speak out - open.alberta.ca · p a g e | 2 speak out – the alberta student engagement initiative...
TRANSCRIPT
Speak Out
A Summary of Student Voices Online
November 2008 to June 2009
www.speakout.alberta.ca
P a g e | 2
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
Major Themes and Issues from www.speakout.alberta.ca (Weeks of November 3, 2008, through April 3, 2009)
Theme Issues Things that are conducive to learning
Classmates that want to be there Clear objectives and instructions Small class sizes Physical comfort A structured learning environment Regular interaction with teacher and classmates Flexibility in learning pace and space
Advice for your teachers Be enthusiastic, knowledgeable, and creative Be approachable and treat students with respect Explain the relevance of material being taught Control the classroom but maintain a positive atmosphere Cater your lessons to all learning styles Be flexible with deadlines
Teaching methods that work for you
Educational field trips! When concepts are taught using various techniques Dynamic activities and assignments that involve more than simple
robotic memorization Discussions and debates of concepts A teacher who keeps discussions relevant and respectful Hands-on activities in math and science classes Small written responses help you improve your writing Opportunities to apply knowledge in real life contexts
Suggestions for improving the curriculum
Assign texts that are modern and relevant in English class Include more current and global affairs in all courses Revise the CALM content to make it more relevant to your
immediate lives Encourage participation in relevant extracurricular activities
School politics and administrative challenges
More student input in all levels of decision-making Inform students why and how important decisions are made (e.g.,
new school rules, curriculum changes) Enforce school rules in a respectful and consistent manner
Stresses of student life Sources of stress: school work, teachers, friends, family, planning for your future, and work
Social relations are just as challenging as academic endeavours What helps you handle the stress
Supportive social networks Exercise, hobbies, relaxing activities, etc. Time management Asking for help Having a place to talk and share
Graduation and post-secondary school
Post-secondary school and scholarship applications are overwhelming and time-consuming
More help with deciphering requirements
P a g e | 3
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
Theme Issues Tests and diploma exams
Importance of regular study habits Proper time management is crucial Too much stress about diploma exams! Make testing environments more comfortable Practice tests are useful Teach test-taking techniques
You love to debate! Politics and society Religion and freedom of expression Philosophy and human nature School systems and rules
Dealing with bullying Speak out and tell your story to people who can help Educate students about all forms of bullying Teach self-protection and how to find help Promote tolerance and compassion through education
French language program
Learning the French language is beneficial Fear that French-Canadian culture will die out if not supported in
schools Special education Tools and training for success in all aspects of life
Improve students’ ease of access to additional help Technology as an educational accompaniment
Technology can enhance the learning experience with variety SMART Boards are great PowerPoint can be useful when used as an accompaniment Computer labs, laptops, and online school networks are useful when
used properly Don’t let technology be a distraction Don’t let technology replace teaching Don’t become dependent on technology
Advice from graduates Create a life plan with goals to work towards Keep a flexible attitude because interests will change over time Follow your own dreams Find your passions
P a g e | 4
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
Description
Speak Out Website Discussion Forums Background
Launched by the Minister of Education on November 26, 2008, Speak Out—the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative—encourages Alberta’s youth to get involved in a variety of activities to share their thoughts about the education system. Speak Out has four components: an interactive, fully moderated website; Speak Out forums where small group-facilitated discussions are held at schools around the province; the Speak Out Annual Student Conference where 200 youth from around the province will gather; and the Minister’s Student Advisory Council, comprised of 24 youth ages 14 to 19. Speak Out’s website, comprised of moderated and interactive discussion boards and a daily blog, went live on November 3, 2008. Although many provinces in Canada have youth and student engagement initiatives, Speak Out is unique in that it is the only initiative to provide an interactive online presence, thus allowing students to discuss their education issues and concerns and to brainstorm recommendations and solutions with their peers across the province. Because the website is moderated, every post is reviewed by human eyes prior to posting to ensure relevance, privacy, anonymity and safety. The Community Rules for the website are clear: keep it relevant; keep it respectful; keep it safe (no names, no places, no schools, no contact info, no URLs); keep an open mind; and keep it clean. With these clear expectations, the website has a 90% approval rating. Setup and Activity
The Speak Out website features a “Discuss” tab under which students can create their own discussion topics, view the archive of discussion posts and respond to ongoing conversations. The discussion section is divided into several “forums” created by the Speak Out administration, including monthly forums that feature a different theme each time. When students join, they can create a personal profile, complete with an avatar and a signature signoff. Members can then create their own topics under the forums to talk with other students across Alberta about their school experiences and their education. Discussion topics have varied immensely across the forums—from what kind of music is best for studying, to suggestions for improving the curriculum. Students have enjoyed being able to connect and speak out with peers, as is clear from the tremendous response.
P a g e | 5
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(A) Workforce Planning Themes Issues Teaching as a career Your interest in teaching as a career depends on your teachers’
portrayals of their jobs: if it’s positive, then you’ll be more likely to consider becoming a teacher
Teaching appeals to you because teachers can have a positive influence in people’s lives by helping them to learn, to grow and to have confidence
Teaching does not appeal to you because it requires a lot of patience, involves long hours, is stressful and you believe that there are too many restrictions that hinder teachers from teaching in the manner they believe is best
How current teaching practices could be improved
English and social studies classes could be improved by including more discussions and small written responses
Math and science classes could be improved by including more hands-on and interactive activities
Teachers generally need more freedom so they can teach the subjects for which they have the most passion
“Teachers are so essential in shaping the future generations. They can be a catalyst for change. Inspire young people to do great things.”
“The best "adverstising campaign" for careers in teaching and education is the living advertising that educators are.”
P a g e | 6
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(B) School Work Themes Issues Concerns about graduation and post-secondary school
Preparation for your graduation ceremonies commands a lot of your time and energy; it brings stress but also excitement
Decisions about post-secondary school and scholarship applications can be overwhelming (how to apply, where to apply, meeting the requirements, etc.) and you need more help
Talking about tests and diploma exams
Parents and teachers place so much emphasis on diploma exams that you become more anxious and stressed about them
Practice exams, regular study habits, a positive attitude and sharing study tips and test-taking techniques help you prepare for exams
Proper time management is a crucial skill for dealing with heavy workloads
Your suggestions for increasing the excitement factor
School readings for subjects like social studies and English would be more interesting if the texts assigned to you were more modern, relevant and interesting
You’re excited by newer, non-traditional subjects like media studies, psychology and culinary studies
You enjoy class more when…
The teacher is enthusiastic and very knowledgeable about the subject; the course content includes more current affairs; the relevance and ultimate purpose of the material is explained to you (for e.g., why exactly are you learning Shakespeare?); your classmates want to be there; you’re given clear objectives and instructions; class sizes are small enough to support comfortable discussions; your assignments involve more than robotic memorization; your teacher is approachable; the material is taught using various techniques; and when you’re physically comfortable
Topics that you enjoy debating (but remain divided about) include:
The recital of pledges to school, country and God each morning; singing the national anthem; secular versus religious education; the full-year or semester school setup; public versus private schools; the use of music in class; cell phone rules; dress code regulations; and gender-segregated schools
P a g e | 7
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
Themes Issues Your suggestions for improving the quality of life at school
School cafeterias need to offer more options and healthier menu selections
Schools should recognize accomplishments other than academic or sports success, such as attendance, community involvement, volunteer activities, etc.
You learn more from interacting with people who are different from you than by simply reading about them, so encourage social interaction among students of all backgrounds
Maintain a consistent and simple school schedule, so students can focus on learning and not on which day of the week it is
“it's so cool to have a place to talk about stuff that actually matters with people that are open and helpful :)”
“If you review each night, studying for an upcoming exam gets much easier because you know the material and you aren't cramming everything the night before.”
“Smaller class sizes help me learn a lot better. You have an easier time asking questions and one on one help, plus the teacher has better control over the class so class time is not spent on disciplining.”
“why do writing assignments have to be about some boring topic?...I wish that teachers would put some excitement into teaching...I would do soo much better...”
P a g e | 8
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(C) What happened in school today… Themes Issues Social relations are just as challenging as academic endeavours
Learning how to deal with friends and social drama (for e.g., gossip, bullying, peer pressure) can be exhausting and often distracts you from school work
A strong and supportive social network is necessary for your success and sanity (despite its potential for distraction)
Your suggestions for improving the curriculum
Educational field trips are an excellent (yet underutilized) activity that help you understand and apply concepts taught in class
Physical education in high school should be about developing a positive attitude and becoming familiar with an active lifestyle, not about skills
All of your courses should be revised to include more global and current affairs, so that they’re more relevant and interesting
Substitute teachers should be used more strategically and should be better prepared for the class they’re teaching
Politics and administrative challenges
You think students should be encouraged to approach the school administration with issues and not be afraid to offer solutions of their own
The student voice needs to be heard for all administrative decisions, and students should be permitted full disclosure about decisions because you’re the ones most affected
Rules and regulations within each school should be enforced in a respectful and consistent manner to avoid confusion (for e.g., dress code, cell phones, class disruptions, etc.)
“field trips can be great! it completely breaks the repetitve enviroment of a classroom. and it helps everyone who learns by doing.”
P a g e | 9
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(D) Stressed Out! Themes Issues Sources of stress include…
School, homework, friends, family, dealing with others’ expectations, extracurricular activities, teachers, university and scholarship applications, making decisions about the future, social/teen drama, diploma exams, work, dealing with lack of motivation, changing schools, lack of sleep and poor learning environments
How you de-stress Physical activity, listening to music, hanging out/talking/venting with friends, dancing, watching TV, snacking, reading, napping, using available resources for help (e.g., guidance councillors, learning centres), reminding yourself that there are people with worse problems out there, etc.
Eliminating the sources of stress
You’ve discovered several ways to help minimize stress. They include: time management (being aware of time spent on certain activities and making productive use of spare time); making study schedules and sticking to them; making school a priority so other activities don’t infringe on school work; choosing your friends wisely and reminding yourself to ignore gossip; seeking guidance and advice from informed sources, as well as doing your own research; keeping the lines of communication open with your teachers; making new friends and focusing on friendships
“what helps is just turning off the music, shutting down MSN, facebook etc and just working on one thing till I get it done. The success of getting one thing done often helps the stress levels and give me motivation to get more stuff doe.”
“Staying on top of tests and quizzes is key. Jamming it all, in one night does not work so well...”
“Is it bad that this site is becoming a hobby?”
P a g e | 10
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(E) Teaching that works for me! Themes Issues Advice for your educators
Find that perfect balance between being strict and being fun, formal and informal, demanding and flexible
Teach your subject with creativity and enthusiasm, be approachable, treat your students like adults, do your research, and explain why things you’re teaching are important to learn
Teaching methods that work
You enjoy discussing and debating concepts in class, and you appreciate your teacher keeping things on topic
Vary the teaching methods so all learning styles are catered to and to avoid monotony
Hands-on activities help you understand new concepts in math and science classes
Learning environments that make you comfortable
To perform your best, you need to be physically comfortable
Testing environments are too artificial and unnecessarily stressful; keep things calm and relaxed and you’ll avoid test anxiety
Keep course content relevant and interesting
Include more current affairs to make courses more relevant and interesting
Revise the CALM content so the material is more relevant to your immediate life experiences
“I personally need a blend of textbook work, essays, assignments, questions, labs and other hands on stuff in order to learn.”
“Teachers who take the time to make their room inviting do make it easier to learn...”
P a g e | 11
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(F) Bullying… Themes Issues Sharing your stories as victims of bullying helps you to heal
Bullying exists in many forms (for e.g., cyberbullying) and is an unavoidable aspect of school life
Sharing your story helps you to manage and move beyond the emotional pain that a bullying experience caused you
How to deal with bullying
Intervening in a bullying situation can be tough to do, especially when you don’t know the people involved
You find that it’s best to notify authority figures about an incident and to speak out as it’s occurring if you feel safe enough
How to prevent bullying Sometimes the person doing the bullying needs friends or someone to talk to
Inform students about what constitutes bullying and how to make themselves less vulnerable; let them know there are ways for them to get help and stop it
Education can help make people more tolerant and compassionate by teaching about differences
“It wasn't bullying for them, it was a way to make friends over a common enemy.”
“I challenge you to send someone a positive honesty box message just for the fun of it and to help counter the cyber-bullying that happens on facebook. :)”
“I think at some point every body has been a bully. intentionally or not. the sad part is, i think it's become human nature to tease others”
P a g e | 12
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(G) C’est ton éducation. Qu’en penses-tu? Themes Issues Pride for French language and culture
You’re proud of your francophone heritage and glad that your parents have continued their traditions through the language
Achieving a bilingual status in French and English is an accomplishment you’ll always be proud of
Advantages of learning French
You believe that knowing French will increase your education choices and job opportunities
Fluency in French will allow you to communicate with people in other cultures across Canada and in other countries
Threats to the French language program
French-Canadian culture and identity risk dying out if nothing is done to promote its existence in schools
More awareness is needed about the differences between French language courses designed for francophone and anglophone students
“je crois que le francais me donnera plusieurs avantage: pouvoire communiquer avec plusieurs autres gens, avoir un meilleurs emplois, plus de choix d<etudes secondaires” (“I believe that knowing French will give me several advantages: the ability to communicate with more people, to have a better job, more choices for post-secondary education”)
“ce que je trouve le plus important c'est que la culture elle-meme reste vivante; la langue, les fetes et les traditions.” (“what I find the most important is that the culture itself remains alive; the language, the festivals, and the traditions.”)
P a g e | 13
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(H) Where is the world in your education? Themes Issues Your want to be a global citizen
You enjoy learning about and debating current global issues, and being involved with humanitarian activities
Your optimism and enthusiasm mean you can offer a fresh perspective on the state of the world, as well as solutions that can make it a better place
Extracurricular activities that focus on raising awareness and social activism are rewarding and you wish you knew more about how to become involved in those kind of activities
School should include more global issues in the curriculum
Currently, you learn about the world and other cultures in courses such as social studies, English and other languages (French, German, etc.)
The curriculum should focus on finding solutions to the world’s problems and on learning about people and leaders who have done good, rather than focusing so much on the negative aspects of the world’s history
More emphasis should be placed on student exchange programs and school trips, because you believe that travelling and interacting with people is the best way to learn about other cultures
“That's why the quote "Think global, act local" is so great because there are so many issues and needs to be met right in our own province. (E.g., Homelessness)”
“We read about people who make or spread violence, like Hitler or Stalin but we don't spend as much time thinking about the good work of people who create or spread peace, like the Dalai Lama”
P a g e | 14
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(I) Learning Anytime, Any Place, Any Pace Themes Issues You need structure and flexibility
You benefit from a structured learning environment and from the guidance offered by regular interactions with teachers and peers
You also need flexibility to be able learn at your own speed and in the places that are most comfortable for you
How your school upholds this learning concept
Your school offers online courses that allow you to learn at your own pace and in environments that are more comfortable for you
Classes are often divided according to students’ preferred learning pace and interest level (International Baccalaureate classes)
Teachers can help by being flexible in their scheduling and by offering after-school tutorials or question periods
“The truth is that most kids aren't responsible enough to handle that amount of freedom. Students need to learn to make sacrifices in order to get the education they need.”
(J) Special Education
Themes Issues School should cater to all types of needs
School should provide the tools and training for student success in all aspects of their lives, not just academic instruction
Make better use of program funds by using resources more effectively and by finding creative solutions to student needs
Academic success should not be a determining factor when deciding which students need additional funding for their education
Altering the way we talk about and treat students with special needs
Reconsider using the word “special” to label students who require unconventional help in school (because of its negative connotations)
Separating students with different learning needs can be helpful, but should be done as little as possible so that people become used to interacting with and learning from one another
“There is lots that people with disabilities can do, it is only the matter of asking finding out what they need”
P a g e | 15
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(K) Been there, done that… Themes Issues Advice from recent graduates is respected
It’s important to create a life plan so you have a goal to work towards, but maintaining a flexible attitude is crucial because your interests will change over time
Remembering to stay true to your own dreams
While you appreciate the advice and guidance offered by family, you often feel too much pressure to live your life according to their expectations
You’re happiest when you have the freedom to follow your own dreams and the support of your friends and family regardless of success or failure
“I enjoy planning and having goals, but I definitely don't have all the answers to people's questions about my future yet.”
P a g e | 16
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(L) Using Technology to Learn Themes Issues Technology can enhance your learning if it’s incorporated responsibly
Incorporate technology into the classroom in a manner that is relevant to enhance your learning, but not in a manner that distracts you or makes you overly reliant on it in the long run
Students need to be taught to use technology in accordance with the principles of Responsible Digital Citizenship
Online learning or other high-tech tools can never outweigh the benefits of classroom interaction
Technology that helps you learn, and how you use it
Computer labs, laptops and online school networks (for e.g., Schoolzone) help you complete assignments, do research, organize your notes and schedules, and communicate with teachers
Tools like PowerPoint can enhance a lecture when used to accompany discussion, but teachers must be careful not to let it replace their teaching
SMART Boards are a great investment
Dangerously distracting technology
Cell phones are an essential communication tool outside the classroom, but are mostly distractions when used during class
Laptops are great for taking down lecture notes in class, but it would be hard for teachers to monitor inappropriate Internet use, etc.
“What I enjoy most is that as we read the slides, the teachers provide different information to enhance what is on the slide”
“At my school we also use D2L which stands for Desire to Learn and it is a pretty awesome site.”
P a g e | 17
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(M) Student Information and Modern Education
Themes Issues Substitute teachers pose some challenges for you
It is challenging to remain on schedule with your course when you have a substitute teacher, but you generally respect the job they are doing and appreciate the challenges they face as well
Substitute teachers should specialize in the course they fill in for.
Transferring personal information between schools
Transferring schools or districts is challenging because there is a communication breakdown between each school and the districts
Transferring personal information would be helpful to your new school or district, but you are concerned that you may be unfairly judged before you have the chance to prove yourself
Teachers should share information on your learning style.
This is a good idea, but teachers often teach the way they are comfortable teaching or they teach to the majority of their students’ styles rather than catering their lesson to each individual style
“The most difficult challenge for the substitutes is that they are constantly compared to their original teacher. If the administration or a TA were present in the classroom for the first day would help the new teacher.” “I don't think trying to provide a different learning method for everyone is very effective, it would be to time consuming to get any real worth out of it.”
P a g e | 18
Speak Out – the Alberta Student Engagement Initiative – A Summary of Student Voices Online
(N) Inspiring Education
Themes Issues The length of time students should spend in school
Twelve years is enough time in school. After twelve years, you are ready to move on
You want flexibility to complete your classes faster or slower depending on your life circumstances and the pace you want to work at
How you are assessed There should be evidence that you are progressing in your class, but you feel that the current grading system is arbitrary and does not reflect your true effort or progress
You said that sometimes grades may indicate that the curriculum needs to be updated or that there was a bad teacher instructing you rather than your actual progress
What school is and what it should be
School is a place where you learn the skills you will need in the future
School, in its current form, does not allow freedom for students to explore their desires.
Students should feel privileged to have the opportunity to attend school.
“I was just wondering what is so important about grades (or marks) in assessing people when it is just one indicator of a level of achievement at single point in time?” “School can be free, invigorating, current, modern, fresh.”