 90 455479:39 94 845 ,74:3/ 147 90 00.97.9 0307,943

8:550741.4.0

%000.97.92,709,8050703.0/034724:8809-,.83/0;0734390

57428041/070:,943 3 9047 /070:,93 90 00.97.92,7094:/

3.70,80 90011.03. 41 90 3/:897-574/:.3 00.97.9,9 407 .4898

,3/5,8839480.4898,;384394.:89420783/, ,84 ,/ , .0397,0/ 3899:943, 03;7432039 147 90 574;843 41

00.97.93/,854070307,9432,3,0203933/,,8897:.9:70/-90

0.97.9$:55.941%0.9574;/0/14790089,-82039

41,0397,0.97.9:9479%0,8089,-80/990

5:75480 41 /0;0453 , :31472 3,943, 5407 54. ,3/ 41 574;/3

.0,7,3.014754075740.98

%0.9,84 809:5 ,30947 41 89,9000.97.9 -4,7/8$854070307,943 :3/079,38 ,3/ 2,3,02039 -4,7/8 :3/07 .0397, 47 439

5,7930785147905:7548041200937043,5407706:7020398:77039

9070,70$89,90307,90,-4:99497/84190.4:397897,3828843

/897-:943,3/8:554100.97.9


8/29

#06:7020398,3/25,.941070:,943

%0706:702039841/070:,943,70

44/4507,94385,333,3/2,709/0830330078

$:11.0398:55,3/1:0/;0789$:11.03997,3828843317,897:.9:70

11.039/02,3/8/07085438;03088,3/2,3,02039

!74;84341793.039;08,3/44/57.083,8

%$#&%

%0-03019841070:,9433.:/0

9 3;4;0888:041 8:7;;,41 90 199089 0 011.039 :398 ;0,3/49078

50780,50700.97.9974:.42509943,3/334;,943

2574;080307,943,3/5,333011.03.,3/0.4342

#0;9,,94341905407033007357410884320,383.70,80/4-,3/

.,033455479:3908

%$&%

443,70900110.9841070:,9431907 90 /070:,94341 00.97.9 9070 8, :0 .,30 3 4:7 00.97.9

-8 &99 -8 147 00.97.9 34 3.:/0 430 949, 57.0 147 , 9080

.4254303980307,94397,3828843/897-:943,3/4.,807;.0%070,70

805,7,90 ,//943, .,708 147 1:0 ,/:892039 ,3/ 9,08&99 -8 3 90

/070:,90/ 03;7432039 -0 :3-:3/0/ 20,33 9,9 0,. 41 90

.425430398-09020/805,7,909,57.05074,994:7147

0,. 3 ,//943 9070 2, -0 , .425099;0 97,38943 .,70 47 897,3/0/

3;0892039.,701470,.

!%$#&%

%025,.9841/070:,94343!407$8902507,943,701443


9/29

$5993394805,7,90039908

7/309474507,94789:7339430:97,88902574;/078

!4075,394507,94789:733945407574/:.943.425,308

438:2078,70970,90/,8.:8942078%039071,.080850.,417/4507,9478,3/5407574/:.943.425,308

.,30/94.42207.,80389;04308

3;08920398,70 70/:.0/ 94232:29 88902 4507,90/ .4807 94 907

298

7,/04188902,:942,9434..:78

,77097020395747,2870/:.0903:2-07414507,9350784330390

.43974.03970

',74:8%7,38,.9434/08

443 90 8:..088 41 -07,,943 41 ;,74:8 80.9478 41 90 0.4342

00.97.92,7098 :3/07039 97,38943 '079., 3907,90/ :9908 .

2,3,0/0307,94397,385479,3/8:554100.97.9070:3-:3/0/,3/

.4250994330307,943,3/8:55,83974/:.0/;0390/110703.083

00.97.92,709897:.9:708,3/70:,94754.08,74:3/9047/907083483089,3/,7/2,70924/0

%097,38,.94324/08,70

,907,97,38,.943

:9,907,97,38,.943

!4424/0

,907,%7,38,.9438

-,907,97,38,.943-09003,8:5507,3/,-:073;4;089030.94341

5407,94304.,94339030947,3/90097,.94341908,20,24:3941

5407,9908,20920,9,349074.,943,.-,907,97,38,.94384:/

90701470-07057080390/-,$4:7.05489;030.943.4330.90/94905439

4130.943,3/,8330,9;030.943.4330.90/9490543941097,.943


10/29

%084:7.0 ,3/ 9083,70,88:20/94,;0908,208097,38,.9437,903

%0540730.9438,884.,90/9/1107039-,907,97,38,.9438.,3

31:03.0 90 4,/3 43 97,3828843 1,.908 8 , 708:9 5407 148 43

308 ,3/ 97,3828843 39071,.08 .,3 3.70,80 47 /0.70,80 /0503/3 43 9088902 4507,93 .43/9438 97,38,.943 80 /70.943 41 5407 97,38107 ,3/

903:2-074197,38,.9438.438/070/

%0.43.059:,24/041-,907,897:.9:7089,903.48,3//8.4803907394

97,38,.943.4397,.98070906:,3990897,/0/,3/9057.08,70,9 90743

/8.70943 ,3/ 349 , 2,9907 147 90 $ 0 , -,907, 97,38,.943 8 2,/0

-09003,03.4,3/,/8.494:997/5,793907;03943%08097,38,.9438

,709038:-2990/9490$390,-803.041,3.430894343908890290$825/85,9.08,

9097,38,.94389,9,70706:0890/2,3,325,79,.,7014790807;.0

3,-,907,97,/324/0

!,078,77,30905:7.,80,3/8,097,38,.9438,24390280;08

,. 8.0/:0 .447/3,947 $ ,3/ 0,. 5407 0.,30 ! ,70

7085438-0

147038:738:55/02,3/-,,3.0:9,907,97,38,.9438,70,3090384341-,907,97,38,.943898,97,/0

9,98,77,30/-0307-740783,2:9,907,97,38,.9439070,702,3

0307,94354398,90,8924709,343082,79070,702,34,/54398

,90,8924709,3430

%08.0/:3.447/3,947$41,74:5412:9,907,97,38,.9438574;/08

90 2,2:2 ,8 0 ,8 5745480/ 0307,943 ,3/ /02,3/ ,9 /1107039

0307,943,3//02,3/5439870850.9;0%0.447/3,947,84574;/0890

2,2:2,3/5745480//02,3/8,9/11070394,/54398419074:5%0$

/090723089010,8-9419874:5412:9,907,97,38,.943,3/8:0898

232:2 5488-0 .:79,20398 1907 13,,943 90 10,8-0 2:9,907,

97,38,.94388.0/:0/


11/29

!4485,9.

%0544890840-:07,3/80074100.97.9%0544:8089041107841

8:55078,3/-/4190/02,3/07894/0907230908:..0881:-//078480411078,3/-/,;0-003,..0590/%0544411078904592:2-84;3,

.0397,0/ 0.4342. /85,9. 24/0 9,3 394 ,..4:39 90 30947

.43897,3983.,8041.43089432,3,02039354424/09054424/0

.438/078 05.9 90 25,.9 41 97,3828843 30947 .43897,398 %0 544

24/0,88:20825.990.42292039410307,9478.,70-//394

8:555407%0/090723,943410.4342.4592:28/43099005.9

.438/07,9434190.4308943

$!,79.5,943,97

3 90 70897:.9:70/ 03;7432039 8 80 5407 94 ;,74:8 $8 ,9

.425099;057.08%:8$8,;090-07994.4480908147

.4397,.98%02,472,349,;0.4397,.989908390743

,70,%82,08;,74:8.42-3,943841$.4397,.985488-03

57,.9.003974/:.090.43.05941,$5,79.5,9432,97!942,090;8:,,94341.4397,.980,807!8,2,979903:2-0741

74806:,94903:2-07418,3/903:2-0741.4:23806:,9490

3:2-0741$839088902,.03973982,97.,3-094:941,8

,17,.94341,949,4,/.4397,.90/-,$.4:2394,7/,

74 %:8 90 0397 .47708543/8 94 90 17,.943 41 90 949, 4,/ 5407

.4397,.90/-$1742,%08:241,900397083,.4:233

982,978:39!848905,79.5,94341,$3,.4397,.99

,03.0903,20$5,79.5,9432,97

%0349,9431448,439030841((438/07,94,70,889023

. 0,. ,70, ,8 94 8 ,3/ 94 $8 3 9 09

$,3/$-03,70,,3/$


12/29

,3/$-03,70,,88433

$.02,9.41,94,70,88902370897:.9:70/03;7432039

!.51.51.51.51

.51.51.51.51.51.51.51.51

.51.51.51.51(

070 .51 701078 94 .4397,.9 5,79.5,943 1,.947 $:55480 9,9 $

/02,3/8 5: 5407 4:9 41 . 5: 8 /02,3/0/ 1742

5:17425:1742,3/

5:1742

%03.4:230397083,700,8/0130/,8.51

.51

.51

.51

%0-4./,43,841!.47708543/901706:03./0;,943805993

5708.7-0/ 298 %0 80.43/ ,88:25943 8 9,9 90 3/;/:, 00.97.,

.4330.9438 93 ,3 ,70, ,70 84 89743 ,9 0,89 3 .425,7843 94 4.,

/02,3/811/,43,-4.8.47708543/9490/02,3/84190$83430

,70,949083,34907,70,

#"&%#$#


13/29

90 0307,9478 3 8:. ,3,70,.43899:90, .407039 74:5 84 9,9 , 90

0307,9478 8500/ ,3/ 84 /43 940907 2,39,33 907 70,9;0 5407

,308$:.,3,70,8/0130/,8,.43974,70,%0-4:3/,70841, .43974

,70, 0307, .43./0 9 9,9 41 ,3 3/;/:, 00.97.9 -4,7/.425,3%4:3/0789,3/904,/1706:03..43974574-0209:8.438/07,

8309:7-40307,947889028:553,384,90/4,/

%:7-308500/4;073388902

:708488.02,9.,908500/4;07338890241,890,29:7-30%0

88902.43889841901443.425430398

-,8500/4;07347%88900,79419088902.80380890.,3038500/1706:03.8

90 8500/ 3.70,808 90 1 -,8 24;0 4:9,7/8 ,3/ 90 5439 43 3,0

20.,38224;08/43,7/8%070;0780,5503803908500//0.70,808

/7,:.,25107

9.4257808,549;,;024;020398.43;0790/39454070;058943

;,;024;02039%8830.088,7347/0794450347.48090890,2;,;0

,,38957088:70890,23,020.,382

8,7/35;490/,9,3/8,349077/35;490/,998

3 20.,382 574;/08 , 24;02039 94 90 .43974 ;,;0 3 574547943 94

.,30 3 8500/ 9 ,84574;/08 , 100/-,. 174290890,2 ;,;024;02039

3

$500/.,307

9574;/08 , 890,/ 89,90 5407 4:95:9 80993 147 90 9:7-30 98 /43,7/

24;02039 45038 90 :5507 549 ;,;0 84 9,92470 890,2 8,/2990/ 94 90

9:7-30:3/07890,/.43/943803.02470890,/54074:95:9%070;0780

,55038147:5,7/24;02039418500/.,307


14/29

!%#

$!'#$$%

88:20 9,9 90 88902 8 39, 4507,93 :3/07 890,/ .43/943890

3,020.,38289,943,7,3/549;,;0.480/890,2;,;045030/-,

/013902,39:/09:7-307:333,9.4389,398500/99:7-3054074:95:9

/013902,39:/09:7-307:333,9.4389,398500/99:7-3054074:95:9


15/29

-,,3.3900307,9474,/09904507,93.43/9438-0.,7,.9070/-

-,,3.3900307,9474,/09904507,93.43/9438-0.,7,.9070/-

S889021706:03.8500/

!S0307,9474:95:99:7-304:95:9S890,2;,;080993

08,4-9,3,30,73.702039,24/0,74:3/90804507,93.43/9438

09 90 5439 43 90 3,020.,382 -024;0//43,7/8 - , 82,

,24:3998,.422,3/..,:808909:7-3054074:95:994.,30

,3/.,390701470-079903,8

!

070!890.422,3/0/3.70,8035407%0.422,3/83,!0809839424943,806:03.0410;039890

549;,;024;08:5,7/857088:70414843949094541902,3

5894324;39/43,7/890890,2;,;045033.43806:0393.70,80

909:7-300307,9478500/ 3.70,80 0 901706:03.408:509:824/0

90800;03982,902,9.,

.4397-:908470:5,7/841!

3.70,8031706:03.1.,:808901-,89424;04:9,7/8849,924;08

/43,7/-,574547943,,24:39190.43806:03924;02039419

702,3310/,98110/43,7/8

%030924;0203941890701470

..!.1

%41,.9478.4397-:90949024;0203941

%024;0203941890,24:39-.90549;,;04503898

.4397-:90/-,3/,3/.,3-079903,8


16/29

%024;02039/0503/3:5439883450384304190547984190549

;,;0 ,/2993 57088:70 4 394 90 .3/07 9070-24;3 90 2,3

58943 ,3/ 45033 90 890,2 ;,;0 - 079,3 :891,-0 82513

,88:259438..,3-02,/0,99889,0,70 3079, 70,.943 147.08 41 2,3 58943 ,3/ 890,2 ;,;0 ,70 30-0

.425,70/9490147.0800790/439058943-57088:704

0.,:8041,-4;0907,90414,/2990/9490.3/078574547943,

94547945033

%0 ;4:20 41 4 ,/2990/ 94 90 .3/07 8 9:8 574547943, 94 90 920

3907,41%024;0203984-9,30/-/;/3904;4:20-

90,70,4190.748880.943419058943%:8/9

9.,3-0 ;0710/ 174290 8.02,9./,7,29,9, 5489;024;02039/

.,:80830,9;0:5,7/24;020390,..4:3931479030,9;083:80/

36

%,390,5,.097,3814724106:,9438009

8!88

8888$8

23,938,3/80.,3790

8!.888

!.8#8($%$8

070

#8500/70:,94341904;07347

$,3418500/4;07347

%$920.4389,39418500/4;07347

%08500/4;07338890241,/749:7-30824703;4;0/3,//943,

100/-,. 445 574;/08 902547,7 /7445 .425038,943 94 570;039 389,-9


17/29

%8830.0889,90/-90,703079,41503894.,90.70:,908907,90

41,90735:994909:7-30

%

09:83470,9090/3,2.708543804190890,29:7-3039072841.,308

3 5407 4:95:9 94 .,308 3 890,2 ;,;0 45033 070 94 89,0 890,2

9:7-309700,9:398:80/%0/3,2.708543808,7031:03.0/-941,.94780397,30/890,2-0900390309890,2;,;0,3/178989,041

909:7-30908947,0,.943390700,90/..,:808904:95:9190

4 57088:70 89,0 94 , -03/ 9,9 41 90 57088:70 89,0 %:8 90

9:7-30 97,38107 1:3.943 8 .,7,.9070/ - 94 920 .4389,398 47 0,80 41

,3,889-0,88:20/0709,9909:7-30.,3-024/00/94,;00,8041

,3,889-0,88:20/0709,9909:7-30.,3-024/00/94,;0,830

06:;,039 920 .4389,39 :70 848 90 97,38107 1:3.943 24/0 41 ,890,29:7-30%5.,90920.4389,39%90837,3094


18/29

%%#$#&%

#%#

%03.7020393540735:99490889028!!070!!890

3.702039,9:7-3054074:95:9,3/!8904,/3.702039%03098:75:8

54073,3,70,7057080390/-90/110703.033.70,80/0307,943!,3/3.70,80//02,3/!8,-847-0/-9088902394,8

#,90 41 3.70,80 41 89470/ 309. 0307 8 90 0307,947 74947 98.0/:0/1706:03.19089470/03078

!#80.44:08

070!#8907,9341909:7-40307,947,3/8/0130/,898

3079,.4389,39

%0309.0307-03574547943,9486:,70418500/1706:03.

%0309.0307,9,1706:03.41118;03-

111

!#11(

#,9041.,3041309.0307890701470

//9

!#1//91

8 90 1706:03. .,308 90 24947 4,/ .,308 -03 80389;0 94

8500/907,90414,/970850.9941706:03.0

b!b111

070 90 .4389,39.,3 -0/0907230/02507., 8 5489;0 147 ,

570/423039249474,/


19/29

793905407-,,3.006:,9430,;0

!#1//911!90!!

##!#$%%#%#

# #!#$%% #"&

%#$%$$%

.425090 -4. /,7,2 705708039,943 41 ,3 84,90/ 5407 88902

.425783 9:7-30 0307,947 4;07347 ,3/ 4,/ 8 0,8 4-9,30/ -

.42-3390-4./,7,29100/-,.44588433:70

$%$%%$$

%024/0411:708489,99070,709425479,393.702039,35:98

94904,/1706:03..4397488902!.90.,3038500/.,30780993

,3/!/90.,3034,//02,3/09:8.438/07,825089:,9433.

908500/.,307,8,10/809930!/8!/884-9,30/,81448

8!.8!$%!$$%!$#%$8%%8(!8(


20/29

!$$%!$#(!

090,39810/147909:7-30,3/810/14790540788902

$ 90 8500/ 4;07347 ,3 8 0,8 ,/:89,-0 - .,33- 0398 41

;,74:838099-0,88:20/147825.99,9$884,/:890/9,9$9

9 ,84 70.430/ 9,9 !$ 070 !1!# 3 5: :39

.,3031706:03.4

1#(!

%0 ,-4;0 06:,943 ;08 90 890,/ 89,90 .,308 3 1706:03. .,:80/ -

.,30831706:03.,7082,419047/07411742344,/941:4,/

9 98 :3/0789,3/3 1:70 848 90 30,7 70,94385 -090031706:03.,3/4,/

147 1700 4;07347 4507,943 9 8500/ .,307 809 94 ;0 , 8.0/:0/

1706:03.41,91:4,/%0/745478450419870,943858


21/29

!#1#(!

0.70,803889024,/1##(!

1.4:78090.4397-:94341/0.70,803889024,/82:.0889,390

3.70,8030307,9434795.,;,:0841,3/#6:490/0,707

!!0.70,803889024,/!

438/07 34 90 890,/ 0110.9 41 .,33 8500/ .,307 80993 !.8

!.8

9 4,/ /02,3/ 702,33 10/ 0 !/ %0 890,/ 89,90 .,30 3

1706:03.84-9,30/,81448

8!/8$%!$%!$8%%8$%!$#(!.8

1890,/89,90$%!$$%!$#(!.

1$%

1#!

1908500/.,307809938.,30/-!.0904,//02,3/.,308

-!90890,/1706:03..,3084-9,30/-8:5075489430


22/29

!.!/1471

:70/05.98944,/1706:03.549843094;08.0/:0/1706:03.

,9

7,90/4,/,3/90490794;0908,201706:03.,97,90/4,/#$!$

%44-9,390/3,2.70854380;390.,3031706:03.,81:3.943

4190920147,8905.,3034,/02:894-9,390,5,.03;07804106

%0.,7,.90789.06:,943-034197/47/07/3,2.70854380.,3

43-04-9,30/147,850.1.3:207.,.,8040;0790.,7,.90789.06

.,3-0,55742,90/,8178947/07-0,2339070,9;02,39:/084190920.4389,3983;4;0/%5.,;,:084190920.4389,398414,/1706:03.

.4397488902,7070,90/,8

%$%%%!$

0993%$%%,3/$%90-4./,7,2411870/:.0/

949,9411:701742.0.,3790

8!.85858#%58(!/8

58%5888#58#%58(!/

19#!$#58059%58##58(


23/29

%054941.,3031706:03.;078:8920147178947/07,55742,943;03

,-4;0 843 3 1 789 47/07 ,55742,943 8 4-;4:8 , 5447

,55742,943

%##!%

$4 1,7 0 ,;0 .438/070/ 90 82510/ .,80 41 , 830 9:7-40307,947

8:553,384,90/4,/438/0734,57,.9.,889029,3:2-0741

0307,9389,9438,3/4,/8985488-094/;/0,30903/0/540788902

8,3,943,7/3948:-,70,82,-089,9000.97.9-4,7/83.90

0307,9478,70 99.4:50/94090784,8941472,.40703974:50,

900307,9478708543/3:384394.,30834,/478500/.,307809938

$:.,.407039,70,8.,0/,.43974,70,3.901706:03.8,88:20/

94-0908,20974:4:9389,9.,80,8/3,2..43/9438475:754808

41/0;0453,8:9,-0.43974897,90,.43974,70,.,3-070/:.0/94830


24/29

8500/ 4;07347 9:7-40307,947 ,3/ 4,/ 88902 90 .43974 897,9008

/8.:880/841,7,7090701470,55.,-094,33/0503/039.43974,70,

!#!#%!&$%#%#

9 8 8003 1742 90 ,-4;0 /8.:8843 9,9 9 90 8500/ 4;0733 88902

389,0/ 430,.2,.30 90 890,/ 4,/ 1706:03. .,7,.90789. 147 ;03

8500/.,30780993,8.438/07,-0/744501479088902-03:80/147

90:897,943,-4;090890,/89,90/744531706:03.-01742

344,/941:4,/

$8902 1706:03. 850.1.,9438 ,70 7,907 8973039 ,3/ 90701470 84 2:..,3031706:03..,3349-09407,90/3 1,.99 8050.90/9,990890,/

.,303 1706:03..,3349-0 9407,90/31,.9 98050.90/9,990890,/

.,3031706:03.-00740890,/89,901706:03..,3-0-74:9

.,3-,.94908.0/:0/;,:0-,/:8938500/.,307809939088902

.4:/:3/07439407,-0/3,2.1706:03..,3089.,30834,/9

0,/8 94 90 3,9:7, 8:08943 9,9 90 8500/ .,307 80993 -0 ,/:890/

,:942,9.,-2439473901706:03..,30847985:75480,83,17421810/974:,33907,94794908500/.,307708:93390-4.

/,7,2 .431:7,943 843 3 1 %0 88902 34 24/108 94 ,

574547943, 5:8 3907, .4397407 . ,8 8 0 343 1742 .43974

9047;08074890,/89,900774701890,/89,90

%083,!.80307,90/-903907,.439742:89-04145548908394

8.,..4:39814730,9;0833-4.1473907,.4397407

4

858%58$#858%88%98


25/29

1890,/89,9088

3.4397,89 9406 0 13/9,9 90890,/89,90.,3031706:03.,8

-003 70/:.0/ 94 074 - 90 ,//943 41 90 3907, .4397407 %8 .,3 -0,7:0/4:958.,,80170,.08890,/89,90,.4389,39;,:043

03

!.!/.4389,390.,:8041903907,93,.9434190.4397407988

435488-011

3.0397,4,/1706:03..4397441,;03.43974,70,90.,30077473

1706:03.8343,8,70,.4397407747%0,//943,83,10/-,.

39024/10/.439748.02057080390/,-4;08903907,41390,-4;0 8.020 -03 074 :3/07 890,/ .43/9438 , 4., /083

.790743 8 232,943 41 /9 147 , 8905 /89:7-,3.0%8 3907, 8

3/00/90


26/29

9200774741,83.7434:800.97..4.7:317429054078:5531,.9

24/073 5407 889028 005 97,. 41 3907,90/ 920 07747 , 90 920

.4770.9;0,.9432,3:,,/:892039!.908500/.,3078099389,03-

, ,70 570 ,8830/ 89,943 3 ,70, ,8 8443 ,8 90 920 07747 0.00/8 ,5708.7-0/;,:0

%0 /3,2.8 41 90 574547943, 5:8 3907, .4397407 .,3 -0 89:/0/

3:207.,439088902-034114:7947/079047/07419088902,8

3.70,80/-430990,//!74547943,5:83907,.43974079

14789054,//89:7-,3.0415:884331:70

4,/1706:03..4397493907,.4397407,.0;0074890,/89,9007747

,3/1,89/3,2.70854380-:99007.8034.439744;079070,9;04,/341

;,74:8 0307,93 89,943 0 0.4342. /85,9. 41 90 .43974 ,70, 1 ,

8://033.70,8034,/4..:783.43974,70,904,/1706:03..43974

.,308908500/.,307809938414;0734741,0307,93:394190,70,

84 9,9 940907 9080 :39 2,9. 90 4,/ ,3/ 90 1706:03. 709:738 94

8.0/:0/;,:0%8,.9435,.031080.43/840;073574.0884198

.,30 4,/341 ;,74:8 0307,93 :39 .,30 3 2,3307 3/0503/039 410.4342.4,/3.438/07,94331,.98420:3982,094;074,/0/

$420.439744;074,/341 3/;/:,:39.,3 -0 007.80-,/:893 90

,31,.94741 3907,40;079883498,981,.9478,981,.94784:943

8 ,.0;0/ - :83 3/0503/039 .439748 147 4,/ 1706:03. ,3/ 0.4342.

/85,9. 0 4,/ 1706:03. .43974 8 1,89 ,.93 .43974 ,3/ 0.4342.

/85,9..43974884,.93.43974.,/:89908500/.,307809933

0;07 23:90 3 ,..47/,3.0 9 .422,3/ 83, 0307,90/ - .0397,

0.4342./85,9..03970:708488.02,9./,7,2


27/29


28/29

%0 .43974 4-0.9;0 34 8 94 70:,90 90 1706:03. 41 0,. ,70, ,3/ 94

82:9,304:870:,909090305407,85073907,70,5407.4397,.988

390.,80411706:03.574547943,5:83907,.4397407-0389,0/

84,894;0074890,/89,900774739030540714,8.425,70/9490.4397,.90/ 5407 9 8 .43;03039 ,88:20/ 9,9 0,. .43974 ,70, .,3 -0

7057080390/-,3

06:;,0399:7-300307,947,3/4;0734788902$2-48:80/98:11

7010794,70,,3/948098:117010794,70,

3,384,90/.43974,70,.,80903.702039,5407!!,8,..4:390/

147-907,90413.70,804189470/309.0307,3/3.70,803,70,4,/

.,:80/-3.70,8031706:03.$3.0,903097,385479854073474:941,3,70,4,/.,:80/-3.70,8031706:03.$3.0,903097,38547985407347

4:941,3,70,981,.92:89-0,..4:390/1473903.702039,5407-,,3.0

06:,943410,.,70,

!40797,3854790/4:941,70,8;03-

!90''83

070

5407,3084106:;,0392,.308419094,70,847 3.702039, .,308 3 ,3/ 903.702039, 90 30 5407.,3-0

0570880/,8

!905:%

070%''.48!7

$3.03.702039,5407,308,703907,8413.702039,1706:03.080.,3

790,8

!90%1/91/9

0701,3/1,703.702039,1706:03..,30841,70,8,3/70850.9;0

$2,7903.702039,903054074:941,70,8;03-

!90%1/91/9

070


29/29

''.48

%

!7

,%%03.702039,5407-,,3.006:,943147,70,.,3-079903,8

!!/11!901/9

92,-03490/9,9,6:,3990849079,31706:03.,703507:39

%,390,5,.097,381472,3/7047,33009

8!8!8!908(58%588

070,8/0130/0,707

58%581

simulation and optimization of automatic generation control under deregulation

Documents