Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1721029Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1721029

!!!!"#$%&%&'!(&)!"#$#&)%&'!*+#!,%'+*!*-!.(*#/!(&)!%*0!1%&%232!4-/#5!!6#'(7!4-&0*/38*%-&!(&)!*+#!,-7#!-$!9(*%-&(7!:3/%0;/3)#&8#!!!

!!"#$%!'(!)*"%+, M.A. International Law and Settlement of Disputes United Nations University for Peace!

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1721029Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1721029

! !"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&&&&&! &&!"#$%&%'(")*+#&(",-& & & & & & & & & -&&./*.'0"12340%1'& & & & & & & & & & .&&& !"#"$%&'()%*+,"-.(/012030&$2&".(42560%7($28(9":'*8*,*17& & & & /&

&../*56#*73&('*+%860*01*9(0#"*%'*.'0#"'(0%1'($*:(;"?",*@-"2:(*3($2(42:"%2$:0*2$,(A*2#"2#6#( ( ( ( ( -0(B< >"302021(:'"(C"1$,(/*6%&"(*3(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%( ( ( ( ( .-(A< ='"(E*%-$:0?"(A*2:"2:(*3(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%($28(:'"(!"#@*2#0+0,0:0"#(( ( .1(

!",$:"8(='"%":*(23 )%*1%"##0?"(4-@,"-"2:$:0*2( ( & & & & & 45&

&.../*?'2#"-0('2%'8*06#*@A%'%&3&*>1"#B*C1"*9(0#"& & & & & & 4.&&

;< ='"(9020-6-(A*%"(A*2&"@:(F"2"%$,,7( ( ( ( ( ( 4.(B< ='"(9020-6-(A*%"(3*%(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%( ( ( ( ( ( 46()3 ;(E*:"(*2(/$20:$:0*2( & & & & & & & 47&

&.D/*56#*E#C%'%0%1'*1C*06#*+%860*01*9(0#"*('2*%0-*A%'%&3&*>1"#**

*******%'*F(0%1'($*>13"0"11&-* & & & & & & & & 05&&

;< E*%-(A%"$:0*2($28(=%$2#-0##0*2($:(:'"(E$:0*2$,(C"?",( ( ( ( 0-(B< ='"(E$:0*2$,(G2#'%02"-"2:(*3(!01':#($28($2(42:%*86&:0*2(:*(:'"(( ( ( 00(

A$#"(C$H(A< ;(E*:"(*2(>":"%-02021($(/@"&030&(E6-+"%(*3(C0:"%#(3*%(:'"(9020-6-((

A*%"( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 01(>< !"?0"H(*3(E$:0*2$,(A$#"(C$H( ( ( ( ( ( ( 0/(

-3 8%$9:;:"& & & & & & & & & & 0?&43 8"*9$">%,@&"*>&A"B:,+"*& & & & & & & 60&03 !@%&A@:$:CC:*%,& & & & & & & & 6?&63 =*>'*%,:"& & & & & & & & & 1-&13 DE9%*+:*"& & & & & & & & & 14&/3 )'$'

& -&

E#C%'%'8*('2*E#C#'2%'8*06#*+%860*01*9(0#"*('2*%0-*A%'%&3&*>1"#1'-0"340%1'*('2*06#*+1$#*1C*F(0%1'($*J3"%-I"32#'4#*

&! (IJ:K'"(:'021#(H'0&'($%"(2$:6%$,,7("?"%7+*87L#($%"($0%.(3,*H021(H$:"%.(:'"(#"$($28(:'"(#"$(#'*%"&

+@%&C;#$:I"+:'*&'(&%>:+%>&P'$;&%P%*&+@%&

CE'>;I+:'*&'(&>'I;&CE'(%,,:'*"$&"++%*+:'*J&@'Q%P%EJ&:,&

":$R&@"E>,@:C&Q"+%E&,I"EI:+R&I";,%,&+@',%&'*%:$$:'*&

C%'C$%&Q'E$>Q:>%&Q@'&$"IB",:I&"II%,,3&D(+%E&"$$J&Q"+%EU,&(;*>":9*:+R&

:,&>:((:I;$+&+'&;*>%E,+"+%3&V"+%E&:,&"&*%I%,,:+R&('E&>'%:"$'9;%&,;EE';*>:*9&

Q"+%E&"*>&:+,&I%*+E"$:+R&+'&@;&"$'*%J+&:*,+%">&+"B%,&:+,&C$"I%&:*&"&

@:,+'ER&+@"+&9'P%E*,&:+,&I'*+%*+&"*>&>%+%E

& .&

"++%&+'&>%(:*%&WQ"+%E&@:,+'ERX&:*&E%I%*+&R%"E,J&"*>&"&,+;>R&'(&+@%&E%I%*+&C",+&%E*&D9%&Y&WV"+%E&8;E%";IE"IR&"*>&"&M%Q&a;&E%,';EI%&C'$$;+:'*&@"P%&('EI%>&@;"R&+@%R&I"*&'*$R%&R&"*&"I+'E&Q:+@&

+@%&E%c;:,:+%&+%I@*:I"$&I"C"I:+R3&b*>%E,+"*>"#$RJ&+@:,&:*+E:I"+%&Q'EB&:*P'$P%,&"&I%E+":*&&*#:.(

Q@:I@&9:P%,&+@%&&"&C'Q%E(;$&%I'*':%P%$'C%$&@",%%*&

:&:*&,'&'*&+@%&"*"$R+:I"$&'Q*&+@%&$",+&.6J555&R%"E,&:*+'&W+@E%,@'$>,&:*&Q"+%E&@:,+'ERJX&>%%P%$'C'I3;*%,I'3'E9O:&:*&+@%&,"&Q"+%E&",&"*&%I'*':+RJ&@'C:*9&+@"+R&,%%B:*9&(;$$&I',+&E%I'P%ER&+@%R&Q';$>&>:,T:*I%*+:P:Z%&Q",+%&"*>&CE%,%EP%&E%,';EI%,3&/""(LE:B&83&8$;%&,+"+%&I"C"I:+R3&/""(";+@'EU,&>:,I;,,:'*J(023%$(*3(4603(&&&&1&V"+%E&CE:I%&@",%I'

& 4&

D+&+@%",:,&'(&Q"+%EE%";IE"IR&%`:,+,&"&C'Q%E(;$&"*>&Q%$$T%,+"#$:,@%>&$%9"$&

,+E;I+;E%&(';*>%>&'*&+@%&'E9"*:Z:*9&CE:*I:C$%&'(&,+"+%&,'P%E%:9*+R3/&S'E&R&+@%&,+"+%&Q:+@&"*&"IB*'Q$%>9%:+:'*"$$R&$"99%>&

#%@:*>&'+@%E&Q"+%E&I'*I%E*,3--&=*&+@%&$",+&,%P%E"$&>%I">%,J&@'Q%P%EJ&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&@",&

#%9;*&+'&I'*,:>%E&+@%&CE'C%E&C$"I%&('E&:*>:P:>;"$,&"*>&I'&:*&+@%&G%"9"*T!@"+I@%E&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&/&!@:,&('I;,&:,&%P:>%*I%>R&+@%&CE%C'*>%E"*I%&'(&*"+:'*"$&"*>&$'I"$&$"Q,&9'P%E*:*9&Q"+%E&;,"9%J&"*>&+@%&%`C$:I:+&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&+%EE:+'E:"$&:*+%9E:+R&"*>&,'P%E%:9*&,+"+%&C'Q%ER&%"E$R&Q"+%E&'IE%CO("'O5-5O"5710%O"5710%553C>(3&&&&&-5&=*&+@%&>%P%$'C:*9&Q'E$>&+@',%&,';EI%,&*'+&>:E%I+$R&I'*+E'$$%>R&9'P%E*R&CE'(:+T+"B:*9&CE:P"+%&:*>;,+ER&"*>&,%I;E%>&Q:+@&$%9"$&('EI%3&d'P%E*%I:,:'*T%P%$'C%>&+'&&,%I;E:+RX&"*>&%*@"*I%&W:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I''C%E"+:'*X&Y'+@&I'E%&'#[%I+:P%,&'(&+@%&bM&)@"E+%E3&/""(b3&M3&)@"E+%EJ&"E+3-3&

& 0&

%E"3-.&=*+%ET9'P%E*&CE'(%,,:'*"$&'C:*:'*&"$,'&:*:+:"$$R&,;CC'E+%>&

+@:,&C',:+:'*3&!@%&-??.&W2;#$:*&N+"+%&"&;*:c;%&&+'&+@%&C%E:C@%ER&

'(&E%,';EI%&%E*&,R,+%&+'&&@",&@">&>E"E"Q&(E'%*&:,&,@';$>%E%>&&R';*9&9:E$,&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&-.&=+&:,&I'&!@"+I@%E&9'P%E*"#$%&CE:I%3&3&3&3&K"*"9:*9&Q"+%E&",&"*&%I'*'&:,&"*&:&%c;:+"#$%&;,%J&"*>&'(*%*I';E"9:*9&I'*,%EP"+:'*&"*>&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E%,';EI%,3l^3&!@%&+E%"+';#+%>$R&&:*&$:9@+&'(&+@%&%I'*':,I;,,:'*3&&&&&-0&N+%C@%*&)3&KI)"((E%RJ&;(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(>*-"#:0&($28(42:"%2$:0*2$,(4-@,0&$:0*2#.&6]-^&Geo. Intl Envtl. L. Rev.(-J&1&]-??.^3&&&&&&-6&World Health Org. & U. N. Childrens Fund Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and Sanitation, Progress in Drinking-water and Sanitation: Special Focus on Sanitation&].557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3Q@'3:*+OQ"+%Eh,"*:+"+:'*h@%"$+@O

& 6&

Q@'&'(+%*&@'$>&+@%&I;$+;E"$&E%,C'*,:#:$:+R&('E&Q"+%E&I'$$%I+:'*3-7&D$$&I@:$>E%*J&>;%&+'&+@%:E&

>%P%$'CR&]#^&'P%ET%`+E"I+:'*&"*>&

C'$$;+:'*J&]I^&I%E+":*&%*P:E'*3&.5&&

A'$$;+:'*&"*>&'P%ET%`+E"I+:'*&I'*+:*;%&+'&,+E%,,&E%,';EI%&"P":$"#:$:+R&('E&@;&%I'*'&:*>;,+E:"$&CE"I+:I%,J&..&CE:&'P%ET%`C$':+"+:'*&:EE%P%E,:#$R&>%9E">%&"II%,,:#$%J&

E%*%Q"#$%&E%,';EI%,&('E&@;:I+%>&+'&@"P%&"*&%*'E%I:,:'*T&I'*+%*+&,%%&9%*%E"$$R(U.N. Dev. Programme, Human Development Report 1990: The Concept and Measurement of Human Development(]-??5^&Q'E$>J&"9E:I;$+;E%&:,&+@%&CE:&:*&+@%&C'$$;+:'*&'E&'P%ET%`+E"I+:'*&'(&E%,';EI%,&Q%E%&E%,C'*,:#$%&('E&,'>E%,,:*9TP:'$"+:'*,T'(T+@%T@;m.5">>E%,,:*9&]';+$:*:*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&,+E;99$%,&:*P'$P:*9&M%Q&)'*,'EI:'&a:>E'%*%E9p+:I'&>%$&_:+'E"$^&&&&&.0&=+&,@';$>%&*'+%>&+@"+&+@%&Q'E$>&:,&*'+&WE;**:*9&';+&'(&Q"+%EX&:*&"&$:+%E"$&Q"R3&=*&("I+J&+@%&9$'#"$&Q"+%E&,;CC$R&("E&';+Q%:9@,&@;,&'(&+:%*:9E"+:'*&'(&+@',%&"II%,,:#$%J&E%*%Q"#$%&E%,';EI%,&'(&9E';*>&"*>&,;E("I%&Q"+%E&]'(&Q@:I@&@;&>%,%E+:(:I"+:'*3&S'E&"&>:,I;,,:'*&,%%(Peter GleickJ&)"$O(D$:"%.&02&The Worlds Water 2008-2009: The Biennial Report on Freshwater Resources&-J&6&].55?^3&&&&&.6&=*+%ETd'P%E*(O",,%,,

& 1&

$'*9%E&&WQ"+%E&,I"EI%JX&,'I:"$&%P'$;+:'*&"$$'Q%>&('E&+@%&">%c;"+%&

>:,+E:#;+:'*&'(&E%,';EI%,&('E&*%"E$R&6555&R%"E,3./&!'>"RJ&,@'E+"9%&:,&I'Q:*>$%>&'P%E&+@%&$",+&I%*+;ERJ&9$'#"$&Q"+%E&

I'*,;J&"+&"&E"+%&+Q:I%&+@"+&'(&C'C;$"+:'*&9E'Q+@3.7&V"+%E&;,%&:,&

CE'[%I+%>&+'&E:,%R&05m&:*&+@%&*%`+&+Q'&>%I">%,&"$'*%3.?&&

& !@%&@'C%&('E&+@%&:*>:P:>;"$&"+&+@%&@%"E+&'(&WQ"+%EE%";IE"IRX&I':,IE:&$%9"$$R&"II';*+"#$%&Q@%*&+@%R&(":$&+'&%E&"*>&+@%&,+"+%J&"*>&+'&%*,@E:*%&+@:,&+E"*,('E%P%$'C%>&"+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$&Y&%,+"#$:,@:*9&%*+:+$%%c;"+%&('E&+@%&%c;:+"#$%&,"+:,("I+:'*&'(&@;&+@"+&CE:'E&Q"+%E&%&CE'P:,:'*&+'&+@%&C''E&I',+T

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&.1&V"+%E&$:&+'&:*IE%",%&;CQ"E>,&'(&.:$$:'*R&.5653&/""(U. N. Dept of Econ. and Soc. Affairs, The Word at Six Billion,&b3M3&2'I3&LNDOAOVA3-60&]-???^J&@++CHOOQQQ3;*3'E9O%,"OC'C;$"+:'*OC;#$:I"+:'*,O,:`#:$$:'*O,:`#:$$:'*3@+&M"+:'*,&%,+:&$:P%&:*&Q"+%E&,I"EI%&"E%",&'(&$%,,&+@"*&-J555&I;#:I&&('E&"9E:I;$+;E%J&:*>;,+ERJ&%*%E9R&"*>&+@%&%*P:E'*

& /&

CE'@:#:+:P%J&E%,;$+:*9&:*&+@%&::,+E;,+&'(&'$>&>%P%$'C&:*&+@%&I'P%*"*+&%*,@E:*:*9&,:&

:*,+E;%+%E&+E%"+R&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&"$$&

I;EE%*+$R&C':*+&+'Q"E>&+@%&%`:,+%*I%&'(&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+J&;*:P%E,"$&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*&

:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&!@%&&:*&d%*%E"$&

)'%E&+@%&

=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'P%*"*+&'*&LI'*':,+:*9;:,@:*9&%`:9%*+&,+"+%&

'#$:9"+:'*,&(E'%+%E&"&*%Q&('I;,&'*&@;%

& 7&

=*>:P:>;"$,&"*>&I'&>%P%$'C%>&('E&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&+@%:E&>:9*:+R3&!@%&;E9%*IR&'(&

+@%:E&*%%>&:,&CE'P%*R&+@%&,%E:';,*%,,&'(&+@%&@;"E>&Y&>%,C:+%&:+,&*'E'&:*&"*R&+E%"+R34/&!@:,&I'*I%C+;"$&,C"I%&%`:,+,&"$'*9,:>%&

+@%&:*+%ECE%+"+:P%&CE'#$%&:+,&$%9"$&

,+E;I+;E%&+'&'+@%E&";+@'E,347&&!@%&@;:*9&:+,&%'$'9:I"$&,+%E%'+RC:*9&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'&"*&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&+@%&+%I@*:I"$&"*>&[;E:,>:I+:'*"$&:,,;%,&+@"+&Q';$>&C%EO.557h-OQ:*B$%EO3&V:*B$%EU,&E%P:%Q&'(&*"+:'*"$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&+@';9@&$:J&:,&"&@%$C(;$&C$"I%&+'%9:*&"*&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&[;E:,CE;>%*+:"$&,+"*>"E>,&"*>&Q",&,%&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&2%I3&-1J&-?11J&??4&b3M3!3N3&4&e@%E%:*"(+%E&=)LN)Gf3&&&&&47&DI">%&$%9"$&,+E;I+;E%&'(&+E">:+:'*"$J&,+"+%TI%*+E:I&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:*I$;>%&d%+Z$%EU,J@%$&*'+%&-J&a'>9,'*U,J@%$(*'+%&?J&D*+@'*R&NI'++&j&d%'E9:*"&)';,+"$:*J&='"(G?*,6:0*2(*3(D$:"%(!01':#.(46]0^ Nat. Res. J.&7.-&]-??6^J&"*>&P"E:';,&'+@%E&Q'EB,&I'*I%*+E"+:*9&'*&+@%&*"+:'*"$J&E%9:'*"$&'E&I'

& ?&

I'*,+E;I+3&D*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&:*+%E"I+:'*%+Q%%*&>'&"$$'Q&+@%&E%">%E&+'%&:*9&'(&+@%&

E%">%EU,&$%9"$&%*+:+$%:*9&+@%&*'E&+@%&P"E:';,&Q"R,&:*&Q@:I@&:*>:P:>;"$&,+"+%,&"E%';*>&+'&E%,C%I+&

+@%&"$,'&I'%EJ&$"QR%E&'E&[;>9%&Y&:*P'$P%>&:*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&$:+:9"+:'*R&"$$'Q:*9&+@%&

WI'*+%%&(;+;E%&%*('EI%:(:%>&,'I:'T%I'*'%E%>&"&;*:P%E,"$&E:9@+J&+@%&:*+%9E:+R&'(&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&*'E&+@%&I@"$$%*9%&'(&CE'9E%,,:P%&

::(:%>&,'I:'T%I'*'&Q@"+&C;EC',%&>'%,&:+&,%EP%&Q:+@:*&+@%&$"E9%E&

Q"+%E&E:9@+,&C"E">:9H&a'Q&>'&,+"+%,&"II%,,&"*>&CE''%,&+@%&Q'EB&'(&,+"+%,&:*&"CC$R:*9&"*>&:*+%ECE%+:*9&+@%&;*:P%E,"$&@;%E,&]#'+@&"+&@'

& -5&

& S:*"$$RH&a'Q&@"P%&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&+E%"+%>&+@%&;*:P%E,"$&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*&+@%:E&

>'%E,n&a",&E%I%*+&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&

"II%,,%>&'E&:9*'E%>&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>n&=,&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E&Q@"+&Q:$$&+@:,&&===&'(&+@:,&%,,"R&Q:$$&';+$:*%&+@%&$%9"$&*'E&:+,&&I'EE%,C'*>:*9&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,3&!@:,&Q'EB&:,&$"E9%$R&>%,IE:C+:P%J&"&+E">:+:'*"$&

%`%EI:,%&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&I'*,+E;I+:'*&+@"+&"++%E"Q:*9&(E'&>%+%E&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&C'$:+:I"$&>%I$"E"+:'*,J&"9E%%%E$R:*9&:,,;%,J&'E&%P%*&E%$"+%>&E:9@+,&"*>&'#$:9"+:'*,3&V@%E%&

>:,,%*+&%`:,+,J&:+&:,&*'+%>&Q:+@&"*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&+@"+&"&>:P%E,:+R&'(&'C:*:'*&%P%$'C&,:9*:(:I"*+$R3&

N%I+:'*&==&Q:$$&+@%E%('E%&>E"Q&"*%Q&(E'%I$"E"+:'*,&"*>&$%9:,$"+:'*J&,I@'$"E$R&

E:9@+,&I'*,+E;I+:'*,J&+@%&E%C'E+,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&",,'I:"+:'*,J&"*>&+@%&:"3&V@%E%&

*%I%,,"ERJ&+%`+,&Q:$$%&C"E+:"$$R&E%CE'>;I%>3&!@%,%&,';EI%,&Q:$$%&"I">%%&:*&",,%,,:*9&+@:,&$%9"$&%((%I+&"*>&:%E&"$$&E%$%P"*+&$%9"$&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&4?&!@%&(';E&+E">:+:'*"$&,';EI%,&"E%&+"B%*&(E'R&I:P:$:Z%>&*"+:'*,g&>3&,;#[%I+&+'&+@%&CE'P:,:'*,&'(&DE+:I$%&6?J&[;>:I:"$&>%I:,:'*,&"*>&+@%&+%"I@:*9,&'(&+@%&%+%E

& --&

,';EI%,&C%E+":*:*9&+'&+@%&E:9@+3&!@:,&%>&$%9"$&[;,+:(:I"+:'*&

('E&+@%&E:9@+&Y&:*I$;>:*9&"&>%+%E&I'*+%*+&Y&C',,:#$%&@%E%3&

N%I+:'*&===&Q:$$&:*+E'>;I%&+@%&I'*I%C+&'(&"&W&

c;"$:+R&Q:$$&"$,'%&I'*,:>%E%>J&",&+@%,%&%"&'(&Q@"+&"&&+@%&,&+'&'*%&"*'+@%E&"*>&+'&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&

*'E&'*&"&+@%'E%+:I"$&(E":E%I+$R&+E"*,(%EE"#$%3&!@%&E%,%"EI@&:*P'$P%>&:,&c;"$:+"+:P%J&",'+@&+@%&

E%$"+:P%&C";I:+R&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&"*>&+@%&>:P%E,:+R&'(&$%9"$&("I+'E,&

>:((%E%*+:"+:*9&*"+:'*"$&,R,+%&C'$:+:I"$&CE%,,;E%,&%`%E+:*9&:*($;%*I%&'*&

+@%&I';E+U,&Q'EBJ&*'+&+'&

& -.&

+E%"+&E%,%"EI@3&

N%I+:'*&=s&Q:$$%9:*&Q:+@&"&+@%'E%+:I"$&'P%EP:%Q&'(&*'E&('E&

+@%&Q"R&:*&Q@:I@&:+&,;CC'E+,&'E&I@"$$%*9%,&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&*'E%,&CE%C"E%>R&$%9"$&":>&MdF,J&

I'&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&:"3&8%I";,%&$:+:9"+:'*&9;:>%,&"E%&'(+%*&

$:&:*&>%+":$&'E&$"IB&+@%&"+"#",%,&Q:$$&"$,'%&I'*,;$+%>3&)",%&$"Q&Q:$$%&"*"$RZ%>&Q:+@&+@%&@%$C&'(&,%I'*>"ER&

,';EI%,&:*I$;>:*9&$"Q&E%P:%Q,&"*>&I",%E:%(,3&=*&,%P%E"$&C$"I%,J&+@%&'E:9:*"$&$:+:9"+'E,&Q:$$&

#%&",B%>&+'&I'*+E:#;+%RE:%(&'E&,;CC'E+:*9&>'I;J&:+&,%%&'(&CE'+%I+:'*&",&"&,$;Q%$$%E&:*&\'@"**%,#;E93&V%&%(:*:+:'*&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&;I%>&'E&>:,+'E+%>&+@%&

:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>3&&

&

!../*56#*73&('*+%860*01*9(0#"*%'*.'0#"'(0%1'($*:(;%('E%&CE'I%%>:*9&+@"+&+@:,&C"C%E&;,%,&+@%&+%E

& -4&

$",+&@"$(TI%*+;ER3&=*&("I+J&"*&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&+E%"+R&$"Q&E%P%"$,&+@"+&We+f@%E%&"E%&*'t&

:*,+E;&c;"$:+R&Q"+%E&:*&">%c;"+%&,;CC$R&",&"&

(;*>":(:I"+:'*J&@'Q%P%EJ&>'%,&*'+&:'%,&*'+&%`:,+J&*'E&+@"+&:+&:,&;*"IB*'Q$%>9%>&'E&;*CE'+%I+%>R&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&:*&,'&

+@"+'+@&:+,&*'E&E%$"+%>&'#$:9"+:'*,&I"*%&';+$:*%>&:*>%C%*>%*+$R&'(&

'+@%E&E:9@+,3&!@:,&:,&+@%&Q'EB&'(&+@:,&,%I+:'*3&!@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&';+$:*%>%$'Q&+@E';9@&

+@%&+E">:+:'*"$&"I+:P:+R&'(&$%9"$&I'*,+E;I+:'*g&+@%&E:9@+U,&:*+%$$%I+;"$&'E:9:*&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&

E%$"+:'*,J&",&Q%$$&",&:+,&$%9"$",:,J&,I'C%&"*>&'#$:9"+:'*,&"E%&I'%,&@"P%&,%%*&+@%&,+E;99$%&'(&+@%&'CCE%,,%>&

'E&*%9$%I+%>&E%('E,&@;%*+:+R&('E&"&I$":,&'(&+@%&b*:P%E,"$&2%I$"E"+:'*&'(&a;&'(&+@%&%c;"$&"*>&:*"$:%*"#$%&E:9@+,&'(&"$$&:+:'*"$&I:P:$&$"Q&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&Y&+@',%&,+"+%T9E"*+%>&E:9@+,&('E&+@%&;,%&'(&E%,';EI%,&+'&,&+'%&,O(,?3C>(&CE'P:>%&9E%"+%E&I$"E:+R&"*>&I'*,:,+%*IR&:*&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*J&$%">:*9&+'&9E%"+%E&N+"+%&I'&I$%"E%E&I'

& -0&

+@%&@;&+@%&I$":;I+:'*3&

!@%&E%I%C+:P%*%,,&'(&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'",%9"*&+'&E%($%I+&9E'Q:*9&I'*I%E*&('E&Q"+%E&:,,;%,&:*&+@%&T-?/5,30/&8R&

+@%&%"E$R&.555,J&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&('I;,&'*&Q"+%E%9"*&+'&,@:(+&(E'&$"*9;"9%&",&+@%R&,@:(+&+'&E%($%I+&

+@:,&9E'Q:*9&I'*,%*,;,30?&

N%P%E"$&+RC%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>'I;&%>3J&.55?^3*&&&&0/&/""(D,:+&i3&8:,Q",J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':(02(:'"(9GE;(!"10*2R(A'$,,"21"#($28(W@@*%:620:0"#.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&.5?J&.--&].55/^&e@%E%:*"(+%E&8:,Q",&9GE;fg&D,:+&8:,Q",&j&)%I:$:"&!'E+"[">"J&A'$21021(F,*+$,(D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(C$28#&$@".&02&Water Management in 2020 and Beyond&-J&-5&]D3i3&8:,Q",&%+&"$3&%>,3J&.551^3&&&&&07&b*+:$&E%$%",%&'(&+@%&.551&a;%%$T"TI'*P%E,"+:'*TQ:+@T+@%T*%QTI@":ET'(T;*TQ"+%EOu&>':*9&E%,%"EI@J+&+'&E%$"+%&:+&+'&C%'C$%U,&$:P%,&"*>&+'&E%$"+%&:+&+'&C'$:I:%,&:,&,'R"&=P"*'P"&j&D"E'*&\"((%J&D$:"%(=*@#(A,0-$:"(A'$21"($#(F,*+$,()%0*%0:7J&Circle of Blue&]D;93&-7J&.55?^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I:EI$%'(#$;%3'E9OQ"+%E*%Q,O.55?OQ'E$>OQ"+%EP:%Q,TQ"+%ET+'C,TI$:

& -6&

#';*>R&$"Q&+'&(;$(:$$3&!@%R&"E%J&+@%E%('E%J&+@%&:*9&$"Q&>%P%$'C%>'+@&Q:+@:*&"*>&';+,:>%&'(&+@%&

b3M3&,R,+%%&",&:*+%ECE%+"+:P%&9;:>%,&Q:+@&E%,C%I+&+'&,+"+%,U&+E%"+R&

'#$:9"+:'*,365&S:*"$$RJ&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I;,+'>E%,,%>&@%E%3&!@%,%&:*I$;>%&E%9:'*"$&@;%I$"E"+:'*,&%P%$'C:*9&

'#,%EP"+:'*,&'(&+@%&)LN)G36-&

N%P%E"$&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&+E%"+:%,&Y&+@%&;+:%,&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&!@%:E&>%(:*:+:'*,J&@'Q%P%EJ&("$$&,@'E+&'(&

CE'+%I+:*9&Q"+%E&E%,';EI%&">%c;"IRJ&c;"$:+R&'E&"II%,,:#:$:+R3&DE+:I$%&-0&'(&+@%&)'*P%*+:'*&

('E&+@%&L$:%c;"+%&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E364&!@%&

b3M3&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&_"Q&'(&+@%&M'*TM"P:9"+:'*"$&b,%,&'(&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&V"+%E&)';E,%,J60&

+@';9@&*'+&:*&%((%I+J&",,%E+,&+@%&CE:'E:+R&'(&WP:+"$&@;&A"+E:I:"&V';+%E,J&\20?"%#$,($28(!"10*2$,(;@@%*$&'"#(:*(!"#*,?021(42:"%2$:0*2$,(>0#@6:"#R(D'$:(C"##*2#(C"$%2"8(3%*-(/:$:"()%$&:0&"_(02&Resolution of International Water Disputes&---&]=*+%E*"+:'*"$&8;E%";J&A%E:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,&"E%&:*I$;>%>&:*&N%I+:'*&=s&","IB9E';*>&:*('E&+@%E%&+'&CE'+%I+&"&E:9@+&+'&:*>:P:>;"$&"II%,,3&/""(BourquainJ@%$&*'+%&4J&65T60g&i:%(%E&j&8Ek$

& -1&

2:,"#:$:+:%,&';+$:*%,&W+@%&E:9@+&'(&C%E,'*,&Q:+@&>:,"#:$:+:%,&+'&,'I:"$&CE'+%I+:'*&3&3&3&:*I$;>:*9&

&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,3&!@%&d%*%P"&

)'*P%*+:'*,&Y&"$&I:P:$:"*,&

"E%&9;"E"*+%%>&Q"+%E&('E&I'*,;J&

'#$:9%,&C"E+:%,&*'+&+'&"++"IB&'E&>%,+E'R&W'#[%I+,&:*>:,C%*,:#$%&+'&+@%&,;EP:P"$&'(&+@%&I:P:$:"*&

C'C;$"+:'*&3&3&3&e:*I$;>:*9f&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&,;CC$:%,3X67&6?&!@%&N+"*>"E>&K:*:&'(&+@%:E&_:#%E+R&]-??5^J'+@&%*,;E%&+@"+&We>fE:*B:*9&Q"+%E&,@"$$%&

"P":$"#$%&+'&%P%ER&CE:,'*%E&Q@%*%P%E&@%&*%%>,&:+3X15&

N:*I%&+@%&-?/5,J&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&@;%I$"E"+:'*,J&E%,'$;+:'*,&"*>&"9E%%:*9J&+@%,%&>%I$"E"+:'*,&,%EP%&",&%P:>%*I%&'(&,+"+%&CE"I+:I%&"*>&I"*&:*>:I"+%&"&

,+"+%U,&'Q*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&:+,&$%9"$&'#$:9"+:'*,3&!@%&s"*I';P%E&2%I$"E"+:'*&(E''C+:'*&'(&C'$:I:%,&Q:+@&WE%",'*"#$%&,+"*>"E>,&('E&c;"$:+R&

"*>&c;"*+:+R3X1-&!@%&K"E&>%$&A$"+"&DI+:'*&A$"*&(E'&AE':+:'*"$&+'&+@%&d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*,&'(&-.&D;9;,+&-?0?J&"*>&G%$"+:*9&+'&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&s:I+:%&"P":$"#$%&+'&%P%ER&[;P%*:$%&"+&"*R&+:&M"+:'*,&)'*9E%,,&'*&+@%&AE%P%*+:'*&'(&)E:'I;

& -/&

+'&@"P%&"II%,,&+'&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&:*&c;"*+:+:%,&"*>&'(&"&c;"$:+R&%c;"$&+'&+@%:E",:I&*%%>3X1.&

D(+%E&+@:,&>%I$"E"+:'*J&+@%&",,%E+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,%I"&"9E%%&2%P%$'C%>&Q"+%E&"%c;"+%&,+"*>"E>&'(&$:P:*93X16&S:*"$$RJ&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&@",&(';*>&,;CC'E+&:*&(';E&E%I%*+&

>%P%$'C%P%$'C%>&:*&+@%,%&>%I$"E"+:'*,&Q",&(:E,+&">'C+%>R&+@%&

b3M3&,R,+%9%,&+@"+&WE:9@+,&+'&(''>&"*>&I$%"*&Q"+%E&"E%&(;*>"&('E&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'".-O3&&&&&&16&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&A'C;$"+:'*&"*>&2%P%$'C&N';+@&D,:"*&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&N"*:+"+:'*J&M%Q&2%$@:J&=*>:"J&M'P3&-1T.-J&.557J&='"(>",'0(>"&,$%$:0*2J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOO>>Q,3*:I3:*O:*(',"I',"*OCC+O2%$@:m.52%I$"E"+:'*m.5/3C>(3&]W"II%,,&+'&,"(%&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&I'*,+:+;+%,&"",:I&@;,&'(&N+"+%&"*>&d'P%E*&K'P%%(";$+3",C`&]P:"&W(:*"$&>'I;&+'&",,:,+&>%P%$'C:*9&I';*+E:%,&:*&+@%:E&%(('E+,&+'&3&3&3&CE'P:>%&"II%,,&+'&,"(%&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&"*>",:I&,"*:+"+:'*X&Q@:$%&E%I"$$:*9&+@%&"IB*'Q$%>9%&"9%*I:%,3&!@%E%&"E%&I;EE%*+$R&.1&bM&'((:I%,&Q'EB:*9&'*&+@%&

& -7&

,:%I">%3&

&D(+%E&+@%&.555&d%*%E"$&D,,%9:*9&WE:9@+,&+'&Q"+%EX&:*&+@E%%&C$"I%,3/.&!@%&b3M3&N;#T)'%$:*%,&('E&+@%&G%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&

G:9@+&+'&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*X&+@%&,"&I$"E:(R:*9&+@%&

I'*I$;,:'*,&'(&'+@%E'>:%,J&&"&E%C'E+&WF*&+@%&NI'C%&"*>&)'*+%*+&'(&+@%&G%$%P"*+&

a;%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*&+E"*,&"&E%C'E+&+'&+@%&bM&d%*%E"$&D,,%%,IE:#%>&+@%&+Q'&",&WI'*,:,+%*+&"*>&%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;%&D$#;c;%Ec;%^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O:,,;%,OQ"+%EO:%`C%E+O"**;"$3@+P%E,%&L((%I+,&'(&+@%&=$$:I:+&K'P:*9&"*>&2;;I+,&"*>&V",+%,&'*&+@%&L*['R&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,&"*>&+@%&G:9@+&+'&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&N;CC$R&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&>%$3:(F608",02"#(3*%(:'"(!"$,0Q$:0*2(*3(:'"(!01':(:*(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2J&b3M3&N;#TI'&:*+%*+J""&COHRE(c)J@%$(*'+%&65J&"+&.00T.653&&&&&/0&b3&M3&a:9@&)'

& -?&

+'&Ib(;E+@%E&eI$"E:(Rf&+@%&I'*+%*+&'(&@;&+@%&

aG)&]:*&d%*%P"^&+'&>%+%E&,"*:+"+:'*3&G%I%*+&

,&>%P%$'C%>&

#R&+@%&)LN)G&:*&d%*%E"$&)'"*9%E';,&>:,+E"I+:'*&(E'%,C:+%&:+,&P"9;%&$"*9;"9%3/7&!@%&=*>%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+&@%E,%$(&>%,IE:#%>&10O.?.&",&"&

W#E%"B+@E';9@3X/?&

!@%&('$$'Q:*9&N%C+%UD$#;c;%Ec;%J&:,&'*9':*93&S'E&"&CE%$:%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;&N"*:+"+:'*J&d3D3&G%,3&10O.?.J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO10O.?.&&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^3&*&&&&//&483&"+&q73&&&&&/7&K"*R&'(&+@%&0-&,+"+%,&"#,+":*:*9&(E'&,"*:+"+:'*&@%%$:%P%>&*'+&+'&%`:,+&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&F+@%E,J&:*I$;>:*9&d%E%>&s'+%&'(&-..&:*&S"P'EJ&M'*%&D9":*,+J&0-&D#,+%*+:'*,g&2%$%9"+%,&"$,'&)'*(:E,3;*3'E9O!KAO?410453-/--4.5773@+

& .5&

:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q37-&G%,'$;+:'*&66O_3-0&I'*I$;>%,&+@"+&We+f@%&a;E:*B:*9&

Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&>%E:P%>&(E'&'(&C@R,:I"$&"*>&&:+,%$(&('E&+@%&'((:I:"$&C'$:I:%,&'(&>:P%E,%&*'*T,+"+%&"I+'E,37/&

!@:,&:*IE%",:*9&"IB*'Q$%>9%&C'+"#$%&Q"+%E&Q:+@&%`C$:I:+&E%(%E%*I%&+'&+@%&,+"*>"E>,&'(&"P":$"#:$:+RJ&"II%,,:#:$:+RJ&"II%C+"#:$:+R&"*>&c;"$:+R&,%+R&+@%&)LN)G&:*&d%*%E"$&)'+P3I'+Ph%*O*,h,"O.5-5T54T.4O451.16.6-.-03@+%02O021(D$:"%($#($(B$#0&(S6-$2(!01':.&German Information Centre New Delhi&]K"E3&.4J&.5-5^J&@++CHOO9%E%(:*:+:'*&CE'

& .-&

:*+%E*"+:'*"$&'E9"*:Z"+:'*377&!@:,&Q';$>&,%%J&+'&"&,9'I;%P'+%>&+'&W+@%&

G:9@+&'(&DII%,,&+'&V"+%E3X&);,+'&+'&

:*>%C%*>%*+$R&CE'+%I+&"&@;$RJ&+@%&:>%"&

'(&"&@;%E&+@%&>%P%$'C%I$"E%>&+@"+&:+&>'%,&*'+%$:%P%&,;I@&"&E:9@+&+'&%`:,+&:*&"*R&Q"R3?4&&

&

B"302021(:'"(C"1$,(/*6%&"(*3($(!01':(:*(D$:"%(

&

& D$+@';9@&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I''&,'J&$:B%&+@',%&'(&A%+%E&d$%:IBJ%9"*R&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&77&COHRE(a), #6@%$&*'+%&07J&"+&.T43&&&&&7?&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&I;,+'&I'*($:I+%+Q%%*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"*>&MDS!D3&2%C%*>:*9&'*&+@%&9$'#"$&CE%P"$%*I%&'(&,;I@&"&C',:+:'*J&+@%&>%P%$'C'%,&*'+&"II%C+&+@"+&+@%E%&:,&"&E:9@+&+'&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*3UX^3&)"*">"U,&'((:I:"$&C',:+:'*&%*I%>R&+@%:E&P'+%&'(&"#,+%*+:'*&E%9"E>:*9&+@%&.5-5&d%*%E"$&D,,%&,"*:+"+:'*J@%$&*'+%&/13&N+:$$&)"*">"U,&E%CE%,%*+"+:P%&:*,:,+%>&'*&+@"+&'II",:'*&+@"+&*'&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&@">%%*&E%"I@%>&'*&+@%&:,,;%3&/""&N+"+%"&+'&+@%&b3M3&d%*%E"$&D,,%

& ..&

I'*,:>%E:*9&+@%&*+,01$:0*2#&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3?0&!@%,%&,'&

%*>%"P'E,&":&"+&"*,Q%E:*9&c;%,+:'*,&"#';+&+@%&,I'C%&'(&,;I@&"&E:9@+J&:*I$;>:*9&@'Q&

&('E&Q@"+&C;EC',%,3&D++%&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,&"E9;&8Ek$%C%*>%*+&

E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&"&>%E:P"+:P%&'(&,+"+%,U*&0*^"&*2*-0&&E:9@+,&'#$:9"+:'*,3&=+&:,&(E'&

,%I;E:+R&'(&+@%&C%E,'*3X?/&V"+%E&:,&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&%*,@E:*%>&:*&+@%&2%I$"E"+:'*J&+@';9@&

DE+:I$%&.6&*'+%,&+@"+&We%fP%ER'*%&@",&+@%&E:9@+&+'&"&,+"*>"E>&'(&$:P:*9&">%c;"+%&('E&+@%&

@%"$+@&"*>&Q%$$T#%:*9&'(&@:J&I$'+@:*9J&@';,:*9&"*>&

:I"$&I"E%&"*>&*%I%,,"ER&,'I:"$&,%EP:I%,3X?7&!@%&*'*T#:*>:*9&E:9@+,&%*,@E:*%>&:*&+@%&

b2aG&Q%E%&,C$:+&:*+'&+Q'&I'P%*"*+,J&'*%&CE'+%I+:*9&I:P:$&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,&]=))AG^&"*>&

+@%&'+@%EJ&,'I:'T%I'*'%CE:P%>&'(&:+,&'Q*&&"E9;%&('E'+@&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*,3&!@%&

'E:9:*&",,%E+%>&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I"*&@"P%&"&$"E9%&:%E:P%>3&&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&?0&/""&1"2"%$,,R&d$%:IBJ&!01':(:*(D$:"%J@%$(*'+%&0.3(&&&&?6&/6@%$(*'+%&/3&&&&&?1&/""(D*+'*:'&L3&=E;['J&='"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&.1/&].55/^3&&&&&?/&b2aGJ@%$(*'+%&06J&"+&"E+3&43&&&&&?7&48:,+:*I+:'*&Q",&$"E9%$R&'*%&I";,%>R&)'$>&V"E&C'$:+:I,3&!@%&E:9@+,&:*&+@%&b2aG&Q%E%&I'*,:>%E%>&+'&@"P%&*'&P"$;%&E%$"+:P%&+'&%"I@&'+@%EJ&R%+&:*"+%>&,'I:"$&"*>&%I'*':+:'*&('E&+@%&(;$$&E%"$:,"+:'*&e,:If&'(&,%P%E"$&'(&+@%&E:9@+,&%`C$:I:+$R&9;"E"*+%%>&;*>%E&+@%&=))AG&"*>&+@%&=)LN)G3X^3&&&&&-5-&D+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$J&,;I@&",&:*&+@%&:*+%ETD

& .4&

=(&'*%&>%E:P%,&"&;*:P%E,"$&@;&A%E:'>:I&G%C'E+&:*&.5-53-5/&S'E&+@%&(:E,+&+:R&@%$>&+@%&>%*:"$&'(&Q"+%E&+'%&"&P:'$"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+,&+'&$:(%&"*>&%c;"$&

CE'+%I+:'*&;*>%E&+@%&$"Q3-57&=+&:,&:&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&"E+3&1J&2%I3&-1J&-?11J&???&b3M3!3N3&-/-3&e@%E%:*"(+%E&=))AGf3&&&&&-54&N;,"*&K'$$%E&FB:*J&C0+"%:7($28(D",3$%"R(/*-"(4##6"#(02(S6-$2(!01':#(='"*%7.&02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.45J&.4/&]\3&G'$"*>&A%**'IB&j&\'@*&V3&)@"C%,&C',:+:P%&'#$:9"+:'*,J&+@%&%,,%*I%&'(&=))AG&"E+3&1&,%%$R&I'*,:,+&:*&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&+@%&%01':(+'&$:(%&:+,%$(J&*'+&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'E&IE%"+:'*&'(&+@%&I:EI;3&!@:,&,%I'*>&+",B&:,&&:*&K%$:,@J@%$(*'+%&463&&&&&-51&i:%(%E&j&8Ek$&A%E:'>:I&G%C'E+&'(&=,E"%$&>;%&:*&.55/J&b3M3&2'I3J&))AGO)O=NGO4&]M'P3&.-J&.557^J&"+&@++CHOO>"II%,,T>>,T*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd57O066O?5OA2SOd57066?53C>(nFC%*L$%&Q:+@&=))AG&%*('EI%:*9&'#,%EP"+:'*,&E%c;:E%,&,;#+$%&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*3&D&WE%I'%&Q:+@&%`C$:I:+&E%(%E%*I%&+'&"*&=))AG&"E+:I$%&+@E';9@&C"E%*+@%+:I"$&I:+"+:'*&"+&+@%&I'*I$;,:'*&'(&+@%&'#,%EP"+:'*&C"E"9E"C@3&D$+@';9@&+@%&)'%c;"+%$R&'#,%EP%>3&=*&:+,&'#,%EP"+:'*,&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&"II%,,J&+@%&)'$R3&/""()'>,T*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd-5O007O51OA2SOd-5007513C>(nFC%*L$%%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&$%9"$&c;%,+:'*,&"+&@"*>&I"*%&(';*>R&E%">:*9&+@%&W_:,+&'(&=,,;%,3X&/""&)':I&G%C'E+&'(&=,E"%$&]D>P"*I%&s%E,:'*^J&b3M3&2'I3())AGO)O=NGO|O4&]M'P3&-/J&.55?^J("+(@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,O@EIO>'I,OD>P"*I%s%E,:'*,O))AGT)T=NGT|43C>(3&

& .0&

Q"+%E&>%E:P%>&(E'%,+E;I+:'*&'(&

%`:,+:*9&:*(E",+E;I+;E%^&'E&'028"%"8&]%`3&+@E';9@&E%,+E:I+:'*&'(&+@%&,&"*>&

C%'C$%&%,,%*+:"$&+'&Q"+%E&CE'P:,:'*&'E&:*(E",+E;I+;E"$&:';#+(;$&Q@%+@%E&+@%&)'%('E%&+@%'>R3&!@:,&:,%I";,%&"$+@';9@&+@%&)'%E,+"*>:*9&Q:+@&+@%&,+"+%R&a;&'(&+E%"+R&%*('EI%:((%E:*9&"I">%:I+:'*"$&E%,+E:I+:'*3&/"".("&[;,+:(R&Q@R&+@%R&@"P%*U+&>'*%&,'3&/""()''I;>,T*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd??O050O.0OC>(Od??050.03C>(nFC%*L$%

& .6&

CE'+%I+:'*&"*>&(;$(:$$&

E:9@+,&:*&--].^--1&"*>&-.]-^--/&=)LN)G3--7&DE+:I$%&--]-^&E%">,J&

(

e+f@%&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,&+'&+@%&CE%,%*+&)'P%*"*+&E%I'9*:Z%&+@%&E:9@+&'(&%P%ER'*%&+'&"*&">%c;"+%&,+"*>"E>&'(&$:P:*9&('E&@:J&I$'+@:*9&"*>&@';,:*9J&"*>&+'&+@%&I'*+:*;';,&:&'(&$:P:*9X&

CE'+%I+%>R&DE+:I$%&--]-^&&"E';*>&"&I'E%&

C@E",%J&Q@:I@&('E&DE+:I$%&.6&Q",&+@%&E:9@+&+'&W,%I;E:+R&:*&+@%&%P%*+&'(&;*%&'*+'&+@%&(E'*+&'(&+@:,&I'E%&CE'P:,:'*R&

,%P%E"$&_"+:*&D&CE'+%I+%>&(E'%$%+:'*R&)@:*"3&N'I:"$&,%I;E:+R&Q",&

+@%&('I;,&'(&DE+:I$%&.6J&*'+&"&>%$:&W:*I$;>:*93X&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&--0&!@%&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'J&U%*-(>0?0#0*2(:*(42:"1%$:0*2R(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#($#(B$#0&(S6-$2(!01':#.&02&Giving Meaning to Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights&4?J&4?&]=,("@"*&K%E"$:&j&s"$%E:%&F',+%EP%$>&%>,3J&.55-^g&K%$:,@J@%$(*'+%&46J&"+&A"E+&===D3&/""($,#*(i:%(%E&j&8Ek$:I@'+'%$R&I'*,:>%E%>&"*&;*>;$R&*"EE'Q&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&*"+;E%&'(&+@%,%&E:9@+,&"*>&I'EE%,C'*>:*9&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,3X^&&&&&--1&=)LN)GJ@%$&*'+%&4/J&"+&"E+3&--].^&]W!@%&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,&+'&+@%&CE%,%*+&)'P%*"*+J&E%I'9*:Z:*9&+@%&(;*>""E>&'(&C@R,:I"$&"*>&:+:'*"$&%`%EI:,%&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&I'*,+E;I+:'*&e>%

& .1&

!@%&%E&+'&",,:,+&"*>&CE'E"(+:*9&d%*%E"$&)''&

,'R&+@%&LI'*':*9J&"*>&",&,;I@J&&,;CC'E+&('E&"$$&'(&+@%:E&

I'*I$;,:'*,&Q:+@:*&+@%&"II%C+%>&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&%"I@&E:9@+&+'&Q@:I@&+@%R&C%E+":*3&!@%R&%(:*%,&+@%&*'E&]>^&%,+"#$:,@%,&9;:>%$:*%,&('E&,+"+%&"I+:'*&:*&+@%&E%"$&

"(('E>"#$%&Q"+%E&('E&C%E,'*"$&"*>&>'%,&+@%&CE%P%*+:'*&'(&>%"+@&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&-.-&!@%&C;EC',%&'(&"&9%*%E"$&I''I;>,T*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd7?O-/7O-?OC>(Od7?-/7-?3C>(nFC%*L$%

& ./&

(E'%@R>E"+:'*J&+@%&"P':>"*I%&'(&>:,%",%J&"*>&Q"+%E&('E&C%E,'*"$&I'*,;&@R9:%*%3&!@%&%$%&@%"$+@JX&Q@:I@&:,&+'&,"R&+@"+&+@%&(;$$&,I'C%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&:,E'">%E&

+@"*&'%,&%c;"$:+R&'(&'CC'E+;*:+R&('E&C%'C$%&+'&%*['R&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3-./&

& &

L"I@&%$%%(:*:+:'*3-.7&LM(%$(H%$%0)&E%(%E,&+'&

W,;((:I:%*+&"*>&E%9;$"EX&c;"*+:+:%,&('E&C%E,'*"$&;,%J&",",%>&:*&+@',%&9;:>%$:*%,&('E&@;%P%$'C%>R&+@%&V'E$>&a%"$+@&FE9"*:Z"+:'*J+&+":$'E%>&+'&$'I"$&I'*+%`+,3-.?&=*&

N3($%0)J&Q"+%E&,@';$>%&(E%%&'(&I'*+"&*'+&*%9"+:P%$R&:&CE'`:"#:$:+R3X&LCC1"2(H$#&Q"+%E&,@';$>&

*'+&I'J&@';,:*9^3&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&-.1&d)-6J@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q--3&!@%&"CCE'"I@&+'&(;$(:$$:*9&+@%&E:9@+U,&(;$$&,I'C%&]",&,;CC'E+:*9&@;,&'(&"II%,,:#:$:+RJ&"(('E>"#:$:+RJ&"II%C+"#:$:+R&"*>&c;"$:+R&Q%E%&'E:9:*"$$R&>%P%$'C%>R&+@%&)LN)G&:*&+@%&I'*+%`+&'(&"II%,,&+'&@%"$+@&I"E%3&/""(1"2"%$,,7(d)-0J@%$&*'+%&763(&&&&-.?&d)-6&]#6@%$&*'+%&44&"+&q-.^&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%,&Guy Howard & Jamie Bertram, World Health Organization, Domestic Water Quantity, Service Level and Health&].554^3&&&&&&-45&d)-6J@%$&*'+%&44J&"+(q-.]#^3&!@%&=*>%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+U,&%`C$"*"+:'*J&+@';9@&+''E'">&+'%&,;:+"#$%&('E&+@%&,"1$,&>%(:*:+:'*J&:,&@%$C(;$&:*&I$"E:(R:*9&E%c;:E%&N"*:+"+:'*J(c6"#:0*22$0%"R(VF**8()%$&:0&"#L(%",$:"8(:*(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2(]S%#3&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O:,,;%,OQ"+%EO=%`C%E+O:*>%`3@+&AE"I+:I%,&|;%,+:'**":E%&T&L*9$:,@X&@RC%E$:*B^3&&&&&-4-&d)-6J@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q-.]I^:T:::3&

& .7&

S'E&,'"#:$:+R&&+@"+&+@%R&"E%&

6#63%6&:*%7&E:9@+,&Y&$:&+'&;,%,&+@"+&>'&*'+&Q",+%J&>%,+E'R&'E&(;$$R&%`C$':+&"P":$"#$%&

E%,';EI%,3-44& &

& !@%&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&,+%&36,30,,;"$,&:P:>;"$,&:*I"C"#$%&'(&E%"$:Z:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+@%%,:9*"+%&

E%,C'*,:#:$:+:%,J&"*>&Q@%*&P:'$"+:'*,&,;E("I%J&CE'P:>%&%((%I+:P%&E%R'+@&*"+:'*"$$R&"*>&

:*+%E*"+:'*"$$R3-4?&M"+:'*"$&:*,+:+;+:'*,&,@';$>%&E%,C'*,:P%&+'&@;&

"II';*+"#$%&+'&,+"B%@'$>%E,3&

& d%*%E"$&CE:*I:C$%,&'(&$"QJ&+@%&(';E+@&:*+%ECE%+"+:P%&,';EI%&(E'&:,",%>&'*&%"E$:%E&:>%",R&N@;%J&/""(H. Shue, Basic Rights, Subsistence, Affluence and U.S. Foreign Policy,&-7T66&]-?75^3&L:>%&(:E,+&%%c;"+%&S''>J&='"(!01':(:*(;8"56$:"(U**8($#($(S6-$2(!01':.(b3M3&N;#TI'&b2aGJ@%$&*'+%&06J&"+&"E+3&.]-^3&_:B%Q:,%J&+@%&=)LN)G&'#$:9%,&,+"+%,&C"E+:%,&W+'&9;"E"*+%%&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+,&%*;*I:"+%>&:*&+@%&CE%,%*+&)'P%*"*+&Q:$$%&%`%EI:,%>&Q:+@';+&>:,IE:&",&+'&E"I%J&I'$';EJ&,%`J&$"*9;"9%J&E%$:9:'*J&

& .?&

W"II%,,:#:$:+RX&"*>&"*&W:&IE',,TI;++:*9&'#$:9"+:'*X&:*I;JCC#40%M#*"#)J&@",&+Q'&I''%(:*%,&+@%&C"E"%E&Q@:I@&"*&%((%I+:P%&E%R&:,&CE'C%E$R&

%*['R%>3&Lc;"$:+R&:*I$;>%,&"&>;"$&9;"E"*+%%&'(&%c;"$&"*>&%((%I+:P%&CE'+%I+:'*%('E%&"*>&

;*>%E&+@%&$"Q3-06&=+&:,&:%EJX-01&"*>&We+f@%&E:9@+&+'&"*&%((%I+:P%&E%R&*%%>&*'+%&:*+%ECE%+%>&",&"$Q"R,&

E%c;:E:*9&"&[;>:I:"$&E%R3X-0/&D&@;'%,&*'+&*%I%,,"E:$R&:*I$;>%&"&E:9@+&+'&>%(%*>&'*%U,&%*+:+$%R&"*&"E9;E%,,&Q';$>%&W:*"CCE'CE:"+%X&

'E&W;**%I%,,"ERX&Y&"*&%,C%I:"$$R&>:((:I;$+&+",B&Q@%*&'*%&"IB*'Q$%>9%,&+@"+&%E%>&+@%&*"+;E%&'(&*'*T>:,IE:&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&q/J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.Od)O.5&]\;*%&-5J&.55?^J&"+&QQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,OI%,IEO>'I,O9IOL3)3-.3d)3.53>'I3&&&&&-0.&!@';9@'+@&I'%;"$&*"+;E%&'(&$%9"$&%c;"$:+R&I'&Q",&*'+&E%:+%E"+%>&:*&+@%&=)LN)GJ&Q@:I@&'*$R&"IB*'Q$%>9%,&W+@%&%c;"$&"*>&:*"$:%*"#$%&E:9@+,&'(&"$$X&]=)LN)G.(#6@%$&*'+%&4/J&"+&WAE%"&@",%%*&",,%E+%>R&+@%&))AGJ&@'Q%P%EJ&+'&WI'*,+:+;+%&"",:I&"*>&9%*%E"$&CE:*I:C$%&E%$"+:*9&+'&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&@;&+@%E%('E%&"CC$:%,&%c;"$$R&+'&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'

& 45&

[;>:I:"$&E%:%,&Q';$>%&E%*>%E%>&:*%((%I+:P%&Q:+@';+&$%9"$&E%:*('EI%%&"*&'#$:9"+:'*&+'&%*,;E%&"+&$%",+&

,'%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&:+,%$(J&+@"+&:+:';,$R&"*>&%((%I+:P%$R&",&C',,:#$%&+'Q"E>&+@%&(;$$&'#,%EP"*I%&'(&+E%"+R&'#$:9"+:'*,J&

:*I$;>:*9&+@%&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&@;;+R&:,&c;"$:(:%>J&@'Q%P%EJR&"&

E%,';EI%&W$''C@'$%X&>:E%I+$R&%*,@E:*%>&:*&DE+:I$%&.]-^&=)LN)G3&&

&eD&,+"+%&'C+:'*&'(&$%9:,$"+:P%&:P:>;"$,&Q:+@:*&:+,&+%EE:+'ER&"*>&,;#[%I+&+'&:+,&[;E:,>:I+:'*X&+@%&E:9@+,&:+&%*,@E:*%,J&+@%&

=)LN)G&'*$R&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&"&,+"+%&W+"B%&,+%C,X&+'&CE'P:>%&('E&E:9@+,TCE'+%I+:'*&",%,+&:+&I"*&

:*&+@%&CE%P":$:*9&I:EI;%9E%%&C',,:#$%&"+&"*R&9:P%*&

"*I%&'(&"*R&>%$:#%E"+%$R&E%+E'9E%,,:P%&%"&"IB*'Q$%>9%,&+@%&%*'E%&,;#[%I+&:&%>^3&&&&&-6.&GorsbothJ@%$&*'+%&.4J&"+&/&]%>%>^3&

& 4-&

+@%:E&:9%>&"E%&,'&,;#[%I+:P%&+@"+&+@%R&'(+%*&"$$'Q&

)'*P%*+:'*&CE'+%I+:'*,&+'%&%((%I+:P%$R&*;$$:(:%>3-64&!@:,&E''RJ&+@%&)LN)G3-60&LP%*&

Q@%*&"#$%&+'&E%,C'*>&+'&"*&',+%*,:#$%&P:'$"+:'*J&+@%&$"E9%&""+"&E%c;:E%>&Y&

:*I$;>:*9&+@%&"#:$:+R&+'&,+"+:,+:I"$$R&"*"$RZ%&:+&Y&&

%E,+''>&>:&+@%&"#,'$;+%&&Q@"+&

"I+:'*,&Y&+@';9@&,+:$$&E%c;:E%>&Y&%(%EE%>&+'Q"E>&+@%&CE'9E%,,:P%&

::I&E%P:%Q&'(&,+"+%&,;#&"(+%E&+@%:E&I$"E:(:I"+:'*&:*&d)-63&

& 4.&

!.../*?'2#"-0('2%'8*06#*@A%'%&3&*>1"#B*C1"*9(0#"*

&

;&,;CC'E+&(E'%9E%%,&'(&E:9@+,&(;$(:$$%9E%%,&:,&"&>%(:*"#$%J",:I&

+@E%,@'$>&Y&'E&('E&';E&C;EC',%,J&"&&(E'%%>&+@%&E":,'*&>x}+E%J&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+&Q@:I@&:,&+'&%,+"#$:,@&I$%"E&'#$:9"+:'*,&('E&N+"+%,&C"E+:%,&:*&E%,C%I+&'(&+@%&(;$$&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+,&:*&c;%,+:'*3&=+&+@;,&::+:';,$R&"*>&%((%I+:P%$R&",&C',,:#$%&+'Q"E>,&+@"+&9'"$3-1-&&(

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&-67&A@:$:C&D$,+'*&:,&,'&Q:+@&+@%&>%P%$'C%,IE:#%>&"*>&>%P%$'C%>&:*&+@:,&N%I+:'*3&/""(A@:$:C&D$,+'*J&W6:(*3(:'"(;+7##R(:'"(A'$,,"21"#(A*23%*2:021(:'"(E"H(\&Q:>%,CE%">&,;CC'E+&:*'+@&+@%&DI">%'%,&*'+&,:9*"$&"&I'*I%C+U,&$%9"$&*'*T%`:,+%*I%3&/""(i"+@"E:*%&d3&~';*9J&='"(9020-6-(A*%"(*3(G&*2*-0&($28(/*&0$,(!01':#.(;(A*2&"@:(02(/"$%&'(*3(A*2:"2:.&44&Yale J. Intl L.&--4J&--4J&-.4J&-.6&].557^&]E%(%EE:*9&+'&+@%&

& 44&

!'&I$"E:(R&,;I@&'#$:9"+:'*,J&+@%&)'%&>%$:#%E"+%J&I'*IE%+%&"*>&+"E9%+%>&",&I$%"E$R&",&C',,:#$%&+'Q"E>,&%(:*%&+@%&I'*+%*+&'(&+@:,&W:P:>;"$&E:9@+3&d%*%E"$&)';I"+:'*J&:,&CE:%E&+@%&)'P%*"*+3-16&

&

& !@%&)LN)GJ&:*&:*+%ECE%+:*9&+@%&>;+:%,&%*,@E:*%>&:*&+@%&=)LN)GJ&I'*(:E&+'&%P%$'C:,IE:&.]4^^3&!@%E'">&$"*9;"9%&'(&d%*%E"$&)'

& 40&

+@%&W$''C@'$%X&Q:+@:*&CE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*R&;,:*9&,:+;"+:'*,&'(&9E',,&*%9$%I+&",&CE:&:+,&+E%"+R&'#$:9"+:'*,3&!@%'E%+:I"$$RJ&+@:,&Q';$>&

%*"#$%&,+"+%,&:*&>:((%E:*9&I'*+%`+,&'(&C'$:+:I"$&%I'*'&'(&CE'+%I+:'*3-11&

D,&:+,&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&J&",&+@%E%"I@&:,&CE:&:+,&&+@%&,;#,%c;%*+&E%P:%Q&'(&:

& 46&

(;$$&;,%&'(&+@%&%(:*:*9&+@%&&

(:*"$$RJ&Q"+%E3-/-&!@%&"CCE'"I@&'(&+@%&)'%(:*%>&:*&"*R&I'P%*"*+3-/4&K',+&@;&W:*&+@%'ERJ&+@%&I'E%&%$%&I"EER&>:E%I+$R&I'EE%$"+:P%&'#$:9"+:'*,3X-/6&!@:,&"$$'Q,&;,J&,JX&+@%*&Q%&Q:$$&I'&.-&d%*%E"$&)'%c;"IR&",&:+&:I:"$&E%",'*:*93&D$$&+@E%%&IE:+:I:,:,I;,,%>&:*&N%I+:'*&s&Y&"E%&%E%>R&+@:,&%,,"RJ&@'Q%P%EJ&+'&('E;+:%,&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&+@';9@&IE:+:I:,

& 41&

& !@%&I'E%&I'*+%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&"*&%*+:+$%%@R>E"+:'*&"*>&>:,%",%3X-//&

V:+@&(%Q&%`I%C+:'*,J&%P%ER&,%I+'E&'(&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'&+@:,&"CCE'"I@3&d%*%E"$&)'&>:,%",%3X-/7&!@%&CE:'E:+:Z"+:'*&'(&C%E,'*"$&"*>&

>'R&+@%&G%C'E+&'(&+@%&a:9@&)'R&+@%&I'*I%C+U,&:*I$;,:'*&:*&&:*&N%I+:'*&==3&!@%&

!@:E>&d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*J&('E&:*,+"*I%J&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&We+f@%&2%+":*:*9&A'Q%E&,@"$$&,;CC$R&

CE:,'*%E,&'(&Q"E&>;E:*9&+E"*,(%E&Q:+@&,;((:I:%*+&(''>&"*>&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&+'&B%%C&+@%&@%"$+@3X-75&=*&,:+;"+:'*,&Q@%E%&Q"+%E&:,&,I"EI%&'E&CE'P:,:'*&$:J&Q"+%E&('E&,;EP:P"$&

+"B%,&CE:'E:+R3&!@%&b3M3&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&V"+%E&)';E,%,&:*,:,+,&+@"+&:*&C%E:'>,&'(&I'*($:I+&'P%E&

E%,';EI%,J&CE:'E:+R%&9:P%*&+'&Q"+%E&+'&,3X-7-&!@%&8'**&)'*(%E%*I%&

'*&SE%,@Q"+%E&].55-^&,+"+%,&+@"+&WeQf"+%E&,@';$>%&%c;:+"#$R&"*>&,;,+":*"#$R&"$$'I"+%>J&

(:E,+$R&+'",:I&@;%"&'(&Q"+%EU,&":P:>;"$U,&P:+"$&

@;R&,I@'$"E,&:*&

#'+@&$"Q&"*>&@;R&%`C%E+&+%I@*:I"$'>:%,3-70&!@%&VaFJ&('E&:*,+"*I%J&:*,:,+,&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&A:%+%E,%J&G$:021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#R(='"(\#"36,2"##(*3(!01':#(=$,O(02(;,,"?0$:021(/*&0$,(S$%8#'0@(!"?0#0:"8.&.?&Hum. Rts. Q. /?1&].55/^g&2"P:>&8:$I@:+ZJ&F0?021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#(="":'R(='"(9020-6-(A*%"($28(4:#(4-@*%:$2&".&--?&S. Afr. L.J.&070&].55.^3&&&&&-//&i:%(%E&j&8Ek$

& 4/&

+@"+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"+&$%",+&W:%&+@%&(:E,+&C$"I%&('E&*"+:'*"$&C'$:IR&%"E>,&('E%I:,:'*,3&d%*%E"$&)'&8"E+E"^&:,&%*';9@&+'&%*,;E%&@;3-77&D,",:I&@R9:%*%&('E&"*&:*+'$%E"#$%&E:,B&+'&@;&,'I:"$&

I'*+%`+,3-7?&D$+@';9@&+@%&*;,X&Q'E$>Q:>%&:,&+@;,&9%*%E"$$R&

>%+%E%>3-?-&

!@:,&:*:+:"$&>%+%E%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&I'E%&*+,01$:0*2#&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:*&C"E"9E"C@&4/&'(&d%*%E"$&

)'%$:#%E"+%$R&"P':>,&,%++:*9&,;I@&"&c;"*+:+"+:P%",:,&:+,%$(3&483&"+&q13(&&&&-7/&48&E%"$:,+:I&56$,0:7&'(&$:(%tX&T&&+'&+@%(36,,(#&*@"&'(&+@%&E:9@+3&/"".(K"$I'$&8"E+E"%(:*:+:'*&>;%&+'&I'*+%`+;"$&>:((%E%*I%,3&/6@%$(*'+%&-.?J&"+&-3&K"$I'&,%EP:I%,&:,&*'+",%>&,::9*:+R3X&)E',,(:E%J@%$(*'+%&-.?J&"+&-.3&V"+%E&:,&C%E@"C,&;*:c;%&",&,;I@&"&*;,&Y&Q@:$%&@%$C(;$&:*&:$$;,+E"+:*9&,;CC'E+&('E&+@%&E:9@+&:*&,'&+'&9E'Q&%`C'*%*+:"$$RJ&IE%"+:*9&C'+%*+:"$&('E&I'*($:I+3&d$%:IBJ&!"560%"-"2:#.@%$&*'+%&-71J&"+&743&!''&

& 47&

+@%&I'E%&I'*+%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+3-?4&N%I'*>J&+@:,&"II%,,&%$:#%E"+%J&

I'*IE%+%&"*>&+"E9%+%>&,+%C,&+'Q"E>&+@%&(;$$&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+J-?6&:*I$;>:*9&E%I'9*:+:'*&

'(&+@%&E:9@+J-?1&+@%&">'C+:'*&"*>&:E%,,%,&

%P%ER'*%U,&*%%>,J-?/&"*>&+@%&IE%"+:'*&'(&"&&"#'P%&Q:+@&+@%&

'#$:9"+:'*,&'(&C"E"9E"C@&4/3&!@%&I'E%&I'*+%*+&'(&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&I"*&+@%R&>%$:#%E"+%J&I'*IE%+%&"*>&+"E9%+%>&,+"+%&"I+:'*,&+'Q"E>&+@%&%*['R&('E&(E%%3&=*&("I+J&We+f@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&*'&&+'&,;,+":*&$:(%&:(&C"R:*9&('E&Q"+%E&Q';$>&"+&"$$&::P:>;"$U,&

"#:$:+R&+'&CE'I;E%&'+@%E&%,,%*+:"$,&]%393",:I&(''>&'E&,@%$+%E^3&

S:*"$$RJ&+@%&&(E'&+'&+@%&%*['RR&(:*>:*9,&'(&+@%&)'"J&q45J&10J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O)DMO)FO0J&LO)3-.O)DMO)FO6J&]K"R&..J&.551^J&"+&@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O064//("453@+

& 4?&

'(&+@%&(;$$&E:9@+J&+@%&)',&C$;,X&"CCE'"I@&+'&I'*+%*+3.55&!@:,&@'$:,+:I&

;*>%E,+"*>:*9&:*I$;>%,&+@%&Q"+%E&*%I%,,"ER&('E&">%c;"+%&@%"$+@&"*>&@;&+'&,"R&+@"+&+@%R&"E%&,:R&d%*%E"$&)'&:*I$;>%>&"&,"*:+"+:'*&%$%:,+:*9;:,@%,&+@%&:*+%E%,+,&"+&+@%&@%"E+&'(&+@%&(&]WV@:$%&+@%&@;%$:*%,&"$,'&(":$&+'&>%(:*%&+@%&+%E'&%$3:(F608",02"#.(#6@%$&*'+%&/43&B6:""(1"2"%$,,7(=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;%C%*>%*+&E:9@+&+'&,"*:+"+:'*&",&"&I'%c;"+%&,"*:+"+:'*&W:,&+@%&CE:>E%,,%>&"9":*&:*&q4/]:^3&&&&&.50&S'E&"&>:,I;,,:'*&,%%()"@:$$J@%$&*'+%&-/6J&"+&05-T0503&

& 05&

'#$:9"+:'*&+@"+&>'%,&*'+&>:E%I+$R&E%(%E&+'&Q"+%E&:+,%$(3&!@:,&R&+@%&("I+&+@"+&

#",:I&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&*%I%,,"ER&('E&+@%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&I$%"*&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&"+&+@%&I'E%&'(&+@%&

E:9@+J.56&"*>&+@"+&:+&Q"EE"*+,&:*I$;,:'*%I";,%&"&E:9@+&+'&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&*'+&CE'+%I+%>R&"*R&

:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'P%*"*+3.51&

& =*&+@%&%*>J&+@%&[;,+:(:I"+:'*&'E&I$"E:(:I"+:'*&'(&"&E:9@+&+'&,"*:+"+:'*&:,%R'*>&+@%&

,I'C%&'(&+@:,&%,,"R3&!@:,&%,,"R&Q:$$&+E%"+&+@%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&%&"II%,,&+'&">%c;"+%&Q"+%E&('E&

>'%E%>&:*&+@%&CE'I%%>:*9&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&*"+:'*"$&[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&

@'Q%P%EJ%I";,%&+@%&";+@'E%$:%P%,&+@"+&"&&[;,+:(:%>&:*>%C%*>%*+$R&'(&+@:,&%$%13"0"11&-*

&

& =+&:,&I$%"E&(E':*9&,%I+:'*,&+@"+&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&::*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&2%P%$'C:*9&I;,+':%,&$:B%&+@%&)LN)G&"*>&+@%&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&_"Q&D,,'I:"+:'*J&"*>&+@%&

+%$%'$'9:I"$&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&@;&===3&D,&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&.56&d)-6J@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q.?&]WL*,;E:*9&+@"+&%P%ER'*%&@",&"II%,,&+'&">%c;"+%&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&*'+&'*$R&(;*>":9*:+R&"*>&CE:P"IRJ+&:,&'*%&'(&+@%&CE:*I:C"$&&a%"$+@&FE9"*:Z"+:'*J&FE"$&,;#:I"+%&+@"+&+@%E%&"E%&%C%*>%*+&,';EI%&'(&$%9"$&CE'+%I+:'*3&d)-6J@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q.?&]I:+:*9&+@%&E:9@+,&+'&@%"$+@&"*>&@';,:*9^&&&&&.5/&);,+'&+'&I'*,+:+;+%&"&(:E%P%$'C%>&+'&E%c;:E%&+@%&I'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&+@%&$%9"$&:*+%*+&'(&Q"+%ETE%$"+%>&>%I$"E"+:'*,J&E%,'$;+:'*,&"*>&E%$"+%>&+E%"+:%,&Y&",&Q%$$&",&*'*T'#[%I+:'*&+'&>%P%$'C:*9&*'ER&I"C"#$%&'(&%,+"#$:,@:*9&[;E:,>:I+:'*3&&

& 0-&

i:%(%E&"*>&8Ek$&Q';$>&%P%E&(:*>&>''&

"*>&*'+&;*>%ER&*"+:'*"$&[;E:,CE;>%*I%3&

&

;:(:I"+:'*&'(&"&*%Q&

:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E&'*&+@%:E&(;*>":9*:+R&'E&"E%&+@%R&$%9"$&%*+:+$%:+R&I'*>:+:'*,&'(&R&";+@'E:+"+:P%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$'>:%,&"*>&Q:>%$R&"II%C+%>3&!@:,&C@:$','C@:I"$&CE'#$%:(:%>3&!@%&CE%,%*+&%,,"R&"P':>,&+@:,&I'*I%C+;"$&>:$%":9*:+R&+@E';9@&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&E%I'9*:+:'*3&=*&+@:,&Q"RJ&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&>%&WC',:+%>X&$"Q,3&D,&+@%&VaF&:*,:,+,&:*&:+,&@"*>#''B&'*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&We@f;"E>,&+@"+&%*,;E%&+@%&(;*>"&>:9*:+R&'(&:*>:P:>;"$,&"*>&I'

& 0.&

E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*J&"*>&,%I'*>J%I";,%&+@%R&"$'*%&@"P%&+@%&";+@'E:+R&+'&E%I'9*:Z%&'E&E%[%I+&

*'P%$&I$":%E:P%,&(E'&%`%I;+:P%&(;*I+:'*,J&.-.&"*>&+@%&$",+&,%P%E"$&>%I">%,&@"P%&,%%*&+@%:E+@&'(&

:*9&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&"&

:+&:,&+@%&('I;,&'(&+@:,&,%I+:'*3&

D#E'&:*&N%I+:'*&==&Y&:,&&%*+:+$%%(:*%&+@%&'#$:9"+:'*,&C$"I%>&;C'*&+@%&,+"+%3X.-1&N'I:'T%I'*'&+@%:Z%>&';+,:>%&'(&,+E:I+&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&,R,+%&z%+$"*>J&W2(97(9028R(D$:"%(!01':#($28(S6-$2(!01':#J&Forbes Magazine Online&]DCE3&-.J&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3('E#%,3I':*9^&@",&CE%,,;E%>&,'

& 04&

>%(:*:*9&I'EE%,C'*>:*9&>;+:%,3.-/&!@:,&%C%*>%*+$R&%*,@E:*%>&02(,$HJ&+@%R&E%c;:E%&"&>%9E%%&'(&$%9:+:&'(&

c;"$:+RJ&"II%,,:#:$:+R&'E&"II%C+"#:$:+R3&=+&:,&:&+@%&Q"R&:*&Q@:I@&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E&'E&I@"$$%*9%>3&!@:,&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&,@';$>&%*"#$%&;,&+'&:9*:+R3..5&

!@%&:&:,&"$E%">R&I',&,%+R&2$:0*2$,&I';E+,&

"E%&"$,'%:*9&">'C+%>&%$,%Q@%E%3&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&+E:#;*"$,&:*IE%",:*9$R'EE'Q&(E'%*I%J...&"*>&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&@"P%&%P%*%9;*&+'&&I'$'*:"$&

@:,+'E:%,J&('E&%`"%(:*%>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$$RJ&WI';I+:'*&'(&)FaGLU,&$:+:9"+:'*&9;:>%&]**3&65J&.51^&:,&+'&:*($;%*I%&(;+;E%&$%9"$&>%I:,:'*,R&CE'P:>:*9&"&E%,';EI%&('E&[;>9%,&W:*&'+@%E&[;E:,>:I+:'*,&Q@'&T,"*:+"+:'*&:,,;%,3X&COHRE(c)J@%$(*'+%&65J&"+&./73&&&&&..-&Langford & Nolan,(#6@%$&*'+%&-/0J&"+&--3&&&&&&...&48&M'$"*&I:+%&L;E'C%"*&I",%&$"Q&'*&+'E+;E%&",&;,%>&+'&:*('E%I:,:'*,&'(&+@%&)'

& 00&

",&>:P%E,%&",&N';+@&D(E:I"J&=*>:"&"*>&DE9%*+:*"&@"P%&,:9*:(:I"*+$R&:*($;%*I%>&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&

"#E'">3..0&!@%'EE'Q:*9&'(&('E%:9*&,+"*>"E>,&:,&'(+%*&:*,+:9"+%>R&+@%&[;>:I:"ERJ+&

$:+:9"+'E,&%(:*:+:'*&'(&

Q"+%E&E:9@+,&]:*I$;>:*9&+@%&"E>,'+@&I$"E:(:%,&"*>&,+E%*9+@%*,&+@',%&,+"*>"E>,&('E&(;E+@%E&;,%&:*&

'+@%E&[;E:,>:I+:'*,3&!@%&Q"R&=*>:"*&I';E+,&@"P%&:*+%ECE%+%>&"*>&"CC$:%>&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&('E&

:*,+"*I%J&@",%%*&J&E:9@+,&@'$>%E,&Q:$$&:*&+;E*&,;((%E&"&$',,&'(&

CE'+%I+:'*3&G:9@+,&">P'I"+%,&Q'EERJ&('E&:*,+"*I%J&+@"+&E%I%*+&N';+@&D(E:I"*&[;>9"E>&&",&

$"Q,&>:E%I+$R&%*,@E:*%>&:*&"&,+"+%U,&I'*,+:+;+:'*&'E&'+@%E&$%9:,$"+:P%&:*,+E;"E>,&'*&Q@:I@&+@%R&"E%",%>3../&N%I'*>$RJ&,+"+%,&I"*&%*,@E:*%&@;&+'&:&:*&>%+":$%$'Q3&&&&&..6&_:+:9"+'E,&'(+%*&E%(%E%*I%&'+@%E&I';E+,&:*&+@%:E&"E9;&N'I:"$&S'E;"$"*I%&'(&"#;*>"*+&*"+;E"$&E%,';EI%,&"*>&%,+"#$:,@&"&CE%I:,%&@,$2(*3(-$2$1"-"2:('(&$"*>J&Q"+%EtX^&]%>%>^3&

& 06&

:*&+@%:E&%`+%E*"$&E%$"+:'*,3..7&N'&+@%&$%9"$",:,&'(&"&E:9@+&"E9;%>&:*&"&

*"+:'*"$&I';E+E''3&S'E+;*"+%$RJ&+@%&W:*+%ECE%+"+:P%&"++:+;>%X&'(&

+@%&I';E+&Q:+@&E%,C%I+&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:,&&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I",%,J&]#^&

E%I'9*:Z%>&"&:((%E%*I%,3&!@%&$%9"$&'E>%E&Q:$$&'*$R%&

#E:%($R&%`C$":*%>&:*&%"I@&I",%&+'&>%:I:"ER&

'E&+'&@:9@$:9@+&+@%&+E"*,:I:"$&CE:*I:C$%,3&=)LN)G&E"+:(:I"+:'*&Y&+@%&I%*+E"$&$%9"$&

#",:,&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&Y&Q:$$&"$,'%&*'+%>J&",&,+"+%,TC"E+:%,&+'&+@:,&)'P%*"*+&"E%&+@%&

C"E+:%,&&+'&'+@%E&,'I:'T%I'*'%*I%J&+@%&$:,+&'(&I",%,&

%`C$'E%>%$'Q&:,&E%$"+:P%$R&,@'E+3&!@:,&:,%I";,%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&E%&E:9@+,&]%393&CE'C%E+R^3.45&!@%&%`C$:I:+&;,%&'(&"&W&",&+@%&:I+:'*,&@"P%&*%P%E(%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%>&"&&(:E,+3&!@%&[;>9R&

I';*+ER&"*>E:%($R&,;%P%$'C%EJ&Q@:$%&'(&CE"I+:I"$&:&65J&E%,C%I+:P%$R3&&&&&.44&!@%&E%">%E&,@';$>&("%E&'(&+@%&%,,"R&Q:$$&>%C%*>&'*&"&,+E'*9&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%,%&I'*I%C+,3&

& 01&

I'*I%C+&"*>&]I^&+@%&E%$"+:'*&'(&+@%&&%`C$:I:+&E%(%E%*I%&+'&"&&('E&+@%&

(;$(:$$&

#%$'QJ&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&E%c;:E%&+@%:E&E%,C%I+:P%&9'P%E*%&"&,C%I:(:I&"&

]#^&"++%3&&

S:E,+J&c;"*+:+"+:P%&,+"*>"E>,&"E%&*'+&('E%E%>&",&@%$C(;$&9;:>%$:*%,&('E&+@%&IE%"+:'*&'(&"CCE'CE:"+%J&I'*+%`+T,C%I:(:I&

,+"*>"E>,&+@"+&@%$C&,+"+%,&&:*&*"+:'*"$&I",%,&:,&'(+%*&%P:>%*I%&'(&+@%&:%P%$'CR&+@%&I';*+E:%,&I:+%>&,'&+'&+@%&I$%"E%,+&CE'+%I+:'*&'E&E%[%I+:'*&'(&+@%&:I:"$&%*('EI%R&+@:,&%,,"RJ&@'Q%P%EJ&:,&I'*,:>%E"#$R&%:*9&'(&+@%&02:"%2$:0*2$,(,+"+;,&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"*>&+@%&J&%>3J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3I'@E%3'E9O,:+%,O>%(";$+O(:$%,O$:+:9"+:*9h%,IhE:9@+,hTh"I@:%P%h,+E"+%9:%,h.5543C>(3&]N';+@&D(E:I"&:,&'(+%*&,%%*&",&"&W$:+%+%EJ&:*I$;>:*9&%393J&+@%&K:$$%**:;

& 0/&

'(&"&U,&W"E#:+E"E:*%,,X&:*&I'*+%`+;"$:Z"+:'*3.4?&!'&[;>9%&"&I';E+U,&

:*+%*+:'*&(E'%&,@'E+,:9@+%>J&@'Q%P%EJ&",&*%:+@%E&+@%&(E%%&

CE'P:,:'*&'(&Q"+%E&*'E&+@%&,C%I:(:I"+:'*&'(&"&C"E+:I;$"E&"R&

:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&!'&,"R&+@"+&+@%&(":$;E%&+'&,%+&"&+@E%,@'$>&"&%`%I;+:P%J&,'&$'*9&",&+@%&%,,%*+:"$&9&SE"*I%.04&%*,@E:*:*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&",&"*&%,,%*+:"$&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&.4?&/""(1"2"%$,,7(~';*9J(#6@%$&*'+%&-6?3&/""($,#*&8$;%:((%E,&(E'&,%+&:*&a'Q"E>&"*>&8"E+E"%+%E&+'%&W>%P%$'C%>X",%>&02:"%($,0$&:*&+@%:E&a2=&]a;&",&+@%&Q'E$>U,&

& 07&

%$%%I%,,'E&+'&+@%&

&+@%&

I'*,+:+;+:'*"$:+R&'(&+@%&_"Q&d'P%E*:*9&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&]-?44^.01&",&

:*+%E(%E:*9&Q:+@&+@%&R&+@%&S$%3.07&

!@%&)';E+&'(&DE#:+E"+:'*&(';*>&+@%&$"Q&+'%&Q:+@:*&+@%&%`%I;+:P%&I'"E>&Y&%,C%I:"$$R&"&*'*T#:*>:*9&>%I$"E"+:'*&Y&:,&*'+"#$%&('E&:+,&%"E$R&,;CC'E+&'(&+@%&

:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&,;EE';*>:*9&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&D$+@';9@&8%$9:;&+@%&=)LN)G&:*&-?74J&+@%&)';E+&>:>&*'+&I:+%&+@:,&$%9"$&,';EI%&",&:+&@">&*'+&R%+%%*&

@%$>R&+@%&)LN)G&+'&:*I$;>%&"&@;%&:*,+"*I%&e!d=f&e'E>:*"ER&I';E+&'(&'E:9:*"$&[;E:,>:I+:'*f&DP:9*'*J&K"R&-.J&-??6J&*3&-0?.O?6&]SE3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3I"I%3(EO[;E:,CE;>%*I%OE%+,O%";CE%,,:'*O+9:-.56-??63@+%&$"&)'9%+&-??/&e2%IE%%&'(&+@%&S$%&I;$+;E"$&E:9@+,&Q:+@&+@%&$"*9;"9%H&WD&I%++%&(:*J&$"&$':J&$%&>pIE%+&';&$"&Ey9$%&P:,p%&r&$x"E+:I$%&-40&9"E"*+:,,%*+J&%*&+%*"*+&I'%,&'#$:9"+:'*,&I'EE%,C'*>"*+%,J&$%,&>E':+,&pI'*':+:'*,&>%&$%;E&%`%EI:I%3X Constitution Coordonn&S%#3&-/J&-??0J&"E+3&.4&]8%$93^3&&&&&.65&/""(#6@%$&{&==&A"E+&DJ&+@:,&%,,"R3&&&&&.6-&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+J&"EE}+&*'&41O-??7J&DCE3&-J&-??7J&q8313.3&&&&&.6.&!@:,&%`I;,%&:,&%",:$R&]"*>&'(+%*&I'EE%I+$R^'EE'Q%>&:*&'+@%E&*"+:'*"$&I'*+%`+,3&=+&:,&:

& 0?&

!@%&)';E+U,&,+:C;$"+:'*&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*I$;>%&"&>%(:*"#$%&%>&(E%%&'(&I@"E9%&I"*%&,%%*&",&:&,;CC$R&'(t&Q"+%E&('E&@';,%@'$>&C;EC',%,&:*&'E>%E&+'%&"#$%&+'&$:P%&>%I%*+$R&

"II'E>:*9&+'&CE%P":$:*9&$:P:*9&,+"*>"E>,3X.64&!@%&,+:C;$"+:'*&'(&-6&I;#:I&&:*&+@%&VaF&9;:>%$:*%,&I:+%>&

#R&d%*%E"$&)'%E&+@"*&+@%&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%>&('E&,;EP:P"$J&+@%&)';*I:$U,&E;$%&,+:$$&CE'+%I+%>&"*&

$-*62:&'(&Q"+%E&+@"+&("$$,&Q:+@:*&+@%&W#",:I&*%%>,X&9;:>%$:*%3.66&!@%&[;>9&+@%&:>%"&'(&"&&I'*I%E*,&:*&=*>:"&"E%&C'$$;+:'*&"*>&'P%ET%`+E"I+:'*3&D&.554&,+;>RR&+@%&

=*>:"*&9'P%E*3.61&AE:P"+%&I'EC'E"+:'*,&@"P%&"&$"E9%&E'$%&

+'&C$"R&:*&+@%&>%9E">"+:'*&'(&I'&+'&+@%&

$:+:9"+:'*&'(&*;&E"*9%&*'+%>&"#'P%J@%$&{&==J&A"E+&83&&&&&.61&D$:"%(`0"H#R(4280$.&Circle of Blue&]D;93&-7J&.55?^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I:EI$%'(#$;%3'E9OQ"+%E*%Q,O.55?OQ'E$>OQ"+%EP:%Q,T:*>:"O3&&&&&&.6/&N%%&GorsbothJ@%$&*'+%&.4J&"+&-4T-0g&FoodFirst Information and Action Network, Investigating Some Alleged Violations of the Human Right to Water in India: Report of the International Fact Finding Mission to India&]N"#:*%&A"#,+&%+&"$3&%>,3J&.550^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3E":*Q"+%EI$;#3'E9O>'I,OE%C'E+hB'(3&

& 65&

N:*I%&:+,&"II%,,:'*&+'&+@%&=)LN)G&:*&-?/?J&=*>:"&@",%%*&I@",+:,%>R&+@%&)LN)G&('E&

*'+&9:P:*9&(;$$&$%9"$&%((%I+&+'&)'P%*"*+&CE'P:,:'*,&:*&>':"*,&";+R&'(&+@%&,+"+%&+'&"CC$R&

+@%,%&CE:*I:C$%,&:*&:"J&@'Q%P%EJ&@"P%&IE%"+:P%$R&

"P':>%>&+@%&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R&E%,+E:I+:'*,&'*&,'I:'T%I'*'%P%$'C%>R&+@%&N;CE%%*I%&,+%&@",&*'+"#$R&">'C+%>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,&

:*&:+,&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&+@"+&E:9@+U,&I'*+%*+J&>%,C:+%&+@%&(":$;E%&'(&+@%&A"E$:"

& 6-&

& !@%&U628$-"2:$,(!01':#(I",%&IE%"+%>&+@%&CE%I%>%*+&('E&+@%&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R&'(&,'I:'T

%I'*'%E%>&W(;*>"&

:*&+@%&2ANA^&I';$>&*'+%&,%%*&",&$%,,&,:9*:(:I"*+&+@"*&Q@"+&:,&W(;*>""&2ANAJ&+@%*J&Q%E%&I'*,:>%E%>&I'&+'&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&,'I:'T

%I'*'&%`C"*>%>R&"&,%E:%,&'(&N;CE%&+@"+&>%+":*%%,&%*['R&"$$&(;*>":*9&

W+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:P%&Q:+@&@;&%P%ER+@:*9&+@"+&9'%,&"$'*9&Q:+@&:+J&*"%+":$:*9&+@%,%&W#",:I&*%I%,,:+:%,JX&*'+:*9&+@"+&$:(%&W:,&"E"3I'%&>:,+:*9;:,@%>&(E'%C%*>%*+&,'I:'T%I'*':I"+%&+@"+&+@%&I';E+,%$:%P%&+@"+&,'I:'T%I'*'%C%*>%*+$R&'(&I:P:$&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,&]W*%:+@%E&C"E+%:*9&,;C%E:'E&+'&+@%&'+@%EX^J&"$+@';9@&+@%R&E%c;:E%&CE'+%I+:'*&+@E';9@&"E9;'IO/7641O3&&&&&.1?&48:"&]-??5^&D3=3G3&]i%E3^&4.-J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.0?/3&!@%&[;>9%*+:I"$&+'&@:,&[;>9:"&V3A3&:*&+@%&,":"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3:%$EI3'E9OI'*+%*+O%?-573C>(3&

& 6.&

"$$'Q%>&+@%&)';E+&+'&>%I$"E%&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&W:*I$;>%,&+@%&E:9@+&'(&%*['RR&"*R&I:P:$:Z%>&,'I:%+R&:&

,@%$+%E3X./6&S:*"$$RJ&:*&;%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&,@';$>%&9;:>%>R&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&

,+"*>"E>,&$:B%&+@%&K"E&>%$&A$"+"&DI+:'*&A$"*&,:9*%>R&=*>:"&:*&-?//3.//&!@%&)';E+&>:E%I+$R&

c;'+%>&+@%&A$"*J&Q@:I@&,+"+%,&+@"+&We"f$$&C%'C$%J&Q@"+%P%E&+@%:E&,+"9%&'(&>%P%$'CE:*B:*9&Q"+%E&:*&

c;"*+;%&"9":*&:*('ER&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,^&@">&9":*%>&Q:>%,CE%">&"II%C+"*I%&

:*'+@&E%9:'*"$&"*>&*"+:'*"$&I';E+E''3./?&

b*('E+;*"+%$RJ&*'&=*>:"*&I';E+&@",&%P%E&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%>&"*R&E:9@+U,&W&+'&E:9@+,T>%(:*:+:'*&+@E';9@&+@%&=)LN)GJ&Q@:I@&+@%&"#'P%&[;>9T==&P3&K3s3&M"R;>;J&].55-^&0&=3_3G3&16/&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3:%$EI3'E9OI'*+%*+O%55-53C>(3(&&&&.//&48&:*&P:'$"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&I$%"*&Q"+%E&;*>%E&DE+:I$%&.-&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&'(&=*>:"3X^3&&&&&./7&483&"+&q43&=*&+@%&I",%&)"%6-$::7(F%$-$()$2&'$7$:&?&AE:*I:C$%&.&'(&+@%&N+'IB@'$&('E&+@%%*%(:+&'(&CE%,%*+&"*>&(;+;E%&9%*%E"+:'*,3&/""(A%E;

& 64&

$"*9;"9%&$:B%&W+@%&%,,%*+:"$&9%,@&,+"+%3&=*&:+,&-???&[;>9%"&'(&

+@%&&*'+&:+,%$(&,C%I:(R&"&E%RJ&:+&%,+"#$:,@%>&"&I'%E&@'Q&+'%,+&,'$P%&+@%&:*(E",+E;I+;E"$&CE'#$%:3:,O+@%T@;&:*&\':%&)@'Q>@;ERJ&[680&0$,(;8'"%"2&"(:*($(9020-6-(A*%"(;@@%*$&'(:*(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#(f(;(A*-@$%$:0?"()"%#@"&:0?".&?&*3&4/&]K"E3&.4J&.557^&];*C;#$:,@%>&Q'EB:*9&C"C%EJ&)'E*%$$&_"Q&NI@''$^]'*&(:$%&Q:+@&";+@'E^];,%>&Q:+@&C%E%E&(E'%E&9E"*+:*9&CE%$:&,';EI%&:,&*'+&E%">:$R&"P":$"#$%J&+@%&I",%&:,&Q%$$TB*'Q*&:*&,'I:'T%I'*'&:,&c;:+%&E"E%3&/""(A$#"(C$HR()"*@,"L#(\20*2(3*%(A0?0,(C0+"%:0"#(?o05-544&]$",+&P:,:+%>&M'P3&7J&.5-5^3 D&(:*"$&>%I:,:'*&('E&+@%&I",%&Q",&>%$:P%E%>&:*&.55/J&:*&("P'E&'(&+@%&A%'C$%U,&b*:'*3&A%'C$%x,&b*:'*&('E&):P:$&_:#%E+:%,&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"J&].55/^&-&N3)3)3&/-?&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOO:*>:"*B"*''*3'E9O>'IO0--741O3(&&&&.7.&!@%&=*>:"*&)';E+U,&$"*9;"9%&:,&*'+&>:E%I+$R&:*+%EI@"*9%"#$%&('E&+@%&:>%"&'(&"&W:"J&VE:+&'(&A%+:+:'*&M'3&-?1O.55-&]N3)3&K"R&.J&.554J&,%I'*>&'E>%E&9E"*+:*9&CE%$:

& 60&

+%E&"&WI'E%X&*'E&">>E%,,%>&+@%&%3&8"EE:*9&(;E+@%E&[;>:I:"$&:*:+:"+:P%J&=*>:"*&CE'9E%,,&@:*9%,&'*&$%9:,$"+:P%&:*I'EC'E"+:'*&

'(&+@%&=)LN)GJ&+'&Q@:I@&+@%&I';*+ER&E%%&A"B:,+"*:&I';*+%EC"E+,3&

M'*%&'(&+@%&I",%,%$'Q&(;$$R&CE'+%I+&"&E:9@+&+'&I$%"*J&">%c;"+%&Q"+%E&"II%,,&'(&"&,C%I:(:I&

c;"$:+R&'E&c;"*+:+R&+'&%*,;E%&@;9:I:"$&"++%%P%$'C&(;E+@%E&:*&+@%&(;+;E%&Q:+@&$%9:,$"+:P%&I@"*9%3&

8"*9$">%,@&:,&'(+%*&I'&('E&Q%$$T:*+%9E"+%>&Q"+%E&%,@&Q@%E%&

'P%E&-555&:*>;,+E:%,&@"P%%%*&:>%*+:(:%>&,:*I%&+@%&-?75,&",&;*,"(%$R&>:,I@"E9:*9&Q",+%&

:*+'&+@%&Q"+%E&"*>&":E3.?5&D9":*J&,'I:'T%I'*'&",&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&.71&F$%1&]-???^&D3=3G3&]D$$3^&0-J&q?T-43&!@%&)';E+&:+,%$(&"$,'&'E>%E%>&+@%&:R&+@:,&Q"E&IE%"+%>&,'I:"$&+;E

& 66&

*'*T[;,+:I:"#$%&WCE:*I:C$%,&'(&,+"+%&C'$:IRJX&"*>&+@%&=)LN)GJ&+@';9@&"II%>%>&+'J&:,&$"E9%$R&

:9*'E%>&:*&>'&[;E:,CE;>%*I%3.?-&N::I:"ER3&=*&+@%&!$80*$&:0?"(90,O()*H8"%(

I",%&'(&%"E$R&\;$R&-??1J&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&2:P:,:'*&'(&+@%&N;CE%&:*&';E&>'f&&,;,+":*:*9&I'*>:+:'*,&I'*9%*:"$&+'&9''>&@%"$+@&"*>&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&.?-&=*+%EP:%Q&Q:+@&2E3&i"P'I"+%J&S'E%C%*>%*+&@;&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&"*R&E:9@+U,&&N"*:+"+:'*&j&=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&|;%,+:'*&'(&a;&L`+E%%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.(A$:$%02$(8"(;,+656"%56"R(90##0*2(:*(B$21,$8"#'.&a;'I,O-.,%,,:'*ODTaG)T-.T.0hL3C>(&]P:"&@RC%E$:*B&Q:+@&+@%&+:+$%&'(&+@%&>'I;&V3A3&?.J&q.5&]\;$3&-J&-??1^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-4.43&

& 61&

%*,;E:*9&c;"$:+R&'(&$:(%&I'*,:,+%*+&Q:+@&@;&

%%$:P%E%>3&_"+%E&:*&+@%&,"%>&+'&+@%&=)LN)G&"*>&+@%&K:*:,+ER&'(&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,&

C;#$:,@%>&"&M"+:'*"$&V"+%E&A'$:IR&"IB*'Q$%>9:*9&+@"+&+@%&W"P":$"#:$:+R&e'(&Q"+%Ef&('E&

,;,+%*"*I%&'(&$:(%J&:*'+@&c;"*+:+"+:P%&"*>&c;"$:+"+:P%&+%E%,@:&I';E+,&I'*+:*;%>&+''EE'Q&('E%:9*&,+"*>"E>,&",&+@%R&%`+%*>%>&

,'I:'T%I'*''C+%>&"+&+@%&,;99%,+:'*&'(&+@%&"CC$:I"*+3&=*&;#O(;02(*(/$,0#'(

g"28%$(?%,@&]U,**8(;&:0*2(),$2(A$#"R(;@@",,$:"lJ&]-??/^&0?&23_3G3&]D2^&-J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&G"ZZ"c;%J&;&&"##.(#6@%$&*'+%&.7?&"+&/J&**3&4T0&]WDE+:I$%&4-&"*>&4.&3&3&3&%*I'3&D*R&"I+&'E&':"&+@%R&;,%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&",&"",:,J&"&C$"*BJ&'*&Q@:I@&+'&9:P%&$:&E:9@+,3X^3&&&&&45.&S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@&]4286#:%0$,()*,,6:0*2^J&;*E%C'E+%>&V3A3&7?-&]-??0^J&]>%I:,:'*&\;$R&-6J&.55-^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.6/7

& 6/&

'+@%E,&%P%$'C%R'*>&+@%,%&:*:+:"$&

$"*>"&>:E%I+:P%&CE:*I:C$%,3450&D&CE'&P:'$"+:'*,&

'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&8"*9$">%,@&Q:$$&I'*+:*;%&+'&$"9%@:*>&=*>:"&:*&%((%I+:P%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&

CE'+%I+:'*&;*+:$&$%9:,$"+:P%&:**'P"+:'*&I"*&W'C%E"+:'*"$:Z%X&%`:,+:*9&E:9@+,&Q:+@&%P%$'C&Q"+%E&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&:*&+@%&-??5,J&"9":*&Q:+@&

E%(%E%*I%&+'&=*>:"*&[;>:I:"$&,+"*>"E>,3&D$+@';9@&A"B:,+"*&@",&&+'&"&P%9%+"+:P%&$:(%&'E&&"*&%"E$:%E&[;>9%P%$'C%>&:*&"*&%"E$:%E&:*,+"*I%&'(&+@%&,"R&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&2:P:,:'*&'(&+@%&N;CE%"+%>&2%I%&+@%&:*,+:+;+:'*&'(&"II';*+"#:$:+R&

& 67&

>%,C:+%&+@%&("I+&+@"+&+@%&%*P:E'*&E%%,@345?&&

!@%E%&:I:"$&,+"*>"E>,3&=*&/028'(42#:0:6:0*2(?9&+''+@&CE%P:';,&=*>:"*&%*P:E'*%I$"E"+:'*,&E%$"+:*9&+'&+@%&;,%&'(&*"+;E"$&E%,';EI%,34-4&!@%&'C:*:'*&"$,'&

E%(%E%*I%>&W9%*;:*%&*%%>,X&",&+@%",:,&('E&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&$'I"$&Q"+%E&"II%,,J&:,,;:*9&"*&

:*+%E:%C%*>%*I%&

'(&+@%&[;>:I:"ER34-6&b*+:$&+@%,%&CE'#$%&+@%&=*>:"*&%`"&'*&Q"+%EU,&(;*>"&N+'*%J&]-?7-^&].^&N)KG&.56&"+&.-.&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3E:,@"#@>"E"3I'J&($'E"&"*>&(";*"&%,C%I:"$$R&E%CE%,%*+"+:P%&,":*9&@;&+'&%`+E"[;>:I:"$&B:$$:*9,J&+%EE'E:,&>%+%*+:'*J&"*>&(E%%>':,"CC%"E"*I%&I",%,3&&&&&&4-6&!@%&[;>:I:"ER&,@';$>%&%*,;E%>&$%9"$&,;CE%

& 6?&

&

03&!@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&

&

& D$+@';9@&:+,&)'*,+:+;+:'*&"$,'&%*,@E:*%,&,'I:'T%I'*'%E%>&,%C"E"+%$R&",&:+,&I';E+,&

@"P%&:*+%ECE%+%>&+@%,%&CE:*I:C$%,&&+@%&%((%I+:P%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&

E:9@+,&('E&S:$:C:*',3&&

!@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&@",&@">&"&X&"*>&"&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,J&"*>&+@',%&Q'EB:*9&+'&CE'+%I+&@;9&+'&E%,C%I+&

:*+%E*"+:'*"$&E:9@+,&,+"*>"E>,J&'(+%*R&&:+,&AE'+'I'$&WI'*,:>%E:*9&+@"+&+@%,%&"9E%%&

'*$R&+@%&)'&+@%&C%E%&+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&E"+:(:%>&:+&:*&-?7?3&&&&&4..&D,&"&9%*%E"$&E;$%J&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&@'$>,&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&CE:*I:C$%,&"*>&"9E%%&Q",&C%E@"C,%,+&%`C$":*%>R&+@%&A3)3=3\3&:*&+@%&U%""(]*2"#(A$#"J&Q@