sustained treatment of amd containing al and fe 3+ with limestone aggregate neil wolfe and robert...

29
Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage Task Force Meeting March 2011

Upload: savana-carrow

Post on 16-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe3+ with Limestone Aggregate

Neil Wolfe and Robert HedinHedin Environmental

West Virginia Mine Drainage Task Force MeetingMarch 2011

Page 2: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage
Page 3: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Limestone Advantages

• Limited solubility– cannot over-treat– Can install years of treatment capacity

• Can store on site in open piles without loss• Not hazardous• Less than 20% the cost of lime and caustic

alternatives

Page 4: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Limestone Disadvantage

• When exposed to acidic water containing Al and Fe3+, solids quickly form

• Solids foul limestone aggregate, greatly decreasing its effectiveness

Page 5: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Project GoalsUnderstand why the effectiveness of limestone treatment is reduced by Al and Fe solids.

Develop a treatment approach that can overcome these limitations and provide sustainable treatment of low pH AMD with limestone aggregate

Page 6: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

pH 2.9Acidity, 290 mg/LAl, 29 mg/LFe, 8 mg/LMn, 15 mg/L

Two parallel 27 m3 roll off containers filled with ~30 tons limestone

Construction of Experimental Flush Units

Agri Drain SDS

“Small” limestone

East Box

West Box

Page 7: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Experimental

• Measure performance of limestone units– Influent and effluent samples

• pH, alkalinity, acidity, sulfate• Total and dissolved Al, Fe, and Mn

• Vary operational parameters– Flow rate– Water level in limestone bed– Drainage trigger (time, water level, chemistry)

Page 8: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Solids

Solids form when alkaline conditions arising from calcite dissolution cause:

• Al3+ Al(OH)3

• Fe3+ Fe(OH)3

Solids accumulate in the aggregate in two manners

Page 9: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Solids accumulate in pores

Page 10: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Solids form scale on limestone

Page 11: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Scale flakes off revealing clean LS surface

Page 12: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

What happens when a limestone bed is drained empty?

• Solids in aggregate pores are flushed away– porosity is restored

• Some scales are dislodged, exposing clean limestone surface– Alkalinity generation is restored

Page 13: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Treatment Goal

• Identify the retention time necessary to achieve treatment goals

• Identify the bed drainage schedule that maintains treatment effectiveness

Page 14: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Long-term alkalinity generation

Page 15: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Location pH Acid Fe Al Mn

Influent 3.0 239 8.9 25.6 14.1

Effluent 6.9 -58 0.6* 2.9* 3.0**

Metals are mg/L and acidity is mg/L CaCO3 *Suspended solid; **dissolved

Average chemistry since change to 1 gpm and 1/wk drainage (28 months)

Page 16: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Mn removal, flow 1 gpm, drain 1/wk

Page 17: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Solids accounting for the West Box

Fe flush, 40.7%

Fe Retain, 49.0%

Fe Discharge,

10.3%

West Box Fe Accounting

Al Flush, 34.8%

Al Retain, 51.8%

Al Discharge,

13.4%

West Box Al Accounting

Page 18: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Solids accumulation will eventually affect calcite dissolution and bed performance:

• Limestone must be either replaced or cleaned

Page 19: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Cleaning limestone bed with an excavator and AMD flow

Page 20: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Cleaned limestone aggregate

• Cleaning cost: $5/ton• New limestone costs

$22/ton

Page 21: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Effluent pH of Mitchell East Box Before and After Limestone Cleaning

4

4.5

5

5.5

6

6.5

7

210 230 250 270 290 310 330 350 370 390 410 430

Days of Operation

pH

East Box

Limestone Cleaned

Page 22: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

West box performance as of March 2011

• 3.2 ton CaCO3 net alkalinity generation

• 10% of installed limestone has dissolved

Page 23: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

West box performance as of March 2011

• At $40/ton LS installed (with settling pond)– $408/ton CaCO3 net alkalinity

• Comparative costs– Anna S VFP system, $400-550/ton CaCO3

– NaOH system, $1,500 – 2,500/ton CaCO3

– lime plant, $800-1000/ton CaCO3

– Stream dosing (lime), $175-291/ton CaCO3

Page 24: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Summary

1. Effective treatment of acidic Al and Fe3+

contaminated mine water can be achieved with limestone aggregate as long as the bed is regularly drained empty.

2. Fouled limestone aggregate can be cleaned and its alkalinity generation restored.

3. Sustainable Mn removal can be achieved at pH levels between 6.5 and 7.0.

Page 25: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Scootac system (2010)

• Renovation of existing VFP– 735 tons LS aggregate and 223 CY organic

substrate

• Installation of parallel DLB– 1,000 tons LS aggregate– AgriDrain SDS

• Polishing pond

• Flow distribution

Page 26: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage
Page 27: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Scootac system, Nov 2010 – Mar 2011

Flow pH Acid Alk Al Mn Fe SO4

gpm mg/L CaCO3 mg/L

Raw 85 3.9 88 0 9.9 25.2 0.3 961

Drainable LS Bed 44 7.4 -219 243 <0.1 0.9 0.1 952

Vertical Flow Pond 41 7.1 -137 164 <0.1 21.3 1.0 923

Polishing Pond na 7.3 -163 193 0.1 11.7 0.8 992

Page 28: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Scootac system (on line Nov 2010)

Page 29: Sustained Treatment of AMD Containing Al and Fe 3+ with Limestone Aggregate Neil Wolfe and Robert Hedin Hedin Environmental West Virginia Mine Drainage

Questions?

• Insert good photo or figure