i

TABLE OF CASES

Page Nos.

A

A.C.G. Venancious v. Jagajothi, 2008 ACJ 1434 164

A.Krishna Patra V. Orissa State Electricity Board, 1998 47, 166

ACJ 155 (Ori.) DB

A.S. Manjunathaiah and another v. M.V. Nanjundaiah 226

and another, 1986 A.C.J. 295, Kar.

A.S. Sharma v. Union of India and another, 1995 A.C.J. 204

Guj.

Adamkhan Mohamed v. Ramesh Raya Naik, 1978 A.C.J. 231

409 Kar.

Ahmedabad Muncipal Corporation v. Narendrabhai 204

Lalbhai Shah, 2010 ACJ 15

Ali Khan v. Vijay Singh, 2007 ACJ 350 (Raj.) 48, 167

Allanoor v. Dilip Singh 1998 ACJ 136 (Raj.) 133

Allimuddin v. Emperor, AIR 1945 Nag.242 327

Amar Nath Goel v. Mayur Syntex , 1990 ACJ 93 (Del) 168

Amina Begum v. Ram Prakash, 1979, ACJ 449 All. 230

Amritlal v.Union of India, 2004 ACJ 1868 (Raj.). 122

Anandi Ravji Vats v. Oriental Insurance and others, 1988 266

A.C.J. 129, Bom.

Anantanarayanan J. in Re Natarajan allias Natesan, AIR, 335

1966 Mad. 357

Anchor Products Ltd. v. Hedge, 1969 A.C.J. 117, H.C. of 250

Australia.

Andhra Marine Exports (P) Ltd., Quilon and another v. 216

ii

P.Radha Krishnan and others, 1984 A.C.J. Mad.

Andrews v. Director of Public Prosecution, (1937), 2 All 312

E.R. 552

Angel Travels v. K.C. Naik (1991) 1 Kar. LJ 37 3

Angoori Devi v. Megh Raj, 2003 ACJ 293 (Del) 197

Anirudh Prasad Ambasta v. State of Bihar, 1990 ACJ 238 102, 103

(Pat.) FB

Anitha v. Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board, 202

2010 ACJ 27 (Kar) DB

Asa Singh and others v. State of Himachal Pradesh and 246

another, 1981 A.C.J. 313 H.P.

Ashok Kumar v. Surinder Kumar, 1999 ACJ 1119 (HP) 168

DB

B.

B. Govindarajulu Chetty v. M.L.A. Govindaraja 15, 177, 179

Mudaliar, 1966 ACJ 153 (Madras)

B.K. Singh v. Union of India, 2006 (4) ACC 242 (SC). 128

Babu Singh v. Champa Devi and others, 1974 A.C.J. 168 249

Mad.

Baldev Narain v. State of Bihar, AIR 1959 Pat. 442. 165

Bani Ram Das v. National Insurance Co. Ltd , 2008 ACJ 150

538

Banwari Lal Aggarwal v. Jeewan Kumar Badu, 2002(3) 222

ACC 160

Barkway v. S.Wales Transport Co., (1950) 1 All E.R. 292. 259

Barkway v. South Wales Transport Co. Ltd. (1948) All 200, 264, 275

E.R. 460.

iii

Barkway v. South Wales Transport Co. Ltd., (1941) 3 All 246, 248

E.R. 322.

Basant Kaur v. Chatarpal Singh, 2003 ACJ 369 (MP) 214

Beni Bai v. Chhandilal, 2005 (2) ACJ 816 (MP) DB 235

Bhagwandas and another v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. 241

And another, 1990 A.C.J. 495, M.P.

Bhagwat Singh and another v. Ram Pyari Bai and others, 256

1991A.C.J. 1115, M.P.

Bhaswarlal v. Kabulsingh and others, 1989 ACJ 189, MP 234

Bhuwanweswar Sahu and others v. Sudhir Kumar and 210

others, 2003 A.C.J. 1247, Jhar.

Bipal Bashi Das v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., 2009 (1) 51

ACC 288 (Gau.) DB.

Bisarti Bai and others v. Madhya Pradesh State Road 218

Transport Corporation and others, 1990 A.C.J. 103(M.P.)

Bishan Devi v. Sirbaksh Singh, 1979 ACJ 496 (SC) 179

Bollord v. North British Railway Co., (1925) S.C. 43, H.L. 259

Bourhill v. Young, (1943) A.C.92,: see also Supra n.16 p. 10

249 & 250

Burmi v. Tej Bhan, 1994(2) AJR 24 (P&H). 136

Busthi Kasim Sahab (Dead) LR’s v. Mysore State Road 271

Transport Corporation and others, 1991 A.C.J. 380, S.C.

Byran Pestonji Gariwala v. Union Bank of India, AIR 300

1991 SC 2234.

C.

C.K.Subramonia Iyer v. T. Kunhikuttan Nair, AIR, 1970 140

SC 376

iv

Calcutta State Transport Corporation Calcutta v. Kamal 264

Prakash De, 1976 A.C.J. 183 S.C.

Chairman Thiruvallurar Transport Corporation v. 120

Consumer Protection Council, AIR, 1995 SC 1384

Chairman, The Trustee of Port of Madras v. Suganesan & 61

Co.,1996 ACJ 1224 (Mad.)

Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Bihar State Road 236

Transport Corporation v. Manju Bhushan Sinha and

others 1992 ACJ 1073, Pat.

Challis v. London & South Western Railway Company, 325

(1905) 2 KB 154.

Chandrakanti Das v. State of Orissa, 2010 (1) TAC 339 304

(Orissa)

Cheriyakutty Mammi v. UmmerKutty, 1996 ACJ 402 112

(Ker.) DB

Chinna Gangappa v. B.Sanjeeva Reddy, 1998 (1) TAC 268 62

AP

Chintaram v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 1986, A.C.J. 1043, 333

M.P.

Colhills Ltd. v. Devine, 1969, 2All E.R.53. 231

D

Davies v. Mann, (1842) 10 M & W 546 189

Dayanand v. Baijnath, 1991 ACJ 975 (Raj.) 133

Delhi Transport Corporation v. Neelam Deshwar, (2009) 1 224

ACJ 1 (Del.)

Deputy General Manager & Divisional Controller, 302

Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation v.

v

Kamappa, 1993 ACJ 539 (Kar.)

Devi Singh v. Vikram Singh, 2008 ACJ 393 204

Dhanrajmal Govindram v. Shamji Kalidas & Co., AIR 166

1961 SC 1283

Dhanwanti v. Kulwant Singh, 1994 ACJ 708 (MP) DB 191

Dhulabhai v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1969 SC 78 117

Donoughue v. Stevenson, (1932), A.C.562 19

Dwarka Nath v. Income Tax Officer, Kanpur , AIR 1966 SC 81 149

Dwarka Prasad Jhunjhunwala and another v. Shushila 253

Devi and Others, 1983 A.C.J. 570, Pat.

F

Farida and others v. Abid and others, 1997 A.C.J. 322, 245

Raj.

Fenton v. Thorley & Co. Ltd., (1903) AC 448 (HL) 46

First National Bank Ltd. v. Seth Sant Lal, AIR 1959 Pun. 169

328

Francis Xavier Rodrigues v. State, 1997 Cri L.J., 1374 341

Bom.

G

G. Govindan v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd, AIR 1999 83

SC 1398

G.M. Orissa State Road Transport Corporation v. 272

Maheshwar Rout and others, 1983 A.C.J. 124 Ori.

Gajanad v. Virendra Singh, 2010 ACJ 145 195

Ganga Rama and another v. Kamalabai and others, 1979 263

A.C.J. 393 Kar.

vi

Gangi v. Second Additional District Judge, Hamirpur, 301

2001 (1) TAC 519

Gayatari Devi and others v. Ramesh Chand and others, 218

2000 A.C.J. 898, (Raj.)

Geeta Bai and others v. Ram Singh and others, 1998 249

A.C.J. 1231 M.P.

General Assurance Society Limited v. Jayalakahmi 276

Ammalj , 1975 A.C.J. 159 Mad.

General Manager, Karnataka State Road Transport 304

Corporation v.Pandu ,1998 ACJ 1389(Karn).

General Manager, Kerala State Transport Corporation v. 141, 277

Susamma Thomas, 1994 ACJ 1(SC)

Gobalad Motor Services Limited and another v. R.M.K. 212, 247, 264

Veluswami and Others, A.I.R.1962 SS.C. 1 274, 276

Golan Jilani Khan v. The State, 1972, ACJ 431, Ori. 341

Gorli Bai v. Kanti Lal, 2002 (3) TAC 402 (MP) 223

Gothelal Chourasis and another v. Gajjansingh and 227

others , 1988 A.C.J. 120, M.P.

Gourikutty v. Raghavan, 2002 ACJ 1356(Ker.) DB 137

Gousipala Manemma v. Andhra Pradesh State Road 248

Transport Corporation and another, 2001 A.C.J. 901, A.P.

Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation v. Kamla Ben 187

Valjibhai Vora, 2002 ACJ 780

Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation v. Ramanbhai 178, 180

Prabhatbhai , 1987 ACJ 561 (SC)

Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation v. Union of 50

India, AIR 1988 Guj 13

Gulab Singh Meruji v. Jayantilal Shankarlal Brahmin, 125

2001 ACJ 346 (Guj.)

vii

Gulaba Ram v. Divisional Forest Officer, Bilaspur, H.P., 245

1991 A.C.J. 493, H.P.

Gurbax Singh v. Financial Commissioner, AIR 1991 SC 120

435

H

H. Paul v. Bank of India, 1998 ISJ (Banking) 550 (P&H) 147

DB

Hanuman Dass v. Usha Rani and another, 1978 A.C.J. 310 232

(P&H).

Harendra Nath Halder v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd, 164

2006 ACJ 975

Harihar Mohanty v. Union of India, 1996 (2) ACC 438 11

(Orissa).: see also Supra n.25

Harinagar Sugar Mills v. Shyamsunder Jhunjhuinwal, 107

(1962) 2 SCR 339

Haryana State v. Krishan Kumar, 2003 ACJ 549 (P&H) 214

Haynes v. Horwood (1955) 1 K.B. 146. 19

Hazara Singh v. P.L.Joseph and another, 1996 A.C.J. 277, 205

Del.

Hedley Byrne & Co. Ltd. v. Heller & Partners Ltd. (1964) 19

A.C.465.

Helen Ekka v. Anil Sharma, 2002 ACJ 1982 (MP) DB 233

Hemu Bai v. Satish , 2007 ACJ 1159 203, 233

Henderson v. Henry E.Jenkins Sons, 1970 ACJ 198 231, 265, 276

Himachal Road Transport Corporation and another v. 205

Vinod Bali, 1998 A.C.J. 1284 H.P.

Himachal Road Transport Corporation v. Baldev Kumar 153

viii

Nayyer, 2007 ACJ 678

Himachal Road Transport Corporation v. Himi Devi and 243

others, 1981 A.C.J. 365, H.P.

Hindustan Aeronatics v. T. Venu and another, 1972 A.C.J. 254

266, Mys.

Hirachand and another v. Union of India, 1971, A.C.J.475 211

I

I.Palley Ram and another v. P.K.Janardhan and another, 238

1985 ACJ 812 Del.

Indari Lal v. Vijay Kumar , 2009 ACJ (MP) (DB) 195

Inderjit Kaur v. Somnath, 2007 ACJ 2865 (P&H) 198

Iswari Yatayat Cooperative Society Ltd. And another v. 264

Umroo Singh, 1976 A.C.J. 318 M.P.

J

J & K State Road Transport Corporation v. Presiding 262

Officer M.A.C.T. and others , 1987 A.C.J. 945, J & K.

Jagat Singh and other v. Sawal Singh, 1971 A.C.J. 66. 276

Jai Prakash v. National Insurance Company Ltd., (2010) 2 15, 283

SCC 607

Jai Singh v. Gashwal Motor Owners and Others, 1983 267

A.C.J. 397, All.

Jameskutty Jacob v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd, AIR 65

2006 SC 3690

Jamla Bi v. Gurmit Singh, 2003 ACJ 1035 (MP) 213

ix

Jay Laxmi Saltworks (P) Ltd. v. State of Gujarat, 1994 (4) 7

SCC 1

Jayshree Narendra Kataria v. Somnath Damodhar Kale, 65

2010 (10) TAC 10 Bom.

Jhulan Rani Saha v. National Insurance Co. Ltd, AIR 2, 17

1994 Gau. 41

Jones v. Great Western, (1930) T.L.R. 47. 259

K

K. Nandakumar v. Managing Director, Thanthai Periyar 180

Transport Corporation Ltd , AIR 1996 SC 1217

K.L.Pasrija and others v. Oriental Fire and General Ins. 228

Co. Ltd. And Others, 1986 A.C.J.252 P & H .

K.P.Verma v. State of Bihar, 1990 ACJ 32 (Pat.) DB. 104

K.Perumal v. State , 1998 4 Crimes 382 18, 321

Kamla Devi v. Ram Kishan, 2009 (1) ACC 920 153

Kamla Verma v. Rajesh Kumar Singh, 2002 (2) ACC 279 198

(Jhar) DB

Kanai Manna v. United India Insurance Co .Ltd., 2009 93

ACJ 544 (Cal) DB

Kanti Lal v. Manohar Lal, 1994(1) ACC 413 (MP) 136

Kanwaljit singh and Others v. Santokh Singh and Others, 237

1983 ACJ 470 (P&H)

Kapil Kaur and others v. Union of India and others, 2000 209

A.C.J. 864, P & H.

Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation v. 299

Kumudavalli, 2004 (1) ACC 80 (Kar).

x

Kartik Ram and another v. Chandra Gopal and others, 265

1998 A.C.J. 1118 M.P.

Keshab v. Nasiruddin, (1908) 13 CWN 501 316

Kishan Lal v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, (1994) 4 SCC 120

422

Kishori v. Chairman T.S. Coop. Society, AIR, 1988 (MP) 15

38

Koh Hung Keng v. Low Pee L.T. Co., 1967 A.C.J. 303 202

Kothai v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd ,2003 ACJ 991 214

(Mad.)

Krishana Bus Service Ltd., v. Smt. Mangli and another, 243, 246

1976 A.C.J. 183 S.C. 248, 274

Krishna Sehgal and others v. U.P. State Road Transport 206

Corporation and others, 1983 A.C.J. 619, All.

Kumaran and another v. Augustina, 1976 A.C.J.479 Ker. 229

Kusum Devi v. Dungaram, 2008 ACJ 1709 (Raj.). 123, 155

L

Lai Kuit Seong v. Public Prosecutor, (1969), ACJ 341 332

Federal Court of Malaysia

Lakshmi Soren v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., 2006 151

ACJ 551 (Cal) DB

Lalchandhari Shah v. Raj Nath Shah, 2005 (1) ACJ 695 93

(MP) DB

Laurie v. Regian Building Co., Ltd. (1942) 1 K.B. 152. 200, 275

Laxmiben Pravinchandra Barot v. Thakore Prabatji 194

Babuji, AIR 2010 (NOC) 5 Guj.

Life Insurance Corporation of India v. State of Rajasthan, 301, 309

xi

2007 (1) ACC 899 (Raj.)

Lilaben Udesing Gohal v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., 276

(1996) ACJ 673.

M

M P State Road Transport Corporation v. Bhoj Singh , 169

1992 ACJ 1151 (MP)

M S Grewal v. Deep Chand Sood , 2001 ACJ 1719 187

M.C. Mehta v. Union of India, AIR 1987 SC 1086 173, 175, 288

M.K.Kunhimohammad v. P.A.Ahmedkutty, 1987 (4) SCC 27,161, 287

284

M.V.Jayadevappa v. Oriental Fire and General Insurance 67

Co. Ltd.,2005 ACJ (3) 1801 (SC)

M/s Automobile Transport (Rajasthan) Private Ltd., and 274

another v. Dewalal and others, 1977 A.C.J. 150, Raj.

Madan Lal v. Chimman Singh, 1991 (1) ACC 265 (MP) 132

Madhya Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation v. 244

Anjani Chaturvedi and Others, 1993 A.C.J. 363, M.P.

Madhya Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation v. 49

Bhoj Singh, 1992 ACJ 1151 (MP)

Mahendra Pal Singh and another v. Prakash Chand 244

Goyal and others, 1987 A.C.J. 677, M.P.

Maitri Koley v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., 2004 ACJ 94

46 (SC)

Malikdhinar English Medium School v. A.Babudeen, 190

2006 ACJ 1711 (Mad.) DB

Mallamma v. Mahaboob Ali, AIR 2010 (NOC) 10 (Karn.) 138

xii

Mallika v. S.V. Alagarsami, 1982 ACJ 272 (Madras) 181

Manager, New India Assurance Co. Ltd v. Chintnala@ 133

Anagaiah Narasimha, 2002 ACJ 1524 (AP) DB

Managing Director, Tamil Nadu State Transport 9, 186

Corporation v. Ayyammal, 2007 ACJ 66 (Mad.) DB

Manful v. Mehmood, 2005 (1) ACC 765 142

Mangal and others v. Subhadrabai and another, 1981 200

A.C.J. 156 Kar.

Mangilal v. Chairman, Rajasthan State Road Transport 215

Corporation, 2000(1) ACC 509 (Raj.)

Mangilal v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR, 2004 SC 1280 322

Mangla Jat v. Raju, 2001(2) ACC 195 (Raj.) 137

Maniben S. Pandya v. Shashikant P. Shrigalor, 2005(1) 214

ACJ 592 (Guj.) DB

Maniklal Dubey v. Mohd. Ismail, 1999 (3) Civil LJ 329 51

Manju Gupta v. National Insurance Co. Ltd, 1994 ACJ 298

1036 (All)

Mantoo Sarkar v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd, 2009 ACJ 123

564

Mathew Joseph v. Johny Sunny, 1995 ACJ 1183 (Ker.) 46

Maya Devi v. Kartav Bus Service Ltd. and Others, 1987 256

A.C.J. 145, P & H.

Meena v. M.P. State Road Transport Corporation, 2006 203

ACJ 2383 (MP) DB

Minu B Mehta v. Balakrishna Ramachandra Nayar and 101, 182, 248

another, 1976 A.C.J. 118 S.C.

Mishra v. Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, 2006(1) ACC 140

362.

Mishri Bai v. Munna, 2007 (1) ACC 911 (MP) DB 220

xiii

Mita Gupta and others v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. 219

And others, 2002 A.C.J. 393 Cal.

Mithu Rani Sadar v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd., 220

2006 ACJ 2868 (Cal.) DB

Mohammad Kasim Abdulgani Mesra v. State of 336

Karnataka, 1984, ACJ. 480 Kar.

Mohammed Aynuddin alias M alias Miyam v. State of 343

Andhra Pradesh, 2001, ACJ 13 SC

Mohammed Iyub v. Muzaheed Pasha, 2010 (1) TAC 313 90

(Del.)

Mohd. Riyazur Rehman Siddiqui v. Deputy Director of 106, 154

Health Services, 2009 (3) ACC 300 (Bom) FB

Mohd. Yaqub v. Union of India, AIR 1971 Del 45 169

Moosola Rama Rao v. District Collector, Srikakalum, 87

2002 ACJ 1085 (AP)

Mst. Anachi v. Ram Chandra, 2002 (1) AJR 643 (Raj.) 302

Mt. Prag Kaur v. Devi Dutt, 1998(1) ACC 313 (P&H). 139

Muljibhai Ajrambhai Harijan v. United India Insurance 276

Co. Ltd., 1983 ACJ 57 (Guj.).

Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay v. Laxman 187, 189, 288

Iyer, AIR 2003 SC 4182, 2004 ACJ 53

Muthu v. State, 1990, ACJ. 530 Mad. 329, 331

Mysore State Road Transport Corporation v. Albert Dias, 10

AIR, 1973 (Mysore) 240.

N

N. Ramachandran v. Meera, AIR 2010 (NOC) 12 193

N.K.K. Siva Baghyam and others v. P.V. Kalliani Amma 216

xiv

and others, 1991 A.C.J. 283( Ker.)

N.R. Patel & Co. v. T. Aparna, 2006 ACJ 2719 195

N.Tantry v. Shwaleela, 2002 (2) TAC 44 (Karn.) 223

Nageswar Shri Krishna Choube v. The State of 338

Maharashtra, 1973, ACJ.108 SC

Nand Lal v. State, 1980, A.C.J. 423, Delhi 346

National Insurance Co. Ltd v. Chandra Prava Barman, 126

2001(2) TAC 698 (Guj.) DB.

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Akhilesh Dwivedi, 2007 (4) 202

ACC 312 (MP) DB

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Anjana Shyami, 2001 (2) 143

AJR 523

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Balbir Kaur, 2001 ACJ 555 145

(P&H) DB.

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Honnappa, 2008 (3) ACC 56, 163

726 (Karn) DB

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indu Saraswat, 2009 ACJ 153

2413 (Raj.).

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indu Sharma, 2000 ACJ 111

808 (P&H)

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Khushboo, 2009 (3) ACC 60

460 (Pat.)

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Malathi C. Saliam, 2005 161

(2) ACC 414

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Mossamat Das Choudhary, 303

1998 (2) ACC 111 (Pat)

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Murti Devi, 2002 (1) TAC 145

470 (P&H) DB.

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Phool Singh, 2008 ACJ 58 60

xv

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Puja Roller Flour Mills (P) 65

Ltd, 2007 (1) ACC 219

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Ramilaben Chinubhai 203

Parmar , 2007 ACJ 1565 (Guj) DB

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sahiba Khatun and others, 197

2000 A.C.J. 168 M.P.

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Santro Devi and Others, 281

AIR 1998 SC 1485.

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Srimatya Basanti Mondal, 223

2002(3) TAC 453 (Cal.) DB

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Vijay Kumar Sharma, 297

2009 ACJ 403 (JHAR).

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. William Jenifar Ajitha 61

2009 ACJ 1042

Naugapa Chinsya ans another v. Bhogoban Sahoo and 227

another, 1988 A.C.J. 685, Ori.

Nek Ram and others v. Punjab Roadways and others, 217

1984 A.C.J. 396 (P & H.)

New Asiatic Insurance Co. v. Pessumal Dhanamal 176

Aswami, (1964) 2 SCJ 428

New Asiatic Transport (P) Co. Ltd. v. Manohar Lal, 103

(1966) 68 Punj. LR (Del.) 51.

New India Assurance Co. Ltd v. Ganga Devi, 2006 ACJ 108

2857 (Jhar.) DB

New India Assurance Co. Ltd v. Mehebubanbibi, 2003 (2) 55, 129, 162

TAC 639 (Guj.) DB

New India Assurance Co. Ltd v. Parameswaran , 2006 163

ACJ 1176

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v Raju Markose, 1989 ACJ 180

xvi

643 (Kerala)

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Bhavani Nanji 153

Pachanbhai Patel, 2007 ACJ 2067

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Bimla, 2001 ACJ 388 134

(P&H).

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Boda Hari Singh, 302

2000ACJ 1580 (AP)

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Debajani Sahu and 207

others, 2000 A.C.J. 1512 Ori.

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. G. Lakshmi , 1999 ACJ 131

1068 (AP)

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Meenal And Ors, 2 171

(1993) ACC 443

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Molia Devi, 1969 ACJ 103

164 (MP) DB

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Ponnamma Thomas, 304

2009 ACJ 1331(Ker.)

New India Assurance Co. Ltd v. Rajendra Prasad Bhatt, 90, 128

2002 ACJ 1762 (MP)

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Santra Devi, 2007 ACJ 78

2273 (P&H) DB.

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Saroj Tripathi, 2008 ACJ 196

1274

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Sheeja, 2007 ACJ 338 51

(Ker.) DB

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Shymo Chauhan, 2006 163, 193

ACJ 923

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Takhuben Rajhabhai, 174

2008 ACJ 989 (Guj.) DB

xvii

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Vibhuti, 2004 ACJ 769 79

(Karn.) DB.

New India Assurance Co. v. Rukiyabai, 1985 (2) ACC 499 119

New India Assurance Company v. Kamla,2001(1) P.L.R. 280

831

New Indian Assurance Co. Ltd v. Rattan Devi, 2007 ACJ 203

1817

Nishet v. Rayne and Burn, (1910) 1 KB 689 325

O

Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. v. Kamal Kamini, 99

A. I . R. 1973 (Orissa) 33

Oriental Fire and General insurance Co. Ltd. v. Suman 298

Navnath Rajguru and Others, 1985 A.C.J. 243, Bom.

Oriental Insurance C. Ltd. v. Arati Mishra, AIR, 2010 79

(NOC) 17

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd v. Parveen Juneja, 2003 ACJ 195

378

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Badri Ram, 2002(1) TAC 136

194 (Raj.)

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Dongkholam, 2007 ACJ 46

1973 (Gau.)

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. M.A.C.T. Perumbavoor , 149

2000 ACJ 558 (Ker.)

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Meena Variyal, AIR 2007 193

SC 1609

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanak Chand, 2009 ACJ 191

xviii

2240(HP)

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Ram Babu, 2007 ACJ 1406 136

(All.)

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Rooplal Singh, 2000 ACJ 128

502 (Pat.)

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sanjay Kumar, 2007 ACJ 134

222 (P&H).

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Ullasini N. Kamble, 2002 222

(1) AJR 301 (Kar.)DB

Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. v. R. Mani, 2000 ACJ 145

247

P

P. Mahalakshmi v. I. Babu Rajendra Prasad and another 234

case, 1988 ACJ 88, AP

P. Rathinam Nagbhusan Patnik v. Union of India, AIR 321

1994 SC 1844

P.Dappammal (since deceased) and Others v. 238

International Space Research Organization and another,

1986 ACJ 812 Ker.

Padma Srinivasan v. Premier Insurance Co. Ltd., AIR 93

1982 SC 836

Padmabai and others v. Madhya Pradesh State Road 210

Transport Corporation and another, 2001 A.C.J.785, M.P.

Padmanabhan Nair v. Narayaniutty, 1988 ACJ 58 (Ker.) 50

DB.

Padminbai Ashok Yadle v. Mannan Ismail Shaikh,2003 127

xix

ACJ 247 (Bom.).

Parkash Kaur and Others v. Municipal Corporation of 239

Delhi and Others, 1985 ACJ 639 Del.

Parvati Bai v. Bhagwat Rambhau Shelke, 2004 AACJ 192

1647 (Bom.)

Penu v. State, S. Acharya, 1980, ACJ.294 Ori. 345

Pepsu Road Transport Corp. v. Kulwant Kaur, 2009 ACJ 56, 163

1329

Perumal & others v. G. Ellesamy and another ,1974 A.C.J. 269

182,Mad.

Philippose Cherian and another v. T.A.Edward Lobo and 236

another , 1991 ACJ 634, Ker.

Pitabas Panda v. State, 1972,ACJ. 432 Ori. 342

Poonam Verma v. Ashwini Patel & others, AIR 1996 SC 187

2111

Prakash Vati and others v. Sulakhan Singh alias Lakhs 199

and others, 1999 A.C.J. 521, P & H.

Premaeswari Das and Others v. Saman Devi and 212

Anothers, A.I.R. 1960 314

Premlata Shukla v. Sitaram Rai , 2006 ACJ 1081 (MP) DB 216

Puspa Bai v. Ranjit G.P. 1971 A.C.J. 343 and 346. 202

R

R v. Spuuge, (1961) 2 All. E.R. 688. 270

R.J. Foujdar Bus Service v. Ganpat Singh, 2007 ACJ 1591 48, 168

(MP) DB

Rachna v. Himachal Road Transport Corporation 196

xx

through its General Manager, Shimla and others,1990

A.C.J. 840 H.P.

Raghib Nasim and another v. Naseem Ahmad and other, 212

1986 A.C.J. 405 All.

Rajasthan State Co-op Diary Federation v. Brij Mohan 221

Lal and Others, 1990 A.C.J.118, Raj.

Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation v. Nand 227

Kishore and Others, 2002 A.C.J. 1564.

Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation v. Siraj 93

Ahmed, 2006 ACJ 526 (Raj.)

Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation, Jaipur v. 273

Narain Shankar and others, 1980 A.C.J. 411, S.C.

Ram Chander v. Naresh Kumar, 2000 ACJ 727 (P&H) DB 83

Ram Dulare Shukla v. Madhya Pradesh State Road 270

Transport Corporation and others, 1970 A.C.J. 120 M.P.

Ram Singh v. Anil, 2009 ACJ 73 (MP) DB 56, 163

Ramathal v. Kerala State Road Transport Corporation 225

and another, 1986 A.C.J. 186, Ker.

Ramdev Singh V. Chudasma v. Hansrajbhai V. Kodala 46, 92, 112

1999 ACJ 1129(Guj.) DB

Ramlayak Ram v. Umrawati Devi , 2002 ACJ 1146 (HP) 233

DB

Ramwati v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., 2005(2) ACC 492 9

(All) DB

Rani Devi @ Usha Rani v. Devilal, 2009 ACJ 858 (Raj.) 171, 287

Ranju Rani v. Branch Manager New India Assurance Co. 324

Ltd., 2003 ACJ 1588 (Pat.)

Ranu Bala Paul v. Bani Chakraborty, 1999 ACJ 634 131

(Gauhati)

xxi

Ratnam v. Emperor, AIR, 1935 Mad. 209 339

Rattan Singh v. State of Punjab, 1939 1 M.L.J. 660 347

Ravi Kumar v. Manager, Indian Textile Co-operatives 236

Ltd., 2006(1) ACC 184 (Karn,) DB

Ravinder Kaur v. Haryana State, 2001 ACJ 635 (P&H) 215

Revathi Rajeskaran v. Vijaykumaran, 2002 ACJ 1925 215, 233

(Mad.)

Rishi Prusti v. Orissa State Electricity Board, 1999 ACJ 166

440

Rita Devi v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., 2000 ACJ 801 324

(SC)

Rohtan Singh v. Chander Kala, 2010 (1) TAC 140 (P&H) 194

Roopa Bai v. Ramayan Vikasdhr Diwan, AIR 2010 (NOC) 204

3 (Chhat) DB

Russell v. London & South Western Rly. Co., 230

24(T.L.R.)548

Rylands v. Fletcher(1868) LR 3 HL 330: (1861-73)AII E 1. 6, 174,177

S

S.K. Bhatia and another v. Jaspal Singh Mann and 250

another, 1990 A.C.J. 13, H.P.

S.Kesar Singh v. Balbir Singh, 2004 (3) TAC 241 (J & K) 301

Sajjan Singh v. State of Punjab, 1986 ACJ. 88 P & H. 340

Sakamma v. Divisional Commissioner, 1994 ACJ 1266 300

(Kar).

Sakharibal Hasanali Makarsi and others v. Girish Kumar 197

Rupchand Gadia and others, 1997 A.C.J. 95 Bom.

xxii

Sankardan Das v. Grid Corporation of Orissa Ltd. 1998 47, 166

ACJ 1420 (Ori.) DB

Sanno Devi v. Balram, 2007, ACJ 1881 (MP) DB 115, 155

Sapna v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.,2008 ACJ 490 93

Sarbati v. Anil Kumar, 2006 ACJ 2532 (P&H). 124

Sarda Devi v. Birbal Ram, 2009 ACJ 2780 (Raj) 48, 167

Sardar Mohan Singh Bedi v. Mano Maya, 1972 A.C.J. 174, 255

Patna.

Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation ,2009 (6) 286, 380

SCC 121

Sarwar Khan v. State of Andhra Pradesh, AIR, 1968, AP 347

290

Satvantkumar Harjit Singh Vig v. Aarti Jayant Lalwani, 55, 162

2005 (1) ACJ 255 (Bom.) DB

Satyabadi Nayak v. Dameli Khilla, 1991 ACJ 211 (Guj.) 105

DB

Savara Pydi Raju v. T. Venkata Rao, 2007 ACJ 2245 (AP). 124

Scott v. London and St. Katherine Docks, (1865) 3 H & C. 259

598.

Selvarajamani v. National Insurance Co., 2003 ACJ 1152 164

Sewassam Alias Sewan v. Nanhe Khan alias Asgar Begand 260

others, 1987 A.C.J. 354, M.P.

Shaju v. Babu, 2008 ACJ 1228 (Ker.) DB. 191

Shakila Khader v. Nausher Gama, 1975 ACJ. 363 S.C. 320, 339

Shambhu Nath Mehra v. State of Ajmir, AIR, 1956, SC 337

404

Shamma v. Kartar Singh, 2008 ACJ 892 (MP) DB 48, 167

Shankarayya v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd., 1998 325

ACJ 513 (SC)

xxiii

Shantaben Gordhandas Bhatt v. Gujarat State Road 92

Transport Corporation, 2002 ACJ 1714

Shashibala v. Rajender Sharma, 2008 ACJ 2744 204

Sheela Kumari Singh v. G.S.Atwal & Co. (Engg) Pvt. Ltd, 188

2006 ACJ 980 (Jhar.) DB

Shivaputra Mahadevappa Hadapad v. State of Mysore, 335

1970 A.C.J. 160 Mys.

Shivlal and Others v. Rukmabai and Others, 1987 A.C.J. 240

341, M.P.

Shyam Sunder and others v. The State of Rajasthan, 1974 259

A.C.J. 296 S.C.

Siddarmappa Patil v. President, Bhartiya Vidya 126

Vardhaka Sangha,1997 ACJ 713 (Karn.).

Sindhu v. Sekar, 2009 (1) ACC 828 (Mad.) DB 194

Sitaram Akinchan v. Rajesh Sharma, 2007 (4) ACC 604 165

Smith v. Salwyn, (1954) 3 KB 98. 316

Sohan Lal Passi v. P.Sesh Reddy, 1996 (5) SCC 21 160

Sohan Singh v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., 2009 ACJ 193

2869

Sombathina Ramu v. T. Shrinivasulu, 2009 ACJ 187 (AP) 188

Sripal v. Rajendra Prasad, 1999 ACJ 92 (All.). 127

State of Haryana v. Darshana Devi, 1979 ACJ 205 (SC) 125

State of Karnataka v. Peter Frank, 2001 (1) ACC 704 215

State of Karnataka v. Satish, 1999, ACJ 1378, SC. 327

State of Madhya Pradesh and another v. Diwanchandra 222

Gupta and Others, 1989 A.C.J. 320, M.P.

State of Madhya Pradesh through Collector, Jhabua and 191, 268

another v. Ashadevi and others, 1988 A.C.J. 846, M.P.

State of Madhya Pradesh v. Pehlajrai Dwarkada, 1976 119

xxiv

ACJ 222 (MP) DB

State of Mysore and another v. Fatima Manwali 231

Fernandis and another, 1979A.C.J. 323 Kar.

State of Orissa and another v. Nalini Kumari Patnaik and 257

others, 1989 A.C.J. 126, Ori.

State of Punjab & another v. Jalour Singh, ILC 2008 SC 297, 303

MAC – JAN-6, 2008 ACJ 2874 SC

State of Punjab v. Harbhajun Lai Kochhas and others, 246,247

1980 A.C.J. 437 H.P.

State of Rajasthan and others v. Lakshmi Sharma and 268

others, 1992 A.C.J. 895, Raj.

State of Rajasthan v. Ram Prasad, 2001 ACJ 647 SC 49, 168

State of Rajasthan v. Vidyawati, AIR 1962 SC 933 184

Sudhir Kumar Rana v. Surinder Singh, 2008 ACJ 393 190

(MP) FB

Sulochana v. Karnataka State Road Transport 167

Corporation, 2005(2)b ACJ 849

Sumati Debinath v. Sunil Kumar Sen and another, 1994 258

A.C.J. 734, Gau.

Sushil Kumar Jaiswal v. Bank of India , 1997 Bank LJ 37 148

Sushila Devi v. Ibrahim , 1974 A.C.J. 150. 274

Sushma Mehta v. Central Provinces Transport Services 102

Ltd, AIR 1964 (MP) 133 (DB)

Swaranlata v. N.T.I. Pvt. Ltd., A I R 1974 (Gauhati), 31 99

Syad Akabar v. State of Karnataka, (1980) A.C.J. 38, S.C. 230, 247, 248

AIR (1979) S.C. 1848 326, 334

T

xxv

Taj Hussain v. Misru Khan, 2006 (1) ACC 30 (Raj.) 190

Talasila Sandhya v. Andhra Pradesh State Road 228

Transport Corporation and another, 1999 A.C.J. 629 A.P.

Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation Ltd. v. 305

A.T.Narendiran, 2010 ACJ 77 (Mad)

Threeti v. M.A. C.T 1996 ACJ 609 (Kerala) 16

Tilak Singh v. Shahi Bijulwan and Others, 1999 A.C.J. 251

661, H.P.

Triveni Prasad and others v. Indrapal Kachhi and others, 243

1997 A.C.J. 269, M.P.

U

U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. Shanti Devi, 224

2007 ACJ 2750

U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. Trilok 92, 286, 379

Chandra, (1996) 4 SCC 362

U.P.State Road Transport Corporation v. Rajani, 2007 9

ACJ 1771

U.P.State Road Transport Corportaion v. Motor Accident 139

Claims Tribunal, AIR 2006 NOC 198

Udayshanker Bhai v. Heirs and Legal Representatives of 224

the deceased Ala Rama and Others, 1988 A.C.J. 161, Guj.

Union Carbide Corporation v. Union of India, (1991) 4 277

SCC 584

Union of India the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, New 207

Delhi v. Sudhir Khanna and others, 1990 A.C.J. 215, H.P.

xxvi

Union of India v. Bhagwati Prasad, AIR 2002 SC 1301. 122

Union of India v. Satish Kumar Patel, AIR 2001 MP 41 50, 122

United India Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. 201

Maddi Suseela and others, 1979 A.C.J. 110 A.P.

United India Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. 299

Pallapu Sridevi, 1994 (1) ACC 110 (AP).

United India Insurance Co, Ltd. v. Somari Devi, 1999 ACJ 46

864(Pat.)

United India Insurance Co. Ltd v. Kashi Ram, 2004 (1) 324

ACC 527 (Del.)

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. B. Hemavati, 2001 ACJ 134

749 (Cal.) DB

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Bodali Bai, 2009 ACJ 78

2213 (Chhat.).

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Dhanlaxmiben 152

Satishbhai Bhagat, 2008 ACJ 966 (Guj.) DB

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Economic Roadways, 48, 167

2002 ACJ 2024 (Mad.)

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Hussain Sab, AIR 2006 66

(NOC) 437 (Kar.)

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kadviben Udabhai 59

Rathwa, 2006 ACJ 2019

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kantabai , 1991 ACJ 181

22 (BOM.) DB

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Mehtab Bai, AIR 1999 92

Raj. 293

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Mohammed, 2000 ACJ 305

158

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Patramana, 1996 ACJ 305

xxvii

427 (Kar)

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Patricia Jean 139

Mahajan, AIR 2002 SC 2616

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shabbir M Attarwala, 303

2007 ACJ 2860 (Bom)

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Surinder, 2006 ACJ 79

1285 (P&H.) DB.

United India Insurance Co. v. Shaik Saibaqtualla, 1992 133

ACJ 858 (AP) DB

United India Insurance Co.Ltd. v. Kishorilal, 2005 (2) 164

ACJ 1399

United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pritpal Singh 42

(1996-2) 113 Punj. L.R. 49

Urmila Devi v. Sukhdev Singh, 2002(1) ACC 157 (MP) 137

Usha v. Tamil Nadu State Road Transport Corp. Ltd., 151

2009 ACJ 2424 (Mad.)

V

V. Narayana Reddy v. Syad Azgar Bareed, 1981 A.C.J. 246

307 Kar.

Varalakshmi Sundar v. Meeran, 1981 ACJ 50 (Mad.) 105

Varkeychan v. Thomman, 1979 ACJ 319 (Ker.), 46, 324

Vasathy G.Kamath v. Keral State Road transport 229

Corporation, 1981 A.C.J.353 Ker.

Vatticherukuru Village Panchayat v. Nori Venkataraman 119

Deehsithulu, 1991 (5) JT 140

Veeran v. Krishnamoorthy, AIR 1966 (Ker.) 172. 10

xxviii

Venkatachalam v. Sundarambal Ammal and another, 252

1983 A.C.J. 513, Mad.

Vikram Singh v. Manvendra Singh, 2007 ACJ 950 194

W

Walmikrao Jayaram Kajale v. Uttam Buvaji Raut , 2004 151

ACJ 2009

Wing v. London General Omnibus Co. (1909) 2 KB 652 177, 179

Y

Yakan v. The State of Madras, 1968, A.C.J. 216 212

Z

Zoological Park v. S. Kaynana Raman, 2008 ACJ 133 194