student and teacher (mis)conceptions of engineering christine cunningham museum of science, boston
TRANSCRIPT
Student and Teacher (Mis)Conceptions of Engineering
Christine Cunningham
Museum of Science, Boston
What is Engineering?Name:__________________Age:____I am: male female (please circle one) Briefly answer the questions below in one or two sentences. Don’t worry about being right or wrong—just write what you think.
(1)In your own words, what is engineering?(2)What does an engineer do? (3)Draw a picture of an engineer at work.
(4) Please describe your picture.
(5)List three things that are created by engineers.a.__________________________________b.__________________________________c._______________________________
Engineers….Build bridges, buildings, and roads
Engineers….Fix cars, engines, and machines
Engineers….Use or fix computers
Engineers….Drive trains
What is Engineering? (students)
What is Engineering?
0.0%10.0%20.0%30.0%40.0%50.0%60.0%70.0%80.0%90.0%
Arrang
e Flow
ers
Mak
e Pizz
a
Devel
op B
ette
r Gum
Sell F
ood
Teach
Chi
ldren
Impr
ove
Banda
ges
Creat
e W
arm
er J
acke
ts
Clean
Teeth
Read
About
Inve
ntio
ns
Figure
out
How
to T
rack
...
Desig
n W
ays
to C
lean
Wat
er
Desig
n Thin
gs
Wor
k as
a T
eam
Writ
e Pro
gram
s
Super
vise
Constr
uctio
n
Desig
n Tun
nels
Impr
ove
Mac
hine
s
Set U
p Fac
torie
s
Drive
Mac
hines
Const
ruct
Buildin
gs
Inst
all W
iring
Repai
r Car
s
% o
f S
tud
en
ts C
ho
os
ing
“An engineer is a person who…”
• Most common response: “engineers fix things”
• When more specific, they indicated that items fixed included buildings, cars, electricity/wiring, phones, motors/engines and technology. – “works with special technology to fix things”
“An engineer is a person who…”
• Second most common response: engineers build things
• Those who were specific about what was being built usually mentioned buildings or wiring– “bills thing and wacks as a team. And most
are boys.”– “Makes stof and brakes stof.”– “An engineer is some one how does
lectrisady.”
“An engineer is a person who…”
Other responses:
• “I don’t know”
• Engineers work/operate things
• Attributes of engineers– “Has a vevry in porting job.”– “is very, very very smart at math”
• Engineers design or improve things
What is Engineering? (teachers)What kinds of work do engineers do for their jobs?
0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
60.0
70.0
80.0
90.0
100.0
Des
ign
Tun
nels
Impr
ove
Mac
hine
s
Des
ign
Way
s to
Cle
an W
ater
Wor
k as
a T
eam
Impr
ove
Ban
dage
s
Des
ign
Thi
ngs
Set
Up
Fac
torie
s
Cre
ate
War
mer
Kin
ds o
f Ja
cket
s
Fig
ure
Out
How
to
Tra
ck L
ugga
ge
Writ
e C
ompu
ter
Pro
gram
s
Con
stru
ct B
uild
ings
Dev
elop
Bet
ter
Bub
ble
Gum
Rea
d A
bout
Inv
entio
ns
Sup
ervi
se C
onst
ruct
ion
Inst
all W
iring
Rep
air
Car
s
Driv
e M
achi
nes
Tea
ch C
hild
ren
Cle
an T
eeth
Arr
ange
Flo
wer
s
Sel
l Foo
d
Mak
e P
izza
% c
ho
os
ing
An engineer is a person who…# respondent
% respondents
(10) Respondent refers to features of engineer as a person 8 10.6%
(20) Respondent refers to self knowledge 4 5.3%
(30) Helps people/humankind 19 25.3%
(40) Designs/improves technologies 49 65.3%
(50) Constructs/makes technologies 33 44.0%
(60) Reference to object of engineer's work 11 14.7%
(70) Fixes technology 1 1.3%
(80) Operates technology 3 4.0%
(90) Respondent refers to how an engineer works 35 46.7%
What is Technology? (students)
What is Technology?
0.0%10.0%20.0%30.0%40.0%50.0%60.0%70.0%80.0%90.0%
100.0%
% o
f S
tud
en
ts C
ho
os
ing
How do you know if something is technology?
• Most common response: it uses/has electricity– “I think I know because I think that technology is
something with power or electrisaty”– “stuf that thay did not have in the old day's that runs
on elechric”– “I know technologh because you need to plug it in that
is why I know.”– “it works by bataries or by a plug. A lot of the time
you miteuse a charger.”– “I think I know because these thing work on electricity.
These thing can eletrify you.”
How do you know if something is technology?
• Next most common response: mentioning the function of technology– “Technology is something that makes you
learn like books and a computer.”– “technology is something that makes it easyer
for people so they won't have to do all that stofe”
How do you know if something is technology?
• Because it was created by people– “you can find out if something is technology if
it is made by human minds”– “I know if something is technology because it
takes lots of men to build something and because it takes a very long time.”
What is Technology? (teachers)
What is Technology?
0.010.020.030.040.050.060.070.080.090.0
100.0
% C
ho
os
ing
Science and/vs EngineeringScience and/vs Engineering
Engineering is Elementary (EiE)
Lessons that integrate engineering and technology concepts into elementary science.
Goal 1. Increase children’s level of technological literacy
Goal 2. Increase elementary teachers’ understanding of technology and engineering and their abilities to teach these subjects to their students
Goal 3. Modify the U.S. system of education to include engineering at the elementary level.
EiE UnitsScience Topic Eng Field Technology CountryWater Environmental Water Filters IndiaInsects/Plants Agricultural Pollinators Dominican
RepublicWind & Weather Mechanical Windmills DenmarkSimple Machines Industrial Redesign Potato USA (Af
Am)Chip Factory
Earth Materials Materials Walls ChinaBalance & Forces Civil Bridges USA (Hisp)Sound Acoustical Animal Sound Ghana
RepresentationOrganisms Bioengineering Model Membranes El SalvadorElectricity Electrical Alarm Circuits AustraliaSolids & Liquids Chemical Playdough Process CanadaLandforms Geotechnical Bridge Siting NepalPlants Packaging Plant Package JordanMagnetism Transportation Maglev Vehicle JapanEnergy & Power BotswanaSolar System Astronautical Brazil
Science and Math
• Lesson 1: Engineering Story• Lesson 2: A Broader View of an Engineering
Field• Lesson 3: Scientific Data Inform
Engineering Design• Lesson 4: Engineering Design
Challenge
What is Engineering?
0.0%10.0%20.0%30.0%40.0%50.0%60.0%70.0%80.0%90.0%
100.0%
% o
f C
orre
ct A
nsw
ers
MA Control Pre
EiE Pre
MA Control Post
EiE Post
What is Engineering?New Items
0.0%10.0%20.0%30.0%40.0%50.0%60.0%70.0%80.0%90.0%
100.0%
DevelopBetter Gum
ImproveBandages
CreateWarmerJackets
Figure outHow to Track
Luggage
WritePrograms
DesignTunnels
% o
f C
orr
ec
t A
ns
we
rs
EiE Test Pre
EiE Test Post
What is Technology?
0.0%10.0%20.0%30.0%40.0%50.0%60.0%70.0%80.0%90.0%
100.0%
% o
f C
orre
ct A
nsw
ers
MA Control Pre
EiE Pre
MA Control Post
EiE Post
Contact Information
• Christine Cunningham: [email protected]
• National Center for Technological Literacy: www.nctl.org
• Engineering is Elementary: www.mos.org/EiE