speedy ird seminar 03-2013
TRANSCRIPT
IRD$Seminar$
$The$UN$system$role$in$assis1ng$
government$policy$and$implementa1on$$
Andrew$Speedy$–$Visi4ng$Professor,$School$of$Agriculture$$$
$
Wednesday$13$March$2013$
RLC$$
RAP$$
RAF$ SAFR$
RNE$
SEUR$
FAO$HQ$
SLAC$SNEA$
SAPA$
• $$Headquarters$in$Rome$$$• $$Five$Regional$Offices$$• $$Five$SubMregional$Offices$$• $$Five$Liaison$Offices$$• $$SeventyMFour*$Country$Representa4ons$• $ThirtyMsix$countries$with$mul4ple$accredita4on$$
• $$3600$staff$• $$192$Member$Countries$
$Development$is$a$mul4dimensional$process$involving$changes$in$structures,$ins4tu4ons,$and$aVtudes$as$well$as$the$accelera4on$of$economic$growth,$the$reduc4on$of$inequality,$and$the$eradica4on$of$absolute$poverty.$Michael$Todaro,$1983.$Economics$for$a$Developing$World,$Longman.$
Low$income$countries$
• Food$aid$• Poverty$Reduc4on$• Water$
• Agriculture$• Forestry$• Fisheries$• Alterna4ve$enterprises$
Botswana$ Brazil$ China$
India$ Indonesia$ Malaysia$
Namibia$ Nigeria$ Pakistan$
Peru$ Philippines$ Senegal$
South Africa$ Sri Lanka$ Sudan$
Swaziland$ Thailand$ Tunisia$
Turkey$ Venezuela$ Vietnam$
Some$Middle$Income$Countries$(104$in$2010)$$
Table 1: World Bank definition of income categories Middle-income countries (MIC)
Low-income (LIC) Lower-middle-income (LMIC)
Upper-middle-income (UMIC) High-income (HIC)
$995 or less $996 - $3,945 $3,946 - $12,195 $12,196 or more
Table$2:$Years$of$gradua4on$from$LIC$to$MIC$since$2000$$
2000 $ Turkmenistan $2001 $ - $2002 $ Armenia; Ukraine $2003 $ Azerbaijan; Georgia; Indonesia $2004 $ Angola $2005 $ Cameroon; Congo, Rep.; Lesotho; Moldova; Nicaragua $2006 $ Bhutan $2007 $ India; Sudan; Mongolia; Timor-Leste $
2008 $ Côte d’Ivoire ; Nigeria; Pakistan; Sao Tomé and Principe; Solomon Islands* $
2009** $ Senegal; Uzbekistan; Vietnam; Yemen $
Glennie,$J.$2011.$The$role$of$aid$to$middleMincome$countries:$a$contribu4on$to$evolving$EU$development$policy.$ODI$Working$Paper$331.$$$
National $ Most poor people live in MICs $
Regional $ Spillover effects to nearby countries $
Global $ Crucial contribution to global public goods $
Reasons$for$suppor1ng$development$and$poverty$reduc1on$in$MICs
For $ Against $Better value-for-money $ Scarce resources $Encouraging private capital $ Crowding out private capital $Danger of removing aid$ Perverse incentives $Targeted interventions $ Limited influence $Sub-national support $ Fungibility $Support to civil society $ Intergenerational poverty $
Sharing expertise and knowledge transfer$
Common$reasons$given$for$and$against$aid$to$MICs$$
Glennie,$J.$2011.$The$role$of$aid$to$middleMincome$countries:$a$contribu4on$to$evolving$EU$development$policy.$ODI$Working$Paper$331.$$$
Middle$Income$Countries$
• Na4onal$Plans$• Laws$• Interna4onal$Compliance$
• Trade$• Health$and$Food$Safety$• Environmental$and$CC$
• Poverty$Reduc4on$• Economic$restructuring$(urbanMrural)$
Finance
Business
People
Health Education
Social protection
Pension
Leisure Housing
Culture Environment
Work Goods Food
Biosphere
Industry Agriculture
Energy Water
Incentive
Tax
Tax
Social services
Environmental services Policy Framework Land
Finance
Business
People
Health Education
Social protection
Pension
Leisure Housing
Culture Environment
Work Goods Food
Biosphere
Industry Agriculture
Energy Water
Incentive
Tax
Tax
Social services
Environmental services
Land
Trade$ Interna4onal$agreements$
Foreign$Policy$
Na4onal$Security$
UN$Agencies$
• UNDP$• UNICEF$• UNFPA$• FAO$• IFAD$• ILO$• IOM$• UNAIDS$
• UNESCO$• UNHCR$• UNIDO$• UN$Women$• UNODC$• UNV$• WFP$• WHO$
Policy$needs$and$gaps$
• UrbanMrural$divide$• Migra4on$
• Land$tenure$• Agricultural$Restructuring$• Ecosystem$management$
• Climate$change$adapta4on$and$mi4ga4on$
• Food$systems$
Agricultural$Restructuring$
• Number'of'farmers'reducing,'urbanization'• Differentiate'small,'medium'and'large'(commercial'farmers)'
• Provide'public'investment'in'appropriate'infrastructure'
• Encourage'but'closely'regulate'investment'by'the'private'sector'
• Develop'a'fair'system'of'contract'farming'for'small'farmers'to'work'with'the'private'sector'
• Encourage'sustainable'development'and'the'welfare'of'farmers'and'consumers'
• Positive'bene@its'of'migration'
Outcomes$
• Local$leadership$capacity$&$public$administra4on$improved$
• Agriculture,$forestry$and$fisheries$produc4on$increased$$• Workers$educated$and$employed$
• Improved$rural$infrastructure$
• Quality$of$life$improved,$no$more$poverty$
• Capacity$for$natural$disaster$preparedness$
Outputs$$• Capacity$building$in$policy$and$management$at$local$level$
• Agriculture,$forestry$and$fisheries$development$inc.$animal$and$plant$health$and$food$safety$
• Rural$informa4on,$educa4on$and$communica4on$programme$
• Synchronized$development$of$rural$infrastructure$
• Social$security$
• Health$system$
• Educa4on$$
• Culture$program$
• Sport$
• Capacity$strengthened$for$natural$disaster$preparedness$and$mi4ga4on;$
• Preparedness$against$typhoons,$flash$flooding,$salinity$intrusion,$and$4dal$sea;$
Some$Human$Rights$
• Right$to$food$• Health$care$(medical$care)$
• Educa4on$• Equality$of$both$males$and$females;$women's$rights$
• The$right$to$work$• To$own$property$• Free$Speech$• Safety$from$violence$
Implica4ons$for$policies$and$programmes$
1.$People$are$recognized$as$key$actors$in$their$own$development,$rather$than$passive$recipients$of$commodi4es$and$services.$
2.$Par4cipa4on$is$both$a$means$and$a$goal.$
3.$Strategies$are$empowering.$
4.$Both$outcomes$and$processes$are$monitored$and$evaluated.$
5.$Analysis$includes$all$stakeholders.$
6.$Programmes$focus$on$marginalized,$disadvantaged,$and$excluded$groups.$
7.$The$development$process$is$locally$owned.$
8.$Programmes$aim$to$reduce$disparity.$
9.$Both$topMdown$and$bonomMup$approaches$are$used$in$synergy.$
10.$Situa4on$analysis$is$used$to$iden4fy$immediate,$underlying,$and$basic$causes$of$development$problems.$
11.$Measurable$goals$and$targets$are$important$in$programming.$
12.$Strategic$partnerships$are$developed$and$sustained.$
13.$Programmes$support$accountability$to$all$stakeholders.$
$
The$way$forward....$
• Review$strategies,$policies$and$laws$in$rela4on$to$the$holis4c$policy$framework$to$iden4fy$needs,$gaps,$synergies$and$conflicts$in$current$legisla4on$and$make$recommenda4ons.$
• In$par4cular,$consider$the$promo4on$of$culture,$educa4on,$environment,$gender$balance,$health$and$social$protec4on$within$the$context$of$rural$development.$
• Develop$interMministerial$and$interMdepartmental$(local)$mechanisms$for$integra4on$and$synergies$in$rural$development.$
Capacity$Building$
• Ministers$and$Vice$Ministers$
• Provincial$leaders$• District$Leaders$• Local$Leaders$• Private$Sector$• Civil$Society,$NGOs$• Teachers$(Training$of$Trainers)$• Adults$• Children$
“Projec4ons$indicate$that$the$world’s$higher$educa4on$system$must$accommodate$nearly$80$million$more$students$by$2025.$To$do$so$in$conven4onal$campuses$would$require$the$opening$of$three$large$(30,000$students)$campuses$every$week$for$the$next$13$years.”$
Some$of$these$campuses$will$be$built$but$most$will$not.$Capacity$can$be$increased$more$quickly$and$economically$by$inves4ng$in$distance$and$eLearning$opportuni4es.$In$par4cular,$higher$educa4on$systems$should$invest$in$the$crea4on$of$open$educa4onal$resources$(OER).$This$will$create$a$global$pool$of$high$quality$material$that$can$be$adapted$and$versioned$for$individual$countries$and$ins4tu4ons,$all$of$which$should$engage$in$this$important$collec4ve$effort$to$widen$access$and$improve$quality.$$
Sir$John$Daniel,$President$&$CEO,$$Commonwealth$of$Learning.$$
Innova4ons$
• Policy$programme$for$ministers,$directors$general,$interna4onal$organiza4ons,$banks,$NGOs.....$
• High$level$residen4al$course$• MPP/MPA$
• Distance$learning$• Teleconferencing$• Mentoring$
The$Lecture$Room$2020$
Is$it$working?$
If$not,$why$not?$
What’s$Wrong$with$the$World?$
• Equality$• Gender$• Economics$
• Environment$
• Poli4cal$system$
What’s$Wrong$with$the$World?$
• Conflict$• Food$crisis$• Economic$crisis$
• Poli4cal$crisis$• Natural$disasters$• Climate$Change$
Na4onal$Economy$
Market$Economy$
Public$Sector$
Government$
Manufacturing$ Service$Sector$
Agriculture$(Farmers)$
Banks$
Real$Estate$
Exports$
Credit$
Consumers$
Tax$
Labour$
Global$Companies$
Global$Finance$
Global$Economy$
All$bubbles$can$expand,$contract$or$burst$
Market$Economy$
Public$Sector$
Government$
Manufacturing$ Service$Sector$
Agriculture$(Farmers)$
Banks$
Real$Estate$
Exports$
Credit$
Outsourcing$
Bonds$$$$$$Hedge$funds$$$$$$Leveraging$$$$$Futures$$$$$$Deriva4ves$$
Consumers$
Tax$
Labour$
Collec4on$of$books$and$ar4cles$at:$hnps://docs.google.com/folder/d/0BxHirJwNdGgkQVBFSE80dHhNeE0/edit$
YouTube:$hnp://www.youtube.com/user/AndrewSpeedy/videos?flow=grid&view=1$
$
$
$
Thank$You$