For More InformationVisit RAND at www.rand.org

Explore the RAND Corporation

View document details

Support RANDPurchase this document

Browse Reports & Bookstore

Make a charitable contribution

Limited Electronic Distribution RightsThis document and trademark(s) contained herein are protected by law as indicated in a notice appearing later in this work. This electronic representation of RAND intellectual property is provided for non-commercial use only. Unauthorized posting of RAND electronic documents to a non-RAND website is prohibited. RAND electronic documents are protected under copyright law. Permission is required from RAND to reproduce, or reuse in another form, any of our research documents for commercial use. For information on reprint and linking permissions, please see RAND Permissions.

Skip all front matter: Jump to Page 16

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis.

This electronic document was made available from www.rand.org as a public service of the RAND Corporation.

CHILDREN AND FAMILIES

EDUCATION AND THE ARTS

ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENT

HEALTH AND HEALTH CARE

INFRASTRUCTURE AND TRANSPORTATION

INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS

LAW AND BUSINESS

NATIONAL SECURITY

POPULATION AND AGING

PUBLIC SAFETY

SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

TERRORISM AND HOMELAND SECURITY

Report Documentation Page Form ApprovedOMB No. 0704-0188

Public reporting burden for the collection of information is estimated to average 1 hour per response, including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering andmaintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. Send comments regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of information,including suggestions for reducing this burden, to Washington Headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and Reports, 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, ArlingtonVA 22202-4302. Respondents should be aware that notwithstanding any other provision of law, no person shall be subject to a penalty for failing to comply with a collection of information if itdoes not display a currently valid OMB control number.

1. REPORT DATE 2013 2. REPORT TYPE

3. DATES COVERED 00-00-2013 to 00-00-2013

4. TITLE AND SUBTITLE Promoting Online Voices for Countering Violent Extremism

5a. CONTRACT NUMBER

5b. GRANT NUMBER

5c. PROGRAM ELEMENT NUMBER

6. AUTHOR(S) 5d. PROJECT NUMBER

5e. TASK NUMBER

5f. WORK UNIT NUMBER

7. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) RAND Corporation,Homeland Security and Defense Center,1776 MainStreet, P.O. Box 2138,Santa Monica,CA,90407-2138

8. PERFORMING ORGANIZATIONREPORT NUMBER

9. SPONSORING/MONITORING AGENCY NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) 10. SPONSOR/MONITOR’S ACRONYM(S)

11. SPONSOR/MONITOR’S REPORT NUMBER(S)

12. DISTRIBUTION/AVAILABILITY STATEMENT Approved for public release; distribution unlimited

13. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES

14. ABSTRACT

15. SUBJECT TERMS

16. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF: 17. LIMITATION OF ABSTRACT Same as

Report (SAR)

18. NUMBEROF PAGES

18

19a. NAME OFRESPONSIBLE PERSON

a. REPORT unclassified

b. ABSTRACT unclassified

c. THIS PAGE unclassified

Standard Form 298 (Rev. 8-98) Prescribed by ANSI Std Z39-18

This report is part of the RAND Corporation research report series. RAND reports present research findings and objective analysis that address the challenges facing the public and private sectors. All RAND reports undergo rigorous peer review to ensure high standards for research quality and objectivity.

C O R P O R A T I O N

Promoting Online Voices for Countering Violent ExtremismTodd C. Helmus, Erin York, Peter Chalk

Key Findings• AmericanMuslimsareincreasinglyusingtheWeb

andsocialmediatohelpcounterviolentextremism.DiscussionswithanumberofMuslimleadersactiveinsocialmediasuggestthatitispossibletoexpandsucheffortsevenfurther,anddoingsoisamajorobjectiveoftheAugust2011WhiteHousestrategytocounterviolentextremism.

• WhileMuslimAmericansplayanactiveroleincounteringextremism,severalfactorsmayworktounderminehigher-levelengagement,including:lowradicalizationratesamongAmericanMuslims,nega-tiveperceptionsofU.S.counterterrorismpolicies,alimitedreservoirofleadershipcapacityandCVEfunding(whichpreventseffectiveoutreach),andbeingviewedassell-outstothosemostsympathetictojihadicauses.

• Insomecases,theFirstAmendmentmaylimitU.S.governmentattemptstofundCVEprogramsofanideologicalbent,butthisrestrictioncouldultimatelybenefitCVEdiscourseasitfreesMuslimgroupsofthetaintofgovernmentfundingandpreventsthegovern-mentfromhavingto“choosesides”inintra-Muslimdiscourseanddebate.

• BoththeU.S.StateDepartmentandthe“think-dotank”GoogleIdeashaveinitiatedinsightfulprogramsthatseektobuildcapacityandotherwisepromotecredibleMuslimvoices.

• Recommendationsincludedesecuritizingeffortstocounterviolentextremism,addressingsourcesofmistrustwithintheMuslimcommunity,focusingengagementsandCVEeducationonsocialmediainfluencers,buildingleadershipandsocialmediacapacityintheMuslimcommunity,enhancingprivatesectorfundingandengagement,andfindingavenuestoenhancegovernmentfunding.

Al-Qa’idaanditsadherentshavesoughttopromotetheirvisionofmilitantjihadthroughanincreasingpropagandacampaignontheInternet.Theyhaveusedchatroomsandmessageboardstocreateandfoster

communitiesofradicalinterest.1Theyhavepublishedradicale-magazinesandthousandsofextremistYouTubevideos.2SomehavealsoembarkedoncampaignsusingTwitterandFacebook.3ThiscontentincreasinglytargetsWesternaudiences,seekstoarguethattheWestisatwaragainstIslam,offersreligiousandideologicaljustificationsforviolence,andexhortsfollowerstotakeupthecauseandact.

ItistruethatthiscampaignhasproducedanextremelylowyieldofrecruitsintheUnitedStatesandthatvastmajori-tiesofAmericanMuslimsholdnosympathiesforal-Qa’ida’sdistortedvision,buteventherarestsuccesscanhavedisastrousconsequences.4

Individualsjointhejihadistcauseforavarietyofreasons,includingthebeliefthatthejihadistcauserepresentsathrillingcalltoaction,thesocialbondsoffriendsandpeergroupsthatgalvanizethewilltoact,amisinformedviewofscripturaltenets,andadesiretodefendagainstaperceivedwaragainstIslam.Extremistnarra-tivesontheInternetseektoexploitallofthesefactors.5

Consequently,theAugust2011WhiteHousestrategyforcounteringviolentextremism(CVE)hastakenafocusoncoun-teringextremistnarrativesontheInternet.6TheWhiteHouserecognizesthatsomeofthemosteffective,potent,andcrediblemessagesagainstal-Qa’idaandotherMuslimextremistgroupswillrisefromwithintheAmericanMuslimcommunity.Theseindividualshavefargreatercredibilityamongkeyconstituentsandareabletoaddressthornyandcomplexissuesofreligiousideology.TheycanpromotecallsforreligioustoleranceandcounterperceptionsthattheWestisatwarwithIslam.Suchvoicescanalsoundercuttheviewthatmilitantjihadisanexcit-ingandworthwhileendeavorandprovidepositiverolemodelsforconstructivepoliticaldebate.Importantly,withtheboundlessnatureoftheInternet,thesevoicesnotonlyinfluenceAmericansathomebutcanprovideaneffectivecounternarrativeabroad.7

TheWhiteHousestrategyseekstoencourageandempowercredible,authentic,andconstructiveonlineMuslimvoiceswhowillinturnplayaleadingroleinhelpingtocounteral-Qa’ida’s

– 2 –

attemptstorecruithome-grownAmericans.Consequently,thepurposeofthecurrentstudyistounderstandhowtheU.S.govern-ment,aswellascivicinstitutions,canhelppromoteandempowerthiscadreofcredibleMuslimvoicesontheWebandinsocialmedia.AswiththeWhiteHousestrategy,thegoalisthatsuchvoiceswillhelpundercutsupportforterrorism,reducethelikeli-hoodthatyoungAmericanswillheedthecalltoviolentjihad,anddisruptrecruitmenttoviolentmilitantgroups.Weshouldnotethatcrediblevoicesdonotrequirefameorhighesteem,butthosecon-sideringthepathofjihadwillbefarmorelikelytolistentothosesharingsomesemblanceoffaithandtradition.

Wehaveconductedinterviewswith31academicexperts,governmentanalysts,andAmericanMuslimandcivicandreli-giousleaders,includingthosewhohavetakentoblogsandthesocialmediaairwaves.Wehavealsoconductedareviewofrelevantpublishedliterature.Thegoalistounderstandbarriersthatmaylimitthemotivation,effectivereach,andinfluenceofsuchvoices;understandlessonslearnedinpromotingonlinevoicesthatcounterextremism;andidentifyrecommendationsthatwillbepertinenttoboththeU.S.governmentandtheprivateandnonprofitsector.

Key Issues and Challenges in Empowering Constructive Muslim VoicesAmericanMuslimshaveplayedanimportantroleinhelpingtocounterextremismandsupportforal-Qa’ida,andwebeginthissectionwithabriefsurveyoftheirCVEefforts.Tobetterunderstandhowthenumberandreachofthesevoicescanbeincreased,wethenidentifykeybarriersthatmaylimitonlineengagement.Finally,wereviewprominentexamplesofsocialmediacapacity-building.

Existing CVE in the United StatesExistingCVEeffortsintheUnitedStatesincorporateavarietyofapproachesthattakeplacebothinpersonandonline.Thissectionisintendedprimarilytoaddresstheonlineeffortsandthepotentialcapacityofsocialmediaeffortstoexpandthem.How-ever,anoverviewofofflineeffortsprovidesadditionalinsightregardingthespectrumofCVEworkandhelpstoinformtheextentofpossibilitiesforsocialmedia-focusedefforts.

Offline CVE in the United StatesOfflineCVEtypicallyoccursviapersonalinteractionswithlocalimams,conferences,orworkshopsputforthbyfounda-tions,Muslimcommunitygroups,interfaithefforts,and—ofcourse—everydayinteractionswithfamilyandfriends.Onapersonallevel,localimamsprovidedailysupportandcounselingtotheircommunities.Oneimamwespokewithhasanopen-doorpolicyforhiscongregationandhassuccessfullycounseledthreeindividualsawayfromthoughtsofmilitantjihad.Onesuchindividualnowsayshis“jihadistofeedthehomeless.”8

Morebroadly,nationalorganizationssuchastheCouncilonAmerican-IslamicRelations(CAIR)holdyouthconferencesthataddressthe“mythsandrealities”ofradicalizationandpro-

videyoungMuslimswithaforumtoopenlydiscussgrievancesortheirperceivedroleinAmericansociety.9InterfaitheffortsincludeworkdonebytheWorldOrganizationforResourceDevelopmentandEducation(WORDE)Foundation,anorgani-zationaimedatdevelopinganunderstandingbetweenMuslimsandnon-Muslims,tobringyouthfromdifferentfaithstogetherfordialogueandcooperativecommunityvolunteeringandto“humanizeothercommunitiesthathavebeendemonized.”10Forexample,theyrunaprogramcalled“YouthAgainstHunger”thatbringsyoungpeopletogetherfromdifferentfaithstomakesand-wichesanddistributethemtohomelessshelters.TheyalsohostpancakebreakfastswithChristianpastorsandMuslimleaderstotalkaboutwhatitmeanstobreakbreadtogether.11

Similarinitiativesarelocalizedinothercommunities:WithintheBostonarea,theGreaterBostonInterfaithOrga-nizationbringstogethermembersoftheMuslim,Jewish,andChristiancommunities.12Forexample,bridgingthegapbetweenthevirtualandthetangibleareawarenesstrainingsonInternetsafetyforMuslimcommunities.Organizationspartnerwithlocalmosquestohostworkshopsdirectedprimarilyatparents,designedtocoverthe“spectrumofdangers”ontheInternetthatincludesnotonlyradicalextremismbutalsopornographyandcyberbullying.13Theseeventsarebeneficialforgettingthebroadercommunityinterestedinwhatisviewedasanexception-allylow-probabilityissue.

Online CountermessagingThemostdirectformofonlineCVEisbasedoncounteringthemessagingofextremistgroups,typicallyviaonlinehateforums,socialmedianetworks,orindependentwebsites.14Sucheffortsarechieflyintendedforpartiallyradicalized“fence-sitters”—thosewhoaresympathetictotheextremistnarrativeandsomewhatengagedintheonlineradicalcommunity,butnotyetmotivatedtoactintheirownviolentjihad.Tobeactiveinthiskindofcountermessaging,anindividualrequirestheologicalexpertiseandskillsinpersuasivearguments:Thegoalisto“usethepowerofscripture”todelegitimizetheradicalnarrative.15

OnesmallandanonymousMuslimorganizationcreatesonlineprofilestoengageinextremist-orientedchatroomsandprovidemorepositivecounternarratives.Theyalsooperateunat-tributedTwitteraccountsthatcriticizeextremistarguments.16Thesuccessoftheseeffortsismeasuredbytheamountofatten-tiontheyreceivefromthecommunitybeingtargeted;agoodaccountmayevenbe“followed”onTwitterbyknownradicals.

Othersocialmedia–basedmessagingutilizesvideocontenttodiscredittheextremistnarrative.TheMuslimPublicAffairsCouncil(MPAC),forexample,producesoriginalvideocontentthatisthendistributedviaYouTube.Thise-dawah,oronlineout-reach,includesaseriesofprograms,including“InjusticeCannotDefeatInjustice,”ashortvideoshowingseveralpopularAmeri-canimamscondemningviolenceinthenameofIslam.17

Finally,somegroupsandindividualshaveestablishedwebsitesthatdirectlyconfrontargumentsformilitantjihad.Oneexampleis

– 3 –

asitecalled“TheJWord”runbyconservativeclericYasirQadhi.18Anotherwebsite,“FatwaonTerrorism,”isanonlineplatformforthedistributionofafatwacondemningterrorismwrittenbyaPakistaniimam.19Thewebsiteofferstranslationsofthetextandpublicizesrelevantarticlesandevents.Thesewebsitesareone-waydistributorsofcontentandoffernoopportunityforinteraction;usersmayviewordownloadinformationbutcannotrespondtoit.

Online Resources for the American MuslimAlessdirectkindofonlineCVEoccursviaanumberofpopu-larMuslimwebsitescateringmorebroadlytothemainstreamMuslimpopulation.

Thesewebsites,whichinclude“virtualmosques”suchasSuhaibwebb.comaswellasblogssuchastheMuslimChannelonPatheos.com,arenotfocusedonissuesofcounterradicalization;rather,contentrelatedtoCVEisintegratedintoabodyofmaterialaddressingrelevantissuesforMuslimsinAmerica.ThisculturalrelevanceallowssuchwebsitestovastlyoutstripmoredirectCVEeffortsinpopularity:WhiletheaforementionedMPACvideohasupwardof30,000hitsonYouTube,20Suhaibwebb.compullsinapproximately70,000hitsdaily.21AnotherpopularsiteisMus-limmatters.org,runbySalaficlericYasirQadhi,whichpublishesdailyarticlescoveringtopicsrangingfromthepoliticaltothequotidian.22Thesitehasbeeneffectiveinemployingsocialmediatoincreaseexposure;postsarepublicizedviaaFacebookpagethathasmorethan50,000“likes”andanactivebodyofcommenters.

Whilethemajorityofcontentonthesesitesdoesnotdirectlyaddressissuesofjihad,somearticlesdealwithrelevantCVEtopicssuchasInternetsafetyorjihadoftheself( jihad al-nafs).23Furthermore,followingtheMuslimprotestselicitedbytheanti-Muslimfilm“InnocenceofMuslims”inSeptember2012,Muslimmatters.orgwasveryactiveinFacebookpostscallingfortoleranceandforbearance.Postedmessagesincludedanarticleentitled“5ExamplesofSupremeMuslimTolerance,”amessagepublicizingthepeacefulMuslimprotestsinCasablanca,andvari-ousscripturalmessagesurgingrestraint.24

Othersites,suchaseShaykh.com,offeramoreinteractiveuserexperiencethataddressesthesameissuesoffaithindailylife.Thesite,aninitiativeoftheIslamicSupremeCouncilofAmerica,offersuserstheopportunitytosubmitquestionsoffaithtoagroupofIslamicscholarsforconsiderationandresponse.Amongthethousandsofquestionsonthesitearequeriesrelatedtodoctrine,technologyandIslam,andassociationwithpeopleofotherfaiths.

Inadditiontooperatingwebsites,individualimamshavealsoemployedsocialmediatodevelopbroadnetworksoffollow-ers,enablingthemtoengagewithalargecommunitybeyondtheirowngeographicalsphere.These“rockstar”imamspossessbothgenerationalawarenessandreligiouscredibilitythatallowthemtoamassthousandsoffollowersonsocialnetworkingsites.25SheikhHamzaYusuf,afounderofZaytunaCollegeinCalifornia,isonesuchleader:HisTwitteraccounthasmorethan28,000followers,andhisactiveFacebookpagehasmorethan70,000“likes.”26

Muchlikeimamsoffline,thevirtuallyconnectedimamsneedtoactas“personalcounselors”aswellasspiritualadvisorswhenfollowersreachouttothemdirectlyviasocialmedia.Thepopularityoftheseindividualscomesinpartbecauseoftheirabilitytoconnectwiththeyoungeraudienceandaddress“whatitmeanstobeaMusliminAmerica.”27BymakingthemselvesavailabletothebroadpopulationofInternetusers,theyprovideyouthwitharesourcetoobtainrelevantanswerstotheissuesthataffectthemintheirdailylives.

Challenges Confronting Online CVE ActivismBasedonconversationswithMuslimsocialmediaexpertsandCVEstakeholders,itappearsthatseveralbarrierslimitthelevelofMuslimCVEengagementonline—andtheylikelyalsoapplytoofflineCVEefforts.

Perceptions that Radicalization Is Not a ProblemSomebelievethatviolentradicalizationisnotaproblemsignifi-cantenoughtoaddress.AccordingtoaPewResearchCentersur-vey,64percentofAmericanMuslimssaidsupportforextremismamongMuslimsintheUnitedStatesisverylow.28Thisisunder-standableonseverallevels.First,asRANDscholarBrianJenkinshasdemonstrated,the192MuslimsintheUnitedStatesarrestedonterrorismchargesbetweenSept.11,2001,andtheendof2011representonlyatinyfractionofanestimated3millionAmericanMuslims.29Furthermore,manyindividualswhoradicalizedosoapartfromactiveMuslimcommunitiesandcongregations.30AsMuslimplaywrightandsocialmediaactivistWajahatAlinotes,“Themajority[ofMuslimAmericans]donothangoutwiththeseviolentextremists....IfyouaskmostAmericanMuslimswhatyouaredoingtostopextremism,theywillsaytheydon’tknowthisguy.”31AnotherinterlocutorwhoseekstopromoteMuslimengagementinCVEissueslikewisenotedthatbecausethethreatseemssosmall,“it’shardtoconvincepeoplethatthisshouldbeaprioritywithincommunities.”32

Alienation and Lack of TrustTheU.S.approachtocounterterrorismisafrequentlycitedcom-plaintinMuslimcommunities.ManyopposetheU.S.interven-tioninAfghanistanandwereopposedtotheU.S.presenceinIraq.Domestically,morethanhalfofAmericanMuslimsreportthatgovernmentantiterrorismpoliciessingleoutAmericanMus-limswithincreasedsurveillanceandmonitoring.33Specialareasofconcernaretheuseofinformantsandstingoperations,whichsomefearhelpfacilitatetheradicalizationofthosetheyintendtotarget.34Forexample,in2010,theFederalBureauofInvestiga-tion(FBI)infiltratedtheIslamicCenterofIrvine,California.35Inanefforttouncoversympathiesforal-Qa’ida,theinformanttalkedupviolentjihadsomuchthatcongregantsgrewfrightenedandobtainedarestrainingorderagainsthim.MuchcontroversyandnegativemediacoveragehavebeengeneratedoutoftheNewYorkPoliceDepartment(NYPD)’screationofanintelligencedivisionthatmonitoredpopularcafes,Muslimcollegestu-

– 4 –

dents,andevenkeyMuslimpartnersinthecity’sCVEefforts.36AlthoughtheNYPD’sactionshavebeendefendedaslegalandprudent,thecontroversyhasbeencitedbysomeintheMuslimcommunityasamajorconcern.37

Perceptionsofagrowinglevelofanti-MuslimrhetoricinmainstreamAmericansocietyisalsoanissue.APewForumonReligionandPublicLifereportssurveyresultssuggestingthatnearly40percentofAmeri-cansholdanunfavorableviewofIslam.38Thesenega-tiveviewshaveappearedtomanifestthemselvesinvary-ingwaysandhavebeencon-veyedbyanincreasingarrayofrancorousvoices.39Therewerebroadandpublicpro-teststothedevelopmentofaMuslimcommunitycenteradjacenttoGroundZeroinNewYorkCity.Threestateshavealreadypassedlegisla-tionbanningSharialaw,andsuchlegislationisundercon-siderationin21otherstates.Therewasalsothestrangefurorassociatedwiththerealityshow“AllAmericanMuslim”onTheLearningChannel,whichdepictedtheordinarylivesoffiveMuslimAmericanfamilies.Follow-inganonlinecampaigninwhichtheFloridaFamilyAssociationchargedthattheshowwaspropagandaforMuslims,numerouscorporatesponsors,includingKayakandLowes,pulledadvertis-ingthatinturnledtotheshow’scancellation.40

TheremayalsobeaperceptionthatbothmediaandthegovernmentunfairlyfocusontherisksposedbyMuslimterror-ismwhilegivinglesscredencetothreatsposedbyotherU.S.-basedextremistgroups,includingright-wingextremistssuchaswhitesupremacygroups,skinheads,andantigovernmentmilitias.AccordingtoaninterimreportbytheNationalConsortiumfortheStudyofTerrorism,right-wingextremistskilled168indi-vidualsin144lethalattacksbetween1990and2010,excludingtheOklahomaCitybombing.41Thiscontrastswith23individu-alskilledinlessthan25Muslim-perpetratedattacks,excludingthe2,977killedonSeptember11,2001.42Further,thenumberofright-winghategroupshasrisenby69percentsince2000andnowtotals1,018.43Despitethesethreats,mediaattentiononthisissueseemsscant.Further,HouseHomelandSecurityCommit-teehearingsondomesticterroristthreatsfocusalmostsolelyonMuslimradicalization.

SeveralcommentatorshavearguedthattheseissuesriskalienatingMuslimAmericansandcouldlimittheircoopera-

tionwithlawenforcement.44Iftrue,theywouldalsounderminecommunitywillingnesstospeakoutmoreactivelyagainstviolentextremism.Regardless,anti-MuslimattitudesandlegislationhavebecomeafocalpointofAmericanMuslimcivicactivityandhavedivertedattentionawayfromcounterradicalizationissues.

Somesaythatcounterradicalizationactivitiesmayexposethemtogreaterattentionfromlawenforcement.Forexample,

ImamAbdullahAntepliofDukeUniversityseesvalueinhavinglegitimateMuslimscholarssuchashimselfenteringextremistchat-roomstoprovideanalternativemessage,buthefearshewouldbemarkedbytheFBIforsuspiciousactivity.45Anotheractivistagrees,sayingthat“peopleareveryhesitanttoengageinthisbecausetheyknowtheywillbewatched”bytheFBI.46Ithasalsobeensuggestedthatsev-eralprominentscholar-runwebsitesrefusetopublishtheirresponsestoquestionsaboutthelegitimacyofjihadoutoffearthattheywouldgetblacklistedbythegovernment.47

Theissueoftrustandalien-ationmayimpedethemotivationofotherMuslimswhomightaddressradicalizationmoreforce-fullyonsocialmedia.Foranyissuetobeworthyofsomeone’ssoapbox,itmustbesomethingthatelicits

excitementandzeal,acauseworthfightingfor.Whereoneperceivesthethreattobeexaggeratedorfeelsunderminedbythestateandbroadersociety,thatzealiseasilylost.WajahatAlireportsthatmistrustofthegovernmenthasa“chillingeffect”andcreatesatrustdeficitwithAmericanMuslimcommuni-ties.Heassertsthat,“Thisisaffectinghowwecaneffectivelycounterviolentextremismatlocallevelsandusingsocialmedia.Thatiswhereweareatrightnow.Thatisanunderlyingproblemthatneedstobeaddressed.”48ImamAbdullahAntepliagrees:“Thereisageneralsenseofintimidation.[Muslims]don’tfeelencouragedbytheU.S.tocombatIslamicextremismorthepervertedversionof‘jihad’.”49

Poor Leadership CapacityMostMuslimcommunityreligiousinstitutionssuchasmosqueslackboththetimeandcapacityforsocialmediaoutreach.MosquesintheUnitedStatesfrequentlylackimamsandapaidstaff,andmanythatdohaveimamshirethemfromoverseas.50TheseimamsattimeshavelimitedcommandofEnglish,arefrequentlyslowtoconnectwithyoungparishioners,anddonotimmediatelyunderstandandusesophisticatedsocialmediatools.51AsRabiaChaudry,presidentoftheSafeNationCollab-

“Newmediaisthelanguageofanewgeneration...andtechnologyischanginghowwe

interact,shareinformationandsharenews.IcanputupaYouTubepostthatgoesglobalandafriendinIndonesiacanlikeitandputitonhisblog....Ialwaysthoughtnewmediaisatoolandatoolcanbeben-eficialorworsedependingwhousesit.Ourenemies,violentextremists,arespeakingthislanguagetopropa-gatetheirmessagebutalsoforrecruitment.Al-Qa’idahascreatedthousandsofYouTubevideosthatarewellproduced.We’veseenBinLadeninhiscaveandhevideorecordsamessage,postsitanditgoesglobal.Thewaytheyhaverecruitedtheloneradicalisprimarilyusingnewmedia,chatgroups,emailmessages,boardsandsuch.Sothequestionis,howdoweuseitforgood?Thisisthemillion-dollarquestion.” —Wajahat Ali

Muslim playwright, activist

– 5 –

orative,noted,“Forwebpresenceyouneedpeopleon[mosque]boardswhoknowthatthatisimportant.Itellthem,‘youcanuseFacebookforfundraising,’buttheydon’tlikeit.”52

TheselimitationsalsoapplytoMuslimcivilsocietyleader-ship.BrieLoskotaandNadiaRoumaniarguethatthereisa“dearthofcivilsocietyandpublicleaderswhoarebothrootedintheirIslamicfaithandabletoaddressissuesofrelevancetotheirowncommunitiesandthebroaderpublic.”Manyofthosethatdoexistare“burningout”duetohighworkloadsandalackofresources.53ThesameissaidofMuslimchaplainswhoserveonaburgeoningnumberofcollegecampuses.54Theseindividualsareenormouslyinfluential;theyaretrainedandcredibleIslamicscholars,directlyserveyoungcadresofMuslims,promoteapositivevisionofIslamtothebroaderstudentbody,anddirectlybenefitfromavibrantandmulticulturalcommunity.55However,asMuslimscholarHaroonMoghulnotes:

Mostofthesemenandwomenaresooverworkedanddirectingtimeandattentiontostudentsthattheydon’thaveTwitteraccounts,can’tputsermonsonlineandtheycan’tlinkupwithplatformstomediainmosteffectivewaypossible.Thatisnotwhattheyaretrainedtodo.56

Limited Funding for Muslim CVE ProgramsThechallengeoffundingimpedescounterradicalizationactivi-ties.MPAChassoughttoholdanimamsummittodiscussCVEissuesandotherthings,butalackofmoneyisamajorbar-rier.57Likewise,WORDEFoundationhasappliedforfundingtotrainMuslimleadersinsocialmediapractices—butuntilitcomes,theirlevelofoutreachislimited.58FundingalsoremainsthecorelimitationfortheMuslim-runorganizationthatrunscounterextremistTwitteraccountsandpromotescounternarra-tivesinextremistchatrooms.Fundingisespeciallyimportantforthisorganizationasitssuccessdemands“consistency”ofengagement.59

TheU.S.governmentmightbeoneresourceforfundingcommunityandonlineCVEefforts,butFirstAmendmentrestrictionsonlawsrespectinganestablishmentofreligionposealimitingfactor.SomeCVEbattlescenterontheappro-priatebeliefsofIslamtoincludethemeaningofjihadandtheresponsibilitiesofMuslimslivinginanon-Muslimstate.Theseandmanyothersaretheologicalmatterswherethestateislargelyrestrictedfromdirectlytakingsides.However,thisismuchmoreofablessingthanacurse:NearlyeveryindividualinterviewedforthisstudyarguedthatgovernmentsponsorshipofMuslimvoicescouldunderminelegitimacy.Asonescholarputit,“Atthispointintime,theAmericangovernmentissimplyviewedasthekissofdeath.IftheAmericangovernmentgetsinvolved,thentheconstituencyyouwanttoreach,theywillnever,everlistentothatpersonagain.”60 ThisisoneofthekeylessonslearnedfromthePreventprograminBritain.Fol-lowingtheJuly7,2005,attacksinLondon,theBritishgovern-

mentsoughttodirectlyfundcounterextremistvoices,includ-ingQuilliam,athink-dotankrunbyprominentex-Islamists.Unfortunately,governmentsponsorshipultimatelyunderminedtheorganization’scredibilityamongtheaudiencestheyweretryingtoreach.61AsterrorismscholarPeterNeumannnotes,“Thankstotheestablishmentclause,Americanofficialswillneverfindthemselvesinapositionwheretheyhaveto‘pickwinners’or‘adjudicateinintrareligiousaffairs’.”62

Privatefoundationsareobviouslynotsoconstrainedasthegovernment.Wealthydonors,establishedfoundations,andcommunitydonationshavebeenakeyresourceforavarietyofcommunityandwebCVEinitiatives.Otherorganizations,includingadvertisingandtechnologyfirmssuchasGoogle,havelentexpertisetotrainingandcapacity-building.Butreservationsremainasfarasmoreactivelyfundingsuchinitiatives.SomeMuslimfoundationsarereluctanttowadeintotheCVEarenaforfearthattheremightbeabacklashamongkeyconstituents.63Secularinstitutionsarealsohesitant.LeadershipintheDepart-mentofHomelandSecurityreportedlymetwiththeheadsoftwoleadingfoundationsanddirectlyaskediftheywouldbewillingtofundprogramsandactivitiesthatcounteredextremism.Theresponsewasanoutrightno,withthestatedreasoningthattheydonotwadeintomattersofideology.64

Credibility, Stigma, and the Oversecuritized Approach to CVEAnotherissuetoconsideristhatofcredibilityandthefrequentlysecuritizedapproachthegovernmenttakestoengagementwiththeMuslimcommunity.AnumberofcommentatorshavenotedthatwhenthegovernmentreachesouttotheMuslimcommu-nity,itoftendoessosolelytoaddressthethreatofterrorism.This,inturn,leavestheimpressionthatthegovernment’sonlyconcernisthatMuslimsmaybecomeviolent.65Likewise,itseemsthatsomeoftheseconcernstranslatetoMuslim-initiatedCVEefforts.

Asnoted,therearegenuineconcernsthatmanyMuslimsdonotseeradicalizationasasufficientlyprominentproblem.AsmallnumberofMuslimscontactedforthisstudydemurred,seeminglybecauseofresentmentthattheywereentreatedtoaddressaproblemthatonlyfurtherstheextremiststereotype.Otherswhodidspeakwithusechoedthisconcern.Oneinter-locutorobservedthat“Muslimsarenotjustaproblemthatneedstobefixed.”66Anothernoted,“Ifyouframe[CVEissues]inasecuritizedway,youenduppushingpeopleaway;youstigmatizetheverycommunityyouaretryingtoreachoutandhelp.”67Also,individualswhotaketosocialmediaseektoaddressissuesthatconcernthemandtheiraudience.Asalocalimampointsout,mostyoungMuslimstodayarelessconcernedwithmilitantjihadandmorefocusedonobtaining“studentloansandgettingmar-ried”and“understandingandtryingtotranslatemodernityinthebackdropofmaintainingspirituality.”68

Thecredibilityofthemessengerandmessagecanalsobeatrisk.ThereisatleastaminorityofMuslimswhomayviewan

– 6 –

excessivefocusonCVEassellingouttogovernmentinfluence.Itwasnotedthatnationalizedorganizationstakingastrongstanceonradicalization,aswellasotherardentcounterextremistvoices,arequicklyseenasselloutsandlosecredibilityamidthosemostsympathetictojihadicauses.69OnepragmaticfactorhereisareluctanceofsometoactivelyseekoutCVE-brandedcontent.MainstreamMuslimsmoreconcernedwithlivingdailyliveswillnotperceiveCVEissuesassomethingthatconcernsthem.Otherindividualswhobecomemoresympathetictojihadicausesareunlikelytoseekoutcontentthatprovidesaforegoneconclusion.

Manyofthosewespokewithtalkedof“reframing”theissue.AlejandroBeutal,aformergovernmentanalystatMPAC,arguesthat“framingiskey.”Whenamosqueandsynagogueconductaninterfaithevent,itshouldnotbeframedasacounterradicalizationissue,itshouldsimplyfocusonbuild-inginterfaithrelationshipsbecausethatis“therightthingtodo.”70SomeofthemosteffectivevoicesaddressingradicalismtodaydosobymakingCVEonlyasmallpartoftheirmission,orbyaddressingCVEonlyindirectly.MuslimMatters.organdSuhaibwebb.comareblogsthatspeaktoavarietyofcontempo-raryissuesfacedbyMuslimstodayandsohavecultivatedlargeandfaithfulfollowers.Theyprovidearticlesandothercontentaddressingtheissueofradicalizationonlyonoccasion.Themessagegetsoutandleveragesthebroad-basedcredibilityoftheblogwithoutmakingCVEtheprimaryissueorstigmatiz-ingtheaudience.TheapproachofnothavingallCVE,allthetimealsohelpsmaintaintherelevanceoftheblogandthuskeepsreadersreturning.

AnotheralternativeistopromoteabroadarrayofMuslimvoicesthat,whiletheymightnotaddressCVEissuesdirectly,canhaveaprofoundandpositiveeffectonreligiousdiscoursewithinandbeyondthecommunity.MuslimscholarMoghulpointsoutthatsuchvoicescanachieveseveralimportanteffects.71First,thereisvalueinpromotingvoicesthatcanserveasMuslimconduitstomainstreammedia.Thosewhocreatea“brandandidentity”onthewebcancircumventthetraditionalwayofbecominganexpertandcanpositivelyrepresentIslamtosociety.ThesevoicescanalsoserveasrolemodelsforMuslimyouthwhoarereluctanttoreachouttoimamsorparents.AsMoghulsays,“Iwouldratherfeeltheyshouldtalktome,ratherthanachat-room.Socialmediaiskeybecauseyoucanamplifyintelligentvoicessotherecanbesomeoneyoungfolkscanturnto.”72

Socialmediacanalsopromotemainstreamreligiousteach-ings.WhenMoghulledtheMuslimStudentAssociationatNewYorkUniversity,heandhisfellowstudentsmadeapointofplacingsermonsontheInternetandquicklyfoundthattheaudiencegreatlyexpandedbeyondtheconfinesoftheuniversity,with10,000to15,000downloadsmonthly.ThesermonsreachedMuslimsinIndiaandRussia,andIslamicschoolsinthePersianGulfstates.AsMoghulstates,socialmedia“putsvoicesoutthereandbuildsthiskindoffollowingandthathascredibility.Whenyoubuildcapacityandhelppeoplethinkstrategically,theywill

answerquestionsintheCVEworldwithoutmakingthosethecentralquestion.”73

Inaddition,socialmediacanhelpfillthevoidofcommunityinyoungMuslims’lives.Withmanymosquesrunbyforeign-bornandoldermembership(affectionatelyreferredtoasthe“uncles”and“aunties”),arisinggenerationgapexistswithyoungAmericanmembersfeelingdisconnectedandalienated.Partici-pationinanactiveandhealthyfaithcommunityhasbeensaidtohelpprotectindividualsfromtherisksofradicalization.74Aspreviouslynoted,somerisingstars,suchasImamSuhaibWebbandSheikhHamzaYusuf,arefillingthisgapwitheffectiveweboutreach.Othersareturningtoonlineprayergroupsandsocialmediacommunitiesofinterest.75

Finally,socialmediacanprovideanalternativeoutletforthoseinthecommunitytoexpresstheirconcernsandgrievances.MoghulprovidestheexampleofBosniaduringthe1990s,wherethousandsofMuslimswerekilledordisplacedinacampaignofethniccleansing.Muslimsworldwideweretraumatizedbytheeventsandsearchedforwaystorespond.Some,seekingtheonlyrecoursetheyknew,wenttoBosniatofight.ThishasalsobeenanunfortunateoutletformanyangryabouttheU.S.warsinIraqandAfghanistan.ForthisandavarietyofotherissuesimportanttosomeMuslims,thewebcanamplifyvoicesofprotestandgalvanizeamorehealthyresponse.

Case Studies of Capacity BuildingBoththeU.S.StateDepartmentandthe“think-dotank”GoogleIdeashaveinitiatedinsightfulprogramsthatseektobuildcapac-ityandotherwisepromotecredibleMuslimvoices.Theyoffervaluablelessonspertinenttoourrecommendations.

U.S. State Department Capacity Building Program TheU.S.StateDepartmenthasrecentlyworkedwithsocialmediaexperts,includingplaywrightAli,toprovidesocialmediatrainingtokeyMusliminfluencersabroad.TrainingsessionsthatranapproximatelytwoandahalfdayswereheldinPakistan,thePhilippines,Singapore,Malaysia,andJakarta.Individu-alswereintroducedtosocialmediatoolssuchasFacebook,Twitter,LinkedIn,andmore,withaspecialemphasisonusingthesetoolstoconquerhateandextremismandtobuildbridgesbetweencommunities.Individualsweretaughtthebasicsofhowtosuccessfullygetamessageout,theartofstorytelling,andthecreationofviralmessages.Basedonparticipants’enthusiasticreception,theprogramwasjudgedasuccess.Insummarizingtheoverallgoaloftheprogram,Alinoted:

Theideaistoempowertheseleadersandchangeagentsandgivethemtheskillsandresourcesandcapacitytoengageinproactiveworkthathelpstheircommunities.AndtheU.S.interestinthisistoensureahealthiernarrativeemergesthatisproactiveandnonreactive;onethatpromotespositivesocialchangeandattractsteen-

– 7 –

agers,andinsteadofthemgoingtoal-Qa’idatheywillgotothesepeopleinstead.Thatisthelong-termgoal.76

Google Ideas’ Counterradicalization InitiativeGoogleIdeaswasfoundedin2010andhasthegoalofusingtechnologytohelpaddresscomplexandintractableproblems.Initsfirstproject,GoogleIdeassoughttotackletheissueofradical-izationbycreatinganetworkofrenouncedreligiousextremists,gangmembersandneo-Nazis(referredtoasFormers),andsur-vivorsofattacks(i.e.,Survivors),nongovernmentalorganizationsandbusinesspartners.

Inexploringwaystodeveloptheircounternarrative,GoogleIdeasfirstthoughtitmightmakesensetoputtogetheracam-paignthatincorporatedeverythingfrombillboardstobrandedwristbands.ButthisideametstiffresistancefromfocusgroupsofFormersandSurvivors.AccordingtoYasminDolatabadi,prin-cipalatGoogleIdeas,“Theseguysareallactivistsalready—theyhavetheirownbrandandoperationandtheyarenotlookingforanumbrellabrand.Fromthatmomenton,theorganizersknewthattheywerebestsuitedtoplaytheroleofenabler”ratherthanimposingsomethingfromGoogle.77

GoogleIdeashasplayedthisroleofenablerthroughanumberofinitiativesthatseektoconnectFormersandSurvivorswithkeypartners.TogetherwiththeCouncilonForeignRelationsandtheTribecaFilmFestival,GoogleIdeashosteda2011conferencecalledtheSummitAgainstViolentExtremism(SAVE).HeldinDublin,Ireland,theeventconvenedavariedconsortiumofformergangmembers,neo-Nazis,andreligiousextremistsaswellasnon-governmentalorganizationworkersandattackvictims.78Thecon-ferencehelpedidentifythecommonthreadsoftheformerextrem-istexperienceandhelpedconnecttheseactivistswithpotentialfunders.Theycommissionedresearchthatultimatelyhighlightedhowrolemodelsandpositivepersonalrelationshipscankeepindividualsfromenteringextremistgroupsandcanfacilitatetheirdeparture.79TheyalsoworkedwiththeLondon-basedInstituteforStrategicDialoguetodevelopawebplatformwhereFormersandSurvivorscanconnectwithotherindividualsandhelpthemavoidthepitfallsofextremismorexitfromradicalgroups.Thewebsite,builtwiththeprobonohelpofRehabstudio,alsoallowsFormersandSurvivorstocraftsocialnetworkswithoneanotherandsolicitprojectfundingfrompotentialsponsors.80

GoogleIdeas’effortstoplaytheroleofconvenerandenablerhaveproducedseveralotherkeypartnerships.TheTribecaFilmInstitutehelpedcosponsortheDublineventandinFebruary2012itlaunchedTribecaTeachesLosAngeles,anafter-schooldigitalstorytellingprograminagang-infestedsuburbofLosAngeles.The18-weekprogramtrainsmiddle-schoolstudentsintheartoffilmmakingandseekstohelptheseyoungpeopletelltheirownpersonalstoryandtobecriticalconsumersofmedia.81Inaddition,thefirmeBoostpitchedinbycreatingawebsitethatoffersclearandbasicadviceonthefundamentalsofcraftingastrategy,developingandsustaininganonprofit,usingsocialmediaforoutreach,andmeasuringprogramsuccesswithGoogle

Analytics.82TherearealsoeffortstoenlistprivatesectorsocialmediafirmstohelpincreasethesocialmediacapacityoftheAgainstViolentExtremismnetwork.Forexample,BuzzMouthdonated$100,000worthofprobonoservicesintheformofsocialmediaconsulting.83

RecommendationsThefollowingrecommendationsaredesignedtoincreasethenumber,reach,andeffectivenessofconstructiveMuslimvoicesontheInternetandsocialmedia.

Appreciate that CVE Takes Many FormsEffortsthatachievetheobjectivesofCVEstakeholderscancomeinallshapesandsizes.SomeapproachCVEheadon,includingthosethatdirectlycountermilitantideology,undermine“jihadicool,”andemphasizethenegativeimpactofciviliancasualties.Butindirectmethodsalsohavevalue,suchasprogramsthatfos-terinterfaithrelationshipsorhelpyoungMuslimsbridgethegapbetweenfaithandasecularsociety.

ThereisalsobenefitinsocialmediathatpromotesawideassortmentofmainstreamMuslimvoices,evenifsuchvoicesnevermakeCVEacentralmission.Sermonsandotherreligiouscommentarypostedonlinecanhelpcreateauthenticvoicesthatareechoedinthemainstreammedia,creatingnewrolemodelsthathelpyouthmakemeaningfulconnectionswiththeirfaithandpromotingmainstreamreligiousteachingsthatprovideasubtlecounterweighttojihadinarrativesbyfosteringapositiveandnormativevisionofIslam.Socialmediamayalsohelpindi-vidualschannelgrievancesintomeaningfulpoliticalactionandcanhelpalienatedyouthconnectwithhealthyonlinecommuni-tiesandprayergroups.Theoptionsandpotentialbenefitsaremany,butthekeyisthateffortsplacinglessemphasisCVEandsecurityaspectswillgainbettertractionandresonanceamongmanyimportantaudiencemembersandpromoteparticipationfromabroadercadreofinfluencers.

Address Sources of Mistrust in the Muslim CommunityAspreviouslynoted,thereexistsalevelofmistrustbetweenpoten-tiallykeyvoicesandtheirgovernmentandbroadersociety,basedonconcernsaboutU.S.foreignpolicy,domesticcounterterrorismpoliciesthatintheviewofmanystakeholdersunfairlytargettheMuslimcommunity,andavocalnumberofAmericanswhoseanti-MuslimprotestationsalienatemanyAmericanMuslims.

TheU.S.governmentshouldseektoaddressthesepolicyconcernsasopportunitiesarise.U.S.approachesinthisregardwerenotfullyexploredforthisreportandnumerousotherauthorspro-videfocusonthistopic.84Still,variousdepartmentsandagenciesofthefederalgovernment,suchastheDepartmentofHomelandSecurity(DHS),theJusticeDepartment,FBI,andNationalCoun-terterrorismCenter(NCTC),haveengagementprogramsthatseektobuildrelationshipswithMuslimcommunitiesandallowindividualstheopportunitytoairgrievances.85Clearly,itwillbeimportanttocontinueandexpandthiseffortasitmaybevitalto

– 8 –

enhancingthereservoirofactiveandcredibleMuslimvoices.Bothtoneandempathyarekeyinsuchefforts.BoilerplateresponsestoMuslimconcernsarenotinorderandofficialsatalllevelsshouldconveythattheyunderstandandappreciateMuslimconcernsandareatleastfactoringthemintopolicydecisions.Officialsshouldalsoacknowledgemistakeswhentheyaremade.86Informantswillcontinuetoplayanimportantroleinidentifyinganddisrupt-ingfutureterroristthreats,buttheUnitedStatesshouldcarefullyweightheiruse,applythemsparinglyandensurethattheiractionsdonotunnecessarilyantagonizeorevenradicalizepotentialtar-gets.87AsnotedbyDavidSchanzerandcolleagues,thegovernmentshoulddevelopclearpoliciesforwheninformantscanbeusedandshouldcommunicatetheseopenlytocommunityleaders.88

Relatedtothis,U.S.governmentagenciescouldalsodirectlyusesocialmediaasameanstopublicizeoutreach.Whilesomeeventsshouldremainprivateandunpublicized,audienceandimpactcanbegreatlyexpandedthroughvideotapedengagementsplacedonYouTube,liveTwitterfeeds,orblogs.Sucheventsshouldobviouslynotbecontrived.FishmanandLebovichargueforcreat-inga“safespace”forintra-MuslimdiscourseondifficultpoliticalquestionssuchasthepresenceofU.S.troopsinIraqandAfghani-stan.MuslimAmericansshouldnotfeelconstrainedinspeakingoutontheseissuesfor“fearofbeinglabeledterroristsympathiz-ers.”89Byallowingandpublicizinganactiveandhonestnationaldiscourse,U.S.governmentagencyrepresentativescancommuni-cateawillingnesstolistenandpromotehealthypoliticaldiscourseamongakeyMuslimconstituency.

ItisclearthatU.S.leadersfromacrossthepoliticalspectrummustactivelyworktocounterthegrowingrancorinthepublicdiscourseonIslam.PresidentBarackObamahaspubliclycalledforinterfaithengagementandtoleranceandhasbeenclearthatthenationisnotengagedinawaragainstIslam.90Thissentimentshouldbeloudlyechoedbyleadershipfromacrossthepoliticallandscape.Inaddition,leadersfromallpartiesshouldspeakoutimmediatelyandforcefullyagainstanystatementsfromtheirmembersorconstituentsthatmayappearbigotedorthatservetopromotefalsestereotypes.IfAmericansocietyexpectsMuslimstotakeastandagainstextremism,itisincumbentuponpoliticalandcivicleaderstospeakoutpubliclyagainstIslamophobia.Programsthatenableinterfaithengagementareparticularlyimportant.TypicallyseenasanantidotetoIslamicextremism,theyalsohelpcounteranti-Muslimintoleranceamongotherreligiousgroups.91

Finally,whiletheU.S.needstoaddresstherisksofMuslimextremism,itisimportanttoproperlybalancethisneedwitheffortstoaddressotherdomesticthreatssuchasright-wingextrem-ism.FailuretodosoonlycastsunduesuspiciononMuslimgroupsandlimitsopportunitiestodetectandthwartright-wingattacks.

Enhance Education on the Threats and Risks Posed by ExtremistsTheU.S.shouldcarefullyuseitscommunityengagementstoeducateAmericanMuslimsabouttheeffortsofal-Qa’idaandotherextremistgroupstorecruitandradicalizeU.S.citizens—doingso

inawaythatdoesnotoverstatetheriskorsuggestMuslimsareathreatinandofthemselves.OnesuchtoolistheCommunityAwarenessBriefingdevelopedbyNCTCanddesignedtohelpinformthepublicaboutal-Qa’idaeffortstorecruitandradical-izeAmericans.IthighlightsrecruitingvideosandexamplesofpropagandaandtheeasewithwhichthiscontentisavailableontheInternet,andseekstoeducateindividualsonwhatgovernmentsandcommunitiescandotocounterthisthreat.92

Focus Engagements and CVE Education on Social Media InfluencersBroad-basedengagementprogramsareimportantbutthereisparticularvalueinreachingouttoadiversearrayofMuslimsocialmediainfluencers.Theseindividuals,alwayseagerfornewcontentandstorylines,canechotheengagementstoamuchbroaderrangeofpeople.Furthermore,bydemonstrat-ingU.S.governmentconcernsandredresses,thereisagreaterchancethatanynegativeopinionsofthegovernmentcanbesoftenedormollified.Likewise,theU.S.governmentshouldalsohelpsocialmedialeadersunderstandtheimportanceofCVE-relatedissues,andtheCommunityAwarenessBriefingisobviouslyaready-madetooltodoso.U.S.officialsshouldidentifybothestablishedandup-and-comingsocialmediapersonalitiesandincorporatetheseindividualsintointeragencyengagementstrategies.

Build Leadership and Social Media CapacityEnhancingthesuccessandreachofpositivevoicesintheMuslimcommunity,especiallythosewillingtodirectlycounteral-Qa’ida’soutreachefforts,willrequirebuildingtherequisitecapacityofAmericanMuslimleadersandinstitutions.Thiscapacitybuildingwillneedtofocusonbuildinggeneralinsti-tutionalcapacities,leadershipskills,andsocialmediaexper-tise,alongwithevenbroaderskillsinthearts.EffortstobuildnetworksofMuslimleadersandempowerthemwithinformationandresearcharealsorequired.

Build Institutional and Leadership CapacityInstitutionalcapacityandleadershiptrainingareanimportantandfoundationalsteptoenhancingthenumberandpowerofcredibleMuslimvoices.Oneissueishelpingtodevelopreligiousleaderswhohavescholarlycredentials,understandandareabletoworkinanAmericancontext,andcanspeaktoyoungAmerican-bornMuslimswhomayfeeldisenfranchisedfromlocalreligiousinstitutions.ThereisalsoaneedtohelpbuildMuslimcivilsoci-etyactorsandfaith-basedorganizations.Emergingleadersandtheirinstitutionswillneedknowledgeinorganizationalmanage-ment,thecreationofnonprofitstructuresandfoundations,andtheabilitytocompeteforfoundationgrants.93

AnumberofMusliminstitutionshavestartedtobuildthiscapacity.Forexample,HartfordSeminaryhelpstrainAmericanMuslimchaplainstoworkinuniversities,hospitals,andmosques,andtheAmericanMuslimCivilLeadershipInstitute(AMCLI)

– 9 –

andMPACbothofferleadershiptrainingtoadiversearrayofup-and-comingMuslimleaderswiththegoalofenhancingtheirskillsforcivicengagement.94Fundingfromfoundationsandnonprofitsarekeyforsuchprogramsandshouldbeenhancedwherepossible.

Build Capacity for Social Media OutreachThevalueofsocialmediatrainingwasechoedbyanumberofthoseinterviewed.AsMoghulnoted,“Youcanfigureitoutonyourownbutitdoesn’tmeanyouwill.[Training]savestimeandenergy.Thosewithmostvaluablecontributionsdon’thavetimetofigureitout.”95Anotherindividualobservedthat,“Youdon’thavetoteacha20-year-oldhowtotweet,butyoucanteachthemhowtotweetwell.”96Representativesofonemarketingfirmthatprovidessuchinstructionagree,observingthattrainingcanhelpindividualsknowwhotheyaretargeting,howtotargetthemandhowto,forexample,crafteffectivemessagesonTwitterwitha140-characterlimit.97Ultimately,individualsandinstitu-tionsshouldbeabletodevelopapropersocialmediastrategy,utilizeanalyticsthathelpdeterminethereachandeffectivenessofoutreachcampaigns,andimproveexecution.TrainersshouldprovideguidanceontechniquesthatcanhelpwebcontentriseinGooglesearchrankings,andhelpreligiousscholarsandinstitu-tionsunderstandtheimportanceofpropersoundbitesthatcanplaywellonTwitterandFacebook.98Helpingindividualsandinstitutionsdevelopsubstantivecontentisalsoimportant,associalmediaissimplyatooltoconveyameaningfulmessage.SupporttotheologicaltrainingsuchasthatfosteredbyHartfordSeminaryandZaytunaCollegeisrecommended.

Inpromotingthistraining,itwillbeimportanttoidentifyup-and-comingleaderswhocanmostbenefitfromtheeduca-tion.Asthecasestudiessuggest,oneapproachistoworkwithCVEstakeholderswhoareintentontakingupthemantleofcounteringviolentextremismandrelatedcausessuchasbuildinginterfaithrelations.Socialmediatrainingshouldalsopiggybackonothercivicandreligiouscapacity-buildingprogramssuchasthosebytheHartfordSeminary,ZaytunaCollege,AMCLI,andMPAC.Itwouldalsobehelpfultoprovidethistrainingtomem-bersoftheNationalAssociationofMuslimChaplainsandtheMuslimStudentAssociation.Manysuchprogramsalreadyincor-porateasocialmediaelementtotheirtraining,butenhancedpri-vatesectorfundingandpartnershipswithtechnologyandsocialmediafirmsmaywellincreasethevalueandeffectivenessofthistraining.Inadditiontoin-persontraining,aneasy-usemanualorwebsiteonbestpracticesforusingsocialmediaforreligiousengagementwouldalsobehelpful.Suchamanualwouldprovehelpfulforlocalcommunityandreligiousleaders.

Work with ArtistsArtists,includingthoseworkinginfilm,music,andmore,areimportantbecausetheyhavethecapabilitytoprovidecontentbeyondthatofscholars,religiousleaders,andsocial-religiouscommentators.Theycanweavestoriesthattellameaningfulandengagingtale,craftvideosthathavethecapacitytogoviral

onYouTube,anddraftscreenplaysthatallowtelevisionandthesilverscreentoserveasimportantvectors.99TheseartistscanplayacriticalroleinthecounterradicalizationdebatebothintheUnitedStatesandabroad.Programsthatseektobuildartisticandsocialmediaskillsetswhileexplainingbarriersthatlimitreachandinfluencecouldproveenormouslyhelpful.

Empower Influential Voices with Research and InformationAnotherkeyaspecttobuildingcapacityistoempowerkeypartieswithinformationthatwillexpandtheeffectivenessandreachoftheiractivities.Thisresearchcantakeavarietyofforms.MirahmadiandFarooqoftheWORDEFoundationargueforenhancedresearchonMuslimpublicopiniontobetterunder-standMuslimattitudes.Theyspecificallyrecommendresearchonthe“challengesandthreatsthatfaceMuslimcommunities,thereconciliationofIslamicandAmericanvalues,MuslimidentityissuesinAmerica,andbarrierstointegratingintomainstreamAmericansociety.”100Oneimamagreesandarguesthat,“Foun-dationsshouldgetintunewithwhatisgoingoninmindsofyoungMuslims...findoutwhatintereststhemand[learn]theirstruggles.”101Classicmarketingresearchcanalsobehelpful.FocusgroupswerecertainlypivotalasGoogleIdeasundertookitscounterradicalizationprogram,andthistypeofresearchwouldalsoprovebeneficialtoabroaderarrayofactivists.TherearealsoTechnographicsurveys,whichhelpsocialmediastrategistsplanoutreacheffortsbyhelpingthemtounderstandhowaudiencesvaryintermsoftheirparticipationinsocialmedia.102

Build Social Networks of CVE ActivistsCVEactivists,leadersintheMuslimcommunity,artists,privatefoundations,governmentrepresentatives,andtechnologyfirmsshouldbeconnectedviaabroadrangeofnetworks.Conferencesandworkshopsareimportantastheyprovideavenuewhereindi-vidualscanlearncommunityneeds,supportandencouragenewandexistingefforts,sharetipsandexpertise,andbuildrelation-ships.AccordingtoMoghul,“Themostprofoundimplicationshappenaftertheeventandpeoplearesocializing;thatiswhenpeopleprocessandaskthequestionsthattheyareuncomfort-ableaskinginapublicsetting.Youtakesmartervoicesinthecommunityandintroducethemtomentors.”103DolatabadiofGoogleIdeasnotes,“Oneparticipantcameto[theSAVEconfer-ence]withhisbusinesshatonbuthesaidhewenthomeandcried[becausehehad]madegreatfriendships...”104 Ultimately,networkingisbeststartedinpersonthroughavarietyofconfer-ences,workshops,andretreatsbutcanquicklygoonlineandthenspreadthroughFacebookgroupsandotherwebvenues.

Understand the Important Role of Nonviolent IslamistsForthoseseekingtopartnerwithorsupportMuslimvoices,onepressingquestionis:Whichareappropriatevoicestosupport?ScholarLorenzoVidinoprovidesanexcellentdescriptionofthisissueinareportpublishedbytheU.S.InstituteofPeace(USIP).105MuslimcommunitiesintheUnitedStatesarehighlydiverse,vary-

– 10 –

ingconsiderablyalongsectarianandpoliticallines.VidinoweighstheprosandconsofworkingwithnonviolentIslamists,someofwhomholdhighlyconservativeviewsonwomenandspeakwithapalpableangeragainstU.S.foreignpolicy.

Theriskinworkingwiththeseindividualsisthattheirideol-ogymayfunctionasa“conveyorbelt”forradicalizationandmaylaytheideologicalgroundworkforsubsequentviolence.However,asVidinopointsout,thosewhospeakoutagainstviolenceare“inauniquepositiontoinfluencethosemostlikelytoengageinviolence.”Theyalsohavehighlevelsofcredibilityamongpopula-tionsmostatriskofradicalization.106Someofthoseinterviewedforthisstudyconcurwiththerisks,butmanyothersarguedthatsuchvoicesarecriticalinthecounterradicalizationdebate.Asoneintervieweesuggested,thisrubricof“goodMuslim—badMuslim”is“damaging.”ThenonviolentIslamistsaretheones“youwanttobeanallybecausethosewhofollowthemaretheonesyouwanttoinoculate....Byeliminating[thesevoices]youarelosingtheaudi-enceyouwanttotarget.”107

AsVidinopointsout,thereisnoclearanswertothedilemma.Wesuggestthatfoundationsandprivatesponsorsareinthebestpositiontoweighthesefactors.Theywillbeunencumberedbythevastbureaucracythatsaddlesgovernmentagencies,andsomayhavemoreabilitytoconsideranyrequestsforfundingorcapacity-buildingassistanceonacase-by-casebasis.Theymayalsobeabletomonitortheimpactoftheireffortsandcontinueordiscontinueassistanceasthesituationwarrants,andtheyareinapositiontoside-stepthornyissuesofideologybybasingassistanceonspecificanddefinedprogramobjectivessuchasderadicalizingindividualsalreadyontheextremistpath,providingonlinesafetytraining,orfosteringinterfaithrelations.Theseareworthwhilegoalsregardlessofagroup’sideology.

Twootherissuesareworthpointingout.First,suchIslamistgroupsareaminorityintheMuslimAmericanlandscape.AccordingtoasurveyofAmericanmosques,only1percentofcongregationsidentifythemselveswiththeSalafitradition.108Suchgroupsarealsomorelikelytoeschewfundingandassistancefrommoderateorsecularorganizations.Consequently,theissueislikelylessadilemmathanitmightotherwisebe.Second,thevalueofprovidingappropriatecapacity-buildingprogramsamongabroadcross-sectionofgroupsandindividualsmayoutweightherisksofprovidingnoassistanceatall.

Enhance Private-Sector Funding and EngagementAnumberoffoundations,nonprofits,andtechnologyandmediafirmshavehelpedsupportavarietyofvoicesandinitiativesimpor-tanttocounteringal-Qa’ida’sonlinepresence.Werecommendthatprivatesectorinstitutionsconsidernewopportunitiesforenhancedfunding.WealsourgethattheU.S.governmentplaytheroleofconveneranduseitsfundsandinfluencetofacilitatenetworksofcredibleMuslimvoices,promotefundingandassistancefromnonprofits,foundationsandthink-tanks,andinvitepublicrela-tionsfirmsandtechnologyoutfitstobuildwebandsocialmediacapacity.Sucharecommendationhasbeenofferedbyanumber

ofcommentators,includingBritishscholarPeterNeumannandtheWORDEFoundation.109IthasalsobeenacknowledgedintheWhiteHouse’sStrategicImplementationPlan.110

Find Avenues to Enhance Government Funding WhilethegovernmenthaslimitedabilitytofundAmericanMuslimsocialmediaoutreachefforts,thereareseverallinesoffundingthatshouldnotprovecontroversial.First,theWhiteHouse’sOfficeofFaith-BasedandNeighborhoodPartnershipsactivelyfundsprogramsthathelppromoteinterfaithdialogueandcooperation.111Itwouldnotbeastretchtohelplocalfaith-basedorganizationsusesocialmediatocreateonlineplatformsthatcanmaximizetheimpactofin-personevents.112

TheremayalsobearolefortheNationalEndowmentfortheArts(NEA),whichawardsmatchinggrantstonot-for-profitorganizations.Itseeksinparttousethesegrantsforstrengthen-inglocalcommunitiesandrecognizesthatart“worksonaudi-encestochange,confront,challenge,andinspire”Americana.113TheNEAhasvariousgrantmechanismsthatmaybesuitabletoassistaspiringAmericanMuslimartistsinenhancingskillsetsandcreatingworkthatcountersextremism.Thisneednot“choosesides”inMuslimideologicaldebatesbutcouldhelpfundworksthatpromotetoleranceandinterfaithengagement,counternotionsof“jihadicool,”andemphasizenonviolentapproachestoconflict.AcceptingNEAfundingislesslikelytostigmatizeanartistthewayfundingfromanovertlysecurity-focusedagencysuchasDHSorNCTCmight.114

AnalternativeisthatthegovernmentcouldworkthroughtheUSIPoranongovernmentalthink-tanktohelpadministeragrantprocesstofundsmallinitiatives,includingcapacity-buildingefforts,forAmericanMuslimartistsorotherswhosimilarlyproposeeffortsofanonideologicalnature.TimStevensandPeterNeumannhaveproposedsuchaprogramfortheBrit-ishgovernment,sayingamajorbenefitofworkingthroughanintermediaryisthatitwouldhelpavoidaccusationsofgovern-ment“meddlingandmanipulation.”115

ConclusionItisworthconcludingthisreportbyemphasizinganimportantandundergirdingmessage:TheU.S.governmentandprivatefundersmustplaytheroleoffacilitatorratherthanorchestrator.ThisisthekeylessonlearnedfromtheGoogleIdeasinitiative,whereorchestratorsquicklyabandonedacentrallydirectedmediacampaignandinsteadplayedtheroleofenablerbybuildingskills,facilitatingfunding,andhelpingactivistsforgenewconnections.Ultimately,themessagebelongedsolelytotheindividualactivists.ThisapproachentailssomeriskasactivistswillcriticizepoliciesoftheU.S.governmentoradvocateviewsthatseeminglydivergefromthemainstream.Thechallengecomesinappreciatingthatsuchauthenticityandcriticismonlyservetoempowerwhatishopedtobeacoremessageofpeaceandtolerance.Ultimately,theU.S.governmentandprivatesponsorsmustallowcredibleMuslimvoicestoreachtheirownconclusionsandfindtheirownmessage.

– 11 –

Endnotes1U.S.SenateCommitteeonHomelandSecurityandGovernmentalAffairs,Violent Islamist Extremism, the Internet, and the Homegrown Terrorist Threat,Washington,D.C.,May8,2008.2ChristopherBoucek,U.S. Strategy for Countering Jihadist Websites: Testimony to the House Committee on Foreign Affairs, Subcommittee on Terrorism, Nonproliferation, and Trade,CarnegieEndowment,September29,1010.3NationalCoordinatorforCounterterrorism,Jihadists and the Internet: 2009 Update,May2010;IssamAhmed,“NewestFriendsonFacebook?PakistanMilitants,”Christian Science Monitor,July8,2010.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Asia-South-Central/2010/0708/Newest-friends-on-Facebook-Pakistan-militants.4BrianMichaelJenkins,Stray Dogs and Virtual Armies: Radicalization and Recruitment to Jihadist Terrorism in the United States Since 9/11,SantaMonica,Calif.:RANDCorporation,OP-343-RC,2011.AsofDecember13,2012:http://www.rand.org/pubs/occasional_papers/OP343.htmlSeealsoBrianMichaelJenkins,“GettingtheThreatRight,”CATO Unbound,Washington,D.C.,June12,2012.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.cato-unbound.org/2012/06/12/brian-michael-jenkins/getting-the-threat-right/5Helmus,Todd,“WhyandHowSomePeopleBecomeTerrorists,”inPaulK.DavisandKimCragin,eds.,Social Science for Counterterrorism: Putting the Pieces Together,SantaMonica,Calif.:RANDCorporation,MG-849-OSD,2008,pp.71–112.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.rand.org/pubs/monographs/MG849.html6ExecutiveOfficeofthePresidentoftheUnitedStates,“EmpoweringLocalPartnerstoPreventViolentExtremismintheUnitedStates,”August2011;ExecutiveOfficeofthePresidentoftheUnitedStates,“StrategicImplementationPlanforEmpoweringLocalPartnerstoPreventViolentExtremismintheUnitedStates,”December2011.7ThispositiveinfluenceabroadisespeciallyimportantasgovernmentcensorshipandpressurefromformalreligiousgroupslimitfreeandopenreligiousdialogueinmanypartsoftheMiddleEast.TheUnitedStatesprovidesanimportantspacewheresuchdialogueislegallyprotectedandculturallysupported.8Interviewwithimam,April24,2012(namewithheldonrequest).9CoreyP.Saylor,Written Statement of the Council on American-Islamic Relations on the Extent of Radicalization in the American Muslim Community and that Community’s Response,CouncilonAmerican-IslamicRelations.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.cair.com/ActionCenter/PeterKingHearings.aspx10Imaminterview,2012.11InterviewwithDr.HediehMirahmadi,WORDEpresident,MontgomeryVillage,Md.,May21,2012.12GreaterBostonInterfaithOrganizationhomepage,undated.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.gbio.org/13InterviewwithMuslimmediaactivist,April12,2012(namewithheldonrequest).14Theforumsreferredtoherearenotorganization-specificchatrooms,butratherunaffiliatedradicalforums.Gainingaccesstoanofficialal-Qa’idawebforum,forexample,isnotpracticalforCVEmessagingduetothestrictmoderationofsuchforumsandcarefulvettingofparticipants.Mediaactivistinterview,2012.15InterviewwithImamAbdullahAntepli,DukeUniversitychaplain,Durham,N.C.,April4,2012.16Mediaactivistinterview,2012.17MuslimPublicAffairsCouncil,“CyberExtremism”memorandum,September14,2011;LaurieGoodstein,“AmericanMuslimsMakeVideotoRebutMilitants,”New York Times,July31,2010.Non-Muslimswerealsoanimportantdemographictargetforthisvideo.18AndreaElliott,“WhyYasirQadhiWantstoTalkAboutJihad,”New York Times,March17,2011.Seealso“TheJWord”website,undated.AsofNovember27,2012:http://thejword.org/19DominicCasciani,“IslamicScholarTahirul-QadriIssuesTerrorismFatwa,”BBC News,March2,2010.AsofNovember27,2012:http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8544531.stm20MuslimPublicAffairsCouncil,“InjusticeCannotDefeatInjustice,”YouTubevideo,July12,2010.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3IofpsHOosE21Imaminterview,2012.22Someexamplesoftheofferings:Muslimmatters.org,“MakingSenseoftheEgyptianElections:APoliticalAnalysis,”June28,2012.AsofNovember27,2012:http://muslimmatters.org/2012/06/28/making-sense-of-the-egyptian-elections-a-political-analysis/andQadhi,Yasir,“HowtoSpendYourSummerVacation,”Muslimmatters.org,June4,2012.AsofNovember27,2012:http://muslimmatters.org/2012/06/04/muslimmatters-treasures-how-to-spend-your-summer-vacation-yasir-qadhi/

– 12 –

23Islam and the Internet,nine-partseries,Suhaibwebb.com2011.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.suhaibwebb.com/miscellaneous/announcements/launching-islam-the-internet-series/AbuAaliyah,Jihad al-Nafs: The Greater Struggle,Muslimmatters.org,November23,2007.AsofNovember27,2012:http://muslimmatters.org/2007/11/23/jihad-al-nafs-the-greater-struggle/24MuhammadWajidAkhter,5 Examples of Supreme Muslim Tolerance,Muslimmatters.org,September20,2012;Muslimmatters.orgFacebookpage,April2007.AsofNovember27,2012:https://www.facebook.com/MuslimMatters25NadiaS.Mohammed,“RiseoftheAmericanRock-StarImam,”Elan The Magazine,undated.AsofNovember27,2012:http://elanthemag.com/the-rise-of-the-‘rockstar’-imams/26HamzaYusuf ’sFacebookpage,February17,2008.AsofNovember27,2012:https://www.facebook.com/pages/Hamza-Yusuf/805840654327Mohammed,undated.28PewResearchCenter,Muslim Americans: No Signs of Growth in Alienation or Support for Extremism,August30,2011.29Jenkins,2011;SeealsoJenkins,2012.30DavidSchanzer,CharlesKurzman,andEbrahimMoosa,Anti-Terror Lessons of Muslim-Americans,Washington,D.C.:U.S.DepartmentofJustice,January6,2010.31Aliinterview,2012.32Mediaactivistinterview,2012.33PewResearchCenter,2011.34PeterBergen,AndrewLebovich,MatthewReed,etal.,“Post–9/11JihadistTerrorismCasesInvolvingU.S.CitizensandResidents,”NewAmericaFoundation,2011.Accordingtoarelatedstudy,informantswereusedin69of191terrorismcasesandundercoveragentsusedin21cases.NewAmericaFoundationandSyracuseUniversity’sMaxwellSchoolofPublicPolicy,“RoleofInformantsandUndercoverAgents,”The Homegrown Threat,2011.AsofDecember14,2012:http://homegrown.newamerica.net/about/role-informants-and-undercover-agents35JerryMarkon,“TensionGrowsBetweenCaliforniaMuslims,FBIafterInformantInfiltratesMosque,”Washington Post,December5,2010.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/12/04/AR2010120403710.html36MattApuzzoandAdamGoldman,“InsidetheSpyUnitthatNYPDSaysDoesn’tExist,”Associated Press,Aug.31,2011.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.ap.org/Content/AP-In-The-News/2011/Inside-the-spy-unit-that-NYPD-says-doesnt-existChrisHawleyandMattApuzzo,“NYPDInfiltrationofCollegesRaisesPrivacyFears,”Associated Press,October11,2011.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.ap.org/Content/AP-In-The-News/2011/NYPD-infiltration-of-colleges-raises-privacy-fearsAdamGoldmanandMattApuzzo,“NYPDBuiltSecretFilesonMosquesOutsideNewYork,”Associated Press,February22,2012.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.ap.org/Content/AP-In-The-News/2012/NYPD-built-secret-files-on-mosques-outside-NYEileenSullivan,“NYPDSpiedonCity’sMuslimAnti-TerrorPartners,”Associated Press,October6,2011.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.ap.org/Content/AP-In-The-News/2011/NYPD-spied-on-citys-Muslim-anti-terror-partners37TinaMoore,RoccoParascandola,andCorkySiemaszko,“BloombergDefendsNYPDSpying,”Daily News,February24,2012.38PewResearchCenter,Public Remains Conflicted over Islam,August24,2010.39WajahatAli,EliClifton,MatthewDuss,LeeFang,ScottKeys,andFaizShakir,Fear,Inc.,The Roots of the Islamophobia Network in America,CenterforAmericanProgress,August26,2011.40LisaDeMoraes,“TameRealityof‘All-AmericanMuslim’LeadstoCancellation,”Washington Post,March7,2012.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/tame-reality-of-all-american-muslim-leads-to-cancellation/2012/03/07/gIQAXSOoxR_print.html41NationalConsortiumfortheStudyofTerrorismandResponsestoTerrorism,Far Right Violence in the United States: 1990–2010,August2012.42“TheBenefitsofHindsight,”The Economist,August18–24,2012,p.33.43SouthernPovertyLawCenter,“SPLCTestifiestoU.S.SenateaboutRisingExtremistThreat,UrgesVigilance,”September19,2012.44HediehMirahmadiandMehreenFarooq,A Community-Based Approach to Countering Radicalization: A Partnership for America,WORDEFounda-tion,December2010;BrianFishmanandAndrewLebovich,Countering Domestic Radicalization: Lessons for Intelligence Collection and Community Outreach,NewAmericaFoundation,June2011.Oneconcern,forexample,isthatreportingpotentiallyradicalizedMuslimstoauthoritiescreatesariskthatlawenforcementwilluseundercoveragentstofomenttheprocessfurtherasakindofcontrolleddetonation,ratherthaninterveningtostoptheradicalizationprocessinitstracks.

– 13 –

45Antepliinterview,2012.46Activistinterview,2012.47PhoneinterviewwithMuslimsocialmediaexpert,May5,2012.48Aliinterview,2012.49Antepliinterview,2012.50IhsanBagby,The American Mosque 2011: Activities, Administration, and Vitality of the American Mosque,CAIR,ReportNo2,May2012.51Mohammed,undated;InterviewwithRabiaChaudry,Washington,D.C.,April9,2012.52Chaudryinterview,2012.53BrieLoskotaandNadiaRoumani,Enhancing Impact in the Public Square: Building Capacity and Developing Leadership among American Muslims and Their Organizations,BrookingsInstitution,August2011.54MatthewDaneman,“MoreU.S.CollegesAddingMuslimChaplains,”USA Today,March24,2011.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2011-03-24-muslimchaplains24_ST_N.htm55PhoneinterviewwithMoghul,NewAmericaFoundation,June8,2012.56Moghulinterview,2012.57PhoneinterviewwithAlejandroBeutel,formergovernmentandpolicyanalystattheMuslimPublicAffairsCouncil,May22,2012.58Mirahmadiinterview,2012.59Mediaactivistinterview,2012.60PhoneinterviewwithIslamicscholar,March30,2012(namewithheldonrequest).61H.A.Hellyer,Pursuant to Prevent: British Community Counterterrorism Strategy: Past, Present, and Future,InstituteforSocialPolicyandUnderstand-ing,2011.62PeterNeumann,Preventing Violent Radicalization in America,NationalSecurityPreparednessGroup,June2011.63SuchabacklashmayoccurbecauseofperceptionsthatCVEisnotasignificantissueorbecauseitmaybeviewedaskowtowingtogovernmentsecu-rityprograms.64Mediaactivistinterview,2012.65FishmanandLebovich,2011,p.21;ImamMohamedMagidandHumeraKhan,The Roles of Muslim-Majority and Muslim-Minority Communities in a Global Context,SabanCenter,BrookingsInstitution,August,2011;MirahmadiandFarooq,2010.66PhoneinterviewwithMuslimchaplain,February24,2012(namewithheldonrequest).67Beutelinterview,201268Imaminterview,2012.69Socialmediaexpertinterview,2012.70Beutelinterview,201271Moghulinterview,2012.72Moghulinterview,2012.73Moghulinterview,2012.74Schanzer,Kurzman,andMoosa,2010.75Chaudryinterview,2012.76Aliinterview,2012.77PhoneinterviewwithDolatabadi,June8,2012.78JasonWalsh,“GoogleIdeas’sNew‘Think-Do’TankTakesonViolentExtremism,”Christian Science Monitor,June29,2011.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Global-News/2011/0629/Google-Ideas-s-new-think-do-tank-takes-on-violent-extremism79JaredCohenandBrendanBallou,SAVE Supporting Document: Becoming a Former: Identity, Ideology, and Counterradicalization,CouncilonForeignRelations,March2012.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.cfr.org/united-states/save-supporting-document-becoming-former/p27056

– 14 –

80InterviewwithAlexStrugnell,InstituteforStrategicDialogue,March9,2012;OliviaSolon,“FormerTerroristsandNeo-NazisGetTheirOwnSocialNetwork,”Wired.com,April25,2012.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2012/04/wiredcouk-nazi-social-net/81TribecaFilmInstitute,“TribecaTeachesExpandstoLosAngeles,”February6,2012.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.tribecafilminstitute.org/youth/news/138791639.html“TribecaTeaches:LennoxMiddleSchool,”Vimeovideo,April24,2012.AsofNovember27,2012:http://vimeo.com/4096453682eBoost4SProgramhomepage,undated.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.4sprogram.org/index.html83Dolatabadiinterview,2012.84FishmanandLebovich,2011;MirahmadiandFarooq,2010.85Neumann,2011.Forexample,DHShastheOfficeforCivilRightsandCivilLiberties,whichholdstownhallandcommunityroundtableeventswhereindividualscanvoicegrievancesandenableDHStopromoteunderstandingofissuesrelatedtoviolentextremism.TheDepartmentofJustice’sCommunityRelationsServiceworkswithMuslimAmericansandotherminorities.U.S.attorneyshavebeentoldtofosterengagementwithcommuni-tiesonissuesofviolentextremism.TheFBIconductsengagementprograms,asdoestheNCTC.86Moghulinterview,2012.Asanotherindividualnoted,“Whycan’twehavethePresidentsay,‘WeunderstandMuslimshavelegitimateissueswithPalestinianIsraeliconflict’...Actuallymakethesedisenfranchisedpeoplefeelapartoftheprocessbynotalienatingthemfurther...”PhoneinterviewwithanonymousIslamicscholar,March30,2012.87Foranexcellentdiscussiononthisissue,seeFishmanandLebovich,2011.88Schanzer,Kurzman,andMoosa,2010.89FishmanandLebovich,2011,p.23.90PresidentBarackObama,“RemarksbythePresidentonaNewBeginning,”June4,2009.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/remarks-president-cairo-university-6-04-0991Importantly,interfaithengagementsoughtnotpresupposethatfundamentaldifferencesintheologydonotexistamongparticipantsfromdifferentreligiousbackgrounds.Instead,interfaithengagementsshouldseektohelpparticipantsunderstandthesedifferencesandcreateanatmospherewhereinterfaithfriendshipscantakeroot.Suchwasthecaseinaneventcalled“BuildingHope:Muslims,ChristiansandJewsSeekingtheCommonGood.”Theten-dayeventheldinJune2011broughttogetherinfluential,conservative,anddevoutChristians,Muslims,andJewsinordertodiscussissuesofcommonconcern.Theevent’sunusuallengthallowedtimeforparticipantstosharepersonalconvictions,wrestlewithandappreciatekeydifferencesintheology,andbuildmutualfriendships.SeeYaleCenterforFaithandCulture,ReconciliationProgramwebsite.92ExecutiveOfficeofthePresidentoftheUnitedStates,“StrategicImplementationPlanforEmpoweringLocalPartnerstoPreventViolentExtremismintheUnitedStates,”December2011.93LoskotaandRoumani,2011;Mirahmadiinterview,201294AmericanMuslimCivilLeadershipInstitutewebsite;phoneinterviewwithNadiaRoumani,AMCLIdirector,May31,2012;Beutelinterview,2012.95Moghulinterview,2012.96Mediaactivistinterview,2012.97InterviewwithRebeccaBouchebel,QorvisCommunications,May31,2012.98Onecommonlycitedfatwaagainstterrorism,forexample,is600pages,fartoocumbersometoplaywellinsocialmedia.99RANDhasexaminedhowArabiclanguageworksofartcanpositivelycounterextremisminthebroaderMiddleEastandhasconsideredsomeofthebarriersfacedbyMiddleEasternartists.LowellSchwartz,ToddHelmus,DaliaDassaKaye,andNadiaOweidat,Barriers to the Broad Dissemination of Creative Works in the Arab World,SantaMonica,Calif.:RANDCorporation,MG-879-OSD,2009.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.rand.org/pubs/monographs/MG879.html100MirahmadiandFarooq,2010.101Imaminterview,2012.102Forexample,thesurveysidentifytheprevalenceof“creators”whopublishblogsanduploadvideos,“conversationalists”whopostTwitterupdatesandupdatetheirFacebookstatus,“joiners”whovisitsocialnetworkingsitesandmaintainprofiles,aswellasmere“spectators”and“inactives.”SeeCharleneLiandJoshBernoff,Groundswell, Winning in a World Transformed by Social Technologies,ForresterResearch,Inc.,2011,p.63.103Moghulinterview,2012104Dolatabadiinterview,2012.105LorenzoVidino,Countering Radicalization in America: Lessons From Europe,UnitedStatesInstituteofPeace,SpecialReport262,November2010.

– 15 –

106Vidino,2010,p.7.107InterviewwithMuslimsocialmediaexpert(namewithheldonrequest).108IhsanBagby,The American Mosque 2011: Basic Characteristics of the American Mosque; Attitudes of Mosque Leaders,CAIR,ReportNo1,January2011.109Neumann,2011;MirahmadiandFarooq,2010;Beutelinterview,2012.110ExecutiveOfficeofthePresidentoftheUnitedStates,“StrategicImplementationPlanforEmpoweringLocalPartnerstoPreventViolentExtremismintheUnitedStates,”December2011.111TheWhiteHouse,Office of Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships,undated.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.whitehouse.gov/administration/eop/ofbnp112InterviewwithAliDialo,June15,2012.113NationalEndowmentfortheArts,“2012Guide,”2012,p.1.114InterviewwithTawfikHamid,M.D.,Arlington,Va.,March3,2012.115TimStevensandPeterR.Neumann,Countering Online Radicalisation: A Strategy for Action,TheInternationalCentrefortheStudyofRadicalisationandPoliticalViolence,2009;interviewwithPeterNeumann,KingsCollege,March5,2012.

Additional ReferencesAmerican-ArabAnti-DiscriminationCommittee,Bridges,undated.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.adcmichigan.org/content/bridges

AmericanMuslimCivilLeadershipInstitutehomepage,undated.AsofNovember27,2012:http://crcc.usc.edu/initiatives/amcli/

Bagby,Ihsan,The American Mosque 2011: Basic Characteristics of the American Mosque; Attitudes of Mosque Leaders,CAIR,ReportNo.1,January2011.

DeMoraes,Lisa,“TameRealityofAll-AmericanMuslimLeadstoCancellation,”Washington Post,March7,2012.AsofNovember27,2012:http://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/tame-reality-of-all-american-muslim-leads-to-cancellation/2012/03/07/gIQAXSOoxR_print.html

Gray,David,andAlbonHead,“TheImportanceoftheInternettothePost-ModernTerroristandItsRoleasaFormofSafeHaven,”European Journal of Scientific Research,Vol.25,No.3,2009,pp.396–404.

InstituteforStrategicDialogue,Radicalisation: The Role of the Internet, A Working Paper of the PPN,undated.

Li,Charlene,andJoshBernoff,Groundswell, Winning in a World Transformed by Social Technologies,ForresterResearch,Inc.,2011,p.63.

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis. RAND focuses on the issues that matter most, such as health, education, national security, international affairs, law and business, the environment, and more. As a nonpartisan organization, RAND operates independent of political and commercial pressures. We serve the public interest by helping lawmakers reach informed decisions on the nation’s pressing challenges. RAND’s publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors. R® is a registered trademark.C O R P O R A T I O N

© Copyright 2013 RAND CorporationISBN: 978-0-8330-7854-4

www.rand.org

RR-130-OSD

About This ReportTheAugust2011WhiteHousestrategytoempowerlocalpartnerstopreventviolentextremismseekstopromotecommunity-ledcounterextremismactivities,particularlythosepromulgatedontheInternetandsocialmedia.ThisreportseekstoidentifywaystoempowerpositiveandcredibleMuslimvoicestocounteral-Qa’ida’sgrowingInternetpropagandacampaign.ThefindingsfromthisreportwillbeofinterestnotonlytotheU.S.governmentbutalsoprivatefoundations,nonprofitgroups,andtheprivatesector,whosesupportiscriticaltothesuccessofthenewWhiteHousestrategy.

Theauthorswishtothankthemanyindividualswhocontributedtothisresearchreport.Firstandforemost,wethankallofthosewhograciouslylenttheirtimeforinterviews.Itistheirinsightfulcommentsthatmakethesubstanceofthisreport.WearealsogratefultoFranciscoWalter,whohelpedpreparethisdocumentandlentaninvaluablehandtoallfacetsoftheresearchprocess.BothOmaral-ShaheryandWasifSyedprovidedhelpfulreviewsofdraftmanuscript.WealsothankJenniferBrysonandBrianJenkins,whoprovidedexpertreviewandcarefullyconsideredcritiquesofourreport.Anyerrorsremainthesoleresponsibilityoftheauthors.

The RAND Homeland Security and Defense CenterThisresearchwasconductedwithintheRANDHomelandSecurityandDefenseCenter,ajointcenterofRANDJustice,Infrastructure,andEnvironmentandtheRANDNationalDefenseResearchInstitute,afeder-allyfundedresearchanddevelopmentcentersponsoredbytheOfficeoftheSecretaryofDefense,theJointStaff,theUnifiedCombatantCommands,theNavy,theMarineCorps,thedefenseagencies,andthedefenseIntel-ligenceCommunity.

FormoreinformationontheRANDHomelandSecurityandDefenseCenter,seehttp://www.rand.org/multi/homeland-security-and-defense.html.