state of arizona commission on judicial conduct … · state of arizona county of maricopa notary...

41
This order may not be used as a basis for disqualification of a judge. State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT Disposition of Complaint 13-322 Judge: No. 10573 10934 10971 10967 10929 10760 10179 10972 00214 11046 10808 10541 14823 14824 Complainant: No. 10573 10934 10971 10967 10929 10760 10179 10972 00214 11046 10808 10541 14823 14824 ORDER The complainants appeared to allege that twelve judges had engaged in judicial misconduct by filing documents in a case without paying filing fees. The responsibility of the Commission on Judicial Conduct is to impartially determine if the judges engaged in conduct that violated the provisions of Article 6.1 of the Arizona Constitution or the Code of Judicial Conduct and, if so, to take appropriate disciplinary action. The purpose and authority of the commission is limited to this mission. After review, the commission found no evidence of ethical misconduct and concluded that the judges did not violate the Code in this case. The commission does not have jurisdiction to review the legal sufficiency of court rulings. Accordingly, the complaint is dismissed in its entirety, pursuant to Rules 16(a) and 23. Dated: January 22, 2014. FOR THE COMMISSION /s/ George Riemer George A. Riemer Executive Director

Upload: truongkhue

Post on 03-Apr-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered

This order may not be used as a basis for disqualification of a judge.

State of Arizona

COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT

Disposition of Complaint 13-322

Judge: No. 10573 10934 10971 10967 10929 10760 10179 10972 00214 11046 10808 10541 14823 14824

Complainant:

No. 10573 10934

10971 10967 10929 10760 10179 10972 00214 11046 10808 10541 14823 14824

ORDER

The complainants appeared to allege that twelve judges had engaged in judicial misconduct by filing documents in a case without paying filing fees.

The responsibility of the Commission on Judicial Conduct is to impartially determine if the judges engaged in conduct that violated the provisions of Article 6.1 of the Arizona Constitution or the Code of Judicial Conduct and, if so, to take appropriate disciplinary action. The purpose and authority of the commission is limited to this mission.

After review, the commission found no evidence of ethical misconduct and concluded that the judges did not violate the Code in this case. The commission does not have jurisdiction to review the legal sufficiency of court rulings. Accordingly, the complaint is dismissed in its entirety, pursuant to Rules 16(a) and 23.

Dated: January 22, 2014.

FOR THE COMMISSION

/s/ George Riemer George A. Riemer Executive Director

Page 2: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered

This order may not be used as a basis for disqualification of a judge.

Copies of this order were mailed to the complainant and the judges on January 22, 2014.

Page 3: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 4: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 5: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 6: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 7: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 8: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 9: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 10: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 11: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 12: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 13: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 14: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 15: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 16: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 17: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 18: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 19: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 20: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 21: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 22: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 23: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 24: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 25: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 26: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 27: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 28: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 29: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 30: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 31: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 32: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 33: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 34: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 35: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 36: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 37: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 38: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 39: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 40: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered
Page 41: State of Arizona COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL CONDUCT … · STATE OF ARIZONA COUNTY OF MARICOPA NOTARY CERTIFICATE OF DISHONOR AND NON RESPONSE PRESENTMENT Be it known, that a duly empowered