supplementary online content -...
TRANSCRIPT
© 2017 American Medical Association. All rights reserved.
Supplementary Online Content
Stahl A, Krohne TU, Eter N. Comparing alternative ranibizumab dosages for safety and
efficacy in retinopathy of prematurity: a randomized clinical trial. Published online January 8,
2018. JAMA Paediatr. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2017.4838
eTable 1. List of inclusion and exclusion criteria for CARE-ROP
eTable 2. List of all infants who did not reach the primary endpoint analysis at 24 weeks
eTable 3. (a) List of reported medical history conditions of all infants who died during the
study. (b) List of all adverse events occurring in infants who died during the study.
eTable 4. List of all protocol deviations (PD) during the course of the study
eTable 5. Primary outcome analysis per patient and per eye (full analysis set).
eTable 6. Hazard ratios of need for rescue treatment.
eTable 7. Efficacy outcomes.
eTable 8. ROP baseline and final outcome values for all patients
eTable 9. Baseline characteristics and staging for both infants receiving rescue treatment
eTable 10. List of all eyes receiving re-treatment
eTable 11. Complete list of all systemic VEGF levels measured in CARE-ROP
eTable 12. Numbers of all (serious) adverse events occurring during the duration of the study.
eTable 13. Oxygen supplementation
eFigure 1. Blood sampling protocol
eFigure 2. APGAR scores of all randomized patients
eFigure 3. Distribution of plus disease for all eyes over the course of the study.
eFigure 4. Physiologic vascularization.
eFigure 5. Systemic VEGF levels.
eFigure 6. Systolic and diastolic blood pressure measurements for all patients.
eFigure 7. Heart rate, oxygen saturation and respiratory rate for all patients
eFigure 8. Development of weight, length and head circumference development
2
eTable 1. List of inclusion and exclusion criteria for CARE-ROP
Inclusion criteria
- bilateral ROP in zone I (stage 1+, 2+, 3+/-, AP-ROP) or ROP in posterior zone II (stage 3+, AP-ROP)*
- legal representatives or their designates willing and able to attend regular study visits with the study infant
- written informed consent to participate in the study
Exclusion criteria - pediatric conditions rendering the infant ineligible to anti-VEGF treatment or to repeated
blood draws as evaluated by a neonatal ICU specialist and a study ophthalmologist
- congenital brain lesions significantly impairing optic nerve function
- severe hydrocephalus with significantly increased intracranial pressure
- ROP stage 4 and 5
- ROP only in peripheral zone II or zone III
- known hypersensitivity to the study drug or to drugs with similar chemical structures - contraindications for an intravitreal injection as listed in ranibizumab summary of product characteristics (SmPC) (1)
- systemic use of anti-VEGF therapeutics - use of other investigational drugs (excluding vitamins and minerals) at the time of enrollment,
or within 30 days or 5 half-lives prior to enrollment, whichever is longer
* Zone I is defined as twice the distance from the optic disc to the fovea measured temporally, posterior zone IIis defined as three times the distance from the optic disc to the fovea measured temporally
ICU = intensive care unit
3
eTable 2. List of all infants who did not reach the primary endpoint analysis at 24 weeks
Premature study discontinuation (deaths)
infant no. 1 infant no. 2 infant no. 3
ranibizumab dose 0.12 mg 0.20 mg 0.20 mg
sex male female male
date of death (days post baseline) 101 161 115
cause of death sepsis cardiac failure renal / liver failure
base
line
char
acte
rist
ics
at b
irth
GA (weeks + days) 23 + 5 27 + 2 25 + 1
weight [g] 550 720 635
length [cm] 31 30 31
head circumference [cm] 21,5 23 22
AP
GA
R
1' 4 6 4
5' 4 7 6
10' 6 8 7
stag
ing
of R
OP
base
line
ROP stage 3 3 3
ROP zone II p II p II p
plus disease* moderate severe moderate
retinal hemorrhage (clock hours both eyes) 5 15 7
vitreous hemorrhage absent absent absent
last
vis
it date of last visit (days post baseline) 101 160 112
ROP stage no ROP no ROP 1
ROP zone fully vascularized avascular retina II a III
plus disease* absent absent mild
All premature study discontinuations were due to death of the infant (one in the 0.12 mg and two in the 0.2 mg group). All deaths occurred at least 101 days (14 weeks) after study treatment and none was suspected to be related to the study treatment. There were no deaths among infants receiving multiple ranibizumab injections.
* classification of plus disease severity as judged by the investigator
4
eTable 3. (a) List of reported medical history conditions of all infants who died during the study. (b) List of all adverse events occurring in infants who died during the study.
a) 0.12 mg ranibizumab
0.20 mg ranibizumab
infant no. 1 infant no. 2 infant no. 3
medical history location active at
study start
medical history location active at study start medical history location active at
study start
Laparotomy due to NEC worsening non-ocular no Anaemia non-ocular yes Anaemia non-ocular Yes
Laparotomy due to NEC worsening non-ocular no Cardiomyopathy non-ocular yes Respiratory
distress syndrome non-ocular Yes
Laparotomy due to NEC worsening non-ocular no Renal failure non-ocular yes Patent ductus
arteriosus non-ocular Yes
Laparotomy due to NEC worsening non-ocular no sleep-wake
disorder non-ocular yes Intestinal obstruction non-ocular Yes
Necrotising enterocolitis
(NEC) non-ocular no Pulmonary
hypertension non-ocular yes Unspecified fever non-ocular No
Neonatal intestinal perforation non-ocular no Hypothyroidism non-ocular yes Staphylococcal
sepsis non-ocular Yes
Neonatal intestinal perforation non-ocular no Osteopenia non-ocular yes Bronchopulmonary
dysplasia non-ocular Yes
Bacterial sepsis (Escherichia coli) non-ocular no Respiratory
failure non-ocular yes Hypothyroidism non-ocular Yes
Neonatal intestinal perforation non-ocular no
Bronchopulmonary dysplasia
non-ocular yes Intestinal dilatation non-ocular Yes
Neonatal intestinal perforation non-ocular no Arterial
hypertension non-ocular yes
Anaemia non-ocular yes
Patent ductus arteriosus non-ocular yes
Intraventricular haemorrhage non-ocular yes
Cholestasis non-ocular yes
5
0.12 mg ranibizumab 0.20 mg ranibizumab
infant no. 1 infant no. 2 infant no. 3
Arterial hypotension non-ocular yes
Bronchopulmonary dysplasia non-ocular yes
Adrenal insufficiency non-ocular yes
Cardiomyopathy non-ocular yes
Thrombocytopenia non-ocular yes
Coagulation disorder non-ocular yes
Infantile apnoea non-ocular no
Bradycardia non-ocular no
6
b) 0.12 mg ranibizumab
0.20 mg ranibizumab
infant no. 1 infant no. 2 infant no. 3
adverse events severity time from
injection to start of AE [d]
adverse events severity time from
injection to start of AE [d]
adverse events severity time from
injection to start of AE [d]
Intestinal fistula moderate 20 Arterial hypertension mild 7 Hyperglycaemia mild 1
Adrenal insufficiency moderate 1 New retinal
haemorrhage mild 70 Hyperinsulinism mild 1
Gastrointestinal dysbacteriosis moderate 48 Constipation mild 32 Arterial
hypotension moderate 74
Pulmonary hypertension severe* 48 Respiratory tract
infection moderate 28 Pulmonary hypertension moderate 62
Bronchial obstruction severe* 48 Worsening of
ROP moderate 91 Pain moderate 79
Arterial hypotension severe 0 Circulatory
collapse severe 41 Increase in
severity of plus disease
moderate 3
Sepsis severe 101 Circulatory collapse severe 128 New retinal
haemorrhages moderate 43
Cardiopulmonary failure severe 160 New occurence
of plus disease moderate 78
Cardiac failure severe 37 Bronchopulm. dysplasia severe 29
Sepsis severe 37 Hepatic failure severe 62
Renal failure severe 112
Ascites severe 101
Abdominal
compartment syndrome
severe 101
Respiratory failure severe 101
* = rated severe but non-serious by the investigator (all other severe events were rated as serious adverse events (SAEs)) Note: None of the occurring adverse events was suspected by the investigator to be related to the study drug.
7
eTable 4. List of all protocol deviations (PD) during the course of the study
Protocol deviations (PDs)
infant deviation category protocol deviation PD severity
0.12
mg
rani
bizu
mab
1 time schedule visit date not within scheduled time frame minor
2 time schedule visit date not within scheduled time frame minor
3 time schedule visit date not within scheduled time frame minor
4
in- / exclusion criteria study assessments before written informed consent minor
time schedule visit date not within scheduled time frame minor
5 study treatment rescue treatment with re-injection and laser treatment minor
6 time schedule visit date not within scheduled time frame minor
0.20
mg
rani
bizu
mab
1 time schedule visit date not within scheduled time frame minor
2 time schedule visit date not within scheduled time frame minor
3 time schedule visit date not within scheduled time frame minor
4 time schedule randomization date not on date of baseline visit minor
5 time schedule visit date not within scheduled time frame minor
6
in- / exclusion criteria study assessments before written informed consent minor
time schedule visit date not within scheduled time frame minor
All PDs were considered minor since they did not impact the primary endpoint. Most PDs were noted in the category “time schedule” and were due to study visits being outside the pre-defined time window. In all these cases the visit schedule was missed by a few days.
8
eTable 5. Primary outcome analysis per patient and per eye (full analysis set).
Full analysis set (FAS)
Incidence of patients without need for rescue treatment
0.12 mg (N=10) n (%) [95%-CI]
0.20 mg (N=9) n (%) [95%-CI]
Total (N=19) n (%) [95%-CI]
Odds Ratio [95%-CI]
All patients 8 (80.0)
[44.4; 97.5] 6 (66.7) [29.9; 92.5]
14 (73.7) [48.8; 90.9]
1.88* [0.26; 13.49]
Gestational age at birth ≤ 25 weeks 4 (66.7) [22.3; 95.7]
4 (80.0) [28.4; 99.5]
8 (72.7) [39.0; 94.0]
0.50 [0.03; 7.99]
Gestational age at birth > 25 weeks 4 (100.0) [39.8; 100.0]
2 (50.0) [6.8; 93.2]
6 (75.0) [34.9; 96.8]
-
Incidence of eyes without need for rescue treatment
0.12 mg (N=20) n (%) [95%-CI]
0.20 mg (N=18) n (%) [95%-CI]
Total (N=38) n (%) [95%-CI]
Odds Ratio [95%-CI]
All patients 17 (85.0)
[54.5; 98.3] 13 (72.2) [38.5; 93.8]
30 (78.9) [54.6; 93.9]
2.18 [0.26; 18.19]
Gestational age at birth ≤ 25 weeks 9 (75.0) [36.8; 96.3]
9 (90.0) [55.5; 99.7]
18 (81.8) [54.4; 96.4]
0.33 [0.02; 5.46]
Gestational age at birth > 25 weeks 8 (100.0) [-; -]
4 (50.0) [10.6; 89.4]
12 (75.0) [35.7; 96.6]
-
p-value for difference between treatment groups per patient (Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel-Test): 0.529 * Odds ratio estimate adjusted for gestational age (Mantel-Haenszel estimate) p-value for difference between treatment groups per eye (Rao-Scott Chi-Square Test): 0.425 Confidence limits and p-values are calculated assuming a stratified cluster sampling design with subjects equivalent to clusters, eyes equivalent to units within clusters, and gestational age equivalent to strata, using the Taylor series linearization method for variance estimation. For percentages, modified Clopper Pearson confidence limits are calculated. N and n refer to the number of eyes, i.e., for N the number of infants times 2. Note: Patients who discontinued the study prematurely (i.e. due to death) are considered as having received rescue treatment in both eyes in the FAS.
Number of patients and eyes without rescue therapy up to week 24 in the full analysis set (FAS). Note that patients who
discontinued the study prematurely due to death are considered as having received rescue treatment in both eyes in the FAS.
The data shows effective treatment in the majority of patients in both groups with no statistical difference between the two
dosages, confirming the data found in the per protocol analysis.
b)b)
9
eTable 6. Hazard ratios of need for rescue treatment.
Per protocol set (PPS)
Hazard ratio of need for rescue treatment Ranibizumab 0.12 mg (N=9) vs. Ranibizumab 0.20 mg (N=7)
Hazard Ratio [95%-CI]
All patients 0.89* [0.06; 14.36]
Gestational age at birth ≤ 25 weeks 0.89 [0.06; 14.36]
Gestational age at birth > 25 weeks -
Result from Cox proportional hazards model of need for rescue treatment, censored at the last study visit or death, with treatment group as predictor * Stratified by gestational age
Full analysis set (FAS)
Hazard ratio of need for rescue treatment Ranibizumab 0.12 mg (N=10) vs. Ranibizumab 0.20 mg (N=9)
Hazard Ratio [95%-CI]
All patients 0.75* [0.05; 11.97]
Gestational age at birth ≤ 25 weeks 0.75 [0.05; 11.97]
Gestational age at birth > 25 weeks -
Result from Cox proportional hazards model of need for rescue treatment, censored at the last study visit or death, with treatment group as predictor * Stratified by gestational age
Hazard ratios stratified by gestational age are comparable between the two dosage groups
a
b
10
eTable 7. Efficacy outcomes
Full analysis set (FAS)
ROP severity, n (%) Last post-baseline assessment ≤ Week 24
Baseline No ROP III , 1 IIa, 1 III , 1+ Total Ranibizumab 0.12 mg (N=20) IIp, 3+ 9 (45.0) 6 (30.0) 0 (0.0) 0 (0.0) 15 (75.0) I, 3+ 3 (15.0) 0 (0.0) 2 (10.0) 0 (0.0) 5 (25.0) Total 12 (60.0) 6 (30.0) 2 (10.0) 0 (0.0) 20 (100.0) Ranibizumab 0.2 mg (N=18) IIp, 3+ 8 (44.4) 5 (27.8) 0 (0.0) 2 (11.1) 15 (83.3) I, 3+ 2 (11.1) 1 (5.6) 0 (0.0) 0 (0.0) 3 (16.7) Total 10 (55.6) 6 (33.3) 0 (0.0) 2 (11.1) 18 (100.0) Total (N=38) IIp, 3+ 17 (44.7) 11 (28.9) 0 (0.0) 2 (5.3) 30 (78.9) I, 3+ 5 (13.2) 1 (2.6) 2 (5.3) 0 (0.0) 8 (21.1) Total 22 (57.9) 12 (31.6) 2 (5.3) 2 (5.3) 38 (100.0) N and n refer to the number of eyes.
Efficacy shift tables for all eyes in the full analysis set (FAS). The majority of eyes (58%) had no ROP at the last available post-baseline visit. Sixteen eyes (42%) had stage 1 ROP in either anterior zone II (5%) or zone III (37%). Plus disease was present at the last available visit in only one patient. This patient died 115 days post baseline and the last visit was at 16 weeks (112 days).
11
eTable 8. ROP baseline and final outcome values for all patients
Note that last visit was at 24 weeks for most patients with the exception of the three infants who died during the study (see comments in table). p = posterior; a = anterior; n.a. = not applicable, OD = right eye, OS = left eye * classification of plus disease severity as judged by the investigator
staging of ROP (OD) staging of ROP (OS)
baseline last visit baseline last visit comment
patient stage zone plus disease* stage zone plus
disease stage zone plus disease* stage zone plus
disease*
0.12
mg
rani
bizu
mab
1 3 I severe no ROP n.a. absent 3 II p moderate no ROP n.a. absent
2 3 II p moderate 1 III absent 3 II p moderate 1 III absent re-treatment both eyes week 10
3 3 II p mild no ROP n.a. absent 3 II p moderate no ROP n.a. absent
4 3 II p mild 1 III absent 3 II p mild 1 III absent
5 3 II p mild no ROP n.a. absent 3 II p mild no ROP n.a. absent
6 3 II p mild no ROP n.a. absent 3 II p mild no ROP n.a. absent
7 3 II p moderate no ROP n.a. absent 3 II p moderate no ROP n.a. absent death week 12
8 3 I moderate 1 II a absent 3 I mild 1 II a absent re-treatment both eyes week 12
9 3 I severe no ROP n.a. absent 3 I severe no ROP n.a. absent rescue right eye laser + rbz wk. 2
10 3 II p mild 1 III absent 3 II p mild 1 III absent
0.20
mg
rani
bizu
mab
1 3 II p mild 1 III absent 3 II p mild 1 III absent
2 3 II p moderate 1 III absent 3 I moderate 1 III absent
3 3 I mild no ROP n.a. absent 3 II p mild no ROP n.a. absent
4 3 II p severe no ROP n.a. absent 3 I severe no ROP n.a. absent re-treatment both eyes wk 6 + 14
5 3 II p moderate 1 III absent 3 II p moderate 1 III absent
6 3 II p moderate no ROP n.a. absent 3 II p moderate no ROP n.a. absent re-treatment both eyes week 8
7 3 II p severe no ROP n.a. absent 3 II p severe no ROP n.a. absent death week 20
8 3 II p moderate no ROP n.a. absent 3 II p moderate no ROP n.a. absent rescue left eye laser week 2
9 3 II p moderate 1 III mild 3 II p moderate 1 III mild death week 16
12
eTable 9. Baseline characteristics and staging for both infants receiving rescue treatment
Rescue Treatments
infant no. 1 infant no. 2
ranibizumab dose 0.12 mg 0.20 mg sex male male
at b
irth
GA (weeks + days) 24 + 1 24 + 5 weight [g] 400 510 length [cm] missing 29 head circumference [cm] missing 22
AP
GA
R 1' 2 2
5' 4 7
10' 5 7
OD OS OD OS
RO
P
base
line ROP stage 3 3 3 3
ROP zone I I II p. II p. plus disease* severe severe moderate moderate retinal hemorrhage (clock hours) absent absent absent absent vitreous hemorrhage absent absent absent absent
RO
P
at r
escu
e date of rescue (days post bsl) 17 n.a. n.a. 14 type of rescue laser + 0.2 mg rbz n.a. n.a. laser ROP stage 4a 1 2 3 ROP zone missing II p. II a. II a. plus disease* absent absent absent moderate
RO
P
at E
OS
ROP stage no ROP no ROP no ROP no ROP Vascularization to ora serrata no yes yes no plus disease* absent absent absent absent
Note that only one eye per infant received rescue treatment. Both rescued eyes had no ROP at the final study visit.
p = posterior; a = anterior * classification of plus disease severity as judged by the investigator
13
eTable 10. List of all eyes receiving re-treatment
Re-treatments
infant no. 1 infant no. 2 infant no. 3 infant no. 4
ranibizumab dose 0.12 mg 0.12 mg 0.20 mg 0.20 mg
sex female male female male
base
line
char
acte
rist
ics
at b
irth
GA (weeks + days) 23 + 3 25 + 0 26 + 3 25 + 1
weight [g] 560 645 1075 550
length [cm] 30 32 35 30.8
head circumference [cm] 18 22.5 24.5 19.5
AP
GA
R
1' 5 2 7 6
5' 5 6 8 7
10' 7 6 8 8
OD OS OD OS OD OS OD OS
stag
ing
of R
OP
base
line
ROP stage 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
ROP zone II p II p I I II p I II p II p
plus disease* moderate moderate moderate mild severe severe moderate moderate
retinal hemorrhage (clock hours) 5 6 absent absent 6 6 10 12
vitreous hemorrhage absent absent absent absent absent absent absent absent
re-t
reat
men
t date of re-treatment (days post bsl) 69 105 50 56
ROP stage 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
ROP zone II a II a II p II p II p II p II a II a
plus disease* mild mild mild mild moderate moderate mild moderate
re-t
reat
men
t date of 2nd re-treatment (days post 1st re-tx)
71
ROP stage
3 3
ROP zone
II p II p
plus disease*
moderate moderate
end
of s
tudy
ROP stage 1 1 1 1 no ROP no ROP no ROP no ROP
ROP zone III III II a II a n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.
plus disease* absent absent absent absent absent absent absent absent
vascularization to ora yes yes no no yes yes yes yes
14
Re-treatments were evenly distributed across the two groups. Six eyes received one re-treatment and two eyes received two re-treatments. Final ROP stage at 24 weeks was no ROP in four eyes and stage 1 ROP in four eyes. p = posterior; a = anterior; OD = right eye, OS = left eye * classification of plus disease severity as judged by the investigator
15
eTable 11 a, b. Complete list of all systemic VEGF levels measured in CARE-ROP
Free plasma VEGF (0.12 mg group) patient no.
week 1 2 a 3 4 5 6 7 b 8 c 9 d 10
0 39.32 7.8 * 23.52 23.35 16.18 59.58 30.16 ** 26.68
1 24.18 38.75 41.09 28.83 24.85 30.82 21.52 105.61 30.4 18.51
2 34.9 20.85 28.83
3 33.64 26.18 7.8 * 26.84 31.9 31.15
4 29.49 29.49 30.4 #
5 20.19 7.8 * 25.51 7.8 * 169.39 17.51 18.18 7.8 * 77.66
6 16.84 16.84 19.99 38.55
7
8 20.74
9
10 49.15 #
11 53.89
12 24.18
13 23.52
14
15 23.52 7.8 * #
16 7.8 *
17 22.22
18 17.03
19
20
21
22
* measured value was below detection limit of 15.6 pg/ml and replaced by 7.8 pg/ml
** hemolytic sample (excluded from analysis)
# baseline value before re-injection / rescue
a re-injection in week 10
b patient died
c re-injection in week 15
d unilateral rescue treatment
a)
16
Free plasma VEGF (0.20 mg group)
patient no.
week 1 2 3 4 a 5 6 b 7 c 8 d 9 d, e
0 24,85 46,66 7.8 * 56,52 7.8 * 7.8 * 35,45 7.8 *
1 16,18 63,08 7.8 * 99,82 7.8 * 17,51 22,19 7.8 *
2
16,84
3 22,19 30,82
7.8*
7.8 * 43,85 # **
4
20,19
7.8 * 16,29
5 18,85 63,08
43,37
16,29
6 23,52
20,19
16,84
7
20,19 #
8
7.8 *
7.8 * #
9
16,18
10
11
52,35
12
20,85
26,18
13
27,5
14
22,19
15
16
17
7.8 * #
18
19
20
7.8 *
21
7.8 *
22
23
7.8 *
* measured value was below detection limit of 15.6 pg/ml and replaced by 7.8 pg/ml
** hemolytic sample (excluded from analysis)
# baseline value before re-injection / rescue
a re-injection in week 7 and week 17
b re-injection in week 8
c unilateral rescue treatment
d patient died
e no VEGF measurements available
Note that CTAD buffer was used to prevent thrombolysis. Values represent free plasma VEGF.
b)
17
eTable 12. Numbers of all (serious) adverse events occurring during the duration of the study
Summary of treatment emergent adverse events* Frequency of patients 0.12 mg rbz
(N=10) 0.20 mg
rbz (N=9)
- with adverse event 10 9
- with ocular adverse event 9 9
- with non-ocular adverse event 8 9
- with ocular adverse event with suspected relationship to study treatment 5 a 4 b
- with non-ocular adverse event with suspected relationship to study treatment 0 1 c
- who died 1 2
- who died with suspected relationship to study treatment 0 0
- with serious adverse event 5 6
- with ocular serious adverse event 2 2
- with non-ocular serious adverse event 4 5
- with ocular serious adverse event with suspected relationship to study treatment 1 d 0
- with non-ocular serious adverse event with suspected relationship to study treatment 0 0
* defined as adverse events with start date after the first study treatment a conjunctival haemorrhage, retinal detachment (ROP 4a), injection site haemorrhage b conjunctival haemorrhage, corneal edema, retinal haemorrhage, retinal vascular disorder c respiratory failure, hypotension d retinal detachment (ROP 4a)
Events were distributed evenly between the two study arms.
18
eTable 13. Oxygen supplementation
Supplementary oxygen 0.12 mg (N=10) 0.20 mg (N=9)
N median number of days N median number of
days
befo
re
base
line
intubated 10 23 9 35
CPAP or high flow nasal cannula 10 48 9 39
nasal cannula 2 13 0 -
oxygen by hood / incubator 1 10 0 -
base
line
to
wee
k 24
intubated 6 1.5 8 3.5
CPAP or high flow nasal cannula 8 6 8 12
nasal cannula 5 19 5 83
oxygen by hood / incubator 1 13 0 -
(a) Supplementary oxygen therapy given before and after baseline ranibizumab injection. Before baseline, oxygen demand was evenly distributed between the two groups (more days intubated in the 0.2mg group but more days with CPAP / high flow nasal cannula in the 0.12 mg group). In the post-baseline assessment, the 0.2mg group showed more days with oxygen via nasal cannula compared to the 0.12mg group (83 vs. 19 days). N = number of infants; CPAP = continuous positive airway pressure
(b) Target oxygen ranges (in %) for the first 10 postnatal weeks. Median values and ranges are comparable between the two groups.
Target oxygen saturation (%) - history since birth (median)
postnatal week
0.12 mg (N = 10) 0.20 mg (N = 9)
N lower limit (min-max)
upper limit (min-max) N
lower limit (min-max)
upper limit (min-max)
1 8 85.5 (83.0-86.0) 95.5 (93.0-96.0) 8 85.0 (71.0-88.0) 95.5 (93.0-99.0)
2 8 85.5 (83.0-86.0) 95.5 (93.0-96.0) 8 85.5 (80.0-88.0) 95.5 (93.0-99.0)
3 9 86.0 (80.0-92.0) 96.0 (92.0-98.0) 8 85.5 (80.0-88.0) 95.0 (92.0-98.0)
4 8 85.5 (80.0-86.0) 95.5 (92.0-96.0) 8 85.5 (80.0-88.0) 95.0 (91.0-98.0)
5 8 86.0 (80.0-88.0) 96.0 (92.0-98.0) 7 86.0 (80.0-88.0) 96.0 (93.0-98.0)
6 8 86.0 (80.0-88.0) 96.0 (92.0-98.0) 8 86.0 (80.0-88.0) 96.0 (93.0-98.0)
7 8 86.0 (80.0-88.0) 96.0 (92.0-98.0) 9 88.0 (70.0-88.0) 98.0 (92.0-98.0)
8 10 87.0 (80.0-88.0) 95.5 (92.0-98.0)
8 88.0 (64.0-88.0) 98.0 (93.0-98.0)
9 8 86.0 (80.0-88.0) 96.0 (92.0-98.0) 8 88.0 (80.0-88.0) 98.0 (91.0-98.0)
10 8 86.0 (85.0-88.0) 96.0 (95.0-98.0) 8 88.0 (80.0-90.0) 98.0 (94.0-98.0)
a)
b)
19
eFigure 1. Blood sampling protocol
Flow chart for collection of peripheral blood samples. Whenever possible, blood collection for CARE-ROP was combined with routine clinical blood draws. Care was taken to ensure standardized methods for blood collection and sample handling. CTAD was used as anticoagulant due to its superior qualities for measuring free VEGF. * CTAD = citrate, theophylline, adenosine and dipyridamole.
Blood collection using neonatal cannula.Fill CTAD* collection tubes with 200 - 500 µl of blood.
Close tube and invert 3 times directly after bloodcollection.
Centrifuge within max. 1 hour after blood collection.(3.000 g, 15 min., room temperature).
Use the same centrifuge throughout the study.
Store plasma at -20°C.
20
eFigure 2. APGAR scores of all randomized patients
APGAR scores of all infants are presented as histograms. There was no observable difference between the two treatment groups.
Apgar score - 1 minute
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 100
1
2
APGAR score
nu
mb
er o
f in
fan
ts
Apgar score - 5 minutes
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 100
1
2
3
4
5
APGAR scoren
um
ber
of
infa
nts
Apgar score - 10 minutes
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 100
1
2
3
4
5 ranibizumab 0.12mg
ranibizumab 0.20mg
APGAR score
nu
mb
er o
f in
fan
ts
21
eFigure 3. Distribution of plus disease for all eyes over the course of the study.
In almost all eyes plus disease resolved within the first weeks after treatment. There was, however, recurrence of plus disease in some eyes between week 6 and 16. Absent values at later study time points (week 16 – 24) were due to infant deaths.
day 0
day 1
day 3
week 1
week 2
week 3
week 4
week 5
week 6
week 8
week 1
0
week 1
2
week 1
6
week 2
0EOS
0
4
8
12
16
20
mild
moderate
severe
absent
missing value
num
ber o
f eye
s
day 0
day 1
day 3
week 1
week 2
week 3
week 4
week 5
week 6
week 8
week 1
0
week 1
2
week 1
6
week 2
0EOS
0
4
8
12
16
20
num
ber o
f eye
s
a)
b)
0.12 mg ranibizumab
0.20 mg ranibizumab
22
eFigure 4. Physiologic vascularization.
Left: Time-to-event analysis for complete vascularization to the ora serrata. Physiologic intraretinal vascularization occurred more effectively in the 0.12 mg group. Note that eyes in which complete vascularization did not occur before the last study visit or before the first rescue or re-injection were censored in this analysis.
Right: Number of patients with complete (top) or at least partial (bottom) vascularization to the ora serrata. In the 0.12 mg group, 50% of patients had complete bilateral vascularization to the ora serrata at week 24. In the 0.2 mg group, complete bilateral vascularization was present in only one patient. Between 67% (0.2 mg group) and 80% (0.12 mg group) of patients showed at least partial bilateral vascularization to the ora serrata (i.e. at least one clock hour of the retina vascularized to the ora serrata).
* patient received bilateral re-treatment
# patient received unilateral rescue treatment
† patient died
23
eFigure 5. Systemic VEGF levels.
Free plasma VEGF levels from all patients in the 0.12 mg group (top) and the 0.2 mg group (bottom). Blood samples were collected before (baseline) and during the first six weeks after ranibizumab injection. Horizontal lines represent mean values. CTAD buffer was used to prevent thrombolysis, resulting in generally low VEGF levels since only free plasma VEGF is measured. The dotted gray line represents the detection level of our assay (15.6 pg/ml). Note that several VEGF levels are below detection limit at baseline (i.e. before ranibizumab injection). Only four infants with measurable VEGF levels at baseline show a transient drop of VEGF levels below detection limit during the course of the study (black and blue in the 0.12 mg group; green and orange in the 0.2 mg group). There is no sustained suppression of mean VEGF levels after ranibizumab injection in either group.
24
eFigure 6. Systolic and diastolic blood pressure measurements for all patients.
Blood pressure measurements were collected at baseline and during the first six weeks following each ranibizumab injection. Note that the x-axis is not continuous and that values for rescue and re-treatment represent only one to two infants (indicated by brackets). Values at day 0, 1 and 3 for one infant receiving rescue treatment in the 0.2 mg group were not reported.
a)
b)
25
eFigure 7. Heart rate, oxygen saturation and respiratory rate for all patients
Measurements were collected at baseline and during the first six weeks following each ranibizumab injection. Note that the x-axis is not continuous and that values for rescue and re-treatment represent only one to two infants (indicated by brackets). Values at day 1 and 3 for one infant receiving rescue treatment in the 0.2 mg group were not reported.
a)
b)
26
eFigure 8. Development of weight, length and head circumference development
Charts for weight, length and head circumference development in both study groups are shown over time. Note that the x-axis is not continuous and that values for re-treatments represent only one to two infants (indicated by brackets).
a)
b)
c)
27
Reference:
1. Food And Drug Administration. Full prescribing information. LUCENTIS (ranibizumab injection) for intravitreal injection [Internet]. 2006 [cited 2017 Sep 3]. Available from: https://www.gene.com/download/pdf/lucentis_prescribing.pdf