social market economy – third way or compassionate capitalism? marcus marktanner, american...
TRANSCRIPT
SOCIAL MARKET ECONOMY – THIRD WAY OR COMPASSIONATE CAPITALISM?
MARCUS MARKTANNER, AMERICAN UNIVERSITY OF BEIRUT, LEBANON
PREPARED FOR:BIRZEIT UNIVERSITY, INSTITUTE OF LAWRAMALLAH, PALESTINE, DECEMBER 4, 2008
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Table of Content1. Liberalism: One Way 2. Socialism: Another Way3. Social Market Economy (SME): Which
Way?4. SME: A Superior Way?5. SME: How to Pave the Way?6. Embarking on the SME: A Rocky Way7. Conclusions
Liberalism: One Way Was not the first political economy Mercantislism Physiocracy Liberalism Classical Economics: Smith, Ricardo, Marx Neoclassical Economics: A Natural Law? A theory of allocation without distribution Liberalism: A games without rules The First Globalization Wave (1870-1929) 1929: Great Depression and the End of
Liberalism From Liberalism to Keynes
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Socialism: The Other Way Physiocracy recycled Why was Marx a Classical Economist? Efficient Allocation vs. Just Redistribution Justice of what? Efficiency, consumption,
opportunity? A theory of distribution without allocation Socialism: No market game The Marxian Legacy in Developing Countries 1989: Fall of the Berlin Wall and the End of
Socialism From the End of Socialism back to Liberalism
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Social Market Economy: Which Way? What’s the difference? Combining market efficiency with equal
opportunity The market is in the heart, yes But, the market needs to be in order SME: The market as a game with rules Ordoliberalism: The state defines the rules of the
game How? Theory matters, but history, too! Order policy requires principles of economic policy
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Social Market Economy: A Superior Way?
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Social Market Economy: How to Pave the Way? (1) Build fiscal capacity to become more equal and productive
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
60.0
0.0 7.5 15.0 22.5 30.0
Y = Logistic(4)
FisCap
EH
IIe
st
0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
0.0 7.5 15.0 22.5 30.0
Y = Logistic(4)
FisCap
Ma
nu
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Social Market Economy: How to Pave the Way? (2) Because investment in social opportunities creates
economic ones
0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0
Y = Logistic(4)
EHIIest
Ma
nu
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Social Market Economy: How to Pave the Way? (3) And vice versa
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
60.0
0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0
Y = Logistic(4)
Manu
EH
IIe
st
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Social Market Economy: How to Pave the Way? (4) And Social and Economic Opportunities Create Higher
Incomes
4.0
5.8
7.5
9.3
11.0
20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0
Y = Logistic(4)
EHIIest
lnyc
on
st
4.0
5.8
7.5
9.3
11.0
0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0
Y = Logistic(4)
Manu
lnyc
on
st
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Social Market Economy: How to Pave the Way? (4) The East Asian Tigers Example
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Embarking on the SME: A Rocky Way Different countries require different policy
priorities Social Market Economy starts with the state Fiscal capacity building is not a goal in itself The less market efficiency is aligned with equal
opportunity, the more the state must invest (not consume)
The introduction of the Social Market Economy, however, is not easy.
Take the case of the Arab world
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Embarking on the SME: A Rocky Way (2) Challenges to SME introduction in the Arab
world: Legacy of import-substitution Political constraints Geopolitical constraints Geoeconomic constraints
Social Market Economy – Third Way or Compassionate Capitalism?
Conclusions The SME needs more awareness Awareness in developed and developed countries SME works better, the more are committed to it Developed countries must help paving the way
towards the third way of the SME to prevent development to end in a dead end as socialism and liberalism did.
Developed countries best show their compassion for capitalism by opening their markets and committing themselves to ordoliberal capacity building.