standards infrastructure as a national growth engine: from imitator, imovator, to innovator por dr....
DESCRIPTION
Exposición en la conferencia internacional del 23 de agosto "PERÚ, PAÍS COMPETITIVO: IMPACTO DE LA INNOVACIÓN Y LA CALIDAD EN LA APERTURA COMERCIAL"TRANSCRIPT
23 August 2011 (version 2)
Donggeun CHOI Chief Manager, Korean Standards Association (KSA)
Guest Researcher, National Institute of Standards and Technology (USA)
Standards Infrastructure as a National Growth Engine:
from Imitator, Imovator, to Innovator
1
Contents
I. Warming Up Quiz about South Korea
II. Korea’s Economic Growth
III.Economic Growth with Korean Standards
IV. Changing Global Business Environments
V. Future Agenda 2
Q. Basics of about S-Korea?
Q1. Where is it?
Q2. How warm/cool is it?
Q3. How big is it?
Q4. How many live there?
Q5. How many live in Seoul Metropolitan area?
Q6. What is the GDP in 2010?
Q7. What is the GDP ratio of 2010 by 1960?
Q8. What is the ranks of GDP and Trade in 2011?
4
Q1. S-Korea: where is it? Where is Korean Peninsula Located in Asia?
1) North-Eastern Asia
2) North-Western Asia
3) South-Eastern Asia
4) South-Western Asia
*Between China and Japan
5
Q2. S-Korea: how warm/cool is it? What is the common weather of Seoul, S-Korea?
1) August:51°F-66°F, January: 01°F-15 °F
2) August:61°F-76°F, January: 11°F-25 °F
3) August:71°F-86°F, January: 19°F-33 °F
4) August:81°F-96°F, January: 29°F-43 °F
6
Q3. S-Korea: how big is it? S-Korea is around OO% of Peru in size
1) 8%
2) 13%
3) 18%
4) 23%
* South Korea: 100,032 km2, Peru: 1,285,216 km2,
- Lima region: 32,129km2, - Junin regoin: 44,197 km2, - Pasco region: 25,319 km2
7
Q4. S-Korea: how many live there? S-Korea is around OO% of Peru in population
1) 75%
2) 115%
3) 145%
4) 165%
* Peru: 30,135,875; S-Korea: 50,004,441 (2012 July)
8
Q5. S-Korea: how many live in Seoul Metropolitan area?
Seoul Metropolitan area (Seoul plus 50k near by area)
is around OO% of Peru in population
1) 25%
2) 50%
3) 75%
4) 100%
* Seoul metropolitan : 23,616,000 (Seoul + Incheon + Gyeonggi
province)
9
Q6. S-Korea: What is the GDP in 2011?
Which country is most comparable (IMF, PPP, $Million)?
1) Argentina (716,419)
2) Brazil (2,293,954)
3) Mexico (1,661,640)
4) Peru (301,967)
10
Q7. S-Korea: What is the GDP ratio of 2010 by 1960?
What is the growth rate 1960-2010?
1) 50 times
2) 100 times
3) 200 times
4) 250 times
* Peru: 2.5B to 154B (60times)
11
**GDP nominal in 1960-2010 - 4B to 1,000B (250 times)
13B to 1,000B (Mexico 75 times), 15.2B to 2,100 B (Brazil, 130 times)
12
**GDP per Capita in 1960-2010 - 155 to 22,424 (nominal)
13
Value of imported goods and services as percentage of GDP.
Q8. S-Korea: What is the ranks of GDP and Trade in 2011?
GDP nominal and Trade volume ranks?
1) GDP: 8th - Trade: 15th
2) GDP: 12th - Trade: 22nd
3) GDP: 15th - Trade: 8th
4) GDP: 22nd - Trade: 12th
* Exports(7th) and Import(8th)
14
So, What do these mean? - Korea’s Development
Rapid and Successful Development in the 1960s-90s
Short and Quick Industrialization History
Government Leadership based Success
Limited Private Sector Leadership
Export/Imports Trade Dependent Country
All of above applies to Standards Infrastructure
US-Korea is major trading partners in both Goods/Services
Standards Governance of Trade Partner May Matter
15
II. Korea's Economic Growth
16
1. Korea’s Economic Growth - GDP and Export
17
Korea’s National Strategy
Export-driven Growth Strategy
Globally-harmonized Open Policy
GDP (12th )
Export (9th)
GDP: (1970) 3 B-USD (2009) 1,364 B-USD
Export: (1970) 0.8 B-USD (2009) 364 B-USD
Source: IMF
2. Korea’s Economic Growth – World Class Product
The number of Korea’s World Class Products has grown ten times: (‘01) 55 products (‘09) 387 + 197
World Class: ranked within top 5 in global market share Movie clip of ‘Korea’s World Class Products’ (MKE)
18
3. Korea’s Economic Growth – World No.1 Products
Korean Product with No.1 Global Market Share (2002) 49 Products (2009) 148 Products
Expansion of world No.1 products has been supported by export-driven policy and globally-harmonized standardization strategy
19
Products M.Share Companies
Memory/DRAM 50.0%Samsung Electronics,
Hynix
TFT-LCD 46.0%Samsung Electronics,
LG Philips LCD
PDP 52.0%Samsung SDI,
LG Electronics
LNG Carrier 73.0%Hyundai Heavy Industry,
Samsung Heavy Industry
CDMA Mobile Phones 38.0%Samsung Electronics,
LG Electronics
Flash Memory 54.0%Samsung Electronics,
Hynix
Industrial Monitor 70.0% Kortech
large-size marine
diesel engine61.3%
Hyundai Heavy Industry,
Doosan Engine
4. Korea: Industry Development - 1950s to 2010s
50-60s Raw, Agric,
Marine.
70s Light Industry
Fabrics, Clothing
80s Heavy Industry
Ship, Auto
90s EE product
00s ICT
10s Smart Product
Knowledge Serv
20
5. Korea: National Priority Evolution - Standards and Quality Infrastructure
‘60: Legislation, Organizations
• ISA, MA, PSA
‘70-’80 : Quality Control
• KS certification, TQC, QC-Circle, Quality Control
’90 : Quality Management
• ISO 9000, WTO-TBT, International Standard
‘00 : Internet, Climate Change
• Web-base technology, E-commerce, GHG reduction,
• Sustainability
’10 : Smart Technology, Convergence Industry
• IT-convergence, mobile, smart phone, smart car, smart home, smart city
21
6. Korea: Key Legislation Timeline 1949 Agriculture Inspection Act
1961 Industrial Standardization Act
1961 Measurement Act *1992 Act on Weight and Measurement *2000 Measures Act
1967 Industrial Product Safety Control Act *1993 Quality Management Promotion Act *2000 Quality Management and Industrial Products Safety Control Act
1974 Electrical Appliances Safety Control Act
1980 R.O.Korea’s Constitution (27 Oct)
The State shall establish a system of national standards.
1999 National Standards Framework Act
2010 Framework Act on Product Safety
22
7. Korea: Key Legislation - Standards, CA, Measurement
23
8. Korea: Key Organization Timeline 1961 Bureau of Standards (within Ministry of Commerce)
*1973 (IAA) Industrial Advancement Administration
*1999 (KATS) Korean Agency for Technology and Standards
* merged with National Technology and Quality Agency
- 1994 (KOLAS) Korean Laboratory Accreditation System (AB for labs)
- 2001 (KAS) Korean accreditation system (AB for product certification)
1962 (KSA) Korean Standards Association
1975 (KSRI) Korean Standards Research Institute
*1991 (KRISS) Korean Research Institute for Standards and Science
1990 (KASTO) Korea Association of Standards & Testing Organizations
1995 (KCA) Korean Association for Quality and Environment
Certification * 2001 (KAB) Korean Accreditation Board
24
9. Korea: Key Organizations
25
G
G
G
G
III. Economic Growth and Korean Standards
26
1. Korean Standards – Publications 1962-2009
300 1081
1846
4698
7029 7475 8552
9368
10845
15176
19865
22058
23372
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
62 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 00 02 04 06 09
•1962-2000 : Zero to 10,000+ KSs • Production Based Standards; Mainly from JIS, BS, DIN, ASTM, etc
•2000-2010 : 10,000 to 20,000+ KSs • Function based Standards; Mainly from ISO, IEC
Imitator
Imitator
+Innovator
= Imovator
27
Mainly from JIS,
BS, DIN, ASTM, etc
Mainly
from ISO, IEC
2. Korean Standards – Number of Publications
KS iSO/IEC DIN BS JIS
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,031 39,555
23,372
10,864
24,229
40,000
No. of Standards
Quantitatively, the number of KS is world class level
Similar to the total volume of ISO plus IEC
Consideration of industrial changes,
Korea employed new classification system in KS: In line with ISO ICS (International Classification System)
More standards on functions and processes than product standards
I E C 6,146
ISO 18,083
28
3. Korean Standards – mainly originated from ISO/IEC
29
Original (15%)
JIS, BS, DIN,
ASTM, etc (24%)
ISO, IEC (61%)
as of
Dec 2007
Statistics 61% identical/modified from ISO, IEC
24% based on JIS, BS, DIN, ASTM, etc
15% purely Korean
Strategy Harmonized
with Int’l Standards
Originated from advanced formal or non-formal standards
These National Standards Have Assisted Korea Economic Growth Institutionally
30
4. Korean Standards – KS Certification
KS Certification in 1985 – 2005 (cumulative)
KS Certification of KS (based on ISO, IEC, other advanced standards) Contributed to the Development of World Class Korean Products
Semiconductor, Ship-building, Automobiles, TFT-LCD
Knowledge and Technology transferred to developed countries
Number of Certification
Number of Factories
Number of Standards
30
5. Korean Standards - ISO Certification in Korea The double increase of ISO 9001/14001/TS16949 Certifications
have facilitated Korean Export, thus Economic Growth Higher Level of Openness and Advancement of Socio-Economic Infrastructure
31 (Source: ISO Survey 2004 and 2008)
ISO 9001 : 11th(‘04) 10th (‘09)
ISO 14001: 10th (’04) 6th (‘08)
TS 16949 : 6th (‘04) 3rd (’08)
32
6. Quality Activities in Korea
Number of Quality Circles
2003~2005 Listed Companies
Companies
with QC Circles
Average Profit Ratio
No
Yes 1,240
289 No
0.0415
-0.0517
Yes
Companies with QC Circles Reported Higher Profit Ratio
KS and ISO Certifications have triggered QC Activities
QC Activities have positive impact on Business Performance in Korea
32
IV. Changing Global Biz Environments
33
V. Standards and Trade & Innovation
34
ISO, IEC, …
JIS, DIN, …
1. Imitator, Imovator, and to Innovator in Standardization
35
Law • Legislation
• Regulation
Mark • Certification
• Test/Inspection
Award • Promotion
• Competition
Korean E
conomic G
rowth
Standards have functioned as a mechanism for
knowledge and technology transfer in Korean economic growth. It started from the position of imitator, has evolved to imovator, and will transform to innovator in the upcoming years.
36
2. Strengthening ‘Research’ Activities domestically and internationally
Trade/FTAs Public Policy Economic
Impact
Business Strategy
Corporate Intelligence
Open Source Model
R&D-IPR-Standards
Technology Innovation
Service Innovation
Case Studies HRD
Education … …
37
3. Standards and Trade “New rules will determine who flourishes, and who falls
behind. At the heart of those new rules are standards.
Honourable John Manley, Canadian Minister of Industry (March
2000)
“From a macroeconomic perspective, it is significant that
standards make a greater contribution to economic growth
than patents or licenses…. Innovation potential alone is not
sufficient to maintain competitiveness. An efficient
dissemination of innovation via standards is a precondition
for economic growth.”
“Economic Benefits of Standardization Summary of Results”
Published by DIN German Institute for Standardization (2000)
**Korea’s trade statistics
38
**Peru’s trade statistics
39
**Brazil’s trade statistics
40
41
"Approximately 80 percent of international trade is affected by standards
and the health, safety and environmental regulations that incorporate the
m. The Department of Commerce is pledged to ensuring level playing field
s for US manufacturers and exporters by urging our trading partners to a
dopt market-driven performance standards, and to seek assurance of confo
rmity to agreed-upon standards so that we can achieve the goal of "one te
st, one time, accepted everywhere.“
Dr. Arden Bement, Director, National Institute of Standards and Technology (20
02)
“At the international level, standards are becoming a pillar of the new glo
bal trade system. As barriers to trade and investment are eliminated and
information technologies continue to evolve, standardization is taking on
an increasingly important role in global affairs.”
“Canadian Standards Strategy and Implementation Proposals” (March
2000)
4. Standards, Innovation and Competitiveness
42
Standardization
Testing /Inspection
Certification
Accreditation
Legal Metrology Calibration
Measurement
**SCaM is tech-quality infra
43
5.1 Task – Three sectors (not separately)
CA M S
44
5.2 Task – Governance: who/what Government led?
Industry led?
Partnership?
Model country?
USA?
Germany?
Japan?
Government
Industry
45
5.3 Task – Standards harmonization and development
Gold-powder/Zinc/Copper, Oil/Gas/Petroleum,
Coffee/Meat, Machinery
Harmonization with ISO, IEC
Harmonization with Exporting countries
EU, USA, China, Switzerland, Canada
Harmonization with Importing countries
EU, USA, China, Brazil, Ecuador
Developing Pure Peruvian: pros and cons?
What if they are slightly different?
46
5.4 Task – Seven Pillars
Source: NSCAF (KSA 2012)
Infra- structure
Process
Human Resources
Metrology
7
6 4 5
Stakeholders Strategies and
Implementation Plans
2 3
Laws, Systems and Institutions
1
Performance
47
5.4.5 Task – HRD/HRM
Concept
• Cultivation of human resources(education, qualification, eligibility criteria)
• Management system for human resources
• Capability of human resources(size, level)
1) Standardization
• Experts on standards planning(Strategy, needs)
• Experts on standards development
• (development & preparation)
• Experts capable of international standardization activities
48
2) Conformity Assessment
• Policy experts for conformity assessment
• Certification auditor
• Experts for testing, calibration, inspection
• People in charge of quality control
3) Metrology (science, industry, legal)
• Experts on measurement standards development
• Experts on reference materials development
• Experts on reference standards development
• Experts on international measurement standards development and activities
5.3.5 Task HRD/HRM (2)
49
CONCLUSION - Cooperation to move forward together
1) Strategy for Expanded Role/Domain of Standardization
2) Efforts in Human Resources Development for Standardization
3) Serving and Contributing More to Int’l Standards Activities
4) Strengthening ‘Research’ Activities‘ at nationally and internationally
5) Cooperating with our neighbors
Thank you for your attention!
50