smullyan, this book needs no title

7/30/2019 Smullyan, This Book Needs No Title

1/194

T I

Copyrighted Material

s

A B U 0 G E T F

LIVIN PRDOXS

Auhor of Wh Is te Nme of Tis Book?

Coprigted Materil


2/194

Copyrighte Material

ic/losy

"Profeo deontae and gain h paadoxe andquky lp aonng co all huh nly y a nt

t. I mthn I h lt a on t and I' c t tfil ri: -Dug Hoer. T N Yk T B R

A bft h ll a mgcan, h ath h mnl n n an ila gi ang pn and rh ma wh w

h w n rd. not bt pul o h ut n v o h ph ad hil r [Ti o] h

pckd and d wn a rady fr omething n k abt' -Criic

o Sulan ntexis. l nay o nv h h wll n dont -gan Mlvn Fng

I sba o d um, R Sml

n l o ll

g m nd t ge1 Ze philo u dbl-eg in to muc V nkng-hn le c s y t lldg cim t c q x o lad ea en w a dermsm. T sSmun exb me mgician o vy ng d d ul eeainng

Rod S so P Mem a Iaa Ur H a Dm Pr U a g t , n, d T C Unvity gcn H ohr

o c dely alad W I f ? A PzLISBN --3-3

17.i"iilnbii:iiSiiiiiiii 1 4 5$14.95clbCnGb 9 806 7 62814A !b ' rigted Materil


3/194


4/194

H BKND TILE


5/194

s Ram M m

HEORY OF FORMAL YTEMFRS ODE LOGHE AO S ETHA S E AME OF H BOO?HE HESS MTEES OF HEO HOME


6/194

TBOOK

EDS NO T'l ,by Ry M ull

Pc, c Ew Cs Nw rsy


7/194

ustratd by Mchel Dvid Brown

by Rym M SmuyCpyrgt 1980 y Rym M SmyA rgs eserve N prt f ts k my epruced ay fm r y y es, xcepr te icu f re qus revew,wtut per wrg m t puseAress ques to Petc-, EeoCffs, NJ 07632Pre te Uite Stes Amerc

PreceH Iera, Ic LPretcH f Aur, Fty Lt SydetceHl f C, L TrtoPrecH f I Prve Ltd Nw Prce-Hl f p Ic koPretceH f Sutest As Pe , Sgporith B Lited Wto w Zea

8 5

ibr of Corss Clogig blicio Duy Rymd Mhs bk ees o ttl P lsohic etin

itN66. 9 -26BN -1391905X

SN ---{K}


8/194

Contents

FLES CS

S One Wrr? 3 he Mn Wh Dd tnt t Be Enied 3 he Mn Wh Wned rnq Life Sesh r Unsesh -iess es f Omiss Sr f heEst 6 A B n Ecnrc 7 Prrtf n Unscessf Est Sr f heFe Peekb a Mchne? 9 Sr f

he St 10 Mdes 11 dt 1 iate 12

I O RCUSLYPOX?

Wnt 1 Rnist n HWf 1 On Shn U! 8 On ann

ient 0 is r Bam On he Sef-erpetin re f Anees Csed Sstems f hht A hht n Anie Whe Yr Friend hrws Drs Ahht Prens nd Chdren On Cinne' Ha 9

I TO OU SO! tane Prax 1 F mercn n-ins 1 D Anims Perceie Gd 4 ANe Rei 4 s Life Trc 4 Tt Schpee 4 d S! 4

SOmC LES

e Astme Wh Beiee in he Psbi Mirces 1 Te See d the Skepc t nther S S An U-rtte Dst he Mn W Ws Si-e Evetin Cmprmise Bit a Piece Determiism r Fr 9 Siphrei Sem 64

mai Chsti Scest 6


9/194

V H VRY DCUL TO AY

WL!A Remar nnei 77 This s Ver Diit t Pa We 77 bems 79 Bes anchr 80 F es f ife 82 T K Nt En 5

ZN X?

e e a te D 93 A Zen Frmet 93 Ze 93 A Qinteseti Ze c e t 95 H m a t a i team 96 De ae R Di? 98 A f Eart 99 Be f rasDe N t Q v e 1 0 ae NeNti! 10 h D Y is t e E

itene? 0 Sa 108 O rin Oai Eitement 109 Di G t te Mnaste 110

T F KOWLDG

e F i K e e 19 a t re? 9 s M a Macine? 0 nii

es Res 120 ptane Hedim 11 W Are a a Definitin? 17 amatism an rt 1 0 Mra Respiiit 12 a Be Str? 1 Vettes 19 s Sciece ncmtie i Tee? 140 Msticism and Visi 14

T WOUT UG

e Mer Pei 1 he MePeri 1 A rm 12 V The reaLee 0 V Bck t te Me Pei 16 Epie in Heaven 1


10/194

A

0

0


11/194


12/194

Su ne

ne wrri a ne i v , since wrf s ne f e m pin in If ne as rr en, e a s I ave een ne ma eve wr f cu ne ma a ake e rcansecear o wr f evn rer cars han wr

s rea r , ck wo enshi mef rm a an mrrw k ca f f, oe wrrin, ra rn w ke a cncivaerecn r e re i aws wrrng he i s noakng enugh prca?

A l m , e av m a m mn re isa I o wr eng A m m , hs g awas wre me

Te o Di t t toe nie

ce pn a ime ere ws a man wo c n snein ved He ws vr creiv nv an was

prr a ne f e wrs m pr iis nvrses Ahs cues ui is ivr nv m is piiTi e c n. e ave p is i ner ce a acin pi n a fra nvrSi is craive wrk pr n h pse Evnenvie m f e marvs a is wrk, s fhis mrvs m kig mre preii

i dc pi annm Tis a he wrie e w e wre ohe n dci he w cne s wrin, op n mre n i ifime He w rrae a iswrk s e pe ar hs f pe s nvhm pms, w w a r ? T ears w


13/194

FA Fb, i ot ubli o got r itv t si You s t our ors to ubli t t to mount to somethin W ri t is t ubliios si Ys but t v oo or u ecently" Atull, t i ot vr ui big ir t it uit ll i i rt o o too is svigs i r uit lrg si lys liv vr gl rtir to t outr r ou ribl butiul sot i is o s

bult

sl but bsolul gorgous ous. sot o s b r t ost buiul o ils ils ils rou Evryo o ss t tur g iv I sois oul ot tll tr sooing t tr or t vious stto All tis o our oul ot s . So sol ll is or osos gv vry t to t oor r l s ring

it For t rt ti i is l r ro bigvi For t irst ti s , s tl . Ut rs ltr t ol ollgu r is s-tgious uivrsi. Ar lu t togt ollgu s Ho rily you loo o o you

e M Wted aTqi L

O tr s o li o otsri u tig s tt st ll is y griingtt t v o


14/194

-FS FSe r Ueh

s t o vot ll is ti rgis o orig o t us o t bl oloring bt olt ooi olitil syologilt bl ri tol i W rtilr o ig vr srii ur t su to l us o ybo tt vot tt usls! i slis? o ou ot unrst yo

rst t l! o v u bo i o tig I o s o ultrior otivo s I to biv i rirtio W I i

bbis l b bor so bl so it Ms o big bl or it i t li r rulu I t to b sur tt i I o b bl I o'tt ur

ppe

Jm: r o t tis r ot

Jn I o , s otr , oJm: ou b o liitJon s, I ut r t rt rlly onviig

rgt or t ortl it o t sol . o I ko or urt I il suriv boil t T s vry py t otr st i ovro

pe Otst

o o t ir bt otiit


15/194

ALS CIESurbl tiist? Wl l, otiis s o sys " Evryig is or t bs ki il surviv

iurbl otiist s o o ss "Evryting is bst ki ill surviv A v i ki ostuviv, t i s still or t bst

tr t I oul ll pessiistic otiist ssiist otiist is o sly sk is sys ry u ri tt vrytig is or t bst

St te tist

O uo ti t s l gontri " I I, s ll vr tk bout H it i vr

rig, itty triig ligul sill it sls I I, " Dit is tr rissis bi-ioi, ligt bi vryo ot vrybo ov i Sll ll oul tlk bout s " H s terribly guily bu is ogotriity ! H t sing " Ho orribl , I gotri gtri I gotri Yo s b tugt

rlist il tt otig o rt s or s-l igrul sibl t gotist ss guilt isgr i is o ig, isg o o's ig o i But ll is s guilt tll orls t ur i o is gotisi obvious rsos, i t oly i ors. T t gy o ligtt or or r tt iro t t rbl o gtis s ll rg! T orsig you o is b ashaed or ulty or your gis tl accentuates t ig is t t r tb mora gl t l but just t rli tt t


16/194

A ANSeal ivae of in eceic i mk ouer w e mc r if a or e

cenric f r heo w e ia ofaanning i em in r e e ieron eeme e eim ove a e overa he c wa i wie ce o eemer a cn ma e wen f no oci, as o on , o o, e e he se se se , ec. n evero wa o e !

he al ai Hw e hs chne Hw e as mae Hes o one an ei ne f awas aki a imefhe o a a aks a e n o e a coaaehm po his maifcen cae nfne, wa ei o eaize wa a he ere rai of i eei iaaoing i frmer eim as so e e en ino aee eprei wic ae e re of s fe

it cnci

orlst we roe o are eocenc o ev k o k a i f remse as ve ee miz, r rc o eme em o ve ae n inee in o people

Vct Ts ovi can w knw ma ne hee s is i ii an aiapies. I weren o r cine ee pep w

l I sen mc ime ran an nki em?oalst ecae all e ee en mch ime

eaing an inkin a ae e w a ac lkeo


17/194

FASFACIS-rrai o Ue gt

ou st t oa tt ts tyt ly s t us y ayt l s "h, y t tty t ay sssu

a a tt gt ost ty ss sss gtst ost l a utlu y lts to g st o lts

a o st o gts t s t e! le otst y tt too gotr t tt ty got out ast o y tsts s ul oe got ut ot o t o out t ost pnce ut a t t t soy o orig o t

tly, ls scssu ltrust h t ta

gotst ost t lso o ts o t st uc o goist A ls u to a o ltist ta o o o to oot tht

t the Flea

O upo tim as a. is ma a a ogis og a ls T ls i ir ouso Sth a a t gt ri o A irs ri i llig

iiually i y sr. Tis rov igl it h ri l sr. is as so iii uly ll Tr is su ig scin Sinc it Wi or Ari quip I soul v ul t l S uras a toi arialuar to ill all s, spry irous u oug r s ll a r a S


18/194

S F joou excime, "his e spr is meou! hs ep is ecen

Bu he mn s ro he e p s cu onefcie. W e hpee s his hogh he prs necen s hh oferous Hece he h o oena he os oor o vene. s he coda me n, nd he oo es ch co ed

ka Main'

his so-hoh compee une- I hope conince m ers of he ve of mhic s

Peboo is oe of m os Is she mere mche? If hs, s exreme cu o ou ho he ors! I hvfen oneed, Ju how os hs mrbe mchieok Inorni mchines e uomobes or fo h m, ve he mos nced eecic epme re ofeu compice bu o icoe hei o open ids p compe eeoo

owoe eekoo ork ho hs proem vexe me a o ime ni I n fon he ser! he ee Scienc Mhemcs come i Who hee oiscipes I ou h eme in he rk foreve u now kno

hppene hs zed h o mere rmchhiosophc heorzi soe he pm h s

eeded ee pemen n o I hre oe hr of hods en experimen pchoos o kee eebonde bsevion fo sevr mohs o mo cre ecord een F I h ce o oe pobe ompee if o I co ierp he co fin boed don he correc inepreon o he smuneous so a se f ri


19/194

S CSifta aio ay o t qatio ar xtrlgi f h ll vral vol h ta o

li th piiov mot ail ahata ol ri va li fiaig th qail b lv at all I a iv twy yar ago thlio wol hav b iposil otai But o wav ip opr S I rt h fast optr i worl prga all th ratio a wai t va h but at las t ay arriv wh h

atio lv a whol y, aao bhavor lor a ysry to I w octl w wo a prt vry ai to a v ny ils whaov, I ow xly hr rsps

a, f xapl, h usio of oi I h pa, gav a oa, a aoluly way owg ho woul rpo r rspos to

ai at I ul gral la whh woul ovr all av u a law B rr, I ul vav ou t i law wio ahaial aalyi

at ti law I will ll yo vry i I hav vv a oa, a ls spo i aly ha way, ly wa o bri o rogni what a Ua by ahai, pt log at d

eence po a wa tally bli t th iaii ut ow I ow Whv iv hr a oa i ly o hin v o, a vry i i i a hig! hr h y i or h ot

Sto fte Suito

O r wa a a who wa i lv w a mnsr'a a lan t ask h isr or h an aia O vig g vi to ou or nn

0


20/194

-FABLES AND ANCIESHe pent the enire evening earnly convrsig wih theinise aout liiu tpi; e tie hi bet o ipim wih hi

own thelgial erudiin and great piriualiy.Af e left, he inis aidtohi dauhe, "Dear I hinkou houlay oen a lil e pracical "

Modesty A: a po of yor aoplishs, y ar rarably t

B: I ot tA: h Iv aht y! By islaig yo ty,

o tyig to a h iprss hat y ar so t

tat o wot ta rit f ayhig v yo oty Bt I hh y! Y a aecting h air of ybt i o oig yo ar ig s io

B: I li I saiI

s?

A conrr rcn c y a awh ha h n n m mrs He n his r e i m

a n c c mr hiai a N c e m nhi n m 1o i o cr c

Te ri i n nrn n nran at H is c m rhly nr n r r r


21/194

S Sogcate

oowi oi a al po gav h flowig ao o a aoobii ivlvi a oa Sh pyialy h h wa i h a a o ha wa abl t aa wi aliy

ail w o givi a p a oapbx wiVllag a w aki abo p liht o h oo ri iy ai a i iot ai a ail a av

oy o ai o of i ploy o y r a I i a i h to b o

r of i who a o o a ai Yval a a al I l b a a i I a

a iv ay lai b o y i h a w

a ig aa whi a ia hol l h ai

t I ow ol ha h h wa i hig hl i vy poorly i ahi a wa t tiipl i a h followig io

ipal (i a oi W a i a

ahaiStnt: I ot i hinipal Oh o o to i hai

hi w pp y aa wiho ig aai o o i ro o a il i ihv


22/194

-FALESAFCIEe. ve e cer a a v iree ces cae. f kw ac u

evn knw cI nce aw a a f c r aapce r re fr a r.

e maaca r e :e an aer ecn an r

in c in a reara Te a ca vr a Y wa r eck rae r r a e earae T a r e rY wa a

I knw e r e rkaracric He a u ce

men H e ve a a ce wc nv pv vr ef s n a

ca er f e ceH k risin re f ic

a a rear n wic a e n:

SPASMASAST

USASSD

ca nvr a h bu I su h u I


23/194


24/194

D

II.' RICLXC?


25/194


26/194

C' o W

I ow o wo who soks Sh sys: Is o h Iave to sok I hoose to. I oul sily iv i up ay ti Iish to but I s o rso why I shoul. But I ssur yoI oul if I w o r husb sys t hr Th s oly aioliaio You oult iv up sokig v if yoa o You r ot strog ouh to giv i up; you have to So to k yourslf fl br, a to avoi havi tofss you ow wss of hrr you fool yourslf iolivig ht yo hoose to. Bu i s oly a raioliatio

I ow ohr wo who soks Sh sys: I s o hI wnt to sok; I hlp yslf hv ri svral isivig i up, ut I hv fil I fri I us o hv a vrytg harar I woul lov to stop bu siply a rusba sys to hr: Ths oly a rioliio You raily oul sop iily, if you lly w o o, you

hoos o sok f ll, ooy ismaking

you you flash a guily for oig th whih you ow to barul So o voi y oral rsposiliy fo your syou fool yourslf io blivig ht you a' hlp i Bu his oly a rioliaio

y oly usio about al his is: Why popl oiibly supi

A Ratioais is WifeOr "ywives don't ih thir hubs to brly raio"

D Wie Do you lov Rainalis Wll o ours Wha riiulous usioWife You nt ov Raionalis ow wha ki of oss is this

7


27/194

ULY Wi Bus if yo reall lov you ouln' hv on

wht yo iRaionalis

I hv lry xpn o you h rso i wh I i ws not h I on' lov you but bus ofuh n suh

Wie But his suh n suh is oy raializaion oureally i i bus o so n so n his so n so woul nv if you y lov

E !

Nt Day

Wie Drling o you lov Raionalis I' no so urWie WhRainalis houh I i bu h rgun you v

sry pving h I on' is no oo b

O Sutting

I hv har uh hs ay about s hrpyPopl o tohr in a gup an a nourg os h ohr I is sai o b oo o "sra on'shosiliy out of on's sys

his y no b b i Bu prhps w shou lsohv gup "shu up hrpy ssions T is, pop oohr n lrn o shu up h ohr I sy shu up a"

avisy bus popl sois o shu up a h or !Whn w a ngry w sr ah ohr n whn w rsill ngri w shu up t h or Shuin up a prsonn b us s ggrssiv an y hosi s sing athi In popl sois reaen o shu up Ys i


28/194

S L S DUSLY DLois hpps h a prso i opy sys: "Myroul is h I o h I ls io ro h Iop y h h I l s sh up ! s SHT ! B ' y I' lr! s vrls i h p s rris hy h hs h suppr h h is ps h shuppr's s o ohu

I w o a s us si: Thr r

opl h o ly ss whih rso B s s so B pos ou 's rorTh A ss o B h h o h sys: "h oyou ls or ? h ' ou l sy h Iw o sy? hy you lys hu up? o B hosrs : I hv o yu s ! Bu h s o h I a ri o shu yu p I o oy o h

coe of h yu s o o h h yu sa i fours o shou o sy h you u y hsa o I shoul us s to sy h opps hywh I or ou o ou p i s shug u p' ?I f yhig ss h i is l you h rg shu p I say his us you o o o h o ofwha I s u o h h I s i u i ol I

hoult ora you So ho is rl ryg o shu upwho? Prso h rspos : Thr you g shuig upagi ow you a ryig o l u o hviai wh I sai Is ' his wy o shug up? rs Bspos: "I ws o ryig o you l uly; I srly poiig ou o you h i you soh argu ous h py gy ov h

h oh pry is ryi o shu h up Ys suos hislly xis uoruh is uh o I oul sy o h su o hig

p u I h I hv y s or h I shu I lyshoul lr o shu p


29/194

S O i1SL PAAAL? On Rainin Siln

i a ot lotai t ppo arlisa O tti t b apriatl a a

t at t i yo btw tti aii ilt o ty a t a t Wll tay av t a otatio bt al t a ootatio aot iv to oo oc alyi t

i bt taily av o t i oapl t i ag t ai t a aiilt t ol aly o t ay a t lo aow ilt t t wol o ot plia to ay tat ow t t urly botaia o tatatt t ao i ilt o at lat t y t it i aaio t ao aa t y t i lt bt ay t iltl

tat it t t t ay t ot about t a o orribl to y a tat aot v big yl to o lt s osi opl Wat i t btw

pi ilt a stti t to arly o oivaio a tti rha ol hti opiuouly aii ilt avalray ai tat rar u a o

trai to t a othi tially ariv ostil t aii ilt t otio siv ta assiv po o i tat v yo rly xps yo tout to aot sohvr yo ar trhul ost op a truly yourlt o prso vrally it yo o t aboitsly agry rous, oil a vi upraiv Wha o yo

o Wll ts irusas it ight i wiss thig o yo to taly ri i i th trur th gs But his is vry irt ro hu I you ar truly aul i yo ar truly a g youl wll o b oi it wll not ppr ha you artall ilt. i your oppo ls ht yo a

0


30/194

S SO i1SLY PACf

a lt aou t o a o t l b o o o ta

ll a ggaat t ao a ta l

t a c bt t a a l t t t; t t l

a o t at o t tat ott oot ta g o ol bot l t hut bs b atlga oto a aoasoct oto o

a l ou oo o a aa ttg ? ls tt o o ca l m o ass tt l to ol t c t p a uu Sug u ol o sl; a slt o ot a lt olv at t aost w ols ato

g ato Wh o ot o a lt l a lt o t ool s

e age quie ecause he no meo ecause he is o e que

ae r Bae

ally ou l to b as o goo g but bla o t ba hngs o t ol og goo coul ouy pa

at l o h a a ay bt og ba oul a ug om o os a say ngs l was o aly I who ; was wa m y past causs aohng o o w h ao cam o rom bu roug Y s au o l t a a


31/194

\ iUL PC? a t aly a o a a l b Woul a b oh a

g nd

bla o t ba ng I a ? My w agly aal

aa a oug I t I t o ai yl o g but o t bla yl o ba ng t at ally a oly wh I ?

Oh S-tuain aut

g a w pl lluaon o a oon

by a p lv l abu a ang

a o l ugg a a b I a Bu I b you afraid l a u? Bau yo lo yu a ayb y aaly woul a a n an g ll

n a wa aa o a wa aa ta lot a o a g l a an ay o u

al w bl avan bta . bl a n ng na so far alao bu a n guaa a a mt t g o o wa o vl mpa-

g o b al Funanal a a l ala w a a al u ally ouag anxy on ?y al pl O ou uo o o (w I n go o C . S w)


32/194

- S L S IDICL PXIC? n ie eeing n he ee z amnn , n ha n s neve e

vin eqie coiuay eig

ttempt. I he iey nes ie he pice ns in I e se hi nxiey n cmeg sue ne vin , ne mih he se

I ccsng he hoic uch is poin vie ee h eo ahicism n ing i u he ne ing anxious ou

n ne e meime iey h omene ese hy n he e h h ses e ne e l h e n e eye

ee m h n s i somhing n y ng c nse n i

s ely cus ie ve ne h sI h y e ay no us y o ee ins m e e y ill

Cd Sys ofThugh

m eme I ms isuing o ysm huh s uch ha hee o e ing ha e ngven i

e yem e pain a h yem se aiy cce h y mises h e m amples:

2


33/194

USY A alvis who wh qus as o h uaa

ns o alviis will xli ours y ao s

a I a rih Yur roul is h yu hav n sav 2. A ai This wh, wh qsi as Goxis, will say ours y ao liv i o Y proud o ai h xis o a ing ra hanyorsl

A l vr i h xis o h vil who w sa: ours yu n' liv i h vil Th irs hi h vil

lvrl s is o nvi pp h s xis . A Ahis wh wil sa: rial aru agiv u will vi u hr is G. Yo hav a hh ,suprsiis v i

. A Marxis wh w sa urs u a ap hEomi irpra o Hsry r raz ha h CssSl is he l issu Yr upr has

bouris6 A Fria wh will sa urs u a s h Ia rih Al h rass y hav iv ais pshaai hry ar purly sv raaizas aasalizi ha whih o y is s hrai

A Fii iriis wh wi sa ours a raliz ha his is a a's wr a h ar

iai w l on h i vl quall on h prsal a psholial lvl ours a s his; yu ar a ma [r i sh is spai o awoa ours ou a s his y hav oia y ml haviis iol whih ly provs yoin

I av prhaps iv r ha h xaps Th irsn hi is ha i h ariy o h ass h o h upsI av mio a asil s hruh h pruis o hhrs A surly I us i a si lr aory wihoalizig i I wor wh pris oul ?

24


34/194

S F S UUS

t

Ysy I s scss n sc sah can' a s as ancssay pa css n a sch s a a y sas cscn n ya hs c s c as a

no ncsay c a s any s s as s c Ips a s I sc a s csI a c n y s Ia n ny ,s as o

s p T s sps as a c as a s s cOn s s a h cc

R a s s s ns z ,h s a cssy hs s

s an s n scp as cssy n y s y ass p

s Dtsat

Y ha n a sn pn co ss csn nh cs


35/194

S LI SO IDICO DOICL ov youor who oi ay doe lv yuwho osaly hrwig r a you. ha ar yo o ? o ar

arig a hai o arr u ha rai hik raiakss our ri kow yu vry wll a i rlyroi n fiig h wksss a irig h ar whrthy ray hur ha ar yu o o? I a hink o vrassii is . is o l hi kp hurig you a o ar hai as gruly a yo : o v l hi kha h hurig you aus i ig hur hi lig

tol ha is hurig you l l his i h irs ossil ur a ak y o h our I ro Somay all uh a our aily u I hik hi is a allyrvr oio iliss . I y rur o his pi lar

so ovius ours s o ak your ow ars a throw h k a hi vry i h rws ar a yu Thiours s oo uo Bu s hary wihou isa

aags For o hig a la o prul warar Fothos who y warar, his ay h s our. B Irsu h ary o y rar ar r fr pa Ihul also rr h your r ma o e ecosiously aae ha he is hoig das Th apaiy of hua o raonaiz is aasi vry ais otha h is sais If yur ri wr old ha h s hrwig

ars h igh o hhy ia . H ih sy home? vr hr ars I a a palovi a hy shuI hr rs? I is ra you ho ar hrog h ars I aly g ys. s o i you ar hrowg rears a hi h ay ovr H w say: S so wasi yu a h yu a rig wary yu who was hr h r a h wh . was oy

g ysl a I i us o sr a hr apprah wih is avori . This is o auy lk ovr your a ipig i ca ac do!

2


36/194

H S S UUS D a pss cnks an aknsss an caync y n Ts y n ca

t a y a as ks an y assy a y a k ack o a ckh yu F a as F as ouags snas a sayng s I aa y n sn s s a Y rallh s ngs H y p go ays n yu as ack a as n y

a ma n yu a ny a ca an a cp asthn yu ha s s raiip n a-tnsp ay ha s ps a a a ntps pa a cs nsp ? H ca y a a cs ans ss gng a- I ca sp y n c tangy gng angy an n s? a

th a h a as any can' y ak a jWy a yu s sns n n nsa ng aac a an yng k n a s g c ,yu a yu sa ys y nsa ys yu ncsa ys Y u- s a yu a n a a ay l a nshp a yu a ha a cs ansp yu a

t a y a ns c an yu a a nsa y n ys Btts can' k Sn y s c ay anaz a a p n N yu at s ncasa y n aay y -n a y ac y ay ng s nnngaay y can' p ng s Y

s s a psycas Ys, n y n sy a a can yu on sc a ? I s I c y s I c p yuB I a unny n y a c sag

2


37/194

L PC ght t d hd

as somims o higs wich he chile absolulae asig thm as well as oh auls ha hs hingsa all d o thm. he as sa, We a ol wise mo exice a o chil a oe ow behat s goo o he chle ha he chl no msles A h ans say o h ch n Yo ae oo youg to alie hat what we ae oing is al yo best

ogm iess. Bu wh yo go a bcome mt then o will le a we we gh ms be awuly embaassng to h as w he

hil go an coninu o bl as ml as hatthe as w no h! Say e chl achs sny athe aes a somwhe hi inis, a he ciles sayig No! All m li exnces ha connc

e mo han e ha you w oally wong! fh aswoul say, Wll w he bs we could Im s hehl wol ogive hm o he so B uose heas sise We e igh , onl you e oo young oalie a he ime Now suose he chil ls B Ioh o sa ha wh I gw I woul ealie you weih Wll ow I have gow . ow com I o ale

t s a th oi that h aes mus n he suaio bi to he embaassig sie Wha a h as ossibly sayhe onl ly ca i o is his We d o say ha ! Whae sai was ha wh yo go and ome maue heo il alize e wee igh! Now, yo ase o haveow b clel have o bcome mae e yo aeo svey, b yo sil hi le hl e v ac hat

o sil l ca se we we gh ol os ho mmae yoil ae his gume , I amit s baabe

28


38/194

ULUSL

O utin s i

dul tereor you soud cu or ir ayosiss e realzaio ht we lve in a cie ad we cn't o at we lke It would be a ne w d do we alt au oig just wat we ped! Thre ae oeeoe aso to oer As o ge oder, wl reze a a't aways b he wy yu l. We s lear toprise.

Teeger Do yo ea beleve e h peind aot realize we cant al d wh we le u rely tat lowly of as o be h wod rey wn toaiy all y esireseen hoe whch h hrs reI alize a an' grafy er wh, or wd wno. But ot egr i n a cpse. Thsimiaio (if sod be uch) s soehn w.

ee to all it se re e as quie hr!u C hat you le. s a cope whehr oua t a opoise o ot. t ks o eene wh o se o t; te at a yu ave o oproie weheo ke t or o

Teeger ae oing ore o sa abo thi ha wt a aey sai owever, te qestion o"n oe's ha

oe ot oe wti e ope o wt we ave bee sss- f am oing soe at whi s ohers he gra yoa egitimae ight o opai Bt a my eingy ai gro ossbly njure oers

Al O orse t rt oers you were ivng ety i veryo re hs ir oul o ay or. t you ar o. You are living n a soey i wic sor

a o me s te acepe r. And yor efusal o aide byt or i a re at o ggrssn gst ociey An yor ares a oe w ar or you! Yo ot

29


39/194

CL IC t us themsg you wal aou lie his Coul yoo have he iss o cu you hai a las ung h yao e ou oo oviig o you n a o ie wh yo e o you o he yo ca ma you oecisio

Teeger Oay i my log i us you that muc be hay o cu t

Ault ga la! o o! on' wan you o cuou ha o lase me I wan o b o o make yo

u you ha wa you o cu you hai bcauseou

wa oo bcause I wan you oTeeger Th a aa ha you ae askin o he

ogicall mossil you as me o cu my hai soile o me o do so. Bu i you ema ha at o cumy haiha woul cu y ai eve ha you o skeha s simly iossible

Adlt he h yo shoul se sychiais 'm sut ou we he hans o copn analys ae oule o yas yo woul be suicnly maue o t ou you ha You woul he do so o you o cco wihouyoe's lling you o

Teenger Bu o' nt o wa o cu y haiAult You e layig silly wo gas! you w o

sychs you woul a whle wa o c you hai yo woul be gla ha you wae o.Teenger Bu sice o' wa to wan o cu my hai

th as you say sychiais woul inlunce e i heicio o aing o cu y hai whic icinally o' bl ieve woul ally hae bu l us assue o h motth woul h s say sic o' wn to cu my hai

sychiis woul inuece chang his wathe ovously do' t wan o s sychiais

0

Adlt Bu you hol s sychiaisTeeger Bu ot wa o Adlt The you go being selish agan! Bcause o ot


40/194

S S DUUS PD'at to see a pcitrist, ou do't see oe. It ever occurs toyou tat it yr iturit ad eotoa instability youre uring countlss ohers. Bu o Becuse you satisieit your ondi it llws t yu don't chnge t

egr All right, I am rell urtng ou t y so-aled"eross, d you rell at e t see a psciatrist il see one

o, o on't want ou to see a psycitrist just tease e a you to see a sychitrist ecause you want tot becaue ant ou to.

eegr I ard we are i te sae piin as eoe ol w I c see ut o te cult is ths : o yu knoo ay oter kid o being hm i I sa irst, ould tet to see a psciatrist, ad alo om I ul wat toee

u More or ges! ou oud ealize tis is erious mater. Your okes are ot uy!

eeger am beig qui serious. I srousy canot at at t is ta you o wat e to do. You sy you at me ut my ar ut oy i wat to, ic you kno do'd you ant e to see a psciatrist, but ol i I at tic agai do't. So I a qute conused Wt o you at to o

u Wat do I t you to o do't at anytig! at you to do at you at to do, ot at wat you to oeeger ut at i exct wat I a dig. So at's t

roe at' te robe e rbem is tat you are ot

uting your aireeger But ou to e tat ou dot at e to cut

m air ness I t to, ad told yo don't wt to, aece yo d't at me to, so I am ot oig ayti yoo't at me to o

Are't ou cever, it you gic ad sopistryLoo 'm ot ere to discuss Aristotle d Pato t yo

3


41/194

S LI S IDICSL PAXICAL' sa o sg a s vauabe a a engy o heseesss wo gams woun ' i be smpe o you jus o cu

ou ai a lok lke ec huma beig chage?eenagr Bu I o't an o cu my haiAul Bu I an you o wan o cu you a nagr Bu I can' wa o cu my haiAul a o you man yu ' ? ou ma ou on.

f couse ou cou cu ou hai i ou wan o enager I ' sa I ca' cu m ha. O couse I can I

ai I ca' an o cu my haAul h ou shou se a sycasenager Mus we go hough ha agan?Aul No we o' have o go ough nyhing agai. I

m c sase wih hngs s h aeenag Goo Can I go o?Adul O couse ou ca go o hy o ou hae o ask

y msso ? e ou a ch? You ac as I am sango You ca go weve ou l ke Oy I wish ou wu cuo ha

enager l me honsy why is it o imoa o yoa I cu my hai?

Aul I's o imoan o me, i's impoa o u Aso m I o ' cae wa yu o You ae o og a c . o

e ol eough o make yu o cisons you soucie o cu you ha I is u who shou c o mwho cs i o you

nag Bu hy su I cie o cu y aAul I shoun' hae o l you wy. u sul ko

why by yous wou y ang o l y.enagr I'm soy bu I on ' kn wy.

ul couse you kno wy! Hw can ou go auike ha w you knw ns ope?nagr I m soy i os p . u I b a I

have e g o ce ow I sa a my a.Aul ou'e no o i ons p u a oy o

3


42/194

I L SO IICL IC?a o on ol, ow ou ould o go auookig lk a

TeegerNo a is no u.

Io o o i

euei tons o I o s unoua a a t

os oplAu Bu o o i i is i o o aou ong

eopl?eeger is o ys o o answ o ha uso t

bvousl ns o au o onse

Au oul ou ak aound ak on e ss io l lk i?Teeger O couse oAdu o?Teenger s la, I canno iagin a I woud

e ik iAu o? as so saul aou nui?

Teeger is oig ojl saul aou Is us a m culu as iuc in can auaos wic woul ak i ipol o o

Aut Bu suppos ou i ik i ou you?Teeger As I sa i is vy a o o iagn ha I

oul k t Bu i I l l k i No, I su I woul'yow

Aut y oTeeger ause I oul no wan o on osdut Oh oy! Spak aou nonsiny! Wy is ay

ose o on os wih uy a long aTeeger I o' now y. I u ss wosmuc

oso mAdu ou ae ng oally iaional! You isa

o I oug a la a you w inllignTeeger 'm so bu I canno ag a I am gaoal Ju bau I on ng o ano a amabl o sa ay res o y n os no atha ce i is aional No am I iaona o


43/194

S S RCL PC? tet t beae o t o hat the aso s Doeh ea tha I a theeo tellget Possbl eeha ee etall ce a col thn bete oe o the oe the obl col come h o h e oe to the ohe Bt ata caott east t the oeto th

Al o hole tble that o ot coom oo aet the ate le o coong h he otaoable he o othe Aga t o ego It ala

1, "I, Becae o e og ha t ae o eece the eeTeenae I o beleve coo h thng to o

th tAl O oe t oe t ht o ot eale hat

thogh o e tg ot t oo o a acalloomg the e ct lettg o ha go

Teenae hat eath a talg abotAl ea that ettg o ha g o aog ot t alt ocet bt t the ocet o yo oge g o g o a lg o be one hem So ot eto o coog o ot coog o ave too hethe o t to o ot he ealsc eo wee o co bt to hch go o coo

Teenae A th ot t tell o that t yo ot h lag o gae atcla o a obvoslg the te coo a otaa ee eog e o age g o ta le alt e eogh the e og ha Bt ce el leng ha am ot eag t ot o coot h ee eel ecae I e that a actall ee

hot h og ha he ol ee be oog t ee eag og a O ee long ha bto t hot t o the ae o the oale al, thega I ol be coog Bt ce a eag the aI e the a ot coog coo ea to gnt e ta clato the ae o aothe


44/194

W I U va heoe a oally cousin issu wh se the em oom i he way you

A: Aai you lay all hs semancs o m I ol yo ot hee o iscs h yo he hlosoy o wos Yol get yo hai ct Dot yo eale ha yo long haia yo oo ffmin

n Oh, ha wa s boeng yo Wy int yoa o aie Well, ot belee o one momnt a itae e oo minae o e i is icoceable that

ythi hich aaly ws on a male boy ca ma ito eeia ex, eha yo wll be elln me ha myexl oga oo eemiae Pehas you woul le e toove them lso

A: o so beig ceousn: o being aceios uie seiously oul

t be is i ociety is ovn to a oi o eesy i

ich

e ill ge he billiat iea at he sexual ogan eiate n hence ill emove them oe o looo ascie

A: Eogh hese c aasies You no hey aeiiclos a ot ying o casae yo, bt jus vese e a shol be a a a a oman soul be om

n What sa sae o aais ha eole sholhae to tal e this o me a an s a ma a a woa s aoma itho havg o bel ieve hey shoul be I hi allhis oveaxie bot e being mascule an women beingiie oing oe ham an oo

A: Lo, hi it is oless to aue any moe iho b thi ou bbonly euse o c yo a, an

bvosy ohi can ay wll cane you min. I hnve i o hisel cae ow o eah a ol yo o ct ai, yo ll oulnt

n O cose olA: So even o hmsel ca ice youn ha oe o ollow hat oes o ollow a all

35


45/194

RCULY PC oo he st lace I o t o ee o ot the

a o Bt et o te ae o agmet assm the

he a yo ay i he came o to ea which by h a

th a iiculou cocet bt et tat oit o} e camo to eah a commae e to ct ha I olse his ea oly tat I am ot esiiv to hat ige calle h exena voice o Go eve thi oe oly tha I am isensiive o he in ea voie o Gothe voice o iluece hic os ihin e I Go eall

ae me o cut my hai he oul now bee a to comow to ea an tell m o o so he now me ell eogto o that ne hose c icumsace I olt I he e to cu my hai e he will cause me o di to o o I a smle

Adl: You sea as i you hae o il l o you ow he uc hig as ee wi ll ic Go has give yo t o o

o ho ecies whehe yo cu you aTnag Yo aise subl b exmely imoat oit o a aly igt a aly ng Yes t ee whoecie hee I cut y hai Bu ha oes o at al ule othat Go also ece hee I cu y ha

Adul I o etan you a allTnag Le me t his way I I am ungy the t

to me hehe I ea o o e ecie ehe o o toat B I hae ee y lie dided to be hngy Similal I ae he dei to cut my hai he i o e hehe It my hai o ot O I esie o to c y hai aga to me ha I o abou i Bu is no myeos myll, omy owe wich emines my ve si Wae iowe iall i Nau Go o a yo il li i s hi owe

hich is he imay lemen i ecing whe o no I cty hai Peole o no cognz e imoance o s owehey in i y ho o yng i a oeme e o a e i ie o aancally i mo e su inoace

36


46/194

- O S PC? o ea aet I a be o bo as to te

that o ave osa tie to su this owe o

e te to tae the e o Go eAl hat eath e o ayg ht a bsouey te thouh I aize t

xte cu ai o o to acce eso ve ee atete to su Go oe i y ie ai as ee the ao cause o a ou sycoogica t eca eaie ats o o ovesaio It wa ot

og tat ay agee to ct y hai to ease ; oe toa eage a usate ha I wou ot cu m t ease my I ohe os t as o eog o yoo g vaos ssues o e to change my ehvior; yoe to oce chage m ve o y o make me ct ai ot sg Go et s ie oma uoate o a t o tht. But to be iiae wih me

t o ot tt y ai b o ot wnt o cut m hai oethig a o asc a a oe amaig It a ommaing soeig iossibe I as ese oo t oma e t cu y hai. Bt t eseesaoe tha eeessto comma me to want o c m hait thi ate te o omma o e oe which aaio hat igt be cale Go oe

Al: o ot e icuos Ho ou ossiba o to wt to ct you hai I cat g isie yoa ae o wat hat I wat yo t wa Wo o o I a Go

Ta: No that he whoe oit But ou equenyt s o we o ahe a you ish ou we. I ae onget that ou ai obm i is a you ae o Go yo

o hat yo ae o a ou a uiousy aging a yoat be (hat has he rel ason you l e cuc ) Ia hi o oy o h bas o you bao owa m ate ohe chin bu aso you baio to you spouse aa o o ies I cosanly o ha s ot

3


47/194

S L SO D'LOULY RDCL eoug o yo o bn os o o you wl but yoage an ue an ac u a you can n ope's ve

l o you w. An s I sa s you ajo omI so a I canno be o oe o yo i smae. I a exec you o le wa I m sang as i i sn ow I ealy o ws o ake leae

38


48/194

m I U S


49/194


50/194

Sr Pox

th t mct much o o thg Cosee a ho sas "Oh Go, I ohg Im ohg Im ol sgcat sec vast vese eally ohgt t ame a l also a "I am huma humas a oe eo to mals o Go has vege s bvg s ee l l a amals ae o couse o a hghe levea lats No oe a las Bu a owe Wha coule oe ea a eect tha a owe owe otacg yth! lowe s as beauul a eect as t be t o ceato at s best I aot be a betea t s

hee am obvosy be ha a oe oe seect et ol seable ohg Is h oteaable

Fou Aeric is

r d o he Geat Whe Oouse beleve he Gea Whe S eve eel the eathte t

Scod Ida: o ev ou I hae always elied he eat Whe eve ol ee he ea Whtet

hrd Ida o sage M case s he oose have

ay el he Gea We S bu ee coul belee he Gea Whe belee ha my eelig ae butchlsh sues os eoce by my acesal eachgs

orth Ida: t seems I a he oly wholly maue aae oe amog ou I eh eel he Geat Whe S oelee he eat Whe t


51/194

O YOU SOD ms c d?

Assig hee s a o, oul o be upse iamas ceve m c heeas uas ae sohoost he abi to o so I hat ase a be a h realaso h ma hmas beliee a o s ha e acuallyave m achac acia eoies o he as i whch eeceive iecl

I a ot aogehe iig! oe hae he eelg a

ogs Peeaboo a Peeaoo ae i dire oac eve hich e huas mel aso abou I my co-ecu houl be oc he oul o all he hologcaises o he as amou o o ga joe? Oe a asagait asos t maes sse o aso agas ah. In maes ese o easo agast auoi! Bu oaso agaist acual e ucoscous oes? ha

oe o ch easos hae?

Nw go

beieve egos have be ee b . oub haa o hem eve ahes is holl r Ye each aoai ome ee o h Sie oe e hae beeaowe o eset he spculaos wh soul I o bealowe to expess Ae all a oe eso allbee ha a ohe So s spculao. [I ha oeqael chece he lieaue so I o o o o

gal is.]he is a o. Bu Go is oal. Hs e spa,thogh, is ve logsay soe llos o blons o yasAe o goes e ll ee a pace o p hiese gog. So o wll h x placee b? ser he ole uose o eoluio s o a us moals ?) o

4


52/194

-ITOL YOU SOlbe he ext . s is ou ea uose A counlessml lea i w sa we asra o an o aga,

e evelo o o w we all use og an boethe ext o. Te we ake oe e ne uons sataiig oals o ace us ec. a iiiu.

Is c? nrsan lan pp a l isessnal a r N nl s ru o eeous surns o l bu n cos e ran Tatha we us all n e sr o le as lng as ea, bu alas e a l o l e era an so ea s ou na

ea M lea ns also no e a o ol s i wo ae ac s rn wso bu ol oul ea a ile more wul n ou a al e ga asese ks e as e soon o l c o salzao. I am also no a my nl o alze ae is ac s ue onl o e ac e o aeoug, bu also ac I ae lve ou an o

gal au coup w e ac look a ltoug oscolore sss a I surnl use o sea a is a a an aso ow l as beusu ounae an a a' prsonal sueeou.

Wll, wo am I o nra wr o so a aelcs? u us cnss I ae n le

ou le as r n s ps ansucal s w I n a eron a s,m aus owa s r o n an. n I ha sucl u s I le s rago en a my l s ra bu sp am n aeora sa xuang pn an I wan pan o


53/194

I TO U SO he s s that I a be ea r sst tha I a be h t s e 's beg trac he

e thght that e s tag tes e higs eme nnym he ie I a a a m what I have bseve

ee sha I stg sset that hee s ve iea beee h mc e has se htg e ees ha ie s tag I h he agc ese e s ahe temeamea a hich as ite t

the mt seig e has eihe exeiece iesse hi t s the y seig ahe tha hentty seig ch is eva o he mae e eas a ie hsh cao he btsec hat hose h a ms he age e a hee es h ce mst he agic eemes ha a ie hat s t sa he a thse hse ai es a sch ha

the b t be ha gaess avabe sthe exea evomet A i t s ths eoe h ms e tage ie t tse h ca sest

he tageies o e s I am me a seg aeah hat eah is age s smehig b i eveeieve Seg ght cme smeha cose esecia

he the eg aeas t e veabe bt hi hs msses the a he s hig isie me thaeig bt ee that seg is smehig be rntdld hld lntd ahe ha smehig be tag-e ve Seig s st G am ai he ec

hi he tagic as se b hse h caim e be agi ces me a ceai mac a meamai

ie eite saomasochisic es oub hathe Ge ageias ee hgh o e as agic his ay!hei tagees' a o a oa dee spit he beauy them oes se s mc t he sffrn ve butae t a ssia eeg Uiesa amohsiait seems me e sueig as esseia

4


54/194

-I Olit os o a ami t a o astoht, os sbimi ass ot throh s, o

ic o s b inndnty

o si( his , i a smbs sbim ba o c amacs

o sos to tos o caim a ac o as o is icaiv o immati o moioa , is o o o co as ai h oa ha ihst om o ba s oa oc t

aiv ascs o a si som o m as s cosist ivhig av b saig h sa ta ov o a socal ssimisti hiosos sc as Schohaa vo ama a al amog m avois os a lita hioso i s a i h ssimislosos o ssig o axi ci, b

i oothn. av ii as, hi is bcas h ssimsi osohs a a oimis at' also oc as ao hoso, Wh is h a h ssimisic ilosos, so ch ai O cos , bcas o o i is t

Though o Schoa

ha Soha sho b a as a ssss m as aasic Mab is somwha ssimisibo Li houg o i a coicig wa bu h su as

l is icbl oimisic abou Dah h i oia o o i h mo oimisic ha hoig

ow amo ss oh h ci ihocio o tosa aig as, his a b

$


55/194

O YOU SO ecase she ows ha i he all, hey all bac ioe wob whee e ae sae; eeoe ei all is a ee

esoe eaes will clai a ly is oimisic Bu oalalisic Scoeae is acig as i e believe a aeea we sill i soe sese t a ae sae i e womb oohe Na ysel wol give a oe aica ieeaio i ha e qesio is o wee we exis ae

ea b whee exisece isel is all ha ee ooexisece Soe iae ae will el O cose hey aeie Exisece is e ve oosie o onexisece

I ow he ae oosie Bu s o i s ius eo e oosie ls eo

Yo o!

he olloig covesaio ocue hle was ingw some lose ies inlung oe maall im B a gilall e M a el be isussing wh B

the qesio o a ale He beleve i o be a seesuesiio. On he ohe an M ns o bieve in smeo o aele o he goussae b Gohha aeso's ow oexisene is ioncabe o one, an ha i mossle o oe o belve in song he cann eveoeive. e o age wh M, an uhemoe beve ate bee i he eai o ah is bu a oa unun

esii. ha also bee n sussing h B quesio o egoassivnss. B ns a I am vey egsseive as ov e g ., b my a u a eassess Moe sca, he ns a i vy nemao o egoassie ope, a on ass g wngo I ik a h s bng eass n assg hs, bu

4


56/194

-T YU Slog t hese houghs we on my mn a e t osao coesaio wen as lows

Io b s Wul o ke o now he

raleas o the s eie

YesI o I he tumhany say o al l my skea

es 'I to o so hs g genea aughh si t wo t be unny i yu we hoy

to sv he o oul h o one aoun o oa

s o cous got anohe lughhe It ol be esing i us hose whoe svive, n ose wo in' n'

I tought bo this an ans myse sung wih th the beeves eing oy usae a n ingb to got ove n obeieves, sne hy woul l ae t s go out o isence So I woul be gain

I i I hi t woul be sill unnie h vese ti th seics we e only ones o suvive I cae gi t seics ogehe sying Po aymnoo b e s o wih s , glaing n eling s I yuo su el s so I h han he wu e e whs o


57/194


58/194

I


59/194


60/194

e Asoo Wo ePossby o cs

Oce o tie hee as sooe e blieeh the aws o celesia echaics sally hel Bu he ae to the ossibili o icles e i o go so a s oeieve tha hee eve had bee n icles o hat tecessil ld be icles i he uue he as eele t the ogic ossibili tha the ight have beeice i the as h hee ight be iacles i the

e his oe e his celsial echaic veell ut his eeae as o he kpical pe; he as ot oubig Thos O couse his oubg Toses ot o he sua te o heas he Bblicobig homs s oubu bou iacls, h was oub h it l kow ha icles ee occu e saist ecse eve s icle o o ow o

ice ht call hpee, h soul believe thaice eve hape Wha roofo I have ha e e oice A so hee he me sonoica eicio he sull ece i o ape i ih ulss hee i miace

Oe e eic eclipse. Pople ske him Aeo e t il tae lace? e plie O couse it will

ess o ouse, hee is iacehe o he eice eclipse aive, but hee as ocipse he eople exciel e o him aske htaee W thee iacle e eplie No, o hees o ice ust s ha I isclcuae

e S e

Sr: I oe bush hee is ose ih hee eas iee t ails oge ees

5


61/194

PSOHCFALS-Sktc Nosese tat bs tee o monse wi

tee eas, ve eg, two ais, a oange eySr:

ee ee ch a moe yoe bStc: ee o moe i yoe sSr: Yo ot have t ae m wo o it a yo ave t

o o ve k o the b a yo wi ee sc ose

Sc: I w be ay t tae a oo o mye, bt ae yo wi ot ee ay c mose

Sr: t i ile o to ics i e i yo aae a oo a ee o yoeStc: Ve we I i go o a oo

f miuts latSktc: a a wa ig! e sc moe

e b

S: eay at atat I o ave w I ac a moe the bSc: hat e tbe wi yo ee! ae awa

y ee tg whic eality ot eiS: i at bieve thee o c mote t

Sktc: ca ae yo hee t

Sr: i o o caeStc: ot aeSr: A yo aw ohigStc: Oh o, aw omhigSr: Wa i o eeStc: a a mone wi ee ea ive eg, a t

as Bt t ee ae eow o oage

S So

Oce o a tme ee was a ma wo e te t a

5


62/194

HSOPBICAL FA is t to bcom amous al i at t th so al o his tg to g o ta msca

tat i whh t was o og imora to him wr oot was amous l i ha too

ohe S So

Oc t was ma who was oom b msasiatio ha all sors o marabl iss as t ttimat at al wot volumousl w wt a w was ot ow, rl golss, o too at i i wha h ha wt For ma most a iis wi g , a hs mausri o a

ai wth at a joi t t col o as h slowl but sur lost al is mstica isight Th o a, a hs mausctt ol ot sta a wor o wat a wri

Uo us

Oc o a tim tr was a ualist bl atm a ma saat substas Just how tta ot to ows was o o thsts l. But was sure hy w sarat

bstacsis ualist otualy a barabl aiuot bcaus s hlosoia bls, but o utit asos A a xcllt mra ic tat sit was i sight o th st o s l. log ooti o ta to i Bu h was t rom sui b

53


63/194

HILOSOPHICAL Fuch sons a h i no wn o hu oh o by hih; () h ws i suii mih b moy won; h

s aai hmigt b an a, an h i no wn is h ossib iy o na unishmn So ou oo uaisa ui s

hn cm h isoy o te miac u Is c oth ak was o annh h sou o min niy bu h boy unconin a bo Absouy obsab chn cm o h k; h boy con inu

c us a i i sil ha sou o h coss in obsv cou ossby know ha h k ha an hg, uss h ak inom hm

o you bi h such a u is ipossb in pincp ssuming you bi i possi wou you k i ? Wou yo i as imo? s i nmoun o suic? hnyhng in Scipus obing h us o such u?

uy h o o h ak can l u al i sponibi is on ah Aoh usion Suppos you spous oouch a ug, an you knw i You wou know h sh o ho lon h ou bu a us a i h i ha ou yo o you m any ss?

o un o h soy ou us was o ous, !ow h cou annh a h ms h is sol ha is n a wy no

ubc o any o h ooin objcion . An so o h stim in ya, h wn o b wih a ih ha yingomoow moning I w o own o h so an h u My ys o suing a o a las Wh hsthouh h pacuy asp

ow a his poin a cuious hn hppn A n o huis who knw aou hs u, an who knw o h

uins o h s ci o pu hm ou o hi misyo in h mi o h nh w us was s asph in uiy so no h hous n inc h ugo hi ins h nx monn oy o swowihou any sou inan h s hn wa

4


64/194

-lSHICA ALSto go o h gso o g g H ook i ho anbo aking i si Now I sl b as" So ooki

n hn wai i ina in wic i was sppos oo A h en o h inval angiy xci Da this su s hp a al! I sill obiousy ha soun a suing as mc as ev!

Dosn all is suggs a phps igh b sothing us ll wong wih ualis?

The M o W S wEvehg

Onc h as a n wo was sis wi tng!is phiosopy o li was a i is bs o b sis wivying. An azing hing is acuay live uto is pilosophy His ai go many popl xlyxaspa. Bu ws sisi wi oo Wn askBu a you n dissaisi wi anying? h piO I a o os issaisi wi many hings bu my

dissisio os o bo a al I am cysais o b issisi Bu a you no bing inconsistn? O cous I a! sisi wi h oo ! h coow a you y sisi wi ng?" Wy cainy! A you saisi wi ac ws an AolHil? O cous n A you sais a ws wa i ina? cou no A yo sais wi ai

ouion? O cous no A you sisi wi ach h hua is han wi anniiio? Oous o n w on you sais wi? ano sis wi ning in piu a ony siswi ings in gnl

55


65/194

SOC FSCpe

Oc uo a i wo boys ou a ca. On o hm saii wi a h ca h oh on sai ", ha sot i ou h a togh, w shou sha aha ai a o o a ha o m h s boy sa shou hav h ho ca h sco sai, " , whou sha a sha ai ha o ou an ha m his sai wa h who a h sco sai, "

t s sha ha a ha ong cam a au who sai m ou shou igh about his ou shou co- iv him huas o h cak

Bt d Pie ng- Vew bv s a isa o jug o at o a sos i ohavio aat m h oa icu

uos o am a ma bas his wi suas ba, o bho h o og bas his hs cmstac I wo sa t ba w bssi ot o

Jug d Defet Jd to Ddt) ho h cou ss oo b hag b th c i o a

dt: a a

A Hoc S d: ot sa wh o o wa oh oo b ai

dostc Sdst: Oh o you msusoo I s o oh


66/194

PSOC Feoes ai I esie bt e eas ei ai ive

Cr Wh o o al i a; oes aal vaiios

B: No has his woe obee o magies oes

A Skpical Mysi oh: ave o eve a a sia exeiees

Jm: O ave hem al he ime b I o beive

Poxic Raionaist Oe ee was a ma wo was osa a iiaigia We se Wh a o so aioal e eieeas iaioa o b so aioa asiall I aioa ove aioaiy; he mo he bee he mosaioa ig I a o s o b as ioa as a a s aso s aio

Hon h h Ta bove is eiise o so o w ase e mase ow o o get amo w h ao s i la o ao w a

A Buisi Bit wo ies wee wi e o e o Oe si o o sie hisi to bje o ilig b? e o h so e sai B t bg is

On Lif d Dea Wol o a e ieamig eso

B: Oh ei i oves ivig e is yiall so eso wo wil go o ivig he es o is

B se w e omeme


67/194

O F- t at st s t ohe i A sa Wh

I t ig o going i

iO Isolatio : v s o Dst ha a o isa

B: O ot at a am i isoa eol B ae ot feel isoae Wh I wih ol

I'm

ai a that he a o a isoaom t soae Bt he I ao I oaget that t e a eo a so h oat hatv

Fous?D I issig t t i a ve as

t oit ai t a s at o a mo a o a aos

RevlaionD o I iev h os vaio havg tb vig

Ar Bditic BitD Fen to Bddh): i oig a sho hav ig iscssing ha a ga g o

Bt: is ihot saig Fen W o o si hi si shio? Is t

his i t is atte i sc a vios waBht: at o a was aughig t Wha sc

s wa h c hat h I which o sem sa t i et a eist

Sl I h oowig vs i ow a


68/194

HSH FBL ad te teeH ad te eTh cannot ee tei n eauy

wo yas a, o my amazm, cam upo hoowig passag in Spgs Pops acs a Tongus

s a sgh o p pahos o s how h spig owsaving o iiz a iz cnno o a i gso aac on ano, o s on ano u mus

av cos o aimas, o whom aon hos scs is

I T, Trfore ? I tnk tee I am

Culd eO t eally mene else nly thnk he' me

eesr Fee W?

Scene Exstentalist: Bu yo uldn't ma such a omis Yo

av o way o owg ha yo wi p i i h uVcim: Wha h hl a o aig aou? O cos

w i h uExstentialst Bu how o yo ow you wil i i h

u?Vctm: Bcas hav deced o p i i u

as how owExstentialist I o o ny a yo now onsy in

o yo oms I is jus ha o o s how yos goo nion ca ossiy gaan ha yo wiav ay goo inions i h u A a, h ch a hng as changing os min!

9


69/194

SPHC FAL-Vm No wih me hee s I ee bea omiEsenas: ow o ou ow aVm: ae nee boke a omise m whole ieEsenas: I beie ou I o oub ha o

e ou e me a ou hae neve e boe omise Iake ou wo imici Bu jus becaue o hae eve ithe as boke a omie wh oe oo ha ou eel he uue?

Vm ea on unesa ou a al Ae ou a

omee eeminisi o aisi osiio? t as i wee aea wie i he boo o I wll a e ua ince on' now he boo I ae o wa o owiha he uue wi be? ohe wos ae o ing o ele ha I hae ohig o sa i he mae

Esenals No o ; I am o saing ha a all I haeo beieve i ee wi . Bu sage eough ill o h

ucial sue hee ha o a a ic eemi oulome o e same cousio I wou on o ve ieeeasons he eemis wou a ha whehe o o oee ou omise he uue ic eemie b haw o hics ogehe wi he ese oguao o hunese an sne ou o o know enough abou he seonguao n ou hae no aiona mea o owig h

uue e eeminis wou hus sa s no u ohehe ou kee ou omise o o; i i u o he uive is law o he ohe an beli i ee ll anhece belee a a a ime u o wha u o atha ime You have ow mae a mise o you ow ee wi l You ese ien o kee Bu o no beiee ha ohae he owe o choose n wha ou w choose o o i e

uuVm Bu do hae he owe! I o I hae veo bke m wo. Do is o cnsiu v sngobabi si eience ha I w no bea m mis uue?

60


70/194

O Sxstentalist: Oh obabl sc evence! I wasn nng

f his at al ! I houh o wee cain a ceainy ha yo

ee o ose I al you ae alkn aou s pbality, the Im ot se I woul saee wh ou. Ine hect ha o ave eve e bke a se i s n sl ooobabilisi caio ha o wo i he e houhehas oe eeva acos shoul be an no accoun . A ae i a o ae saying i s ha is ly ha yo wille o mise wil o spue o Al I ojc o s yo

bsole cetanty ha o ll e ou posect: O ous I ceain It's no a e a oobabi li ; t s a eso o coplee an oal ceany ooget that t s ho have ae he se Thee is noowe t ti ivese hich ca oce e o bak mise

xstentalist: now ha o owe i h uns ca

ase o o bea o wo know ha ul wll o ae neof t most songwill slwll ope I ae eeownee a woul chaacze o as ownbbo heeoe I now ha no enal oc caome o o ba a poise Bu ha os no ea ha yelo't ave he powe o ba ! An no onove oa ossb now whehe ou w choose o o

hs th ct: nt chose o o hs ! I kn I won Exstentialist: B h o o now?cti: I ot ow ow I ow I jus nowExstentalist: aly ow tha a s hay woh o

o ow a o sa ha o ow u a o on nowow o o

ct: I s e

I d now, b I on now ow I nowExstentialst: ha is culous! n nowcti: I d Exstentialist: o octm: I o


71/194

SOPmAFALS-Exsentalist o o

Etc etc

Seea mohs ae he ici el ino h has o a eibai sugo his sgeo was a iabolica chaace whoseseia was o om bai oeaons whose exess uose was o ma eole choose o ba h oises. An

so he ei bai sgo oeae o o icim a as s he icim ci ? o bea is mse Shol aee ha he oowing cosaio wih a emis

Detemnst So o be o miseVictim Oh esDetemnt Wha wo o sa ow o h exisiais

ow abo o ie oesaio

Vctm Obios ms ami ha he xiseias waigh a was wng. e caim hee was a ossibii ha wol choos o ba m mise I aime hee was' Soea was igh a was wo

Detemst: wol o i ie ha w. o wg o os. B wo o sa was ih wag oo.

Vctm a o o meaDetenst was igh i ha i was o eai hao wo ee o omisehis o ow eai. B hewas wng i sain ha wa to o wheh o o oe o omis. is basic ac is ha he beiees ei

Vctim has o alac also biee i ee wi

Detenst ou ma o sed o bi i wiVictim No si bie i e wi Detenst: Ee ae o xeece wih h bai

eo Ee a h oce ou o ba o isVicm wa o oced o ba m is chos o

ba m omis

6


72/194

PBOOPHIC FALSeenst You a a o sa a you acua

bi a i was yu coc in a a a h

sy c caus you o a ou os?Vim ous i as coc!eens ou soun qu ou o acVi Ha! How coud anon in s in b

u o akin a pos?nis l ask you ou a

you pos ?

ici ? as I a a as bsh I cou o a s ?enis u o you b i s oa g o ba

s?ic cous o! u in s cas n h

is ou ha os a bang i I usa o coos lss o o wons

Deeinis I o usan oVim oo n I ona a os I so goo ih hosl i as s o a concBu sholy a y ba opaio I sa o iw alla acs a I soo isco so o o cciaos I ha ai o a ino cosao A haing ahm o cosiaio I h az ha is s

o goo oI o a o goo o m soall bo goo o yo as a whol I o os I ow alha king h os ou ha o hicatha bag isi h ac a I u gan ha i ilwas uhical o a a os nouay i lih choc is o alas w cal a h uhicat sois bw o nhical an h ss

hica Wh soon aks a cal ois h as conon wh is hoi choice h aks hiss h is cong h ncal ac o baing is; i h s his is h a o o asos bcing o ca Ths as si uaio. I ha ohoic bu o a y is

63


73/194

PHSOmCAFALSDeenst: Yo se a he ha hoie he bai

sgeo sa to thatVictim:

No o I mea I ha a choice a I hose o o hebest thig e the icmsacesDeterminst: No hom o o hi o ae ig

oo ho o atioaize a loue! Nx I sppos oul be tllig me hat the bai opeaio ha ohing to o iho socalle choice

Victim No Im ot saying tat I is qui possile ha he

bai opeaio se i moio vaious hoghs concening heesiaili pig m pomise Ha I o ha sethoghs I wo in ha p my pomse Bu h apaio i no rce me o bea my pmis I oe i acco I cse to a m pomise

Determnst: A I sa tha hat is a comple an ueaiaizatio O cose he bai peaio case yo to

bea o pomise I o ha o ha he bai paioou wou ha pt ou pomis since you i ha hepeaio o boe it I is as simple as ha I en X isolloe b eet Y a i Y woul not ha occe ha Xot occe ho ca o illgy y hat X was hecase o Y Wha he maing case is hee

Victim: I isage I is icoceiabl me ha I i ot

bea my pomise o m w ee will When I mae a pmisehee is o poe i th uniesehe ha m w ilwhih a case me o a i

Schzoc S

D h is a conesaio e o szopni s a lunaic aslum in momes o excpional lui y

irst Scirenic I mg ins ou o o I


74/194

PSOm eame shoi ie I hae bee a ahist I awas ow tha te s o o this wo; he a hatte s oos o a wish ss o . B m whoeg oe agais oess wo hece I hae maago escae m hs a wo i which the is o o io m ae o o aa hc he a o ts as o I am ha

Secnd Schzphenc Tha s sig; m cae s ita he oosi e A m ie I hae ow ha h mut be

a o his wo B I hae as o he hog oo o n igning a igmaish ha I woae i mse og ago o scae om his hios a ce o m ea o eea ishm So insa o hishsca esae I a a he schoogica escae o aiae aas wo whh o oes o eis A iso I am so hay

Thid Schzphenc ow iica m m oi o iwte aemt "ee s a o is a sh anasy a heame h is a o is s as mch o a anasthe o wa oe ca eih So ahogh o achnk o hae sca m he a o yo hae mca m oe aas wo o aoh. I o hae ehag each ohe's aasy wos

Now ase s e I bee o o ha eah o heams hee i s a o he ist a o is a aasy btaso ha s a aas o ass tha ihe is a Go oth s' t I sa his becase I iiy uh wi eab ya se eihe como o he sjcio is abeih oe a be hc he isjncio is no u . Bccog to he aw o he exce me which is a amous

aw o cassica ogi ay osiio h is u o i is t his as a cassca ogic dos o ay o he awo B on i so isc ing i a wo gong couto asica ogic ha I ha o cae io a anay wol ich a casca aws o ogc a A i s wo I ame ha


75/194

SOm St czpenc: n ou cas e os ionical o

al o o ave esca om al wol io aas wol, bu i eali o ave on v vseoo the aw o e ecle mi obviousl soun an hol o eal wolanboy i is ig min nwshat So we o oub e law o ecu milethen o wee living in a nas wol Bu now a e lawes a o o snt wol, ou sn wol is e eae am suis at o ae sill wi s

ow case s e, ve en ave ha aasos to wish o escae m eal wol o a anaso B coul see o way acay o o is T obmot ceasingl sumounabe, nil sunl aiz eollowg Alough venl aim e law o e le mi , js as vemnl ny law o conaio ainl bleve a soe oosiions ae boh ue

lse aicula, s wol i s bo al wo an anas wol. So o esca, ha m o ain w as

g Once was a son o was bo a san Sn-tis an an xcln oica wil ca isus oChis o sot Css viws w aps no woyooox So sai was no a rue san Snis ue mainain was . e sa was by viu o a a

he woaly assn o oow u asc psitions a is nal vl s na 3 sug isal; 4 aih can cu al. nou a on s ne any ocos

O a Cs a a s incon H w o a

66


76/194

-PBOOHCFALSto g a anibioi O e way e m a in a llowCisia Siis wo aliz s inions. oowilile alou su

Fen Hw om you a sing a o I oug yobsib o os o isa Se.

s Fien wy a u s a oo?s Yu bl i sa S o' yo

Fn O ous!is h you age at ma is unalFen O cous!s a as my boy is ual os boy is

al is oc a mal insums an ugs alal. wa ses am I sg a o

Fn a a momt o az siln) Goo Go wat

ot o isa sopisy is ts! You must b ig!s I am ot g a is is o sophisy I is plaiol logi !

Fen ats wa yo all loic I'm aai I otav m use o you ogic! oo ow a yo eslaiaiig at you a o si a oto

How coul I be? Doos ae ual!

Fe Bt tis is isaiy!Ch Moe so a ou bl a mat al?Fen oo I cao tae yo siosly! I suspt tat

yo ae i ou chu oly to saage cause o isiacie No te Cisa Sist wul al lie s !

Chs But e mst, i e is to b consis!Fen Yo ae ot bin cnssen you a I a oly

beig ypiial Yo all yousl a sia Siis yto o a oo beause o yo la o al i . A teyo aioalize yo as by ying at yo a seig aoo a yo all oos al

h: B y a! I a it may appea as i I am sing a

7


77/194

SOC. FASoco bt my seeing oco s te o he wo oeaace o he wol o ealiy hols he h

omena but o i the oumea wol end I ot ow mch about hiosohy nomea o heomea I am a simle hos hisiacienis a cannot be iee wo o wha yo ae say . Iaot belve hat yo ally believe hat yo a no sin aoco

Cs Bt o cose m ot ice I am commie o he

oosiio that mae s ea he I ms believe ha myeein a ocothouh ppe to be ems n eliybe alse

m aai I mst toaly agee wih Chis mae s ao a ocost s a simle as that

ow comes moe sube ont he e wak away mhis isus he Chis mt a secon hsia Scicee a he olown ialoe too lace

end ow come yo ae vsi n octo hoh yoeieve n hsia Scice

Cis I o

end he yo mst eiee that eoh ih a hea Cis I oiend he hy o yo se a ocoCs Becase I o't have eoh aihend Oh he o n' lly belee Chisia

ciceCs s

iend I am ! Exai Cs I bliee that comee aih s aeae o haig ha enouh ih ha I co get well I wol o ee oo o oco Bt I alisic eoh to now ha Iobably o ot have eoh h o his ece I wl see oco


78/194

PJSO Fend Oh o don have ome ih Chsa

ice

Ch o o oa misusan m o hae come aih hdnes o Cisia Scice Scicay ave com ih he ac a ha enogh aih that ld et we whot eial hep then I wou hs ac Iave complee ih a heo I ee usi ase a Chisia Sciis

Fend he h o o se a oco

Ch Becase I dont hae eouh ih ha wi g eho oe A I hae ih i is ha ha ouh ai atI o get e the I o mmb ow I o o haeih ha ey s o o o. A ha Chisiacice eches i ha hose wh enogh ah g w Yoow as as I o tha an Chisia Scis havese mica h a as a s hae di

Fend Deah is aCh Oh ome o ow o a mapysca yo aeigh b ot o hos now ha I ma whe I ait ied

end Y I ges o But he he ie o becasehe i hae eouh ah

Ch Eacy n ha s he hoe oi I o wa

e oe o hose ho i o ac o ih wa aisica aie m imiaio s bcase I aie ha I haogh h I o g w o o I o tha I d haogh ih t gt Do o ow whehe o o I do

Fend O ose o O yo a o hat eot o ae ha b oig a oco o ae oaig o ah o sa awa m a oo h o

ege o ihCh I beiee tha a o A ih I o e aoco the I ga a I have mo aih

tha I o ow

t I he ae nogh ih to ge Fen ow a o haCh mea o ae dob

9


79/194

JSOWCFSend: O cos Cri: Goo Go ! how ca yo on a say

away a oco?

you ure

wou g w wiou aoco i wo ak pc ss o you o comnta I o' s o . Bu you ow ae am ig in ha i tay away o a oc my oy is hy pbaica will g wl ony i ha nouh ai Bu yo n'now i I w ou a nce you o' kow a will g wl wiou mica hp. How n ca you pssby

ta e sponsibii y o aising o o s a ooiend a a og paus guss you ae ih wi aeo ac wa sai. I s now ha i o o l conntha yo wi ha oug aih, canno i goo aihaise yo o say aay om a oco. A ig usa wa I sai abou aing oubs a yo wo' aeeough ai. So ow I say, Yes bie i you o' se a

oo he you wil ae nou aih o g wl wiooe.Cr: ow ca yo kow isrend hae aih i iChr: on yo sa a o eeyone my osiiorend O cosChi: he yo wo ae sai hat aso o os Cis

ia Scieiss wo say away m ocos a wo i as s ac o suicie ai end: I gss soChi: But i se ass you wo ae be wgend: I ppose so Yt i tese cass oe cao b sue

a a eoug ohs l ie mb to aise m a we maiese ou ai i ei ith o i mi

a ioce thi i o e oit a hy wot aee e sgy blie tha ai iocs iCh: l ow sppose I too yo aice a say

m a oo, a bsee ie o wol oel

ed: a o it ae eog i

70


80/194

-mLSPmCFABLSCs rriad Ys, ys, w now ha! hav aad

gd ao h Th pn hh , is ha i say aa ro

doco and d as a rs o ack o ah, h wod yo oai yo had n wron in ving ha had nogh iho g who a docor

Fen Ys, gss wod hav o!Cs Th yo wod hav givn ad advic ! od

o h pary epnsble o dah? od yo i hasov? d yo prhaps , "od od,

n hadn adisd h o ac agais his dg igh si w h s ody Fen (a a ong pas Yo craiy o h

o don ow wha o say oica, gss yo ar ihY sohing dpr whin ds ac as do Th whooi s ha on shod n coprois wih ac o aihrand ha aih sois ars, sil h ong r is

bs ha hav h, ad aso ih ha o ih a, and so orh. ca s any pos ocions to hisho poin o vw, wih nogh aih hs v o-os os h oiv pow

his concds y soy d nog, I cn apprca ansypahi ih oh poins o vw ocay I wo sa

Chris is in h rh wr a Chrisian Scn s hch s noiky, no ipos wod v and ac as Chrs dTh ha noh h ca cr who dca hos ipy ha sh sa awy ro docors hohr hand, ndrnd rinds pn ha i is no good ocoprois wih ck h

L now y ads oard Chsan Scnc

h wors hng ao o cors, is is cais Pa-icary norna is h ac ha crn , who hav o sayn h ar d or ac o dca ano A cas was oncbh o cor, and h cor ce h pans o v hhd dca anon Had hs jg, I wod havoncrr hai yo ca a in noran, and as

71


81/194

SOC "Ds s av h o racc s wo? y asw s n cors a so as h o o h crc o s cc h as wa, say a wh a, b ay at a wa bcas ro saco o v ad c y a, y shar h co o oo o Crsacc o ss o casas . Howv, hs oy sd sry

o vaa Chrsa cc ry, s aso vs-

a ow ay sychosoac a , wc b alav cd by so o sao o ssp ! r, h Chsan Scss ay ocor lqny ha do ors, b need s ra? h o son wc ca aswrd a piiso prcal nvsaon s ncssay. Th cca qso w eal c o Crs a cc o ah a

onvy? And s, sasca daa ay b os lWa s vra l spa ad gnra s o halh Csa Scs copad w oChrsacs

hr s s l l or h cr! a so o h roposo b vd y Chrsa css Wa abo h rooso a a a? ray, I do' ow wh

a a o ( yo o ow w o o a al, as y' b oop!. Wa o W, srg I ow o b a, c I avc v sr al , I ' o s a' sc a ba da bv s'! c b ay, an way b sr sllg, a , s ssl ha bl h a nay o s ay h on

d dc sn. I say s pssie I do ssr a cssary r I hav or condnc has ay od wh a ang . ranky, I nd sychoo-cy oss bv ha s a , b I do o

e se f tt s mwh rn. s tinab wee wrinc mattr ctly r whth rly xrinc crti sensnn brin n attr s ccnt fr th snsatin

7


82/194

- PHC FS oss i ta i a c sigga say that i ca c sng, b &y

a s oss iy ha t ca. s o t " co y cos h atid sta cic ! E I s so o na , ayd at ay dos a is oy shd by o d oposio it I spciay sogy taoa codnao o i s o o hns c osg at s

ai y osiio o hisia cic tsc to si o sig, I bi sig s a t ista ciss a on h y say i is ot is ng ay b a ood o o ha, ad ay ao ai t o a s ng a sic heli onaity o sg ay w dc h sns o od so I o so s a i yo

st ciist, od i ot a ch happac is bl o in s o no o a a Chsiacis , cas I a o at paac a ha. hat s ay, a o typ ho ca soing js bcas s help to I ca dsaos wo a cons d dny hs spc . so, ga oc b a Csia cins ad o

s gy oat hstia cic, wold isa ciis t as aa os ts o wat I i t

t oias a tha s th as ast oacs nd sa cic ay oog y c ls b is h to say o a ogi I l dasicay o. I pdct at

dd yas h i sl b sa cic chcst bs l o l " is nd i it o t s docos. I hn y w say sotig ts "O os, dca att a pely pysicaces s o , sing a doco gs yo o aitha by a as s docto


83/194


84/194

VD1CUT PY W!


85/194


86/194

A k o Soaiy

hav n dy rnd srcs n a yra scan pays and hs pay snds s r andponaneous, a snr as n a an nspnans r sy scarsp anass and pa-n rqrd achv s spnans cs

sa n ar h p ny say a is, ads aang raan a spnanys c y s

This I y Difcu o

ar nna piao ac c d a snd Scr pan snaas vry c pay r spcy s cp r ar ray any ca"s n h Many pp v cpan a s ry dc pay Bach "scay

w do v ha s n r a r ar vrw pp n h wrd s dayscpard nn-n cnr r ndd vn ry yars ao aac r Schr scay r anyn s r a ar ! o say ha s c o pay scay s ssang hn n rd!

L v y an cn anay c ay adrs say s a vry ad anay s dc r a rd sig a ngna s nd rare r a rd o s ana Th ny rs h sng nnas ar

nas, and an rds r ar cparavy wngngas r a rn Thrr s unomon r abrd o sn a nna B s cp r osay ha s ul r a rd o sn a nna brd happns a ng a n s ass and sara ng n rd r sn a ngnga

77


87/194

TS ISVERY DIFFICUTTO PLYWL!- a na n a s r sk a na s p issb r s a

na! ny a r s aa y a a s ra y rsnk pp a ss r ay rcsw, might app a a r s a a aw as n n r p a a s ora r a cpy ar r a s"dny sc a r ar a a s-

n c nca ay s s a nvr n sa aan n s e a a B s s vry dr rm ry s a nna, r say w ut s s k aa

ay w crs say a y aay s rr ra y say sc Bac r Scr s nt k

nn a na t s a y d cvadscpnd an ciz ar rrs thght and paiand k crs aks r pay cassca sc a a na ds ts a ta t cssary an r n spiit rm s a n-na arad a s pssa scans da a ssay arsans ar n t arss, pay a

annr v drn r sn a na Bwn a r ars n scr payd as aty k snn a nna n s s ay c sany r cnprar arss av s!

t ack an pn r s nc n as a sca pr r s pran accrd w a vn cpsr sn T pan

tacr rs y at nr pay Scr ay a as n s ! 's n a s s ack "gs "ans r any k a 's s a rrsnay s a as nScran as can ayn a s as n s ay vryy s rn r ss Scrn scy sn ncks

7


88/194

IS IS VY DI O Y !n sh is hs way Ys, i hr who chaadcay sh os so o hr crazy inhons hr r

or Schran nar wr aod o roen

shh pay Schr ay B sh nvr w as a rs any or o sov "sca pos

L concd hs ssay wh wo joks Th s isao a a in a say sn o h r aazn,nohr an radng a wsh nwspapr psd don Hsad "Ho ca yo rad a sh nwspapr psd dow?

h ohr answr, "Do yo hnk s asy h ohr sory i s acay a r on ohnson and Boswr hr a a concr n whch so von vroso hadjs swad hoh a vry dc pc Bsw sad hac s hav n v dc hson answrd "D-c? I wsh had poss!

obs

nc whn was p r a scan h copnd o h way payd a prcar pass H od ho

I handd a cran odao and addd, o don'raz in wha a raka way yo hav ovd hsro!

I s say was hndrsrck! n h rs pac was novn aar ha hr was a odaon ha shos how chI kow ao sc ! I nvr hnk n rs o odaos I doo dny ha hy s s do' hnk ao h n h

scond pac I was oay naar o ay pbe aonling o ! h who ida o pr sovn spcay sc srks as so wd! No ony wrd osdsharons and dsrcv s ha how yo hk o asa srs o pbes o sod? No wondr yo don njovng or ha yo do!

79


89/194

S IS Ifc O Y ! oi a siia any h ais o havin

v os i aso anaogos oplii h avs o h oca o ovng ch a copy aal ial qao cors h cao i i accoac h h al qai b d ol h o cai noh h a i o a cnsco bng, i ha os h (hch od' srrs h on n' h ca o t h ao s ial

aioha a algi h or " , aal i aly o yo il ay a n ao os Thi i s so is das a o, o lv a ho s h i "lving iv ry o o ho o no l hs ay blv jcio h oo o "ro s d y

vcio ha h o o as sohn a ol, a' h h a o sars

Bee Sco h as yon as nny aacd o a v ds ad n o vr d aas hi hos ds adso aic ih oio o a "gnra ld ao , an as (and a ry rsnl ha choos ri oc a gna cao po

ah ha aong o y o inrss A cos o n a h a a n yars odr han ha a sach dndr o h sg schoo sh al od ar o "qrd cossook a vr dsdai y ad H said, "As or av a y l hah ida o bn a c gna No do no c ' n a rd gna ogh h cnet

0


90/194

VRY D T Y WL! gta ti a ic a a ct g d nd th ea bing ca ohat pt h i ohing g ibi a cd ga vidd th " a dc h sit shi ctaassi ah ha hig t b dic c h a abt ca "chashi a ha ah atit o i, i i ti acq a godg o th d as a a cs; h do hav tt ta t b "choa i th d It thc bt ha igh t th "ata cha h "tdi "scsci choa havaid i qi ght; t t agai

v h ast o cha hs activi i k h sig th dc ca o th w h has n bc a n ahi hch w

ai th bs ca; th ov ca aaii th , throgh his aca pc soav a antat dg th ggaph ighohda g ha a a cha h"d ba d a th b a n h wc bt tha h banst h banst kot th th b s th dc h o

atica id ad ight as t th pt sthat I a b "ing aot hin "nng itretl ish I cd as hi! Th dsnci is ic t ai aional, a t i o c viatac

o t ai i ha I a tin to sa os, that I v h appach o h ah tha th

appach th cosci scha nd I aga phasha I do t jc o schashp vdng i c as a bdct o h s ca cs , it a that t, chash is is a n cta o hch ca a, " ach hi Ind, it a v ha h v ddaic choa s i his w i a, sng h w d id cta

1


91/194

V D O Y WL! e fLe

I t i b i ia t I t all alcl al

t t t a s wa ain hat t ng H a a h dos la st, tha i gs a v ad a da a i o o, ta t sic, that hing o

aa ta acc ngh, tha g ldscili oc l t gg t go, boing, al dal, tha ta scili d ll cs o tht t, b at dos av ng hsalt, t plai ad an i, bt t l sls nass, -

tall bc i icia i , a t la pt ti t bi t d c t t

co y H va os H i ta th iao o o a, a o ol as, s noy hl

t t a la il l bi sn, o otings b laig d accin, a c a "vng, dos pla w a layig laing adl l sd, v ls t sllig, b l t ha i layig d ll ad o o oyig h

oo a, w togh at w "ssing a il . ha wo o co yach s wt a gh ha "lanng tacing sl, la t o oscoslg t la la wa al h ho a a d v la ca a

82


92/194

S IS RY I O Y !hing t cpai ; h is njoing hs to chowv, h v pogsss! t o as c , s sa

hat h aoaca pgsss sowha t not i a wansat wih his ans Lt s sa ha h has hapaci o bcoing st a, cas o hs appoach h dos bco st a Pop sa h o hs pangI s ai and ovng o hav so o an arst t onts i is as a as a can o sond as yo s ov and enj sc Can passags in soaon o

a as ati as h can pa B copos ons a who acs cohson n dph cc o andiscip i I s sad yo hav rsa an an cod sta on yo wod sros app yos and s oldiscpn Ths cocds dscrpon o th scondp

W da ad wich o h two tps do o pr O

haps I shod as whch o tw yps do o nd o Spaing o s I ind h s tp a gsoigha! I dot carh good na gs, o h is agso igha So a nd at a ond hos i hs w ngnss t nd so ch dssasc- o th sa hs at, I sl d sch a pson aso igha As scond tp I nd h ot

so igha, ah sa I s oios sad ayo shod t dvop hs capacs And so I nh scond tp sad Ms w choos ing o st h scod tp I sa o ag h pon h I ish t sa that ta i s s choc has o h Iis t cnoncs o h nvs

I wish t consd tw o ps ach which

ns cain as o h s and scond psh thd tp cons a h dsadanas o h std scod hs tp gs and copans awa ndsacticng v tdos and npasant is consan gt-ing hs lac o dnaon and ac o sdscpn s gs owh a w as o is rsang acvi

8


93/194

S IS V D O Y WL! is i gi is sc ag sas igs iI is bcas sadads a hgh a I a giv aig s I is ss a s a aasic is a ra ig a shd b a b hsih a ad rsac ha I ssss Ys Iaca i is aid Th as a adc b ciss ciica ard s h do hi aig T sp a i i ad rgcriiciig rs rah a g svs W

ha d i h p I gss v l l is dsasT h i h iss cis al h adaags

s ad scd ps s appac is c ha scd p; h s s is r ors ad hs ada aing awa as saos as a b rd sigs Has gr s "d "discip "acric, h

s as a ors o ba a rss i ss a a a gra crica ac, b ir acscis a ap a a arcaassag r ad o ad v agai ds h f a "racicig "laig H dos idd si ad sr h d a h s "sig a orig H isc l a dog w is o a sh coaig a i o

d ds ad ad ds H spis o h bad os ad as h god ods Th dggi ds o cpai o criicih ad oods is ar o bs joig hs hg h god ods Ad so ar al is o i aski h h d is in h doggi d sa "Di-ios d s a god ods B cras h hirs p d sa "Hrri Ms h d as ad I a

a hl a ndg gh god fod a a a A aris h r p is ik dgg has ansv dscrnag sno and nc srs ad ss god, and brs ih h ad ha scarcrs ih s jcs i aaca S hrois p is s c "cnscios crica as "c

84


94/194

- RY O Y ciosy sc and dscn T o o syp on oos or pp cop op n h

pcn y s s s ! H s so chpnc! H sps hos an os on ds! H hs soch sdscpn! H ds no pon soass. H is oos h scc nd s why pos! H dos no js e wh hs ns h, hte hs nrs h o , ss hs rs r haon hs s o s h. H scoos hs, h

dscps hs h ocos oscs nd 's hy hccd H sns o hs nd corcs hs s, 'wh pop sy h, h o won! n ra y,hs n o as hs han d scngh good ods as hs on pornc as a ooco. cos d cos n s aood sco wh an r pnc d s

o anng hs o a psson d sco. Thdo s o conscos o s a oy o oods hs scn And ks o s s no o pohs, ah s aoacy sc hos ways oayng whc poc s rss cos, o yp ay cos a sra scn jsk o s p, h a dnc o appoa ! s

p hs h n con a a ood scor,whas h o p spy os ood ood

T K s s G s jy

n o y ao sayns Concs s dcaon H sad, To kn s no as od as o o. To o s no asgood as o njoy.

pann on cns, w d h ypc hh-cn Cs c po n sohn hs

8


95/194

TISISVERDIFFCTTOPYWLL!-My fiendcomes to visit me from aco the h l.We ill u cu and enjy e cassi tee

h dh n is h h po od say "njoy ahthan "sdy o "an Evdny h casscs sohngto ovd and noyd a an "sd o "and

h hav h t Taos concp o ann! o-tnay hs ia is o connd o h annt Chnspanng vn o cnis, and sva hosnd swad, nd h ah o Rot Bwnn dspyin a

ia a d owad h dcaon o hs son . Th oownassa is o Wia yon Phs's oo et nin

n hs days, hn h is sch a ong acon vy-h aains h ci sys in dcaion, i is in-sn o r ha Brownin's dcaion spyh ci sys pshd o is as possy

haps sa o a ha no arnd an in odrn sv had so i o schoo and co Hs caonpndd asoy and csiy on his ncnons has ncorad to sdy anyhn h wshd Hs ahrnd h prc ry nr sn h o any nsi ton o arnin and a ow h o do acy as h chos,spy pon copn insrcio in wha s-

ct h yoh prssd any ins Ts h rnr, n, h odrn ns, sc hony andcnpnt, as w as pano and oran, chsy aria aoraoy as d p n h hs hsory nda Nw y on nows h so as dn csno now is concnd, o schoos and cosas in cav ch o dsrd o oys and

is sdy c sscs or yars who n o rda p a sh and h odn ans show a sry has . on wans pos and pcca sson s poy a pa o or wo aon n sc

ndianaplis The s Meill Cpany lishes [ st cess a pzzled y the case wk alne i sect What nath dd helps ean]


96/194

Y DC O PY h gra advaags o o schoos an cogsc so a as hy spir nca criosiyar o

rariy o a schoary ar; hi srngh is ohdircios. h s o Bowing's dcaio was ha ath ag o wy h w or ha os cog gradas v ow; ad his owdg was a his co-and . His avori rading on h rain , or , was ar ay; o o h asos wy his ory ss sdic s sipy cas h nvr raid how igora

os o s ray ar. I sppos h did o iv ha cod ass yrs schoo ad nivrsiy raing aow so

his ssg inrsd norosy; i is a asoyrc prssio o y own phiosopy o dcaio Maycric his as ig oo "is Thy say, "This ay a

igh o Ror Brownig's ahr, who had ny o ony, oo Ror Browing, who was doss an ns chid. Bthis hod o dcio wod hardy appic o hogh and sss. Unory v iam yoPhps ind o spos h aov passag y conining: hrh is, h os oys ro p s wing was wod ry n d o aciv ds and ss o an

dd or h aniis o soci inrcos . ih ninyino o a dd sch a do so ar as i a or i hhppiss or cin wod a ai. ownng wash hddh an H was prondy arnd wiho dary ad wiho conci; and h was piaiy a sociabing.

a sad ps ivd Boning's nd o

dcaion is iappica o h asss. is ad siks as iis! hy cano sosvn, or prhaps aiary ny sosav hs o spcr o Rr rwning's h? I a nkng now onry ss se s e PD o e eivae pfb e sg ss s I asgsing h rdic posa a inca ca o

8


97/194

S D O Wh o sho ot b as a vss adada schoos, b sho b at hgh schoos ad -

a schoos h h a v o so dd Thsod a, cos, ha h achng hos wod a tha a vrss, a h saars o ow Thsgh sond v pnsv B h b a cod aao snd s on tha o thtre dcao o s ongo a thn ha a osandng or schoa a bwased at a na schoo B hs s ng! Chd

cogn an apca a a b ha anads rao avo sndrsandn, h as hng n h word hat

I od wn s ha ssors red o ch a nar hgh schoos ! ach prosso shod ach whr h wans . Iod k o s on ha nar and hgh schoo pos-ons ad as aracv as hos at nvrss da I

od nvsg nr schoos , hgh schoos , cogs, anada schoos a on h vr sa caps, wh a cooachng sa, wh t gh b q coon o a prossoo b sanos achng n cors a a cog ora v and anoh a a hgh schoo o narchoo v I hn wod b rvos o ongsrs hav rqt onac wh cog an gd sns.

dss to sa, I hav al bn agans ana-ons and qd coss. Concnng anons, a notrr ojcng o an po wo wshs o an aanda or hs copnc o h jo , o o an ns o hgh lann ha shs o an nmin sdnso h qcaos o prs hr sds. I a ojcng and q srong a as h ncss

o h ach o a cors o hav o por o ohrs hgrss o h sdn To ror a sdns a ss o k a ra s as l kng hppocrac oh And crn dsros an dcn a-tonshp wn chr and sdn ps ach h o o an advrsar rahr han a rnd.

88


98/194

- I VY IICULT TO Y t qi coss , th sa argn in ir or s

s, hat dnt a o ar o know w is

o th and ha h shod posd hshich a a b ond b o ns o s . I ha knvcas o qr corss w ha sad ngs , ' I glad hat I was orc t an so and s I hadn' n I nv hav co o i s. Now so happs h psona princs n ha d o h ppsi point viw I can hons s a ha n

oa ro anhng I hav r rrd a; a I ot a hs was pan, rsraon haac, brnss

h iws Einsn oward hs own oa dcai s t a or wd knon an appr n h crciv prcss o ng orcd o cra s s n ns nd whh n d or no o

a sch a rrng c, ha a passng s naio, h od n a o consd a sncb o v a ya! H copars h s procss o rg ac hah bast s voracsnss orc nins, v whn no hngr ns hd aa sak bv ha h njon o sng andkn a b pod b ans corcion ad a ss o

. In, h rgardd as sor o a rac a aona hos ora dcaon had no angd h ho os nr.

O s o ads w sa "s, ha ad s aigh Eins , w a' a ns s a or hi ociv dcaiona poc was n good r sdinar pp, wo hs orcon w wo r o

hch I wis o rp: Ha nr occrr st o Ensn a s on corgcors s granss

sscr h oowng vs o rsn on g


99/194

S SVRY DFFCUT TOPLYWL!-ao as dsrv o b or w th har ar

If th cogs wr r, t ra hd t o wodd t gt th oc at gs t k or h sh .S co ho w hwrt thara ov o ar b avg h nara ho oftachg what ch wss to rn, a ss g ta sha ar what o hav n as or cc oog whch sod b a pac o dg a, s

a odos ad ha ad th og atd t frvoos ass a th jadsprts wo hav ss cv Schoarsh sto b crad ot b cops o , b b awag a rtrst nowg. T ws srco accossths b opg t hs s prcs aracos hstd has for hsh arg s a sst fo

schos not for th cog or bos no or ad t sa rcos wor to p o a prssor

ee James Ellt Cat A Mmi f Rph Wd Ems ston and NeYo Htn Miin Cmpany e ieside ess Camde Vo 611 631

0


100/194

VIS ZENPAOXC'


101/194


102/194

S d

o h h c hs ayh h oow c

a h o snsha

os igh py ha ogs hav o s n agy (o o b o cs h v do has o h sa o B hs so s q sp cop wh h oon say o h sa ad h

o W s s o say Uoy a y c h sa do

Z Fan

0 soday s a yo bo ondo oo

h h s ohn b don d ohn o ba s s a o yo o oh B asy o I a h a o a s

Wa I Zn'

o o ow ha Z s, o a On

ao n now wha n s dd, onnha Z was, od cas o b ryn o dn yn n a O cno ow wha a ay ss o has had s on as s "a s n yo yo no y on


103/194

IZPACfs s , sowha, h py giv by h Z

oso ais S o h qsio Ho wod yo

aaci ric o Sao (Zih? Hi s c i vyay ric, oy ao rats o a c o h gd

ios ar sos srag higs ! c i a-acs th ac sccs , hy ar ap o iss h oi. ahacs (or rahr h hi osop o ah-acs, a Rss gav h os diiio Mah

ac h sbct whch o o o wha w aa bot o wh wha w ar sayig s . Thoca Say Tba, a cbrad ivi addrss a hs iiio e sc? wod hav oh r hs W, Z ig b o sch sct. Z ay w b te sc which o dos oo a s ta aot, or whh wha o s

ay s t ada hi osophy sd , who oo a cors wih oic o o a cors h oc ad i Z. H dscrid cds as oows h irs day, h achr ca

smullyan, this book needs no title

Documents