sp 88093

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

1/12

Republic of the Philippines

COURT OF APPEALS

Manila

SPECIAL TWELFTH DIVISION

HANAMEL ROLGINS RESOURCES CA-G.R. SP NO. !"#CORPORA$ION% Petitione&% Me'be&s(

VILLARAMA, JR., Chairman,

- )e&sus -

CARANDANG, an* TAGLE, JJ.

HON. +U,GE EN+AMIN $.IAN/ON% Actin0 P&esi*in0+u*0e R$C of alan0a Cit1%&anch 2 AN, RI/AL P&o'ul0ate*(COMMERCIAL AN3INGCORPORA$ION% Respon*ents. 44444444444444444444445- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 5

D E C I S I O N

VILLARAMA, JR., J.

$his is a petition file* un*e& Rule 26 to annul the O&*e& *ate* +anua&1 78%9!!2 issue* b1 public &espon*ent in Ci)il Case No. 87"-ML fo& Nullification ofForeclosure Proceedings and Mortgage with prayer for Determination of ProperInterest Rates/Amount of Obligation *is'issin0 the co'plaint fo& lac: of inte&est

to p&osecute% on the 0&oun* of f&au* an* conni)ance b1 plaintiff;s counsel ?RCC?@

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

2/12

CA-G.R. SP N. !!"#$%EC&S&N

P76%!26%!!!.!! as shob@ o&*e&in0 the *efen*ant ban: to pa1 thesu's of P7!!%!!!.!! fo& atto&ne1;s fees an* P8!%!!!.!! as e5e'pla&1*a'a0es.9

On Au0ust 9% 9!!7% p&i)ate &espon*ent file* a ?Motion o& E5tension of$i'e >$o ile Ans

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

3/12


On eb&ua&1 72% 9!!9% petitione& th&u counsel file* a 'otion to *ecla&e the*efen*ant ban: in *efault an* to allo< it to p&esent e)i*ence e!parte"#$ Anotice of hea&in0 on the sai* 'otion

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

4/12


const&aine* to

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

5/12


file* a 'otion to *ecla&e the *efen*ant in *efault he file* it onl1 on eb&ua&1 72%9!!9 afte& the case ha* al&ea*1 been pen*in0 fo& al'ost a 1ea& *ue to theincessant e5ten*in0 of pe&io* to file &esponsi)e plea*in0. An* *espite se)e&al

e5tensions 0&ante* to p&i)ate &espon*ent% it

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

6/12


7/25/2019 Sp 88093

7/12


.aamana %s" 'ourt

of Appeals% 6 SCRA 2@.; 5 5 5

?We #isa(ree. The na$re !f e-rinsi" fra$#, as #is"$sse#%re&i!$s) ne"essari) re$ires ha is "a$se e ra"eae ! s!mefra$#$en a" !f he %re&aiin( %ar) "!mmie# !$si#e he ria !fhe "ase. $he Cou&t notes that the p&e)iousl1 enu'e&ate* ne(i(ena"s ari$e# ! %eii!ner's f!rmer "!$nse /ari!s *ere in n!*a) sh!*n !r ae(e# ! ha&e een "a$se# ) %ri&ae res%!n#ens.

Att1. Ga&litos neithe& conni)e* no& sol* out to the latte&.

?.aamana %s" 'ourt of Appeals% cite* b1 petitione&s *oes notsuppo&t thei& cause because its factual bac:0&oun* is *iffe&ent f&o' the

instant case. In that case% the Cou&t foun* that ;La5a'ana ha* *i&ectl1cha&0e* his la

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

8/12


conclusion?

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

9/12


petitione&s. $he1 alle0e*l1 &efe&&e* the 'atte& to Att1. illa'o&

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

10/12


an1 f&au*ulent act of thepre%ailing party which is committed outside thetrial of the case(

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

11/12


HEREORE% p&e'ises consi*e&e*% the p&esent petition is he&eb1,ENIE, ,UE COURSE an* acco&*in0l1 ,ISMISSE,% fo& lac: of 'e&it.

No p&onounce'ent as to costs.

SO OR,ERE,.

MARTIN S. VILLARAMA, JR.

Associate +ustice

E CONCUR(

ROSMARI D. CARANDANGAssociate +ustice

LUCENITO N. TAGLE

Associate +ustice

CERTIFICATION

Pu&suant to A&ticle III% Section 7# of the Constitution% it is he&eb1ce&tifie* that the conclusions in the abo)e *ecision

7/25/2019 Sp 88093

12/12


'

sp 88093

Documents