stable structures of transeurasian - uni kiel · janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Stable structures of Transeurasian
Martine Robbeets
![Page 2: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
The Transeurasian languages
![Page 3: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
The northern Eurasian macro-area
![Page 4: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
The northern Eurasian macro-area
Nichols (2011: 177)
"over time the families [of Northern Eurasia] have come to resemble each other more and more in structural typology, culminating in the Eurasian or Altaic linguistic type and a high degree of structural consistency”
Janhunen (2014: 331)
"speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there are no areal or typological features that are specific only to "Altaic" without Uralic. ... there is nothing in "Altaic" that is not equally true of Uralic".
![Page 5: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Organization
• Dataset
• 20 shared typological features
• Development of typological similarity over time
• Delimitation Transeurasian from Uralic type
• Areal versus genealogical patterns
![Page 6: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Sample languages
Selected contemporary Transeurasian languages
Turkish (Turkic)
Khalkha (Mongolic)
Evenki (Tungusic)
Korean (Koreanic)
Japanese (Japonic)
WALS
![Page 7: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Old Turkic (8th-14th C) Middle Mongolian (13th-17th C) Manchu (17th-19th C) Middle Korean (15th-16th C) Old Japanese (8th C)
Selected historical Transeurasian varieties
Sample languages
![Page 8: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
WALS
Sample languages
Selected neighboring languages
Turkish
Khalkha
Evenki
Korean Japanese
Eastern Khanty(Uralic)
Ket (Yenissean)
Kolyma Yukaghir(Yukaghiric)
Nivkh(Amuric)
Ainu(Ainuic)
Rukai(Austronesian)
Mandarin Chinese(Sino-Tibetan)
![Page 9: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
1 Phonological structure
![Page 10: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
F01. Presence of tongue root vowel harmony Ko 2012; Ko, Whitman & Joseph (in press)
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
1 - - + + + + - + - + - - + + +/- - -
Tk (pre-) OT Kh (pre-)
MMo Evk (pre-) Ma
K (pre-) MK
J (pre-) OJ
Khn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
-RTR +RTR
Khalkha e u o a ʊ ɔ
Ewen i ə u o ɪ a ʊ ɔ
Middle Korean ə ɨ u a ʌ o
Pre-Old Japanese *i *ə *u *e *a *o
Nivkh i ə u e a o
Proto-Yukaghir *i *e *o *u *ɪ *a *ɔ *ʊ
![Page 11: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
F02. Absence of r- in initial position
Japanese razio
Korean latiwo
‘radio’
Even radio
Khalkha radio
Turkish radyo
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
2 + + + + + + + + + + - - + - - - -
Tk (pre-) OT Kh (pre-)
MMo Evk (pre-) Ma
K (pre-) MK
J (pre-) OJ
Khn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 12: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
F03. Presence of velar nasal but not in initial position
Evk. ŋene- ‘to go’, Ma. genu- ‘to go together’ < pTg *g- if followed by n, r, l, m, y
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
3 + + + + - + + + - + + + + - - + -
Tk (pre-) OT Kh (pre-)
MMo Evk (pre-) Ma
K (pre-) MK
J (pre-) OJ
Khn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 13: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
4 + + + + + + - - + - - + + - - - +
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
F04. Presence of voicing distinction for stops
Not in Korean: lax aspirated tense pul ‘fire‘ phul ‘grass‘ ppul ‘horn’
Not in (pre-)Old Japanese: J b, d, g < OJ np, nt, nk
In Japanese: J b, d, g
![Page 14: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
2 Lexical and semantic structure
![Page 15: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
F05. Preference for non-verbal strategy of verbal borrowing
Wohlgemuth 2009
Non-verbal Verbal
Tk. klik-le- / klik et- << English click
Khal. zee-l- << Mandarin zhài ‘borrow, lend’
Ud. tancewa-la- << Russian tancewa-t’ ‘to dance’
J zyogingu suru ‘to jog’ << English jog
Evk. vypolńaj- << Russian vypolnja-t’ ‘to fulfill’
Mandarin kaobei << French copier ‘to copy’
Ainu moketa- << J mouke-ta ‘to make a profit-PST’
K coking ha- << English jog
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
5 + +/- + +
/- - +/- + +
/- + +/- - - - - - - -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 16: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
F06. Presence of a two-way proximal-distal distinction in demonstrative pronouns
Proximal Mesial DistalJapanese ko- ‘this’ so- ‘that’ a- ‘that over there’Old Japanese ko2 ‘this’ so2 ‘that’ ka ‘that over there’Korean i ‘this’ ku ‘that’ ce ‘that over there’ Evenki er(i) ‘this’ tar(i) ‘that’Manchu ere ‘this’ tere ‘thatKhalkha e- ‘this’ te- ‘that’Turkish bu ‘this’ şu ‘that’ o ‘that over there’Old Turkic bo / bun- ‘this’ ol / an- ‘that’Khanty timi ‘this’ tomɨ ‘that’Yukagir tiŋ ‘this’ adiŋ ~ ediŋ ‘that’ taŋ ‘that over there’ Ket tu- ‘this’ ki- ‘that’ qa- ‘that over there’ Ainu ta an ‘this’ ne an ‘that’ to an okai ‘that over there’ Nivkh tyd’ ‘this’ hyd’ ‘that’ ad’ ‘that’
more distantRukai ina ‘this’ ana ‘that’ ona ‘that over there’ visible Mandarin zhè(ge) ‘this’ nà(ge) ‘that’
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
6 - + + + + + - - - + + - - - - + -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 17: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
F07. Property words are verbally and nominally encoded with traces of switched encoding
verbal nominal switching
Japanese OJ atu- ‘to be hot’
OJ tasika nar- ‘to be trustworthy
OJ taka ‘high’ OJ taka- ‘to be high’
Korean MK kwut- ‘to be(come) hard’
MK kanan ha- ‘to be poor’
MK toso ho- ‘to be warm’ MK toso- ‘to be warm’
Tungusic Ma aka- ‘to be sad’
Ma. den ‘high, tall; heigth’
Ma. jalu ‘full’ Ma. jalu- ‘to be full’
Mongolic WMo. qala- ‘to be(come) warm’
WMo. qara ‘black’
MMo. bulqa ‘hostile’ MMo. bulqa-‘to be hostile’
Turkic OTk. kat- ‘to be hard, firm, tough’
OTk isig ‘hot’
OTk. ač ‘hungry’ OTk. ač- ‘to be hungry’
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
7 - + - + - + - + - + - - - - - - -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 18: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
3 Morphological structure
![Page 19: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
F08. Inflectional morphology is predominantly suffixing
prefixing suffixing isolating
Ket + nominal + verbal
Nivkh + + light
Ainu + +
Mandarin + light +
Rukai + +
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
11 + + + + + + + + + + + - + - - - -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 20: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
F09. The imperative is expressed by a bare verb stem
OTk. kel ‘come (here)!’ Tk. gel 'come (here)!’ MMo. ire ‘come!’ Khal. ir ‘come!’ Ma. gene ‘go!’ OJ mi ‘look!’ K mek-e ‘eat!’ < pK *a 'be!' Ainu nu 'listen!'
Evk. eme-kel 'come!' J mi-ro 'look!' Khanty qolǝnt-a 'listen!' Nivkh ɣe-ja ‘Take!’ Rukai vilivili-a 'pull!' Ket úl-d-al-gaŋ 'wash him!’ (water-ACC-3.M.OBJ-IMP-wash) Yukaghir wie-Ø-k ‘make!' (make-IMP-2) Ainu nu yan 'listen!'
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
9 + + + + - + - + - + - - - - + + -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
bare with suffix
![Page 21: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
F10. Absence of obligatory numeral classifiers
With classifier Without classifier
Japaneseenpitu san-bon pencil 3-CLAS ‘three pencils’
Old Japanese nana se 7 rapid ‘seven rapids’
Koreanpus sek calwu writing.brush 3 CLAS ‘three writing brushes’
twu nala 2 country ‘two countries’
Middle Koreantwu kalh 2 knife ‘two knives’
Manchuilan fesin loho 3 CLAS sword ‘three swords’
loho ilan sword 3 ‘three swords’
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
10 + + + + + + + + - + + + + - - - +
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 22: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
F11. Formation of a secondary nasal oblique stem in personal pronouns
nominative 1SG oblique 1SGOT ben min-
Khal bii bidn-
MMo. bi man-
Evk. bi: min-
Ma. bi min-
OJ wa wa-nu-ni (1SG-OBL-DAT)
Shuri waa- waN-
Khanty mä män-
Rukai -lrao -iae
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
11 - + + + + + - - - + + - - - - - -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 23: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
4 Syntactic structure
![Page 24: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
F12. Dependent-marking of clause arguments
(1) TurkishBu ev-i Ahmet-e yap-tı-m. this house-ACC Ahmet-DAT make-PST-1SG‘I built this house for Ahmet.’ (Göksel & Kerslake 2005: 146)
(2) KhalkhaÖwgön-iig ger-t-ee ury-jee. old.man-ACC home-dat-REFL invite-PST ‘He [the tiger] invited the old man to his home.’ (Janhunen 2012: 296)
(3) EvenkiNungan eri gule-ve o:-ra-n.he this house-ACC make-PST-3SG ‘He built this house.’ (Nedjalkov 1997: 83)
(4) Korean Halapeci-kkey ton-ul tuli-ess-eyo.grandfather-DAT money-ACC give-PST-POL‘She gave her grandfather some money.’ (Sohn 1994: 84)
(5) Japanese Yamada sensei-ni tegami-o mise-ru. Yamada teacher-DAT letter-ACC show-NPST‘She shows the letter to professor Yamada.’ (Iwasaki 2006: 122)
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
12 + + + + + + + + + + + - + - - + -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 25: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
F13. Dependent-marking in possessive noun phrases Dependent marking Head marking
Turkishoda-nïn kapï-sï room-GEN door-3SG.POSS ‘the door of the room’
Khalkamin-ii eej I-GEN mother ‘my mother’
Evensvinija ulrə-n swine meat-3SG.POS ‘swine’s meat, pork’
Manchuama i bo: father GEN house ‘father’s house’
Khantyqul-əm fish-2SG ‘your fish’
Koreanna-uy yenphil I-GEN pencil ‘my pencil’
Ainu eci-sikí-hi 2PL-eye-GEN ‘your eyes’
Japaneseanata no atama you-GEN head ‘your head’
Nivkhvit-ɣaŋ 2SG-book ‘your book’
Yukaghirtude kerewe-d ugurce 3SG cow-GEN leg ‘the legs of his cow’
Ketb-a:m 1SG-mother ‘my mother’
Mandarinbâba de máma father GEN mother ‘ father’s mother’
Rukaitolropongo-ni dhipolo hat-2SG.GEN Dhipolo ‘Dhipolo’s hat’.
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
13 - - + + - + + + + + - - + - - + -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 26: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
F14. Extensive use of converbs
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
14 + + + + + + + + + + - - + + - - -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
(1) Turkish (Johanson 1995: 314) Ali gel-ince şaşır-d-ı Ali come-CONV be.surprised-PST-3SG ‘When Ali came, he was surprised’
(2) Khalkha (Janhunen 2012: 280) Ger-ees-ee gar-aad house-ABL-REFL exit-PFV.CONV deuc-en jil-iin daraa ol-d-lao forty-ADN year-GEN after find-PASS-FIN ‘She went away from home and was found forty years later’
(3) Even (Malchukov 2012: 213) Dagam-mi, kunte-le d’u-v it-ti-n approach-CONV clearing-LOC house-ACC see-PST-3SG ‘When he came nearer, he saw a house on a clearing’
(4) Korean (Sohn 2009: 300) Kiho-nun nol-ko ca-ss-eyo. Kiho-TOP play-CONV sleep-PST-POL ‘Kiho played and then slept’
(5) Japanese Taroo-ga bangohan-o tabe-te Taroo-NOM dinner-ACC eat-CONV furo-ni hai-ta. bath-DAT enter-PST ‘Taroo took a bath after he ate dinner’
![Page 27: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
F15. Use of locative existential construction to encode predicative possession
Turkish Ben-de bir kitab var I-LOC a book exist
Khalkha Nad-ed nom bai-n’ I-DAT book be-DUR
Evenki Min-du: kniga bisi-n I-DAT book be-3SG
Manchu Min-de bithe bi I-DAT book be
Korean Na-hanthey chayk-i issta I-DAT book-NOM exist
Japanese Watashi-ni hon-ga aru I-DAT book-NOM exist
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
15 + + + + + + + + + + - + - + - - +
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 28: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
F16. Use of the ablative case form for comparison
(6) Japanese chikyu:-yori omoi globe-ABL be.heavy ‘heavier than the globe’
(5) literary Korean i eyse te khu-n salang this ABL more be.big-ADN love ‘a greater love than this’
(1) Turkish bu araba-dan daha büyük this car-ABL more big ‘bigger than this car
(2) Khalkha ene xun-ees iluu this person-ABL good ‘better than this person’
(3) Evenki oron-duk gugda-tmar deer-ABL tall-COMP ‘taller than a deer’
(4) Manchu ere niyalma ci sain this person ABL good ‘better than this person’
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
16 + + + + + + + - + + - + + - - - -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 29: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
5 Grammaticalization patterns
![Page 30: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
F17. Direct insubordination
Deverbal noun suffix Finite suffix
Old Japanese naga- ‘to be long’ -> naga-sa ‘length’
punapi1to2-wo mi1-ru-ga to2mo2si-sa boat.people-ACC see-NML-GEN be.enviable-FIN ‘How enviable it is to see the boat-people!’
Middle Korean yel- ‘to bear’ -> yel-um ‘fruit’
K onul-un swuep-i eps-um. today-TOP class-NOM not.exist-FIN ‘No class today.’
Manchu mute- ‘be able’ -> mute-re ‘ability’
uthai sin-de bu-re at.once you-DAT give-FIN ‘I shall give [it] to you straight away’
Middle Mongolian quri- ‘come together’ -> quri-m ‘feast’
ulu busire-m. NEG believe-FIN ‘they don’t believe’
Old Turkic tug- ‘be born, rise (of sun)’ -> tug-ar ‘sunrise, east’
ögir-ä savin-ü yorï-r rejoice-CONV be.happy-CONV go.on-FIN ’it happily goes on with its life.’
Khanty Mansi uul- ‘to sleep’ -> uul-əm ‘sleep’
məta wajaɣ lök ənt-im some animal track NEG-FIN ‘There is not a single animal track’
deverbal noun suffix clausal (ad)nominalizer finite suffix
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
17 + + + + + + + + + + + - - - - - -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 31: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
F18. Grammaticalization of non-case marked deverbal noun suffixes into converb suffixes
deverbal noun suffix clausal (ad)nominalizer converb suffix
Deverbal noun suffix Converb suffix
Old Japanesekazas- ‘to adorn’ → kazas-i ‘adornment’
ip-u ko2to2 yam-i1 ino2ti taye-n-ure say-ADN thing stop-CONV life cease-PERF-SUBJ ‘[he] stopped speaking and [his] life ended’
Middle Korean ilwu- ‘to achieve’ → ilwu-k 'achievement'
sywoping sa-kwo tina ka-cye bread buy-CONV pass.CONV go-HORT ‘Let’s buy bread and then continue on our way’
Evenki bagda- ‘to become white’
→ bagda-ma ‘white’Sama-sel eme-mi asi-va-n ice-re shaman-PL come-CONV wife-ACC-3SG see-FIN.3SG
‘Having come, the shamans saw his wife.’
Middle Mongolian quri- ‘come together’ -> quri-m ‘feast’
Khal sour-maan (study-CONV) ‘only if you study’ < -m + -AAn reflexive possessive
Old Turkic yap- ‘to cover (tr.)’ → yap-ï ‘horse-blanket’
toruk at sämrit-i […] yügür-ü bar-mïš lean horse make.fatt-CONV run-CONV go-INFR ‘After a lean horse fattened itself, it went running’
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
17 + + + + + + + + + + - - - - - - -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 32: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
F19. Grammaticalization from negative verb to verbal negator
inflecting negative auxiliary verb + lexical verb in an adnominal form
independent negative verb
negative particle + inflecting lexical verb
negative suffix on inflecting lexical verb
![Page 33: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
F19. Grammaticalization from negative verb to verbal negator
independent verb particle / suffix
Tungusic
Evenki esile e-dyeli-m tadu-gla now NEG-FUT-1SG there-ENCL
‘Now I will not be (live) there.’
Nanai xola:-ci-si read.NEG-PST-2SG ‘You didn’t read.’
Written Mongolianükü-be-üü ese-be-üü
die-PST-INTER NEG-PST-INTER ‘Did [he] die or did [he] not?’
manu baɣši ese ire-be our teacher NEG come-PST ‘Our teacher did not come.’
Old Japanses-uru sube1-no2 na-sa do-ADN way-GEN NEG-NML ‘Nothing can be done.’
ki1mi1-ga k-i1-mas-an-u lord-GEN come-CONV-deign-NEG-ADN ‘You did not come, [my] lord.’
Turkic
Chu. epĕ kil-melle mar I come-DEB NEG *ma-r NEG-FIN ‘I don’t have to come’
OT kod-ma-ŋ-lar put-NEG-IMP-PL ‘don’t put!’
Uralic proto-Uralic *e- negative auxiliary Khanty ǝntǝ negative particle
Mandarin bu / mei ‘not exist’ bu / mei verbal negator
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
19 + + + + + + + + + + + - - - - - -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 34: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
F20. Grammaticalization of plural/collective markers on first person pronoun into inclusive/exclusive distinction
first person pronoun first person + PL/COLL + collective/plural
inclusive/exclusive
Old Turkic biz ‘we’ biz-ler (we-PL) ‘we (as a group)’
Shor 1PL IMP = EXCL Shor 1 PL IMP + -lar PL = INCL
Middle Mongolian
ba ‘we’ bi ‘I’ *bi-da I-PL
ba ‘we (EXCL) bida ‘we (INCL)’
Manchu pTg *bö 'we' *bö-(x)e (we-COL) *bö-se (we-COL)
be 'we (EXCL)’ muse 'we (INCL)'
Evenki pTg *bö 'we' *bö-(x)e (we-COL) *bö-ti (we-COL)
bu 'we (EXCL)' mut ~ mit 'we (INCL)'
Middle Korean wuli 'we' wuli-tul we-PL
‘we (as a group)’
Japonic OJ wa- 'I/we' Kikai wa-naa I-PL Kikai wa-tjaa I-COL
Kikai wa-naa ‘we (EXCL)’ Kikai wa-tjaa ‘we (INCL)’
Ainu cóka ‘we (EXCL)’ aoka ‘we (INCL)’
Nivkh n’yŋ (EXCL) mer ~ mir 'we (INCL)'
Chinese wǒ-men ‘we (EXCL)’ zán-men ‘we (INCL)’
Rukai -nai ~ nai- ‘we (EXCL)’ -mita ~ ta- ‘we (INCL)’
Tk OT
Kh
MMo
Evk M
aK M
KJ O
J
Kh
Ket
Yk
Niv
Ain
Ch
Rk
20 - + + + + + - - - + - - - - - - -
Tk (pre-) OT
Kh (pre-) MMo Evk (pre-)
MaK (pre-)
MKJ (pre-)
OJKhn Ket Yk Niv Ain Ch Rk
![Page 35: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
![Page 36: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Decrease of typological similarity over time
"over time the families [of Northern Eurasia] have come to resemble each other more and more in structural typology, …”
Nichols (2011: 177)
![Page 37: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Delimitation Transeurasian from Uralic type
“there are no … typological features that are specific only to "Altaic" without Uralic".
Janhunen (2014: 331)
F Altaic/Transeurasian Uralic
1 tongue root vowel harmony palatal harmony
4 voicing distinction for stops original singleton-geminate distinction
5 non-verbal strategy for verbal borrowing direct insertion
7 mixed and switched encoding of property words nominal encoding
9 bare stems as imperatives marking of imperatives with second person suffixes
13 dependent-marking in possessive noun phrases original head-marking in Uralic
18 grammaticalization of non-case marked deverbal noun suffixes into converb suffixes peripheral case-marked deverbal noun suffixes
20 inclusive/exclusive distinction on first person pronoun
lack of an inclusive-exclusive distinction on its person pronouns.
![Page 38: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Areal vs. genealogical patterns
• History: decrease of typological similarity over time
• Geography: absence of features in spite of geographical proximity and sharing of features in spite of geographical isolation
• Distribution: structural uniformity originally lower in Korean (70%) than in Japanese (90%)
• Recurrent grammaticalization: prototypical Transeurasian structures are cyclically renewed by new morphological means
• Isomorphism: structural parallels combine with formal correspondences
![Page 39: Stable structures of Transeurasian - Uni Kiel · Janhunen (2014: 331) "speaking of "Altaic" instead of "Ural-Altaic" is a misconception, for there ... • Dataset • 20 shared typological](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071101/5fda2ce9c9a120645e4d5bf0/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Conclusion
• over time Transeurasian languages have come to resemble each other less in certain typological features
• possible to delimit a Transeurasian structural type from a Uralic one
• residue of features of common ancestor