standing committee on public accounts · 2020-02-07 · standing committee on public accounts 1st...

STANDING COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

1st SESSION, 40th PARLIAMENT

2012 Special Report from the Office of the Auditor General of Ontario on Ornge Air Ambulance and Related Services

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/001


EXHIBIT LIST

LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document entitled "Background Materials for Hearings on Ornge Air

I Ambulance and Related Services" dated March 23, 2012. ' ! MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE -

Submission, speaking notes for Minister Deb Matthews dated March 28, 2012.

ORNGE- Submission, speaking notes for Ron McKerlie, Interim President and Chief Executive Officer dated March

I 28, 2012.

Exl-IIBifNo.-i 7o6;oo_4 _____ :--F'RA.i\fc£·-· aE:ii-NA._s_=- sli1Jmis-si0;,- -Te1!e~--Ciai-ed -1~~e-- 2: : 2010. I '

Exl-In3IfN"O~-i 7o676osA.· ~- FRA.Nfz" --K.i:-Eifs-, -Mi>i>-----=- · s~b~issia-n:-- ietie~-dateCi December 29,2008.

--- .. ----·--- ------- --·------- _, ··---···-------- ---- - -~------ ---- .. ···--· EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/005B . FRANK KLEES, MPP- Submission, letter dated April 14,

! 2008.

EXHIBIT NO. 1!06/00SC 1 FRANK KLEES, MPP - Submission, document entitled I

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/006A

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/006B


........ -----


! "Performance Agreement Between Her Majesty the Queen : in Right of Ontario as represented by the Minister of Health j and Long-Term Care and Ontario Air Ambulance Services

Co. for the Provision of Air Ambulance and Related Services."

--

i LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document entitled "Ornge Hearings: Press articles for the period of

: March 23-April2" dated April2, 2012.

LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document • entitled "Ornge's Amended Performance ! (2012)" dated April 3, 2012.

Agreement

I ·!-·-------·-·-·- ---· ·-· ·----- ---- -·-·-- ·----··· ·----- --- ···------·----- ------------------- -------ORNGE- Written submission, letter from Interim President and CEO Ron McKerlie dated April 2, 2012.

' ------ ---·--···· ··-· _______ ,, ____________ .......... _______ -- ------ -·--· ---

GEORGE SMITHERMAN - Submission, speaking notes dated April 4, 2012.

.. .. .. - ··- ...... - .... . - - --·- r .. .. - ----· ----- ........... ----- .... .. ·------- ... ... -· ..... - - --- --- ----··· .. -· .... .. --- .. . - ·--·

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/009 I FRANK KLEES, MPP - Submission, entitled "Stakeholder

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/010A

Briefing - Ornge and Ornge Global Holdings LP" dated January 19, 2012.

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE -: Written submission, letter from the Assistant Deputy ! Minister of Health and Long-Term Care dated April 4, I 2012 .

..... -- -- .. .. ·-----·- ·-· --------·----~-- ------------ --------··-------- -------.--·- ·------ --------- .. .-.. --------EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/010B ; MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE-

l Written submission, letter from the Deputy Minister of

1 Health and Long-Term Care dated April4, 2012. .

-Ex:Hil3ir-No~ i7o67o"i"i---r LEGis"I~A"frvE · ·"REsEA""Rc:H ___ sE:RvicE:-· -_ Do-~l:i~~nt I entitled "Ornge Hearings: Press articles for the period of i April2-16" dated April 16, 2012.

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/012 WILDEBOER DELLECE, LLP - Submission, speaking notes for Alfred Apps dated April 18, 2012.

) ....... . .... ----------·- - --· --------- - ------·- ...... .. . -------------------- .... -- - .............. --------- -EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/013 1 MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE-

I Submission, speaking notes for Malcolm Bates dated April I 18,2012.

EXHII3ITNO.··uo6i014 -t~~~f~:E:sr~~Y.~~on, P~;~;L~~;~-;o~ c~:~~ 1

Bartolotta dated April18, 2012.

EXHIBIT. NO.-f/06/0 15 ---- r FRANK."""ki"EES~--MPP--=- --w~itte~--~;bmi~~i;;~-~~titl~d : "Talking Points for Dr. Chris Mazza" dated April 18, 2012 .

.. - . .. .... . .. "" .... - -- -- ....... -- - -- ... - --+-- ----.. --- .---·- ----·----- ................ ..... ---·····-- ----·---------- -·- ............ ... ---·-------·--EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/016 MINISTRY OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND

TRADE - Written submission, entitled "Follow up: Public Accounts Committee Testimony by Cathy Worden" dated

i April16, 2012.

EXHIBrfNo~/66;oi7A. ___ i""iEGISLA TIVE ----RESEARCH -·s -ERVICE --=---noc~~~nt

.. --· ---------- ·-----.-


~-- .... ·----- ---· EXHIBITNO. 1/06/018A

. -· ·· ···. ------


i entitled "Ornge Air Ambulance Hearings: Background on i 'Indicators of Government Control"' dated April 19, 2012. I r ______ .. __ - ----- -------·--·-·---·------- --- ------------------------ -----. LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document i entitled "Ornge Hearings: Current Press Articles for the ' Period of April 17- 23" dated April24, 2012.

---- -·- ---'"""""'"""" -------·--·- · .. ..... _ -------- - ........... --- ---- ---· . ------- .. ----·-. FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Submission, I document entitled "Fasken Martineau Fees Billed to Ornge

Entities" dated April25, 2012. - "---.-·---- -· •. . -------- ----

FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP- Submission, Research and

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/018C r FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP- Submission, : speaking notes for Lynne Golding dated April25, 2012 .

-·-·--"-


EXHIBIT NO. 1106/021


. .

FRANK KLEES, MPP - Written submission, entitled "Air · Ambulance Reform- MB-20 Submission" dated September

24,2004.

RAINER BEL TZNER - Submission, speaking notes for Rainer Beltzner dated April25, 2012.

WILDEBOER DELLECE, LLP - Written submission i entitled "Questions of Mr. Frank Klees MPP" dated April i 25, 2012.

LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document entitled "Ornge Hearings: Current Press Articles for the Period of April24- 30" dated April 30, 2012.

- -----·- -- -· ---- -- ---·"·-

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/024 i LIZ SANDALS, MPP - Submission, document dated May 2, 2012.

-- --·· ----

EXHIBIT NO. 1106/025 ORNGE - Submission, speaking notes for Patricia Volker dated May 2, 2012.

----

EXHIBIT NO. 1106/026A KELL Y MITCHELL - Submission, speaking notes for Kelly Mitchell dated May 2, 2012.

------

EXHIBIT NO. 1106/026B KELLY MITCHELL - Written submission, document dated May 2, 2012.

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/027 ORNGE- Submission, speaking notes for Steve Farquhar dated May 2, 2012.

··•····-·-i · ·- ···-·•·· ···· -·· ........ ----------- -----···

EXHIBIT NO. 1106/028 FRANK KLEES - Submission, letter from David Caplan, Minister of Health and Long-Term Care to Cliff Friesen, Executive Vice-President, Bearskin Airlines, dated November 6, 2008.

LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document entitled "Ornge Hearings: Background on Witnesses for May 9, 2012- Mr. Rick Potter" dated May 7, 2012.

-- --·-····-

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/029B i LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document · ' entitled "Ornge Hearings: Background on Witnesses for

May 9, 2012- Mr. James Sinclair" dated May 8, 2012.

EXHIBIT No. 1/06io29c -- j LE-?fsLATIVE - RE~EARc.f( -s£~v1-cE- --__:_ - -15-;c~~ent j entitled "Ornge Heanngs: Press · Articles for the Penod of : May 1- May 7, 2012" dated May 7, 2012. ·

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/030 ---------· -·-····· ·-·- ~ . . ··- -·--·-·· --· ·······--------- --- -·· --- - ·-- -------~-.-- -- ______ ..

MINISTRY OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND · INNOVATION - Written submission, document entitled 1 "Minister's Middle East Business Mission January 24 -I February 3, 2011" dated May 3, 2012.

- . - --- ·- -·-··· ·-· -... . .. -- --·- --- -· +· -·--· ·-· ··-- ----- . --·-··--· ···--- -··-- - -· ---- ---- ---· -. ------· -- . ·-·-. EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/031



... --EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/034A

. ----- --- . - · - - - ----- .


-- .. -· --- - ·-·




i FRANK KLEES, MPP - Submission, letter to Attorney

I

General Eric H. Holder, Jr. ofthe United States Department of Justice dated May 6, 2012.

AIR TRANSPORT ASSOCIATION- Written submission, i document entitled "Standing Committee on Public

Accounts Document Request- Wednesday, April 18, 2012" dated April18, 2012.

OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF THE CABINET: Written submission, letter to Committee in regards to j requested documents, dated May 9, 2012 .

. ------- ----~ -- . - -..... ···- ----~- ··- ·- ----- --------- --- -- ·

~ LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document ! entitled "Ornge Hearings: Background on Witnesses for J May 16, 2012" dated May 11 , 2012. I -------------- --- ---- -··· ·---------------------------- -- ----------------- ------ --~

; LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document I entitled "Ornge Hearings: Press articles for the period of ' May 8-14" dated May 14,2012.

1 FRANK KLEES, MPP - Submission, letter from Bernardo 1 Fernandez to Luis H. Navas dated November 4, 2010. I ·!··--------·-- -------------- --~ -------------- ----------. ------- - -------- -----

1 FRANK KLEES, MPP - Submission, document entitled : "The Risky Business of Executive Compensation and I Baking" by Luis Navas. L -- -- --··· - ·· ·--··· ·-- --···- ·--·- --- ---- --· ... --- -- --- -- --- -----·--1 LUIS NA V AS - Submission, information package : including documents entitled "Stakeholder Briefing- Ornge

and Ornge Global Holdings LP"; "Ornge Global: New Business Ventures and New Structure"; "Notice of Annual and Special Meetings of Shareholders to be held on May 11, 20 12 and Management Information Circular of Canadian Helicopters Group Inc"; "Executive

: Compensation"; and "20 10 Qualifications and Experience: , Hay Group Health Care Consulting."

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/037 A



-----· .... EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/039

. .. ...... ----------- ... - -- -EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/040

. ......... ·-· ·- -- --- --EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/041

- -EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/042




- -------------· .......... ----- ---EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/045

T -- - ---- --- ---- -------- - - -------------- ------- --·----· .•• --·-··--------·----- ----·--·-·· ·"

1 JACOB BLUM - Submission, information package

! including documents entitled "Jacob H. Blum Resume";

I "Summary of the Performance Agreement and Rights and Privileges of the MOHLTC and Ornge and MOHLTC's Rights to Terminate"; and "Pre-integration and Post-integration charts."

·I ------ ------------------- ---- ------ .. --------- ---------------------- ----- ----------[ JACOB BLUM - Submission, document entitled "Affidavit ' of Jacob H. Blum" dated May 16,2012. I ..... -------~-. -------- . - -·· --- - . -- •.. -······ ---- --. ------··· ---- -- - - ----·-------- - ----- -·-·-

: MARIA RENZELLA - Submission, information package ' including documents entitled "Speaking Notes for Maria

Renzella"; and "Resume for Maria Renzella." -----·-- ------- ------------.... --- _____________ _____ ____ ,,, ..... ---- .... , --------- ··- - --

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE -i Written submission, entitled "Responses to Questions I

: Raised at the Standing Committee on Public Accounts ; regarding the Independent Health Facilities Act and the' I Health Facilities Special Orders Act."

j ________________ ------------------- ----------- - .. ------------------------ --------------- ...... ----' OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF THE CABINET ....., · Written submission, letter to the Clerk of the Committee , from William Bromm, Legal Counsel and Special Advisor

.. ~~~t~~ ~~~--~ :' ~~-1~- · --- - ------- - - - -------- - ------1 KELL Y MITCHELL - Written Submission, information 1 package including documents entitled: "Services Agreement 1

dated 23 August 2010"; "The Progressive Conservative , Party of Ontario - letter from Lynne Golding to Chris

Mazza"; and "Certificate dated 1 January 2011." _I - -------- --- --- ····· ---- ................. - - ......... _____ - - ---- - -- --- -··---·- ---- -- -- -·----- - -·--·-

1 MINISTRY OF FINANCE - Written submission, letter ; from Tim Shortill, Chief of Staff, Ministry of Finance to the i Standing Committee on Public Accounts dated May 16, i 2012.

l i£oisLA.rivE ___ RESEARC-IT sERvicE·---= n~~~e~t ! entitled "Ornge Hearings: Press articles for the period of

1 May 15-22" dated May 23, 2012. ---' ....... -.... --~- - .. -··· -·-----·. ~--··· -.

1 LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document ' entitled "Ornge Hearings: Background on Witnesses for · May 30, 2012" dated May 24, 2012. I

" ... --· ···--···--· ----·· .. ·-·····--·· ·--- ...... ___ -.-.---

. FRANK KLEES, MPP - Submission, document entitled 1 "Investigations Concerning Air Ambulance and Related ! Services" dated May 23, 2012.

:·· rfiol\1A:s ___ :RcifHFELs----=- s;b-~i~~io~,-d~~-~e~t--~~titi~d I 1 "Resume for Thomas M. Rothfels."

-- ·---·- · · ---~- - ---

EXHIBIT NO. 1106/046 ! LUIS NA V AS - Written submission, document entitled 1

"Resume for Luis Navas" dated May 22, 2012. --- ----- ---------·--------- -------~------------------- --------- ------------ ---- ---- -- --------

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/047 1 TOM LEPINE - Submission, document entitled "Resume i for Tom Lepine."

-------------- - ---------- -~- ---------------------------- ----------------- - --- ------- ------ ----------------- - --EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/048 i AIR TRANSPORT ASSOCIATION OF CANADA -

! Written submission, letter dated May 25, 2012. -- -- --- --- ------- ------------- --------- ---- -------- +---- ----------------------- ---------------------- -- ---- ---------------------------- ---- ------EXHIBITNO. 1/06/049A j LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document

1 entitled: "Omge Hearings: Background on Witnesses for

: June 6, 2012" dated May 31, 2012. --- -- --------------- ___ ______ L_ ______________________ -- - ---------------------------------------------

EXHIBIT NO. l/06/049B ' LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document



. ---- - - - - -- ·-··--- -- -- ------------ ---·--

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/050C

---- ----------.. ------·· ··------

entitled: "Omge Hearings: Press articles for the period of May 29 to June 4" dated June 4, 2012.

I TREVOR KIDD- Submission, speaking notes for Trevor 1 Kidd dated June 6, 2012. L __________________ ---- ___ c _____ --------- -------- ------------- ___ ------------ __ _

I TREVOR KIDD - Submission, document dated June 6, i 2012.

-r-·--- --------------------------------- ------ ------------ ------ ------ ----, ! TREVOR KIDD - Submission, document entitled "Resume i for Trevor Kidd, Paramedic" dated June 6, 2012.

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/051A I CYNTHIA HEINZ - Submission, document entitled 1 "Supplementary Notes - Ontario Legislature Public' ! Accounts Committee" dated June 6, 2012.

--- -----· ----- ------------ -· -- -------------- - -- -----L- ------ ------------------ ---------·-------------------- ----- ----·- ·-- ---------------- ----- --- ... ' EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/051B i CYNTHIA HEINZ - Submission, document entitled

I "Omge Corporate Org Chart" dated January 1, 2012.

EXHIBIT NO. uo61051c -r- cmfH:iA.- HEINZ -- -- Submission:·-·--do~ti'me~t- ~ntitled ! "Resume for Cynthia Heinz" dated June 6, 2012. J -- --------------------------- --- ---- ... ----- --- -------·- -- ·-- --· - . ------

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/052 1

ORNGE - Written submission, document entitled ' "Documents Directed to be Produced" dated June 5, 2012. I --· -- - -- ............ - ----- ............... .. ·t·-- ·------- ------- -------·----------- - - ------ ------------ --- -- .. -------- -------------- --------- ..

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/053A ' FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Written I submission, letter entitled "Time Entries for Fasken ! Martineau DuMoulin LLP relating to Services to Omge

_________ ....... ________ ________ ---~- ~~~~~~:' da~~~~~~~~:-~~-~~-~ ______ __ _________ ---------------EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/053B i FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Written

I submission, document entitled "Time Entries for Omge j Entities" dated May 31 , 2012.

EXHIBIT. NO~ i ;0'67054A -· TLE.GISL-ATIVE--REi~iEARCH SERVicE -=- DoZ~~nt

1

1 entitled "Hearings (June 13, 2012) on Ornge Ambulance

1 and Related Services: Background Information on

I Witnesses" dated June 8, 2012.






···- ------ - - . - - ·--·-····- .. ·-·-MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE-

. Submission, speaking notes for Malcolm Bates dated June I 13,2012.

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE: Written submission, letter to the Chair dated June 12, 2012.

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CAREsubmission, document entitled "Land/ Air·

Ambulance Investigations and Inspections."

FRANK KLEES, MPP - Submission, chart entitled "Performance Agreement Annual Report Checklist -January to July 2006."

FRANK KLEES, MPP - Submission, chart entitled "Investigations Concerning Air Ambulance and Related Services" dated May 23, 2012.

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE__: Submission, speaking notes for Ruth Hawkins dated June 26, 2012.

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARESubmission, speaking notes for Rick Brady dated June 26, 2012.

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CAREWritten submission, letter to the Clerk of the Committee entitled "Motions from June 13" dated June 15,2012.

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/058D 1 MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE-1 Written submission, report entitled "Ministry of Health and

Long-Term Care's 2009 Audit Report by Meyers Norris Penny."

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/058E MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CAREWritten submission, letter to the Clerk of the Committee entitled "Motions from June 13" dated June 19, 2012.

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/065 LIZ SANDALS, MPP - Submission, email from Chris Mazza entitled "For you to forward as appropriate" dated November 1, 2007.

-- --- ----------------- ---- ------- -- -- -- ------ -------EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/066 FRANK KLEES, MPP- Submission, document dated May

123, 2012.

EXHIBiiNo~ ilo67o6-7A. ___ -,- iE:ars"LA.rrv£·-- iffi-s E:AR:cf"f ___ s_:ER.vic:E------n~-zli~~ili

! entitled "Hearings (July 18, 2012) on Omge Ambulance 1 and Related Services: Background Information on Witness"

dated July 13, 2012. ---·----·--· --- - ----.-······---- .- ------------ -- - -------- --------- --·· --------· ------------· ···-----------·

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/067B LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document 1 entitled "Omge Hearings: Press articles for the period of

1 June 22 to July 13, 2012" dated July 13, 2012.

------- ----- -------------------~ ---i-- ------------------- ---------- ------ ---- ------- -- -- ---------EXHIBITNO. 1/06/068 1 MINISTRY OF FINANCE - Written submission, e-mail

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/069A

. .. ·--······--


I entitled "Public Accounts Document Request from I

' Wednesday, June 13, 2012" dated June 27, 2012.

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CAREWritten submission, e-mail entitled "Update on Motions from June 13th, dated June 27, 2012.

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CAREWritten submission, e-mail from James Stewart, Director of

i Policy, entitled "response" with attachments: "Memo from I Forensic Investigation Team" and "Letter from Rainer ; Beltzner dated December 15, 2008" dated July 4, 2012. I - --- . . -· ... - -- -----·- -- -- - ... . --- ----------- -·/·· ------- -------- - ---- --·- -~- -- -----· ---. -- - ·------------- --------- ---~--------- -----· ---- ·-

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/069C i MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE-' Written submission, letter to the Clerk of the Committee

entitled "Document request update" with attachments: "Standing Committee on Public Accounts: Motions or Requests from SCOPA Affecting MOHLTC" and

1 "Occurrence Number Investigation Reports 1 to 15" dated i July 16, 2012. I

Exrfrn"ri -No.-ilo67o76 ____ : i rs·A-KIRBIE .=·-w;.-itt~~-s~1J~is~ion~ -Iette~ to -th~ --chci~


- -·· ..... ~ ..... . . .



, dated July 18, 2012. I ------ ~--- -----·-···- ----------·-·-·-···· .. · -· ··-·- ----- --· --· - ·--- -----------·-·· -·- ·-··~-· ·-··········--- ·-·· - ·· ··· ·-.. -···- ·---· -·~ ·-~

i CITY OF OSHA W A - Written submission, e-mail entitled ! "Standing Committee on Public Accounts - Document : Request June 26th, dated July 18, 2012.

i 11\co B-BLui\X ~- Writte~-sub~is-sion, · l~tt~~-ciaieci "Jii1)r 17, 1 2012. L. ------- ------- -- ------ ------------------------- -- --- ------- - ---- ----- ---------- --------- --- -- -------- --: FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Written 1 submission, letter dated July 17, 2012.


- --


- ··- ·-- - · ' -

WILDEBOER DELLECE, LLP - Written submission, e-mail from Alfred Apps to the Clerk of the Committee entitled "Public Accounts Committee- Correction".

--WILDEBOER DELLECE, LLP - Written submission, document entitled "The Ornge Scandal: Media Errors, Political Gamesmanship, and the Auditor General's Dereliction of Duty" dated July 15, 2012.

- --···

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE -Submission, speaking notes for Minister Deborah Matthews dated July 31,2012.

BRUCE WADE - Written submission, letter from the Minister of Health and Long-Term Care dated April 2, 2012.

FRANK KLEES, MPP - Written submission, letter entitled "AW139 Safety Concerns - Medical Operations and

i Mission Readiness" dated February 23, 2011. ---·---- ·····--- _,._, ______ ,_ ----· -·-····-

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/077B FRANK KLEES, MPP - Written submission, e-mail



: entitled "Final Draft for Ornge consolidated F IS FO 11" · dated July 22, 2011.

- ·-FRANK KLEES, MPP - Written submission, entitled

I "meeting minutes from August 18, 2011" dated August 18, 2011.

---

PHIL MCNEELY, MPP- Written submission, e-mail from John Cunnane to Ron McKerlie dated July 30, 2012.

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/087 T TREVOR. KIDD - Written submissio;;::-docu~e;_t-e~titled : "Document Sent to Frank Klees - April 2011" dated June 6, . 2012.

. . . . -· ..... .. ..... ·--- . -----····· ........ --· -+ ----- - ········-·-······· EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/088A POUL-ERIK BINDERUP - Written submission, e-mail

I

' entitled "Letter from Omge Air Pilots" dated July 30, 2012. ~ ····--···· -------- -------·-·------ _}_~--- -------···- .... -- ------ ··--· ----- ------------ -- ---------- --- -----·



1 POUL-ERIK BINDERUP - Written submission, e-mail [ entitled "Pilots Letter to the Standing Committee" dated 1 July 30, 2012. I

··-- -- ----------- --··

! RICK POTTER - Written submission, e-mail entitled 1 "Standing Committee on Public Accounts Document

Request" with attachments: "Omge Invoice April 2012"; "Invoice Requisition-OG Hours Rick Potter"; and "2011 T4

! Slip for Rick Potter" dated July 30, 2012. --- ------- -----· ------- ---·---~---- -------------i-------- --- ----------~- ------------- -------------~ - - ---------------------------- --

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/090A FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Written submission, letter dated July 20, 2012.

.. . . -- -. ----- -------- ---------- ------- ---------- - ... -------- ----.- ------ -· --------- """ ------EXHIBITNO. 1/06/090B : FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Written

submission, document entitled "Response to the June 13 ; Request of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts to

Fasken Martineau DuMoulin, LLP: Volume 1." . .. . . ---- · ---------------·--·· ·--- ·-------------------------------- .. - ··- ---- ·····' - - -

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/090C FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Written I submission, document entitled "Response to the June 13

Request of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts to Fasken Martineau DuMoulin, LLP: Volume 2."

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/090D

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/090E

- - -- -- ------- ------- -- --

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/090F


- . .. -- ----- --·. - "" -~---

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/090H

; FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Written

1 submission, document entitled "Response to the June 13

1 Request of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts to ; Fasken Martineau DuMoulin, LLP: Volume 3." ' ----·--··---------- ··--·----·-···- ···· -·····-·----- --·- - . ~ FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Written , submission, document entitled "Response to the June 13 1 Request of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts to

Fasken Martineau DuMoulin, LLP: Volume 4."

FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Written submission, document entitled "Response to the June 13 Request of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts to Fasken Martineau DuMoulin, LLP: Volume 5."

FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP - Written submission, document entitled "Response to the June 13 Request of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts to

i ;~~;E~~:~~~;;;i~~~~~~;;e;~~ -Writtell ' i submission, letter dated July 30, 2012.

- -

--- --- ---- ------- --·- ··-···---- -- ------ -----~ ------·---- --·---------------- ----~~---- ---·--------·-------- ------------ ---------- ----EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/090I 1 FASKEN MARTINEAU DUMOULIN, LLP -Written


I submission, document entitled "Response to the June 13 : Request of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts to I Fasken Martineau DuMoulin, LLP: Volume 7."

RON SAPSFORD - Submission, speaking notes for Ron Sapsford dated August 1, 2012 .

. .. ··--· ----··- ··---------- ·-·---------1------EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/092


MEYERS NORRIS PENNY - Written submission, document entitled "Whistle Blower Procedure" dated January 17, 2008.

DA VID ZIMMER, MPP - Written submission, e-mail entitled "FYI re Omge" from Ken Flynn to Rainer Beltzner" dated December 24, 2011.

--- - -·-· --- -·-···· --- -- ---··--- ------------------ --~-- .. ----- -·- ------~---- ----------- -------- ---~. ---------------·

EXHIBIT NO~ 1/06/094 I FR~<\.NK K~~ES, MPP - Written submission, docu~ent ; entitled "Mm1stry Responses to MNP RecommendatiOns i Regarding Omge."

- ----- ·---- .. -- ·- - -·--·-·-·· -- _____ j_ ---·····- ·· ··---·--· -- ---------···-----------------·-----·-------------· EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/095A CANADIAN HELICOPTERS LIMITED - Written

submission, resume for Rob Blakely. -- -- -·-··-·---- ------·-·-· ··---·-·-·--- ----- -f--·------·---·-

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/095B CANADIAN HELICOPTERS LIMITED - Written i submission, document entitled "Dedicated Helicopter 1 Dispatch Reliability, Ontario: 2007-2010."

--·. .. -- - . ..1~--------------·-···---- --·--·------ -------·-·----··-·-- ·-- -- --·------------ --· -- ·- -------EXHIBIT NO. 1106/095C i CANADIAN HELICOPTERS LIMITED - Written

l submission, letter dated July 30, 2012.

E:X"f£113iTNo. -i;o6ic)956- -~cA.NA.brA:tT -ti£Irc6i'ffRs--LIMITED-----~---- w~itte-;

-


.......


EXHIBIT NO. 1106/098A

submission, document dated August 1, 2012 with attachments: "Affidavit of Robert Blakely"; and "Legal Proceedings Resulting in Consent Order." . -·- --- --· · ·- . ·-- ---- ---· -·-·-·--· -------- -·--- -- -------- -------·-- ·-·- ----- ------------ ··----ORNGE - Written submission, resume for Julius U eckermann.

; -MwisiRV-oF-THE-A.fT6R-NEY: . GENERAL·-=- \v~itte~ i submission, letter to the Clerk of the Committee entitled I "Special Report of the Office of the Auditor General of

Ontario on Omge Air Ambulance and Related Services" dated August 1, 2012.

OFFICE OF THE INTEGRITY COMMISSIONER OF ONTARIO AND LOBBYISTS REGISTRATION OFFICE - Submission, speaking notes for Lynn Morrison, Integrity Commissioner dated August 2, 2012.



I OFFICE OF THE INTEGRITY COMMISSIONER OF i ONTARIO AND LOBBYISTS REGISTRATION OFFICE I - Written submission, e-mail entitled "Correspondence

from the Lobbyists Registrar" dated April24, 2012.

FRANK KLEES, MPP - Written submission, Hansard dated May 16, 2012.

----- - ... - -- -------- ·-- -----· -- -·-·- ----- --- + -·--·-- ------ -------·-··------EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/100

1 MINISTRY OF FINANCE - Written submission,

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/101

--- ....


I, document entitled "Review of Air Ambulance and Related Services Provided to the Province of Ontario as Governed by the Performance Agreement Between the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care and Omge."

LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Document entitled: "Proposed Table of Contents - Issues and

1 Observations Paper, Omge Air Ambulance Hearings" dated

, August 1, 2012. ' -1--- ------ - --- --------- ---- ·-- •. -· -- - ------ - ..•. ._ - --------------------- ------ - --- -

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG-TERM CARE -; Written submission, e-mail entitled "Update on Responses" I dated August 1, 2012. I -- . -- ------ r-·-------- --------------- -------.------ .. , ...... ....... ·---- -·-- ---------- ____ __ .. ______________ ---------------------------------------- ·------·-------------

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/103 I FRANCE GELINAS, MPP - Submission, e-mail entitled I "Legislative Hearings" dated July 27, 2012.

- - ---·---- -. -··- ·-·-··- ···--·--- -+-- -- -------- ----------. --···-- ---·----- ------------ -- --- ------------------ --- --------------EXHIBITNO. 1/06/104A I FRANK KLEES, MPP- Submission, e-mail dated July 31

i 2012. ' .... - ·---· ------.- -- ------------- - ---- ·--- --- ----~---- -------- --------------------- -------- -- -- ----~-----

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/104B

EXHIBIT NO. 1/0611 05A

... -----·······.

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/105B

EXHIBIT NO. 1/061105C

I FRANK KLEES, MPP - Submission, article entitled "Thunder Bay without Omge Helicopter Service" dated August 28, 2012. '

- -------·-- - ---··· -·-·--·-···-····· ·- -···· ---------- -----· ---·-------------- ··-···- --- - - ---------

LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Submission, document entitled "Proposed Table of Contents (Draft No. 2) for the Committee's 'Issues and Observations Paper -Omge Air Ambulance Hearings" dated August 7, 2012 .

1 LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Submission, 1 document entitled "Hearings (August 29, 2012) on Omge · Ambulance and Related Services: Background Information i on Witnesses (Jay Lebo)" dated August 23 , 2012. I

-- - - - - ---------- -- ---- ----- - - - · · · - ·---- - -------- ---··------ ------ -~-- -- - · ····---------··- ---- ·-··· · ··-···-··---··· -~---·-- - --.. - ····- - - ·- '-"<

t LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Submission, i document entitled "Hearings (August 29, 2012) on Ornge i Ambulance and Related Services: Background Information · on Witnesses (Poul-Erik Binderup)" dated August 27, 2012. · ~------- ---- - ---·-· ·--·-·· ------ ··-- -·-- ·---------- ------·-------------- - -------·- ·---

EXHIBITNO. 1/06/105D J LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Submission, ; document entitled "Ornge Hearings: Press Articles for ! (August 1-27, 2012) dated August 27, 2012. I

..

--.--------····-··· . . --- -· ...... ·-· ---- - .... ...... ··------. -- ·- ----- . ···---- ···-EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/106A . CANADIAN HELICOPTERS LIMITED - Written

· submission, DVD entitled "Dr. Mazza Interview on BNN 1 August 26, 2009." I

-· ----·--·····--······ ... -L ·------------·- ··-·--·--·--·------ -·-·····~- ---· -··-··· -.. --·-- ·- · --------

EXHIBIT NO. 1106/1 06B ! CANADIAN HELICOPTERS LIMITED - Written




EXHIBITNO. 1/06/110

------

EXHIBIT NO. 1/061111A

EXHIBIT NO. 1/06/lllB

! submission, document entitled "Submission from Rob 1 Blakely, Canadian Helicopters Limited."

OFFICE OF THE INTEGRITY COMMISSIONER OF ONTARIO I LOBBYISTS REGISTRATION OFFICE -Written submission, letter dated August 23, 2012.

BRUCE WADE - Written submission, e-mail entitled i "Ornge suspension" dated August 24, 2012 f- ~- - ~~~-- -~ -~ --~~ ------~~- ~--~-----~--------·-- -- ~--~--~--- - --~- ~-· -~-~--------~---- ---- ~ ~--- ----

1 DA VID ZIMMER, MPP - Submission, e-mail from Chris Mazza to Malcolm Bates dated November 1, 2007.

LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH SERVICE - Submission, document entitled "Ornge Hearings: Press Articles for

i (August 28-31, 2012)" dated August 31,2012 . .. +-~ --~----··--- ·--~ -. - - ~ ~ ~~ -- -·-·---~~---~~ --- ·- - ·- ·------- ~ ·- -------- ~---· -· . -1

BRUCE WADE - Written submission dated August 31, 1 2012. r ~ --~~----- -~-----·- -- -~~- ~-~~~~~--~- -~ -- ~----~---~-- -

i BRUCE WADE - Written submission, e-mails dated : August 31 ,2012. I

- L.- -- -