summary: disposition of comments for pdtr3 20943-5 smmp taesul seo/sungjoon lim kisti/kdb, korea...
TRANSCRIPT
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
1
Summary:Disposition of Comments for PDTR3
20943-5 SMMP
Taesul SEO/Sungjoon LIMKISTI/KDB, Korea
2012-06-06
WG2N1668
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
2
Overview
• PDTR3 of 20943-5 SMMP obtained substantial support (32N2225)
• Comments to be resolved– Canadian : 36– Japanese : 1– United States : 33 (Non-official)
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
3
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (1)
• Comments for errors in transforming MS Word file into PDF format– 11 cmmnts : CA01, CA13~18, CA30~31,
CA34~35
• Editor’s action : To request SC32 Sec-retariat special care while transform-ing word to pdf
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
4
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (2)
• Structure of the manuscript– 5 cmmnts : CA04~05, CA09, CA25,
CA27
• Editor’s action : Restructure the rele-vant parts of the manuscript reflect-ing the comments
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
5
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (3)
• Unclear words or inconsistency of some words– 6 cmmnts : CA07~8, CA11, CA20~21, CA32
• Editor’s action : Make the unclear words clear and use some inconsistent words consistently
• Data, data element, metadata element set, primary/secondary data element, mapping, …
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
6
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (3)
• CA02 : The text doesn’t includes se-mantics and many-to-one/one-to-many mapping.
• Proposals : Remove “semantic” from the title or add more description on semantics.
• Editor’s action : Remove “semantic” from the title.
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
7
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (4)
• CA03 : Define heterogeneity, add why it is important, and explain the relationship with factoring
• Editor’s action : Accept all
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
8
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (5)
• CA10 : Add DE and DEC to Abbrevia-tion Clause
• Editor’s action : Accept all
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
9
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (6)
• CA12, CA19 : Change “semantic mapping” to “data element concept mapping”
• Editor’s action : Change “semantic mapping” to “data element map-ping” because mapping is performed at data element level under same data element concept.
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
10
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (7)
• CA22~24 : Increase the complete-ness of the examples
• Proposals : Modify some table field names and add DC as primary data elements
• Editor’s action : Improve the example reflecting the comments
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
11
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (8)
• CA26 : Questions about value map-ping
• Editor’s action : Improve the relevant parts reflecting the comments
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
12
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (8)
• CA06, CA28~29 : Some advices for improvement
• Proposals : Adopt heterogeneity type number and add/complete bibliogra-phies
• Editor’s action : Accept all
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
13
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (9)
• CA33 : Necessity of Annex B• Proposals : Remove or add explana-
tion• Editor’s action : Enhance Annex B
and the text to include clear explana-tion about the relationship with fac-toring
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
14
Summary of Canadian Com-ments (10)
• CA36 : General comments• No specific action is needed.
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
15
Summary of Japanese Com-ments (1)
• JP01 : Comments for errors in trans-forming MS Word file into PDF format
• Editor’s action : To request SC32 Sec-retariat special care while transform-ing word to pdf
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
16
Summary of US Comments (1)
• Typing errors and English problems– 10 cmmnts : US05~07, US09, US12~13
US29~32
• Editor’s action : Accept all
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
17
Summary of US Comments (2)
• US01~03 : Make the scope simple and rewrite the content
• Editor’s action : Rewrite the scope re-flecting the comments
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
18
Summary of US Comments (3)
• US10~11, 26 : Structure of the man-uscript
• Editor’s action : Restructure the rele-vant parts of the manuscript reflect-ing the comments
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
19
Summary of US Comments (4)
• US14, US16~17, US19 : Make un-clear words clear
• Proposals : Explain “less important” and “primary data element”
• Editor’s action : Change “less impor-tant” to “to expect not to be used” and explain
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
20
Summary of US Comments (5)
• US18 : Remove the sentence includ-ing “standardization”
• Proposals : Same as above• Editor’s action : Remove “standard-
ization” from the sentence because the sentence is important part of this TR
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
21
Summary of US Comments (6)
• US33 : Change the title• Proposals : Change title to “Semantic
Mapping Procedure”• Editor’s action : Change title to
“Metadata Mapping Procedure” (cf. CA02)
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
22
Summary of US Comments (7)
• Need discussion to resolve– US04, US08, US15, US20~25, US28
2012-06-06
Disposition of Comments, PDTR3 20943-5
232012-06-06
DATA ELEMENT CONCEPT DATA ELEMENT
(1:1)(1:N)
(1:N)
Property
Object Class
(1:1)
(1:N)
Property
Representation
(1:1)
Object Class
CONCEPTUAL DOMAIN
VALUE MEAN-ING
PERMISSIBLE VALUES VALUE DOMAIN(1:N) (1:1) (N:1)
DEC CD
DE VD
(1:N) (1:N)
(N:1)
(N:1)
Conceptual Level
Representational Level
Mapping is performed at representational level, DE and PV.