state action against gustman

Upload: 10news-wtsp

Post on 07-Jul-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    1/34

    Final Order No. DOH-I6-0535-

    A

    FILED DATE

    -

    MA I 1 0 2016

    De a

    art • nt

    alth

    lam

    ty Agency Clerk

    T TE OF FLORID

    DEP RTMENT OF HE LTH

    By:

    In Re:

    mergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler J. Gustman, R.Ph.

    Registered Pharmacist License Number PS 40327

    Case Number 2016-07452

    ORDER OF EMERGENCY RESTRICTION OF LICENSE

    John H. Armstrong, M.D., F.A.C.S., State Surgeon General and

    Secretary of Health, ORDERS the emergency restriction of the license of

    Tyler J. Gustman, R.Ph., (Mr. Gustman) to practice pharmacy in the State of

    Florida. Mr. Gustman holds registered pharmacist license number PS 40327.

    Mr. Gustman's address of record is 7381 114th Avenue North, #405A, Largo,

    Florida 33773. The following Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

    support the emergency restriction of Mr. Gustman's license to practice as a

    registered pharmacist in the State of Florida.

    FINDINGS OF FA CT

    1.

    he Department of Health (Department) is the state agency

    charged with regulating the practice of pharmacy, pursuant to chapters 20,

    456, and 465, Florida Statutes (2015). Section 456.073(8), Florida Statutes

    (2015), authorizes the State Surgeon General to summarily restrict the

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    2/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    license of Mr. Gustman, in the State of Florida in accordance with Section

    120.60(6), Florida Statutes (2015).

    2. At all times material to this Order, Mr. Gustman held a license to

    practice as a registered pharmacist pursuant to chapter 465, Florida Statutes

    (2015).

    3.

    Pursuant to Rule 64B16-27.104 of the Florida Administrative

    Code, Mr. Gustman was the Prescription Department Manager of record

    (PDM) for Sterile Compounding Pharmacy, LLC, doing business as SCP, LLC,

    (Sterile Compounding Pharmacy) holding Special Sterile Compounding

    Pharmacy Permit PH 27507 and Community Pharmacy Permit PH 27311.

    4.

    The PDM is responsible for maintaining all drug records,

    providing for the security of the prescription department, and following such

    other rules as relate to the practice of the profession of pharmacy. The PDM

    is the licensee responsible for ensuring that pharmacies remain in

    compliance with the laws and rules regulating pharmacies and ensuring that

    all prescriptions filled or compounded at the pharmacy are safe for

    consumption.

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    3/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    5. On or about December 17, 2015, Department of Health Senior

    Pharmacists M.C. and J.S. performed a routine pharmacy inspection at Sterile

    Compounding Pharmacy (Inspection). Inspectors M.C. and J.S. found several

    serious deficiencies regarding Sterile Compounding Pharmacy's compliance

    with the laws and regulations governing pharmacies and the practice of

    pharmacy.

    Facts Relating to Sterile Compounding Pharmacy's Community

    Pharmacy Permit PH 27311

    6. Pharmacies must have the adequate equipment necessary to

    operate as a pharmacy. This requirement includes functioning, calibrated

    scales.

    7.

    The Inspection revealed the pharmacy's scale was calibrated on

    June 2013 with a calibration expiration of June 2014.

    8.

    Pharmacy shelves must be inspected every four months for

    expired medications, and expired medications should not be in active stock.

    9.

    The Inspection revealed pharmaceutical ingredients in active

    stock with a retest date of June 2015. Mr. Gustman did not keep evidence

    of retesting.

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    4/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    10.

    Sterile Compounding Pharmacy dispenses medications to

    patients. Any medications dispensed to a patient must include a patient

    profile, created and maintained by the pharmacy.

    11.

    The Inspection revealed Sterile Compounding Pharmacy's patient

    profiles to be inadequate. Mr. Gustman did not ensure that patient records

    contained a list of all new and refill prescriptions dispensed by Sterile

    Compounding Pharmacy for the patient over the preceding two years.

    12.

    Furthermore, the records did not contain evidence of a

    reasonable effort to obtain the patients' allergies, drug reactions,

    idiosyncrasies, and chronic conditions or disease states of the patient.

    Additionally, the records did not contain the identity of any other drugs,

    including over-the-counter drugs, or devices currently being used by the

    patient which may relate to the prospective drug review.

    13.

    Upon receipt of a new or refill prescription, the pharmacist must

    ensure that a verbal and printed offer to counsel is made to the patient or

    the patient's agent when applicable. If the delivery of the drugs to the patient

    or the patient's agent is not made at the pharmacy the offer must be in

    writing and must provide for toll-free telephone access to the pharmacist.

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    5/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    14.

    A pharmacy is not to dispense a prescription when the

    pharmacist knows, or has reason to believe, that a purported prescription is

    not based upon a valid practitioner-patient relationship that includes a

    documented patient evaluation, including history and a physical examination

    adequate to establish the diagnosis for which any drug is prescribed.

    15. Some of the prescriptions Mr. Gustman permitted Sterile

    Compounding Pharmacy to fill came from a doctor located in Connecticut

    and another in Florida. The patients were located in states such as Hawaii,

    Montana, Ohio, Washington, and Colorado. Subsequent Department

    interviews with patients confirmed they were prescribed the drugs after

    filling out a questionnaire on the internet or in a telephone call. Some of the

    prescriptions were for human chorionic gonadotropin.

    1

    Facts Relating to Sterile Compounding Pharmacy's Special Sterile

    Compounding Pharmacy Permit PH 27311

    16.

    The Florida Board of Pharmacy adopted the minimum practice

    and quality standards set forth in the United States Pharmacopeia (USP)

    Chapters 797, 85, and 71, relating to the standards of practice for

    1

    In molecular biology, human chorionic gonadotropin, commonly abbreviated as 'hCG[,]' is a hormone

    produced by the embryo following implantation. hCG is a legend drug.

    5

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    6/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    compounding sterile products in Board of Pharmacy Rule 64B16-27.797,

    Florida Administrative Code.

    17.

    High-risk level Compounded Sterile Products (CSPs) are either

    contaminated or at a high-risk of becoming contaminated before sterilization.

    Contaminated CSPs are potentially most hazardous to patients when

    administered into body cavities, central nervous and vascular systems, eyes,

    and joints.

    18. PDMs of pharmacies that prepare high-risk level CSPs have the

    responsibility of ensuring that the procedures, techniques, ingredients,

    devices, and equipment used to prepare CSPs conform to the requirements

    of USP Chapter 797, in order to minimize the risk of contamination and

    potential harm.

    19.

    The Inspection revealed that Mr. Gustman permits Sterile

    Compounding Pharmacy to use non-sterile vials and stoppers as part of its

    compounding processes, and achieves terminal sterilization via filtration.

    20.

    Sterilization of high-risk level CSPs via filtration must be

    performed with a sterile .2 or .22 micrometer nominal pore size filter which

    6

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    7/34

    IN RE: T he Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    is certified by the manufacturer to be sterile-grade.

    2

    The identity, purity,

    strength, and stability of the CSPs must be verified after filtration, to ensure

    the filtration does not fundamentally affect the CSPs.

    21.

    The Inspection revealed that Mr. Gustman did not keep

    documentation regarding the filters' certification as sterile-grade.

    22.

    The Inspection revealed that Mr. Gustman did not have proof of

    the identity, purity, strength, and stability of the CSPs after filtration.

    23.

    Sterilizing filters must undergo an integrity test with the

    parameters of the test set by the manufacturer.

    24.

    The Inspection revealed a lack of instructions from the

    manufacturer regarding an integrity test for the pharmacy's filters. Instead,

    Mr. Gustman set the parameters of the integrity test himself, by estimation

    of the parameters.

    2 USP 797 defines this certification as where the filter retains 10

    7 microorganisms of

    Brevundimonas

    Pseudomonas) diminuta on each square centimeter of upstream filter surface area under conditions

    similar to those in which the CSPs will be sterilized.

    7

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    8/34

    IN RE : The Emergency R estriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS4032 7

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    25.

    In order to render glassware or containers used to compound

    medications such as vials free from pyrogens

    3

    and microbes,

    4

    dry heat

    depyrogenation

    5

    must be used.

    26.

    A description of the dry heat depyrogenation cycle and

    documentation of the duration for specific items must be maintained in the

    pharmacy by the PDM. The effectiveness of the depyrogenation cycle must

    be verified using endotoxin challenge vials.

    27.

    The Inspection revealed Mr. Gustman lacked documentation

    regarding the pharmacy's depyrogenation cycle.

    28.

    The Inspection revealed that the depyrogenation cycle has not

    been verified using endotoxin challenge vials.

    29.

    Any autoclave used in sterilization must be temperature mapped

    to ensure that all areas of the oven reach the appropriate temperatures and

    pressures evenly. A description of the autoclave cycle and instructions for

    specific load items must also be maintained by the pharmacy and PDM.

    3

    Pyrogens are fever-producing substances.

    4

    Microbes are single-cell organisms.

    5

    Depyrogenation refers to the removal of pyrogens and is essentially incineration. Depyrogenation is a

    separate and distinct process from sterilization.

    8

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    9/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    30.

    The Inspection revealed Mr. Gustman kept no documentation of

    temperature mapping or description of the cycle. Instructions for different

    load items relating to the autoclave has not been done or kept by the PDM

    and pharmacy.

    31.

    Hazardous drugs are drugs where studies in animals or humans

    indicate that exposures to those drugs have a potential for causing cancer,

    developmental or reproductive toxicity, or harm to organs.

    32.

    Hazardous drugs must be compounded in their own negative

    pressure buffer room. Hazardous drugs must be stored separately from non-

    hazardous drugs. Special hazardous waste bins must be available for safe

    disposal of any hazardous drug. Additionally, compounding pharmacy

    personnel must be given appropriate protective garments.

    33.

    Sterile Compounding Pharmacy compounds Human Chorionic

    Gonadotropin (hCG).

    6

    34.

    Mr. Gustman did not ensure that Sterile Compounding Pharmacy

    has a hazardous drug buffer room. Mr. Gustman permits compounding of

    6

    hCG causes reproductive and developmental toxicity and is therefore a hazardous drug.

    9

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    10/34

    IN RE : The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep t Case No. 2016-07452

    hCG in a positive pressure room, potentially exposing the pharmacy and its

    personnel to harmful vapors from hCG.

    35. Mr. Gustman permits Sterile Compounding Pharmacy to store the

    hCG with other non-hazardous drugs.

    36.

    Mr. Gustman did not ensure that Sterile Compounding Pharmacy

    has hazardous waste bins.

    37. Additionally, Mr. Gustman does not provide protective garments

    which are rated for hazardous drugs for the pharmacy's personnel. This

    places compounding personnel at risk of coming into contact with hazardous

    and dangerous CSPs that can harm the compounding personnel.

    38.

    Compounding facilities must be physically designed and

    environmentally controlled to minimize air-borne contamination from

    contacting critical sites where compounding occurs and where CSPs are

    stored.

    39. The number of potential contaminants in the air is categorized

    by the ISO level. Clean rooms7

    must meet ISO Class 7 criteria. Sterile

    he clean room is a compounding environment that is supplied with HEPA or HEPA-filtered air, the

    access to which is limited to personnel trained and authorized to perform sterile compounding and facility

    cleaning.

    10

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    11/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    compounding must occur in a segregated area inside the clean room that

    meets ISO Class 5 criteria with unidirectional airflow.

    8

    40.

    Air sampling must be conducted in the various rooms to verify

    their ISO Class level, by incubating the air on a growth medium to reveal

    hidden colony forming units of microbes. The results of the sampling must

    be transformed into colony forming units per cubic meter of air. The purpose

    of this is to provide standardized evaluation for adverse trends.

    41.

    The Inspection revealed that Mr. Gustman did not ensure that

    Sterile Compounding Pharmacy transforms the results of the air sampling to

    colony forming units per cubic meter of air.

    42.

    The Inspection revealed that Mr. Gustman allows Sterile

    Compounding Pharmacy to compound hCG in vials which are partially

    stoppered. The vials are then removed from the ISO Class 5 environment

    and placed in a freezer, the ISO Class of which is unknown and without

    unidirectional airflow. After freezing, the hCG is transported across the length

    8

    The maximum amount of contaminants permitted in a room decrease with the ISO Level. The maximum

    amount of contaminants allowed in an ISO Class 7 Room is more than the maximum for an ISO Class 5

    room.

    11

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    12/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    of the buffer room and placed in a small lyophilizing

    9

    chamber, which sits on

    the floor between two shelving units.

    43.

    Therefore, the sterility of the hCG cannot be assured with this

    process.

    44.

    Placement of devices in a buffer room is dictated by the devices'

    effect on the designated environmental quality of atmospheres and surfaces,

    and must be verified by monitoring.

    45.

    The Inspection revealed a freezer located in the buffer room. The

    freezer's coils and compressor were exposed, causing condensation, which

    is a source of contamination.

    46.

    Air flows from areas of high pressure to low pressure.

    Compounding facilities must be divided into rooms that are maintained at

    different air pressures to ensure that the clean room is a higher pressure

    than the surrounding rooms.

    11

    This prohibits air containing a large number

    of potential contaminants from flowing into the clean room.

    9

    Lyophilization, commonly known as freeze-drying, is a dehydration process typically used to preserve a

    perishable material or make the material more convenient for transport. Lyophilization works by freezing

    the material and then reducing the surrounding pressure to allow the frozen water in the material to

    sublimate directly from the solid phase to the gas phase.

    10

    Referred to as a Positive Pressure room

    11

    The surrounding rooms, or anteroom and buffer rooms, must be maintained at an ISO Class 7 or

    better.

    12

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    13/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    47. The pressure readings between the clean-room and the ante-

    room and the ante-room and the general pharmacy must be documented

    separately; this documentation must include daily entries of the pressure

    reading.

    48.

    The Inspection found the pressure readings between clean-room

    and the ante-room and the ante-room and the general pharmacy

    documented as one result. The Inspection revealed Mr. Gustman permits

    staff to document only PASS or FAIL[,] and does not require

    documentation of the actual pressure reading.

    49.

    Media-fill challenge testing must represent the most challenging

    compounding process and be completed biannually by compounding

    personnel. A media-fill challenge simulates high-risk level compounding to

    assess the quality of the aseptic skill of the compounding personnel.

    50.

    The most challenging compounding process for Sterile

    Compounding Pharmacy involves the sterilization, depyrogenation, and

    lyophilization of hazardous drug vials with production of batches with more

    than 100 units.

    13

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    14/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    51. Media fill challenges completed by Sterile Compounding

    Pharmacy compounding personnel do not include the sterilization,

    depyrogenation, and lyophilization process, and the test only produces a

    batch with one unit. Therefore, Mr. Gustman is not ensuring Sterile

    Compounding Pharmacy personnel's skill in compounding CSPs.

    52.

    Surface sampling must be done in all ISO Class 5, 7, and 8

    rooms, with the results documented.

    53. The Inspection revealed that surface sampling is only being done

    in the ISO Class 5 environment, and Mr. Gustman is not keeping

    documentation. Mr. Gustman is not requiring surface sampling be done in

    either the ISO Class 7 or 8 rooms.

    54.

    The surfaces, shelving, counters, cabinets, and carts/casters

    throughout the pharmacy must have smooth, impervious surfaces, free from

    cracks, crevices, and shedding materials.

    55.

    The Inspection revealed the design of Sterile Compounding

    Pharmacy's shelving causes the shelving to have cracks and crevices which

    makes cleaning and disinfecting extremely difficult, if not impossible, to

    perform.

    14

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    15/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    56.

    All cleaning and disinfecting practices and policies for the

    compounding of CSPs must be included in written standard operating

    procedures and shall be followed by all compounding personnel.

    57.

    The Inspection revealed Mr. Gustman implemented a written list

    of cleaning agents, but gave no direction on when and where to use each

    one.

    58.

    Certain Beyond Use Dates (BUD) must be assigned for CSPs,

    depending on the state of the CSP and the environment in which it is kept.

    The purpose of a BUD is to ensure the potency and stability of a product.

    59.

    BUDs may be assigned in a different manner, but such

    assignment must be supported by authoritative literature.

    60.

    The Inspection revealed the authoritative literature upon which

    Mr. Gustman based the BUD assignment was not adequate.

    61.

    The BUD based on stability for hCG referenced a Merck Package

    Insert which is not authoritative literature.

    62.

    Therefore, Mr. Gustman cannot assure the stability of Sterile

    Compounding Pharmacy CSPs.

    15

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    16/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No, PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016

    -07452

    63.

    Compounding personnel must be able to demonstrate

    appropriate hand hygiene, garbing, and gloving competency.

    64.

    The Inspection revealed Mr. Gustman required no observational

    assessments for hand hygiene, garbing, and gloving competency for

    Pharmacy Technician S.B.

    65.

    Additionally, the Inspection revealed that Mr. Gustman's written

    gowning policy was physically impossible to perform, in the current layout of

    the pharmacy.

    66.

    Observational assessments of the media-fill challenge and proper

    hygienic technique must be performed at least semi-annually.

    67.

    The Inspection revealed the last observational assessment of

    compounding personnel occurred on December 8, 2014.

    68. Sterility testing must be conducted on all CSP batches greater

    than 25 units. An alternative method may be used, but documentation

    proving that the alternative method is equivalent or superior to the sterility

    testing method must be provided.

    69. Mr. Gustman uses an alternative method of sterility testing.

    16

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    17/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. P540327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    70.

    The Inspection revealed the validation documentation regarding

    Mr. Gustman's alternative method of testing was clearly marked as a draft,

    and non-final document.

    71.

    Two percent of the batch, or 20 containers, whichever is the

    lesser, must be subjected to sterility testing when the CSP batch is more

    than 500 items.

    72.

    The Inspection revealed that 637 vials of cyanocobalamin

      2

    were

    compounded, but Mr. Gustman only sent 10 vials for sterility testing.

    Comprehensive Findings of Fact

    73.

    High-risk level CSPs pose an inherent risk to public health.

    Without the safeguard of terminal sterilization and strict adherence to the

    standards set forth in USP 797 pertaining to practices and procedures of

    preparing high-risk level CSPs, the public is at risk of the serious dangers,

    including death, associated with contaminated preparations.

    74. The public places considerable amount of trust in pharmacists,

    especially those who serve as the PDM of pharmacies that prepare CSPs. A

    patient is unable to discern whether the medication he or she receives from

    12

    Cyanocobalamin is the most common and widely produced form of the chemical compounds that have

    vitamin 812 activity. Cyanocobalamin is an over-the-counter vitamer.

    17

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    18/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. P540327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    a pharmacy is safe or dangerous, especially because the primary danger of

    contamination occurs at the microscopic level. It is therefore essential for

    pharmacies that prepare CSPs (especially high-risk level CSPs) to ensure that

    their practices and procedures are in strict conformity to the standards that

    have been set forth to minimize the inherent risk to the public and ensure

    the safety of the patients receiving medication.

    75.

    The possibility of a compounded preparation becoming

    contaminated is unpredictable. Therefore, pharmacies must take every

    precaution in the preparation, handling, and storage of a CSP to protect

    against the possibility of contamination. Once contaminated medication is

    dispensed and administered, the danger to the public has the potential to be

    widespread, and potentially deadly.

    76.

    Sterile Compounding Pharmacy, with Mr. Gustman as PDM, is

    incapable of safely preparing CSPs.

    77.

    Sterile Compounding Pharmacy's facility design is inherently

    flawed: the required buffer room for compounding hazardous drugs does not

    exist. Without drastic changes in the physical design of the facility, extreme

    18

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    19/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    risk exists that CSPs will be contaminated or that harm will befall

    compounding personnel.

    78.

    Furthermore, Sterile Compounding Pharmacy's personnel are

    engaged in compounding CSPs in an unapproved and dangerous fashion.

    79.

    Mr. Gustman demonstrated that he is incapable of performing

    the duties of a registered pharmacist and PDM competently. This is

    evidenced by the number of significant and dangerous violations he

    committed in all aspects of practicing as the PDM at Sterile Compounding

    Pharmacy.

    80.

    Mr. Gustman demonstrated, through the Inspection, that he is

    either unaware of, or disregards, his obligations as a PDM of Sterile

    Compounding Pharmacy.

    81.

    Additionally, Mr. Gustman demonstrated, through the

    Inspection, that he is either unaware of, or disregards, the laws and rules of

    the Board of Pharmacy and State of Florida regarding the practice of

    pharmacy.

    82. Without drastic changes in operating procedures, sanitation,

    record keeping and compounding, products produced by Mr. Gustman are

    19

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    20/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    at an extreme risk of becoming contaminated or inherently unsafe for

    consumption.

    83.

    Furthermore, Mr. Gustman exhibits significant shortcomings in

    the competency necessary to safely operate a prescription department. Mr.

    Gustman allows high-risk CSPs to be compounded in less than an ISO Class

    5 environment and filters the CSP through a filter, the quality of which is

    unknown. Mr. Gustman allows hCG to be compounded without a hazardous

    drug buffer room, and in a positive pressure environment. Mr. Gustman

    allows compounding personnel to handle, compound and interact with

    hazardous drugs without the required protective equipment.

    84.

    Mr. Gustman also disregards, or has failed to investigate, the fact

    that many of the prescriptions Sterile Compounding Pharmacy is filling are

    not based upon a valid practitioner-patient relationship. Mr. Gustman does

    not keep the required patient profiles needed to avoid adverse drug

    interactions. Finally, Mr. Gustman does not provide patients with a written

    offer of counseling.

    85.

    A restriction of Mr. Gustman's license to practice as a registered

    pharmacist is necessary because he is presently incapable of, and unwilling

    20

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    21/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    to, operate a pharmacy and prepare products and medications in

    conformation with the various laws and rules of the Board of Pharmacy.

    86.

    A lesser restriction of Mr. Gustman's license other than the terms

    outlined in this Order will not protect the public, because Mr. Gustman will

    still be able to participate in the unsafe and dangerous operation as a PDM.

    87.

    Therefore, nothing short of the immediate restriction of Mr.

    Gustman's license to practice pharmacy as a PDM will ensure the protection

    of the public from his continued unrestricted practice of unsafely

    compounding, dispensing, and selling products and medications.

    CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

    Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact, the State Surgeon General

    concludes as follows:

    1.

    The State Surgeon General has jurisdiction over this matter

    pursuant to Sections 20.43 and 456.073(8), Florida Statutes (2015), and

    chapter 465, Florida Statutes (2015).

    2.

    Section 465.016(1)(r), Florida Statutes (2015), subjects a

    registered pharmacist to discipline, including restriction, for violating any

    provision of chapters 465 and 456, or any of the rules of the Board of

    21

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    22/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R. Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    Pharmacy.

    3.

    Section 465.022(11)(a), Florida Statutes (2015), provides that

    [t]he prescription department manager of a permittee must

    obtain and maintain all drug records required by any state or

    federal law to be obtained by a pharmacy, including, but not

    limited to, records required by or under this chapter, chapter

    499, or chapter 893. The prescription department manager must

    ensure the permittee's compliance with all rules adopted under

    those chapters as they relate to the practice of the profession of

    pharmacy and the sale of prescription drugs.

    4.

    Rule 64B16-28.102(5)(b), Florida Administrative Code, provides

    that a pharmacy shall have such other equipment as is necessary to meet

    the needs of the professional practice of pharmacy.

    5. Mr. Gustman violated Section 465.016(1)(r), Florida Statutes

    (2015), by violating Section 465.022(11)(a), Florida Statutes (2015), by

    being the PDM of a pharmacy which violated Rule 64B16-28.102(5)(b),

    Florida Administrative Code, by not having a properly calibrated scale for

    use.

    6. Rule 64B16-28.110, Florida Administrative Code, requires

    examination of the prescription department shelves at least every four

    months, so that expired medications can be removed.

    7. Mr. Gustman violated Section 465.016(1)(r), Florida Statutes

    22

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    23/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    (2015), by violating Section 465.022(11)(a), Florida Statutes (2015), by

    being the PDM of a pharmacy which violated Rule 64B16-28.110, of the

    Florida Administrative Code by failing to ensure pharmacy shelf inspection

    every four months and disposing of expired medication, by having a

    pharmaceutical ingredient in active stock which expired six months earlier.

    8.

    Rule 64B16-27.800, F.A.C., requires a reasonable effort be made

    to obtain patient allergies, drug reactions, idiosyncrasies, and chronic

    conditions or disease states of the patient and the identity of any other

    drugs, including over-the-counter drugs, or devices currently being used by

    the patient which may relate to prospective drug review.

    9.

    Mr. Gustman violated Section 465.016(1)(r), Florida Statutes

    (2015), by violating Section 465.022(11)(a), Florida Statutes (2015), by

    being the PDM of a pharmacy which violated Rule 64B16-27.800, F.A.C., by

    failing to make a reasonable effort to obtain the aforementioned required

    patient information.

    10.

    Section 465.023(1)(h), Florida Statutes (2015), subjects a

    pharmacy permittee to discipline, including restriction, for dispensing any

    medicinal drug based upon a communication that purports to be a

    23

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    24/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    prescription, when the pharmacist knows, or has reason to believe, that the

    purported prescription is not based upon a valid practitioner-patient

    relationship that includes a documented patient evaluation, including history

    and a physical examination adequate to establish the diagnosis for which

    any drug is prescribed and any other requirement established by board rule

    under Chapter 458, Chapter 459, Chapter 461, Chapter 463, Chapter 464,

    or Chapter 466, Florida Statutes (2015).

    11.

    Mr. Gustman violated Section 465.016(1)(r), Florida Statutes

    (2015), by violating Section 465.022(11)(a), Florida Statutes (2015), by

    being the PDM of a pharmacy which violated Section 465.023(1)(h), Florida

    Statutes (2015), by permitting the dispensing of medication which he knew,

    or should have had reason to believe, was not based upon a valid

    practitioner-patient relationship, by dispensing to patients throughout other

    states who were prescribed drugs after filling out an internet questionnaire

    or placing a telephone call.

    12.

    Rule 64B16-27.797(1)(a), Florida Administrative Code, provides

    that all sterile compounding shall be performed in accordance with the

    24

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    25/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    minimum practice and quality standards of USP Chapter 797.

    13.

    USP Chapter 797 requires that sterilization of high-risk level CSPs

    via filtration shall be performed with a sterile .2 or .22 micrometer nominal

    pore size filter which is certified by the manufacturer to be sterile-grade. The

    identity, purity, strength, and stability of the CSPs must be verified after

    filtration, to ensure the filtration does not fundamentally affect the CSPs.

    14.

    USP Chapter 797 requires sterilizing filters to undergo an

    integrity test with the parameters of the test set by the manufacturer.

    15.

    Chapter 797 requires a description of the dry heat

    depyrogenation cycle and documentation of the duration for specific items.

    The effectiveness of the cycle must be verified using endotoxin challenge

    vials.

    16.

    USP Chapter 797 requires any autoclave used in sterilization to

    be temperature mapped to ensure that all areas of the oven reach the

    appropriate temperatures and pressures. A description of the autoclave cycle

    and instructions for specific load items shall also be maintained.

    17.

    USP Chapter 797 classifies hazardous drugs as drugs where

    studies in animals or humans indicate that exposures to those drugs have a

    25

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    26/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    potential for causing cancer, developmental or reproductive toxicity, or harm

    to organs.

    18.

    USP Chapter 797 requires hazardous drugs to be compounded in

    their own negative pressure buffer room.

    19.

    Hazardous drugs must be stored separately from non-hazardous

    drugs.

    20.

    Special hazardous drug waste bins must be available for safe

    disposal of any hazardous drug.

    21.

    Additionally, Compounding pharmacy personnel must be given

    protective garments rated for hazardous drugs.

    22.

    USP Chapter 797 requires air sampling to be conducted in the

    various rooms to verify their ISO Class level, by incubating the air on a

    growth medium to reveal hidden colony forming units of microbes. USP

    Chapter 797 requires the results of the sampling to be transformed into

    colony forming units per cubic meter of air.

    23.

    USP Chapter 797 requires that sterile compounding must occur

    in a segregated area inside the clean room that meets ISO Class 5 criteria

    with unidirectional airflow.

    26

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    27/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    24. USP Chapter 797 states that placement of devices in a buffer

    room is dictated by the devices' effect on the designated environmental

    quality of atmospheres and surfaces, and shall be verified by monitoring.

    25.

    USP Chapter 797 requires that the pressure readings between

    the clean-room and the ante-room and the ante-room and the general

    pharmacy must be documented separately; this documentation must include

    daily entries of the pressure reading.

    26.

    USP Chapter 797 mandates media-fill challenge testing

    representing the most challenging compounding process to be completed

    biannually.

    27.

    USP 797 requires surface sampling to be done in all ISO Class 5,

    7, and 8 rooms, with the results documented.

    28.

    USP Chapter 797 requires the surfaces, shelving, counters,

    cabinets and carts/casters throughout the pharmacy to have smooth,

    impervious surfaces, free from cracks, and crevices, and shedding materials.

    29.

    USP Chapter 797 requires that all cleaning and disinfecting

    practices and policies for the compounding of CSPs shall be included in

    27

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    28/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    written standard operating procedures and shall be followed by all

    compounding personnel.

    30. BUDs may be assigned in a different manner than prescribed by

    USP Chapter 797, but such assignment must be supported by authoritative

    literature.

    31. USP Chapter 797 requires compounding personnel to

    demonstrate appropriate hand hygiene, garbing, and gloving competency.

    32.

    Chapter 797 requires observational assessments of the media-fill

    challenge and proper hygienic technique to be performed at least semi-

    annually.

    33.

    Mr. Gustman violated Section 465.016(1)(r), Florida Statutes

    (2015), by violating Section 465.022(11)(a), Florida Statutes (2015), by

    being the PDM of a pharmacy which violated Rule 64B16-27.797(1)(a),

    Florida Administrative Code, by:

    a.

    Not using a certified filter for sterilizing CSPs;

    b.

    Not having documentation regarding the filters' certification as

    sterile-grade.

    c.

    Not verifying the identity, purity, strength, and stability of the

    28

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    29/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    CSPs after filtration;

    d.

    Not subjecting the sterilizing filters to an appropriate integrity

    test;

    e.

    Not having documentation regarding the depyrogenation cycle

    and instructions for specific load items;

    f.

    Not verifying the depyrogenation cycle using endotoxin challenge

    vials;

    g.

    Not having documentation regarding the temperature mapping,

    description of the cycle, and instructions for different load items

    relating to the autoclave;

    h.

    Not having a hazardous drug buffer room;

    i.

    Failing to maintain a negative pressure environment when

    compounding hazardous drugs;

    j.

    Co-mingling hazardous drugs with non-hazardous drugs;

    k.

    Not having hazardous drug waste bins;

    I. Not providing hazardous-drug-rated protective equipment to

    pharmacy personnel who compound hazardous drugs;

    m. Not transforming air sampling results into colony forming units

    29

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    30/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    per cubic meter of air;

    n.

    Performing high-risk sterile compounding in an environment

    which is less than ISO Class 5;

    o.

    Placing a freezer with exposed coils and compressor in the buffer

    room;

    p.

    Failing to adequately document pressure readings throughout

    the pharmacy;

    q.

    Failing to conduct appropriate media fill challenges;

    r.

    Failing to conduct timely media fill challenges;

    s. Failing to conduct appropriate surface sampling in the ISO Class

    7 and 8 environments;

    t.

    Failing to document the surface sampling conducted in the ISO

    Class 5 environment;

    u.

    Having shelving with difficult-to-clean cracks and crevices;

    v.

    Failing to have an appropriate standard operating procedure

    regarding cleaning and disinfection;

    w.

    Failing to have supporting documentation regarding the

    assignment of BUDs; and

    30

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    31/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dept Case No. 2016-07452

    x. Failing to adequately and timely assess personnel regarding hand

    hygiene, gloving and gowning.

    34.

    Rule 64B16-27.797(1)(b), Florida Administrative Code, provides

    that all sterile compounding shall be performed in accordance with the

    minimum practice and quality standards of USP Chapter 71.

    35.

    USP Chapter 71 requires, among others, that should an

    alternative sterility test be used, that the method be equivalent, or superior

    to, the methods described in USP Chapter 797 and that documentation be

    kept to demonstrate the method's equivalence or superiority to USP Chapter

    797 methods.

    36.

    Mr. Gustman violated Section 465.016(1)(r), Florida Statutes

    (2015), by violating 465.022(11)(a), Florida Statutes, by being the PDM of a

    pharmacy which violated Rule 64B16-27.797(1)(b), of the Florida

    Administrative Code, by:

    a. Failing to use an alternative sterility test which is equivalent, or

    superior, to USP Chapter 71;

    31

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    32/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    b.

    Failing to have authoritative literature to demonstrate that the

    alternative sterility test which is equivalent, or superior, to USP

    Chapter 71; and

    c.

    Failing to submit an adequate number of items as a proportion

    of the CSP batch for sterility testing.

    37.

    Section 120.60(6), Florida Statutes (2015), authorizes the State

    Surgeon General to summarily restrict a pharmacist's license to practice

    pharmacy upon a finding that the pharmacy presents an immediate, serious

    danger to the public health, safety, or welfare.

    38.

    Mr. Gustman's continued unrestricted practice as a registered

    pharmacist constitutes an immediate, serious danger to the health, safety,

    or welfare of the citizens of the State of Florida, and this summary procedure

    is fair under the circumstances to adequately protect the public.

    WHEREFORE, in accordance with Section 120.60(6), Florida Statutes

    (2015), it is ORDERED THAT:

    1.

    he license of Tyler]. Gustman, R.Ph., license number PH 40327,

    is immediately restricted from practicing pharmacy as a prescription

    department manager of any pharmacy in the State of Florida.

    32

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    33/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    2.

    proceeding seeking formal discipline of the license of Tyler 1

    Gustman, R.Ph., to practice as a registered pharmacist will be promptly

    instituted and acted upon in compliance with Sections 120.569 and

    120.60(6), Florida Statutes (2015).

    DONE and ORDERED

    this

    ay of

    2016.

    4  :

    H. Armstrong, M.D., .A.C.S.,

    ate Surgeon General &

    Secretary of Health

    COUNSEL FOR THE DEPARTM ENT:

    Francis A. Carbone, II, Esquire

    Assistant General Counsel

    Florida Bar Ng 105786

    Department of Health, Prosecution Services Unit

    4052 Bald Cypress Way, Bin C-65

    Tallahassee, Florida 32399

    Telephone: 850.245.4444 ext. 8241

    Facsimile: 850.245.4662

    Email: [email protected]

    33

  • 8/18/2019 State action against Gustman

    34/34

    IN RE: The Emergency Restriction of the License of

    Tyler Gustman, R.Ph.

    License No. PS40327

    Dep't Case No. 2016-07452

    NOTICE OF RIGHT TO JUDICI L REVIEW

    Pursuant to Sections 120.60(6), and 120.68, Florida Statutes, the

    Department's findings of immediate danger, necessity, and procedural

    fairness shall be judicially reviewable. Review proceedings are governed by

    the Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure. Such proceedings are commenced

    by filing a Petition for Review, in accordance with Florida Rule of Appellate

    Procedure 9.100, and accompanied by a filing fee prescribed by law with the

    District Court of Appeal, and providing a copy of that Petition to the

    Department of Health within thirty (30) days of the date this Order is filed.

    34