suzanne liu, margaret a knowling, paul clarkson, joanna m lubieniecka, hongwei cheng,
DESCRIPTION
CLEAR CELL SARCOMA AND OTHER TRANSLOCATION-ASSOCIATED SARCOMAS ARE HIGHLY SENSITIVE TO HISTONE DEACETYLASE INHIBITOR MS-275. Suzanne Liu, Margaret A Knowling, Paul Clarkson, Joanna M Lubieniecka, Hongwei Cheng, - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
11
CLEAR CELL SARCOMA AND OTHER CLEAR CELL SARCOMA AND OTHER TRANSLOCATION-ASSOCIATED TRANSLOCATION-ASSOCIATED
SARCOMAS ARE HIGHLY SENSITIVE SARCOMAS ARE HIGHLY SENSITIVE TO HISTONE DEACETYLASE TO HISTONE DEACETYLASE
INHIBITOR MS-275INHIBITOR MS-275Suzanne Liu, Margaret A Knowling, Paul Clarkson, Suzanne Liu, Margaret A Knowling, Paul Clarkson,
Joanna M Lubieniecka, Hongwei Cheng, Joanna M Lubieniecka, Hongwei Cheng, and Torsten O Nielsenand Torsten O Nielsen
University of British Columbia and BC Cancer Agency, University of British Columbia and BC Cancer Agency, Vancouver, CanadaVancouver, Canada
HISTONESmodulate chromatin
structureH2A, H2B, H3, H4 = core nucleosome
“open” chromatin = transcriptionally active
condensed “closed” chromatin = silenced
HISTONE MODIFICATIONS: the “epigenetic code”
acetylation, methylation, phosphorylation, poly-ADP ribosylation, ubiquitinylation, sumoylation: especially amino-terminal tails of H3 and H4 on outside of nucleosome
• acetylation of H3 and H4 amino-terminal lysines by HAT open chromatin• deacetylation by HDAC condensed chromatin• global hypo-acetylation of H4 is common in human tumours and occurs early in tumorigenesis
• 18 HDAC proteins, in 4 families• mostly nuclear, in transcription factor complexes• some alternate substrates: tubulin, p53, E2F1,
NfKB, Hsp90, myoD1
Class 1 HDACs are overexpressed in colon, breast, prostate, gastric, and cervical carcinomas
PML–RARα, PLZF–RARα and AML1–ETO fusion proteins induce leukaemia (AML), and Bcl-6 lymphoma (DLBCL), by recruiting HDAC-containing repressor complexes to target genes
Histone deacetylases: enzymes altering chromatin structure and gene transcription to silence differentiation
New paper that fits nicely - StatusConclusions - Needs for SS (+ other sarcs)Acknowledgements
HDACmSin3A
TLE recruits, assembles repressor complex
SYT
TLE: a transcriptional corepressor
β-catenin
SSX
HDAC INHIBITORS
• 12 agents in clinical trials• additional agents in development, including HDAC subtype -specific
• HDACi being used in combination with retinoids to treat AML/APL
• mild side fx (thrombocytopenia, nausea; rarely cardiac fx)
• in vitro: induce p21 checkpoint and multiple apoptosis pathways; exact mechanism not clear. Some synergism with other anti-apoptotic agents
• in vitro: carcinoma cells 10x more sensitive than nontransformed
HDAC INHIBITORS
Annexin V + PI apoptotic assay of Depsipeptide in synovial sarcoma
Early apoptotic
NecroticAdvanced apoptotic
Fuji cell line, monolayer culture
SYO-1 cell line, spheroid (3D) culture
Apoptosis & necrosis visible in 3-D spheroid assays, greater than doxorubicin
Relative sensitivity: synovial sarcoma ≥ MDAMB453 breast > MMRU melanoma, SW480 colon, A549 lung > PC-3 prostate, MCF7 breast > normal fibroblasts
Using HDACi FK228 (depsipeptide): • “Results indicated that EWS-Fli1 deregulated histone acetylation through both the repression of histone acetyltransferase (HAT) and the enhancement of histone deacetylase (HDAC) activities in EFT cells”• “Expression of EWS-Fli1 protein and mRNA were also inhibited by HDACIs. We suggest that HDACIs might inhibit the expression of EWS-FLI1 via the suppression of the EWS promoter activity.”
MS-275a new synthetic benzamide HDAC inhibitor
inhibits Class 1 HDACs (HDAC 1 > HDAC 2, 3)
FK228/depsipeptide• Class 1 (HDAC 1, 2) > Class 2 inhibitor• cardiotoxicity seen in recent trials (V-tach, prolonged QT, one death: Shah MH et al Clin Cancer Res 2006;12:3997)
• lipidic, delivered p.o.• long half-life (2-3 days) q week dosing schedules• safe in humans [Ryan QC et al. JCO 2005; 23:3912-22] • dose-limiting side effects = nausea, fatigue
MS-275 causes dose- and time-dependent killing of clear cell sarcoma cell lines.
Cytotoxicity of MS-275 in KAO clear cell sarcoma cells after 24, 48, and 72 h (MTT assay)
0.00
20.00
40.00
60.00
80.00
100.00
120.00
10-7 10-6 10-5 10-6
MS-275 Doxorubicin(M)
Treatment
% o
f con
trol
24 hour
48 hour
72 hour
Cytotoxicity of MS-275 in SU-CCS-1 clear cell sarcoma cells after 24 and 72 hours (MTT assay)
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
10-7MS-275
10-6 10-5 10-6Doxorubicin(M)
Treatment
% o
f con
trol
24 hour
72 hour
Cytotoxicity effects of HDACis on Human Mesenchymal Stem Cells
00.20.40.60.8
11.2
Dox
orub
icin
10-6
M
Dep
sipe
ptid
e1n
g/m
l
MS
275
10-
5M
MS
275
10-
6M
MS
275
10-
7M
% o
f DM
SO c
ontro
l
Day1Day2Day3
Same assay: MS-275 is not toxic to bone marrow-derived human mesenchymal stem cells, whereas doxorubicin and depsipeptide/FK228 are
72h MTT assay
0.00
0.20
0.40
0.60
0.80
1.00
1.20
0.00 1.00E-07 1.00E-06 1.00E-05M MS275
% V
iabl
e FujiHS68J DSRCT
Hs68 normal fibroblasts are also resistant to MS-275, whereas synovial sarcoma and DSRCT are sensitive
Cell line Disease IC50 (uM)
DTC1 clear cell sarcoma 0.28KAO clear cell sarcoma 0.38
SYO-1 synovial sarcoma 0.44SU-CCS-1 clear cell sarcoma 0.63SKNMC Ewing sarcoma 0.79DSRCT desmo. small round cell 1.12MLS402 myxoid liposarcoma 1.23
A549 lung carcinoma 3.55SW480 colon carcinoma 4.67MCF7 breast carcinoma 4.79Hs68 normal fibroblasts > 10hMSC bone marrow-derived
mesenchymal stem cells
> 10
Relative effectiveness of HDAC inhibitor MS-275 against sarcoma, carcinoma and nonmalignant cell lines in 72h MTT assays
3D spheroid cultures: flow cytometry apoptosis assay
untreated doxorubicin 1 uM
MS-275 1 uMMS-275 0.1 uM MS-275 10 uM
Shown: 48h effects on KAO clear cell sarcoma. Similar fx seen on SU-CCS-1 and SYO-1 synovial sarcoma cell lines, fx starting at 24h
5% necrotic
4% apoptotic
88% viable
3%
32%65%
11% 34% 26%
16% 49% 70%72% 17% 4%
method: Annexin V - propidium iodide
SU-CCS-1 clear cell sarcoma: untreated SU-CCS-1: after 24h MS-275
DTC clear cell sarcoma: untreated DTC clear cell sarcoma: MS-275
“Green genes” suppressed in sarcomas . . .
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
6 12 24 48
Time [h]
RQ
(rel
ativ
e to
veh
icle
trea
ted
cells
)
FK228 - 0.5 ng/mlFK228 - 1 ng/mlFK228 - 5 ng/mlCurcumin - 40 uM
HDAC inhibitors induce MEIS2 expression in synovial sarcoma cells (Fuji) by qRT-PCR. Expression change quantified relative to vehicle (0.1% ethanol) -treated cells. Curcumin = negative control (HAT inhibitor). Bars = standard error of triplicate exp’ts.
MEIS2 = conserved homeobox transcription regulator. Negatively regulates BMP and sonic hedgehog in vertebrate limb development to express proximal rather than distal limb pattern
Effect of depsipeptide on EGR1 expression in Fuji
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
6h 12h 24h
Time [h]
RQ
(rel
ativ
e to
EtO
H tr
eate
d ce
lls)
depsi 05ng/ul
depsi 1ng/ul
depsi 5 ng/ul
Similar results also with MEF2C (a transcription factor regulating myogenesis): undetectable at baseline, readily seen after 6h MS-275 or FK228/depsipeptide
HDAC inhibitors induce EGR1 expression in synovial sarcoma cells by qRT-PCR in a dose- and time- dependent fashion
EGR1 = Zn-finger transcription factor; tumor suppressor in fibrosarcoma cells.
ChIP assay: the HDACi Depsipeptide/FK228 increases acetylation of histones in the MEIS2 promoter. Curcumin = negative control. Input = total chromatin; rabbit IgG=anti rabbit Ig antibody immunoprecipitations (negative control).
Effect of 1 uM MS-275 on the transcription of EWS-ATF1 in KAO clear cell sarcoma, by quantitative RT-PCR (primers spanning
fusion site)
0102030405060708090
100
4h 24h 48h
beta-actinEWS-ATF1
HDAC inhibitors in clear cell sarcoma
Effect of MS-275 on EWS-WT1
transcription in JN-DSRCT-
1 cells
HDAC inhibitors in other translocation-associated sarcomas
0.287531
0.163872
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
4 hr 12 hr
No Treatment10-5 M MS-275
SYT-SSX2
-actin
SYO-1 Fuji
00 1 1 1010
[FK228] ng/mL x 24h [FK228] ng/mL x 24hsynovial sarcoma: depsipeptide knocks SYT-SSX down to undetectable in two cell lines
Effect of MS-275 (1 uM) on transcription of FUS-
DDIT3 in myxoid liposarcoma cell line
MLS402 qPCR relative to untreated
control = 100%; equal loading of template
p21CDKN1 mRNA levels (gene known to be induced by HDACi
treatment) in same cells with same tx
HDAC inhibitors in myxoid liposarcoma
FUS-DDIT3
CDKN1
FUTURE DIRECTIONS
• generating expression profiles before & after HDACi treatment
• synergism with Hsp90 inhibitors• further preclinical study: xenograft models for CCS; metastatic model monitored by in vivo imaging
Conclusion: HDAC inhibitors induce growth inhibition, apoptosis, and differentiation in translocation-associated sarcoma cell lines.
FUNDING• Terry Fox Foundation• MSFHR, CIHR
Cell lines: AL Epstein, C Poremba, A Kawai, K Nagashima, J Nishio, P Aman, N Mandahl
Experimental drugs: NCI – CTEPExpression profile data: M van de Rijn