submission to the legislative council select committee on the tasmanian forests agreement
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
1/21
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
2/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 2
C, EG
A
: , .
F A
.
H
(
L FC ).
I FA ,
.
A , FA
.
F , A
,
H A
(HA).
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
3/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 3
E G (EG)
F A (FA)
.
: , .
A , ,
.
A . I FA
, . ,
,
L A,
C .
C
,
L C
A .
C. C
C.
C,
.
A ,
,
, ,
.
, .
A , E
20 ,
5000 .
E D 2006
,
. E
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
4/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 4
. M C
.
M
; F I., F J M,
F , L E C, M C C C, , B I., F &
D C G, E , ,
B, C, A I.,
, G
(ACF) ,
50 , , ,
. ACF , ,
. I 2012, 35,000
ACF .
()
,
A E.
; ,
, ,
,
.
C . I H L.
, ,
. ,
.
,
, EG
. E
F G. ( )
. I
, . I
.
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
5/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 5
F G
FA , H
E C, C .
. EG
, FA
, .
A , FA
.
H
. G
F C
, C B F A A
L ( ),
,
.
I FA
. I
,
.
I , ,
. H
. ,
,
. ;
1999
, .
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
6/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 6
.
1991,
F A
. G .
. A
,
.
F A 1991,
. I M 2009,
C C B C G,
. I , ,
. ,
.
, . I
, , ,
.
, ,
:
/
A A
A
A M (AM) D .
D 1980,
AM. A , E
. F
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
7/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 7
M F AM
1950.
F F C 1989, CE, G
, . , B
. B , 1991
.
D
, AM .
.
.
.
AM
. AM
.
,
. I
.
FA.
A , FA
,
, .
.
,
,
.
, ,
.
I A F (IGA) .
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
8/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 8
FA
. I
,
.
.
, A ,
,
G F C ,
. I
.
A
,
H A (HA).
EG
L C
FA B 2012 (FA B 2012).
EG C 2 FA , ,
A .
A
,
.
.
FA B 2012 A.
H, A
B.
A B
A. G ,
FA, A. D
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
9/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 9
B,
.
FA B
. A EG , ,
A.
M FA FA B 2012.
.
,
.
.
C FA ,
,
.
A, ,
.
MAD .
EG .
I
.
F G A,
. I
C ,
G .
FA ,
.
C , . H
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
10/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 10
,
. F
, G
.
F EG .
2010 2012, H, L, H,
M, D F, , , D, B . E
. , ,
K ,
.
M,
. ( 2010), K A (J 2011), H A (J 2011),
F I A (A 2011), I
G E (M 2012), D F A
B (J 2012), I A (A 2012), F
A ( 2012) F A B (D
2012).
FA FA B 2012
, . G
, .
,
.
FA,
L C FA B 2012.
, .
A
FA . I
,
.
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
11/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 11
.
,
H
, .
,
:
L ;
F ;
F , ,
/ ;
F ;
F (
); ,
F ( ,
)
( ),
.
I A 2011, G F:
, 600 ,
.I , 2011
, ,
.
A G ,
. A I G,
.
E B M
A , D M L
, H AM, C J, D M J, D
M, .
1
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
12/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 12
, IG
EG . B
: () ; () H
; () ; () ; () ; () H; ()
C; () ; () E () .
EG
A G ,
(C B D,
H C), C .
.
I EG ,
/ .
EG
. I EG
. 18.
A 2013, A . I ,
.
,
F, , F ,
.
,
, , .
EG
,
, . G
, . I
D L
2http://www.environment.gov.au/land/forests/independent-verification/pubs/ivg_capstone_final1-1.pdf3
http://www.environment.gov.au/land/forests/independent-verification/report.html4http://www.wilderness.org.au/campaigns/forests/DougApsley
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
13/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 13
F E A
, , ,
.
,
.
, F A 2012
C
.
D FA,
.
.
M
. EG
,
FA ,
.
EG
. FA B 2012 . I
137,000
. FA B 2012
. C 6 F A
, , ,
.
I 2012, F
201112 109,940 3 HL,
.
5http://au.wiley.com/WileyCDA/WileyTitle/productCd-CON4.html
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
14/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 14
I , FA B 2012
571,000
.
, ,
, . FA
,
.
FA . I
571,000 ,
,
, 37,954 C
. C 9
M ,
.
FA,
,
.
,
, FA
.
I 2012, F 12,483 3 . , 84 3
B, 381 2 D, 756 3 H 11,265 3
M.
, C
. B 80
97.5% B FA. M B
I F A
F
FA . H
FA.
6Review of Tasmanian Forest Estate Wood Supply Scenarios. Mark Burgman and Andrew Robinson.
Final Report to the Independent Verification Group, Intergovernmental Agreement, Version 9.9March 7, 2012. http://www.environment.gov.au/land/forests/independent-
verification/pubs/ivg_woodsupply_burgman.pdf
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
15/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 15
I , , M, C ,
41,000
FA.
(
400% 4%).
. A B
IG ,
FA,
.
E
, FA
.
,
, C
. C 9 ,
FA ,
.
FA B 2012
. E L C A F
C A , ,
, 80
25 30 .
,
. A ,
, C .
. B
, FA
.
, J
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
16/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 16
A, . E
G I G
IGA
,
. EG
,
.
FA
,
,
,
,
.
I
. F
$277
.
$20 1765
.
,
,
.
15,000 32,000 ,
, 13.5%
$2 ( 8%) .
, , . HA
. F , G E, BDA G (2009),
H A:
$700,445,000 ;
7IGA job creation figures, taken from the Department for Regional Australia figures on
economic diversification pending; http://www.regional.gov.au/regional/tasmania/projects.aspx:
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
17/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 17
$200,761,000 ;
5131 .
,
. A
CC A
D
, &
,
. A
.
FA FC
,
,
,
.
E C ECE FA FC FC
12 20 .
FC M 2011 FC
. 53.9% FC
A FC
.
A FA 2009 F , 2006, 24
. FA E F C, 2017, 45
.
8Gillespie Economics, BDA Group (2009):Economic Activity of Australias World Heritage
Areas, Department of Environment, Water, Heritage and Arts, Australian Government,Australia.
9
PricewaterhouseCoopers (2007): Sustainable Investments for conservation The businesscase for biodiversity. A study on behalf of the WW F Germany.10FSC Global Market Survey 2011. http://ic.fsc.org/market-information.345.htm
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
18/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 18
I
FC
.
F ,
. A
(, ) ( )
,
.
2012
.
/ (
)
,
.
(
) C F I
(CFI)
, , CFI , (
) , A .
CFI A C C
(ACC). A K
D 2012,
, ACC
ACC
A .
I G ACC
F A, :
1. F G
CFI,
CFI F G
CFI
11Tasmanian Forest Carbon Study (May et al 2012), commissioned by the Tasmanian Climate Change
Office; Tasmanian Forests Intergovernmental Agreement:An assessment of its carbon value(Macintosh 2012), commissioned by the Tasmanian Forest Agreement Independent Verification Group12Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
19/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 19
2. G ()
CFI ()
CFI (
)
3. G ,
,
4. F G ( D
I C)
ACC G
5. G
() ACC , ()
ACC
ACC (. L ,
),
.
, F
G D 2012 M G
C F
A G
CFI
.
EG FA .
.
.
, ,
,
.
FA
, ,
. A
A .
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
20/21
-
8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement
21/21
ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 21
. ,
.
A : '
: I
, . (G
, C 18 2010)
D 2010, , C,
,
C B F A.
C . I 72
29
.
F A C ( 21
), A , " '
' . (G ,
C 18 2010).