social media listening tool a comparative study (1)
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
1/22
SOCIAL MEDIA
INTELLIGENCE
Listening and WebAnalytics Tool A
Comparative Study
Kumar MallampalliHead Emerging Solutions and ITServices
Shamer MPractice Leader Digital Marketing andUXM Solutions
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
2/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page1of 22
Table of Contents
1 Background.................................................................................................................................................. 22 Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 33 Market Trends.............................................................................................................................................. 44 Considerations for Choosing a Social Media Listening Platform ................................................................ 55 Paid versus Open-Source ........................................................................................................................... 76 Evaluation of Social Media Listening and Analytic Tools ............................................................................ 8
6.1 Social Media Listening and Analytic Tools ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 86.1.1RADIAN6..................................................................................................................................................... 86.1.2ALTERIAN SM2.......................................................................................................................................... 96.1.3CONverseon............................................................................................................................................. 10
6.2 Product Feature Comparison -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 117 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................. 178 Annexure 1: Open Source Listening Tools and Their applications ........................................................... 189 Reference .................................................................................................................................................. 21
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
3/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page2of 22
1 Background
Global organisations are looking to scale up their online presence and e-commerce activities. Organizationsare looking to engage with their customers in the online space more actively. They want to listen to what
customers have to say online, going beyond brand interest. There are various tools available in the market
that can help organisations engage with their customers online in a more active manner. The aim of this white
paper is to evaluate leading web analytical and listening tools and suggest the most feasible and holistic
solution to address these needs.
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
4/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page3of 22
2 Introduction
Companies of every kind are beginning to focus more on consumers and have started engaging with them onFacebook, YouTube, Twitter and other social media platforms. But the successful businesses, the ones that
want to really make their social media efforts count, are going beyond just gaining simple visibility.
Opinions and recommendations, discussions and debates, rumours and rants... consumers have taken the
conversations about brands online. Consumer Generated Media (CGM) - content created by consumers on
blogs, online discussion boards and forums and other social media platforms is one of the fastest growing
online segments today. Effectively measuring, interpreting and acting on CGM offers key competitive
advantages for todays consumer-centred brands.
This vast, unstructured, unprompted online conversation is a powerfully rich source of meaningful insights,
intelligence and information that can provide sustainable competitive advantage for organisations.
Social media presents businesses with vast amounts of customer information, as well as a lot of irrelevant
discussion. But, by harnessing the right social technologies, mining for insights and taking informed marketing
decisions, brands have the opportunity to make the most of social media.
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
5/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page4of 22
3 Market Trends
Forrester discussed the Listening Tools Market in its Listening Landscape 2010. Forrester detailed that,businesses had to move to the next big process in Social Media Listening in order to sustain the customer
confidence and stay in the ever-growing critique of social media channel. Businesses cannot remain stuck to
traditional means of collecting data from social media, which has become a quite daunting task with ever
increasing data and ever-increasing consumer engagement with social media. Businesses should try to
evolve or move into next generation listening platform which have much more sophisticated offerings.
Hence, social media listening tools have evolved from just collecting data to Social Intelligence.
Collection of dataAnalysisSocial CRMSocial Intelligence
From 2010 to 2011, social media in the enterprise has reached a tipping point. For many brands, social engagement is no
longer seen as a set of small experiments on the fringe of the organization. Instead, social media has become a core
component of the business strategy. As such, we are witnessing a rapid evolution from ad-hoc and sponsored exploration,
to a desire for enterprise enablement, where social media and social intelligence become competitive advantages that
enable critical business performance.
For organizations that are looking to participate in this evolution, four important areas must be addressed:
Determining how and where listening can significantly impact business outcomes and objectives
Understanding how to manage vast amounts of data, find meaningful insights and support business processes
and use-cases - for today and tomorrow
Determining what should be automated and the role that people need to play; and determining the balance of
internal versus external resources and capabilities
Creating frameworks to infuse social intelligence into the far reaches of the organization and ensuring timely
action with a systematic, best-practice approach that includes performance measurement based on impact to the
business
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
6/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page5of 22
4 Considerations for Choosing a Social Media Listening
PlatformThe listening platform market is still in its infancy. Platforms come in all shapes and sizes, rolling out new
features and tools that enable customers to turn social media data into actionable insight. There is a growing
number of listening platforms devoted to social media everything from highly customized services that are
managed for businesses, to free tools businesses can manage themselves. Between the myriad of platforms
and the accompanying hype, it becomes difficult to figure out the best solution to meet ones needs.
So here are some things you need to consider when choosing a listening platform:
What are the goals of the listening platform?
Since listening platforms have many uses, one must match ones objectives to a platforms strengths. For
example, if ones focus is on monitoring mentions or closely monitoring leads, one should seek out platforms
that are known for this type of analysis. On the other hand, if one seeks alternatives to traditional market
research, then one needs a platform that is well-known for its sentiment-capture and community analysis
capabilities.
Which media sources are relevant to your goals?
All listening platforms collect data from numerous online sources - news sites, blogs, and other websites.
While some specialize in social media sources like Twitter, review sites, and even communities; others have
the ability to cover offline media such as print, television, and radio. If you are focused on market research, ormessaging effectiveness, then you should probably work with a platform that tracks social media and user-
generated sources. But for true 360-degree brand tracking, you may require a platform that also integrates
offline sources such as the traditional press.
What technology will you need to support your goals?
If you are focused on crisis-management, you need a solution built on continuous data capture, but if you are
seeking more episodic or campaign analysis, you can settle for a platform that collects data at scheduled
intervals. If you are handling multi-national brands, you may also want to evaluate each technology based on
its ability to support multiple languages.
How much time and money can you commit to the listening platform?
The amount of time one needs to commit to listening depends largely on the output - dashboards, reports, and
digests from the listening platforms. For example, dashboards require a good deal of time to setup,
depending on the platform chosen, but provide customized data on command; reports save time. However,
they still necessitate that one (or ones department) spend time interpreting the reports and defining a follow-
up strategy.
How prepared is one to use a listening platform?
Choosing a listening platform is only the first step - listening without converting the unstructured information to
meaningful data and determining the action to be taken, is a waste of time, effort, and money. You need to
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
7/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page6of 22
give this last point some extra consideration and be sure to build a process that responds to all the
opportunities your listening platform identifies.
Key Features and Factors Impacting Selection Process of the Tool
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
8/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page7of 22
5 Paid versus Open-Source
Now that you have identified what kind of listening and analytic tool your organization needs, you can choosebetween Paid and Open Source Platforms. However, here are some points to consider:
PAID TOOLS OPEN SOURCE TOOLS
One point for entire Social Media
MonitoringDifferent tools for different purposes
Only one accounts login credentials to
remember
Many credentials for various accounts on different siteshave to be remembered and maintained
Many team members can be provided
accessOnly one person at a time for one access
Helps centralizing social media activity on alarge scale
Only meant for small scale social media managementand also not centralized
Reports and analytics centralized; savestime and cost
No centralized reports, needs to be compiled andcollated separately; may also require humaninterception; slows process and may increase cost
Can be extended to CRM as SCRM
No extension to automated CRMThird party integrations like Salesforcepossible Very few options for third-party integrations
Backing studies by Gartner and Forresteravailable
No backing studies from Gartner or Forrester; onlygeneric blogger support
Report accuracy almost guaranteedReport accuracy not guaranteed
Multi-language options also availableMulti-language options very limited or not there at all
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
9/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page8of 22
6 Evaluation of Social Media Listening and Analytic
ToolsWe have evaluated three leading listening tools against 39 different criteria. The tools and platforms are
examined, studied and assessed based on our experience of these tools, product websites, online secondary
research, analyst reports, and case studies.
To assess the state of the listening platform market and see how the platforms stack up against each other,
we have evaluated the strengths and weaknesses of the following tools: Radian6, Alterian SM2, and
Converseon.
6.1 Social Media Listening and Analytic Tools
6.1.1 RADIAN6
Radian6 delivers one of the most popular listening platforms in the market. Radian6 has become highly visible
for its listening and monitoring capabilities. It also leads the market with its dashboard functionality - providing
more features and toolsets for a broad range of use-cases across many business lines. Radian6 has raised
the bar on features that listening platforms should provide with its recent addition of its Engagement Console -
a social media outreach tool. It is also continuing developments for data integration options into CRM and
existing analytics systems.
Advantages
Radian6 dashboard has a very intuitive layout and easy to use interface
Exhaustive Media Coverage - more than 150 million public sites and sources covered
Covers 13 international languages
Good Filtering Options - Looks at specific metrics like sentiment, engagement, reach, Twitter
followers, vote count or comment count. Allows user to filter the results by media type, geographic
region, or any of 13 international languages
Workflow and Engagement Management
Disadvantages
Radian6 has been acquired by Salesforce.com - This can limit ease of integration with other CRM,
also can influence the future strategy and direction of the product
Radian6 has limited pre-built integration with traditional CRM packages
Radian6 doesnt host a community but can partner - This can lead to functional narrowness
Customers across the board complain of data quality issues and inexperienced service team
It is not known to be very good in text analysis
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
10/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page9of 22
Customer Base
Radian6 currently has over 2,200 clients, including nearly half of the Fortune 100
Website:http://www.radian6.com
6.1.2 ALTERIAN SM2
Alterian acquired Techrigy and its SM2 social media monitoring solution. SM2 has been developed as a
robust standalone web-monitoring tool which is integrated with their Alterian Integrated Marketing Platform
making it now one of the most popular listening platforms dashboards in the market. SM2s real strength is its
potential, within the Alterian umbrella, by integrating the social media data it collects and analyzes, directly
into Alterians existing marketing technology platform. SM2 supports up to 60 languages in content collection
and 20 for sentiment analysis.
Advantages
Alterian SM2 provides one of the most expansive selections of multi-language coverage among social
media monitoring solutions. - Sentiment Analysis in 20 languages and Language Filtering and
Detection in 60 languages
The product is built from a marketing perspective and powered by Alterians marketing platform
Alterian SM2 provides one with a comprehensive set of user tools, reports and metrics that allows one
to track and analyze conversations across the web. SM2 reports include: Daily Volume, Share of
Voice, Compare Dates, Themes, Demographics, Author Tags, Map Overlay, View Reports, Sentiment
Reports, etc.
Alterian SM2 has an extensive Social Media Warehouse with historical data containing over 10 billion
social media mentions, blogs, tweets, posts, images and conversations
Disadvantages
Currently, integration of SM2 with CRM is still in the evolving stage and not full-fledged
A bit complicated to operate but one of the most flexible monitoring tools
Functional Narrowness: It lacks hosted community platform that possesses richer experience for
customer
http://www.radian6.com/http://www.radian6.com/http://www.radian6.com/ -
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
11/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page10of 22
engagement and analysis
Acquisition / Consolidation of the platform is possible in the near future as the market is growing byleaps and bounds
Customers
Website:http://socialmedia.alterian.com
6.1.3 CONVERSEON
Converseon's suite of social listening tools was cited as a leader in listening platforms in the emerging Social
Media Intelligence industry by Forrester. Converseon offers a leading product that does not come with
standard installation but a tailored dashboard built for enterprise installations. It offers professional services
around every step of the Social Intelligence process. Converseons model of starting with technology and
adding human analysis makes for highly effective data quality, leading custom reports, and strong
functionality.
Advantages
Converseons model of starting with technology and adding human analysis makes for highly effective
data quality, leading custom reports, and strong functionality.
Workflow provides option for getting approvals to posts/replies; giving more options to monitor ones
entire social media effort and centralize it.
Conversation Miner allows one to share social media accounts so that multiple people can use the
account without violating any social media venues terms of service. For example, Facebook does not
permit passwords for accounts to be shared with any other users. Conversation Miner allows
Facebook and Twitter accounts to be authorized by one user, for other users to post from, withoutsharing passwords.
Disadvantages
Converseon resides on the other end of the spectrum with heavy service offerings on top of moderate
technology.
There is no standard Converseon installation, the vendor builds a tailored dashboard for its enterprise
installations which essentially means that one has to be sure of what one is looking at in an SCRM
product and get a customized product accordingly.
http://socialmedia.alterian.com/http://socialmedia.alterian.com/http://socialmedia.alterian.com/ -
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
12/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page11of 22
Its customized approach also hurts its long-term strategy, as it increases the overall costs and slows
down the pace at which customers can act on social media data and focuses more on an outsourced
model of Social Intelligence.
Customers
Website:http://converseon.com
6.2 Product Feature Comparison
FEATURES RADIAN 6 ALTERIAN SM2 CONVERSEON
(CONVERSATION MINER)
Exhaustive MediaCoverage (across entireweb)
Scours more than 150million public sites andsources including blogsand comments, forums,
mainstream online newspublications, publicphotos and videos.
Covers Blogs(LiveJournal, TypePad),Message Boards andForums, Microblogs,
(Twitter, Plurk,Identi.ca), Wikis (sitesthat allow the public tomakechanges & updates),Video and Photosharing(YouTube, Flickr), SocialNetwork (XingFacebook,LinkedIn), ClassifiedSites (Craigslist),Review Sites (ePinions).
Conversation Miner has fullcoverage of blogs, messageboards, video and otherforms of social media,
including 100% of tweets asone of the original licenseesof the Twitter Firehose..
Language Coverage
Covers 13 international
languages English,French, Italian, German,Spanish, Russian,Finnish, Korean,Japanese, SimplifiedChinese, Portuguese,Dutch, and Swedish.
It provides language
coverage up to 60unique languages.
Work is also in progresswith linguist experts toincrease its automatedsentiment analysiscoverage to 20languages.
English
AlertsSet up email or IM alertseither as-it-happens or inregular intervals so oneand ones clients can stay
on top of the activity.
No Info.Users receive e-mail alertswhenever a conversation isrouted to them and can alsolog into Conversation Miner
to see the status of allengagements involving them.
http://converseon.com/http://converseon.com/http://converseon.com/ -
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
13/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page12of 22
Data Export Yes Yes Yes`
API Integration withThird Party Applications
Radian6 provides platformAPIs and Social MetricsFramework for integratingthird-party CRM
Alterians APIs forintegration are stillevolving
No
Data Archiving It can archive up to 18months
It can archive up to 24months
No
Filtering by Media Type One can also drill downinto several layers ofdetailed information onones profile results:segment them by mediatype, geographic region,language, engagementstatistics or count links,
social media metrics,percent change over timeand sources to connectthe dots around onessocial media activity.
One can filter databased on media typeslike blogs, wikis, microblogs, video-sharing,etc.
One can filter data based ontype: blogs, Twitter,Facebook, YouTube, andmore.
Filtering by Geography One can understand themagnitude of aconversation across
various regions.
One can also isolatephysical locations ofvarious conversations.
Yes
Filtering by Keywordsor Topic
One can compare tagkeywords between onesbrand and competitors.One can alsounderstand the commonthemes and magnitudeof a conversation andidentify niche keywords
for SEO.
Customer Service teams canmonitor negative sentimentaround critical keywords andreach out to disgruntledclients to turn their opinionsaround.
Filtering based onTimelines
Define time periodsincluding archivedhistory and filter data.
Yes
Filtering byDemographics
Segment data bypopularity, gender andage of author.
Yes
Automated SentimentAnalysis
Get a first glancewhether chatter aboutones topic is positive,negative, or neutral withautomated sentimentanalysis.
Sentiment Analysis in 20languages. Alterian SM2utilizes a proprietary setof technologies includingword parsing, weighting,proximity and Natural
Language Processing toenable the mostaccurate andcustomizable sentimentanalysis.
Conversation Miner employstext analytics, machinelearning, and even humananalysts to provide sentimentanalysis
Sentiment AnalysisInvolving HumanExpertise
It uses dashboardwidgets to analyze macrotrends and understandsentiment changes overtime.
One can manually adjustsentiment results to fine
tune them to onescriteria.
One can customizesentiment specific toindustry or brand.
It does not use a completelyalgorithmic approach thatcan give wrong answers.
Instead, gives a solution thatlets computers do what theydo best and counts onpeople for the rest.
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
14/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page13of 22
Influencer Profiling andAnalysis
One can look specificallyat influencer data tounderstand whos gotclout in respective
industry and what theyresaying.
One can also viewinfluencer data specific tokey media typesTwitter, Blogs, Video,Photos, MainstreamNews, and Forums.
One can find who hasgot how much influencein the social media andplan how one can
convey ones messageto ones target audiencein a positive way throughthem.
Yes
Viral Content Trackingand Analysis
One can gain access tovaluable meaning behindones social traffic, suchas in-depth sentiment,demographics, likes anddislikes and more;quickly and easily.
One can also understandthe context and contentof posts that are drivingthe website actions andresults you want.
Reviewing of contenttype share acrossmultiple channels ispossible with thisproduct.
One can also comparethe share of discussionsacross several brands tounderstand what'sdriving the conversation.
Yes
Trend Analysis Yes It helps track how topicstrend over time incomparison.
Conversation Miner can helpone track changes insentiment, conversation
volume, brand fans, visits toones website, and even webconversions.
Topic and ThemeAnalysis
Use post and sourcetags to create a Socialweb caller ID systemand segment results forin-depth reporting andanalysis.
It helps one discoverissues being discussedabout ones brand,competitors or industryand also understand aspecific audience'sunique interest. One canalso ensure keywordsare accurately utilizedwithin search setup.
Yes
Word/Tag Cloud The Context anddiscussion around onesbrand mentions caninform ones SEO effortsby reflecting thelanguage yourcommunity uses.
It lets one compare tagkeywords between onesbrand and competitors.
Understand the commonthemes and magnitudeof a conversation.Identify niche keywordsfor SEO.
No information available.
Competitive Analysis Yes One can analyze brandconversations againstcompetitors and viewside-by-side
comparisons, rankagainst competitive
Social media accounts canbe used to respond to theconversation and their impactcan be measured and
compared to competitoraccounts.
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
15/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page14of 22
offerings and benchmarkagainst industrystandards.
Campaign Managementand Measurement
No information available Yes, but through theirproduct Social MediaPublisher.
No information available.
Campaign ROICalculation
No information available. Yes, but through theirproduct Social MediaPublisher.
Yes
Customizable Dashboard Dashboards can beconfigured by choosingwidgets from more than40 pre-configuredwidgets in the gallery.
One can also copy onesdashboard to onesteammates orsupervisors and showthem what one is hearingand seeing, and howones activities areimpacting results.
Multiple dashboards canalso be built and savedto segment and easilyview data. Dashboards,Widgets or Engagement
Reports can also bedownloaded or emailedto suit needs.
Maybe Partially Yes
Workflow Management One can use workflowmanagement in the Riverof News, or in theirEngagement Console toscale listening acrossones organization.
One can also use it toassign posts to teammembers, add internal
notes, flag priority,categorize and classifyposts and set up an online caller ID systemwith post and sourcetags, schedule alerts,and report onengagement activity rightfrom the dashboard.
Yes, but through theirproduct Social MediaPublisher. It has aninteractive workflowprocess for easyassignment,prioritization, responseand reviews.
One can engage
through individualizedaccounts forpersonalization.
Audit of trails ofinteractions, responsesand notes of specificposts are also possible.
Conversation Miner providesadvanced workflow featuresto help turn social listeninginto engagement and action.
Conversation Minerworkflows can be very simpleor quite intricate, dependingon your requirements,supporting up to eight
separate steps for anapproval process.
Advanced Roles andPermissions for multipleUsers
Yes Yes, but only theirproduct Social MediaPublisher.
Yes. For e.g.: Administratorscan see the engagements forall users within their clientgroup.
Client RelationshipManagement (CRM)
One can also align socialmedia with ones sales,
Yes, kind of, throughtheir product Social
No information available
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
16/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page15of 22
account and websiteefforts with just a fewclicks.
One can not only learnwhich sites sent peopleto ones business, butalso what they werereading and discussingbefore they clicked, andwhether or not it madethem take action whenthey got there.
Media Publisher.
Conversation Tracking Yes It helps one to drill intothe coverage of specificposts or comments.
Yes. Conversation Minerhelps one to trackconversation real-time, rightfrom where it started so thatone and ones team arearmed with the rightinformation to tackle everysituation.
Fan/Follower tracking Yes Not directly, but, throughtheir Social MediaPublisher, they can helptrack a conversation witha customer.
Yes
Advanced Publishingand EngagementOptions
One can also assign androute posts across theenterprise and track
engagement andresponse via theRadian6 Engagementconsole.
Yes, but through theirproduct Social MediaPublisher.
It helps monitor andactively engage in socialmedia conversationsdirectly from theplatform.
The best social mediasuccess stories involvecompany personnel reaching
out to their fans to amplifytheir impact and to theirdetractors to turn themaround.
Conversation Miner helpsone become such a successstory.
Once a response has beenapproved, users can postthese responses to Twitter,Facebook and LinkedIn
without ever leaving theConversation Miner tool,using its integratedpublishing capability.
Usable on any Browsers,Mobile, PC
Yes. For mobiles, it iscurrently usable only on
Apple iPhone.
No information available It is available on MicrosoftInternet Explorer 7 or higher,Mozilla Firefox 3.1 or higher,
Apple Safari 4 or higher,Google Chrome 10 or higher.
User-friendly Interface Yes Average Average; complicated thanthe other two platformscompared here.
Enterprise Level
Scalability
Yes No Info Conversation Miner provides
scalable accountmanagement that allows one
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
17/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page16of 22
to share social mediaaccounts so that multiplepeople can use the accountwithout violating any social
media venues terms ofservice.
Sample Client List GE, 3M, Microban, UPS,Dell, Kodak, Logitech,Intuit, SallieMae, LorealCanada, Bissell, Pepsi,
AutoNation, Crocs,Canadian Tire, AmericanRed Cross, Mayo Clinic,ComCast.
Microsoft, PayPal, Sage,Skype, Xerox; and,
Abraham Harrison,Bader Rutter, FlintCommunications,Yomego, DigitalVoodoo, MD AndersonCancer Center, Pursuit,Global Crossing,YouCast, Latin List,YouDB, Bullseye, RedBricks Media use
Alterian SM2 for theirclients which collectivelyinclude Kimberly ClarkHealthCare, LoweWorldwide, SharpElectronics, GEHealthcare,Pfizer, 3M, SubWay,MTV, Durex, BBC,Ladbrokes, etc.
Amway, Lion Brand Yarn,Graco, Dow, etc.
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
18/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page17of 22
7 Conclusion
Social media listening is a rapidly growing domain and tools in the market are still maturing day by day.Hence, a organisation should define an approach to transform the unstructured data, flooded from social
media, into meaningful data that can be analysed by the business and then, respond to the social data. An
organization should also develop a framework that can track social media. It should also identify who its true
brand advocates are; and, should learn about them beyond their interest in their brand. Deeper analysis can
lead to better insights about the identity of these brand advocates, their interests and needs.
Our evaluation of the three popular social media monitoring tools reveals that Radian 6 is the most popular
one with intuitive layout and ease to use, Alterian looks very promising for global brands with its multilingual
capability of handling 60 languages and sentiment analysis capability in 20 languages, while Converseons
Conversation Miner platform is not as evolved as the other two platforms.
We also analysed another platform from Webtrends called Social Measurement. Being powered by Radian6,
it also brings to the table, similar social media listening and analytic capabilities as Radian6, but not
exhaustive as Radian6 in terms of functionality. However, it has added extra analytic capabilities by
integrating with the Webtrends Analytic. This provides deep-dive analytics on web activities and very useful in
studying customer behaviour patterns in ecommerce websites.
Radian6 and Alterians SM2 both sell their systems based on the quantity of results. For $600 a month, one
can have unlimited search terms and an unlimited number of users to examine 10,000 results Radian6
charges $500 a month to examine 10,000 net new results, but only one user get access (it costs an extra
$100 per user that you add). So, you will have to likely share a single Radian6 login among many members of
your team and take turns using it. Both Radian6 and Alterians SM2 are offered on SaaS model.
The customization and deployment of the both the tools are quick and calibrated over a period of time.
Radian6 provides platform APIs and Social Metrics Framework for integrating third-party CRM. With
Radian6s acquisition by Salesforce.com, its integration with other CRMs can be limited and also influence the
future strategy and direction of the product.
Rating sentiment is the proverbial Holy Grail of social media monitoring. And neither Radian6 nor Alterians
SM2 have figured out how to accurately automate tonality ratings for blog posts, tweets, videos or social
network activity.
Radian6 can archive up to 18 months of data in its system, and SM2 up to 24 months, so one canretroactively search for content in the blogosphere if one wants to benchmark year on year.
Radian6 has added useful dashboards that enable one to segment out which social media one wants to view.
For instance, if one only wants to see tweets, one can set up a dashboard just for tracking micro media.
Radian6 is the winner when it comes to user-interface and ease of use.
Both the tools are tied on functionality and price. However, Radian6 is slightly ahead with its superior user-
friendly interface, integration with other social media listening tools and better workflow.
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
19/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page18of 22
8 Annexure 1: Open Source Listening Tools and Their
applications1. Twilert
Functions like Google Alerts
Twitter-focused Listening Tool
Geo/location-based advanced search options available
2. Twoolr
Again Twitter-focused tool
Complete Twitter following Analysis only
3. Hootsuite (OpenSource Version)
Has Comprehensive Analytics for both Twitter and Facebook and Listening
Limited features and access only for one team member
Supports Ads and RSS/Atom Feeds
4. Twitter Analytics
Twitter-specific Analytics only
Gives you analysis of interactions as per time-zone, tweet headlines, and conversation history, clicks
and regional analysis for any keywords (even competitors)
5. Socialbakers (Open Source Version)
Offers Analytics for both Facebook and LinkedIn including statistics based on country also
6. Kurrently
Gives real-time search engine results for keywords from Twitter and Facebook
One also has options to search on Kurrently, Google, Bing, Baidu and YouTube through FB, Twitter
or Both
7. Social Mention
Excellent Listening Tool
Works like Google Alerts but it works across the web and not specific to any of the social media sites
8. Klout
Analytic Tool for Twitter and Facebook
Measures awareness on Twitter and Facebook
Also helps identify Influencers across these media
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
20/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page19of 22
Also helps benchmark against competitors
Measures reach, amplification and network and based on that, it gives one a Klout score a unit
indicating ones online influence
9. Blogsearch.Google.com
A complete Blog-Search and Blog-Listening tool
10. Twitterfall
Again a twitter-focused Listening Tool
11. Topsy
Comprehensive Twitter Search Engine
12. TwitterCounter
Gives Twitter Profile Statistics
13. CoTweet (Open Source)
Browser based Total Social Media Management product with limited features in Open Source
For Twitter only in Open Source
14. Facebook Insights
Only does Facebook analytics
15. YouTube Insight
Provides analytics on YouTube pages including page views and demographic breakdown, countries-
based analytics.
16. TweetStats
Handy Open Source tool that only gives twitter statistics
Helps see how many tweets one has posted, got how many replies;
Also helps one see how many tweets ones competitor posted and their web-interaction
One can also see this information for different timelines
17. Twitter Analyzer
Complete Twitter Analyzer just as the name suggests
No registration also required; hence can help observe competitors
Shows level of tweets over time, conversation level, popularity, reach graph, etc.
18. Boardreader
Best forum search engines around
Excellent analytics suite to find what people are saying about ones brand in forums
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
21/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
Defiance Technologies Limited Proprietary and Confidential Page20of 22
Search functionality not intuitive but results make up for it
One can group search by time and see overall trend in forum mentions as well as drill down into
individual results to see mentions
19. CoComment
Handy browser extension/Plug-in to monitor comments on blogs (both - the blogs one has started and
the blogs one has just commented on)
20. Yahoo Site Explorer
Interesting way to track the inbound links to ones sites
Can also help track that of competitors and hence, help choose what inbound links to chase
Results might not be 100% accurate though
21. Omgili Graphs
Bad design of website but excellent Analytics
Gives option to compare different search terms and hence can help track campaigns, events,
products and analyse their popularity level or compare.
Provides graphical results that can be embedded on sites
22. IceRocket
Blog Search Engine
Results not really trustworthy
23. Compete
Helps access site traffic either for oneself or ones competitors
Can compare up to 3 sites to access traffic trends over the past 12 months in OpenSource version
and free overview of traffic sources for the particular site and which keywords are people using to find
the site.
-
7/27/2019 Social Media Listening Tool a Comparative Study (1)
22/22
Defiance Technologies limited
Social Media Intelligence Listening and Web Analytics Tool A Comparative Study
P 21 f 22
9 Reference
The Forrester Wave: Listening Platforms, Q3 2010
Gartner Magic Quadrant for Social CRM
PR 20/20 Social Media Monitoring Tools Comparison Guide
Listening 2.0 White Paper from Converseon
Social Media Monitoring Tools and Services Ideya Market Report, 2nd Edition May 2011
Social Media Intelligence Platforms from Lenati
http://pauldunay.com/how-to-choose-a-social-media-listening-platform-for-b2b-marketing/
http://pauldunay.com/how-to-choose-a-social-media-listening-platform-for-b2b-marketing/http://pauldunay.com/how-to-choose-a-social-media-listening-platform-for-b2b-marketing/