stirling city centre north: a case for logic modelling ? lesley gallagher elaine brown peter walker...
TRANSCRIPT
Stirling City Centre North: a Case for Logic Modelling ?
Lesley GallagherElaine BrownPeter Walker
Stirling Community Planning Partnership 13th February 2013
What We’ll Cover
A community with problems: long standing issues: social economic, environmental, community safety
A problem shared: community planning leadership buy in
A problem unpacked: logic modelling, task managing, performance tracking
A problem solved ~?
Or lessons learned
A Community With ProblemsStatistically 604 households High student population Low numbers of children Above average income and employment
deprivation Much higher proportion of HMOs than city
average Incident rate per 100 households
significantly higher than city 1 datazone within 15% most deprived within
Stirling Council area 2 zones in top 5-20% in Scotland for
education/skills, crime and housing domains Acquisitive crime, particularly from student
residences Highest rate of opiate overdoses in Forth
Valley
Anecdotally Drug use inhibiting business trade Transient nature of residencies Chaotic lifestyles of some
residents Poor property and estate
maintenance Inappropriate waste presentation High levels of antisocial behaviour No obvious community-
competing set of interests - business community, long term community, community activists, student community
A Problem Shared
Central Scotland Police highlighted the issues from their perspective
Recognised the need to intervene earlier, in partnership
Community Planning Partnership- total place type approach
Top down: partner leadership commitment first
Community planning governance essential
A Problem Unpacked
Strategic leadership group and delivery team- senior budgetary commitment and operational direction
Delivery team-all key partners
Logic modelling to develop: Our shared outcomes Our shared aspirations Our shared understanding of the problem
Start with the difference required and work back- change in thinking
The Logic Model (Partially Shown)
Inputs Activities Outputs Reach Short TermOutcomes
MediumTermOutcomes
Long TermOutcomes
Data Partners haveimproved jointworking
Partnercontributions
SupportVulnerableIndividuals
Support todevelopNalaxoneprogrammeKeep wellassessmentsStudentsupport
Reduction inNARCANincidents
People feelsafer
CommunityEngagement
The area is amoredesirableplace to live
IdentifyEnvironmentalImprovements
Change streetlighting fromorange to whiteRemove allexternal graffiti
Well lit, saferstreets
A Problem Solved or Lessons Learned ?
Steps in a performance story:
Headline grab>>>where we were>>>>what we did>>>>>>
Picked up by (who are now doing)>>>>>>as a result>>>>>>>personal accounts>>>>
Implications and learning including what worked/didn’t work, contextual surprises, unplanned consequences>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>evidence